Karnataka High Court
M/S. Balaji Sales Syndicate vs State Of Karnataka on 26 November, 2010
Equivalent citations: 2012 (1) AIR KAR R 359, 2011 (4) KCCR SN 380 (KAR)
Bench: Manjula Chellur, Aravind Kumar
E
g _:
E
§}.\§' '"§."'E'"§E§ E*§§Gfr"§ {?{f}{fE€'§' E}? i§z?aE{NA'§';;%§<;A 17:3' E§A?'»§{§;'3:.,Z.,,{}§~"€E%Z
E'3z'%'§"'E%Z§Z} "E'}':§.IS "E'E*£§Z 263" 3}??? CE?' §ij's£"€>"*é;"§fII'v'E£{§E%Z§¥{ 201:3
§5"E{E§Si%3I'~E"§'
'E'E'"§§i E:--§{}'f*é'E3§;E 'MRS. JUSHCES M.Ai\J&LJLA {Ii"i§%ZL_.§;{.
AN E}
m:':: E~i&\E"}':3.LEE MR. wsflazé: z§RAEf§N.Ii} §i':;2..§~.«zL%-§R_ '
S''I.'j¥Z.P.N<>.e':i{:§O0Q ; "
B E'E7"WEECE\§ :
M/S, Eiaiaji Sales Syridicaie,
N0. 18, NT. Yarci I,ayQ_.:Ifi[,
Ex/Eyssare road? BaI1ga}£s1r_§'~.,
Rapmaented by ' '
Ramesh K1,1ma.r Baggy, vv
.Parmer
{By Sré '
Al\z'D: --_ V . _
St,at€: Qf'£{;1:t":":afaw"é:2:;--..'< .
Rep:"esent<e%d_Vby _ _
Tiie C<3mn1_issi~<2:1e':* of '
n '_ Ca>:;*§fiz1é::j{:i.2:1 "£"'a1:>§€:&a.. ..... .. n
._ V"'=Ja:i%ij}Ia"'§"h¢1"ig€: KE1§j,5'&1§Ei
V' 'é;";V2::'1§§hi:::I§;;;;>;';d '
'ia'§a;:;g,f;:zs:;:i§s;55{;.@e9.
8§;§..2:€:i1a1, G<:'e;i.. A{§'%',}
..wP<2*i§fc§<>11er
H, E?;x3s3;3£}:1da%31fi,
§TE{P is fifieeii zmgfiéii" $<;%<i%'é:2'<i:n ?;3{ E} (E2? E8'? §{':§I,
'§'§:iS ;'E§'E'RP <7<:;nzi§':;._>; am E_E:.>:'
' Aravégzfi Kumm: af ?'%°'§g:.<.§-5: ':3":{'? i'"{':}§{_3w§:'}g: ~
V' "..:%'w:»:,§;-;za'§.E:':f;.«§;fz '$19 N§'u{:Eg:"§1e:":%. ami 0:"{i:=:r iizmiéi 2§.4g.2GG8
_ 'g;':':':"ss=:*«:.:;3,A'ci in SETA Ni; 58?f2{}{}3 :33': thé,-? {fie 05 Eiiziés: E<Zz%f§"L
' i'3;;:.z:".:§;aE<:sre% €,§i;'%«fl"§E$Sii'1§;§ 'éévsr zgppfizizfi,
E*"§e;:;ri:':;;§; §h§:'~:~; {Ea}-2
M'
\M
QEAEE
'§"'?:<::= ;.1:%;se;«::§&;:'%:,w: ix in rs.?'2"£s?si<;>z'1 :;a:v+«s'a.§<>3'1i:':§;§ the {"'{}E'I'é."%:."i¥I'2{??:éFé
xi)? ihzié c)r<i<:~£° 92:5;-3.<.~::s(.i E3}; my E{;:='::mg.2§.;':E<:2;-2 :"§;:>pz:?E122éa=Vf£";i§§i}:;I'1z'2§
d2":1€<E 2914,2008 fig: S'E";'i i\F<:). 5€%?';':Z€){}3 WE':<%:"s;§:§é*1€§'{%:f' _
filé-ad ':3; 31¢? <;ue..-;'%_.i01m':;,__-§ 1E'1c (";:'{'5..*:%é:r, .Je")ivm_.'«..
C<5r"r1m:'s5E0nt?r {>5 (ffc;:'11m<:%:"<:§2=1.E Tex:-«;i<;;~s-s {A;}';.3':;:2.i§.§:;§" §fT'£'£ry 'E3':-tqisswtiz.'
EH, B;-1:1ga§<>:'6 zizzimi EEC}. E 2.2302 <.:-u'1'§'s:( isbe 2¢:.TE':'7:? :u::::'¥{7{.mifzi u{%:::->_ *.
2'2§3{3@;-41.1 {)f the <"z-=':n'3(* 'iQ' f:3='..Vj V€'ii>:.~;z'122?sss:<§s':'~?d."'T -
2: This Cm.:r§" bjgfléirtcier.' dag::-§€.i~.f§é_,3..2GO9 I'1ases e1ci:m'.2.£::c.i
11.}:-é :;':b{)V€ z'ev:'s;i<)I'.1 fez' ai<.>1j1S{§%£ic:"i§::,:; :.i"r'é~.gjpEiéja::E"::g {§i§@S§§€"'H'1§§ of
52} ij:2'ti;.":»«:_Vafi'2s-;§ ':"a2£%' . 212121 {_'iE"{'fi.E]'1}.Sf£1i"i{?€S 5)!' the
a::1s4;é"E.1 és=f "§"j§{35E5iE§'}1€? 'irfistzrmi r°:' g;}2E' in
E1i§E{§_i §ig 'i,=':.af: the 3>:'§'iEi«:}:'2€3.:° pm€§u(:§s~:
_":;._m'1<;%E3s aasghfiaesix-rs: s;:;>s:s:::,. {E€)§.%0E} :r<;aps:s:>.
g:éi};<?§'€?3§z'1f_,__§ :"<'3§§s. b'{2.1'»«;.» ;:}§n:':~::._ EP'3'»e"E ;}1'n.<.~;«. faii
' ~ --i,::":da::=:3" ;~,;;'<;:§2.c.,é*2'iE e1'1E;';.' 3143.. 1.1335162" S:=;*<'£.:?c";;"':
{E3 {:25 £12': ;F{S'E' A<;rE'.. EEE5?' :a><2:'z}.§s:: £8%
C}?
;.1::{:'; msi zz::{'3;«.*z° bx": E32?:z":_ {..;§'
E:§€.::'"<};:{:E E%~3<%E":c?<i:.1§<;% ms i;.:§§{..}§'i1:§,.g;: :{;':z.2i_{?:°§::§:4:
1'; /
2'=:§';{§ « [-
%;2:x;':?:::§.a:-% ;:é a;
{é
h.eg;,d§n§§ -- Ta.§§{.>:"é1:":g._{ I'\fi.2221@::i;41.Es§; E2': :'=':;u;>§r;(:;:'E {if his'; 5:s;.zE3:21:'s&;s"~,:i<3z':,
E36 2'é':vE:*¢:':.é:-is z.1p<';;'1 'aha'. §'<'§§§{:>%*'i:'1;;' gag; :.i;;;j:1'1:?I'1E:$:
E} 'SEE N'§SS.{-'JRE ii.-E:3€T§'%{}I2§ ECS m'v'"S~
CGM1\§ISSiQE;'~£ E3143; 0?? C §%3€"¥'?E-£2114 EEIXC ESE}
MUMBA3; E28(}4{E6%~%} §%Z.§._'.EX 3}
MAE--fiE'sEi3Rs% E:T:I'é{}-.£'.NE£EREE\E{§- ;»g\sz:,"'-<1:-:é:§;f§é:'s"::i§igL "
PRQIl)UC'E'S }'.,'E"E}, ~»v:=s-- €f$*€&'C31'\f ':':§§'£i:é--£1;»: §'Vf§9§.%;%?>€:.} V
SCC 272?}
iii}
3 37$
W STATE: QF' E<AI:1x§.z5{'::;za;§;:; gzzaésgsg
6. 155632;' c0'm.r';aL "j'_E.c}§;"11€:ci ,A_dC§Efi'.i0I1a§
Governmemi 'E-.::_i\;<}s§s.E.<: ._é1p'T;3$2a'r'EEi:g' fer {I16
regpanki<3r:_%:,fa1s§s£=s--s;_e't<.fw'u:,1}t§...gmgépeii {he order pasfieci by fine
a:'Lzf2%1(;rE*i.i.é:s $12153 {f;m1'E:-:h.:i .§:%.1;_zié..V whfie E:':€:ez'p;"€éi'1'1g; a 611:3? in 2':
'éax£.:1g *s:1;21€:ui.€:$» 3;'; is £19 "be magi vgém .refer:;%n<:@ is me é:~m.:°3'é3i-3
"s:§,§€3{i'i§%Z<:$§§E;£ Vgxsjzgrvicierci for in §,E".2€'3 €E'1'E,Ej,f i§,s3e§§" 2-ma a>.xg3z--mded
A*-:rn<:2'w1§T:;;;g§"£;§ia>:i?i-€i~*' mfi E36: §g:§ve.:':. s_[z:":§::>:«s:::=: the 2';:";é.£:e:1iéaz1 {>£' am:
§Q€?§§§-§§E;¥;'§.§§.1"E;'._v§;'%§' $3 §e:3::.§2<:% in LE1;-1. ezééry §{'$e.1.E.'. She w€;s:.:1é $ubz"s:t:3'.i
"*'%_I§:1.ai: §E;%r1"i.:.°}l* E ask is; {s:>~:§';m,:e=,;i.§x--'6 Sifiii ii. s:':2.n'1n<>'{ bi"? E"::%Ed is 1"§1£3.:--'§.3'i
" 21):" .?_<'2;A.--:.m_;:3<3'§"t: §:':¥;.<> 2': Eihs <2I..§':<€-.:' 2m:,€'.e:'i::.};s, wE'::<>:%*2; é.}":s:: £'.§E§${"?:E~§S€€;".
