Karnataka High Court
Ningappa S/O Siddappa Kannuli vs State Of Karnataka Ors on 17 April, 2012
Author: B.Manohar
Bench: B.Manohar
gggértfi:
Ex? 3%: E'§}&;E'§ Ciéiéfi?' GE?' Cfiiif U E'? E3 E§?'aiC'E*E 23;? €:§i.§EE§ii§%3'~ZGEE ")|M\Iru'1fl. I ififfifiii} Tiéifi §'?5~?"> VSEEEE5 Q?' E'=.£3§7~E';EL V EEEECEEQE 1 * .9'.
'§"EHi E§Qi"=E'E3L§§ ME€,£i?EE'f'C§$Ei%.M52§\3Gé'§£§E:%_ " V' R F£{}'E§§f}§3A:g4'2.;§}':j:_§' %1z".?,§'=§<:::«3§ 89 3 55» E -«gag E :2 é';«::_;§.-- 'V ' 3% £3 £xa7$€:": :
i:3;g2;:§;§32i _ S,.5's:;.S§§Véa;§3§;:a E{a;7,:2*:,:§§ v §f%.§SEE'{ éé ;:&:a:f£% j' . ' V _ Sax'::,é'sgVri{:a1mftS§ 'V 2,;a::éE;3:gp2:_V __ ._ Sf {E.E{€v[§4§"E§F%.:{}§§2i._E21fi§;§§I33 ~ Fagsé ;;b{>:.:,£ ;.»%€2::'?s3 Qcéié :£g:§C:§ié;.z::"a2 * -~ , M L23;§:<;§<;&i'j} _ _ 3;' {E §%'_:zEE;1g::g:: 2:' ,T"»fE< :;:i.27:
.~, L 45$ E ifiré §'{:.2_:":"z;;:':' '{}5é5T§:§;;1:'2§§€, ,5-':.e:§v§ ' 'z :§'i;:3.i;;@ cs? E£:z:*::.:3'i;§;§k:2:2§ E, {£3}; 37%;; E33/a::"::>§,¢;»::f§;§ E}s:§;:.'5::'%m::%V §"»g:.;:'¥;£:4§s:.:§is:%:'*":,;.g, E:§z1;':g2:E<}:*€é~ {Sf} Q5} §i%2?:I:; }pa 3% X as . §§}'::3:3:2"1:2g>g};: §>iY.E§:C§_€:§' Eégeé éibifiii 8<;%a::A§§:*i<:E§4:::*isé¢ _ .. .
§;"§{}&T{}'i"i*'i, 'E:":;. Qisyé. E3.%j2:§3u.:">'E">§%§{>'C3:§;. ':"h<% 5§<~se';~.;§s:V21::§, C<>:":':r:V::'s>;sa;§::2:';m"'*¢ S:/:%3~§'}%:'§:'~;;:'<2:a §:E§''2:zpu:" ' ?%'E§§'}§i'§§%?:£%E'i2i, Si; 1,: $3 $2 22:
§'*;:::"s3.V§~::;%L<:i2?::;22, Eizgdzzvazzrzs _ . .5 Béjagyz/,::2"~58§ 5&5: __ %< "E'3;i?:"ifé3:E,§%'§%'1iEC§€§Zi?.,:?§ 55%' Sal ?v'E2i'fl§E«:22;:j L212 é'§3:°E3Z§"E..»é::':; E%;»~3 and §§g:::":s;Z?:avaz::*:i£*: 33121 R, f%"{£1'§§;§}§é;'§§V, 5-%d<.~*.§Q:*-- .§i~_2; 5;;
These _V:;i':ié3: , _ A:'i3i<:k:: 22$ 22:? 525' she ?::{§zZS§:§?;£§'?§§{}E§' 5&5-_V :':r2:§,7:::;g ii} isgaie 2: wzéi sf C€§?.'iO§2if'§ , fzéd 18~®5w§§§2 in :56 E'{(:,EiL§¥i;*'3R~"?.8" 553$; :E":é:*"Lzmziiffiifiézziézzé 522 'Li-3;%§a;'>a:§ :52': £36 §\§{::.§*JiIE,vV'§,E3{:' 2 af:':":air,;:é:iV" xas/='§A':i_s::E€ is ua::€<i as: EXZEZESXE/§i'{f~ :2 ' " ~ 3%: if G {}§;i"§'é:fE';' ::fé2;1i1£é::§L i.
