Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

- Know your Kanoon - Doc Gen Hub - Counter Argument - Case Predict AI - Talk with IK Doc - ...
Upgrade to Premium
[Cites 0, Cited by 1]

Karnataka High Court

Ajit Kulkarni S/O Sri Mallarao Kulkarni vs The State Of Karnataka on 22 January, 2010

Author: Jawad Rahim

Bench: Jawad Rahim

:."'§;§§:$

33* gagzatwé 

Efié THE REG}? CQUR? Q?" E»{fi?3i§'*~§&T.fi=§<é
CERCUET BEEQCH £2? Gé}L$§%R§§%

mag "?§~§T;$ "ma :2" ma? GEE }£éa§'s§§..§;f'aR'¥' 

EE?QRE

ma Hgmmg E"iER.3'é§S"E"§Cj;'E>K!5K'i,iE€15§£E<'§.£a§§AZ'§».é._' L  

cR;,?,:w,§::a::;2§a§ ms; Céja,§>:;s%«:T€3:.@mS:k2@::9,f "= 

CR; R $53 91 $6 25239 &- '€::§{L:s $2 .?fj--i;Cg9§!if:Z?"  

Efii CREW?' §'\:T8,§E.€_'}éf2§€é§

EETWEEN

AEE? K§§L%<,fiaR§'éE V     

§;'% 3% §~'2fi:L§.,fi£{£v:'_} §<L3%'L§<A"§€§$E.< 

AGES AE{;m*;_';§:s';%§;%.E'::»R$ 'L  "   

waaxzmg gag '*%i;~%:.a...%;%.:C§4.j;:§;'§.§:zséagast" ;:_§~§%@::

:;fia$AvAm'3f"m:::_<:_sE§2/§§--:~§»"é?_ «_  '

LAKSH§f'%'§_§.§'?éV:'%R;§'?fi,'§'%§;::_§'§_A£§_§ifi3 %

"syakguxgvi $E§';zwV_,  

$'§§"1:"§;ECT: E{;::;:;--§§§;::'~,;_§é;'      ?E"§"§"§'"§§§'==éE?\
 , {§=g"S:--;_:€«=*;";:§;-ivifiaéégé §a::2::'%é,&s,.:*: ;am_,j:-2

 $fE'{é1;'a*»§:'::'?:.fF% :%';:{;éé;f.ga?2§§<;:
 R§$%"3:'}§'éfiE§*§?

 "{}3€;'ém: .i'%._§'1é%..§R£%E%%~*:1% gwmggéi, gm

A ":;,:r's,':_.;%"'§§:_§§ i§;"S=§g$}'; S? {:§:L9..C 3'; mg §a{,?:?$>C§C?E

 §:§¥§*2;. f%'i%-%.£' §E'§E'?Eii'}§*~«£ER fimzyiézég ?"§-éfiii" Tfiéfi §-4;{3;%=;§$:,.§
 ::$:;%;j§ Ts'-Jmsr 33 yrgmggg ":3 Q£§§§§»% mg @m::E§§§s2sa;;5
    §«:@«3<»a;:3$ §§:r~§a:§2gsg Sf? "$3-gg $32.5 :::;r ":'"§~»£§ iajazqiga,
 ésévgagagzgfgfig Wag? {:5-513$ :~%%§§7.> §§*=;:a .::;::s§§ ijfifiéiififi

   

 .

