Karnataka High Court
Commissioner Of Income Tax Iii vs Shi K N Surendra Reddy & Smt Vinutha Reddy on 2 November, 2011
Bench: N.Kumar, Ravi Malimath
:2»; $33 mag: Qfiflfif fii?' AT Efifififififififi E'}3%.§.é:é<:§ §::§':§§.-2 'i,}'2:=;*. 2""? u:"E2;2.jg :3?' ?af<>:f§;i§":'":%3é:%§1 iZfi7;€ :i>E'zEs::.ié;;%f-::'x»4*';T' $13 §£§:g*§§£: ME. J§§*§:§i.§i;. 'V X T;
.»['z?¥€§:::; 1' ' .' 2 " .
*:*:§§: E§QE§'§LE MR5 g§§}S?*:§5<:§t:V§A%is§-- §§§:§§§§;;?§§
-:':;:zx §\1€3:éL'.<'%;:z§"':<:3.4 ;3:*'..::@ E S 2:: :':':.:2 No. 343 §;€"iZ§{§E.€"}» . f'._ 7'§ E3'i%Z'§"\,?€EiZ-EELIXE: ' "
E {E :}.:'::2:3':2" an (:5 :~:.:_'§ "'i;i}é',{}!§':'."E{f ' A 'E'2:>:--EE£ A "
_ _{';5:§:%::22%:§. «¥--§;a%ar<%;': {:23 EE ;,:'iE--§%_§j:': . §;5:;:e::%:T1E:;e----_E['{'s:3ée=,"<.i'i .. H """ "
'_:¢§a:::sg:g.g;;~a; + :"3»;b::::'V Si? :
2'?:§s5e§:~:.E:é%_23 {E22 :':_%,':j:<:i_§;<:i3::-;:~.£f;*:'"2 :31"
" mi}? E:2<*:{}:j_:1s;*: '.?:j2.:b=: 'T i';i§r§:E€: '?{"i%} ~ «§::32z2:';§g2:§£:m=t:" _ A1' W5-'a_g:§3{%§§£::'%.%.$ "
, 8;: E?) E§2;s§:§':':z:§.E':i E:'z::§ér;22 §<;;:,:'::;2§.'1 ' " 2-7:<év{3{::¢z§'.§:::} .;.........q A 3%} E} * Séwi K ;'E§z.;re:'1<:§2'z.2 1%-édsi}.-* Sim; . 'Si: 2 :2 iii": E%.a:é{i:i3r ?'2'§'«:>$ E539, ?"1 Taiéergzé * E31" B§{::*;E.~; I E{<>:'a;2¢:'2':;1:":;;;f2'-2&2: . _ ~ _ «. .. £:%a::':g§2=:E(3:*s% T--« EEQEG G§}:"ia .' " ._ " '€35-;;§;';<:*;'1€,'§ %:'3_§.
{B3,-* ;%:":i 5%., ET5E":22.n:§te;'I{:' ~ ;._1:':£§» E'v§.. L;.é%;:/2..,H ;%€.§'éf{j3<..x .13; V "E'h§.i% {E1-="-'a §£§{3{§ iii i§§}1€}fi=;V"€i${7E.'E7.._ <:;2'€i{:=.:' s:?;:-;:é':::%<i 2§§--{}é{»20{}6.w«-§}2:s§é§ 6:2.'--:1.:jy.§_'§'Af=J§>§ Zv3?_§j'E§§2r:.:1§;_:;'2€}€)E} 5:33' 'size: g'%$&=;£:s~:~: :z1*:'f:;";.«:' .Z§E{§§;;.i'§}§%., ';::f_:ta;;§::~ 'j {£2 {Q £%}.:";:':':,:§2:1:'5: éhiz ;=s:,ib-.<:3§.2u3§.iz:§ g:gé--_:<3.k mzigswcfi-E" Eaw :'e3:'..;:,i}eC§ %i.§.:.c=.:.'s2.in, {ii} S€:'§'. zmiiie iéze :3:*<§:3;:' §§a§':€j:§ iZ?'4€%~€:%é?z3%.;3G{3*-éj;«-- §V?3:}.;s$~;;;%{§v.V 'é.E":e::° §'§1';%'a'iI 'A, B€'nc:i":, E.32mg§21Ez>§"€ £53'. z'§»§§'§'=%€*.a*;§ §3'r<3c:é<%%:E«§::;§§;" §'§j7':": .I'aL"(>,§ ET36,f§-3;-m§§;"2G8§? 2:5'; :'»s;Q':.:§;*E':%..v§::}:"~E.s'; E§'1%:»:»; ' E22 E12": 25 _ V §§Ei'£"%{§§E§N: '' ' ' ' ' {:3§}ETEEE'_E'z§§S§Si€}E'§€§;"i'}§; 'Eng: 322:3' 9"'. " 'é~:2:.£§'% {%'§€*::z.2:.-? §'E,1f;{§§.§'%§-S 'E if; 5;
