Karnataka High Court
The Commissioner Of Income Tax vs Sri Babu Reddy on 1 March, 2010
Bench: K.L.Manjunath, B.V.Nagarathna
31:5; ";{'§%E3 §»;:§{;;-I; {f{Z%£§E€'§' {g}? §;;xR:\qA2:zm:A Ea'? §§.;§::§;%%:,»:§§2;;?:
E'_}§a"§'E:f3;"} '?:£--2:3 'Fifi: :8'? my {E}? M§%:<:%:':§% 2{§:{;%' PRESE§?'*.ai "E'?%§%I: §--§:;*:2:=s%§;:J,E .E¥i:u§§_}f$'§'EiTfa:E53. _;§:';,:g; _:g:;§~§k';?:L:?::a:;x;*:":4;%' ' % » f "
;2:w:;:§%% THEE%E%§LEi%§J§S?Kfi§§££fi&G§R3T§§A Erik §§:§;Vg33i):"0:?:
' . '.
E.f§';';'§,§§3'0S.§§9€*;'-;"»E:E}i}*E:';51f€%E;§}:hN;i§2/2&3?) ETA $40, 2 " ° _;i?%E;T'§£é'.EE,'N: K "
E , '"§*',%3.:: iimjimgésgiéi 4' J §fi§:0i}E§:~7§'3X . _ ' "
5%. }?_'%u§.§ ii i:I'";g,V A ... ..... .. 7 A ' . _%":3az1gz§31::r£;..V mi' ..
'!:$_5;i$i;€§2:€i {3:§m:2f;§s$ies:";§%§* sf §:1C<:a::;{-:"§'ax ' §§§§:*<:E§. E'{$i{ 3 5 %if'i§:?i.vZé3z_:.iE{f§i::g% fgzzasefis Qaazi .. ;§3angai€§r€:¢ ,H;§?P§§§,L§E€"§'$ 'géfé §{.¥.§;I§i¥iE}€§; Afiif. far §¥§,§s'.S$SE%1é3;{:§":a};§., éaévé
9..
31% Eaéxzg Rséidfiy', fix} §~£«:::':ga§;am<ira Viimgsz, Magiiwaia P033 Beggar Eieifié, _ ' .¥r'3a_mga§.m'$w68, ' . . }2E:$V?:{.}'?§.£>:,'?%E"'§f? {Sri Afifzazizkar 8:5 Egfihava, Ad'%.rS.} This rm fiieii £1/'S 2€>€}--A a:sf $1' §%.z:::','*-195:1_»é§i*"§.$£:"ig ¢;;~{,--s:% V (sf order dated. {}Q.€33.2=T£{}§_ p'a$s:;:*:.:i ETA N0.1836fBafig/2004 far me as'L's,e:_§::a;iae:~;::;,~.:..=r¢:§a;< :<3<}9».{}@, §ra§:'i1:1g to {i} for.m11}a:5 31$ S1;_b:~3*:eL:*2:i'ia:.§_ que'$ti:3_*{1a'ei' éasgxr Stated 's.h€::"€fi1; {ii} aiksw $25155' «--ap§i)eaTE.é;§2_§i~.${:§ asids 3&1:-3 <::§'{}§:r ;3a$:~3fid by $113 i'.?§§E' Baglgajéézsfi: §:.13_?f7I';:3'x E8:%éf>jE%a,s"2g/ i2£}{}é¥ iéatad 89.{}3.2{"}{}€'; agzié C:§::fi§";3;§m__ E~§:1€""'{;:14:'§~s=*::: -"<3? Appéziigtfi éistmnisfiiamex' <:<::i:""i:*.:.1};i:;':g €;'E7:.c: _ 'c.i<i_e1'~' "gagged by the 5-'ass;§$i'a:1i:T "§:}::11ié3§s;f§~L:j3';€:,%*-« {if E§1Cagr::é"'~-Tax? Ciités-1€}{_1} Bangaiem, in '%::'1<;j;fS€. 'Q§fj.12S:i€ie"«,:3L3:":§i_' e{§":3i:§;. ETA N8.5§fi8§Qi3 ._~ .__T:= % EEE'E5iEEN: . . é 4 7%. 'Thfi é;f_"i0?:;3:1}§$$i':>f:3€V'§* GE ' " _§ncvf::"i1€;»_»-7§'5.g'< ' ----- -* . {;:.VR;. B$.}i§C'§§f3§',~._ V _ {;?u§;€:1s"v.!!?:>:;-1ti..,_ "
