Karnataka High Court
Raju Laxman Pachapure vs The State Of Karnataka on 17 March, 2009
Equivalent citations: 2009 CRI. L. J. 3081, 2009 (4) AIR KANT HCR 184, (2009) 3 KCCR 101, 2009 FAJ 448, (2009) 2 EFR 684, (2009) 4 KANT LJ 470, (2009) 4 CRIMES 763
Author: V.G.Sabhahit
Bench: V.G.Sabhahit
3 T§§jE:{1£}§Wx;1.§$SE{§NE?;.R 140:") :1} A§'~§{"} <_::v_:_L E%U§3;P.1,.Y Ei)§%3.§3A§%'F?\;E¥-ENT mg:-<2; BUELE)i.?€{}, 51*}; m,,a{>¥e, <:z.rm~:::~e<3H_Azvs ROAD azzsgzgg <:_mM)R:.;<:A Hi')'f'E1L _ E%.é\N€3AL{)RE2 2, T 4 'E'%~EE3 SE3C':E%E?I"E',¥x§%Y V ~ ~ ?'ezEEN§§:":Z'TRY aw m<?>r_> m~::3Tc7:<I§$z.:1, E§iz.'\'§,_E_)E-)§JV§£::;:'.i'# MS, BEEELDENQ BANG-51,0913 2 U! 'm2>.: =:>E:Pzms' <:(3MM.§%$s_§a:m::R " » _ MYSGRE BANK §zaA:>_> %3Z£H§?~3{}{iE"f'Y <:z""«;";_L,<:§c'::a.;r;}"':"v::'__ ., £3aNG;s.mRf:::'1._ ' £3 ;:s;>;A§e::s;;§z€A ?::s;_:):T:'3%:*:E§::.«=,:S ::'m .
€>wN§:':"2 E2;a§3_§i{L§;§, 4 ':3gj'?%?I§{'«€3E--£Aé*§'i3 mi;3.%:s2J§xa2';:a:;;:;*2:,___ "
E~§If}?'E. NE} Aifli; _4":s;;';«e{;;xs*;ANm;2A v5.m,.A§3E:
H€>..SU~.?' Rf3E';ET}~, '~ _ " ' -
BAE'=§'~{}ALGE~?--':£§ 5g«% _ ' ' §";;R,E;€f§*;3R*9;r;E:V«_ei}.:e::\:mat, (3%-4' HE}Ai,T§1E S£:sw:{::~:$ 33H' gFe'{>€;_{>;' 3§«:Cr§*;::?;:a P%iR.MAF'~$ E3§{;5'xV,&%'é§ EYEZLHI. ..... REZS§3{7?€E,")F%ZFéTE§
-¢ v?7§Vi}';<§_;'§?:31:: ;i'1-§<;':;&3r, fiiirfi f<:::' E;3'".§, Sr: K;?~E.PutB:g0W':§a £03" R-=2 --~ ::-ai?r§sé:>.é3_.€', :.'E3:f'(f;"-«.K.€'}'.~i%é3gha:va3i1, Sr.€30u2';3€:i for Sri G.§{.V.M11rE}i1§ 2:a{i P.¥;..Ui::3e$3fz fé§;fR,5'--6; Sr': Azvinzé Eiizinazg 35:; ii)? Rf?) TE1is;" vs;?3;*1'i{ p€:'f.i'§;E.£;}11. 11$ ffl€{§ m."3.i;i'1%%r §s3*i.:?<;71€s 22$ 5:, 2'2? {sf firm": '<31;-;.::a:=iai:it11":#;o%1 (sf inéia pxayitlg to ciirect. R-- 3. {(3 R6"? to (:€;.1':&i:i€:r {he "3f§r}_;:r*:?:$€:1¥:a'*i.i<>:1 dt. }1.§.Qf§ Viflff A11:zmX--E efi;i:<fe<t:t,ing Ra': its R-3 is "aaiizs acificxz agaizzsi. R-6 industry.
