Central Administrative Tribunal - Cuttack
S Behera vs D/O Post on 1 August, 2023
Sredo7, af Fare a 3 8 as eS OO:
280) yy A NO, ¢ © x CORAM:
peed Versus-
~ r Genera soo KES THINGEALS s & Vlember {A} ar Das eee Fran Kian trrese, apes "ah EPP e aes ne LUEHTESS t & report abnin 2 A}cl submitted TA BSH fer the tour in & APR "
ga PSSA ~~ OF % res ta thre 3 & reds PaO wee "o> y "AO GS Ye fom 2S % & oy oa re wien, sMHfter ym, he sul iy derat EMER EO MOTT out and wit ard ge he being Oppartun him THE allows Without H jay af minc apphcat toon him AS vy A RE < AN, ion, Berhampur be redué ed by ane stage from Rs. $8.00 / fo S400 / In the pay Matrix level S for a period of Three years with effect from OLOL2 ADGS without cumulative effect.
hd wee, 'ad ine tthe the ek zt exyeeheer dye ey SEN y. we pary PS reler Ehat Spi Behera will wwf Viow of the circumstances discussed above, the action of the appellant in claiming food bills for i * Pood J that he was on leave IS not't UN en hiffis permissible to officials when they are on Govt.
Daty ard when they are away frum thelr Headquarters, Therefore, claiming of food bils, which are not actually due to him, is amounts to wrong TA claims and it justifies for taking up the Disciplinary action by the Competent Authority. Bat kere the punishment awarded is found to be too heavy, Therefore, t the punishment of reduction af one ~ ta Rs, $4,100/- tn the level & five) of pay matrix for a period of 3 (three) years is modified as reduction of ane stage from present ve thet cumuilat 3 Ny 2 PRP & dafan .
Orig e ior ap x Ane a "PON He s d re * 'YY [paris ¥ mate Ny Re ¥ x Mention ¢ it 8 OE } | consciously u ~ £ henypora YS cd did t hen, uthority an st Be xy + HAY N OTe es © f ary i Ian vis Aled their gental Res % all consequential bene Departe icant The main p x i g ie .
N ES a Aitted Bs € e on dene Le oe oe ies fen. a ms ad ae ae pw beXS] Pees oo seas Ss eer ie peed st fe [L, bes rated . fey ae Ce * ae Beane. of ; n4 oe Sone oe , f 7 ene eee aren aren pains haat th a bea 4 & x eA oe ae) 'Beak oy taf bed 'es % raat pn $ we Focal wes set oo, ers ee Paso ay annoet oat ye ek 233 ey) corrabar eS be 3p Bead . os wy pn eee Co SS oud ry 4, tS Fags 'at nd ey tees Bend 3 ye een.
bead oot "neh Pomel pon cnea' Nyy RR eal lap "ant eS tee oe te, wey ware Ate ee aid mene Cs Goel < " t a shook oe pte wn rem: tng re Fon' pas aoa a ie | wort Prood aes ae Lars Ra pt ' selec :
ms yore peed +p te ee, boat Pe eine: boned fi pre a 2s, Fe ed bas foe cen a Faas ARS Cad a ' Fea yee ie fey 3% t "aol wee, dot tne be pe 43 acd hen ee £3 food ry nat £5 or, KRARK rac * at fae ea, 1 ye he wee rod tt 4 tft Pata' wane: woe ons ae cnt Fae Qe pet .