u H:'2_§%:%F itizléms {£2 E38 E}m:3Lzg;f%:i, wi'£:§":i:: §'}2<:% sswe.=s;:s :1}? E:21iE:}§i:':g
:1':2;:E.é::z"§;'z§5%. She': wazzézi s§'z:b::1i.§ §E'3:;»;.i'. '92,:-°<>:*{:i 'nameif in be
E'é?£;§{§ 22.55 :'%:é<;E':.2-3s:.:;%~;i';**a,?s gjzzzai :>:":<%&* s;L.:<:t§%': a%:«<E';z'::::%'a:§,i'a?é;¥ EE"§'§.{'EE"§j}Z'if§..E:'i§'§{}E'E
§>g/
<:;R1«:A"I_' I?2AS"FE3REJ_ .E'E'J§§?E§}{"-E1}§%1¥fA'§;E:A 'i.,;:;év;:i§'*;:%::'3 ~ " L
Es; s:*>;i,e:}<it?{§ in EEK? a"::'1£'ry 3;}: Cgéiiff-§57f'.§{}§}.§ ii £3 imiy zfzaé §£'a=::1':s %:E1::'£.
§};z.v:: Ewen z3:'2:%:'1'é1?e::b:'1:':*e:i in E.§':€% §'?§"£.EZ°}«-" '2's»"§}§{"?§i aiane w{.mEs:¥. be
::;'22aé,§iEi€<E £231.' §'.}{Ti§§§§__§ b§"'{}'{.'i;5,§h€. w§.§%1%:": sa1.:z::h z:2:é*{,:jv zmeti i§§E':::zié. we
zany {>'i:I?1e I.' m21i'm*i:;-flss whicth §1:*a';-fa? E}¢:ae;'; ::€:1'1s<éi<:L1sE§*"::a:?t§£~E.{_,é;s§§;_b§~.
{he £4€g,§iss§z1§,L,:rc; ii. xmzfid €211? 1,1:'3.d<::2" 'E;h.::% ;:'r;%s*s:T{?_1T;;§;£*?§; ;:.s:':5{i
as Sififh A5a:4sess§::g Qi'i"ic?«;=%;" as wraéi 3:15»; ihfi"}§§T}}§Effi1§i'§I€:'§xi.£;§§3§)'1;§§;;i7§j5§
are ;:.2ss%_,§£§€d in 1*€=j&{:':4;£11g ihe £rQ§'1i:<3;1ié;>h'20?' i%1Tc%v--"--é15¥S'€S$€€%. E*::': é
sLzj;::;::m"i. of Exes' s:ubm%ssi{>:T1, S§":.r: ';'::~};.iess i:.:;>€>":2-V-1£.E7é';4§'(>EE<)w.i.ng
jzzfigizieixiis:
£3 SHiRA '%:~I§:*§12.1;Ii-«."_';$:ifs;:1::Ds $oMPA;NY
L_1:\I.szt::ED Mimi }sZifrA.'r1»':7 f§:*a;«ff_' Iij;ARNAfrAKA 11999
.2' . . ' . ' S M E
3,13 S';'%}I§%«V.0§ iggzrr AI{.AA§NB 9 % {iii
1 -- '200£:i:K,A;'{_. :=5g}~--.. -
"F. '§;?§2éA.z§_r1.g"heé1:*L'3_E:E"3;:;§ §<3a.:'11ed 21d1=%0c:21ie§; E£§}§)i',EiI§'§3'}§§ 50;'
the pa';"E:fes$ ii,'-»wV$::'§{§ Eye G? '£3e::<«3i"i{ 120 e:=a?L;'21<é::. €339 yeiétvaulé,
.'"~.{3IE{E'7'§a7' '+.7'Q%'.E%{?§'E' E3215; ijéééjéié' §fJ;"t=.$$e<:i i'n£.<} S-i€E"'V§C€3 $33: i,E";s: Seamed
_¢':'::1*vf§fh-«'T=_Z}'.V*{3'<3§'§v€"'J;Z¥'V Vgzgfigzgiaigfézzg 593° E:§'n':~ §.§a-'g:"é.iess aise {ha-, :°9sédu.ar3;
é:~§";.*£.3.j},' E.3E"§{_i€;?2""3;?;-"'E"'1§(?:3§ '$.26 :'<:?v€::m% ('.'E£:"LiEE1S :5 crigziyge the
V._EE:>:' 'E;}t%i:"':;g;€;,;1Xzé{§ 'xx-"$2.4, S3€:{:"L§'<m ESE}? 2211:} S<:ir1s3c§.':.2E<3 H Eff'? §:';nf::§3;*w E --
'.:' =<
. -1__. '
_.r»~
in*£4€3:'p:°é;*»'£,e:Eiém 2:)? %,2:x.é:':§§ 55%.:-1E.'2.':'{.€s:e; emd the 'zé-fix: 1.221% z*§:.s;%21z3é1':§§ En.
w.%";§<:%z ii. 22.315; EX} be §°C*2i€§ Ems be-:e::;=;r.': <%3<p'§'.;-§_Em":{§ E3}? é.E":e:2ir
i,<:>:°dishi.ps;s gmgé :'-.:2;:3'm"; r<;i~2:d.:a; gas; r;.m.€i€¢r:
"Q, Efigfizt 21} (me: wifl
<ieterm2;'ra21i:ive <31' 22.. (1.{f2;i1'{[3"_{)¥'€fig}?V ":é:r;;z"".:1;v::«:a7zf;';;;
iivzmz .21 iaxérig sT~;t{:{_1€:ut-e:a ? 7 E;q
a::«:mm1<m -E-363115-3{=3_ is St.;r:11*1g;-je%:*7. . A vé1:ér:§
i:1<:e:::mpai:ib1_e pa1.ri:2:§é:f. {:5} £219. §z's€<_">":11eE1-.«é;ia§:
Act"; it 30?: cQ:1:?:6=:A"1'*r:r:.<:¥:;i..?éf.sseIf"w_:i:h.~Ehsz
pr_§.:1<:.ipk:s "sf :1fiQ1'a:ij__j;€:y" j;§fi7}i(?S. it is
b 1}'c:5:ri'3«*° §i:11;it.ed
COI1C €I'J."1€;'d v3%;ri%:h' ._ 'zheffi
qt;c:<¥_;i§éns ==__::1s; H5 iarhéti1€1f...i:§1e amount
br?_;«z.';§;h%'._'i{)'~.§;a;x:"~~£:_{§:f:§§'é:ii;::'il<:%:~§ the income
€33 {E12521 ;2__1sSc;:$:;:?.;<;:€3. " Eta. ..i.e3V_ c§q1121§1y Settled iaw
.i;}:éf.:é:; ..if"<.%t}"<i%:"'~Ea.ngi.1agfes E3 plain and;
'-:_11121:1:3bi§»;:.,::§L:_s§'"-$311916 can only 100%; fairly
If
:"2;t: §'}'}.€ "§--.E1I;1'§5Ei2i§gf3 used and i:":%:.<:r1;)rs:fé, it ':50
§,?;fiv<%'A"::fi7€;3.<?'i'.vt<> iihe 1eg__»ji$Eaf;iv6 a:1Emat::;0r:,
.3§?€Y%rtheiess tax laws have ta he
R"~._ ifi;ei'*preted reasazmbiy araé is:
."'§;.:::1sonar:ce with justice aéoptixzg
mzrgosive aygroaeh. The ssniaxzzai
meaning has ta he asceriaiiiefi and
give}; effest ta' A §;§i'{)"€§&%i(}'I"s far
{%€:£i'm':"{é{3r"2g <3:;x:€:§1;3fE{31': Gr .I°E%§§€3f 5;§32::2':§Ed
be (T:€}E§E.§'§§"£..§{"i{'§ 1"¢2:;.§s{}§§aE::E}: zzanzi ESE": f&i.'J€}'l§E"
{>5 *::§t':a*: 'E'.%":::% ::>E3§€::z:€, %><:§2'1;§ '1:h:3;':.