'_ ' '<%£:E=£.'?€;.:*e{§ {E16 f"<311.c>is:.i.z::g:» This writ §>t:i:i'i.i::;s;: s::<;«:1::§.ng up far Gttifim cm fizitz flay; tbs: €T7?<m;"i: "€f§E§§..}€).i'lE{'iti§}§ *w:e1$ §:1€§{.i.if(.§ "Ira: <T.§»::iE»;:wz an' fits: $.§1'§i'1€3 $23.5;".E:=.;1.m_{fE~».i1:: féiz-*..'faw.._ Izxaimiéaiz-a :1af'2.:m§§§«; <.:§::;:IT§<}'§.:1s;i§ Fm "»»'i<f.'T'J~; €'2i.§V»§»§":%?"S'3:33?EZ§i3'§i9§§§€.}Ix'E§"§V:§i§_3€%ii'5{I <.33'é j bfiizaif {>5 Eemzlfiri ce::=s.1:r.1$&:§; £31' {:33 :'€s';J<:::<§:§:i;§¥ £3. '7,€"'h€~:::"i":2,=:..E'§'é:t*§' i;§:.:.€5 C':'.;"§e:§ {Ti§';t%:.::i:§1§:~..;s31.:.§ ?*:i§;3§i:.'_ :'§;3:3.€£3f§:5§'§~:,~ ..5':'§:'}.§*:S§}Ti£i.€'i§_E"i :"e:'::.:«'s{i:, §73é3*£'3g§i§(3}"(ii, s1.:E%m'i.f'§£:i:i .Efjf?5§'}i'§§'§' €1§§'i§§§§'-.2554'. §;§.,2G(.':%8 v«,=='}:ia::'§"; I'{f':§~'i§iitE§ as }3f'.'§'f"E,1E}i'i€?Z'2- E} {}E,'§i',§<§',i£'*1-§5::i§'§'1}}§}f%-:-'j .' V. §?_1*c3§>1i££:i;«2;}2 Peed L:e»::§?>}t% §§<::::iai:;"3.f.i<}1'iE » _ "= 'LA¥?1*é:=r::-i'a':i31 VRME} {313T.kh8, ' -- V ' ' _H_P§§:ci (>11 (}%f"3;2{3G8, 8213,1011 ?'§{3uA Best Before; 'i?Ji*i}1i_':1 six Months {mm the aims cf E'k.:§..
Mfii hjg: Eéhazfiiwal E11<ji:as:f;é<:rs;
L'i'e:E.3 Sziic-is i'*~i'0,2, 3 55- 4, S3Tinga$a_x1£§:'*a tz.i.Eiagc:, §--Imszza' Rozéid, E:'>'a.ugai(;»:'€--€i8.
3} ' {}%.é§.1é:':12§. Szzazgsiét: §'_mprir::£:ar;§z F'c)::>{i ':.9'EI::§§i.i:: ,Ef}£;,*<3?i&21'2e2.t'it:;:11; Prc:mi1m1 REED; €fZ§~*e:tE::_':.":2;1, " " ' Pkd cm: IGXQS, Batch. Naffi, Best I+3ef<::1'e-: wifliilz 6 maxzfhs Fmm ms: daft: G2" gaasrking.
Mfr} B32' Dhaiixvai iizdtzstiées ;:Xi"(§g, 331:5 fig. 2,3 Sz. 3%, S'i£1gaSaB(f§I'8 villager, H<3sm'* f~?<:»a§L Ba.:r:4ga}ore~68.
iiiamataka} Emiia.
