Delhi District Court
Civil Suit For Civil Judge/49/2008 on 16 September, 2010
1 Suit no.49/08
!
"# $ %&' () *+%,
"-%. $ /
021 3 54&(6 7 8 ! 9: + ; <
(>= ?>
@ A BDCFE GIHDJ:KMLON>P
Q LSRTBVU BVU$BXW Y[Z]\T^[_2`a_7bdcfe
g+h>iDj+kli mon-p.q>k:irnsmtqup.q>v w+x'xdizy{q g+mO|
?}g[j+vu~gupd( g>yq w:fpon6q iDp.y+
q(
/g>v>w>v>gup.g>%+>f>:X
g+h>iDj+kli mon p.g[j+y+ x'xdizy{q g+mO|
w)m]j+w[ X() / = M 5w}qup,(+ q>ym.w[p.%u(
wu iDj i( = q:D iz%>M>fu>
H'H'H'H.!7Yu_2ZXb_d
cRfR
Q Y[ZX ¡¢U£XYfe5£XY
u¤,w<;irnh+g¥" i m'mtqup[ )g>vu+g
+s¤,¦>¦[(+ f§>+gXn}T g>k>gup,( = q:D iz%>M>f¦XX H'H'H'H.¨ c ,c[Z:eY[ZXb = g+mtq w+x]iDj©nªmdi mdmdizwuj |«MM¤¬{¦6¤O¦ >f = g+mtq wuj#I>i y) p.qXnMqup h)q>vxtwup®)v>ku~quj{m |«M¯M¤,>M¤O¦ M = g+mtq w+xuv>q>y+i°nizwuj |«M¯M¤,>M¤O¦ M @ ]_7b ¢,c>±> u²:c´³l ¢µ R>HV¶:·V¶]¸+·7¹f¶]¸+Ht¸>º»L,¼OH ½ [e]¾5` c[ZXb3¿SÀÁ:¼&3Ybc  + +q à zg:iÄjmoi x'x3+gXn xdiÄzq>vm+qÅÃ>p.qXnMquj{mn>i m>x.w[p p.q>yw+h)qup Æ<w+x n} 7¦u(7¦3+('(¯f¦3+ t+ª¤,% g>k>g:iDj©nsm>md)q v>q+xtquj+v>guj{m>m>p.w:)kuÇi mong:m+wupdi°nMq>vÅp.quÃ>ptqXn6quj{mtg+mdi h)q[ ¦u +q ygXnMq w+x>md+qÅÃ> g:iDj{mdi x'x]i°n m+g+m>m+q v>q+xtquj+v>guj{muguÃ>Ã>p.w>g>y)+q>v ÈÉptq>Ê:)qXnsm.q>v m+qaà zg:iDj{mdi x'x˧+guj>xtwup3kup.guj{mw+x!zw>gujTw+x5 n+ X(¦>[(D>fM¤,%3x.w[pumd)qaà fp.y)+gXnMq¥w+x gah+qu>i y+zq8j+gu~q: ÆÍÌ !guj{mp.wM¤´Î$ Ï guj+vÐv>q+xtquj+v>guj{m q+Ñ)q>y+mtq>vÒg>kup.q>qu~quj{m w+x zw>guj y+f~ {ÆfÃ+w+m+q>yg+mdizwujf(av>q[~-g[j+v Ã>p.wu~ÇirnnMwup Æ j+w+mtq È iDpdp.q+h)w>ygu§ zq Ã+w}#qup w+x/g+m'mtwupdj)q+ÆÓiÄjÔxtg+h)w:fp;w+x