%/
:1.a::s E': " V
in {i',€}§§'"£§}?.,i'EIE-{.11REE': Gf i.§'2:=: Eéiiif. §n<7.~:T>:"°m;: 'gihéz
$i.:-:mi.€r: §:>r<:v§d;c5s d€?{§E.§{E{li{}§'}E%%,.
ex«:émpiii<.m:a; <32" d€§>ra2{:2'ai:i<3:'1 (3%? the': ve3.I:;;:%'
{sf éghe £:21piE';a§ 2-iss§>:%;.s .f§'<'3m
2?zr1e:':{>n1€: "E"§"1e.:"&éf{i>1'€, ?3uiE£ii:'1ggs;»; :"
h::1i'V€ 233$", "been spc><%ifi<:a.13y ;c§~c--fi.§ii:§:{i: «
}§§.'}(T:§L:(i€: rcagid in the b%}A;'I?;,'E 5:§."{"_:i}'V€§4'.A
mi;Er1.<2§€§,;21E:s:*:3'1ss¢." A' _ ' A. ». . V '
{ Emph assis ¥Sz:;3§jT§. _§3}_: 2
9» K€f{'3§_}i.I1§;_--§ ::h@::' _;m::.c:';'s;;;%';g-- é*L'Z1;.:i£i3{:§'T;;1'*é.€§{3'3 by {heir
Lordships in the abave é:1<:9V{732_é:a'i(uQ'1';_; '$1313 p:'es;(::1i; 88.86
are bei:1,_<.;; exa1'r1i::ed..._
'me: re&sidu21r7y'5.£;_:1L:fy5.Vi:1--.1'1'r:~e:j ir;st.21r1t Case are "$56311" adhesive,
Ceaiiorl :'c';E}V.ss;' s,v;:{igii;3g,j,fv:"{§i'i-sgfliziieisss pins zamd RM. Pms~:", £1 £55
£326 {*€s;1E,s:e:r1'€'§€;:1V <3£7.7'§*v'h'."- Sizrya K2-£1211': {hat {E1680 iiems-3 21:5-=.
v,.E..1'2s;::::<§§);'t:*3z€::V. 1.6 Z+Z:1€;;"y "E"?}4'iv <3? Pa:rIi--E' sf Szthéduée E1 5}? the AC?
W
__nV;:::j:é§3rv'rag; ~"Fe::Z§{}';f'in§g; §\zE2-1E:::3:"i2'~:.Ess. Undé-3:" €3:I'iT1§'}--' EQ "'aiE<>:'§.n.§
Ma€'_.€=:°ia§$ §§2%;=s,---f.{i[E>ce:z2 C§ei"':fIiE"E£',{§ ass %;=x£r22<:t§,s;«:{i §:{2%2'=:3§m a.§:)€}V«:?.
E " En. 2-*.i<:w sf}? §1.§'1.é;', wmfl '.z:21::'3<flf<;' %:21v§s'1g_r; E3:;*:e§: zzgséééi in
€_§:::*:._ $€i§{§ @r";1:°§; ii. E1225; %_:»:-':6-1': }3§"€:':§;=SS{*3€§ info E§€E3§"§-'éiffff §T}}i" $18
.V its e:"::>:'::.{r;r*,a<§ 'é.§2ai': g§<3<><i:s~; :1':s:§1'§.;'<:smé{i :iE*m*e;;~*:1*::"a z1:1"<a {<3 E35:
iI'i}£§&§iE":.§€3{.§ as :*EE'a2§3i,:°;?::L:?v€3 2:-me::E imf, <:x:.I%';z:u.:ss:..iv€s' %E{=;=. %2.;:':.::2 £."i§f§§i'}
r_:<31'm:é:3<§e:{i Ehaé. in Viéfii? {if aha ix?;§i$Ez1%:z.;r'E:s; 3.§'::%;&tE§'"§E21Vi:'1;;;; z.:.fi{?E€:{§
(7%:-?:'"::atZ:z i'i4€:§:':::':-; by 2-m2<m<i§z':;T;§ Eazfi .§.'\§::7' 42/ EEEEBQ Wm: s=:=f§E-%<:i. §E'{}§'"E'1
1.4;, 199%}, ii. 1-"s.-r:)z:§d gas K: s'+;E'2<:»w ::5:1.E.'s':g §§uS§.3."2£.i'i'%f€;'7 zmszi h€E'1{?{;"i 1'1€w §_'j;;<>c>{is.=5 12«-'s:,re Em"-E_z,:.d<::<:i in 'i'.h_:=-2 a-i::?:'é.:~y' mid as-3 saL::5ff; aha a.;<ss:3€s:«».§e3:€ cizaims '§.h2.:E, iI.<?m$ in q_us3ss%;.1Z0:1 *wc3~u..EcE {an :._if15§&--2fi;§1e Emzaidirigg '§.:s1.i.Eoring,§: n1£1'&@.ri2:a.Is', ff. wouid be {>.f.'_.'.:}€cc:;jf <3xan'1£.n.e {he w<>1*<E 'namely' ass»; %1a_§§ ..%3<--:;<":2': i::5i,eé:?§§'I"«:¥ije{i b§xéhiss V scam in 'EEK? <":as@ oi' EEEALAJE {fO.?~!l?--E?U'§";E%ZEZS '»WE:«:;%4eu':g£:*g1§"*gag. §;1araw~Q2._ LEE"? (§i£§e1'€:'n'é': cf:-_:fi;}£:ii0';;'--1:§3 §'r<3:1: va2';'i:>i.é$ '§i.€§v§.§{}I3'i1}'§ffiS'. {E31116 310 be zmaiyged asrxri it was 0bs(_3r:2t¢@ e'--lS.>I3.?§d§":I'Z § "S€e::{:;icm 6-H'-61' _':.h--t.*, ,s%.{:ffi. '§;}f{:=y'iLi§3S far iex,-7y 9:"
':f<3s3a.1eV tax 0;;:_V_§éi?.£;:r3i_ 2';eg€'é'ter{§:§---- "?c1€21.§er and 6v<:ry"'««€j§%21£e:f wh---r.V=;7 315:3. Ii::_b}t:_'VVTi;'0 gei. himseif _r;&§g.i:é:.#:;r;:.1i.<;a11':2:d'cr__ s».uji3~+3t3(:ti()11ss (1) anfi {2} of 'A A VVS-e:;:i;i'0;fl;"A:_:{7 *~SE:E\E'i>,20(i} refers-3 is -<,ra1"1ir:::\:.'z&3+ '¥:L:§7;:><:'_s5 in restsspeczt sf whiciq £55 1éx«¥i'a:b§;€_,AAv Aim!' flhfi warcis 'C<}mpu'£:<«::' 0f ;2}:§.'«§§i:1ds' the: ward 'm'::f:'1&iy" is :2.-waif ;<;:;:3'{.:éngg; v9.ri{mE~: iijgfpes-s <23' <:<}m§3:3t:€r:s Eéke .%:*::';'gi}:i':f;1r1"::§, 1:23:33. pé::'5:s<ma§. :1'1§:':;:<::
<'.v{:.:%1t;:*;;3z4:nf.€3.=:".s>e: and "£.%1r3 §3;_E<::%. '§'h<:% w<i;:'cEsa '£13351 EEEQ Eikc' Es; §mii{>21i:§v€:~ af {hit $121573: fizat 2i2»2.§*§(}z;:$ E:§§}é%E:'s= 0'? {".{}§}}p¥.,EE€3":?% ;%;im_iE2:.z' 31$ 2":'22:*zmf:*":-:::1::i; :::1;?:'2:?, pe2*':s3<>§":a§ angi mi¢::1*{}w ::?.{:::*:1;:31;':«€:§"$, "£'E':s:re {'a}i'lET£€}'i. $36 zmy <§isis§:::"E.s3 an éjézéa p<'2s;asi%.§<a':'*:= §r2'::1'2<:{i§;3§:€%§}-* ;1fi"s::* EEK? ,/ fig Elk/'I.P§§E§i€}E€ :'<:%§'%:%r:*e<ii Ea; E35; Efihe §§E.EE_)i"€.'*EEE€?' C€.§3;.1;E"§f' in me? €Ti£:iS==~3~i',': <25 E-§{')?'vfi'¥i:'-'2'§" E4:-§"}EJC.Z5':'.§'E{.'>;*\-.f S{}€fEE'§"';:' {SUP%T€A}§ ?§'§é' wzjmdse 'E,E'2;21"£' 21.0 Séiff E'22,1vc.>. %:}€r€.:': {ii-*,Sr:"'.:I"i§.f}€fE€fi '€:s:p%a:;'T:.2T:€:::;:ry er i§h.2$1':";'aJLé2.*<a v.n:}r(§s:;; :;s:§{.'i 31:22: w<}r<:i:-a €:iiT'E.':"e;"
