Central Administrative Tribunal - Hyderabad
Karaka Bangaru Naidu vs Defence on 19 February, 2024
OAs Nos./021/448/2022,OA/470/2022,OA/487/2022, OA/457/2022, OA/623/2022,
OA/624/2023 & OA/447/2022
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
HYDERABAD BENCH
OAs Nos./021/448/2022,OA/470/2022,OA/487/2022, OA/457/2022,
OA/623/2023, OA/624/2023 & OA/447/2022
HYDERABAD, this the 19th day of February, 2024
Hon'ble Dr. Lata Baswaraj Patne, Judicial Member
Hon'ble Ms. Shalini Misra, Administrative Member
OA/448/2022
1. Karaka Bangaru Naidu , S/o K.Ramana,
Dob : 28-11-2000 , Age : 22 , R/O : 1-17, Santhapalem (Village) ,
Denderu (Post), Kothavalasa(Mandal), Vizianagaram (Dist),
Andhrapradeshpincode:- 535183.
2. Yelamanchili Ernaidu, S/o Yelamanchili Tata Babu
Dob : 03-06-1999, Age : 23 , R/o Thimmapuram, Padmanabham ,
Vishakapatnam,Gandhavaram Post:531219.
3. Salapu Mohan Kumar, S/o Salapu Manga Raju
Dob : 04-10-1999, Age : 23 , R/o Door No :
81/A,Salapuvanipalem,Paravada,Visakhapatnam,
Andhra Pradesh, 531019.
4. Usulumarti Siva Naga Sree Sravya D/o Usulumarti Rama Krishna
Dob : 06-04-2002, Age : 20 , R/o : Mig 1-150, Simhapuri Colony, Vepagunta
Post, Pendurthimandal, Visakhapatnam,530047.
5. Patnala Surya Kanaka Shyamala, D/o Patnala Viswarupa Chari
Dob : 11-04-2002, Age : 20 ,R/o 55-5-55/5, Umanagar,
Hb Colony, Visakhapatnam, 530022.
6. Eeragottpu Swethasri, D/o E.Syamala Rao
Dob : 17-09-1999, Age : 23 , R/o: 303,Suhitha Nivas,
Oppdavschool,Sujathanagar,530051,Visakhapatanam.
7. Yerra Alekya, D/o Yerra Sanyasi Rao
Dob : 30-06-1998, Age : 24 , R/o : 64-22-30, Kunchamma Colony,
Sriharipuram, Visakhapatnam, 530011.
8. Pilli Divya, D/o Pilli Ramakrishna
Dob : 01-10-2001, Age : 21 , R/o: 36-2-38, Old I.T.I Junction, Sankurupeta
Village, Kancharapalam, Viskhapatnam, Ap-530007.
9. Kundrapu Nanaji, S/o Kundrapu Rrambabu
Dob : 17/04/1999, Age : 23 , R/o: 13-2-64/1mettapalam(Village) Vemulapudi
(Post) Narsipatanam (M) Visakhapatnam,AP.
Page 1 of 24
OAs Nos./021/448/2022,OA/470/2022,OA/487/2022, OA/457/2022, OA/623/2022,
OA/624/2023 & OA/447/2022
10. Palla Sirisha, D/o P Mahalakshmi
Dob :24-05-1999, Age : 23 , R/o : 7-44/4 Sathivanipalem ,Pendurtimandlam,
Visakhapatnam ,53001 AP.
11. Botta.Shyamala, D/o B. A. Satyanarayana, Dob :15-09-2000, Age : 22 , R/o
: 5-124,Sathivanipalem, Jaggayyapalem Post ,Pendurthimandalam,
Visakhapatanam, Andhra Pradesh -Pin:530012.
12. Rayi Siva, S/o Rayi Eswara Rao, Dob :15/03/2000, Age : 22 , R/o : Door
No:1-57,Gavaravaram,Boilakintada Everapalli, Visakhapatnam, 531075.
13. Singampalli Ram Teja, S/o Singampalli Appala Naidu, Dob :12-05-1999,
Age : 23 , R/o : 2-42, Bayyavaram Village,Makavarapalem (M),
Kondalaagharam Post, Visakhapatnam , Ap 531113.
14. Tamarana Surya Prakesh, S/o Tamarana Akkunaidu, Dob :05-06-2000,
Age : 22 , R/o : Door No:3-00,Vajragada,
Village,Makavarapalem,Visakhapatanam, Pin-531113,Andhrapradesh.
15. Kolli Durga Sai Srinu, S/o Kolli Tirumala Rao, Dob :25/09/2000, Age : 21 ,
R/o : 36-92-246/1, Srinivasnagar, Burma Camp, Visakhapatnam, 530008,
Andhrapradesh.
16. Krushna Sahoo, S/o Biswanath Sahoo, Dob :13-02-2002, Age : 20 ,R/o At-
Plot No:- 1177, Sri Ram Nagar, Po- Old Town, Bhubaneswar,
Pin- 751002,Odisha.
17. Bhagya Ranjan Behera, S/o Daitari Behera(Late) Dob :10-03-2001, Age :
21 ,R/o: At-Batitanki ,PO-Nachinta Ps-Khantapadadist-Balasore , Odisha-
756043 Presently residing at Visakhapatnam.
18. Kalivarapu Lokesh, S/o K V Ramana(Late), Dob :05-08-1999, Age : 22 ,
R/o 36-92-205/5 ,Asrrnagar, Burma Camp, Kancharapalem, Visakhapatnam
8 , AP.
19. Chinthakayala Durga Prasad, S/o Chinthakayala Marideswara Rao, Dob
:05-05-1999, Age : 23 , R/o: 1-106, Near Rice Mill, Gummidigonda (V & P),
Nathavarammandal, Visakhapatnam (D) , Andhrapradesh, Pin:531115.
20. Pulamarasetti Bala Murali, S/o Pulamarasetti Ramakrishna, Dob :01-08-
2001, Age : 21 , R/o: 3-26,Chinatalaagraharam, Vepagunta Post,
Pendurthimandal, Visakhapatnam,530047 Andhrapradesh.
21. Name :Pathlavath Shiva, S/o Pathlavth Harya,Dob :10-6-2001, Age : 21 ,
R/o : 1-18 Naiknagaramangal Mandalay Vasudevapur Ranga Reddy Dist,
Telangana 509358.
22. Suragala Pavan Kalyan, S/o Suragala Pandubabu, Dob : 25/07/1998, Age :
23 , R/o Door No:1-91, Pakki Village(Post) ,Bobbili, Vizianagaram(D), AP
535558.
23. Malireddy Kumar, S/o Malireddy Ramu, Dob :16-05-2000, Age : 22 ,R/o :
3-94 Velamapeta , Gullepalli ( V & P), Near By Meesevak, Kotapadu
(Mandal), Visakhapatnam, Andhra Pradesh 531034.
Page 2 of 24
OAs Nos./021/448/2022,OA/470/2022,OA/487/2022, OA/457/2022, OA/623/2022,
OA/624/2023 & OA/447/2022
24. Ommi Shyam Prasad, S/o Ommi Appala Swamy,
Dob :07-07-2001, Age : 21 , R/o : Door No:9-21, Sathivanipalem, Pendurthi,
Visakhapatnam, Andhra Pradesh, 530012.
25. Surugala Manoj Kumar, S/o Suragala Pandubabu
Dob :01-06-2002, Age : 20 , R/o: Door No:1-91, Pakki ,Bobbilli,
Vizianagaram, Andhrapradesh, 535558.
26. Duppada Vasu , S/o D. Mahalakshmi Naidu
Dob :10-06-1999, Age : 23 , R/o : 5-49-3 M V Peta(Vill) Patipalli(Post)
Munagapaka( Mandal)Visakhapatnam(Dist) 531033.
27. Tamarapalli Siva Krishna Manikanta, S/o T Ramarao
Dob :10-06-1999, Age : 23 , R/o : 3-48, Krishnarayupeta,
Vepada,Vizianagaram.
28. A.Bharath Kumar, S/o A.Parameswararao
Dob :25-12-2001, Age : 21 , R/o : D.No. 9-124/10. Pendurthi (M),
Visakhapatnam (D), Andhrapradesh (S).