$4/2;?;:':§:'é '§'r£%,;;é,::::a§;/ §'3§:;;§:a::: §%':;:*:§':::z; ;:.2é5:A;':,;§:2z"::;?:°s; Eéavs ;::§:~;<:: fiisi" %;AZ%3a% :§%;:%.%;%{§ §.:2i~E?;~.?;§E:7 3}}? 'E°€;iS§§'}€}§E§§€:?§"E§[ §'"§%L?E"{fffEE'é° 3,») '§'E:a% §,§§"§ff'~J:£E§'"i{TI€:,' {)5 ':;%:z? ;:>a"3"é;1':é<*zV?;2::."5:: in xwii p<3é:?§éUz':::: 'éhzéé, iézc éfzgzzz:'::is§:si<>:'2€;%:' E2}? 27:: (>L:*:§§5;f._ <'.i.:.;z:'*:ai§ i3E%»~.'2:~E§E;%z--? :;T;'i"§;:.§E§éi'/Ci SE 2::<':1*{?$ gjzgzmgzs =:;.&§' 'i;3:";{_§"'i':'2<--§g;y. iiie ;3<%2ééi<;::'2 %?'é:i;§é§<}z2:%:*s; §"z,:;*'é;E:é3:* a:t<:::§;iA<::1{§;£2C%. V.%;§*:2;:'/":f:gf'§§§:1:1EI;*« .. Mme éézést 'igafzs: 2*:?a__'§'<:§1,:"'§?'i[[ viiféizggieié' *':?:'c§{3:§.g§::{§ 24} ':§":£3 :%'~;ai%{::m{.§ %:'$:~5§§«::::<:i<;:%:V:§,; §?.'} "»fE€'i§»' é:§'--;<?:<;:3V2:E:'2§;: §:"";"§i;T:.§{'}§;{2eii? ;j'.:§ 1;i§§ Egszzrcfi E?€e§E>;*:':13 53.11, §*'::>m: W}. éi£:._?2:2g bé:<é:;._EEi&::;§ :'~;§§gW§:1;g {V333 i:x:)§a§§:':g :35 ans: E:;:.:2ci '%'>%:>iV':;_:*{: 351.3263 ""§.7z"§%3:2::;::, 'Sim Lzmii '€r§"§m:1ai asiéssz" hzaiéizxg z':z:'T-€::1.;§é;:'§:"}§' 2.«;n:§:<3:?=Sa_é-:<:§:{;2:2 58 G? 2:36 ' E35; g{}§:§£'3''''~ijé 3'. r V ,.....
>-MM Ea": s;€z:%£>:3{i5r£%sg§'e;::€%:§%:':3%, i'§':E'}€§§..i:'§'ii1_g: §;;":,2:1%;2V::~t;V; E) / 3'3§é~.<g:z2§§Eu_s§Eéémi E3 ;1e::*~3ss 235% ga:;m.:;1s if :2 SA/'?;_$ §q§§'"Zi§E'i,,.{'{§'é'»:?%. §::i2.i§3%;;:f {:5 ESQ §@I駧:>:2€:"s; 'a,i§E:s§€'E" !S€<7%é§::1": V ?¥~E.$:V'<};s":':V'2':s:" 57a::t:; 2:13 iézsi §:§:":5'i§<%:s;5_; E,7i§§:3"§{',?§,,§§§Ef§,EKé%§
--'7f§'r§3az§':a*2E 33;? 51:3 ;;?<%a:~::"° s:Ea:'ié%s:§ E2}~ E ii? 3 @563 5"§.¢E'/{','.{}EE'§ :'€:é;§>{}::i§€:"§: %2<>Ee:§§:';g__; L; a<:r$:+,: v.{.'A3s§:2';?.Ag '§E':§:§ <::r{;a2:*%;V E35; zfééis :2" €§;'zEé:<§ §~?-- E .El:,§%T}':é'J'%§;*/{E iéggéii 2>«5:"§é ;:3s:%éé%,.%<j:a:'1 ;',3.E"£{?: E'éf:"2":2iE'E5i€§§ 'i§".:%;f :3:;2:f:§":s::f<:" ?}£:<,?E%Z; Viz; :;§%':<i% iV2;:::":§i§ £3 5:» fa 5 /' é 'V':/"%i'.