{sf 23.r:1;}EifEs:'t;:z%és:):: 0:' '§;;:zi:a_1Eri:..>3":.' in i_§'1'<';I~ <"*;'é§=;»s:i: '= of E%C}E'V§§'§;%Y $1.; %.,%€.':A'I'E QM _.A";'E%-{3'<:{§'E";T:§f"5' {SUPRA}, '(E16 S2apzf<§j;jx':t': €§€)ElE"i'"--{ _" W:%}§;§£ {2(>:'§:=5§c:ir;%:*§.1':;§; wE':;»2,'i? fj%I§'2<':.;}é§=4z£é'j:i:'':g§ 2% £"€C'§E,3§.§"C:Ci. 110 bi'-3 g§_v'<i'i1: ii}. Em: wtlfiifigA'i':g;1:11{-*'E'§;""' V empiogmd in éihe...§%'i~:.f;:%zzizzi' v._iSE-:-1,:€r_:1 '""i'__E:1e S§.21"t.e 9%' §;3<}__z";1'0a}»-' :ii:'{1§>£'i:11.;g thé1'{i':':oH ;;;r§ia1;.:r;,r or ;se;::'%<:r;'>1':<'.ia§a_:7;y j;s<:1'1_0o§-_ 2":-:.3_'I'.:. i'1<r>_m 3.11s? <'.i2.1i<:-E of the maifei", adn-1:.-3: '£,é:'_§ v-'§aSs»:{_'\.§..t}7:r3:'e': E:1g§is.eE1 is 'CE. 215, ;1§:1fzé3(:Ei1_§.":éij_'~.<:f if:1s1.1"L:(tti(>1': 21:13; 'pugsil <f§:ij.I':.2e'1f'"{ha_r1 .251 ympii E3c=:i<)ngi:'1g; {:0 21 ' .§s€'(_:t.§{;>*:'a." "<;:sf"<:i_1.'.§' .. ;;:i';:-:~; 1-.L;= Eé-I11'1§;:E.1&ig5§t? of w}1i<t.E"1 .}_§;r;g};I%Sh x':~;_}Ti{>:j_#.'::"in it c:><;p121..i_1'1e:%£§ by s§:e1.é§ngg v '1':aT::1.§:§#" zTx:':§.gE<)~h1d§zs:':s 2.-md {)§'t§?i€i'.E1E5 of n<_>n~ }E$ia1E.§<r {§€1'~.%i{E'<"3I'2'§i? 32:35:15 <3E).se§*vé2a§ £31231'. ~:'}"':{i_i?r;.::'::"§1}i {.119 w<s:V<'i "112;-miatiy' §:'2'";g3<.2;'§;s% A :;%._:1{.2::3i:;"at:£<>1": <3}? "Jv'h'<"i{ is £2<>mp:r'is:-;<*3<:% 12:: ihszé ;§sr£%§re:{;¥i:'1g z:'t':;;u.z_ss<3 Eifiiai ii {)_r€Ei3':e:;;"i§§,»* E'E'1.€;'-3 §}i§;'§}i§55{'f <25 e{g:.;2n:'s:_;,:j 'w2*:2.:E, £":,;§§<;mé§ u-'iii':
't:h<':-*3 cE:':s.:.::~';é3 {Es-s<;::'i":3e;% §:3i:%_§'<.:~§<',x E-*":,z:°t:}2:>;;; ihéi x:és{}r:i "me;-t:m"1a'a§'v" hag asiw b€3€'f": €:X;3ia§::e{§ in i:%:&% s~;23-'aizi a%a%e:__*:s5E'z}2'2 £.%zL%II§ ;."zE5%%{'} ii": 313m €Z'fI%>::'l:.}:"{E §::g;E§s~;h E'i}i:_'~:§<T>::2.:§*}? LE'-°.':' '§'.§'":;'=-*3' is ée:i:> s--;;;:jgI En this <'%::=:::"::?<:*:'£s:>z'*:E it 23% zzéeatizfl Ea"; :"c'-tie? €53 'EIi':::? Eziekziéé 23f; i'§'1a==-': €£}E.%§.'i. 21% 32 of {I)§i}f.-T>{?E"1'E"i§.i{I}E1 pa r21.g:" 2% E321 E'i"§ei1* 3' zzaig-§_r1':e;'1: , WE'2E<':?:
Maxis E."§€':".§"{T*E£I"2{§€'-15".
"12; Ref}; Ass :1}:"<_::ai}.-* §1'2dE<';21é1e<§ E'..:%ar.j':":'c=i:[_~.; High E§<::§':<'){';§ is; 21 '£°E'.*{'<,}g¥'1§K€;?{§ A:'1g;;i::s~§"riE7;igm if?
Scthooi 'u:E':i<_ih_ has ali ;-fl<:>n§_'§ been _£.-:"i:ag3a§i"i§'.::"1§;?§ €<:§2,'1<'éa==1§.§<3n :f_h1*{3:.§gh ziw 1'nediz.:1:_":-:"<:f._ it .1*@{'7:s:"iv'cs; afiiii om; ESE:;AiIi:;:
daitzghter af I\/Iajor Pi_.2'1§.{;.__2::":{_:i ihfi ;5v:>:'1~:>.?_~' Ejixaffi. ' Gujaa' a313,. {TiliZ{;'I'§S.V_{§§5:V_§1"E(§i.€'i .é_'_1I'}fiu 'E."i1€:?:'g;* {f':ia?i%:fiE E-1{iI'£1iS;'$i(j}£'1 EU E3a_;_sf_ ':. --.._VE*{i.g;§§ ~S;;i:}'é<;%§E in éixa-rciséc of ._1fE1e: §'I';z11<:.i;:£1:sV:*1£.'é::§ ri;__3;ht' &;a,i<;i so have b¢:>.s::::1 $11E¥§.I'§:"i§3 tf§fV£,'i'§. f?_iQ by :'\rti<_:i.€ 29[2§--:'§3§7_§1'1:§':' Cc)i'1$'i%it.;.£"i'~£':;;;V. ' '.'i?';':1é: Schzxgl Ems; €iE~r.f?ii1eti.41.a:;.4;'ici£i'1it4 €;&:'f:'§:m" of them in "x"iE3"€.-1-' sf fhé: <':1*ix.€{.z1;i':7._§:':*-5:1??? of me Sé:2,1Ii'€ <3?' Bombay. 'ZE_'h7t;.§)Ii:sVisj(§n$}"'<>1'" thy a=i_:m,2Ea.r ordexx igszzzici by fJhe.;:{ VE3'1;-rm? <31' B<:m'é;;:j.,-* an the. 65" :,§'<'U'}[i&5..E":y7 E954, h&.'£"v'{' 2;:lrea.<:£}_,--' isgzan 5;'u;";1:n;::z'i:~e:%{% % _ % ;::bzEE'_i-'§f:}..9 'i'§j;.:§' 0p<,%:*;»:.?g:§s'»:=é p<>t"f;..é:;.::: {)5 ?{§'§€'.' {}r:"§<;;*rx,. f<}:°f::E1 in {":§_:/grmae 5 i:h<-=:':r<}£', 2%-r22:1°1y f<3z'E}§ds; gzéi E'ri§3mrfij; 9:" E§€i?{f{}E'E{§;i£.'}f S={',?§?{}(}E.S§§ 1':-"}"1€i.'.'_E'%'.", €n;_.g;ii5%E2 is; 1E.'::§€?£§ 42:»; 2;: m<:§§§.:..§:":1 :3? é_r;.s--;§:"=2z<':E"E<"'>.;'L so 2;;:<:§:m: is} 2..u:y' <i:E;":2;.=.~«:<~:~",: 2:12;? ":,:'i§ {:>éE'm:.* *£§':2az': 2.2. ;>a.:':éE_ ¥:3{?:§:':r:1.;§3:J* 'ix': 2;: _ fl 2% §'3i:::;';2'1_:jjs,; ;.><;zw:°se: :.>f Ee.=~.z;,%<--sEai.%<.;;1 211$; Ezgggaé ;_z,:'";<'§_ e:>f §s;3:.;m;% szazizzrai 3155 :'3:"§.o:::;=z:.*; 0? §3:1:"§i;::m*;:':i: §§.:~;~s<;>rEEi 1:': iézat '.,='ii?'J§' ztsf EE':.c :',}.'i2:%'L':§:'f:' cv'cry eémrya' in the §€:g.§ss§21i'i:~*e Eissfi. Ezzzzd 1'0 be ggiw-:'}VT'é"§:3z: 'wfiy-'§{ii:',:'i%§l {'{.)E'].'§'1{}i"£'?EE'i()I'1 zmgi if; was is': "Zr'E'é:;a:{.' <:a>m;.<-ixé. Eh;-ii. the ua»:"«:%.:;; '°iEm:. .:i.j:~:*-:<>; ':e.s " :"ehs:--:<i 1,i§.){T::'1 by the";
G{i2TZf;"'fI'E?1§g wc'=.:°e §E"1E';f;'Ii""f_'_?§;§'(."£.f;Tf§Z_§. 1?}uighi-§;§"i.'-.&§?€:y~.__I'f§;ggf_.IA' the F'£2(;E€?:"21E {"§{}1..::fi; 'E}>¥::i€3<.§';€.%'1em;§.$:?~ v:'<_>:'.:4§c1vM V Emxre '&3<.==3<=.>.:": in {ELEEI -d (">\~r-.._:.': %.§":ie. .;__';'::"-:'wg;2r':v3;Eiéf§f{fé§" ':.E'1£t §egish.:'t:iw heaci i_"t_§s%}-'E.}'} '=f'i'E':{3s S3131:-3 _f*'e21ss{>:2 ceinnat: zifgggiy $15; t;?j:r§7' "é;.?_(f3»§.ji.§3'i.:'_E41Cilififl of Ems: G()VC}'Z'1§"I'1(j':I.'}1 C"tT_£i<§: IV'V 25:: ihgi'§Ti;'?£;:5é{?1'1.t. {'.2'LE'.%E3 far 'Athis_v«::<:>1'isi<.:i.c:i'zs&iion.sV E§'§£*tf. 2-lppiicaxi in the {3£.i.§3€-3: '._béf<)1;'s:«.' '~.%:h£g;"'=.,_I4";3ciemE €01.11': l1a1ve- H0 2>..;:1}3pi_i<j:z;1iié:@:'i {.i.iZ>:'{..iizT1ari%y t;%1€: x-3.«='€>i'€i 'm:'1;.iA11_«;€i:,:' §§I1_§f}()§"§.-S e<:§;::_1:'1:?:*£.n'§<32'1 <>'£" wizai. "«:?;)m;3r§.sss;%{'i in ¥;.h<;*, ;'>rm?e:*.ding ci2i:.ss:;'-.2 in 'A -%}::%1r":§" w<:>r(.:is; it ma"?i'z'1_;~:.:"§Ey £316 A '--"[;j3:§~:':*;><'>ss{;-=. of :%<g4z;.::;i;T:g; 'aa,=}:;.:%;, i'<'>EI<)w;<-3 wfih Elm " aifééamse;-3 <;§vs>;<7§"ibe£i ':3€2i%';:'a=i=.