m+qÕà zg:iDj{mdi x'xÖ§+guj> Ë ¢x'mtqup;q+Ñ)q>y+mdiÄj+k×md)q nMg:izv v>w>y+f~quj{mon+( m+q zw>gujØ#gXnÙnMguj+ymdizwuj+q>vÚmtwÛm+q v>q+xtquj+v>guj{m×guj+v v>q+xtquj+v>guj{mag>k[p.q>q>vÜmtw p.quÃ+g+ÆÝm+qÚn6g:izv zw>gujÜgu~w:fj{m iÄjÞ¯> !"TÄß°nàw+x n} ¯f ¬¤,%]qfg>y+f f zm¢irn¥nsm.g)m.qfv¥m+g+m g+x'mtqup p.q>yq:i h>iÄj+kam+qÒnMg:izvÐzw>gujagu~w:fj{m v>q+xtquj+v>guj{m xtg:iÄzq>v 2 Suit no.49/08 átâÝã>äuå+æuçtæÝátâèádå)æàédêDë+ãuë+ì+êzã:í ä:êrîMì}êDï íÄêDë+æðâ+é áå+æÙç.æuï+ã+ñfòæuë{áTâ+é áå+æØízâ>ãuë ãuòâ:ófë{á,ôÕõ!æ+ö)æuç.ã:í ï+âXîsá ä>ã)á.æ>äFì)å+æ>÷:ó)æXîøêrî{îó)æ>ä×ù{ñÍáå+æFä>æ+étæuë+ä>ãuë{á5úæuçtæ ä:êrî}å+âuë+â:ófç.æ>ä¥ãuë+ä áå+æ¥ä>æ+étæuë+ä>ãuë{áuúãXî-îMæuç ö)æ>ä úIê áå¥ç.æuòÇêDë+ä>æuç´îá.âÍï+ã+ñ ádå)æ ãuòâ:ófë{á,ô ûzáÐêrîÝîsátã+átæ>äÜáå+ã+á ï+æuç´îêrîsátæuë{á ç.æ>÷:ó©æXîªáoî ú#æuç.æ òã>ä>æÛù{ñÜádå)æ â+é'édêzì}êzã:írî â+éËáå+æ ï ízã:êDë{ádê é'é átâaáå+æ ä>æ+étæuë+ä>ãuë{áoîátâ ãuù ê äfæ ù{ñ áå+æaátæuçdò îTâ+é áå+æ ã>üuç.æ>æuòæuë{á æuë{átæuç.æ>ä×ù+æ)áú#æ>æuëaáå+æ×ï+ã[ç ádê æXîTãuë+ä áå+æ+ñ úæuç.æFã:írî6âøátâ:ízäøáå+ã+á áå+æFádêDòæÓú#ãXîøáå+æ æXîîMæuë+ìæÕâ+é ádå)æ ì{âuëádçtã>ì®á,ý átâþúIå êzì)å×áå+æÕä>æ)é.æuë)ä>ãuë{áoî å+ã+ö)æÕù+æ>æuë×ï>çtâuòÇê°îêDë+ü éç.âuòÛádêDòæ átâFádêDòæÕù óá å+ã>äÐétã:êÄízæ>ä átâÕå+âuë+â:ófç$å ê°î ìâuò òÇê ádòæuëá´î#ãuë+äÅå+æédófç áå+æuç étã:êÄízæ>äátâÅå+ãuë+ä>â+ö)æuç áå+æö)æuå êzì}ízæ[ô ÿ ô ûzá ê°îFîsá.ã)á.æfäÉádå)ã+á áå+æèï ízã:êDë{ádê é é ä:ó>í ñ ë+â+ádê éoêzæ>ä ófëá.