§':E}§'ii,:E:'§§ faez" §":":;As:sE2 z:::":{gm'z*'}t "h::% Lzmié x§i"§$§:*{,,2 222123 %:;j; s::"::Ee3* <E:;:Es:{:i 3§~»'i'§~':§%§é€% éififiifté 23§£i§E'E E";£:Eé,% '§E":;:: i;§':<::u i"€fS§}{3§'E{§€E":§ E2i3§{E:'1'1g S'§:§"§};iiE.f:% ézzzéfi G? U 2:/C:"s:_:?;"'2<'%§gs,§§2%;;3:S',« Tizat' :~32;n'<§ <):'::§%:;:" wzyzss; <>:':<:$ 2ag§::§:V2 3:3. "a5.:>3ak;ei2§é:§3;?:9§: ':3ei1}r::: 322:3 <:a:=ug~:,' AA<::;::::.*-._§;;;..,:;:: i}§'£,§£??" iézzéwi 2:":i~8--E§§E 22§§<2x%§§3::§ éhé: vc':*'§?;. '%>é:%:,ié.§{>.:':V«A. éha? ardéf --:i2:;£«6<:i 38% E» §§§3%Eé§ 312:5:..;5é;z:2;2mé{i%;:i_ %[Eé;e;;':::':2é':5{,€:' 11:: §;:*E§'E{TE "fE':°§E3;::12*:§ {Gr "{?{}'§7;:S§{;€AE""E"?;..é'TEE:"SEE £2f;?(?€:Z'{§"i§"i{}€ mil Em: g'-:§":s::* E"f3§EE2E£Eé:j, Q29 E;:«1:3d' 'Tff§1.--1«:;.é:§-f§3y}é':s {)E"§f3§' iiazissi E E§~5~ E $92, ;'1§7:A§E:"~«. zéiaééngg g2T:;~~ :; §.".:V<>E<:%;";;g;V' 2213:; s:>.;>:<':€ss Eamé E3}; §'%ii§€§" §3é2:'~;I:§:xi:'§ E35: 3326 izmci '§'§§bz::':ia3 ::fiz:Az:€§ _. "§~;s::>.¢.:1 {f§E2?§§€3EE§§i1§ E33; .33" '1-:§'?.,§'?.:'§{§&<1;§?::'§,§5};;:3.>€:3C?:}; C€:;a2:*i1 bf: <3:"{§€:" m 3": :3 1§E§{if§'€3£%.§§L{f§fl *;E3%;;% E£_%'3i?i}i"}{,§, :'<::s§3:i}:4':{.§<%:é§ ' [é.;<3:':V:;;:>s:%',§:':?!., 57';%;V2:%2x:;::":§E;:%§3s:§ 35:: :'<'::;::;:'::-'53}; 35:5? 'AwW*-€ :3': §::--'a::"i~;z:;:::':{i%:3 iéééf :'::::{; E E12-§2~2%.'}§E /3%,» V x/' N ;«:"""x\ 'z W 2,, V "'.:::::§ £12355: ;3§3LEV§§éa3:':::s:"$ Eztzmi' Km ::§§Z':%"}%3;5':i" %f3<%§<::;'*€% {iz:::3':g>a'%é:%:22 ,5'i2,2iE':a:§'§ {<1} ixaéé 27:3: <%:i<;ué:"§,,~* 51') 35;» :.A;::;§~a:z';% E:,=2:<'%é<, E 3 E;%_€3E"%:?S 28 ;;;:z:V£:)_::~5 9? 35:11:: é5§"é}3,§§§.§;'{§ :5:1H§::'%x_e:2'e;;:* as? 333$'? §3{:£¢§*:é<>:'1é;>:*s;§ iiészéizzgg ':33; {figs :§i>*;'£:;:';%~..___é::;V., 1 §.L~E2~f§€;%E E ;:;:':s:E zzisz} aha :;2:*<if::* a:E:2::€d E8~5_~.E_Q_§':?;V §:3§;a;.{%c: V§?:':,«_,. ViE"2<:*: E.,.2miE 'i":*E%3L:::é2»;1L iéléi p€i.éi§<):V"ai::'ss hzif*:ie":% 1§EEf<;:é =._LE1--<:%&;§_: K7§'_i"§f:. §}€:?ii§,'§{§§":S.