E32:;':;§:1E--<:: :3 ~ 5&2 :i}é3.§_ ' A-"*¢2';2'1:': EL. {:{,'sE'EE§'§'T:"§$f§~9§€}§}E¥i%E° . <*:§V'§:'";<_'<}2f:[:;€ '§"z2:i<;
"_.{.Z§§"e::Zs3. ",3/'§E} " ' E53 212:: ;;;:I.a§::': Mr K , .f:§3;'3£:§§22:T: $.55 H E_'_§}%'3.§ 2::*§$i:':g; r:sz':'§'. <35 " T. -A;'?\.ifi'..g §§%£S "§.'%2::%§,»-* §E§%."£é'? E,}éE{'.?{}§'E'z_€? E':25?a.;:.:%%.::2..€}':_,1$ 2;-2.5; §°:"£::~a§::
{£:3},.-*' SEE E3 $2-m2':':2:.§E2§ §_z'1<§§;:z'~:: Efizgzzzz-:2: V §%.<:§v:::{'i2:§a:} " "
,:?'*j'\£E}:
SE12": 2%; N Sm"::=.;'2{%§7'a-i2 .E.{<:%z:§{:%y S§'§'E"€' . "\£':"m,2. i. E': §?;<'%<§ {Ey Ni}. "£89. "iii? "if }'v<§.2'£i§'} L3?" E§§<>2:%<, E{.<}:'z.u':221::,;_{;r;:§2;a §T§s:a§,,{2:.}i_:}:"& -« 55?} €}§}i'§ ,.:E€<:%&a§":§>';'*:s:§é:s=:2'§.
"§"'§3_is:; §'i.1f§ i'é§{%{%; ,5 fEi€§:jEg:é;--. zf:f?'Ef§.'f_: E 2:z"§s;§:':;,_§ 32.32%; sf <3i"'::,§:--:=r ::§a%;,:=.d 2%)?Q4?2{}{}€%~-;::%:a.:%'::;€:{§-in,§'§°;"=;Nd;~§.".§§§'?;'E3a:':;gj2@€39 E232"
i.§':(: £*:s;ss:;ass;s;.r:':<;%;;":z'«.g *--"gr":-1% 1,3E%§}9_{?;a§-€}€f§; '_§:fz:f;i.i=2g 'as'; {E} §<:er:";'mE::::'E'.<:>, 'E315 sm'§3s;'£.z?:m)i2*a§ {§_?_.,1<3:k ::'>n:~"~:_<;';s§;' Zziw S§£"§§3I.ff,d 'tEh:%'%'€i;';. {ii} 367:. 21-séiiié: %;;Z*§e {2:'d;@r <:Ea§<§:{iV ';§.5--'£E'<*;;52{E@§3 "g~*:.as':a_ :23; 'Ehs: E"E'§§E', 1?: Bemitéz, §:§2?::§:;;§z3.§<>:"€r :3} z'~'-;z>*--*>g=;:;;E r3;'<72{.%':.,, §..1"i":§.I§::as ETA Mi}. 3 i3'?fB;2:agg;'2i§€f3§, :=:~:{3::g;iI.r.:3::. §;1.;:«-rv $2: '$313; :;%§3{;*::':.%_, ' '§'§n'<::$a% , §'§T;%sa {%{>i§:.§b:':§;: am §<>:° E'%§3:2'::"§.::;§_:: %.hE:':~; éigzjgz $31 Ki? ' g;_V,., <:§£;2§";*5_{;?§°é;;>.:§ '::E":*¢=: §'a}E§{m?'§.t':§,;:
_ . . . .
.';§"§<:sé3?:':e;:: ;:.'§}§3'%§?:2z.§::§ 3.3%? p:'é::§k3§:fs%s:f§ '$5,? '£226 E-=€€;af€:'2z:;s3 :.?E'2a.§.£€::":g;;:i:i§; §..;?.1.<%"'«<.>:*:E'ér;"é'§1::2;§§~s&:;:"§ E33'; '£;':::2i< '.i"zf:¥i:;L1:":aE x5;r'§3,§<?E': §':as:; s2:s:*.1. z:::~f=;ié:i£é '%;E":r3 a';:'{§:;=r éhés {:{}§"§E1'E1iE€§E§E{}E1€:?§' :.::'.:{>§m* :'i%<:*:::i:%:<:2;ré 252% 5:2? E53: §*z';C{§§2'E€3. ;Iza;s5£E:a:~;:}';é?;'*:'£_ :;:*:;§;<*_2"s; 3:;-:i..:*e:? ha-;*<-.33"; g:".r;2s+;:f~:<':<§ ;;¥;.3":.{i §:'E{;', :3":2:4';:'E:é?§':'- ;ga§;.§i:'2 'Ex-i%.§"<;':":* %'E':z§:9; {T3<>m'§ Es: 2.:;:a§2ti2:z§, &ga:9§*§£§§gEg§ £52339 zisreg a§;*3e£a§;é:;*,.Q§f€ -&é§;%::-§;;§§éfiS5 '%;.:%;;::>j--' "