Uttar Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Ltd vs Haryana Electricity Regulatory ... on 24 February, 2011

[Cites 0, Cited by 3]

Appellate Tribunal For Electricity

Uttar Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Ltd vs Haryana Electricity Regulatory ... on 24 February, 2011

 .'£"§i3E ;*?;'§?'§*--E§;§;._«§k*£_'_3a_".i';3 *':rg§z§§,:::3;;_;:§:*é;:>;s-- - r._=s:'£m ;E:..»Ei¢::frRc?:*?r°i'%
{a§PaL&;._  w'm=sm.ci mm
%~...§.§............»* '--G3¢¥.?'3-A4,-...«'£§;9'...m.".ut'>*;?

   
 

_'::s,::.;s.-rec: ;% 1'}.3'¢'~§+& ?'7°E3§i§i¥fi,§&§°:'_,*'a.-3€}.f§'§'

-.3»

   

ﬁg

-4

 

f'§~§::>:*s'7§:::_§::§ §§:*£--2" Rail-:.a:2s§*; .1 _ 'tf§3_g"§7:~3x:-_§*::3is::--a;§ E§°§emi:3;e:°
%§£2:§'§'s§e..¥¥x"¥z'. Justiiiass   '

  
 

 ;$%udi--s::_m§ :mm3m=.:~
in $3333, :'s'2:»3€%:é'zf;

Utt--a.:'  B3T%,é'¥i"?'\»*'E:tr::f~z':':; N3{:f;E;?'3"E 
'%'.§*ss*::s' =;§_%*;--- its  

.. ';r"~v3;:)aE§a.:*.<E {5}

{€;.msnr.:eE- fax'  ..<\{>';::se:iia.m' :'

H.
L':i::_u..n:s<c::! far we 





 :::a::;§:. e,§M'*s::s'$:'m':;1ss*; 13$. i'}:¥§;'E"§;':*§g,v_;}'§;¥_§i$.§;>iZ3:Ei§*>;L§a    \

 

 .£\;3;,>e;?,:§  Lﬁtaar Ha:rya:na SLEE 'xf§'ire:2:m N=§g.a.m §.§1§s:::;'ir.:s;agi 
  'Eh:-2     the  
  by tha ¥~%a«f:w;12*za EEa>c§:'i::%'iy 
'C'C.--'-i'¥'i,ET§"!V.§-'5;~',:'5.£iI'.1¥': in  N4:-..  2 of 2:338, "§'%*za :3:"s:ie:z' 
'2.'>.«i".*'."%   in :'.€_.=€«;:zae::i cs? ARR far £3i:strEb=..:i%m': ef»;_na:.?z'  E§:ug:»p§:g'
8.ju:¥»éjn:"4:-S8  r ;Ay;:g3s2.%i:;ani {cur ihe §,:=:~:<a{ E0t38»~{I>9,. "wh_§i«.-:9  
  is: ffhe mﬁssr' of review or:  prayei' Q3' '%;§'1:a%i Ag-peiiarat
w2he.jre%:3;»- --r»;»%;-§e»::.':ém: wag made «:3? the point an whic§% :*~:*-2x»'ia=.=w wiasc $.a.=..sgg'§':i'
:f»"":'.
-2. T%*;z~3-- s'.-amiss :~z::*'e that the £\p;>e.=3i$an*i* w'¥*:c«-- is a s=;:.:c<;esso':' in %;:t;=.sre:st
(T? the. .<as'::siix=>.rE1TsE:a2 Haryesna: Siaia EE.e;c:?tri<;i't--y Ei~3s3+:=..r'c§  -.t>$::3n  wéh
'£333   c.i§.34:rii'::.:_ti:mi afasté' rertaii stéppiy fe=¥¥cawin_g We :.:2";§F:aL;;r:ci'§i1.rag:_:
stzf 1"-ﬁe:-: s_:aiG_'_ Eisxami. The .«<\;.1g>e$Ea_m on 3%,'§'2..2{3Q}' fi-5912;? an _a;:;:2§ir:;e::ii<a:n
'fi~>:=  Reveizzze .¥?:eqL1_§'§'em:»<3jrri:t r;A¥<i.R} far we .?':'z"ea.nc.§a§. 
2i3G;%~£'»:E+§ ;:«2"o,%<'<::~:fmg;' t.§':e»:'eéEr3' zarmuai .f'~'f~3V%§'§:L2~5:'.= ;r§qL;'§s*+'a::r3ez3i of
-Rs-,--z3"§?"i;'E.?V{3i mi*£i§§on2 c;mr':'€-isgsaanaiiixg tr} R..5'..ai?'5siG,a"é--G nxéiiiarx' nan'
=w:;;n?.=£2_«i.it:s.:'a§ am! Rs 'i£1=S3?_:3iI3 rniﬁiafm of s"s?a$m*1ai2¥«_;--f.  