}%i:"'{.a:i rm"? 5:.a;r,:1_g.:Ee,: Seaifipigtd $£€1"iI1I§3iif '3'E2{:' Rtizsuééi :31" figs: 5;;-£§33.3:3E<:i BS0 E}? fir, :--sr€t as fbligaws: {E31*<3&:.i{§;t<i fu:"'iE':{:%:' t2.3.a.€ (:':a§<*:ém'2:, p{}I£:1f}§§~E-i"{ET£1'fi (f§T""S(}fZ'§§3:ii;i;:._ '?3:%:";"(3<'*},*a:1i:"I:? 1.3333? be Lzzsgfiii 24:4. cwjgsgiai :1i1::r:.':.%._,i:1i.ié':,':*:~';_. é;s::}§{:é» 3:':ti~<xa.§§.§:':g Hgfifif in c'<;137:.}:§:3<>:'s Séigfv.§('j!€?§.E;7§ff{}H;2;§E§§i.,f€iZi!€'i"§I§§;{i},'§} fE;:=:"'£Vi§%<=::§ 332% in t.;::a1'3i.§t§z not z3.>:'{';'fAt:<%<Ti §:;gj;§..iC);:'ig '§r;g's;:a:.g§yt, .' <31" in e::<:2§.:::'c;§[:2a§i<::':'; if.§i;'§}'i'€fS$€:§{.} e:.:'~:; f§7.EfE(§'(_T:g'Eei_1.li£§{fi " = .3534 §:Z.:s.<:::i*<%is;§.::z.g ;:><3WeI° (*<3:;.f§¥;:-':ft=.d . u1.;{%€%1'~«Stas::é_i;;in 22:33:, $319 {?<:I1.i.§a1 {E-mr:t;':z:11£:.i':% 3:3}; ;mi)<§:3¢{:i'_i,11tiéiiizazi '.i?§.{'}'}'.:2'{}{}é ;)a5:$€::;£ t.Ei1{:
2'?:3.§i<)22e.'?ing <}2:d€:I':~ _ "
it x3:{c> ' u§iE;§?;;€§ 2:1:i.§1%g¥:§; %.'!.faa':.
?%fiagf§1i:5;¥.14::":3:,.'{T'.::§,§9}§:§:.1:a%fafi'.'-53$3};;EVi{f!:§}<iiTzg ag'€.:2'i., is u${:::i ii': Qii'?-}ii%--'/fig §2':~£.?;§§;:,§'Li§'f':'€iI'3§ii'%:;?'I.._»§{}" of ?3}3'2'~'s Ffiéixitésa, IQ?:"E';:"'>Z E? :_?:*s.:;15}fis-.'§.:f::z.:;;%iVfE3€%' «a%?.._f::~;_:_12'=r:<:3. $131. v:r}'.:c1'c: f.f'z}€i.3" 23 E,§('?€I'.3(fii ':';:«'1:'~3'?."'{'3€7af;'".'*.'i}. >ii{;._ {3'§z'ék:a or s,3Z_:'.:i1i§aI' §:}"m{"§ur.:'.§" as ;Jz"<:3§'2§*i:;i2%;1:j§-;;:;"<'){§::A{.:.;; Sizzzaii :':<:;«=l' {?€ZB§'i"i£1iEi£ ¥'s!iag.§.:.s:::§ai1z:;.3 > {,.'§:$rfi;1(§sE,!Yi&fi"E"f. ~ V V' 3-,}'éc.i'i:§E:;.§; in the. maE.:{~:s' H133; pieazwe be [é3';éi.11'§'::;g€.::.d"'33:: "ibis }Tf}37::*<-":::r"i:<:;s'z[%.f£""¢ 3 1-3. 13e'§2e§1"ce1":8i:1 {gueries wmsa raisééii by 6*?' £'€S§30E1d€11{. by ES "§i%;§pi§e:T:.a§:éa:::§i"<1aE:r:'d (}?K01:.2Q(}'E' aécizvssseci :0 '?'-h res;:+0:':{3i€:2'€ hfirfiiisa _w.i%_"£.: '1*::'.ft*:r%::1£:_%€ {<3 tiszage of ixxqyugraetzii antic::a.k.1?13g ?::ig€*.I}'I' Izameiy .._ "magn€sium Car%3021at€, the 'T.E"33 r5$}3t:>nz:i€:2's. 1111 their gjrecesziiizgs 3 " é'iate.