â8áå+æ ä>æ+étæuë+ä>ãuë{á ö êzä>æ ã ë+â+ádêzìæÐátâ òã æ×ádå)æ ï+ã+ñfòæuë{á â+é áå+æÓâ:óáoîsátãuë+ä:êDë+üþãuòâ:ófë{á ãuë+äÓã:írîMâFátâ å+ãuë+ä>â+ö)æuç5áå+æ×ï+æ>ã>ìæ+édó>í3ï+âXîîMæXîîêzâuëøâ+é!áå+æøö)æuå êzì}ízæ[ýËãXîáå+æ×ï ízã:êDë{ádê é'é;å+ã:î édêDë+ã:íÄí ñ ä>æ>ì+ê ä>æ>älátâ úIê ádå+ä[ç.ã}ú áå+æTétã>ì+êÄírê á'ñøï>ç.â+ö>êzä>æ>äTátâTádå)æÍä>æ+étæuë+ä>ãuë{á,ýuù{ñTã ä>æuòãuë+ä ë+â+ádê ìæÓä>ã)á.æ>ä ù óáä>æXî}ï ê á.æ×ádå)æ ç.æ>ìæ:êDï{á â+é ë+â)áoêzìæFáå+æ ä>æ+étæuë+ä>ãuë{á3å+ãXî-ë+æ:ê áå+æuç]ç.æuï íÄêzæ>äÅë+âuç]òã>ä>æ ãuë{ñTï+ã+ñfòæuë{á,ô ô !ízã:êDë{ádê é'é ï>ç.ã+ñ)æ>äaá.âÐï+ãXîî ã ä>æ>ì)ç.æ>æÐêDëÇétã+ö)â:ófç â+é áå+æÒï ízã:êDë{ádê é'é!ãuë+äÔã>ü>ã:êDë©îsá áå+æ ä>æ+étæuë+ä>ãuëá étâuç ã îófò â+é /î+ô uý +ý +ô átâ>ü>æ+áå+æuçøú ê áå ìâXîsá,ý ï+æuë+ä>æuë{átã:íÄê átæ édóádófç.æÉêDë{átæuç.æXîsá [ô ï+æuç;ãuë>ë ófò éç.âuò áå+æþä>ã+átæþâ+é édêÄírêDë+ü â+é>áå+æ îó>ê á ádêÄíÄíê áoî-ç.æ>ã:íÄêrîMã+áoêzâuëfô [ô ;êzä>æ âuç.ä>æuç:äfã+á.æfä ! ! ! ádå)æÇäfæ+é.æ[ë+ä>ãuë{á úãXî-ï>ç.â>ìæ>æ>ä>æ>ä æ #"$ ï+ãuç átæ[ô %ô û3å+ã+ö)æ å+æ>ãuç.ä '& )( }ä[ô â:ófë î6æ:í©étâuç5áå+æÒï ízã:êÄëáoê é'é ãuë+ä ü>âuë+æøáå>ç.â:ó)üuå ádå)æÐì{ãXîMæ édêÄí æ ìãuç.æ+édó>íÄí ñXô +* uô 5â ï>çtâ+ö+æFê áoîTì{ãXîMæ×ï ízã:êDë{ádê é é¢æ )ãuòÇêDë+æ>ä #"
-,. ¥õ åfô / 10
ë ófç !å+â:í
æÐãuë)ä
2,3
ä>æuï+âXîMæ>äøêÄë<átæuçdò îIâ+éuáå+æÔï ízã:êDë{á5ãuë+äÔå+æÍîªátã+átæ>äTáå+ã+á å+æøêrî#áå+æ¥ã:óáå+âuçoêrîMæ>ä ç.æuï>ç.æXîMæuë{átã+ádê ö)æÙâ+éládå)æ ï ízã:êDë{ádê é'é ù+ãuë ãuë+ä å+æ êrîðå+ã)ö êDë+üÚã ï+â}úæuçaâ+é #"