 r'na"ii.iQ.:".: Q? n_e.a':«iss:'iiff §§'ii'3£'1.t";'§'_£'~:' .f.3€--.2fm':~_.'>; me. €ji;c2r;r:r:-iT~isas;ig>:3._ 'Was-

-d_,.-'\'.\\



 §':¢as'.~:«3;4*.;e_~:2' a ta-rm' iiircgiaisr an  '*1  €:g'za5<ns*.  it-' §'§E-:=.=-5:3

 

 ;%'%2e<.«'§ew Petii:h321------mn' 34:": .2~:...i'§E3'  __'.-jg '€135' .:'ev'i<3\.-V Cs? he   am

i3.o;>P:Tz§$.<;--.'za:-;--: --c%ls3*;.:'~2Tzfi   '33  0:? *€%":z~": f«:3§io'~.=~.iis't{.; gzoiirﬁiiss;

3.3

W%1ethe:*7t§1e ':'\-'ed-:_3£i-'*;_é:':;n2«:z2E i'<;ssss~ =;*e<:iu+¢'i1::m i'a~:'g;aat m'   by
'the Iiiomwsésvsicaxw has:   imgaaci on "Lina RE'.

-s=.s§:-assay to he paéd by the S'{&'s*t£~:s {3~»::vemm.ent '?

':3; '\:"z'hei%1e;"zhe  :3? acﬁdiiésnai Lméts of e£eci:*i~;:iiy av:4:§£a_'m3e
.~:m accourri: 03:'  2re:5=u~;:i§m*. 'was s";.,si1':§y aiiczcaieci Eu was':
zagrizxuﬁmrai ~C:£}E'§i§L§ET'2$3£B?

<2} ';.-"~.*";*-.3s.>;ihar it-E13 estimaiis;>:3_ cf    corzsu:'--n.=3r n:at3:eg.a's~y

=,.s--.=:;2s e¢i:€Gi;?+'i'3':ti?i--'?

 {3(mn'ni§3is'éa3s"1 n:=;,é_r=:c.i-2:2' the ¥"\'§3.v.%¢§:>.a~' F'e*:§i;éan foiiiowing winicii this

£3§>f:i€t(§5i  Q: :~:_--':' ;;s:s'e:'<*3:T&~:2'ti;

 

 x'¢;c:az*dim;,='  the ,é«.p;:a§§;ant, it had. pwpzszsed  Sass red:z.s::t§m

ia:'gE:_t--   in  'fish-a--m§a§  .i2--§';'=i"3Tr*?--.D8 t:?=."t Wee' 5.?-iiG'A$'¢'3':.f1"'.'Ai.t_*:'»'bT5»'it£')'s'} E';e:.»:£
(::rz:§e;r'e<:§ ii': 2'-e=<iu1c:éa the 'icasss §e~r:we;E by an adiiiiégmaf'  'm;:sé<En_g 5

.-

'1 n  qnsre'     §§~;gurie £3f%h=e=;¢r3ar~

 

bl



:--A'