§?%%a.f::g.;a3§;>£§;v. _ __ < ""
5§T'§':a€§';%3sa:*i;s'§.2.2.€5:'£ §@};3.1:";3%SS§<,>§:@:" af §i"'§€<}§§1$ '§'aX \.Qiz*$§&" :5'; 3;
A u<;6:m::::a:::g, {,}:;.:jێ:1's Raasfi,
-- Efgzngaioras. C & . ;%}3'§~"E',;§d.-§.4,?s§§"'§"§'§"*§ "-{S':'§'K.'3£,Ara¥i:1»:i5 $323: §%:;§' §v§.'£fi{~:$E:;3;<:h3;§3;, Riv.) 1% QM A§'€§,}:
Sri f*:.?v§1,:I"§.i §~¥:':;:<Ea§};, %§{>13ga$a:1<§r::i \f§'§E23_g:":§ ._ ?az§2::%;§22;a§;i P931, ' Efisguz' E---.§o?31i.§ ET%21:"a§g:z;;§{}:"€:~€28. % ,,éR3é:':?~:1éé<':=:;:::::f%:;és:;*§*I (Sr: A.Sha.3"§£«»:a:' 85 E'z«i,Lava, ,%c%é%':a:,'}"» This {TA filed 12f;E§-._:26€§»ia_ {if Q1-E§:'i:;, E6} a1'i5;%T:1g mat: of Ofdfii" e:ia'Tt£{i 275.. :E--f'}.i?{,3~€}E'} A.»_g3e3,s§$€:£i in "f"E'§ 3\E0.€~:54-;"§a:1gi20£§3 far "€315; ' aSs@':a25:::év:':§~ j%,«'f;'a1' 2'G€}2~{E2, §}z'a}*:i;1g {:0 {Ti} f;;§;'r;1z11z':":é'V':;i*;;§f: _s.i:_1.,Y§3$ftea:*2'£f3.3§ z:.;aT.:€:3€;i<3ns (3? £31? $:af€::::§ '{;héi;f'€i:§;' 1a3§£}W 'aihai ;;;§;;;;ea:* *;~:f:.2.{5i 3&1: aaéfié: 3131:: ezmgiax' ;}a$;'-$651 E3}-f__.€;"E3%?.._E 1---.z5§§' T:Fi%:»::j;_gé;:3{>:i-%£: in §'fii';§ Nodéfiéégfiangf 2{'.':€}3 23: E€},2€§€fjr§;:3_ -:;2a§.::{;": :::=:';_3'*:;fE;:?:%,:T;;§""~V' ifiiiézf: @r{§€:r Sf figpgéafiaié ' '£§%?i?'I3,fi,i*I}:1wi._:_"15g' €)1'd€§' p:s:'s.$$es:§ E3}; $3515: §%_ss§Staa,:":€ {:€:?'iE1EfiEi3SS§i)i'§§?E" fffi' Ezzcazzitz *'?3:x;, {firsinza i=i}{1} .i3aI1gaE;{;3'€;m 1:326"-i.§;te§é':i;§V"<}fjé{,§$i,§.r::e ami :§q1.1it:};. ma :{e.5§'2---«€§§§;g 'A _____ V *{"E";€" v{§{§;:1:::i$.$i€s§:£3:' sf . ;E:::*::3*:i':3;'§'z%§?%; V 'A iifiggaziéiiégég, %;;%z.§&%f:E.::«2.. §'éi(3ad§ §:f%a,§;2g:3§a§°eg " 1%, '§";?€i:é3 Ass$}§$ia3::%;_i C{}E'E1§':'§;.iSS§8£'}€i§"' 3%.' §i'Z€:*Giiifi€:" Ta 'fgiiffifia §€}{ 3}, :i..E€.B=..fl:i§di.r;g§ IZ}:;€€1'2'$ E63555; § Eifizam gaizarfz. . ? ._§%E3'§'E§L§..;;§ F$Z?'»E§ V'?-