ã+á'átâuçdë+æ+ñÍæ +æfì}óátæ>ä×ù{ñÍáå+æ×ï ízã:êDë{ádê é'é;ù+ãuë êÄëÐå êrîTétã+ö)â:ófçËú-å+æuç.æuù{ñ å+æ×å+ãXî ù+æ>æuë ä:ó>í ñ ã:óáå+âuçoê æ>ä 54 æuò ï+â+úæuç.æ>äFátâþã>ìá âuëþù+æuå+ã:í é;â+é áå+æÕï ízã:êÄëáoê é'é ãuë+ä áå+æ ìâuï{ñÅâ+éîMã:êzäaï+â}ú#æuç[â+é ã+á'átâuçdë+æ+ñlê°îIæ >åXô #" 6
-,. ! 7/ 98 ô æÅîsátã+átæ>ä áå+ã+á áå+æ ä>æ+étæuë+ä>ãuë{á/ãuï>ï>ç.â>ã>ì)å+æ>ä : Þçtæ>÷:ó)æXîsá.æfäÍáå+æ×ï ízã:êDë{ádê é'é ù+ã[ë étâuç üuçtãuë{á â+é ízâ>ãuë â+é <;
î}ô fý uý étâuçÙáå+æ ï ófç.ì)å+ãXîMæ â+é ã ö)æuå êzì}ízæ ë+ãuòæ:í ñ 3 Suit no.49/08 =?>A@2B CED F G7HJILKM@6B#NON P#Q P6B#N @6BRCSP#T$P U#VRC P N U$DWP NYX CSQW@ UZX\[\X C^]_@6` `a[\XbU @#CEXbF6B cdN P P N F#Qfe ] `#F#Cge#P UR@#CEXbF6B.h XiDEDWP#j$F UR@6ka[bPl`#F#mnP6DoF#Qo@#C^C F6DEB$P#]pXiBqQ @#j$FYV DoF#QrCEe$P `a[b@YXiB CEX Q^Qsk#@6B tu@6B$N Cge#P @ v6DWP P6wxP6B COF#Qy[bF @6B U#V w e ] `#F#Cge#P UR@#CEXbF6B X{z P#T e |^I2}.~!GcN P6wx@6B#N` DWF6wX z z F6D<]B#F#C PX zyP#T e |^I-}.~!G? h XiDEDWP#j$F UR@6ka[bP `#FZmP6D1F#Q@#C^CWF2DEB#P#] X zP#T e |^I-}.~!G|P'zCW@$CWP NCge#@#C@#Q^C P6D1P#T$P U#VRCXiB#vCEe$P z @YXbN N F U#V wxP6B Cz#cCge#P [bF @6Bm@zz @6B#U+CEXbF6B#P NuC FCge#P N P#Q P6B#N @6B C_@6B#N N P#Q P6B#N @6B C@ v2DWP P NC F DWP6`#@#]Cge#Puz @YXbN [bF @6B@6wxFYV B C:X\B A o¡\¢{z£F#Q ¤ zZ| ¥a¦L~!G §¨P @ U$e | P zC @#C P N©Cge#@#C@#Q^C P6DDWP URPYX j XiB#v9Cge#P z @YXbNª[bF @6B©@6wxFYV B C N P#Q P6B#N @6B C2Q @YX\[5P N«CWFf@ N6e#P6DWPfC FoCge#PoQEXiB#@6B#U#X5@Y[ZNYX z UZXi`a[\XiB#P9F#Q)Cge#P DWP6`#@#] wxP6B C F#QSCEe$P.