Karnataka High Court
Sri C Mohan Reddy S/O Chinnappa Reddy vs V Nanda Kumar S/O Sri M Venkatesh Reddy on 7 December, 2009
Bench: N.K.Patil, B.Sreenivase Gowda
(1
1"1.(':>1_11'i:a11i11;g §'o(')(.i 2211"1ci 21111411121111 1:1'12-'1.1j_>,1..*..-'es 111111 1111=di(.*a.1.l
('x.};)c11scs. O11 z=211.'("o1.11:'1t"' of €111' i:1j111'i1=-'S ..='a1..1:'-.;I.z»1i111'd §[)'~xT _:1"1.._i41'11_. 1113
1"i1<'d :1 (:12-1.1111 1.31'-'=i'.i1'i<)11 1t121i1111'111f~«'§ <.*c.)1'11.i'v;>11sé1'ii'§>1fi1j"-.--_j<:>1i
Rs. I 5.00,00()/- 2-1g;2'1i11.~s1 11111': 1'1>.$p()_t1d1.'_111s.."W'
4. The $211,111 0131111 poii1i<)1'17112.'1'<.:1 ('1)1'1'1(i*_11'}1)v }')("1'1=)1«"1*:',i.111}
'1'1'ib11112==11 011 ]5--C3--(.)6. '1'l"1(-"'31f1"il')11112.12';._'21i7tJc.?z' §'1v;1'~.z.11'i1'1_g' Ihv
1cz11'1'11'-id (ii()L11'1SE'1 011 1');§51t'V};1 --si{ic=n<j{:;=:.::1ci '21§' 13:" ('T(i1'1f§i£'i£"I'i.11§,§ 1111~
(1)1111 and d<')c1_m1c1'1tarywg:1'idc:21(t1-E e_'1'k»*.e1i12~i\i31I§* on 1't:'.("()1'('j1. E12115
e.111<_)we.c'1 1111'-iv C;}121j'1I1. 'p€{1i'1'i<')11' i'I1"----}'JE11'1 z.11'1d 2_1\.1.«'e1_1'c'icd
c>0m1')e11sz11.i191115.155. VRs3}1.7O:7_f' O0'/'7~ L.i;]d€'2I' Cfi§'1'C1't;T11t1 1"1crz:1(.'1.<s wii'_1'"1
i_1'1'I':<_r1'(_~.§:.1 21.1 -("$2-/'E';'--'}:ex_1f'V:%111'1'11:1i3»1.__i':'<.i111 111111' (§z'i1t'e-* <)f1'.)(:%t.itio1'1 till the
(ie.1't"t' of c:1C;1)41>s-:i1.. 'I'-3E*i1'1g "*..a1g§?1'i('\!1:(1 1.');-1 {I11} i1111p1.1g{11cr1i
1.}11C.1.g;{c%1111'c?1'1i 2-11191' Aw;-_11'c1. 1111: c1z.1i11111;-.11"1.1 emczi I1'1.~s1.11'2';1_1'11'*1r »('f011_11:;a.T:1'13-3 v,1"1"2~--.*..\~f1=-> }i)1"1=:s(.r1'1€'t:1':1 i1'1c.~sc: ;:1}')pc:2.1_.1.s;. ms]>1r1':1'1\.-My ._s'«;=i1:-'i>:.i_'1'1.ggv (1.1:1}:21';:11tc':1'1'1ei1t' and 1*(>('i1.1<'1im1 of (:<:)11'11'31~1'11.sa1inn. v-"
1' \?V<-: }12:1vc-;2 h(:~.21.1'('i H10 1<==*2:1.1'1'1c=*(i ('f1)1111sci e'51p1.:)r:2:1"i.11g3j " -.I'O;:t.t'_}ii (":1a.i1'11e11}I 21111.1 1111-.' lee-11.'11(.r<"i ("3(_)111'1s1"1 2-1;'"}1)<::e.11'i1'1g for 11111:
1 ...1.1é.<s1z1'2"11'1<'-1: C10. for ('own (is-'1'e.11')l1" 1(*1'1g11'11 of t'i111(-~..