baad eanoed $e Sood oe Pact pe a7 ing aia Cert, we aes eat ued a5 Of on ves Tae om re ne, ; Ls Stas? binet oo pot cae een ret ie pee Ce -, oe sheet +o tg. o Pa woe 'at ~~ fre a ted aA ws, tng 9 wed " Saal Fooa' s ne, Cunt ' ea a, pe eheae sheet aa see, me "qeoel Kens pees, yest, F i in pee ed pa :
: re 4 ' sored a +f? , fon : 'nteind age) vee % it se " ae bene a afd ae oo a at oa a fue 7 oa ae L wey, fee va ui 4g fs od :
ae "apt o we ae rat , oo seme, B Z yee fm, 4a ie ae, ea Os = "o wen boond oe es Sapo! pay na OTe * aye ; ewe Pad fittes vs ee Ae wn, ted ia one ecnen oreen, fev re, noot as oo : tes oa ie o a iS % a as oy ; : feet orem " jin sd ne Pa ; rot he Gnd wn fe hea os pen, ee, eed Sherk: Le on, fa wrooey . Senne Le hee' pany Sewell views os, "fe, . we "ent was) ee Z a Ged Had yea wien, Part Aba wet paved hee arn reed renee aan Aes yee Sawa pecine 'int Pos] . . ' re Fane ae coral boas Cat seed = os, y eed J ; Net iret, % * 7. nes Ce re ~~. Fess ment re as baad fal * 'hao Re hn 4 oe wy raved Coe oO wn aes 'net r, Fas) ie ~~ S me is oN od 2 oy if We Lf; hea ay fos whe Saal 43 s ae oe fae od dead , ; yo of oe orn eae ; Be "bine we "an a . ed eet lind mm $ ® oy 4 as wre, ~~ as he * Pats of Sa Saal aa pee Aree, ee a ae fang' a load pots ¥ y at 'e cast eos fon ween, Sait bane Paad ty a eS wy ioe nee m poe, x one wens * * ed on owen oO Se a re io By ae bee ricais hens Sead! My rey, yy Ped " es pone oh a A, nee we Jock ; ae eee San oe eaene bye Py aes conse! 4 gt can "ey oy Cina we ' ee dob fae, Sous tome, ae v7 we, Yes vues 4 23 ¥ us Saat yy, At "a oS bored, ah hoor. 7 we ee, Brag tind seal Ease rreek, as ao aad 2 wnt peer ee rend "5 bs he 7 ooped we ew face pooh hee pan pal 'at ie ae 'a nsies ' re poh etn ' Le wp ane Son zr wher: 3 3 " wa fe - ae he tee kl a Boo a von = oe os ; ee. a3 . ; & at wn woh saeed ais, Nat pee veer 'ete! Paty oats ps "sah of peed ae haw? ag ty Neg a ces need, an tedeg! ieee wy sere "eee? ra pon o ae enn ie ny " ba aS et ous ie mS oo ae a3 7 leheee keatedk pan "ened Ms hee be Py obs . bk. en mae Dane gion rhs ae wig o _ . oy, rs aoe ware Sead 23 a3 b 7 foe, pees oe . of * om at as cae af eed eee, Oa, " , pone v ro yt th 4 os woe as fe ya vad 'sad 'at pon fn fen "he ent ay res ree, pon . wy ta pn: £ reeed, " ye bod ty tho var lead aes My fees he ed oe Pn aoe oe oes ware cree, ox ae ry re i"
a ity ity vad Ba neo nee o~ aaa ood. goa wees we can x m e5 yee f*, relbnk, pan teas ¥; ws at ioe wore 'na 35 aes, whos ™ %. fom < Saad bad "en to tye 7 * ~% oped 4 we ao ortird, ty pea ak os, oe, pon Peed oon aw teeta Wa. ¥ ' g g ' nes weaned, wei, brit Soe ee . saa Sanne eee' i vo a; ret "anit mtd to Saat ae s 'ap 'poe Aes ~ Bre me Loe a ree Led "~ in peed we weed shoot ied ae = ee ot fr eat ee on ad' baad a sane bd oe Atty ee, tec wes at oe, mm par teed oa res cond wed werd, ~ ap ae rk Pye ey iF Pad 4 raped a a , oes net Neeeed aes ay 'sat! ad vpn Lk naa Nd Foal ne As poe: ae . Ate. wen neon By hs me oe ee rons food 5 ' om g fac aoe ih a ¢ hoe, 'ned sh fos oa "Lp beh ede vee mete fons wos kt ree om a ik peed oS cece CS : oe wegen a an teeaes om tS oo yy hed cae ook oar ve 5 " * rey of f:
a - e if ve .