3. Sz*iJ':V§':i1é3:5iV §'§';,%E1'};'3;i" I}::5~7§:_§'32zj::::€.§:. §§2*;:".%?,€:if§." {',':{}Ei§Ei~}=$§ é,%.§}§§€£1}?§E"§§§ 50;' §€{,iE§'§:f':€?§TS3'~:?1£§g~$:.<3{§§;, . .:§:i=<>,_Ci ihfs {;:=:'«:éé:f gagzsgésci 3;}? 31%.: L::;:f::£ 'E':°i§:i%;é:'::;:.§_"<'Ez:';s:%;*§_ ?;84.;5.;"i"992 <:z:>::§r2:;:'j; £0 32:12:; zzgzd "SSE§EE';L}L§§,£:A:E;€§-3i)';K' _f:E1$.__4-;;}:jfGC@{§ are :}§€S{E§"§i3€§ 'a:;:2€%6:* 3 '§?':,;§:'*-:E:'<::f, %:s€%'§'@:*§é §E£':$$§§}§,§ €326 é}f°C§€§', 22:3 aim: §_12_2«:':{§ §€,a?'£7 § :2=:>£,£<m= 'Z?iz:8_ §':»<'%é'::' .iéTé\§3: §::i§é,%<3::::rs, Ei%iE'"E£7:€';'i izmj Ems ). , g EViE':§%f §>{'?§'§E"%:T'}§'E ° :25} §":,;:m% §:s:;?:£::': :';%:2:2.{§£% $5,': 2 1':
A W M A ¢""'\ M W W W 6" V km 9%»! M.) ( "W ». KM.
W. M F J' {"§EE§_7:€:f'f :2.g":;2,§:':. Eéé;-7 '-f2fA:';«":=;';'n£%:" Eééi/i$§}E'3E3:%iL§%f3'f: {Ema :33'? 535:: £23' 3:22! :E::=: L§_,.2:::{%;
5;:
§:"£:):;:§2:E i7<fEE'Ei.§'21i"j;" f;;<,> ism' ziiizzi :-§e:}a,:g§hé: Eb? §;'€'§;i,i§';'? 2:3Li§§: '£36: 5.33:': $3363 Uiézéjz' Eéazxié, Si?ii:é.:*s;§:::v2?:;*::%Elggéjiéé.
Eezzrzzed <:s:3:ms§e§ §:::r 15:5: :e:<3<:::m::E re:-;§§:::»r3§:;>:":: {::g:éa3:;<§{%:*§._f§VE2:;3;1; $329 Laazzzi 'E'::"i3:,::aa§ w%.é%:{}u: heizfiééégg méé? iiififijixégfax {ft ;:":S§§§€;%E'§':Eg;§ S<é<::3:;::': 55 Q? ééié E€i:3§b§fm.:':s i;iT::§}§'}§§(?£%§'.i{}§E <;:fm:E::3<:1 ;i:2,§:,_:"3.=§j; ?::::stE.z::% _:."é:2;i'a':"é_E":s:é se€:sf;:'<,e:/szj §f§;:i§f}{}§Eif,3€§£, h<:;€::E;5:E;?{_ sazrgsizzzs £5;:é%:§* :2»? 'i?3§.é:.{:r é;Q: _g::::%;2;s sf ézzizdfi z':_:r>'aé::s%, 'ah;-:3 sgi§{E'--ef;:'{%€z;;""E&:' flied %:E3§.s:=:» €r;3:,;§: {§?:.§'§3{} T Ezzggi 3:3, 5:? :;E'2s:% ittatééézéjg {EEECQ ::*?&.§:":
'§
-3 pafisfiéegeiiii 53:; éE:e:% §_2::r':::i '§':"§§i:/zizazé 2i::':€§ 2:} 3&8 '§':*§%3:::":;%£ 55:" §:'%::::,sE?2 §a;;%V:':£' in 2'i{'€3{}i"§§éi§§{fi€fi Ki'§§_:?'§ Ezmx E32}: :35; a:}§":E¢:" :.:§:;:zés:?{§ ., _§§:i§~5--E§%§2 E::':>E::E EEEQEE, Sis: T:"€§§§}\§E'}{§€f3E'Z'§, ai§<::a%:~s :a2<2é Ef:::;:€§E ":«;>%;:é 53:: 51" :éE'::: é ' :2}; s~;::i:jg>'::.:$ izmié ;::":e;7§ ii%Zf}§'E§'1%§,"§E':€;':{§, éézéj {,§€%iiTi§£Tii'.Z7fi§,§€,';?:'E fgécefi 3:23; 133%:
i+;e;%::::}zé{§ ft: --(i::2:::%@:":i. 'E"%:é_*: {Te::>::3§'zV':is:;:s;§(>:'a»¢::"§3a::_::"" E. w;:,§*1<3s_si, §<:s§E<3w§:2§§ 3316 532:8 g}§*:}€:s:%z:2"e ;}:*%:s{_:j:E§b?---..;,m:§§:V:6_ Sé{?.{,3'é§{};C% 2??' 95 {E163 LE'a§'}{.'§ R€§a;*:3i:;* siiéz gr2;1;::~:4-3r:i_ as .. §':}§1:\fi/§{§.»§€::}§'\£€1:',):§/~fT\}Q aifhécié aZ}§'"{§C§" 33313555353 by éhsa Lam? "§'r.%b_a2:2:ai £16"1:3;:3::€='§';*: V aygziig <';:3.{:s:_ ELEz:;% s3{:%<ta:>:1z% E?/VS§§{§'5'?,{§%i?Z§, ':_§:f;é:As' ':':<>:V;Zfia§{i 3:32? .A ~o €.X{',¥£fS--E%% Eziméé, g":<':::t<::"{§,§;_' §_'{:<%;::5:j; ~£3<%:%z: §;,aE«:e::2 '£33,' §§'E('% sw:$&;:;5{,a1:32V €e:>:11:2'1§s:e;§@:2€;" '-%.,«_;} igazsd :9 {he €;::;v:%2':':mi>m. I-"E §ew<A fa asrzjer. .:»:p§?é:*':. _.§:*a:é§ '§-h;::::L {*,7_{}i'i§f3§EC§€€f§ iiézzé éf_}§""{§{?if' {,i2>;:<:£E V ".3.
_ E36363": {gLE§E%§,§OE1€('§ in :21 N<;;:§@é-3.: 4: ;'?.?}"'é8L« .f:~,2<>§?s;;~ V . 'Ea: <7:2i:::?:2-::--:i;~'§EE'--% :>:3s': :::<'::*é: v«;:'é':V §i}é;t:i§§:§ef;>':': {i':§32:§;€:":g_{:i::;;f ii 'aE'":{': §.,2::':{§ 'E':*§:3as:":é:§. §Es:2<'r::: :€=::;:va2;.§:'iV §%::s:" 'W§"§, ':3 g} 5: éééééf} ' E<';:;::é":'3:%s:§ éT3%s:}:.'§:2m:':4::;*%:':?;V f:{§if{}€Tf£3£I,€3 3?: Es: ;::g}:.:§:*s {>5 xa 'f;.E€s%.. .?':{}§[3:{f'.£'. igsgaszsrsé E2}; §'§E%S§S?:,£§EE§ €f<§::::2;z§ss;si§}::s:::* 2;m::% .. :3 ' C{'}E'§"1E'E'°:éSsS§{f§§.'E<;?E' E ':%:<;: E%;é:€;ié}§'§:Z'§ :*<::~t:~5§'2<i}%:{§§?;";:V :3ii:§_L §é<>§::§ ?;%":::> éazzé :2: 0? {:iat§§i:"2;§ E33/ziiél aha izzzgii §':27:.:%; :'é:":c>m*<:*},n::c% 215:: i',::€":~s;;-:E;i%s;_}:"::§ :*:':%:=3;:3{:::":§€::V:%. '§"§:<3:"<>, mi) i:1i"§z*I::§i}; er i;':'é3ggL2§;ar§§;_i f_€f:s::.,éV::5£3 _ iéssazcésé by '£38 ,;'%.s§sés~;é2:zm; V<*:':i::::§5gsi{>:':€:' _.:2-21% §:>r' = <T§§S§E'1§fL~;SE_"%£ :3? ':§":«:% W32': ;§>:3::§t;'::;::3, E hzzx-*::: {i::?::*é;%§1:§i:¢ {:e:':ss§::a:"--_;fé::§_ {ha Q;§"3§:§':,Ti}'}}€3V§Ei,§§'~:*5!