Karnataka High Court
State Of Karnataka vs Prakash Babu Kammar on 29 July, 2008
{Exit 3:. yéamzgg--c.3 ee?V £2; 'E'§€%3:- E--EEGEE ciszgm' 9%' §{.a.RNATAs;2s5_ 2' CEEQCEEE'? ggwcg AT m«§ARwAB 4' .' %"_';A'E'E§D '§%~§§S mg 29% 339;' Q?
BEF{)RE A 1 '§'HE: §§{}N'BL¥3 §e1R.x§{}i'$"'§T:E:{§.§';, 55;.$I}3%¢$C}{A£4£v%%f'§¥§§'}€'ii»~ cagmzsqsgg ;%PPE{\.i...,«x§§5'Q.€§21ii%Q€}? ._. % EETWEEEQ:
$'m':'§ 55* KA§i£N'E'£x_E*';z% "
yr E-EALEYAL POLICE. - zgyygggam gm»! $23?'§~:.£';=¢:;fi--'.:~+;zA§;:1:$§';:"3--z_. :>:r;f::::»_§>;= _ APSE: 1 __ M 3;. E5?-153332; Bast?
g<:;;3::;3§ Ymgs, * A<:";§£E£."§3.§LT'{}}"€§$'§';v , $§%;A:=4§BA;%:";§;é;:«s::;*~g:;;r~§":*5; %;AL;YAL§§AR, ._ 2 A ' _ A<;:E::35 iffx"ElAf72IEf':, Ba,?$s:%~:";s«:*,;~:x-3 ' " §}:,'% V§':';£Le§k' E:'}'§fii§.-§"?fi;%?'i E;2'%XE»%;z%?€E~Z;%LEYfi;Li{g%E3 W €§E'::3'3~.T'g*'§':»?a §*.Sg'~f?;';'_.€}T¥ fig; $§§fi2*,'gzégLE;"sf':«<:s: 23$-'SA£'€T§~§ E<;%£*J§I*=:iAE, éfiisi--:";3-5%» §_{E§2,.~:%{:§, $32133 aaagzzn ;%:,:;§<:: _?:«'a._c§§:§gA;A::gp;:, ' . *::£;3g;K::éAL:¥A;. : E£EZ1SPQ§*é{}§',§'€T$ " §$?.§{K:S§+:é.SE§EKE§M€ S§%$'§"'{, A::'::v.;
THESE £fRE§'J§§?€Ai~ A?PEA§,- ES FELEE} RENEE? SEC-'§'§€}?€ 3=?"E% {E} 8:2 " ' - "{3} €3EP.C, ?R%':{EI'§if,% '30 {_"§RA}'é'? LEAVE; Ti} FEB ;3:F=§ E%P§"'s'£.£'--*-.L §1€_'§A§§'€$T TEE éL?E"}{}?:»'I§'£§*E'Z' ST, 3.1.295}? PASSED BY '§'E§§§ {E§'«§§L JUEEGE, {&§;. ENE} 52: :.}'%e€l*7'{T2 EE§aLE"§;%L, Eifi CRWEENAL C335 N{).,2é8;'2{}G6e é&CQUE'E'E'E§'§G '§'§{E RES?f3%5E3E§'§TSfA{f{f'L§SE§} E. '§'{f} $2 99% '§"E¥E:7; 5.}?-'%"EP*€CES ?;'L¥,«"$'3CZ3, 3-'$3,335, 50% 52: }.G'§-3' Pjiée'. 34» (:3? WC' Cr}. 3-3. ;'€@,521 ;*-.20e3:?, mgg KREEAENAL ;a?9§:.a:, z::{;szv::§~s@ or»: §:::>§ §.§£;fi;R3.j2~;<_}.__i ~:1':s::$. EBAY, TEE C'i}U§'§" EEELEVEREQ TEE FGLLQEWENG:
&U§)G»%v§E:%%'3' "€116 State hag pmfemfad acquifial 9%" $23 msgonfiexzts f€::';t, £i;:e o§1'$::z<:;:::sV.fi*-:31d;é:' S%:C'§im:;;S 323, 34:, 355, 394 ~§;.3:;<:; :::"a£m-§':::; V fs4_o:' §?C;'~
2. 'E13 {gem raievafif €92' this 333963.} are as uniigr:
ea privata camplaint EQ {£113 JPQE-§3'C;':, alltzgiizg that 0:: ISAJZQQ6 aft. abeui i'E.._7§G;V z~"::':;3;.4; he awn: E0 31% pe'=:,reE hiifik 0:: big matégr C:§?{:£6& éhass. acausgd in ffifiharanca sf ihéiii' fiammozz .A _~;;;;:c{:;:.::.§;;,.%a;§'::;;s;e& 311131 3:35: him with the hanés am am me afiiggr V'a€€f:1S€:i"'VéauSe€§ izigtigation aizé that $36 gamegs §1€§f§)§?v~.§Ii§$§§'€E}Ed afifl rescued him; Ea farther aééfigag that €E2§:_. ac€*:=;a$:::d gave iihrea': sf zéamgsr £0 213$ 13% and "a1'£im&'£$}}~*, #33: :9 ma ?a§§{:€ Station. 311$ 33 {he 3?? was an u éuty at Bhatkai, his sampiami W33 :30: réaeiveé 331$ :23 Vifitw Q? the pzaéééiaal infiusnca $11 {ht acmisefi, Em fail':
$123: the: Paiim Wfiéiiié Em: gmpszigg" émzastigaiéz {Em mafia: €3Ii{§ am. A ;%é<>.z-3;23,.;T':;§_.{;«:;_?;
'ii%:m"€:f::zr':t, ap§:'0a{i%3€{': €316 Es«'E2'zgéSi.raf;$ EE~'§.{§',§ :é;;'"'€%::1§:;;:.'=§a§.%:;i 'aEIEéi':3" Ssciian 28% C31: The Saiil €:Om.§}3i3E?;~'Z é~.%::fe:'ré§i" ' far .i}1v€S€5;ga1ié0n ggtzd a cha:"g€s1:1i:e€,c.am_:' {€)' 3}é: §§11€f3"£Zi'g§fi3%3;S*§'§:' 'aha accused! rfiapmlfisnts.
Eéuring {Em ma}, the ;QrQs%i2::i§,irm e§é53;r:2é_:1.€£i §?'%3!3. E {:3 18 am} $31 Eheriz" evidaziztsfiggé' m;:;;::§£ér:%_"E'§§§::E:._E?'.3 '£9 ¥'.f:"§. The giaiémfini; of theAactcussé.x$:€--§7e'§f€c9r:1€*{%. i:::«fiétr Secticn 313 8119.9. '§'h§j;V 'tbig 'V£§efé{uc§€"{2:§"t3?;aI émziai 3116; have gm': E58; 5a ::s§aff,.::%§:>f€%§ié;.5:_ r:f§?ir§.€fi;§$f'V The '§'réa1 {§'x:':1':r'€ ma ap}3r€a3§;:é--":£<32:: 0% tha'x:f:a€e§3}é".é..Q;: mcard, £iC{}}_1§.i'§:f:d {ha acéatussé anti aggrieséeai {'33: figs: {E26 Stats: hag p:*€f€z'*§%:s:§ éffizés 2 .....