29. :Vommi Satish Chandu , S/o Vommi Raju
Dob :26/06/2000, Age : 22 , R/o Door No:21-37-2, Seetanagar
,Pedagantyada, Visakhapatnam, Andhra Pradesh, 530044.
30. Aleti Bhaskar Babu, S/o Aleti Appa Rao
Dob :12-11-1999, Age : 22 , R/o : 28-6-1, Yellammathota,
Dabagardens, Visakhapatnam, Ap-530020.
31. Lakkoju Durga Rajesh, S/o Lakkoju Narasinga Rao
Dob :10-8-2000, Age : 22 , R/o : 2-3, Sainagar Colony,
Sabbavaram, Visakhapatnam, Ap-531035.
32. Deepak Kumar, S/o Dhrup Das
Dob :10-05-1997, Age : 25 , R/o : Ghogharahabairiya,Po- Bairiyadih, Ps-
Harsidhi East Champaran (Bihar)- 845435.
33. Bhabani Shankar Biswal , S/o Raghunath Biswal
Dob :23/08/1999, Age : 23 , R/o : At -Sarbana, PO-Agria, Block/Via-Betnoti,
Dist-Mayurbhanj,State-Odisha,Pin-757025.
34. Rangala Nithin Kumar, S/o R Raju
Dob :20-07-2002, Age : 20 , R/o : 36-93-223, Indira Nagar-
4,Kancharapalam, Visakhapatnam, Pin: 530008.
35. Nambari Narendra, S/o Nambari Maha Lakshmi
Dob :25/03/2002, Age : 20 , R/o : Door No: 2-55,Denderu,
Kothavalasa, Vizianagaram, Andhrapradesh, 535183.
36. Ommi Srinivasa Rao, S/o Ommi Naga Raju
Dob :22/08/2002, Age : 20 , R/o : Door No: 6-
159,Sathivanipalem,Pendurthu, Visakhapatnam, Andhra Pradesh,530012.
Page 3 of 24
OAs Nos./021/448/2022,OA/470/2022,OA/487/2022, OA/457/2022, OA/623/2022,
OA/624/2023 & OA/447/2022
37. Palla Ganesh, S/o Palla Appala Raju
Dob :15/05/2001, Age : 21 , Address : Door No: 3-199,
Sowbhagyarayapuram, Pendurthi, Visakhapatnam,Andhra Pradesh,531173.
38. Dadi Dileep, S/o Dadi Venkata Rao
Dob :17/03/2002, Age : 20 ,R/o : Door No:9-142,Munagapaka,
Munagapaka(M), Visakhapatnam, Andhra Pradesh, 531033.
39. Ankabattula Siva, S/o Ankabattula Appa Rao
Dob :07-12-2000, Age : 22 , R/o: D No: 5-56,
Narava, Pendurthi, Visakhapatnam, Andhra Pradesh, 530027.
40. Yerra Govinda, S/o Yerra Musali Naidu
Dob :18/06/1999, Age : 23 , R/o : D No:8-9,Dibbadipalem,
Anandapuram, Visakhapatnam, Andhra Pradesh,531173.
41. Bheemisetti Ganesh, S/o Bheemisetti Adi Venkata Apparao
Dob :03-07-2002, Age : 20 ,R/o: D No:130/2,Haripalem,
Atchuthapuram, Visakhapatnam, Andhra Pradesh, 531033.
42. Varadi Siva, S/o V.Pedaramana
Dob :02-06-2001, Age : 21 , R/o: 1-25,
Tenugupudi (Vill&Post),Devarapalli (Mandal),Anakapalli (Dt),
Andhrapradeshpin Code:-531030.
43. Vanamoju Raju, S/o V.Sanyasirao
Dob :09-05-1999, Age : 23 , R/o : 3-34/D, Jammadevipeta (P &V) Madugula
Mandal ,Anakapalle (Dist), A P-.531027.
44. Raparthi Tejendra, S/o Raparthi Appalaraju
Dob :01-07-2001, age : 21 , R/o : 8-32/2,Kamparaalam Colony,
Gopalapatnam, Visakhapatnam, AP-530029.
45. Gavara Pavan Kumar, S/o Gavara Kondala Rao
Dob :01-07-1999, Age : 23 , R/o: D No: 1-190/1, Pedanarava,
Pendurthi,Visakhapatnam, Andhrapradesh- 530027.
46. Kosuri Sai Prasanna Kumar, S/o Kouri Srinuvas Rao
Dob :16/05/2002, Age : 20 , R/o 1-42, Salapuvanipalem,
Parawada, Visakhapatnam, Ap-531019.
47. Gite Maroti Vilas, S/o Gite Vilas
Dob :04-06-1999, Age : 23 , R/o D No: At Shellali,
Tq Kandhar Dist Nanded (Maharashtra) 431714.
48. Anakapalli Prasad , S/o Anakapalli Pothu Raju
Dob :14/04/1995, Age : 27 , R/o : D No: Door No: 36-96-72,Ramji Estate,
Kancharapalem, Visakhapatnam, AP- 530008.
49. Gantreti Santhosh, S/o Gantreti Gurumurthy
Dob :22/08/1999, Age : 22 , R/o : D No: 3-16,Mutcherla,
Anandarapuram, Visakhapatnam, AP-531173.
50. Kandregula Sankara Ganga Nookaraju, S/o K Ganga Raju
Dob :10-11-1999, Age : 22 , R/o : 9-146,Near Ramalayam Street,Moolapeta
Village,Thotada,Munagapaka,Vskp.
Page 4 of 24
OAs Nos./021/448/2022,OA/470/2022,OA/487/2022, OA/457/2022, OA/623/2022,
OA/624/2023 & OA/447/2022
51. Pilla Vamsi Chandra Sekhar, S/o Pilla Srinivasa Rao
Dob :11-09-2001, Age : 21 , R/o: 4-14-26, Manual Street , Gnanapuram,
Visakhapatnam, Ap-530004.
52. Billa Lakshman Chaitanya , S/o Billa Lakshmi Narayana
Dob :14-07-2001, Age : 21 , R/o: 4-51, Billalavalasa (Village), Bondapalli
(Mandal), Vizianagaram (Dist), AP-535003.
53. Yeduru Prasad , S/o Yeduru Kunchubabu(Late),Dob :22/05/2001, Age : 20 ,
R/o: 7/1, Sathavanipalem, Jaggayyapalam, Visakhapatnam, AP-530012.
54. Pureddy Ganesh Reddy , S/o Pureddy Ramana Reddy,Dob :08-09-1999,
Age : 22 , R/o : 14-47-6 Pedagantyada, Goduvanepalam,Near Traffic Police
Station, AP, Visakhapatnam, A P 530044.
55. R.Sirisha , D/o R. Mutyalu,Dob :18-01-2001, Age : 21 , R/o : 71-31-116/5,
Malkapuram, Vishakapatnam, A P.
56. Gaidhane Parvesh Jairam, S/o Jairam Gaidhane, Dob :17/4/2000, Age :
22 , R/o: At Post Mohadi (dist) - Bahandra 441909 Maharastra.
57. Meshram Tridip Wedsharma ,S/o Wedsharma Govindaji Meshram
Dob :05-01-1997, Age : 25 , R/o : Sarvadnya xerox And Stationery Siddharth
Nagar Ward Number 4 Durgapur Tadoba Road Tukum
Chandrapur.Maharastra.
58. Walke Shubham Santosh S/o Santosh Walke, Dob :03-10-1998, Age : 24 ,
R/o : At. Mamla ,Mokasa (P), Bordatahsildist-Chandrapur Maharashtra-
441224.
59. Rakesh Gajanan Madavi ,S/o Gajanan Madavi, Dob :23/12/1996, Age : 25 ,
R/o Maralli, Lagam, Mulchera,Gadchiroli, Pin-442709.
60. K Sheshu Kumar S/o K Trinath, Dob :11-08-1999, Age : 23 , R/o : 9-7-462 ,
Md- Lines Tolichowki Hyderabad 500008.
61. Nandavarapu Dhana Lakshmi S/o N Narasinga Rao, Dob :25-05-2000, Age :
22 , R/o : 1-58, Nandavarapuvanipalam, Chintagatla, Sabbavaram,
Visakhapatnam, Ap-531035.