"§"'E"z€r:"{: ;,§<}{>:i {Em} §<.;:":{:{:-x %f.h:-é;°{%€:>:°:;3. in 'é§'1€;'? 2u'§_,_{:..a:':'2:%:':E" ':'§'1::::: gm: <_}:'{:§<2:* z'*::'*s'.="~;i'z"';'<:~:.s-,{s &':3:{§ETI§E§3:='s:'~:32\ff2E": <';:':§§_,»* is; f'::2;s;:§<.2--§f::«:"§§;:ms; 2--mgi :a'§':.{ >5 {-3 3% e,.
{%£_i:%2%:e==2%:5:; cs? ;":a2§1~é§;a;i;':%'§{:.: €j§€E:"f%{ié:T£'E"E §:%21N':a':<:%" ".:"=,1::F§,{i:>§f:V:3y'~ A ~» E;-?:.:T:,§§uz;:g;,§e in E§;'1g§;£§se;h, "§'§'::':s~3 i_§'1E.&:1fp':'s?£,a'E.§{m fimis s:.z;.>p{>r*[. iE""=:>;:s3; "ihfi? {§€;?{T§f%§i€}E"i n";s;::'*:i:§m1£:d in <:Ea1.:5i-s<:2 3; to *«..&,-'§§:}'*;dr;;u.-v 33.3 :+3;'}<;%<%§a:E §:1i:e:*§.m <7:<:e1':c;:~:<;%::;i:::";_5_-;: £2': §"€ES§)€i{f§E: -. _.§:;=.f' . éidfllifif-}}§()§'1 ta S{:h«:}oE:'-'3 3."{i'.f€'.'i""}'€*{§ $0 cI'e'1:.%jE~::€:'{ 3:. E'a,:;ti1itie:tss fie Eiiigguisiicf: _ .. .r:1:£';i":V;(}1*3£,t::'i<-3§~; prcsviiieati for in Sziie: <i=.i:".:t%;.:_Ea-1:' --__.'c}r;"E.gv:';' E,h€'re'f<>re: may hit :"«:;*2":§CE~V 3LE5_ "cam§f<:§7{1;{3.§2;«?;i§:_g~.. §g:_<:§jEit:.i€:s iii} be ;_§;%:<5:'s;i_ {}t1Ey~ £5} .:E'§'<:j £ié.:_:'gEV€; ~i« §_:1dia.r:s ami <:i"t4'i:Z?_:'e:.::s--%; of" .z;1T(ji'1--A$aiat..i<: Ci€",S{§€'.I}§,," {e§1%'*3_ha1,s§§;s s3i,i"*.> *-Eiédj} E2" in yet ;2:.§3.otE1e1'" j1'3r_i_gb%51'eéV:':'{ in 'the cage Sf MAEIARAS}-1"fP¢"1;'fi£§¥BE§}.i} mMm:D ihc ward '13;af:1c1V;.§f'7;V v..?..<.;:V-:}:é:f's;:E"~i:é*.E:;<1i.:"y« {V} af the Ad. wag the SLab;€:c:f~,zI121£3£.ei1* (§Ti Vi<:»i':::és2,ivfiiC.1j§i'tEgm" which cama: is be ama}iySec1 and heEdé2,€QL1nd€:*.: A , I¥?.'}§V£H'21.§_iy $pe21ki:1g; f,ETi.€;'; {?Oi.§.§"§'.S '§Vh§§€"".§§_i§jiF£g 21 mfiariing E0: 21:: iéem €f';€:}5§iTE,§iai.§.":€':€§ in Eihé: Sitéiedtiéts give it the '~...:2:<{f:::;r--::'J§:1§.;§, which :_§f:€:>, zxlaigers {if the . ;'§_<_:fr§<3{Ez,:l§3 i::?{.f:%::<:§€e:"§ $33? g;'r£>L:ping vezriimssg a§.:'"E§{tE<3s in :51 p21;'t:i<::uE3;r g__;:"{:«u;3 <:<}:1sideri:3g {Emir}: 32:': §;*€m%ri<: éstizasséz Gr: 2: r€:~ad3L:},f§ {>37 €§'}f3"}:" E€S~A am? .§.?z::as €£IE&1.§}x"'SiS; £11; £5»; 2-"ivi€E<;*-.:5s€: §.':fzaE'. ihé? }i€g§§55;§a'£é.,::"é;% {mi :2§}i:: i:"éE.<é:':_e:E E8 '{:a:~: 2:-24%} §}a<';_E£:§.:'3;g_g XE':-27:'E'.§'E§'é2'iEi~f~;. E2'1'::<3':"2i:§{i::r: €52 §'f€} i,2§>< =:i:<%§'£;:.:.i::s i¥;:".*.m:-"=2 m2:e;§e.:'= é::'2m' 2:2? s«;p<:<>§f§<..%<'§ ::1;§t%"2:*§§;z.E52: m'T:z::2";%:::";-3:22:? in {%§as.:s;e:rs:s {:1} "E0 8;: §i>z.:EET.E:";g__§ E'§';:= 2%.-'<:.2:'<.£ ":':::IT:eE}.,'" ;~,":;§"E'<*:" {EH}.
the w<>r('i.es '";3a-:<7:ki::_;:' :':'2;:'£_é:.:"§2,:§" in {he hs3.2::<_?i:§;'1g of €-3I3EI"}' §%'i§~z%w i.h<3 §,£?g;i:s1;1u'.'L':*::ie 72m:e:'1{i;.<; to sagjéfztify i.§':rc p21::*§£§1':g H1225L§:'*i.::£_Es{'v z':':2;1cf€>: 022:, {Ff 2: E12212": .-e.'::,'sE2.§3".%s i.Z'{'}i}"i'3'iTi-('){§§!§1§,2'; :"i'ES} be iaxctii '{.i}'}{ii.EfE' t'.ha% ;Xs:_*.'{' C1z::1:35;»<;*. ¥'{i} '€§.gc§:.:«5§.<s w'iEi§f: §}£:'£.ii?'kiE'3g }*I}Ei.EéfE'E2Ii§fé3 §:1f':e:dt~:4 %'}fV__ papcm {ii} with in": a;azA:":'£i i:',%'_f'VEA'.1«';;.=;" §é§';_si%£,;d::;; from ;'::§:1a§t.i<:_ {ii-;}._v:f;§;-i.;._?:: E-iA'.('}{'i)§'§.' {'}«':}'§:€:? i'ib:*-E and {vi} W1:'._E3___§E=:;;fs:é;fix .
12.; t'é"1i 53 Vif§*<:.;1r€ <:§§':z c:e-irzwci with the "gig:£_.c§_f'i;i§js5 t'_1,1a:_€i&% out of jL41f;§ z;?LI'1£i j:i<;»if 'e21z'1y_ <>I.:i':--:_:1* 'm.z:§€--:riai. U:1ci¢:.r '<é.E;<1t.'1s§§*_ {;5}7::he _p21:.**%;z;:':g rna.i'.eriaEs made émt.125?.§L:€.:§{'*-have §'_>:.:>.m'1 '§.':»mugn._§}1t is iemg, hem.-:_ 2;-:.r{3?V,§é'1':*<;:e .§Ez'i1'"}i~§ in entry {'»''}i {3} '~.¥;}2zi,;::.1"se;} a:1»:;% {rs} 1'1{i%%I--::f%«:§'.z.::'1 <,%§<:>i;h, E>z1gs, [bit §:}2§:,.:"'(;§€m {§m';§1,:<£i:'2g ééfiitizfxiir' {T{'}m§2se{:§ , N ;'V:)fj.E.E":<% _g>a':.:'%:§{'*:'»; 2:-in 2:;-,_€E"{=::;é<:§ Q1212'. ;__23;2.n;z:j.,--' Ezéézggs; amti E}a:*'{%;;ms:«; {§:'2::l'a,.:<§_i:.':g "£112:-*:'£.:';:1°sss} ::1a.zi§&>. 0 :1 £1 £3? jU'il£.'x "E-§<:*:'5;:9;§a;1'3:" 2:53; ;:3<==.:' Sh@r:'.:%:' <}>;f{>r<__i U§{'E%€I}]fE.2i3'":§f ;:11€,:2m:i-: °°:ei,.r<.::'2§g §§sJ:"é"1;'} 9:' u§E£"{.{'fZ ¥'>7':'i{."§*§:
::<}a:':<~;a% {.fk..>€j§E 0?