'»T4'.<§:a§%e"~..h$a:fl mg: Eaagneé Gavergzmaai. gieader far fif:'a,_$ i;<:te_, ."§"E'.%;3A{",.c:2;:1";:$::?; fer figs ;:*§sp@11<:%i:ms is abasnfz. A3 fig cmzéd he sééfin fmm the recemg; {ha iremplainfi j§:': af this iziaififiné was fésd 13:: 1€éé4;280§, iihmzgfirz fihé éiisxiqicfii is said its Exam €3C€211§"i"€:d on 13'4.2Q06x '§"E';;£ ccmpiaifiazzi ofisrarzi some sxyfiazzaiian far flag»: (E6333? in the C€)Ii};§§.&§f3.§ @963 gm? say 311jy"'{%f:1':3g in his fi'§?i{§.fi{§{Tt3 bfifefés '£315 uh C-3:}; A. 343:5: :.;":::m?§ {Baum Efé is; raifivazzt to 301:2 $313!: {hem is 3 (15133; ..,~=':r§-' :i£_iéi'}*:~: ,:':;._ Eaxigézzg the c<:>mpa};§:1t 331% {ha Saié ::ie}.a§;V__hLas.; ééfgfii 4¥;x%§e;{--: _« 9 pmgefly €X§)§3_';i}€T{§;¢ it is 0311:;-' <:%3§v.'5vi{%':i:.;§:§«_{}€"E"§'§?' ié avafisfsle an mcem fm' a§pre:r.ia€i%Q;3L.. '§"}';Qz:gh.E;.ié 'ii; " 53:;-ji{,:i"a%§'~.. have sugéaifieé 'ziéx: éyzjzzzfées, '.222:-*:213 fi%3"1£._ e:s;§aé".3i:i:;:{% hf; ighfiv Saizior 332$ %f§:»:~:rfi is f:ié::,_ mes:i:Efa7i ..£:vié::*:1<?e %<§"'s'5:':£§2§01"1; are v'€*:§"$;§03": sf Q25 camgkkzzizgzazgii; '?~Ex:3 Jé3Ef%;é1",AA_':3§§%::' "_'§;£7i§1-ffi€S5S€S émvct s;a§;}<}rE{~:{1 figs: $%%;rs%.§:'§.L' PQEEE, as fa}: 33 the zsaasazafii azzéii a}f;'u;.s1<:."'is_ <::{3:::!:;e}*:1§"::?._. V"§_':'}1§:. '§3s*o$€<:*a:iian axamizzfiaé P'W,4 :vjw§; o _ ::23.a'£.< ~?€§a,V: _ Acstisagé Eaéca/% afisaziliseci 331%:
<::a3mpZ$§3i:a3:z:.V1%£§€}: ':::%ia§:e§Ia%s;.~ E: is net {£252 case af fiht:
Cofifipgiaigzaiiiz. {E133 'V§1€A'--'§x?a:*3"»LVassa11§%:£d $3}? ;%C<f'i1S€{i ?'~§0..% Wifii chV_:§§3;}a;;1_;_?9}k R?%¥£'$t»"'h.a;s__¢1zee:: '{Z"€i3?L€{§ as hsesiriitt and as mgaxrés ' 131%: ..,ab-3.57:3: baafing with the hanfis, 333 £053 ms': suppafi ~*:3::i:--._:se_€"é§:%_:z.__a}S',%;'é*:€ press-a.:~*1€%{3;1 33:5: fiaemfgrs, his widazzca is; 9?? ''f3.:::} Ei;_é:1g:s. fa preve 1:135 incidsnt. PW6 fig azjmsihar wim.€:ss £10 @351' 5:33:53 that $236 aceugaé aagazzlisd E1313 camigflzaizgafit :§?§t§§*«_.ihe cézagspaig afid figs eviéencfi assf PW,5 is §EE€fiE2SiS§€I1§ '4;§§§E1 the evésdagfazza 53f $53.2 51:15; 30 3.130, {E16 p:*0S&c'*.,:fim".: " 'imaiad ?W.$ hastiig anfi is": {ha @033 sxaminaiiszx 135; {ha £122. £5 2«;c},52;,g-'2_§;@?{ girasacutiam ha iieés Q0: ggrsaz Witfi mgagfi E0 %§:s:%.