fined . an. Potad al a rey baad shine gre - ied tnetiny 'Bs veo ee BL aaa 'ane wee ded o% ee ¥e. oe . pee wee ines deed wes ed ae "nt oa ii ico rs ver re, ne, haga ral aft rans tee dane Seert? aa LG ty a, "i Feats) yon a cae 74,3 2" sane Raia ean ee ag eh = ee pons Sed bg bis "
to * om eon eta pe ato hood aon geod, Eset ane. O63 ete ened Paes rene, : oo wane Ww cae . es , sg ocd "oe oad on weed, Seka, ' orn oy one, a one res ; bes is pe poe bee! pe wt fy, oe ~ na? Ls, acl oo Sade ae eet peas fen, ead ~~ ko ms geod ak "nat 'wad eas Kooba, ieee " vo veeet ae Seen' Pi sop me fone ni ES ay a vanes oe . ; ;
fod id a ore Vs 'se bin ae aes hoot ers Ls, Ppeee tee " it A a3 cath wares Oe tet on tent Re ye ben ts 3 hood ones neers eed ae Fc ig e 3 ya peer Boca je m Scbepiet Mood winte, Sees, pene Sern. brane Saat oo as oe) oh nes pe pce det o bs aL: en es SS pac iy Be eae "oy a oe a ae a on oo dos. xe B : 'mt wen ad Sag Si Ae ee ; om barney x ig oe oe pee va eas hs yo bent: 'wet ea eo Poet at cS cpa ; : ye ro 7 wes ook at Po wre ye sein ; fast onan : ae ay od eee roa Fs pees pres a thes Pes 'ed See me ced fen va ve ween £%% ot oe) es on oon : na Eacaees * et By ae o vot ocd son pe. beck pias rn Aer And pad cad Son CE pon 15 ot aah. es or. raat} cS oo a oe Re we el op ee ais ee Pa coal a aM 1 £3 Ak pee é mt vost be 4 os bon y joo tad tea Yak Sek my ook we ; 2 Bs 3 oe Oo ee ton Gs fos ay io oe x Be oe rane 2 "ng *: y, por DA. a Be 5 gor eet open. ' a ee A Seed tne ae sot ns pe 5 im based Soa ae a wa oe ee ze ft gem i ed. Bead aes od oft ns od ek im $ Ae Poo oe "at enh: nad oe ae a es oe press wy na on poses a en oy 'a6 ret SS 'Sdenei oe wine, on, coe nd ay 78, Gs sae) im a pee, sheet bot eke, epee a aA ane Pied nee pe be 6, ry God om : we bo re a5 a Local Fa on Y ot Ze we we ve heed ade ny wo 5 ¥ wna a net Bees hae eos Ea oa bari Ras Lo4, pn ; bas ny ied pees pat ia 'eee, "as at ma 'nod necen oe aloes ue "ee e tye " ne aes oon Cu oe sat os. Sees ™ to hada' 3 Proce t m ¥ Yo, heed ae ua ay et nee panes Sedee " oe et c ve sade z Powe, fed " ¢ % on "oak on ~ oy poo wee pean. on Shee ss D: x BS es oS id an shed : 43 Senstn: re se:
Se 'beet val 43 me ; dint os nares reas tape, baa aes 3 dot Recood wr ad ee) font wae prove : 3 Feel 5 Nhe rae) a * ay we fen "h 'set g etd 998 we ;
pad Oe We ae is Oe :
fers an os ons Seeeae see ee i ay vce nett re af ort 'mel saan: vere, rs eeted: oe, hot ny Le .
ra " teint ea Pa , aere6 bee Weet trot Nil 5, bey power peel £3 ass LA 7 ~~ La.
yee Bg Oe 3 ee ete Sodio Poa he y On ors neds Set fon wa C3 : oe Pid ve Se oe os a ne, z, xa 4 ite ? dp sy; wn ayer a re a eee) if or3 pass os os ow Pe 2 a ae tat ee Fe ws Ws wei we Le < a tad fee. wee een wee CG oo a, § ag ye on me he weeeee ores fos, he « Ss ; Lan roe wn i yom 3 Pood Mey pon 'heed, a won he an aK oS ae aoe bd oa an ben red: Le senerd pow ms es ot, rood feet yee we: AS Sa pn it = 'ak "ee bn : when yen ; Be eth fox Sea ae. ees pee, 4 Ee s Ky wow, aces ae asgl a4 mm £3 gee See, pare vee Coe
-- : ¥ 7 eA at Beet ot ee, Z % "sh eae) Pocca of aes ye ae ot boon Bod agent Tat
4. enn. wr, ¢ ee pee.
Hraoad oe fon "on en Shen Se Load mm oy WG wer hese