DEVESEGME §EE§AF»§ ANS SECL/%RE ?%éA'? THE RE$PGf\§BEE\§T PSLECE HAS NQ JSRESSICTEQN EC E?'xEEz'E§"§"£GA"?'§"'-E»%"'~§'E"€} THE E§3CE§}EE'~é"?}'fi\C££@E?a§"¥" 'WE'§E§§°"§ EE BGVL?R§'éE§vV.E5"'5_<"ZT_HE P§*3'2J§$EC§'€§ Q2; F,&£TO§E§S ACT; EQ48 fi~;§'~J$V...."_°f_T'§*Zé'»f73i'\§">- '??V4<§'§ $ES'EG§2§£%"E"E§ ,am";-§9&:m§$ é§E\§§§E3i mg §fi,¢:I*f§§.':'E--§}j'-«§é$?_;.' E948 ,i~'i§._§?:§E §~';;%'=«fE 3%;,§?{E$m€'%"E§€'=£ '§"G :§"§:{§s<*;?fVV§§§;;"§?:"»:" ;:f:es'£*>__ EEEKE QCTEQQ §.§?§§ER T%§E i7iC""%'". 1?'-S CREW? §'»§C}.§E§§ 2899 B5T's.r"€EE§¥§ E' ?v'?r.§AL3EE"E" 5:§~é€.;':~~:..,_5§a\;s=";:R,s; j' V _ S/Q gm mR3;*:R;:a--.;<:'irx;$_§i 3;,;€xs:;:;§;§ * AGED Aggy? 5'? YEARS = :f:fGR.§<E§*»é<3 :25 THE-%:%E$:g--§«§§? ' VAS§VA§i}flI_T"_;»?2 €EE?v'§EF\é.T . ' j_ Lfi,§<S%é§~s§:%:§mé;:::";ésg;fa€~é. gas';-+2.@;a§. 3 V "%'"Q : §EfQA§<»*i, ":;".:».%';'?:.-_;:;*f: §.j:;%.é,"*%A_;:2i%,;A--,» '

3. 2'-»%m:§§"§" %*5,_U§w%<fi$§_§'-£'§~."=-_» " _ ' - $;'@,svm:,,.m.R;§Q :<:a,:V:»;:«:¢;%fJaR_r%,§;*z.__ AGEQ ,:x§@:;*§3%3 ':'°E:'3,§';% .-- V " .. :r2;@Rs<:;::§ ,a$T%:-§§ §Ef'a§E'f%i'1;§:,'?»rEi?a§'s§fi2GE§4 V 2z,é%$;a:sf;a@i;:??A Cé?3E'¥Ej,Ei'=§T V §;"{3;§'<§'§T§?;?§E§?§-§iR§3€;§é--i§"~§ :as;i:;'§s;f:';':2, 'v.$":,*,:_:~:?,::$:;;a;:~4*;.¢. _ * '::a;§§?:*;_@';s:;'&a.'§'*:L?;:%;:; :;>§:":':°:@§»§E§§ __";;'§3;§;:€5é5€<é;v:{';a :1; 1:»<,§:§":a.-mi; A.§::,,j; ' ':::.:9;;:ir§2__ a§'é,}:aRm"?,a;<a :33? SE%7§_;5'2.E'»'§ §>=§}§;_..E£§ §RE§§iZ}E'ti$E§\§T £333: éfiéufiéfizfifié §m::§§;:Q; <:'-s;§9;:

\ Charge far affenae amfier Seatéggrz 384% mesa careiesgnegg $3 net Siifféfliéfiféi :3 §€'3S$fjL£§§f far 3% gaéfi gffenceg "§'"E*:e ac:
magi he 0? §:;£E": nature a3 8} gémaras axégteace :2? meéégrga, fiaggiyirzg Em zfigex Cs:::"i:'s éecigésnf the Eufige sf %:§*=§§s Sam: QU5S§":€§ Ehe §§VGC@§§§§'Z~{§S' _EE"§§§§c3§:V€{'Z:_ 9' agaéngi the accuséé far éffezéte Em" ::e;%'zEch $6 wag sfiagfii Ea $3 E:r£éii._ sfiaténg »§:i;§:a§:;é'E--E§f'r;'f'--.. an €5T'IQ§€3'g'&€ in iha faaajrgz.
1:, Tm théréy "§;<§:E_SEé§n 2;:s;~ ._§"mx}; aicteniiars is firawm is 3? %:%'aew.§ea;":"s:e=:<:§'~».é§*z;;VEe._§,ué§{;§e Eé§?;j'%'zar§<ham§ Hégh iaamt:%é%é§éj:'é§:f_§s*':"3£;§%::é_§a»::*.:"i'aC*1: séfégaticn. "ihe §eam&aE Singée Euége £§a:E<§:'=2gVmfaé$5_»Ti§2.é"@:.:..::§§hmm: Qfefifififififfi mgazfiiyzg wr::§a;v"&;2§é"{;vr2V'é3§t,§rmé';_3§§'%2§ :3? §"5C{€§§°E8S fies: Er; §e€€E0:*'2 92 gggfiiaé E§i2*'«;:"'*s§:aE§ gyeagaéé sever the gagzeyai Eaw, mi _:é::§E*:%.§V§*2«3V§§-%*:a:}é' :"z§§: c::':n:a.:2*'rani§§; "fa? iha gama iaase 9?" a€:ii§_éA:":, Sgléésgg 53:' the véazfig am: §E'"%§€£§_E§§GfE §"'€§&€"§§?'é§ '.,'<;@:*2i§'§§'*A.s§§::':§a:': G? §§"é:u;§5§<>§2 9:? %'a£*'{a3r§e$ $5: fifififiiéiiéififié $9 " . ::.§fé.§*:}::@ gamégméaée zzyzéa §e<:%,§«:;§: §?2 §;§ im fig: wézéaéz E3; E';-3 %.:'*~.i§":@%§';€!°' $§{'£""§U§i:&£"E8@US mogegsjtim is parmésgéibée Q: mi'? 5% ésagfitg éha fearszafl §§ng§e Euége has ;>z'sa:'%§§s§"2 Q? $ac'¥:§§:*: 2% Q? {Em Generaé C§a:;§.;:;~§2: s-*a::fi%,; "}."4'%i§"? ' "I V in $353 1:13 9? its juégmenz, "sifigsersgieqi :h:;g_:'-- " 2 "E532 if is arises. §e:"ii%er:i':"~:ii<:§:> T§:%.9 v"::»'z:a°' pmvfigzms ff? 5:??? Ag%.s=._ ;';'-2,;a:;_;>*_: R';'é;2é'é;k§'V C3f7f€';'T§?f!?éZ}if;'§f fieiafs {if Q;f}%é2'7:?i§":i$_{?. $f:':}"' §:2QA€f3 %f';@ £555 £35? f:;nC€:'ar} ?v.s§tf: :p¥;gé_@;_.TA§':5:§$ by side in 55:25:'; SW3; garaffé-3 'V 5S:ér§'he£§T;'\ SS9 wi'2;'f@ :9::5:"deri;t§§ ,S@cSz&é}é§' <32' C':,§',Cg grad z'z'?;:é._.:;g}r<é§:T§2f.;;<;;g.":%;%:;f iééfiaie 35(2) 3%" fire i"5¥z35;':';i;'ja:.z?iéz2»a§?'=}£'2'?rt;?z'&v-'a§ ':2v*'éf! gg Secfzbn 26 $2'? Ci§3*3a2'§f5e:;_ £155 {a,><'£"r§<:"i€Q' 559%}, §:%=_::?%é <;«::sé~igfisvzégzzzsiéagfg _.mM§z::;§?§§ zszmz V5 §§§£%SfS*i{§f§; ':?g§;f;reme :;';'§:;:r:';" flag @&;=;:war*ea*' ; 53%: i3.é§?:%, ff? €$:§€ of £r:f;'::f5 £252} 9?" {Em
-I:"C'::?s'1s*:";if:;ff§z": éé zwfi 5:3: $555533 35% 3?" 533% fiilfgzzgeg $.55; 53 §§S§'"§§§ gg g 5332?, {fie ' ' éragaggzéisfi mm!' C§??S€'Q§,£€'??§§5§ ;::;.g%é;§ff$%%%ér2§ z'*f:§r§a,s;'z;?s: mag: 52$ fag" :';';§ ggma §"fT:f:fLé%;:s3 5.3,; 3:'; &f}'5é:;r5e i:%'?§Q:S€ s';':§r§§?s'e;?:i§ 53:? A 'j «-335mg' "
§%"%x<%@@%§§¥2§§§§% 3%%&& V 1%, ?"mm the asbgewatéan 9:' parafifi {fie Ezgégmenz, éé ég gaen Ehgt ma Eeameai Séngie 3:;;i%«{§'Ee--~_'fié§"£:aé ééffer fmrr; the View {fiat when the 9ffafi§g:j?g'--- &§.§:é}§.§éi§ :,.é:_'f'::e"'. same mégr ggmcéaé iaw aflé ge:'2e_jraE. §;a'e.g::§, ::éé%S1cz:=:%j,»,.i?§:'.}..'%g*a{@:;.§§ V' cgme mm €}fi€2'§"§§€?i"'£.
1?. in mew sf varésfia.uEi<:>r:§e:'2i§'{2né":='éé3é'{.§ by iwth sifieg, it vvzméé be r:é<:;'e5sa:*%§"is-'iéfsémuiate tééé fG§§Q'v'=!§E"'§§ ;§@§n:§ fag" éeeéséérgr {E} W%:e§§§ér E§§iEL'E'§;gi£~aéf2 $5__§3£"'=:§;<_s~.'i§§;'§§€sé§€H z£nfiea" ,;,C--f$CiE$€"§ 39¢ A $5 :$§:_"';é;h§§'é«:';}V§*::'i§g;3;é;;§'E:'§'ca:€'gfar fifengeg §iL£§""§§S?"§8§§$ Faaitarées fact £5 Eagafiy §'E':~:*«%.?$gi?3§§&~?7" - "
;"&='§:aE?:é:"-»_p'a'%*a§%é§ :33" §§E'?'%E,_§§t§E'§E§§.§§ ;§s":2s§€:a:i§§§*: ég a'''''"\ N1 \v....u# §a:Ag.&§£~>g %m§eé?:*%i'§'§s§b£e?
.::.3V:} ,_ A15§}§E%?{€;»§'}8'2'f;;.V V§;§?§ ::<2§2$ra:,,rerzi%0§z <3? $e::"%:%a::"2 fiéfiiééfé Efigiéviiéfiiééé am? Eastéer: 3253} 3? $19 %7§€?;@§"£&$ fiat, 3%-8 sf $28 Fafiiwées fiat: §i§§"E;§§§'§&:E%§% z,::2§a? §&C€§§§'§ AA $9 Qfiiifiiéfifi :2:;é€i:%"; iém sgzffaézsé §i§%'"%E.§?'%&§§€ uméar 'figciésgm Z§%f;%é«§a =::f WC» E /) A " 'S' -"*3 Z8 23;" Cgmiéaaxerztéefi 9? gay 0?' ihe pr0v%si§s';.-":2? Ehég figs: mg @665"; made gem? am? ;:3:m%gE'::a§£e u:"s6e:§;r9 "f-§'}§;«a;§§V,*é~v=:;:*2 Q2, SECEEGQ §2 §:"es<:r§bs33 the f§5§mz;é%ng:»~ "Q3, §es§erai genraity fer; af2{e §:g%e:5;4:; is <3é'f?e:'wise exgregsfy pig:/f§:;':§fG? éfzi;?; g§§cAf:;a*:5*§§:_ ' Eéfbjfléff fa fire §r@vi3é5;?:$"--«:;3f §rs:f7z=:§:f;2* "«:%s' gr; f*E$;§€C€" azi any fé7:;féé;*;xVV €f%é:":-% §'5 Say Cfiflffa venfigfl 9?' gay ;;;:%;i;§zz;';s?ie3:?sV V 'éf V£"f7f$ AC2? er 9;' gay r5gié.?s:' {:':3é.;is»:=f,ii'*;;'§-€s"é:§§'?£?'é:'--¢g' sf any arfier in waging g;'axa}izj'~é"i2e-,rewz;;§§e:r,; aciazpgér and mafiaggfiaf 55%iz':;:zi::"g?%f';<::s}}&i§'----:<;%avcf? be gafiiyf 3,? L" ".f;:;.;::>ssr;ab:a mg:
im;§;{5s.sj:%'::é;:7g _f:;zj".¢"2,_:i$>f;:;*z.._,a;:,{;'72f%%2 may exfena' SQ géwa §9e*5;§k,fs _';/24933557 may exierza? $9 g"§:3é .!§§<f2 méfz 3955}; gag if 52%?
;:g:3;?z"r§é2;3;é:;'<:%rz" siév féfifffifififi gfzfer {:az§vf<:f,:"$:?,. 3; fagrifia/:..--i¥:?§ wfiécfi may exéesm' 39 g"ar§@ A §f'§:>;:§3;§:;?', ::.;g§§§gj ;?'E:>r 65%;? g:§§y $5: ;»:.=*§3§s;,:?2 5%? V ;::ss:;a;fr§;m2;::;:;; 55* 35: £'§f??f5f?é§€§': ' '§§5*;"a:.?2f§g:f§§ 5&3? §%'??€§"é3 ::'@:?:r§v§;?:"§§z? $5!' §}"s.;;i iaf 551% ;;??£}%x'?S°:'0s'§§ §f {I.'?.2§§§§:* 3%,? :3?" am; {wig "';!_¥:§§"e éfigrégafiaz" :35" §,i;"§§€§" §§C§'§é.:*f"3 8.13? fags "§"§$a;§5s§" 5;; gr; §£"£i3fi£F3£" :,:2a;;5:§:;ag: £9355": gr §as";'fi:;.§° éafifgx s';'3_§:;zfi;r, Sfég €293 5&5}! Harri 53$ §§§3 " 3% 'W7 "<*:¢ haraésiflef géwaéé be grsazmésheaf with émmégenment s§.._e§té*:er da5c:';';;i:%§:: far a term wézéih may exiené %@ iws--«j3;=é:'r§§;'.,5o;~ wéih Ema 52:' wéié': bstésg' E: ;g mafzsiréai n%gzg«A:m minimum fine is 39%: §E°§SCE'§§8§_E,E.§T°§§_€?' E":;1é<i'§::':;Aj:5é:V»3.€;'3%»§+_%:éf%& 1:31?' Efifi, whereag i§§""!d€E' §e'C%:§$E'": 932;
R3x2.§g§S§,.iV« £5: gasge G? faT%;;'a5V§';:§§:§Edé%i€:V:e:n§T".éA§*;:,§';'~§{EQ/M En'- C&§E <3? mjury E5 g;>f"e$€;"§b§;_é:;":A-».:_' E2563 €;}:%5Z'§3"§,'@?':,_AAEf';A§f*:§§'é.€, the §m';%shm@*ni for an ofV%e§.%.é:::e' prie Envaéveé in the érzgtané cageésf dsa;,!:v§;--v.a.;:g;§ at§r§b:.:ia§%@ tie the petéiééagré4E§'§f§s.,%:;3;fts:::é:; is whether iiéa §r9$ec:,:€&a;i gé"§:E_'i':sé:%*:'é:%r:" sfffersce zmaer Sagfiare Q2 3% S:-?:_::%Eam fifiaiefi 53 graseauiim far game §r ":~,?%.:fz*':%§.§s* What is me sama 0:" séméfar $;ffe,.%<:.1§é §?s; mi {Ewe €§&§§i'%§§§§%'2 <2? Eséééarz ?e::a§ €{1'sf§€ §:e:A'f'§§:;@;A:5£'~«.:;'fidar $€<:t%a3;'; 2:9 :1}? 929.5,; w'§':é€?2 :/'fiaég %sm's--:_;~ V_ "2§§g '§"§§:*§§ fiffefigeg $5? $a:2§& §§§§§§ A '-..;a¥§§§?§s§ §§e&§ mg? fig {:§§§E'§'€§ §§§§§§§@§:,« {3} ifl;z"§:t&:: gg §E{§§;'? fig §€<',"é.§$€'§?' <2? z:1%§:"e §§'"?2:3;?§:€§ 55%;: 952% :32' mg 555339 §<§}'?;',§ 5s:2:¥2'::'§§"@§ ;f§§"f;§:fs r Km») mm...
fhe 53559 (2? éwgive :"??€2':'?ff7S frsm {Em firgzf {fie Egg? 5:' 335%': $ff§;:§e5, wheifger Es? ;"5=§ge<:'zi'~.::::f's'3_._T'-~. size 33839 gzersfsa 53$?" 39:, fie may $5 ;:;'j§'5¢;g;;%::%a?__i_'«' :_. ' wiifi, and fizfea' 55 SRE was' far! gay ;':;é§*:':v;§s=[%fj'::%f" 55mm {X}? exceeding féree, -
{3} Qffer2c§s $53 ;<;:3::3§:% wfsan may are gunigfzzgééie wiziffl 'six-'*:é<= ;4::§=::':é* amaainf 02' ,9:;;2§s;;'7r?7er2€VAVz.--.ir:=:}':«3r '§"-fife sgiifiéevvseazéfcrrz of was £'rsa'ia;3 ;*3€%.;:§::>i_A(;T_éa§-23.2' .{4:§f;v;:}'~%.z55§; er gr" any S§€{j§3f Q?' £5c7§i_fa._z-;1/.*§.:'__'
-.f0r.I' fife Vggrgogeg gf ibis 5e§,':§:*;;2V, 7.9%,-:'§: V» ;::*jffl:,%f;?«::: é .';;.:«: é,fs"3{:?'€i' $955193'; gvéké';*;f.i':§:¢'1;?%%a*:'g';;i.Li%§@;;{:; was 545 of zsaq} :§}":§arfE4§;3e¥ an Qffenge 9;' She game é::':'?:?"*._§s? gzzé' .<2é'3"?':§§ir:i?$'..'L' gazrgfgbfisfiis :i:"3Q'éE'§" Seaféafi j§i3'i.$ aé' ":"§,s:¢"'§§z'::§ afacfa, ans? éfzgé gr: Gfffififié g5:3,::si§'??:§§§€ §£§§§5§3:;* gay §@:::és':3;2 9? She sage' {Eda _£§s*.£;§f"§§,Q€£?§f 9;" 59535 Egzaa, 555%; $9 dgssmefi ::sffe:'::.:"§ 3:' 5395 same kéfia' 55;: av;
g§_;ii§,:2?;fi§ £23 aammfé 31:53:: Qifeséas, %»*;§?§i? :'§£,i:Zf?? gr? éz£7§é§:%?;:§' :2; 3;'; Qfifeficg. ""
s .>,>$ A 1.9») Cm.) far same kéné Q? affanceg £3 far ag ether pr3v§§Ear::i"-sgndes vsfiiaiw %:§ Ea s:3:;g§'s% :9 fie trim in asma,3;;é:,?:'::%?€2;8 'A<%,g cencgrgzéd, ii €23 Ea be rsstéaeé iémé: §8i°;'E§§TE"'E§ 'V"??'£°%v"[3aEL'E~";é;*z.§3?_ V'