////1'
6. T119 SL,1bIf11iSSi(,)I'} of 1.110 lee;-:.1"1'1t-2c.1 (4?<')11:1,~sc.1__i'(..)z' 1'.1"1c c§ai1'na1.1'1i. 1-E1. 1'.}'1c outset. is 1.11211' 11'}:--:* 'E'1'ib1.::1z_':1 1'1z.z.~__-; :'__V?{.':1.1:.'i"}.'_11.i--'.VVtc'(§ er1*<')r in not 2ft\\r'211'(j'1[1§:_{'§1.ES{ a11'1d :"e*2;:sc)1_'12,1bIc.-'Cb11'1.pt+'a':'s:1Ti"i'c?>11; t'owa1"ds 1c)s:s of fL1u.1re=..-. .i11(*.or11e,-I 'Cit;:'1.vcy';1r1(:c*I'~,1;(">i_1»1iii3h"iv1'1g;' food and z1t'{c?1'1dz.-1111 ct}12'1:'5__:c.s. 1(.)S.*.'§»'()f':;.é{1'1'i€'1'ii{.E553..%i.1"1(} f1:1{'1.f{.::1'(> 1,1 1'1he1p1:>i_r.1css and future-> m Vec1_i'(§.-~z.3.V_l cx}"3e1_1s:<:_s Vi7(')1'"'.1;HE)~vi{ij1..11".iC?i3V S11stai.1'1ed by the (:}21i1T1';1.1'1t:. T}'~1--*c., '(';}.21i;<Ij1211'at W'a:~;. i.1i*Lpz1i.icr11t'. for 1m>1'e 1'.1'1a1'1 112 days hi $I_T1"1'<;* '1.3,k§.¥':_--;;:*;'.)it_'<'1Li;_ 1.nT1(.!r:r\v01'1t !'01..1 1' sLT1.1*ge1'.ies a11,d~, ci-0(t'(.(:ig1' ._;,i;':e;LL~;i_s':.::_Vss(é(%.i« V 55% perm.211'1e1'11. di:se1bi1i1y 11:6 z'ig~}:1i'.""1'é.g;.» 3(3%"~.é;§)'"' _1€,%i7t: ,*?c.';rc.ar111 21 nd 29% to t'}"ac wllolc' !;)<)ciy_ . 'Vl'£1f€%.1j(=%f(f§1'C.,time' E1215 ;)1'vfbr'1'0(.1 1.hi..<s a.p;:)m-;%z;1I for 1110dify.i11g' 1:'_hV(;:-._j1[.1dggme1/11."_.:11'1ci c*1'11'12111ui.1'1g_{ the (?(")IT1},)€§1'lS&i1i017
- . A eT1\v;a'1-*;d chi" '.*)y '1 116-? ";'.,af_f:__!_;)__1:1:.'1 a] .
"A.S-3a:gz'1i1T1s1'. i'his. 1'.1"1c I1"1.~.s1[.n"z.u1(tc= Co. im"c1* e:_:1iz;1_ ('.(')1T'1"'ti.c==>1'"1C;_?e'(;E-. «T'1'12.1f the _j z.1(1gn}cr1t zzmd z';m~'e.u'(:1 1J2,1Sf.'S{T(1 by 1.116"
_ "ETT1'i.bur1V£r1 '_§LE.S1I. anti p1'0pm'. I--iowcx-'01.". 1'1(: c11.1i[.)p€(?'1 1.0 paint 'o.1.1"1' "i.1'1a.t': t:h<-3 ('3()I'1'1p€'1"}S2:E1ii(')I'1 a-'m-*2-uric-:c1 t:<:)w2,u'(1s 1.32331 211'1(i ///"
lcgg. 30% in 1:311 l'n1'L.'.a1*1'1'1 zmd 29% ('1iS251II)iIi1.}/' E0 the \\.-'1Tm1v hotly. '["2.iI§.i1.'1g all 1110239 1"c1m'z=mt. I"z;1<'I;'.01*s i1"1t_<.) <*()1'_1v>;i(1c,1_*:uinn zmci 2~1<t<_?q)1i1T1Lg 30% (.1ise1}')i1it"y z":$scs._<;<>(:1 }_'j3;x3~=. (,1(:')x("v".._:'("}'}."_: ='3;(? a\.w:11'ci 21 5411111 of Rs.2._14,200/--.:~tr'>x.x7;11'(;:l':; 1 i1"1c'<.>mc (Rs.:3.5<)0/-- 12 x 17 30/ :?E;jt)';'T.