{tiaih Er": t:E'::f §s;.m:z:? {:§:'::.t:§<}:1e-'zr}»* 'E3aim§:".:z"::'":<%2::':g "§33:;.u'::. §'é°s:'):":1 =J:§:::?<:§'1 <'%:>22::":»;<:
§'E.E:3r%;:=:ss am? <.;E'}E.;=s.§:i*;z:-%<é Em" ':%:<;;> 2223222.:2}-::*t.:2:2: ail" r{>;::e€ ;m<:E ::E<>§,Z':'i 'E'.E";:.3s:=s g-xii thérr three €£'1.'§Z§'§€?".E§; in €212-wigs {V} :"€:?E2s_€:2 '::.=:_} £E'::»:'é:: Ziléifiéf €33.23 «:2? v§L.§i.€1 z%'§'h;-"cir é:'if1<:=.S<:é <;=,_:f:€:r2':;-"*.s9s,, éhe: E',€.g£s.I2zi.L::'e ha-.5 ;':ad(.%€<i thé? w<>r{i§s "2u9;_:*§»T. E' «.5 '§'h{;'. like? Simi.Iar'E;L in afii (Rh:-;%;' «:A;}.:e_1_"::;..<:?'{?:::é 2153 well E;h_<::- xvsrmis "glad f:I"3<,-*2 iii;§:§" Vhgfié-éé bfiexl added at £216 :5'm713,i>f" <3z;f§,fi%:é*s%T,'_':. W<H"ds~3 ".27:11d iahf: §ik€" :=§;Vi§.§.: Zfigiire *§vif;h_ 't,§':é:% d<3S€tré§>t§.m1 {;s.§"_1;h<:: iiezfifyss in £§fz€L:.:3§':3:_'{:$é:~. andi wcmid :1e:>£; 1':1_'£:§i.::~:ie aih =i:}<V--::;11T I"§()i1 (3<;z1<Ee;§fed if}-~~flV:?;€~.§§'§1%i.i'y.' <?.];éu,:s€: agar}; the i1ii<<2.i'i;i%_i%:>:;}1L .ii$ '§lQ is tax ihe paclging r13;:;tg:::"_ia11§ V_fr1i;;1d"é=(§§;éf_s;f J§L13::e 0:113; a§:Li"«:1§e--i (mt. go? &1I'"};y €fi;§71.€1§f'V:'i"I18ii€fI'ial iike é1_f,:?'. JE,1i'.€2 is the basic i'ii:%1f£i 2:x§:d.1f}3.r: pas*;1~;i11g meitiirielis made .<>é:i:. of':j.L1'§€:.._E:.r1Ey am: s;'ub_j<:ct€d ':0 mx, 4-731:: €}{}3il7(3L'3'fafi,~{}H "and 'figs: hike" wouid _V§z%:::'1e;"és",.
r§:<fp;:£i_..:fs;"% 3;') E36 £fG§"£Si{ii€;i'fE'€§ "5-zjusdezzrl €::'§v1§sag£:€i by the pr€e::é:cii;':§:§ words "LAi_;<35i: 'zéeizzgg é1X§1au1sé:i'<.:~:£ of {E36 g3;<~3.r:&::-siis 0:1" 7i;.h:3 C338;-S-§--EE~§, Ether L::%gi3§e1€.:.1re §1.:«1::~; C{m»::é:iar<§c§ ihe vmriisz "'az1{i ihes 3.§k<;é" 55» as $15; bring; in azzjg €}TIh{'fE'" %%,€::m {sf "£h«:i= 5;-szégzzm zéiaaés {Bf gang':-&é§$, in §=.z1E:: :" 354%. b1°<i}a«:ih;
'%:f%2:§§§:''3 1. gm: §;)e;;s::E«;z?;'"; 5 {§if"§<é1'{:z':i'. :':'1é:%ai§:; 2m€i §m>.i:£::"i;2§;s3 '§:z::ré3 E'_"}{'3€'?§"; Thr: gémesiss GI' éhe £:Ea$ss 0%' zz':a_€:€m"aiss <3?
'3'?
maniianeé and {ha rsfareifzce its the wsrfis "and the $33.5" will ham :0 fa saparaiaiv with the descriptian in ea<.;;ijg.j item ami Wauld net 28 %&Vo:1d ans; oiher item net Carxceived ' each sub item, The :"efe§'€n_s:e"i:i}.ef:a;i:i"y_ 1B-A{v} is with r€fer€;f1c€>_§G bardan {inludifig} batsifa-S5§'§.V_%1es§:i.?3e11'A'cfiafh, V' and the wards '**a :f:'d,_thé"i:.1;e",_é:;;:é:{;d:::gj the principie 0f ge.i91€ri:sg'A;§§;§3uid net c@1*1(:<:'::I.'V3;_»*._é«-- CG'_£EG3I"iAC~}.§}¥5:;i'~'§agS Within that gmup "£03 AsL:Lbjié?:t:'%E1;fé€ I'V};a»¢§iti0ner ':0 I ~ __ _ Si.i§}:§§§ifi3_(i us} lS';"'* "i*§.TV';a;V§11?'ch', 'has ref€r:"ed to MAHENDRA E:~J<:3,1I~»;E*;§;R*1:$I<; '[;§'éf;p_§~a»}.44V'L"w§:'g:ein it has been heid at paragraphfi to the foiiéixzihg eVffe;c€;~_ S sgfiryh twa partg, G316, the Gther expianatorye A?£?{;+€:§*:' $r:.:* v;":éad tagfither is brizzg Sui the}-.s!c0pt~ exteni ssf its appiiaabzilitjg 'f:fi§y'. firs? deciams {ha items, wégich "..j';éx:;5»a'Ts:s;§gi;a}e its duty' Eéut rasificts ii '£9 .' 053%? 31035 in reiaiien :9 tbs m'a.:::ufam';L::"'€ 1 Q37 fifiich any pmc:3$$":i$ aréinzariiy camiefi 1.6:: ma: the aié ef pmxiezzz Eéavirxgi thus $p€"€if§€§ {E15 iziems anfi fiza Qenaiiiign an 2AzE':i.<?h 33:. ::i:<.::z.zE:§ be é_"e';'é*-;{*§"°€;f{'i in fz:}':<1=t <:r':i'.r},= if }3'E°{,)(f{'?£1"{Z§-E'; $3.2 23:.::";.;.>E;'f},* in E'.%"w :sé%c.?r<:;:3<'E §3;.:rE by us;i:'1_g the": w<:sz'<i:::; '£':';§1<i>wi:1g; ;1;;::'m§_§§;' i:.hus-3 <%x;T>E.2-m*2.§:"1g;' ézim i§<*.=ms~; flfézai; ,§m._=_;9{:._V ir1t.ei'1<:§c<'i En be <?<w::'=:'"<'»e:.% in {E1113 {fE1f.§'}='~,.' of e3_Xp1'c%s.~.;si<_;1'1s °:12m::.;*Ea:'L 02" '£..:;=,<;;
§%:::£i.:>\x:€éci by {ies;<?:"i;:;é':i::m..A us:.12:z.}§y €ifZ_x:.§"E.E.EE.ESf;iV:'*¥..1:3E€;'fAfé3Vi-3 ''*.§'{.}1'£:?:'' ('? ' ;v%i':f{-;§ in 5:-;i':r:i::':g.3; i:"':<'iéca%i»i'<T;-figs». V:.1:I'a_ ihéf Lz1{1g§:.1.e.2.gc? mi" N<i).4v";§i.;1if:g é-fi:«:i simpitx '12;1t'é:':'%._::§;s "'=.jg) 'i:1:?:'rif3;;r {ha} exprcésaisyfi ' ';§T*;12::':1_1V,{"§.'.:V g; 1 Q2' .. i',i'2_§:1"<a§'r<.>;z1' by eripzzfi Em/1%}? :: v.i;.*'§? i1V1€Li3f~?€§§: éifllbif, evé.> :1 '_ V §?{:1j E41::§.§§€;§ZLf%E:%é :9";---~{a:}1i<t}2 i"1?b1"<-3* mi ' y&T;:fl:f$zx§E§i;E*{Li£§i'1E£.iiv?7i.€E'£.€é£3i 'fix "a;a.:?eig}1t:. 1231.1: it did """ H 'A ii 2<:I: ::'V1V{§fl;>:..s:";3e:}z'"i',t?d to i:2<:Emi:;=_-*.