4..-_.' ./f.

aim §3€éCi§Q£"'% 33?' ggrmg fmrr: t%:??e""§;2;*:':';j@'..«a%.;§e§"a:is;:§;:s* 'E,e=';}. fi&§§§§€§}€€ @228 to whéch {he véctéféég E'2a§za g:§§_*%efed'~ %fi§é;'rE;e':s:--.. arzé we fiée. Infaat, we ve:--:g}"'~§Vnv§§{:;z{; 'sf V?:I§e:::éc' ré::, 2379; V 33% 3: 33? F135 is vi:-ye; ?'%e§..§""é§_1§':E%%':.§3_r$péé*"%:;&i:Véuse the 3ub$E§n¥:%ve charge 13 §';é;:zz*A'__':i%'"sé'<' Segiiar; 3@4€--A sf WC! Exzeij ;§i%2.grw§:§VéV,. §resc?§§e§ fer §€€E§{§§"_£ wider §&C€§Gf§ 33$ is ihree amass" Segiécsn 33"? 9% 3:§~'*C, 'wié::éc%--: égifie §am%$§':m€r2t af '@259 yéaag §r°e§€réb§§3*f{j;' i-f'j3'E'?'"v;€';'T'§$5€:?._ii:?'%.§:.i§%i" Segiiaiz Bfifimi éf WC; _ 2rS,'«.V'%.5%éz!g:e:3? fmm Qiéigr" amgie, the cézayge far QéiférzsceV':§fi{é§%'[::§&§':§§s2§ 2%; 33$ 9%? 33:?' $3 siméiaa is 3%