62. Kundrapu Saikiran S/o K.Satyanarayana, Dob :12-06-1999, Age : 23 , R/o
58-22-57/2/7, Srinivasamappartments,Susarla Colony , Baji
Junction,530027,Visakhapatanam
63. Bangari Pavan Kumar S/o Bangari Venkata Rao ,
Dob:05/12/1997, Age:24, R/o : 19-20-6, Rangireeju Street,
Near Head Post office Velampeta,Visakhapatnam 530001.
64. Kasimkota Pavan Kumar, S/o K Appa Rao,
Age 23, Occ: unemployed , R/o MIG 1/35, Simhapuri colony, Vepagunta ,
Visakhapatnam , Mdl Urban -530047.
65. Ganeswar Singh, S/o Sunil Singh DOB 10-2-1999
Age 23 yrs, R/o At post Tasarada , via K.C Pur, PS Betnoti,
Page 5 of 24
OAs Nos./021/448/2022,OA/470/2022,OA/487/2022, OA/457/2022, OA/623/2022,
OA/624/2023 & OA/447/2022
Mayurbhanj, Odisa 757029.
66. Dhaneswar Majhi, S/o Karunakar Majhi,
DOB 13-07-1995, Age 27 yrs, R/o Keshadiha, post Raidiha,
PS Patna, Kendujhar Dist, Odisha- 758016.
67. A Sandhya Rani , D/o A Atchim Naidu, Age ,
R/o D.No 2-184, Near BHPV Teacher's Layout,
Purushattapuram, Pendurhi, Visakhapatnam, AP.
...Applicants
(By Advocate: Smt. Anita Swain)
Vs.
1.The Union of India, Rep by its secretary , Ministry of Defence,
South block New Delhi, 11,0011.
2. The Chief of Naval Staff, Naval Head quarters, South block,
New Delhi, 110011.
3.The Admiral Superintendent, Lions gate,
Naval Dockyard , Mumbai.
4. The Naval Dockyard Apprentices School,
Naval base Visakhapatnam , Visakhapatnam.530014.
...Respondents
(By Advocate: Sri P. Narayana, Sr. PC for CG)
OA/470/2022
1. Janapareddy Srinu,S/o Janapareddy Ramu Naidu, Age:22 years,
Dob; 22/04/2000,Occ: Unemployed, R/o D No 1-5. Narasayyapeta( V)
,Hodavaram( M). Visakhapatnam ( D) AP 531036.
2. Tholi Yerribabu, D/o Tholi Ramana, Age: 26, R/O D.No.3-31 ,
Kivanipalem (V), Kapuluppada (P), Bheemilipatnam (M),
Visakhapatam-AP-531163.
3. Silaparasetty Ajay Kumar, S/o Silaparasetty Venkata Ramana, Age 22 Yrs,
Dob: 16/03/2000,R/o D.No.9-34 , Yellapuvanipalem (V), Chandra Nagar ,
Visakhapatnam , AP.
4. Yetcerla Naveen, S/o Yetcerla Gouruchetti,Age 21 yrs, Dob 29/09/2001,
Occ: unemployed, R/o Railway Colony , Bus stop Back Side ,
Visakhapatnam, AP
5. Bhillana Sowmya, D/o Bhillana Ramu,Age: 23 yrs, Dob:20/06/1999,
R/o ,Indiragandhi Nagar,Old Dairyaform,Visakhapatnam, AP
6. D Girish , S/o D Sreenu, Age 20 yrs, Occ: unempoloyed ,
R/o D.No 58-18-84, APSEB Colony, Butchirajupalem, Ward 67,
Visakhapatnam , AP
7. Kona Jeevan Bala Raju, S/O Kona Maria Das, Age : 22 yrs,
DOB 17=7-2000,Occ: Unemployed , R/O 34-5-2/1, Gedda Street
,Gnanapuram Visakhapatnam, Andhra Pradesh.
8. Kimmoju Hemasai,D/o Kimmoju Durga Prasad,
Page 6 of 24
OAs Nos./021/448/2022,OA/470/2022,OA/487/2022, OA/457/2022, OA/623/2022,
OA/624/2023 & OA/447/2022
Age:20 years, Occ: Unemployed
R/o D.No:56-5-1,Golla Kancherapalem,
Visakhapatnam-530008
9. Patnala Indira,D/o Patnala Sankara Rao
Age:19 yrs, Occ: Unemployed,
R/o D.No: 2-96, Narva Pendhurthy Madal,Visakhapatnam-530027.
10. Karedla Gowri Aparna,D/o Karedla Mahesh
Age:21 yrs, Occ: Unemployed
R/o D.No57-16-25/1,Subash Nagar,Kancherapalem,
Visakhapatnam-530008.
11. Shifa Afreen, D/o Abdul Munaf
Age :23 yrs, Occ:Unemployed
R/o D.No:38-7-7,Masjeed Street,Marripalem,
Visakhapatnam-530018
12. Digumarthi Kranthi Kumar, S/o Digumarthi Prasad Rao
Age:23 yrs, Occ: Unemployed
R/o D.No:38-4-50,Maharani Street,Marripalem,
Visakhapatnam-530018
13. Raparthi Harish,S/o Raparthi Yerri Naidu
Age:23 yrs, Occ: Unemployed
R/o D.No:22-91,Srinivasa Nagar,Simhachalam Road,
Visakhaptnam-530028
14. Upendra Kona,S/o Chinna Rao Kona
Age:22 yrs, Occ:Unemployed
R/o D.No:2-121,Pendhurthy Mandal,Visakhapatnam-531035
15. Karanam Ramunaidu, S/o K China Apparao
Age:23, yrs, Occ:Unemployed
R/o D.No:1-32,Ankapalle District,Viskhapatnam-531032
16. P Dinesh, S/o P Jaldeep, Age:23 yrs,
Occ: Unemployed, R/o D.No: P10/15,Ashoka Park-530008
17. Rowthu Bhargav, S/o Eswar Rao
Age:21 yrs, Occ: Unemployed
R/o D.No:24-20,Kapuveedhi,Narsipatnam,Visakhapatnam
18. Valisetti Raju, S/o Valisetti Joga Rao
Age:22 yrs, Occ:Unemployed
R/o D.No:8-2-385,Pedda Street,Srikakulam,
Visakhapatnam-532263
19. Bheesetti Harika Pydiraju, D/o Bheesetti Vara Prasad
Age:22 yrs, Occ:Unemployed
R/o D.No:35-5-3/1,Gavarakancherapalem,
Visakhapatnam-530008
20. Karangana Tirupathi Rao
S/o Karangana Kurma Rao, Age:23 yrs,
Occ:Unemployed,R/o D.No:19-24-36,
Pedda Gantyada ,Visakhapatnam.
Page 7 of 24
OAs Nos./021/448/2022,OA/470/2022,OA/487/2022, OA/457/2022, OA/623/2022,
OA/624/2023 & OA/447/2022
21. G Y V Durga Prasad, S/o Gude Kumar, Age:,
DOB 24-10-2021, Occ: unemployed, R/o 20-4/2-52,
Arunodhaya nagar,New Rajarajeswari peta,
Vijayawada, krishna,AP 520001
22. Karukonda Mohan Krishna , S/o Karukonda SomuNaidu ,
Age:-22 , Occ: Unemployed, R/o 36-94-13,
Kancharapalem Bapuji Nagar Ward no 37
Vishakapatnam(Ruban) , Kancharapalem ,
Vishkapatnam Andhra Pradesh, Pin - 530008 .
23. Talla Santhosh , S/o Talla Srinivas , Age:-26 yrs,
Occ: Unemployed , R/o H.no:12-8-275-13/A , Alugadabavi ,
Mettuguda , Secunderabad , Hyderabad , Telangana , Pin:500017
24. Kanumuri Gnana Adithya Tarun ,S/o K Raju, Age:-20 ,
Occ: Unemployed, H.no:6-13-8/1 , Drivers colony,
Lbs nagar, Old Gajuwaka , Vishakapatnam,
Andhrapradesh- 530026.
25. Bathina Mahesh , S/o Bathina Apparao , Age:-22 yrs,
Occ: Unemployed, Address : Medicharla(V), Kotapadu(M), Vishakapatnam
(D) Andhrapradesh , Pin - 531034.
26. Ellapu Gopi , S/o Ellapu Apparao , Age:-19 yrs,
Occ: Unemployed, H.no: 1-128 , Peda Narava(V& P) ,
Pendhurthi(M) , Vishakapatnam , Andhrapradesh ,Pin -530027.