10. T116 T1'ib1,m2.11 I'1£Iu1:.%"v.'_ (fl'1'L_Tdi-!.'1 *2-ii'VE1:I7§('.1iI'1§§ only Rss.f2T:'3._0()()/-- towel1"(i'S._ '"'}£)s:--§A ;<:>:f1"<..;3.':.*{i'(_T~1'1i1105»; 2-md f"ut'u1'c-7 u1'1i'121p}:)i1'1ess.
r I'h€-r 'Vi1'1z-1c1c%q1[.1site ;2u'1(1 rcc11?1i1"cs that <'r1e;1ime11'1t
\-'\7E1S i111:}faqj;%i.1V§.{:{i§;j§_: in the 1'T1(')5'apit2:;11. Htfz' 'l12.115:s --.s'1.1f'f"(-'1'i1'1f_>;S mid 1.:11(k>1'\wr.1'1i'. 11.3111' SL1rgmficsV}:..11V(1_i1fip12;m1:1s:,1'1avci- 'I366-:1"1 i.1'1_sc1*1'c(_1 and it 1'(*qz.1i1"cs ()1"1§>'5I.j11([)i'<' $1i:'g(::--;'y-__fox? 1.11011' 1"e111(":\-21.1. I.')is;;1i)i1iEy to w1'10l(r 'h_<.5CE}_,r. isv;_é?1~:,--:Lss«c;r:€:s;t;:(.i at 3()%. '1'l"a(é ("'.1&l.i.l}.1£..i.111. 1'1as.s in locau" wi£'.1"1 (.1isz;1T5'j.lii v zmd (jiis(".()1'1'1I"(">1"I. E:I'11"(:.)11g1"1.()1_.1E his 11'§"<'. 'E'11c;r1*t::~_f'<:)"1_*§*. we cleem 11 111 to z1we;11"(:i z--1 s:s1.x.11'1 0.!" Rs.+.i"50.()(,)(')/-- " « . V' g)\:
H "51?
_rd.s logs ()1'e1'1'z1C1'1i1.ic.=.s of life 921$ 4--15,12-1i11ssi'. Rs_s.2;"3.(i)(i)€i)/'- 217iv.211"(icr(i by HM.' '1'1"iI.')1me-1.i.
Aw "/ (V)T _t'3_1E':.1_1'<§ ' H}
11. F111'1hc1' . the 'i'1'i}:m11z1i has c1'rc(:1 in 2:1w2,11'c:'1i1'1;._§ only RS.I0.000/-- i".<")wa1'ds 1"1(')1.11'i$1'1i1'1g_§ 1'00(:1 2--mcl ;1.t"';'{-->.uc:121m' c}T12'11'\9;es. The sa.111e* is i112.1<ie(_;11z.:1t.? for {E10 _..:.'._c2:asV(')'1L:;lb;-1.:
('.1aim.21m. has m1de1'g01'1c :.1'eat111<:1a1 as i:'1p__z-1fi.e;1'1'1 A_170i' mO1*_<:"
H1211'; 112 days. He nligght. .1121\.~'c: :;~3;T)0.1':A1 'su'}':)$t.é1.1:1:1:11'V£}i1i'ig)1.1}"1{ t.<")we11'<is the said. c11a1'ges._r '.1'1'1c_=.r0'f'.<_):"c>_ \=\-*fi:.v'L*;i_»:'.L§"111' it': fi': l (:.3 award 3 sum 01' Rs.20.0xO{)/-_ I()\5va1j{"Es" ('.QITt\-*'t'.'._\/"£.l11('('. n(_)1,11'ishi1?1g f(>o(1 an-1_c"E:j-- 21!.:_icé1;c1:';m_:.'._ 'C_.r1r1211f;.§e.s as 21g2"1i1_'ast 1 O , O00 / -- a\v;:_rdCd 13;; 1 1'1}: 'i'V--1'Aii.§_1.:i3.ié1.1' .V ' = W "'f*71_,if1'1'11L:}1;if;' t_1"1'a:1_""I'1'ibLiiiézk has €'1'1'ec1 in a1\v2.11'(.1i1'1;,§ mliy RS'.«1O-,()()E)/..i"11.I:11r<- 1'11c-r<:1i(:':2.1§. expenses. T§.'1c said _ --:111'101.115'it, _i.s'..ir1aCi.c-:qi.1a.1':L:. T116" <'1e.1.ima_nE 1"cq1.1i1*es (..>11_<.* "111('5;.'<:9 5fi','1'A:'_2gEa1'}? for i'*'t'§"I'1'1(.)\-'21E of i1'np1211"n.!~; a1'1('1 }j'1(" W11} 1'1;:\*c Io '--}f)(',~'.dI' 1E1£:=.1:1"1e§i~i().:1.1 expenses e-11?sc'i (..>1h(>1' i1'1(:i(k.:11:":21_1 cx_})e1'1s(=*$. 'I'1[1ta.:"c3'f'(;}r(:..:iRrE* deem il" fit to awe.-111:1 23:. sum of RS.2O,O(}O/4~ ' €..<')w2':11'c'E'r3-- "fut.u1'e n1cd1'c.:2~1I (:'X}Z)('I1St-.'S. The c]e'11'r11a1'1i_ is c>.mitIecl to 2-1 i.oia,1 ("<'>111pe1T1sation of Rs.I§.95'480/~. as ag;_u'ns:-- R:.'.4.7().7(;)0/-- au.re11~Vcf;cé:'d 2.a_fx_r I.}1u '1'1'ibz.1.1'1e.1I with i.1'1E",c'>1"es1 2,11'. 6% pa. £'1'on1 the (_i;'aIf('*-«L)*f=T..j.)t-*i.i_fé.i<;11 {.111 $119 clan: of 1'c?e1I_isa.ti()11.