Vim-2_; Sass ievei was  and :°:mr';i"3i§,--«*'ss=:*:'i'§:1§§j iﬁa'%'a'r§_;eI% m' :3;'s_"':»f»:.~« 
ific-I'-*m'1a's::';<:m:>n   far  --'re;'€i3L;f¢iiQ.r§ of  :1 $115: amaze: 
_w%*:i<;'h is an im:;3E'Cri3=a§:25€: f§gL;te, it is manta-n.<je::i i-Em:  C?C}_mm§.$S§§)'r:
$33; di_':'er:i'i.i'2g;=;  .uf_i.§'ii;,e' 49:9. :'e:iiuc:e. has 21332  :5qiie§iiim:a1;a¥ "i  armies' tiagza
;3:'<>;ms<=:<éi Eggs; target of 2'€:"ﬁ':é~'e in order in generaie z=;a(_':'L::':'L§L¢:s'L:'>=-:32: reve:':":=..:aev
of  c:rr::~r'.<_=.s::. deprived 'she Apps-Ei:ant of asﬁzjétiomssi subssidy. The
§'E'@ihQ(1'3('3§s3g3f ussed 'fits' caicuiatéhg the efféciemy gain as' 
.<:s'>:2s'ea on accouri 011' %:ri::i§ing the gag: th1'::Lagh addéiim-3.332 ':'e'xzenue, 'far
sz"uri'he:.' ma-azs :'educt§0n cs' :'*}~'-L"; augm to been examined by 

Elomimsvsion. The compuiatézzm  the reswznue fs'~:f21'n ihe. 63}'§:§{tié*:£':C'~,='

gain  been asmsaci at by ma Elmnmmissian by a:_v;wsit;is~:.*.i:*;Q  

 fiiz;1;~:s r<a«:Eucti_<3r1 f§'~Qm. tmth ag;rEc2uitu:'e .aPd nan agr§'c:uE*:u:re

3

 Q? the .sa\s'edf --unE'f£s $18 1:'? ML} in saw' nan;

 

a_;;:*icuLE':ur»:2 <_<:3tesg*e:'§r  as in _<:ieie:m§.me the figure :2?'  
was: m:§t gimjper. This cm1~§:::.nEat§0.n wras wmng 'i3$3C?;3=L§'S8- fhe re:\.v*snLve;
fro-.m: €§~'f{'§.G§6~ﬁ'£ﬁy gar: Ema; £3.s3.£-;¥er7:<3j:';a--i~s;ed  try' :'~;gE¥é:f1g  save-:3 z_.=nii'2:
ha.-ii': fmrra ii{.=_:'a. Emtzi' m;<n ag:a%§v:::u':ture czxtzagary, T_h'i§<s n':a':'-'{h~.<':doi<.'3gL.'3~y
Wi€~3.'I:'; W]:"C}r1{;}  is net rea§LEs§tica3§y ;:.<3ss--ibEse i%":s'ai--t;hae unifs} 3631-'8T3 'my'

{8£§1.£Qé:§}§} R1:-2s5:aes'_En'--t1§_1a a__:.'3ﬁs'uEiu;:'e' «seam; be teminsaifg' ifz"a:s's:>_3€err=.=3ci

ts;  L:-':;a:~n a§;ri::L:E'cu:':3 cz2.:ie.gs.Q2'y.. fs:.s*-- timfciismiéng reascms:



'«w,,.__

,.,.«..

 fimn r?e:,:;h;;ci:iQn?  _t:jt1--:"m--'z*:ea'z'a:i¥'ai3--¥  theft 6-12:2.