[5F @6B¬@6wxFYV B C @6B#Nyz P#j$P6DW@Y[`#FzCN @$CWP N U$e#P ®YV$Pz¯X zRzRV$P N3k ]'Cge#P N P#Q P6B#N @6B ComP6DWPuNYX zZe#F6B#FYV DWP N2| ¨PzC @#C P NCge#@#CfCEe$PN P$QWP6B$N @6B Comn@z z P6D<j$P Nym°X Cge£DWP6wXiB#N P6D7z¬C F`#@#]±Cge#P@6wxFYV B C@6B$N`#P6D7z²X{zC P6B CfD P ®YV$PzC7z mP6DWPwx@ N P k ]rCEe$P³F#Q^QEXbUZXb@Y[ zxF#Q2CEe$P©`a[b@YXiB CEX Q^Q2CWFoCge#P9N P#Q P6B#N @6BRC6C F³@6k X5N P k ] Cge#P¯C P6DEwrz¯F#QnCge#P£@ v6DWP P6wxP6B C´P6B C P6DWP Npk#P#C<mnP P6B CEe$P`#@2D<CEX5Pz¬@6B#N±Cge#P#] mP6DWP³@Y[ z FrC FY[bNoCge#@#C2CEe$PrCEXiwxPmn@z Cge#P³PzRz P6B#URP«F#Q2Cge#PfU F6BRCED @ UµC c#C Fm´eaX5U$e Cge#P9N P#Q P6B#N @6B C¨e#@Yzok#P P6B ` DWF6wX z²XiB#vfQgDWF6wpCEX\wxP«C FfCEXiwxPkaVRCe#@ NfQ @YX\[bP NCWF e#F6B#FYV D9eaX z±URF6wwX CEwxP6BRC7z#| ¨P£QEV D^CEe#P2D³zC @#C P N¶Cge#@#C·Cge#P`a[b@YXiB CEX Q^Q³NYV [ ] B#F#CEX QEX5P NV BRCWFCge#P:N P#Q P6B#N @6B C)j X5N P:@B#F#CEXbURP9C Fwx@6tµPCge#P`#@#] wxP6B CdF#QLCge#P FYVRCzC @6B#NYXiB#v«@6wxFYVB C¸@6B#N«@Y[ z FoC F e#@6B#N F#j$P6D-Cge#P `#P @ URP#QEV [ `#FzRz PzRzRXbF6BfF#Q Cge#Prj$P6eaXbU#[bP@6B#NfCge#P `a[b@YX\BRCX Q^Q¹e#@z°QEXiB#@Y[\[ ]³N P U#XbN P NfC F³m°X Cge#N6D @Zm.Cge#PfQ @ U#X\[ X C^] ` DWF#j XbN P NªC F:Cge#P¯N P#Q P6B#N @6B C ck ] @ N P6wx@6B#NOB#F#CEXbURP N @#C P N G ¦ G ¥_@6B#N Cge#P B#F$CXbURP¯X z9P#T e |dI2}3~!Gºsh`#FzC @Y[ DWP URPYXi` Cz9P#T e |dI2}3~!Gº» kaVRCN PzZ`aX C P Cge#P_DWP URPYXi` CF#QdCge#P B#F#CEX5URP©Cge#PªN P#Q P6B#N @6B C1e#@z B#PYX Cge#P6DDWP6`a[\XbP N_B#F6DSwx@ N P @6B ]:`#@$] wxP6B C | ¨P zC @#C P N9Cge#@#Cd@z`#P6DLCEe$P @ URURFYV B Czwx@YX\B C @YXiB#P N k ]9CEe$P `a[b@YXiB CEX Q^Q k#@2B tRc#Cge#P³N P$QWP6B$N @6B CLX zx[\X5@6ka[bPoC F`#@$]@«z²V wlF#Q ¤ zZ| ¼6c ¼ ~#c ¼ ~#| ~#½¾G § @6B#NCge#PURP6D<CEX QEX5P NlU F6`R]F#Qz¾C @#C P6wxP6B C«F#Q@ URU F6V B CfN @$CWP N¼a G!