The l1'1sLT:1'2'1r1('%c CO. V is CIi__1'(*<t_i:c2(.'i {Q '~:Iir.*'~1)(')'.:.5i'I'~, the c.n1'1a11c_:ec.1 (:(m1pe:'1sz'1i.%o1'1 a1r:1'('*;.11'iaI.. of 1./-- 1,(.)get1'1cr with i1'1t".e1'eSt. wi1'h.ir1"£1.._1)C1'i.O'd (':17 ;1";)V1'i"r..'\v<)cE(s f"i*O1'1'1 thc ciam C of 1'c(_tcip1" of copy of the '}"KL.lVC_.1g§Ai,;£'1V.¢t"»]'[' v '='r1{1'h;;:1:'}(Lj.'*e,ci --.(':0f1*1pcnszuion. Rs.1..O0.000/-- 0 L11 __ (3)17 1_hi?_ with f;.1*(')pm1'1;itj'i'12H';¢"A i_1'i'i~s3j1"'es1". shall be kept. in ¥<'ixed E)e2;)osit in the f12;1_11'1w::v {.335 vi'.}"1(I' CIE1iI"£'1E11'}I' in 2.11'1_V N21iTi()1'[1alis€%(:1 or S(.jT1'u;£f}Ci1.i'I'(?(1 E-3211'I;1_{A.fF:'?1f;.1 pc..=_1*ic)(:1 of yc21.1'$ a1"1(.1 rc1'1c\vat)1c> by '21i"1'<1t;11a:=:1"'5"}.§é'2:_1.'s. W21 11 }')L'.:'I'11iS.'-$]'(')1'1 to him to \.Vii_1"1(i1*a\.\r the i'1T11C:1M't?st: A2-z€ipt1'jE": ed 1: I1 e1'c.*()1"1 pc1*i(Jdi(t2-ally'. 'p f() }:3'01't i0 1:] E': 1" 0 im 0 11: st 'Fl'1~t:'i 1*c'-;'.IT1ai111':ng__§ 2'=m1()u111' ("Jf Rs.2.4._78()/-- wit..I"a ..1'1aI1 be _*c;.*.k32':1.st-é(i in {:"1\-«*(>:..11" 0? the <'*Ez1.in1a.1'1t . 11111ner(¥.i.;.1t'c}y (>11 (.lq'.)():-*.ii of the S2'E11'}}t:' by The I.:'1s;u1"211}(.*(* C0.
The 31:31 1.11'_0ry a1n(:)1.11"1t cicp<)si1:c:c'E by 1;}"1c _.I§"_1:"i..js'9:;..r:9_éV::.1§'<ir:__C<g. shall be 1.1*d1'1sI1J i1.t'ec'1 I10 {I10j1.11'is(ijp110113.1"CZ'1:z:i'm:$'=7I'1*i13i,1112$. irmnediat eiy.
Office <1i1'ectcd to d';'>'7'c'."1.\'-'a.f_VI'h('.' 21-x..>ve':1 rd. ei,_ct__{.:)1*:.1j1j}my. sd/..
IUDeE §\='1ga1/--