27. Madugula Somashekar , S/o Madugula Sanyasirao , Age:-22 ,
Occ:Unemployed , R/o H.no:9-146, Pedamadaka ,
Near Ramalayam , Vishakapatnam , AP -530026.
28. Deshmukh Vaibhav Janrao , S/o Janrao , Age:-22 yrs,
Occ:Unemployed , R/o Sauji nagar Malkapur (D) ,
Buldhana Maharashtra Pin:443101 . (Presently residing
at R/o H.no:12-8-275-11,Alugadabavi , Secunderabad. , Pin:500017
29. Pandurang Govind Padit, S/o Govind. Pandu Padti ,
Age:-22 Yrs, Occ: Unemployed ,R/o H.no:#259 ,
Karwar Todur Uttara Kannada , Karnataka , Pin:581324.
(Presently residing at R/o H.no:12-8-275-11,
Alugadabavi , Secunderabad. , Pin:500017
30. Zeenath Abulhasan Mulla, D/o Abulhasan Mulla,
Age:-22 , Occ:Unemployed , Address :75 Jooga ,
Sagadageri Gargone Ankola Karnataka , Pin:581319
Presently residing R/o H.no 12-8-275/13/A1, Alugadabavi ,
Mettuguda , Secunderabad , Telangana , Pin: 500017.
31. Shinde Nikhil Arun , S/o Arun Dattu Shinde , Age:- 22 yrs,
Occ:Unemployed ,R/o :Ap/Chindhecha , Malshirsar ,Akluj ,
Solapur , Maharashtra ,Pin:413108. Presently residing at
H.no:12-8-275/11, Alugadabavi , Secunderabad ,
Telangana , Pin:500017.
32. Balaji R A , S/o Ananda V, Age 23 yrs, Occ: unemployed ,
R/o:No15 3rd Main road Last House Near Hasini Meadows
Apt Vinayakanagar Banglore Pin:560063 , presently residing at .
R/o H.no.12-8-275/13/A/1 , Alugadabavi , Secunderabad ,
Telanagana , Pin:500017.
Page 8 of 24
OAs Nos./021/448/2022,OA/470/2022,OA/487/2022, OA/457/2022, OA/623/2022,
OA/624/2023 & OA/447/2022
33.Chintada Jogeswararao, S/o Chintada Seetarammurthy
Age 26 yrs, DOB: 26-11-1996,Age : 26 ,
R/o D No 4-4 Harijana Colony,
Borubhadra ( V & P) Santabommali (M),
Srikakulam (D)AP-532195
34.Bariti Aravind ,S/o Bariti Ramu
Age 21 yrs, DOB: 10-06-2001,Occ: unemployed ,
R/o D No 000 Colony, Borubhadra ( V & P)
Santabommali (M),Srikakulam (D)AP-532195.
35. Latha Kumari Madisa, D/o Nooka Raju M
Age 21 Yrs, Occ: Unemployed , R/o H No 31-52-20
Yadavajaggaraju Peta,Gajuwaka Mandlam
Near Church Street,Vadlapudi Post
Visakhapatnam, Andhra Pradesh -530046.
36. Yenugula Shivaji ,S/o Y Appalaraju
Age 24 Yrs, Occ: Unemployed , R/o 58.28.28/7
Gandhinagar, Butchirajupaleam
Gopalapatnam, Visakhapatnam,AP.530027
........Applicants
(By Advocate: Smt. Anita Swain)
Vs.
1.The Union of India,
Rep by its secretary , Ministry of Defence,
South block New Delhi, 11,0011.
2. The Chief of Naval Staff,
Naval Head quarters, South block,
New Delhi, 110011.
3.The Admiral Superintendent,
Shahid Bhagat Singh Rd, Fort, Lions gate,
Naval Dockyard , Mumbai, Maharashtra 400001, .
4.The Officer-in-Charge (DASV)
Admiral Superintendent
Naval Dockyard Apprentices School,
Naval base Visakhapatnam
Visakhapatnam.530014.
5. The Officer-In -Charge (DAS(K),
Admiral Superintendent ,
Dockyard Apprentices School ,
Naval Ship Repair Yard , Naval Base,
Karwar, Maharashtra 400023.
6. The Officer-In -Charge,(DAS(K)
Admiral Superintendent,
Dockyard Apprentices School
Naval Ship Repair Yard,
Naval Base, Kochi - 682 004 .
.....Respondents
(By Advocate: Sri P. Naveen Kumar, Addl. CGSC)
Page 9 of 24
OAs Nos./021/448/2022,OA/470/2022,OA/487/2022, OA/457/2022, OA/623/2022,
OA/624/2023 & OA/447/2022
OA/447/2022
1.Manchala Jyoth Gopal, S/o:Manchala Eswararao
Age:-20 years, Occ: Unemployed, R/o- 5-95 Narava Pendurthi
Visakhapatnam,Andhara Pradesh,Pin: 530027
2.Yanapu Jagadeesh
S/o Yanapu Koti , Age 21 years ,Occ: Unemployed
R/o: H. No: 4-41 Narava Pendurthi ,
Visakhaptnam Andhra Pradesh,Pin No :530027
3. Aarisetti Dileep,S/O: Aarisetti Kameswararao, Age:-23
Occ: Unemployed,R/o: D No 1-48
Jerripothulapalam Vallage Chithagatla Post ,
Pendurthi Md Visakhapatnam Andhra Pradesh-531035
4.Savadana Vijay Kumar ,S/O S. Simhachalam
Age:- 21 years, Occ: Unemployed
R/o: 65-3-170, Hanuman Nagar Colony, Malkapuram (Post),
Visakhapatnam-530011, Andhra Pradesh.
5.Botta Santhosh Kumar ,S/o:Botta Pydiraju
Age:23 yrs, ,Occ: Unemployed,R/o:6-88 Sathivanipalem
Jaggayyapalem Post BHPV Via Visakhapatnam Andhra Pradesh 530012.
6.Koribilli Tarun, S/o:Koribilli Sundara Rao
Age:24 years, Occ:Unemployed
R/o: D.No: 1-56 Gavarapalem (V) ,Gorapalle(P) ,Pendurthi (M),
Visakhapatnam (D) Andhrapradesh,Pin Code,531173
7.Jerripothula Durga Prasad, S/o Jerripothula Nagswra Rao
Age:20 years, Occ:Unemployed
R/o : D. No4-63 Narava (V) Post,Pendhurthi Mandalam,
Viskhapatnam, Andhrapradesh,Pin:530027
8.Uppili Venkata Apparao, S/o: Uppili Satti Babu
Age 23 years, Occ : Unemployed
R/o:54,Sathivanipalem,Pendurthi Visakhapatnam
Andhara Pradesh,Pin:530012
9.Chadaram Prudhvi ,S/o: Chadaram Polayya Naidu ;,
Age:24 years, Occ:Unemployed
R/o 10-99, Gavarapeta Street, Thummapala Village,
Anakapalli Mandal, Visakhapatnam Andhra Pradesh, 531032
10.Salapu Sunil, S/o Salapu Suribabu
Age :20 years, Occ: Unemployed
R/o: Dr No: 1-76 Jerripotulapalem Village
Pendurthi Mandal,Visakhapatnam ,Andhra Pradesh-35
11.Ketha Venkata Shiva ,S/o Ketha Apparao,
Age:21 yrs, Occ: Unemployed
R/o:Door No:18-28-3, Balacheruvu, Pedagantyada,
21 Sivalayam Backside, 3rd Line,
Visakhapatnam, Andhra Pradesh- 530044
12.Gavara Naveen, S/o:-Gavara Nageswararao
Age: 22 yrs. Occ : Unemployed
R/o: H.No 4-44 Narava Pendurthi
Visakhapatnam.Andhra Pradesh -530027.