-- {Z?i&§'§:% $3: €€§%"'e:*;:::§ ursfler Séfiéififi %E 9? $28 éK§€'§@?i8S £152, ~a§*:;':§a;:: iéég ?§&$§§ as 32% game a§§§gai§{3r2 gf §'§€g§§§&§"§{f€& é >, aéa« <.\\ §§§§§ : 3 2 36 €~_"{§'?f§@§"§S are urgeé and E:§'§fl§A&§G?@§ {mg aiétéor: -5:; fiéfia 9 V .

aifavggd in-ierms Q?' the Qrée: gaggeé §'=é'{,*x§LT:Qs§f2i'I?Q§ and §s"a£&€§En§g in QC §¥§§.;'?;§;:i'§®:i"}:*;'?.VV:§:9}%*% a?f&m:e puraégééaéig gage: Saaiiagrz: '35%'?¥;'~°?a §§>z;'f.', are quagigeéx . /-\%' " '1 I .;3A¥§:&;?&A.R;a:H§M} ~,13um@§ mi' ..

3 E?

ficcafmngfiy, Cs"¥,?,:'\§0.9143?;'2€%G§ is dé having begging érzfruciwzgg, cg?"

§§iCr§§Cf"~._jGf as $.2~ 4'»\ {@3§ V§3~