%§€§f%i?S§;f5{§V %:~},»' $736 §{>a:"::é::ii <:?{:-:: 3136} 59:' ;.»:~1 , i 1?. E¥":'2::::r: {E36 §.>;2.::%:Ts r:;'::*i*:;»z:f,:e{?§. i:f_'viif"=:€:'V fiszii' {E323 '{§"i{EE1§.§:§§ §E1§?,§E1_§'§:§"":§ E;;:::a:§: ='§'é*§'i'}?':.;:é2:.'é" 'E"TI,i:'f.§'CE $1313 $3553' :*£%s3§:>o:3ci€:1%;5 is .§.-:":;?;;§§:i;;:§" s:i':5§:2§'::s'---%2?:::d,o'§ L3 zzcms Eé gamas of * , :«a:3<*:<:2§:§ .33 6""
my $221 ,.m """'<''' gum! $3"
WM ,.. » ' .5"
Ezmeri. '§E2€ sasaié <,>:'s:§<3:* / K. ' {:3/22:13" .:':§};3é3a§ 312:5; '%}s:<:%:': éfissci ag;§:1§:3:+;§_V 2E'Ee:% '22?iE?,?%£<3;i2%I}i'§Ea>i§2{}%'}§%. {E23 :§i'?{?€}§'E{§ 'n j:';<~;:5' ::t:'::;é5?;Ea'=:€E {:33 §'f§{'f{}EE1'§}J:E§E%iT:§;% (>5 E;:.«2.:2::% §§'E€;"f %;':{::::"::':":§s;$i<:e::£%:' s2{:>':§:f::3 %:E:=:¢ <2 94%. §a;>22§'i §:"s:::":: Vé§::;2i:.¢ ééaazé s:i:::*dg:r ::'%:2: id €f%»E;~ E £%§%,?; 21$ £'2§§"{?2Li{T§}*" :>:>:':§E:"::':::%::§ ':23; i§'}E:i%3 {;%é;:2::*i 1:: 'if:/i§57{§'xE<::.3§i3§}%:%;"2::}{}§£i 52:; T zmii; sf2;3:3:1 is; :LE3<~% ;:3s'--:§Li:§<::":£%:*§ ii} ;"s':21g§%;Vga'£a>4 {figs f§'N._%%,;':}.E§i,"§[.":'?éW~¢v'.:?;;'v,-.2/Té=>%i:i'_ §§'32;1§, :E'2i:::':3 :'3.(3 §'£3§E"§E"i3§,}' §:' Erri:-%§§:.:E2::"é%;;y :32 EEK? Egméé gg;jm:?;i;:3ii Bi} éiéée §7)€3'i,§§§{}§Ei3§"S; {::T:§<Qf3§'3: _;},2\::*Jzi:;;W"'i§_*;,/* 2'*s;:~;:~:;é:es%;=;::1%:V {i<;>:z1;::2:?s;s+:é<>:V':€:;: a::~g32;=;:"/:~._ €53; :':>z;:.z<éssé i%'::§ E§'i;;1i:%;.$ ii?{>m:%:"§::"::€§i§i.._ ii; gg:°g:z"i's;~. ;::ETz;'é:*:";:%;:1§;:':?a;% ;:::z:
-.1, s"a€:%<::3:'{§::A:g§;n éé*":{:': 1%::"§i g:s:it§§§'i;@:':sj;'A 211:: :1; :€éi's;$a:é{é.
§3$:r:':::§%,i,€£:"§i 39 E216 "figs §{3a:'z:5f:i V G*{}'Vf:f'§§?§';€§V§:3'i 'fE;{§?'_{}:;::%? :":::3:::2§'; 5:? :a§};>.é;a:'g:1§§§:_--;: E}:::z:--;_:* xéfzséiéig §z*<2z:: iada V a