Page 10 of 24
OAs Nos./021/448/2022,OA/470/2022,OA/487/2022, OA/457/2022, OA/623/2022,
OA/624/2023 & OA/447/2022
13.Gavara Srinu, S/o : Gavara Lakshmana
Age : 22 yrs, Occ : Unemployed
R/o D.No :- 2-116 Narava (V) Pendurthi (M)
Visakhapatnam, Andhra Pradesh - 530027
14.Chinni Harish, S/o: Chinni Apparao ,
Age:23 Yrs,Occ:Unemployed
R/o:Door No : 9-58 Sathivanipalam (Village)
Jaggayyapalam(Post),Pendurthi (M),
Visakhapatnam Andhra Pradesh, 530012
15.Kadupukutla Appala Naidu,S/o: Kadupukutla Gangu Naidu ,
Age : 21 Yrs, Occ : Unemployed
R/o: Pedanandipalli Village , Deverapalli Mandal,
Visakhapatnam, Andhra Pradesh,Pin : 531030
16.Jerripotula Devi Vara Prasad, S/o Jerripotula Appala Naidu
Age : 22 Yrs, Occ : Unemployed
R/o : D.No : 1-243/1 Narava (V) Pendurthi (M)
Visakhapatnam,Andhra Pradesh 530027
17.Aluguji Lokesh,S/o:Aluguji Eswar Rao
Age:22 years, Occ: Unemployed
R/o- Do No :-6-38-12/6/2 Street No 7 LV Nagar,
Chinagantyada Old Gajuwaka Visakhapatnam,A.P-530026 Gajuwaka
Visakhapatnam,A.P-530026.
.....Applicants
(By Advocate: Smt. Anita Swain)
Vs
1.The Union of India,
Rep by its secretary , Ministry of Defence,
South block New Delhi, 11,0011.
2. The Chief of Naval Staff,
Naval Head quarters, South block,
New Delhi, 110011.
3. The Admiral Superintendent,
Shahid Bhagat Singh Rd, Fort, Lions gate,
Naval Dockyard , Mumbai, Maharashtra 400001, .
4. The Officer-in -caharge ,
The Naval Dockyard Apprentices School,
Naval Dockyard, Mumbai, Maharastra 400023
......... Respondents
(By Advocate: Sri A. Nageswara Rao, Sr. PC for CG)
OA/624/2023
1. Marubaka Balaram, Registration No 529802
S/o M Eswar Rao, Age ... yrs,
DoB: 11/12/1997, Occ: unemployed
R/o Asivani palem, Visakhapatnam,
Visakhapatnam Urban,Andhra Pradesh, 530008
2. Betha Lokesh Likith, 494280
S/o Late B Varaha Venkata Satyanarayana
DoB: 19/02/2002, Age
Address: Ramnagar,Opp. Yarada Park,
Page 11 of 24
OAs Nos./021/448/2022,OA/470/2022,OA/487/2022, OA/457/2022, OA/623/2022,
OA/624/2023 & OA/447/2022
Sriharipuram, Visakhapatnam, Andhra Pradesh,530011.
3. Dasari Vamsi Durga 389966
S/o D Tirupathi Rao, Age.... Yrs,DoB: 28/12/1999, Occ: unemployed
R/o Dno:22-23/1,Ganesh colony,Srinivasnagar,
Simhachalam road Visakhapatnam, Visakhapatnam,
Andhra Pradesh, 530028.
4. SIVERI DEVA RAJU, Registration No 477093
S/o SIVERI RAJU, Age : 26 yrs,
DOB:- 25-06-1996 , Occ unemployed
R/o 2-53,Battivalasa village, Madala post,
Arakuvalley mandalam, Visakhapatnam district
Pin code:531149
5. SHAIK ABDUL KHADAR, R.No. 476977
S/o SHAIK KASIM, Age 21 yrs, Occ: unemployed
DOB:- 06-02-2001, R/o 16-230, operation
Colony, Arilova colony, Visakhapatnam, 530040.
6. Mamidi. Swathi, R.No 569104
S/o Mamidi Srinivasa Rao
Age : 22 yrs, DOB : 05-12-1999
R/o D.No. 71-31-1655/A, Kakarlova, Gandhigram
Post Visakhapatnam -530005
7. Vakapalli Sirisha Rani, R.No 517616
D/o V Prem Kumar,Age.21 yrs, DOB. 25-04-2001,
Occ: unemployed, R/o Revathi -01,Meghadripeta colony
Kancharaaplem-PO, Visakhapatnam -530008
8. NOTLA TEJA SHREE , R.No. 508959
D/o NOTLA RAMU Age: 20 yrs, DOB:- 14-10-2001
R/o Sakethapuram, , Near Air Port,Visakhapatnam- 530009
9. Karri.Dharani R. No 351722
D/o Karri. Phani Kumar, Age : 21
DOB : 19/08/2000, R/o 57-27-49; Old ITI junction
Sriramnagar near Nucambika temple Visakhapatnam
Pin : 530007.
10.Arabinda Beheruk, R. No 552587
S/o Krushna Beheruk, Age 23 yrs, DOB21-4-1999,
Occ: unemployed,R/o Kamalpur,Po-Athagadapatna,
PS-Kabisurjyanagar Ganjam,Odisha,761105.
11. Gokarla Shivaji R. Id No 557023
S/o Gokarla Rajarao, Age 23 Yrs, 15-05-1999
Occ: Unemployed , R/o 1-95, Peddaveadi
Bellupada (Vill),Kanchili (Md),Srikakulam(Dist)
A.P -532291.
12: Ayush Pradhan , R.ID No 572014
S/o Bhagaban Pradhan
Age : 20 yrs, DOB : 23/01/2002
R/o Dr.no.64-5-5, Ram Nagar , Sriharipuram,
Visakhapatnam,Andhra Pradesh, 530011
13 NANIPALLI PRASAD, ID No 583240,
S/o NANIPALLI APPARAO, Age.22 yrs,
DOB 03-05-2000, Occ Unemployed,
Page 12 of 24
OAs Nos./021/448/2022,OA/470/2022,OA/487/2022, OA/457/2022, OA/623/2022,
OA/624/2023 & OA/447/2022
R/o 1-136a Chittiyyapalem ( village), Butchayyapeta (mandal)
Visakhapatnam (district)531026, A.P.
14. Bhutanadhu Anil Dora , Id No 292947
S/o Bhutanadhu Venkata Ramana
Age: 20 Yrs, Dob: 15-06-2002, R/O D.No: 3-73,
Peda Veedhi, Near Ramyalam Laxmi Puram,
Chodavaram , Visakhapatnam ,AP- 531036.
15. Madagala Sravani Kumari, I D No 354831,
D/o Madagala Srinivas Rao
Age: 22 yrs, Dob: 19/11/2000,Occ: unemployed ,
R/o 14.5-1/4 , Banoji Thota
'BC Road, New Gajuwaka,Visakhapatnam
Visakhapatnam,Andhra Pradesh 530026
16. Palivela John , I. D No 409930
D/o Palivela Chilakarao
Age: 23 Yrs , Dob:- 20-08-1999
R/o 15-03-21, Gangavaram, Pedagantyadha,
Vishakapatnam : 530044.
17. Klllo Seethamma, A. No.:550598
D/o Killo Gasiram , Age : 22 Yrs, Dob 16-8-2000
Occ; Unemployed , R/o Makavaram
Makavaram Post,Munchangiput Mandalam
Visakhapatnam, Andhra Pradesh 531040.
18. Gantyada Pavani , Appl. No 572015
D/o Gantyada Gopalam Age 21 Yrs, Dob 27-07-2000
R/o 58-28-9/1/1, Butchiraju Palem, Gopalalapatnam Post
Visakhapatnam- 530027, Andhra Pradesh.
19 Gorle Kumar , Appl. No 503157
S/o Gorle Bangarunaidu, Age 23 Yrs, Dob :-04/06/1999
R/o Door No :: 5-14 BC Colony Ballanki (Village)
Vepada (Mandal) Vizianagaram (D) AP :535281.
20. Ommi Gopi , Appl.No 527942,
S/o Ommi Suri Babu, Age 23 Yrs, 20-10-1999
Occ: Unemployed , R/o 7-24 Sathivanipalem Village
Jaggayyapalem Post Bhpv Via
Pendurthi Mandalam,Visakhapatnam
Visakhapatnam,Andhra Pradesh 530012.
21.Uppili Satish, Appl. No 555604 , S/o Uppili Chinna Rao .