¢.;:g;_'%;;§3§s:¢:%.'a§i::¥.V assault by {he {yzher acaiustai mzii ?,.§};i'$i'{§f{}}f€, '€'.ii:{§_~€.3;':§%.Z?§ V' €§3;€S€ Wimafisas as Wefi ii; <3?' z:c§"E§;:eE§'3 . ?'LQ f3€_':gI'§'§"§}§%lT£?§;'€é:i~~ '§f.§'1*E:' vazgien sf PW.2. ?Ws.é 311% 2?} t}1é7::_x£}§::'::' §§§?€} {?}s'i¥»§5e?'§L?.iv1§::S';'S;fvS~_ am 313:'; Ems:-£36 313$ fizey {Ea §}{Z%§__":T§3'";T%'5§§01*;.'§i Vé:§:?::--.;1r";f§*s;_:s::§'c:Vi§:'%"§@;ai. £1; 'V the circumsiazzares, fi'X{?{'}f}{ 3f5"3§.€fH<?L._=;§f E3'§J.'2-,: §;%§:$z*€ ES :29 €.v}1d$:1{:€ a: gig ta :?0r;'Q59§§a§:' %. vemian {If 2%}: {2i3m§}}§iifl&E}.'{. 3 4.':£:'j5::.:<i::_ am eééher {ha aiiesiéng .:%Zfd" ;sa§;eV:.."g§73'E::'a;<%:;3;V::r tbs E1":%.i£$i§ga?a%:;g Eéificefa iaiizxé --.§g:;:»>.*£2:~:1:&*~::'%, sf éiiigza Wf.§;iE€$S€E§ 3§§€§; {E1611 §£$él__*::};$ "§2.z3e{}ing mtg) firaxasiaésraiéckzz Ehf: fact Efrgai a§s:~¢"§;;v3--.aé1§§;'-Igf 6 flay; ix: Eségizxg 211%: <1o:f:1p1ai21'£ anf;i5'?'§g'_§;', jwha is ga,i;<3,»z:"; $35296 335$}: assauétfid 33}; "$35: a.<::c::;:s€{£ .i:3.;8 3135:.' 53i§§§ai:E€d fizs ::}:3§a§;' aad his €"eJ"1E{iiii1€€"3 is :10? ;c:€£'_e3%§A::«'§§23a:§2 § §§v.2;ffl&ZC§§8} §}ar§ic:.3.§a:'s §'}:" 25333' 9&3: aésimesses, .'§§:_'§zéé:f1. C:;aa;:::*i an appmcéatémg <3? '$136 maimiiai ax"; §'€€f*-€}i"%'Z§§ wag affiziza visas; Eiérzaz €328 p§'QS€C'ifi§{§IE has faiifizi €33 §3?;'{}'ir'€'§ ft}: » §g:i3?E§ 'tzeif?-*$1:§£ reasonahéfi fieaibi. 34 (V x ~.'.4 2 mg. 3%, :x:<>,5>2:§>'gG<§?.
21 A3 §'figa«1z':§§ {hit E?z§§§}€f8i agaizasi :a<":{gj:1iE%:§i, i§:Vé::; wé5:%§j {:rs;%;:,f;3§é$§§et§ §3:*i:':Ci;_3E.%: :3? 23.2%: 33 iaisci s3:3's:<::1 E33' %'£':)l<:.__;'%.§:;{c'2:. é'{;1a:zf:,3'.;*.€; V 32:32 'é&7§"§€E".: {hats 3.2% {We Viztws §=:3:€'5§ii1¢'A§A'>'£V'§3'€Lf',«":{:§;1',-'ff <:>,m: a::s:'§;2?;::<.;Vi '$37 EEK: Tzéai Comm 3.331123%. ha {£31si:1:1"a3<§§§V,_ fi1:«i <.::3.;2t;"{«::z<.t.
i5§=EZ§iZ'°, if iifst '{'3¥"§d.Ef}1C€ is Eseizeaé.'-v§:'£'§::>, ihaé ?;:zf€%::i:£*:s§i:{r:€§*--;fa£V:i9:'s5;{):: 0;?' P'§%?a2 ::z--z:3.z1sf{ bs é'i€'€;'€pZ?_3§. é%31{§ $§E€f€'-Céifiéiifli €:\%:3v:z:...'§;:.€4:»z Eecgézzii View {mm Eaakégzg is t%:é1"a{t':-$,"L__§;é:» «?hs::'é:*§_:°c:V::;'s::n'€53.::c:%?£;, éhsifs ig as magi": 3117: $325 ;.3fp;;§€éz1 ::';;é§é 35:. géiémifisséz.é%C=:r:3:{%i:1g§§°. Sd/*"
Judge