(8%; §{9'zf,é._1*a%3§:":r:i, Adv. for §a;§.§f.E§<~:$.E";;3;£~§'2z2}a, fa::§.¥.§ T §&§'*€E}:
Sr: M.E?;9_m.:::sh, ._
Eiaixgjafisagzgiira Kfiiiagti, I
Efiaziéwaézi §~"~{;$%;.,
E§€gu:*E"{::;i;2§i§ 1 %
E-.%3_:1g3§.:>1'e~§'>8, ' v...VRfE}%}§'€}'%%'Z3eE§'*§'E' {Sri A.SE:a2"&<:a,:* 5% EvE.La§.rfa,§ This WA fiieé 113/S3 2i':%§:}«?g% fE";5f§<::g 19%: arigisxg 03.2% cf mfdai' data} 1_f},:2G=f}5--'"~-. ';§g;$:'s€{'§ in i"FA No.666;'Bzmg/2§Z§€.}j_3 fair 8';:~*5:;s::v':;_$::;-.m::?;*,r:'*¥: 3&3? 2{}i}}--{}*2, gayafgimg is {E} 2_'i'e:):§'1g,j:e:%<;'1'fiz-:1!;:j*«%-*; 553:6 stz1:;_:st<a11i"--ia3 qu{m:st§o£;.s of Eaw siaiad §:_'z::":2'€:é1:;"{ii}pa§E€§'§%£.:_§h%:w..a;;--}:;e--al 331$} S63? asiéiéi thé grzier passeti 2:3,: i§1<3'i:f§:iAT E§a.1fig駧{}f€3"§.I"§ }ETZ§: NQ666/B.:»13.":gf2€}€)3 iiaifzai 1,3;-I--:...§,§}C'2_8€}:'Eii:;, éaiitszi «:_:o:3iE;€--iz.33.7th&: {§§'{}.€}f' 52%' Appeéiaécé <C3on1111§s:3i:):"1€::'7I[_.. <:_;>:§fi;:::1i.::tg $3.6: Gréisr pagseci by {he z'%ssi$i.ais:?:% * §Zi:;3::§:":.i{$.$is:1 €zi__"ziéf ' §}3,£3iE%§ii€3 Tax, C§1'€:§€~ .ié":>{§} ifiangaiett, §:f&,:ha:?.._'i:1aiif:':z'é$s--€__ {?}f§§,,3S§i.€3€f afld <«:<;3;:§t,3,%: ._""3'?§'E:§:9s;-5V' §'§';5;*ss'v.--..::?::3:1;%;":g 23:: far hfgéarizig éiiés {$39, «E, :ié:ii2s'6z'sci the f{)§3;{)S«§e'i{"igZ J{3'BGI'éEE*ET '§'%z--§§S{:. "§§:§;'%§}€a§S am fiiaé %3'§; ftfaas :§'€*2:e:1:,:e raigiizg %:;'§"::>; .L'§'£;A§¥;:::§s§::}g" $::*::§s€a:':i;éa§ §2_:<«:$E§{::::3 Q? 3352:': WE:e€;§1€:* {E23 '"E'§"§%3t3r:gl was Cfifffi-C? ii} Ewiafiézzg 'E§'i5&§f. $1336 baiaii :::<':::<:::.:::% fiE"§.i.§ G'§§'§.€i' 8"{a?,fi':§}":{f§'E§Z8 §:*:32;': %,¥="§"i§;{f§'": i:':<:::}m:=: §:a:::'::'}i: '§';%: s::{:=1:"1 pizégii' Em: is i2;*:'*i'%§'.€;2:: 9;: :%$§:§:§13;§'£= E}éiSi$ :;%a>:":s§2:§::i:.3'{,é: E;-=<>®%£$ £3? §4i{::::§}é;:3§'a'$ E/.