Age 23 Yrs, Occ: Unemployed , R/o 2-1-1999
7-24 Sathivanipalem Village, Jaggayyapalem Post Bhpv Via
Pendurthi Mandalam, Visakhapatnam, Andhra Pradesh 530012
22. Konathala Teja, Appl. No 483289
S/o Konathala Narasinga Rao
Age : 24yrs, Dob 25/06/1999
R/o D.No: 5-9-17/3, Lakshmi Devi Peta
Near Ramalayam Temple, Anakapalli, AP.
23. Alla Tejeswararao Appl. No 460849
S/o A.surya Narayana Age : 23
DOB : 12/07/1999, R/o D. No 1-26 Telaga Veedhi Muddada(V)
Srikakulam(D)Andhra Pradesh Pin code : 532005.
Page 13 of 24
OAs Nos./021/448/2022,OA/470/2022,OA/487/2022, OA/457/2022, OA/623/2022,
OA/624/2023 & OA/447/2022
24. Chinnala Krishna Sai , Appl. No 478690
S/O Chinnala Janardhana Rao
Age: 21,Dob: 29-10-2000
D.No:5-3,Tulasipeta Village, Kotabommali ,
Chittivalasa , Srikakulam, Ap-532430
25.Kandregula Rajesh , Appl. No 579822,
S/o Kandregula Koorma, Age 23 yrs, R/o,
20-1-64 Demuni Thota, Gavarapalem,Anakapalli,
Visakhapatnam -531002.
26 Pyla Sanyasi Naidu 579136
S/o Pyla Trinadharao
R/o - 2-6 , Ramannapalem Vi ,
Bb Palem Post , Makavarapalem ,
Visakhapatnam District ,531113
27. Madhusmita Jena, Appl. No No.:507135
D/o Supath Jena , Age 22 Yrs, 15-10-2000, Occ: Unemployed ,
R/o Pushyami -09,,Meghadripeta Defence Civilian Colony,
Near Sbi Atm,Kancharapalem,Visakhapatnam
Andhra Pradesh 530008.
28. Gali Venumadhavi, 212550, D/o Gali Srinivasa Rao,
Age 21 yrs, DOB 4-2-2001 , R/o D.No 4-207,
Surya Ratna Colony, Porlu, Palem, Water Tank , Visakhapatnam
29. Karri Janakiramudu, Appl. No 533373
Karri Nageshwara Rao
Age 22 yrs, DOB:-17-07-2000
R/o 14/119 Kobbari Thota street, Madugula,
Visakhapatnam Andhra Pradesh,Pin 531027
30. Chhatish Chandra Mohanta, 536701,
S/o Bisheswar Mohanta , Age 21 yrs, Occ: unemployed ,
R/o Saria(V&P) VIA-B Sathili, Baripada ,
Mayurbhanj, Odisha-757100.
Presently residing at Visakhapatnam
Andhra Pradesh,
31. Satyabrata Sethi , 561211
S/o Birendra Sethi Age :- 22 yrs ,DOB 15.01.2000 ,
R/o Angargadia , Po-Kuchei Ps-Kuliana ,
Dist- Mayurbhanj, Odissa -Pin-757105
32. Partha Sarathi Barik, 538130
S/o Sambhunath Barik,Age 22 yrs, DOB 10.01.2001
R/o At/po-Podasul, ps/via- Nilgiri.
Dist- Balasore,Odissa Pin- 756040.
33. Rajat Kimar Dhal, Appl.No 560696
S/O Rajkumar Dhal Age- 21 , Dob- 16,06,2001,
R/o Baura, Po. Ps. Morada, Dist.
Mayurbhanj, State Odisha, Pin.757018, Presently
residing at Visakhapatnam
34 . V Kusumanjali, Appl. No 512612
Page 14 of 24
OAs Nos./021/448/2022,OA/470/2022,OA/487/2022, OA/457/2022, OA/623/2022,
OA/624/2023 & OA/447/2022
S/o V Srinivas, Age : 21
DOB 13/12/2000, R/o 37-2-8/1 , Sankurupeta ,
I T I junction , Kancharapalem , Visakhapatnam , A P 530008.
35. Prasad Mohanta , Appl. No 565749,
S/o Trilochan Mohanta , Age 22 Yrs, 12-2-2000,
R/oat/Po-Anua, Via-Chitrada Ps-Morada PCM High School,
Anua Baripada Mayurbhanj Odisha 757018
36. Amarapalli Jagadeesh , Appl. No 484293
S/o Amarapalli Ramana , Age:22+ yrs,
DOB 12/12/1999,R/o :3-27 near nookambica temple, SC Colony
Bovuluvada village ,Anakapalli mandal, visakaha dist
37. Pawar Mayur Kailassing Appl. No 582571,
S/o Pawar Mayur Kailassing, Age 20 Yrs,
DOB 25 /10/2001, R/o Post. Nadgaon.
Tahsil. Bodwad. Dist. Jalgaon.Maharashtra 425310.
38. Chintala Arjun Appl. No 507184
S/O Chintala Jatlayya
21 Yrs, Age: Dob : 02-07-2001
R/O H.No 5-55,Bc Colony,Lankelapalem,
Paravada (M), Visakhapatnam , Ap, 531019
39. :Saminga Murali Krishna Appl. No. 485094,
S/o Saminga Srinu, Age 22 yrs, ,DOB 10- 06-2000
R/o Simhadripuram (V), Juttada (P) , D.No 1-13
Visakhapatnam (District), 531023
40. Shaik Mehabub, App No 546895
S/o Shaik Sardhar , Age 21 yrs, DOB:- 26/08/2001
Occ: unemployed , R/o D. No 20-220 Surya Nagar,
Kothapalem Gopalpatnam ,Visakhapatnam.
41. Kotyada Sai, Appl No 499878
S/o Laxshmana Rao, Age 20 yrs
DOB:-22-08-1999, R/o 21-67/1 Gollanarayanapuram
near ZP school Simhadhri Hospital down
Visakhapatnam A P- 530027
42. Terapalli Rohith Ravi Teja,Appl No 283861,
S/o T.Vinodh kumar, Age 25yrs, DOB: 15/07/1997,
Occ:unemployed Address: Sidhardha Nagar,
old ITI junction, Kancharpalem,
Visakhapatnam, A P, 530007 .
.... Applicants
(By Advocate: Smt. Anita Swain)
Vs
1.The Union of India,
Rep by its secretary , Ministry of Defence,
South block New Delhi, 11,0011.
2. The Chief of Naval Staff,
Naval Head quarters, South block,
New Delhi, 110011.
3.The Admiral Superintendent,
Shahid Bhagat Singh Rd, Fort, Lions gate,
Naval Dockyard , Mumbai, Maharashtra 400001.
Page 15 of 24
OAs Nos./021/448/2022,OA/470/2022,OA/487/2022, OA/457/2022, OA/623/2022,
OA/624/2023 & OA/447/2022
4.The Officer-in-Charge (DASV)
Admiral Superintendent
Naval Dockyard Apprentices School,
Naval base Visakhapatnam 530014 .
... Respondents.
(By Advocate: Sri M. Brahma Reddy, Sr. PC for CG)
OA/487/2022
1. Gavara Ravi Kiran, Registration No 483175 ,
S/o Gavara Jaya Prasad Rao , Age 25 yrs, Occ: unemployed ,
R/o D . No 3-222, Narava(V&P), Pendurthi (M) ,
Visakhapatnam-AP 8108256106,
2. KimuduPoorna Venkata, Registration No 419711,
S/o K Narayana , Age 29 yrs, Occ: Unemployed ,
R/o D.No 39-33-148/2, LIG-85, Phase -2,
Madhavadhara VUDA colony,(Street)
Near Vinayaka Temple Road, Visakhapatnam , 530018,
3. Bandaru Chandra Sekhar, 546174
S/o B Durga Prasad, age 21 yrs, Occ: unemployed,
R/o D No 11-4-77, Vulli Street, Near Kalla Naidu Mandiram(M),
Vizainagaram, 535001, AP.
.....Applicants
(By Advocate: Smt. Anita Swain)
Vs
1.The Union of India,
Rep by its secretary , Ministry of Defence,
South block New Delhi, 11,0011.
2. The Chief of Naval Staff,
Naval Head quarters, South block,
New Delhi, 110011.
3.The Admiral Superintendent,
Shahid Bhagat Singh Rd, Fort, Lions gate,
Naval Dockyard , Mumbai, Maharashtra 400001, .