" _ " géfii, 2.1? E11211} L1F:'E1Cii'.U re 0? 21 fiiovzxavin;5Vci§_i,y€11 wh;iC§": §:'1i;'1<:?:"£:*d fibre: 0:: yam pi'<3{_i {§§'1:§:1:;:s..1ed. '".E'}'1zr v:'::ry W215-3 eicictierai in ..1§%8{} " """ "' E'h;i:x;E': gzawr yam 0::<%2a.$i<;m £531' £316 A "1§::;a"1j.§'1€{§ c0:.::1s;c=i for L2 1:35:31 sf Endia to Lxrgge f_ £'..'i:9i21'i. ii: we-133 .im;'e:1-::i<*::.% ts: ::=:vaz:ir3: p2'1}?'i}'1€°fiE mi"
4 V{§'l.i€',}' Evy 22»'i<§¢:=2'1i3z;;j ;;1':e:.£ <:xp;m{ii:':§;§ -:2-ms £1H':bi{ 5:? m'1'i'.r'§;. hi: =...::;.:;" zagikliziéugg fiiét-:6 E¥I<;::m <:2m:'1<;;§; 'ma {T{f}§'"3S§'.Fl§_i';'?{"i in Ehe :§'1;=zz1:'1<==:é:"
§§%..;.;;;,<_T;{z=;%s.'-*;:'.<;*s:.§. '§."'E'2<* e3:'::a my wzzsa :=.:i{§_%:ém€:{'§ §::>u€: ii} E..E'2§: s?:>;i.<:z'";§ §§}i§é(?é:E'€i"i§ ;i§.,}{'}'x4'é?. {;_:'1§z' <:€.E':<;.%r <?<}::'1:<;~,:ii';m.:<%€mi: xa,--'<_;:.1§{::i :";:eaz:§'£. £1": 2;.i.E.§:2é:ri:.':§ 153::
EU LXI w<}r§s:.e:bE€: '£'%1;ms::; f2'2E:s:*ir:*:
:m::;muf'a<r€.:n'&a§ 93.2.': 0:? m:;n<:%;z"a§ f§':3re Eses aéxiggibké to di,i$'.f;.-F m'1<i&:' Ham 4 btxi: am:
<:§":a_:mbeé:f h(}E§Sif}§_§ 31.212321 fa:cE:1.m:<:i fmm giasas fabrig: <:a3;1:1<3'£: be piezceeii at par vs?-'iI.§f:., g_Eae3:«s fabrkt zmd <:2mn;0"§: be £:c>;r1ssi<:§.<:1°"««:'t1V:'2:$;'-_ ' '0fif2€:"' nm§mi'21<:t::r€' <3?" gizzszs :_é_':;'§;*::'e yzazrfi." .
141 The wards: 11536:} in a $139212 S1'fE§1l§.=l€:.__'§75€'f_ I"€i§§,ti as eX.h2msi"§w: tmfii and unless i,?1+: '£,eg'is1f~fi;'§-:§§€ .§i'3i;31"}:{I'lS Qt.h€r\,v'is€ by us.i.}:1g {lie we::~3'ds,é S{£':*,}:E' as "a-':.'r"1(.?_%.h€,':1i.1ié:"" 0;" $0., ané 0:11.32 in such {iii'(?¥;iiI;3;'Sf.E1f1'C§€S?'AIlfifif pl'1<§¢m:Ep1.es§A of ejusciem gang-his may be aypiicezble and :L3:'«:3I; :€)tE.'I'f:f;ia?§'§;f;¥\'..{[ xarouid be the r€sp011}%3i§3i§ityVGiflhéé'VCe:>';;;13is__"£13 .§:;*z11b.2u°.1<: upan an enquiry to finéfi (mi as is) xxr%1et:E<:§%;",. §3":u§:t1";{ <i:0m:"1'md1't§I wamizgi farm €1?th<3r par: ';>i"g_§§:;:§ses'-0:9 '$§3ect§{2s a'r1<;i $301. in 22. {:i§<::2..ms:,22nc:s:s 015' this ':':<;,17§;L":iz°r:.:"" ' '"3f'§::;y_ W<)re;§. ";é21Im:E3---" '€'.ha§; E13133 been zzsed in 'ihe A"~§}I"€'_$fiE"iil~. €;?3:£.{.}":;f:"-§X'"1 amsznjgzzivibcafi §{i'.§"§E'£E'§ §:*:s:i:1£:ei,r: ?;;h>;1§; if is":
:%::<;£"1':3+__1,3§'£:_;':?€ a}:'1<:§ is :*e:':fe.r:§%:s3e {.9 §}§E§f; Eihagéssé :>,:":"s',:"'ies:; :::§3e.{:§fi:::21£Ey "-::"§é:*:1.[é.%a>%:.:;%:§i E3: E§i'}§.E':=J' EA p:1:"%'.ii:uE;~:riy in ihégt absmigte 9? {he " 'zmd mg? iéim' 0:" "::i'.<;é'. "R16 w<>§'{E "::e:z:q:%§y" usscfi in E;:§éz"y EA :3? §)a1:*'{',~§E§ Sahecluias ii :55 §3z"::*€,:€%.e:c§::*:§,-3: 'Lites éitéz-s{2r%§3'!'.£<;§:
21 "p:"»:é_§i:>;'l E': "sis: rm: i.1:f%§€;':i"i 2'?.&3 ea: "';<;;z.:§i'i>~:" §§§<<;>. ass 0:' w<}:{E§ "zatzzéifi 'E§"",:{:'; 2.33;:-'=*1 ""5-:£:<':"' am'. i'E3<:: Eémi <23" <-%:'1!.:"'§<::s;j::a3:n:':m{i:1iEase; §~;<:. 2:25;
{§/ AAAA ii} bzfi:':;._;§ w'i§%':é2'3 ii}:-3 5§'~}J€;',i:'..§} £§'¥; h€§° é..'i}B_1§'§'1G{i§E'.E§3§?: M' §:§~:§% ::a€.z.::f€, 'Er; §'.he é':i'i}S€E?§'§{_§€:f mi 572211116? "ijussde:":1 g§::%=m;%.z'§:s:" .§.I'":E€;?I"§f}E"{E§"2ii.§{}E'1 ca;'::mi1 3:16 ::1€£{}g7;i1e:{.i glmti €%{:'é,}°},7 222155 is bit }.":.:-flii -i;'f_'»{.§"§':":':,.UE:'-E"€.§'«.-"€'?. £5. The }z.zc3g;1:'1€-23$. <33." M.A.i:--§i.N§I")E?JX EiZNGENE€E§R§NG pressed E11323 se;'v§<:.<3 by $116 Ee2¥;:"1":c%<:i Czmxxsfiri 55):" i:}1e:_ ;2V$i-s$S*;-.s_ee was 21 1:1a.§.1.<-_=.:" a:'is::i21g 13.'n«:1<3r° {E16, C€:'iI'1il:"Ei:§ Eixeisstés :;%§1_1d 'S::iEé;. Aa::::,_" . E944 wherwamzder ?£,hf;' ""i:L.1bu1a2* E-ZahE':'zp€C§ {?h£1IE'1i35:'§}..'§1€}'i3Si;3g§$~.3 rz:2mui":1<ét.ured by Lhe assesses by ':,_;:~:,.i.1.?;g_;:T ggiezss §**;.}3§%3. iihc ssui:2je<:'!. n1a1te:=r' of c0ns1?dr:.rat:i§2T-:._,__ [E335._Z'é1fi\"£1I'.1'i" {'jS'§,If'}7 2.;§z1dé:'r. CETA :1-::«.1d as tinder:
"33#F, Minérzii ;f:'i3§3:*i%s%3~-.__'»21.fad_ yarn amci
-------- "f,"'r1--@:r3f:~(J:n.; ":1": or in 'i'€§1€iVE..3{C3Eé4if)'4i1§T%Jgff"'-?fT}.'2J,f1LZféiC'{;Ll.1"€ of which any 'A ;{3£'0t::3.s«sS is: :_{§*mf1:i1i;1riIy (3E'£,I°}f'.i(i':d 911 with Ezbe 4' c>§T.p<>xx;@,:;;"' file foilgwinggg, namely;
. 'i71}g§;Ee1sS fibres; anti yam Ezzqéludiug glzzaa ' f~._?éf,;1;<.~;$:.1_€;és-3 2-méi g,;"EaSE-:» woo}:
" {2} as-§:)e3:si:<2ss fibre zamzfi. }:'"Ei.E'IE;
{3} may {}i'h€?:E' zzfzirzégami fa?b:*e :3? }?.E:£"'E:§ wh£32i:E2é:%§' {:<:=::€i::1:w:<>1,:ss 0:' {§i?;.h&ra>é-'§$s; .sm::%E': 21$ .s;Eag.;; 'J€{){¥§ azzé m<:k wazuzfl;
{:19} m.h{:-.2" :";1:m':;.f2a;§fé::u:'E%$ :1: whizéh :m'z'1<=::'2:é i'Eb:'es:é {E37 };'2?;.:*n or E;:<3!:h §rz:%<§a1m:2.2s}i :3 <3? _;33:a%€.Ez31"z1i§'1a:i':es; in wé;-?ig%1i_.
E3>~:";>'Ia:T:;21é.:éz.>z";: '"i"}":iss iéeém dams zmt: §:':<:§u<§_<=: as~;be:=3'ni::>s <':€::r1'§€3m. pr<>£iu<:'i:&§."