<;>§' §;é{§§5+§§8§*};3<;f~z Tm': saéé :'€":;u§*:}; was $z.2%§::::;??;.:fi<§ « :$--'§§§*::s:2§, 3 'E"a:»<: 5§EE€§§? E§€--%§}a§°£: '?%:%:* fis$es;§i:':g Qffistéig 0;} " '"z§":{";'i.§£:i§_:g ihaég iéiif agassgaa %_m.{% ;:'19%, §"§'i8_§§'§§.&§.E1§{3 éwséis :12? zgraéi (3315-3? {_'§e:3{:E.::::{=:3'1i:3 %,x:§1;E':§j:;'"; V. :12? §I"}i"0%2'§S§{}i"§5§ :::«§" Sm;é§_i<::'3 4'%<¥--Afi ;}&§f%;ii;%z.§.%.§:.§"Eff§' 4' ciafzzsegii {,3 6% E' 0%' €_>:3;3§;§::gf£;;§:;:;': §.§;"'sz.~:{f§_3ééE:iQ$ '$5 S€C*i';i{:*§'} E3? :2:;2k6$ 8 ..g§i8SEE "
2%;E':{:;:'<e §}s:;§§~:s 22?' :§3_{t::<>zi:':a%;s:".a::;;{% .{:';";a<;:5§'E;:;:::1:3%';::¢?;tA$'vA i'EItaiE'}.'iaiiZ{fif,§ ;~,a;":z;E . _§3';sgs<: %€:§.";_€:.:x:«% "'%§§ a§<:$ '€355 £%C{T?f{}i[§.§'."i§S ami <§<}ca:;';2__$§é:€,:3 335:3 :':s::i"::j3.af§:':;§%2i:::eéa '§é'2":eti:a::.z* the 'in §':1<r:>E{i%:§:zg iihat i;2;za%1§%zc::f1z~2::{:<e;:' A3;~::;;:g;g:§:'t;"é:'V :*e§::cE:é:'3g 2'e':*€&§p'£s Eng? _-:'_§:.':*:4}::;;;¢::.:* b&S€€§}; an Whicéi 3::z'§:;}a1"e{£ zmuid 33::
;{.?*f'}i§'}j;£v;i;:J_'*T§§£'v}?;ii'L:sZ'.€i"v far {E16 pm"§3§$€:$ <33" Saifiiiars. '$325321 i§z::";*a:g}'2 $u€E'1_ SiE:3."§iGIE"i§E£"1?;'.S %=*{§';;:§{§: ._:ge'i"v_ 2;:§:§{::;.§'a€é:§}s* Eaiia ism; &C{'i<}iEi"§€ V é;::=<:;;:z5:,a':<5f1i'*:::;ié.'é"_°§:.;..::}?;§.1§::* §}a§.,'n'z.€::':€s fifld re¢::s§;3::"£$ eiza?
"*;;'f§r:;é3'~;;.;:i;ssé:&';$eée: 33 a SE3}? {.'i@§3i:'a::':f<;i: §?'{}r 333$ :s:;§«:s$§%:?+s;:;:é::3":'£;".§§ai'" §<3@%»~;E{}{%fi} E35 31%;? §€€§8;§'€§ 3: $52232': 92:52:' :%{,:{::;1::':i.$ éLi§%§ §§§'€:$:::*§f§..}::<i; 1_iiI'1§§{i'E' S§§C'§".§{}§1 44% 3%' "ifizs §§";;€::z':::':e if €33 T3}: ;%.{:'t§., ;}1f*0<7t2::<idé:cE €19 ii'}§T.§§3£§f3 p¢::2'1ai€ij»; g3:*@{:€€;:%43?f:':gé;f;--_%;m<i€t:* S§3€:%:.ia:": E? 3% 0%" $335: $552 P:.1.1'$:§z3;1i 'ta 3 E}'{3}§'.§{:%f?--.V:VS§!§i'€;_%i "5.:3>.__V *{.§':§; 4'-3;SS€i§§Sf;'€3, Q; E'€:'§§§f%£ was g§2x5}'1"-%'E':a'§j "'%.";QG§<;-fir a=%;ia':;*€f §::ai::a{.aé:":r:':{§ E1: i'.E':§:. 3_EE§%§ia} c<§:43§$<«;':}f {E35 p<:n3§*:y Csmici 3-19% Offi<:;éé.%', .§::{:z%v€;* had Eizai, $133 aC§::}'i::'§€.§S§ 'flags r%{;¥t"';:::é§it&iB&& E3 3225 presfixéhed Esra}: a?a'-;-:";§:<':~::2.:*d:?_¢:'_r:i.Lg¥V,'£3%.:~kfggiiasi 3 pergaliy as gar aiséer 2 said ardar avas chafleizgficiié '§:i{:f'éi'%§-.._ E1"I§ -. 'V{:5*57fi§;}.§'i1iSf€é§fiI}{33" 0? §i'1CGi1'i€ 'E'aX Appé-:z';;iS _%§=;§::i{':E:2,...V_ {Q --'z*:é: regectéqi E3}; iiififii' daéeé 3f}.