4.The Officer-in-Charge (DASV)
Admiral Superintendent
Naval Dockyard Apprentices School,
Naval base Visakhapatnam
Visakhapatnam.530014.
5. The Officer-in -charge ,
The Naval Dockyard Apprentices School,
Naval Dockyard, Mumbai, Maharastra 400023.
... Respondents
(By Advocate: Sri M. Mohan Rao, Addl. CGSC)
OA/457/2022
(1) Tirimireddy Naresh, S/o Tirimireddy Ramu,
Age:22,Occ:Unemployed,R/o 6-68-10/4.
R/o KunchumambaColony,HanumanTemple,
Page 16 of 24
OAs Nos./021/448/2022,OA/470/2022,OA/487/2022, OA/457/2022, OA/623/2022,
OA/624/2023 & OA/447/2022
Old Gajuwaka, Visakhapatnam, AndhraPradesh 530026.
(2) BadeNaveen,S/oBadeNookaraju,
Age 24, Occ: Unemployed ,
R/o13298,MangamariPeta,K Nagrapalem,
Bheemunipatnam, Visakhapatnam,Andhra Pradesh-531163.
........Applicants
(By Advocate: Smt. Anita Swain)
Vs
1.The Union of India,
Rep by its secretary , Ministry of Defence,
South block New Delhi, 11,0011.
2. The Chief of Naval Staff,
Naval Head quarters, South block,
New Delhi, 110011.
3.The Admiral Superintendent,
Shahid Bhagat Singh Rd, Fort, Lions gate,
Naval Dockyard , Mumbai, Maharashtra 400001, .
4. The Officer-in -caharge ,
The Naval Dockyard Apprentices School,
Naval Dockyard, Mumbai, Maharastra 400023.
5. The Controller of Examination,
For Director General of Training-1
Government of India , Ministry of Skill Development
and Entrepreneurship . 2nd Floor, Annexe Building Shivaji Stadium,
Shaheed Bhagat Singh Marg, Connaught Place, New Delhi, Delhi 110001 .
... Respondents
(By Advocate: Smt. B. Gayatri Varma, Sr. CGSC)
OA/623/2023
1. Bharinikam Mukunda Trinadh, Appl no:580808,
S/o Bharinikam Venkata Raja,Age 21 years, DOB 23/7/2001.
Occ:Unemployed, R/o Sig nagar,old Dairy Farm,Ramalayam
street,Visakhapatnam, 530040.
2. Mummana.Nithin, Appl No. 559483
S/o M .Ramana, Age 20yrs,Dob .13/07/2002
Occ: Unemployed, R/o D No.2-140, Kothapalem ,
Gopalapatnam, Visakhapatnam,530027
3. Jana Hemanthkumar, Appl no:580386 ,
S/o Jana Appalasuri, Age:23 years,
Dob:14/06/1999 Occ: unemployed
R/o Maddi (V&P) Padmanabham (M)
Visakhapatnam (D),531219.
4. G Narendra ,Appl. No 119810
Kanaka Raju ,Age 23 yrs , DOB 5/4/1999,
R/o 11/77 Pedha Narava Near Ramalayam ,
Visakhapatnam Andhra Pradesh,530027.
5. Pureddy Mahesh Appl No: 517576
S/o Ravi Kumar Age:23Years Dob: 03/10/1999
Occ : Unemployee, R/o D.No: 5-191/1, Sc&Bc colony ,
Venkatapuram, Gopalaptnam, Visakhapatnam, Andhra Pradesh -530029.
Page 17 of 24
OAs Nos./021/448/2022,OA/470/2022,OA/487/2022, OA/457/2022, OA/623/2022,
OA/624/2023 & OA/447/2022
6. Rongali Mutyalu Naidu Appl No:489850, S/o Demudu Babu Age:23Years
Dob: 19/06/1999 , Occ : Unemployee, R/o D.No: 3-17,K Gullepalli(Vill)
K Kotapadu(MD),Visakhapatnam ,Andhra Pradesh -531034.
7. Polimera Ganesh Appl No:557948, S/o P. Apparao Age:23Years Dob:
14/07/1999,Occ : Unemployee, R/o D.No: Veerabadrapuram (Vill),
Kothavalasa(MD),Vizianagaram ,Andhra Pradesh -535183
8. Ballanki Mohan Appl No:494485,S/o Bala Satya Narayana Age:20Years
Dob: 10/07/2002
Occ : Unemployee, R/o D.No: 9/40/105,Nammivanipeta
Colony,Thagrapuvalasa, Bheemunipatnam(MD),Visakhapatnam ,
Andhra Pradesh -531162
9. Boribori Mohanrao, Appl. No:513639
S/o Boribori Latchanna, Age 23 Yrears, DOB: 05/01/1998
R/o Bodiput(V)Munchangiput (M)
Vanabasing (Post), Visakhapatnam (District)A.P-531040
10. Yerupalli Vamsi Krishna,App. No :541654,
S/o Yerupalli Krishna, Age: 22, Dob: 12/06/1999,
Occ:Unemployed, R/o 64-4-13/2,Ramnagar Colony,
Sriharipuram,Malkapuram (M)Visakhapatnam,530011.
11. T.Shyam Babu Application No:-580349
S/o T.Srinivasa Rao, Age:-23 yrs, Dob:-31/08/1999
R/o 12-2-35/12(3) ,Parasurampeta ,Near Sarada Bridge
Anakapalle ,Visakhapatnam ,Andhra Pradesh 531001.
12. K. Sagar, Registration No: 560075,
S/o K. Venkateswara Rao, Age 21yrs, DoB: 27/01/2001,
Occ: unemployed Address: Siddardha nagar, Burma colony, RO water
plant, Visakhapatnam, Andhra Pradesh, 530007
13. Ommi Lalu Vardhan , Application No : 558549
S/o Ommi Pydi Raju,Age 22 Yrs, Dob 28/09/1999
R/o Sathivanipalem (V) Jaggayyapalem (P),
Pendurthi (M) Visakhapatnam (D) Pin 530012
14. Sarwasiddi Murali, Application Id: 548535
S/o Sarwasiddi Appala Raju, Age 21 yrs, Dob:16/06/2001
R/o D No: 1-234,Vedullanarava, Sabbavaram,
Visakhapatnam, A P, Pin No.530049
15. Allu Bala Murali Krishna, Application No : 516760
S/o Allu Simhachalam,Age : 22,Dob : 11/08/1999
R/o D No:1-190,Vedullanarava (V & P),BC Colony,Duvvada SO
Sabbavaram (M),Visakhapatnam,A P 530049.
16. Sarvasiddi Shiva, Application Id No : 138147
S/o Sarvasiddi Appa Rao, Age 22 yrs, DOB 25/04/2000
R/o 1-242,Vedullanarava,BC Colony,Sabbavaram,
Visakhapatnam,A P - 530049.
17. Yeduru Ravi Teja, Application No:571652
S/o Yeduru Suri Babu ,Age: 22 yrs, Dob: 26/10/2000,
R/o Sathivanipalem, Jaggayyapalem (P), Pendurthi (M),
Visakhapatnam, AP 530012.
Page 18 of 24
OAs Nos./021/448/2022,OA/470/2022,OA/487/2022, OA/457/2022, OA/623/2022,
OA/624/2023 & OA/447/2022
18. Nambaru Jagadeesh Durga Prasad Appl. No 479735
Nambaru Eswara Rao, Age 22 yrs, DOB 29/03/2000
R/o D-No 1_55 Venkannapalem Govada (P) Chodavaram (M)
Visakhapatnam District,A P-531023.
19. Ganthakoru Rakesh ,Application Id No:458570
S/o Ganthakoru Mahalakshmi, Age:20 yrs, Dob:09/04/2002
R/o D No-1-77 Narava Narava( P)
Pendurthi (M), Visakhapatnam 530027.
20. Botcha Chandu, Appl. ID 484187
S/o Botcha Lakshmana Rao, Age:22 yrs ,Dob:-19/06/2000
R/o D.No:1-15a-1,Bonkuladibba Street, Paravada (V& Post, M)
Visakhapatnam 531021.
21. Budireddi Durgaprasad, Application Id No : 498655
S/o Budireddi Mutyala Rao, Age : 19 yrs, Dob : 12/07/2003
R/o Narava Pendurthi Mandalam Narava,Vishakapatnam
Andhra Pradesh - 530027.