'.}"%'§.€r wo':":i;<; msssrci in :e;a.ic'I% emzjy W213 'wi€§..Ei1 E'€f§??--'{'_,§}{'f€?'xfifi "marzuiactu.re" eimer by 2-my §}E'(}{'fi€S§S :;z*ci:£;';'1eiL:"i}iy:'u€:2aL£<:*i<:<i ar with $116 aid of me grsmver zmti 'é.E'1'.+::-se.;'x:2*{)i§"d.5s_\:v:3%;*& q'u;;:;.§__ifi~:.Va:':
with §I§"E€ 'W0}"€i 'namelyfi Eff 3-5-3 in iliyisé' E3a1c:?§g§i'%j§'u.:1d§ _ i.E1e::*. Lardships Eiaw :i:1tm'p1f<:E..§3ci the xi;*é:;'?ci ?';:3e1:.1:.é'3:y._'«éihci ciozmizzded 1.1121?" use 01' €x.pr'ess1'(:x1'1 ';::_2i1*1<:%13--?_' 21s;.s§u;fTi"§§;.é:§Tt.<2r the descrripiicn 01' gaods is»; 1,1su_211Iy i11_1,1Vs.t:*z;1Vfi.iv.€ ;2..a'r':'1'<:s:;és'~~..'jjé'.I':Err€ are sim:1g md:£c:21{i_ons; 'Eu iihr';<'- s:wj(4)1x'"a_1.;9'21.;;y';* .. "We: do not. §'.m.d in the instant.
such swzmigg'§:1dici21i4'it:;i::2 _ €1.52---.f,§a1<:e a ::~3€.2m(.i or 22 visa; ii} heici fiiéii. f;fE1?..E'3/f.§S ::10'{ C*>g.1é.2mst,£v5£: 0%' {.0 Enid éhafé. e:':t'.:*y' in q:,2a<sé;'§e:>1'1 iS =.'Ii§};iZx:%3'3£.E"&1§';§-Xféf.w. M£3*:":;*.§;§,>""'btéiiamssfit '§.h€% ix?gEsEz2:i2'z'€ has,-2 ih<:»L1g§hE fit Vise i'"a;;:%§%:§S:§£§::1 E:a.z E}1'in,g 21c§.{iiEri(};rz2}.i gc§@di--: L.1n..{§<;?;" §E1"é':"3;' EA 0;'? P2fa'rE::'="§I -5:§f£3§.§?'f€§L;§,7E€Zf H i§:3S<>w£'7a~1<?I,<§ v..~'»:m§d n<'3'i Eeéziai in 3; C<3r1(tEus-s§:};;':
%l.§:;;z,%;'"' s--é1'1'i;--:j§.-' "£':'::s:»s is 'be? i§11.2s{:*2zi:ivex W E1116: iE":§'E?§'pE'€;?§.i.1'1§_.§ a i§5;e:':z:£
5.-'y:2?2%;§.:§.:: §;}jé:r:'1§%r2:E §.}§".§.§'.§{?i§';*§.€' 13:3 bf E£{§€}g3*§.i',{i "i's::= €:<:5m1E:'1s% E.E":{~r 'rf:','.}§1"é'u.»E"§.-"."'21E:"=§ <22'; Eéms. §§a{.<=: 2"€§€f';;'E'1£Z?:Z '£10 'E,h.é;=, 2*:§e,:s;<%&;5§:":2.e:%m.. }«*'ea-:2". 2%; s=s:F.:<;:E'%; Wff.' ::;:'i: :,::<.'2.a'§;: :3 a:'?::_'::;rg}€ mg: a-::i§.§:m:e:':"£. 2":::*§*:.»='a;m=:t:<«:-<:§_ Ef}; iihs:
8:52 // ES §€3f£iI'fE"z€d C:3r..s:1:2=:s:E i'<.>:" E..%":€ :);p§:>e:駧2-:m.. E:"is3m',{?: Ehii'. L;§U..{§g.13':e:':é. {>5 ':'¢Ef%f§"§§.N§.}§§z'§ E£11"~J{}£?\§ E§E33'E.€Ei'.'s:'%Z} :°«:=:=.§b?:*1"::7§§ is &;:_i'§:2§"g2 w<7:::_E{E mm} E32:
ap§3Ei<:z':.§3§s Sr} aha: §}§<t€.s;~; if Ehe p;'é3ssé:1:J;. ca$<::, "£61 in 23¢} far as VIFZEZ NESS.A.N £32135 1"9€<~:.:"§"{:%{i E,<} '§§;.»ti {he ];e3r:1eci Canxzasstéi gm» '1_1E.m aasesssee. we filld in '¥i.h;£;?~.__5.eai<ffEL-&::~aé;':; é;'.1*12:'é. 'Ra(:~k Series Systi-mr.z'§ ma.m1fa<:t.ure{§ by j;:ss,é§;~:q.Sg:€ ' 'E,he:°€in was; %3r{;ugE2i. uncier wgiciaagiry '{ii;3'L_13.c 215;;.;:'§;21i:1S':1.*£:h€. {?€}i1if31'1I.i{)Z1 Of E12/:5: assesseée to b1fimgé_*; Wii:hi:1 {fiat"'»a?°i£fi':_Ei:':;1i2 No. 33?' urzdesi' ihe hfiaidiilg "E\rIL1sej:i"(t;1bI S:§FSi€?l:1i.&*37.., _ _71'%§£;% 2{di11i*L't.<~:ci fadzsa in Ehtf said <?21ss*@. XV.£iS3.""I.11A?:1_:i.' ';§3§1Cfk Se';-103;' E5}-*S'u3m" m;u':u.f21<:i.1'1;"ed by the e::.SS£*._s$e4<3:,f%:g:I.udecf;'.'é.:":1pEifi<3z", graphic equalizer; $I)6E11i1..:€it°$_R cajéseiieLf(::<E1<; a:1ci 'é;'1,:i'nt'Tab1e",. In this ba<;°:kg;z'~:>u11d. 'i,E1'<";«i:f«~Ld';?dShif§'s._{:a1i:1c:: is 21 ciomtkusian i.ha'?; theses it<;:*m.:s C:a.sseE;1.e "dfe.c_Isi'.j*--.;1fIip1i.f.ier; s;=:icq <?0z,:1.<:i not. be heid "Lhai f:'E,1'i<3i. &Ei"»?f§1VEV£'E§'I'€ZE"£§;' s,sys:;'em 21116 as Siiifh it. was held 'Lha"E' '§tVC:¥:z1né1>L"::i {E§'§, L1§'iCi€I' }"'€SiC§E.§aZ"}-' ciazzsse zmci ii. <>ug;;h§, is fa}? '---a,1.:2«~:§s-3:' ¥_'.3."'§{*:..§"2<1*,;?itC§,§vis'3§z_§ "M'z2s;i{?a§ SySi,eH':ss" 15:11:32 33%?' 9%' C{*Z'E"A, §""§€;*.z}£:e:'-.9 4g'ue:¥_,<:;,§zTz:}.€;";.%;. is aise zmi. a..pp§§{'.z:E':>§@ is {he £a<:i'.a-; 6:}? V"~iEf:€; {?23S€:x, "
n§§'?K it; §h»:*. é:*2:~;i.ar1i' {:a_s<-fig find 'i_.E1a?.. g,§a><}d:=s fieifw Wagdiiiesive iagesg ceitan mils, waéding roiigg brass pins 32° ?.R*'L §i3:§$' :?zm:'*:<}§, is-at saaaéai is f<>:*z7:2 ;}a:'%;. 9? €'.:»3.§3<;>:'§::_§; :i§.€-3.1%; 5.0 £'§«.11§§. @iE.E'2s:~::" u§':{:i€2* EEK: §§€?1'E€"-.'$i§ or $§§)€;i€',.}:€é§. ?~§é::3:'%:".x, ii': is E":e3;{§ a:':(i «::%€n'1<:'m<,i:E*(E '§1§:23.E €..§':.<;*::~.s:;: %.é.&é:.'::&:«s <?am:'1<>'§ 313$: §":€:E{Ti K'; femzz §.>§;§"§. €iE.§T;t=.:' g_f;€;.'2€s'£sa 93' §:E'1€.=}: 2'39 uric"? .2' 'aha: s:3pé:%{:i:3s--.;; 0? gg€:'1€s~:§s?; Ce:'m1:'ng u§':d£?1" ihté i:ai,eg€.>ry 0? "é.a:'§k:;:°mgg' §i.&%r::5;e"I
38. in View {>5 the aijfive (i::$C'a::s;s.<5§{3:1, zafs:....&1}£"s '{;{f=§,Ei'5j (":{msi{§€:'<:%d \,?ié;"*.\¥ é.h22_i, {;u.esa1.§<>;'1 sf 221%' i"{3:*:1':2:Ea£'.e:d"-'£Tiéi:*tEfiin iibéarié ' :*@{§u1?1.'e;Is 3.0 ':39 f.;»3.1'1:~fa»m-*e:*€:£i ;:gz--:i::$:: 'i.E'1é*: §2?1',)s5ssa-':::~:5é;--:-:9 .;2i£'_:;:f§' .%_2':f2:'m:::'i 0? $216 :'€:*m::13e a.:':a:i <::<):'1.:~*s€q11c%3'11.§.j='_.; *E'e1r'i:<;ic>:';--»A '§i3»r;*;':;.fl.;i{:;ii'«~.is.
dis3r11isSeci. No G:'{f.er'S 215.»; 1,0 {:0s?§.ssj"* }"§AA'aL:Eéé"3'€%*3 Nx::§!« .