*.€§ 22.03.2097 had "r'€p£iE{3 sag E3.c:::m':1n<:ie:';~ 1 1,1 it is reievanf to note £112: reply by 73' :"€sp{;:1de11t___T1:€: the 6133 I"€S§}()Z'ld€3'}"i. 'W}i}€1'{t'fi§"} in its }I3}£'(}{'.{_'i€'diI}gS {iat,::::i 22,O3.20{31?_ 'w:.f€:;m'€c} in 2z?c){;s'v:::, 11a311<é1§»' that :;:1ag:1$s§nn1 c:a:'b<3.z1af.{:: is;"""pEi§'mié'%r:;c1 aas:
aI;ti:;"::»3&<ing agexzit £11 some ariiiifkis t.3,m*i.a1' Rule fE'2§'2, fi?jazie$;" E1355'-., to 153:: Itad with I'f§f€.F~':'iI}C€ to the f:§ii1'%:%i?'i'2i<}Ii<-; is:;s:..1,cE§._ 'mg?' "C;e§3t1:--:;i G0v€m"2:x1£:3:;': 1:15,-" pi'<>«:_.*€<e:.ii3}gs €i.3.f.c:ci 1'€§__,{??V._2G{)€3 §1}A':'{C.I'{T€Si'£3.% ' .pQ*s_.xgcI' ":1! 3.224': of PFA Acgrt, *.ax?}i:£::V€~.._f tL's~:c Cé;:7e.i'rz1':1 {}{'§$¥:§f'i:::n'%n%. Has:
spéroztificailfg <:ia:if;i<=_:§E of PEA R1e;3:::3} if shmzlii he .a:;s:s.£~;~§:§%;:1::§;;;.at. €t':'%.iVfi¥'. has '£36611 isgzxed $9 Gutk'21 £21' «. pro<.i':1<ét., ii: 52.21331 mo'?
<:<:s:1't;a1T§§: _ I'€é&Si'3.1'} w{;:«:11(3 be €?Vf3}-3 as pm I%':;a}<::r 6&2 ";E«231€'ic:siki;1g agtnt. :i;}*:ai3 'ma usttti in §<?;e:3{i €:'X§fiEfipi. s,s.2'}z1r:;'€: vtiis anfitrakixzg agaxzt. is; s§;e:{r:ifi<ta.iiy p{%;rz:k:;.i§ffT€<3 'V V'%:§:As€?:'si:v§i__1§i::3t;1?.A F§'§1c:%"""p':"¥:)x2iSit:;=:*:. }:)€1'I}3i$.S 'i.1Sag{:': 0.? Magfitsizim {3é1;r1r3?§:*1é;§:%._z3i:: éz3j;1£5§«::rz§}«:i1;r;.g again; 1:33:31}: in ta-ibis: $a}:, mziwzz }}i3W{§€f, garfigr: §20w<%$1', ft1iéf p<3u:*<ier aggld sosfsgz Ijfjwiifii', 331:1 _r1<3i' in 312:2}? other '1§?;;£3»:E ar'Eiaj7Eé:~3. zmgi tirsfi 32221113 is zaiéac} r€:si:ri£:iE:3c§ nut €:x'cr$e{}ir,:g 29:53. _ '\ :'€:5;p{3I1{'E€:1'1'f s:iri::'€}_§=* in E*£(t{'f()I'£'}.{?iE}{?f3 wifi: 33%: :':i*§é¥::1*V ..1%,VE:'t.: ' "1<:%i_i;'t'véé1L'rg_i. Siaizite, Wzif EF'r:fi€.§<3n is €)Z'C§.€}"£'i£§ --;*3§fT{?€3§'i§iE3 .,-w:» 15 "
" Tustice Sell"
'judge S.:1E}/' Eiliiéfx: 'V