22. Tule Sricharan, Application Id No :537689
S/oTULE JANAKIRAMAYYA , Age : 21 yrs, Dob : 21/05/2001
R/oDoor No. 11-216 ,Pedda Jalari Street,Sompeta - 532284
Srikakulam District,Andhra Pradesh.
23. Mungara Simon, Application Id No :550933
S/o Mungara Govinda Rao , Age : 20 yrs, Dob : 31/10/2001
R/o Door No. 44-8-12/1 Reddi Veedhi, Thatichetlapalem,
Visakhapatnam Andhra Pradesh : 53001
24. Dibya Ranjan Nayak, Application Id No : 513276
S/oSurendra Ku.Nayak, Age : 20 yrs, Dob : 31/3/2002
R/o Bhanjanagar, Main Road,Baunsalundi,
Ganjam,Odissa-761126
Presently residing at .No 64-24-54/C, Kunchamma Colony ,
Gullapalem , Sriharipuram, Malkapur , Visakhapatnam (Urban) A.P - 530011.
.....Applicants
(By Advocate: Smt. Anita Swain)
Vs
1.The Union of India,
Rep by its secretary , Ministry of Defence,
South block New Delhi, 11,0011.
2. The Chief of Naval Staff,
Naval Head quarters, South block,
New Delhi, 110011.
3.The Admiral Superintendent,
Shahid Bhagat Singh Rd, Fort, Lions gate,
Naval Dockyard , Mumbai, Maharashtra 400001, .
4.The Officer-in-Charge (DASV)
Admiral Superintendent
Naval Dockyard Apprentices School, Naval base, Visakhapatnam.530014 .
5. The Office-In-Charge, (DAS(K), Admiral Superintendent,
Dockyard Apprentices school Naval Ship Repair Yard,
Naval Base, Kochi -682 004.
Page 19 of 24
OAs Nos./021/448/2022,OA/470/2022,OA/487/2022, OA/457/2022, OA/623/2022,
OA/624/2023 & OA/447/2022
... Respondents
(By Advocate: Sri P. Naveen Kumar, Addl. CGSC)
--------
Page 20 of 24
OAs Nos./021/448/2022,OA/470/2022,OA/487/2022, OA/457/2022, OA/623/2022,
OA/624/2023 & OA/447/2022
COMMON ORDER (ORAL)
(As per Hon'ble Dr. Lata Baswaraj Patne, Judicial Member) As the issue involved in all the OAs is one and the same, these OAs were heard together and a common order is being passed.
As requested by the learned counsel for applicants, OA/448/2022 is taken up as a lead case and pleadings in the said OA are referred to.
By this OA/448/2022, applicant sought the following relief:
"......to call for the records after examining the same declare the action of the 3rd respondent rejecting the applicant's candidature as ineligible to participate in the selection process for the post of Tradesman skilled on the ground "NAC certificate having done apprentices from Naval yard is not attached" vide notification No.3/2022 dated 30.06.2022 as highly illegal and arbitrary and violative of article 14 and 21 of the constitution of India and contrary to the notification clause No.5, apart from violation of principle of natural justice, hence set aside the ineligibility of applicants in the list issued vide notification No.3/2022 dated 30.06.2022 of 3rd respondent and consequently direct the respondent No.3 to consider the candidatures of applicants for the post of Tradesman skilled by allowing them to participate in the written examination by issuing the admit card/Hall ticket to appear for examination going to held on 31.07.2022 on par with other candidates by accepting their NAC certificate issued by Director General of Training on 21.06.2022 and pass such other order or orders as this Hon'ble Tribunal may deem fit and proper in the circumstances of the case in the interest of justice."
2. The brief facts of the case are that the applicants were Ex-naval apprentices of Naval apprentices school Visakhapatnam and belongs to 2020- 2021 batch. After selection as apprentices, the training started from 1.4.2020, but due to Covid pandemic, the training was cancelled and rescheduled from 1.3.2021 and ended on 28.2.2022. The Government of India, vide Ministry of Skill Development and Entrepreneurship (MSDE) issued an OM on 25.01.2022 for the simplification of processes in the apprenticeship training, exempted the theory examination for ITI passed candidates/ National Trade Certificate qualifications holders to get National Apprentices Certificate (NAC). Further, it was instructed that the industries engaging apprentices in the designated trades must conduct the practical examinations in the last week Page 21 of 24 OAs Nos./021/448/2022,OA/470/2022,OA/487/2022, OA/457/2022, OA/623/2022, OA/624/2023 & OA/447/2022 of the training and the final certificates should be issued on the last day of the apprenticeship training in the designated trades. The applicants were not issued NAC due to the fault of respondents because of Respondent No. 4 did not send the practical marks of applicants to DGT to issue NAC certificates, though the practical training was completed in January, 2022.
3. It is further submitted that the recruitment notification of Indian Navy was issued exclusively for ex-naval apprentices for recruitment of Tradesman skilled on 19.02.2022 to 25.02.2022 inviting applications through online and the last date was 20.03.2022. On request of the applicants, the 4th Respondent issued a provisional certificate to all the applicants on 11.3.2022, in which it was shown that the applicants completed the apprentices training from Naval Dockyard Apprentices School, Visakhapatnam from 1.3.2021 to 28.2.2022.
4. The applicants, being eligible and suitable, applied through online within time and their applications were registered and while awaiting for their hall tickets to appear for the examination, the 3rd respondent issued ineligibility list on 30.6.2022 vide notification No.3/2022 where applicants' registration numbers are figured in the list with a reason that the applicants did not attach the NAC having done from Naval Dock Yard. The applicants gave a representation on 02.07.2022 stating that they have attached the provisional certificate, issued by the Naval Apprentices School as per the notification, but no reply has been received yet.
5. Due to Covid Pandemic, the applicants have already lost one year and due to the negligence of Respondent No.4, the NAC certificates were not issued to them in time, and for no fault of theirs, they are being eliminated by Page 22 of 24 OAs Nos./021/448/2022,OA/470/2022,OA/487/2022, OA/457/2022, OA/623/2022, OA/624/2023 & OA/447/2022 the 3rd respondent to participate in the written examination without accepting the certificates issued by the Naval Dockyard Apprentices School. The respondent issued a mail to all eligible candidates and set to issue admit card/hall ticket to all eligible candidates for the written exam which is going to be conducted tentatively in end of July / early August 2022. Feeling aggrieved by this, the applicants approached this Tribunal.
6. After notice, respondents have appeared through their counsel, filed detailed reply.
7. Heard both sides and perused the record.
8. It is submitted by learned counsel for the applicants that since the applicants have not attached the NAC certificates which are one of the criteria under the notification, their candidature has been rejected. Subsequent to the direction by this Tribunal by way of interim measure, the applicants have been allowed to participate in the said examination. Accordingly, the above said applicants, in all 190 candidates, who filed 7 OAs, participated in the exam and out of 190 candidates, 51 candidates were selected, as detailed below:
OA/448/2022: Sl.Nos.5,6,10,17,24,26,28,32,33,34,37,39,47,50,51,55,56, 58,59,66,67 OA/470/2022: Sl.No.5,13,14,15,16,17,23,29,32.OA/487/2022: Sl.No.1, 2 & 3 OA/457/2022: Sl. No. 1& 2
OA/623/2023: Sl.5 & 6 OA/624/2023: Sl. No. 5,7,8,11,14,15,22,23,30,33,38 OA/447/2022: Sl.No.1, 4, & 5 Page 23 of 24 OAs Nos./021/448/2022,OA/470/2022,OA/487/2022, OA/457/2022, OA/623/2022, OA/624/2023 & OA/447/2022
9. Thus, is to be noted that when notification has been issued, applicants were not in a position to produce the Naval Apprentice Certificate. It is not in a dispute that applicants have participated in the selection process and some of the applicants qualified in the exam.
10. In view of the same, since the applicants who have been allowed to participate in the exam, scored meritorious marks and they are in the select list, the O.A. succeeds and the respondents are directed to complete the further procedure of the selection, and post the selected candidates as per merit and the vacancies.
11. In terms of above, the OA is allowed. No order as to costs.
(SHALINI MISRA) (DR. LATA BASWARAJ PATNE)
ADMINISTRATIVE MEMBER JUDICIAL MEMBER
/al/
Page 24 of 24