~ ~!G ¥ph ¿ G L~!GÀ¼aL~ @6DWPP#T e | I2}3~!G Áyh_P#T e |^I2}3~!G| ¦2|a¡2e#@#j$P e#P @6DWN9Cge#P'ÂZN-|-1FYV B z PY[ZQ F6DLCEe$PÃ`a[b@YXiB CEX Q<Q¨@6B#NÃ`#P6DV z P NCge#PÃD P U F6D N j$P6D<]UR@6DWP#QEV [\[ ] | Äe#P P#j XbN P6B#URP F#Q:Cge#P `a[5@YXiB CEX Q^Q v F PzV B DWP6kaVRC^C P N h V B#U$e#@Y[\[bP6B#v P N @6B#N ¡±e#@#j$P B#F D P @z F2B z CWF NYX{zZk#PY[\XbP#j$P Cge#P z @6wxP2| 4 Suit no.49/08 ÅÆRÆRÇ6ÈWÉYÊiË#ÌYÍ ÎÏÑÐgÒ#ÓÔaÍbÕYÊiË ÐEÊ Ö<Ö9Ê ×.Ó6Ë ÐEÊ ÐÍbÓ ÉÐ ÇÕÉ Ó Æ#ÈWÓ Ó£Ö Ç6ÈfÕ6ËÕ6ØxÇYÙ Ë Ð«Ç#Ö Ú×ZÛ Ü6Ï Ü Ý#Ï Þ Ü Ý#Û Ý#ß¾à áÕYÍbÇ6Ë#ÌZâÊ ÐgÒ Ê\Ë Ð Ó6È Ó×¾ÐÑã Ý ä å Ô#Ó2ÈAÕ6Ë ËaÙ ØÖgÈWÇ6ØÐEÒ$Ó É Õ#Ð Ó Ç#Ö)ÖEÊ\Í\Ê\Ë#Ì:Ç#Ö)ÐgÒ#Ó×²Ù Ê ÐLÐEÊ\Í\ÍÊ Ð׳ÈWÓ ÕYÍ\Ê × Õ#ÐEÊ5Ç6Ë Û'æÇ×ÐdÇ#Ö)ÐgÒ#Ó×²Ù Ê Ð¨Ê{×rÕYÍ × Ç:ÕZânÕ6ÈWÉ Ó É Ð ÇÐEÒ$Ó ÔaÍbÕYÊiË ÐEÊ Ö<Ö ÛÃçÓ Æ$ÈWÓ Ó ×ZÒ#Ó Ó#Яè#Ó Ô ÈWÓ6Ô#Õ6ÈWÓ É Õ Æ ÆRÇ6ÈWÉ6Ê\Ë#ÌYÍ ÎÛ éYÊ\ÍbÓ è#Ó ÆRÇ6Ë ×²Ê5Ì2Ë#Ó ÉxÐ ÇfÈ Ó Æ Ç2ÈWÉ«ÈWÇ Ç6ØÕ#Ö^Ð Ó6ÈYÉYÙ$ÓÆRÇ6ØÔaÍ ÊbÕ6Ë#ÆRÓ2Û ÅJË Ë#ÇYÙ Ë#ÆRÓ ÉfÊiË ÐEÒ#ÓÇ2Ô#Ó6ËræÇYÙ È<Ð Û ç¨Õ#Ð Ó É-êiáëÝ Þ à ä ì àÀÜaäLÝ ä2Û í ÚÕ6î+Ó×ZÒfïðÙ ØxÕ6È áòñ^ñió ææ¨ô#áEÆ#Ù ØxáWÅJÚæ í^õ¬ÓY׾Рó ÚÇ Ç6ØË#Ç2Û ÝZö#ì2Ï{÷dÊ ×xøÕaù²Õ6ÈÊ æ1ÇYÙ È<Ð×#Ï çÓYÍiÒaÊ Û ú¨Ç#Ð Ó-êiáAûLÕ Ì Ó×´Ë#Ç2Û ÝJÐ Çxü«Õ6ÈWÓÉYÙ Í Î×RÊbÌ6Ë#Ó É«è ÎoØxÓ2Û í ÚÕ6î+Ó×ZÒfïðÙ ØxÕ6È áòñ^ñió ææ¨ô#áEÆ#Ù ØxáWÅJÚæ í^õ¬ÓY׾Рó ÚÇ Ç6ØË#Ç2Û ÝZö#ì2Ï{÷dÊ ×xøÕaù²Õ6ÈÊ æ1ÇYÙ È<Ð×#Ï çÓYÍiÒaÊ Û