{}4.2i}{}%'%.. '='.'§'E*'1%'{:" .$.;<&;--s;éS:s€:3, beiiig agig:'°i<:ve{i §3f; 215%: a§'G3.';é$::a*i;d §r€ic1fj$Q §2§*§.f€§"*r€{3i :31: appea} §;£:§'<3:*%: 'fihe E1j:<:«:§2':';:-: b 'E'r%§:s:i1";3§. Tm: "_7§'§'i§3':::':a}; E'1:i§;«:i ma: SE6 ,%_:§Eii§aiisLsi:"_~v..<:§§°' §s:%:";s2§"§.§ §:;:*9<:€:E:{§§:":g3 wagg mi}: 31?: &C€{%§'5i§_§"iC§3 :>2:§§,§*: §§}:; :-..,::'£a;:*% azzé a<:s::<;:'{§;%23gi§; érappaai {E26 33% §§Gc$s:~£§§:'.:,g. ":'3s;§'._;jf:g éiggxéeyad ix; ?;§':§; $3352 €:§§s::: gm z=e:2'&:a2.:&. 233$ fi;E;{:=:§ ""é}§ ils":a§:s§€a3a 23 .33. Wt: Emvsé §"i<':E£};i'°€,§ ins: E{:em1er::{:§ {;"{}ii;€Ef§i'3.: _§_"<;2.if ~ ';.%1& '"&§J;'}€§}§:§§i}3Z5 s;%..a'zc§ ?;;§:<~: §{'3;é.'3i;%'i'Eéf{§ {:<;:.;:"':s€:i E131" :'e:fé§';;?{§5';'=:sijif'":E--.f:é.--., asgessae. ._ 1%, .E3.E'{>§'}§ iéizzs siaaiieziai (351 1'{'§C{}15"--."§, §.-i. fig §f%.§i{§€V§"i§: 3;§i;aT%"f$<3:*" %» 21.31%: :a;s§&:e3$:m:m }§§}9;?'2fi}§Q, figs-:A_VVATa:s3éi:;s&;€t% €13.11 fiéécéaréiai his '€[:.::*§: é:}"ss~:-*A:__:f""~ 331,? %'?§z;:(:g: -4 z;V.v§%;«'§;1:*z1 311% {ha saisri 1"{E'iZUif'I'§ Wag aim p:"::>c;<:§3:;3@.:i '1*22fi"*~&:;;%::%€$$i3":g Ciffifiéfil Q3 K §"§{I%§'«"€fi'zF€3i'° 32T;:'§;:'_$<3<;§"' **i'§§*, €§é§<:€:i§_::::a_ V~'1§9'~Ef'g:'%. £3? ?:§1€ AC': Wag appiéfiti §a:'1€':..;;{;i:§§:§: "=£'v;é?iS«.i':S$'§E.fixC§"V'§,{? "§:i'::>: 8;SS€'SS€@ :::}2":*%.6m<§i;;3.g E3353: §;§'1%:% E3?{;{}§<;~§: 'a'=,*§'ff:§.;CV{::°:;i;i3f§.é<' g-'<:€:r& 3":s:':'é §1a§z:?ai:2z3{E in *£.€::'::':&; {ff §:.§%':€ $a%_s:t§ 7..*«7~.'$¢%::.?':.*§<:;2i:z.,_ 5": 7§*<;=§£{%§:i:g <3? '€336: észzizé zaé-*:<%'E.é.:::§": zisakss ii", ~ . A_ <c§€2=,.*§*~3'§:.£?::..fg€i .3 §3€2"§§%3:z'*;.._._...22;*§j<gi§:g <33: isgai, ffifiifiiiéii, <::'::gi;"1£':er§:'1g £r;:. " ;?§1'€§_T;§ia'"f§??§ ¥;§;;'%.§ _g::z'€:~§"<~:@s.%<>:: {:2}? $3513 ;:2m§'€:$$i9§: Q2"
aé:-'a::3{:z':§:z§:21:§§,'j' $3' '%,@€:§';:'_;icaE §:3.§':szz};%:a2'§a:§r {EF :£:'}_zi€§"ie:* {§a{:@:'a5:§{ts':f_z G? 3:21}? Q%;};{%:r §}E'Gf€iS$i{.'5Ei 92% E3 E:£}'?§f§§{§ bf; 23%:
'~.EE{:§§ "ii? in $316: {f}fiE€:§a§ iéégzfiiéia has is §"::2&§§.'§§;:€:£§§': %}@{;':<3 <3? '' a::%s::@::3:is Eiiifi {}?§"}€;{" {§{§C1§;EiI}a'§E'1?iS, E2": {}2"{,'§€iZ' fa?) {'?@§i':§}'i,E§{3 31:3 §{;%::E §:;<:(}:z:€ E32 2§{:{:@§"<§a§';<:§-: zésééfié figs: p_':'s:¥§$§::sz2s 0:' fiéifi fi<':%i, W