  ¢:.@*r'z&:u1'nes'$. Erﬂm w§'3§'_C;?'; '§;hez'"t

 rims: I'cE£gZ}jF§1 GL§.§%EL!-F53  rnainfiy  Em' i:ﬁ§:§?§*::éiE€.~f€3 Mai"?-'"s-:'~;*
%i§i§3§1ng,*:sa§'e$ Ea: ihg e?a:grit:_L;i;i.=.s:'ae3. CE3'i%§g&Ci'f'y snnéy. if :8: 5:§xeft_ 33$
:~eé;:::;>'rt§3_<>i_; the GCé_E~1E3.?L§'£1"i;§3)ﬁ'<"§§"x is «;:s;':»:1s:é:%V_er?e.a:%1 'far the '.:.,a>._«me=,

is  a_m:¥

*$.L£.§1fS:i'3't;t3i£¥Ri§§,»' when '*§%*;e-- _*;C;C>i'1$.L?.3{{"{i&§" starts 3f;3£"3'SLii'ﬁis"=g the

:-'2;Es:;c:t:ric:§:Ey in an s.-*stih§r.::a¥ way; thee eo.nsc::n;3tiom sf sanigz that
ca':.ege:jy i:'screa.s€es'. E3»imEia:'iy, in thee case of under ra;::;-mmg
ax' ioaci wharezeiefe if the s::'orr"eci ieari  c;1ecia:'ec' or feiund m the
c:'a'ia=:gm"y, we c:cmsum§3ti0n m'? cnniy {fat categ:c:'y is gazing in
énc:*€~:.e':s2e».

ma  he

if thveé ﬁx;:;3e¥i;ani'  éxbice in re.ci=..ss:r23 the C:3mmr~3rci.a§
aa§}r'}ic:u¥E:tr,a%;'§*: citiminated feedersv, tin-an {Em anaargy so 
 transfeerwsd to another feeder

c:a.rm.ei hawzng mm

a§,g;z'§cL2ii:L:;'e. catege--r'y of ¢€:nsu_:m3jr's;.
mmrmercéai fn:z:.m 'is;a'r3hn€:c:a*E £91323 .redvu=m.=3d 'f{"<Z3'm the r'?E'cufﬁ:u

ea.%ag':3'ry' s:an.rm&. be is*an:a;¥af.ed €02'  ts: min 2::-3§;;.ri%cLs%EtL:.:f£¢

Qaiagcsry,  C5Q§T1_m§f§_S§:C%n; §Ei.eg'a=..§¥y :1-*3s;i:--.2Ic--.*;€+,=;:;i  §33L£.;'£}§3il€T§3:* Q9?'

 .»"«._:__\;:_::,=:31E,i*f.-":r3t..i;~.3;'  f,'Lt'(3E"E3;<.=,-.

%hE-ﬁéfﬁirelg t%1§ie--



 

:2} ii?  :'§ar'g;?3i-- 's:-;-f *~*§:;::=im~;iTs.;s:a3z.a:2z':";. its ::.m'nsa%d:es.s's;a::é f't:'~'t"'r.>s.:1:'3'i{£)L3'§§i"3j§

l'''
u

'-«.42

' ::omn1ers:,i:s'i i::t»%s«s.s23;:§ng

 

  f::<2::tz-- ree<:im:i£is:é.r: »<;~§"the iassas 13::  

' ;;isicy ga-in so Qasrzjptzted tag'.t:0n.sE:ieri;n§  $353 -$;9.:vi%n'g

 

.» 1

?%'.'i<:>.m= :€,=1';i'mi<;a§E  red.L_.:cti»:m >&\rh:ar'e this sawmg  30%;: :0.

§'isC3¥7«aiQ?'?{T;:U§iL!F8' t'<:ateg;mti:es:, anti a~e:w:ai'nésn*g

A

  rgaspectéw .g;a'ia2g;::ri3&s unite)»;
ma =a'ev'em,;:e so g'+3ne.rs-zted .<;:h='a§i  ~;f:'-my  :::'<;::*es;.
 saie ta " HT ccmsurner ::ate=.gm'y apgcaroved by tiia

C.:.m'm':é~.

 

ﬁinm  beer: on hi».;;;h»;»:«z' séaie fer years ancé the
has; been foiiowed in 'me order for ARR <3?' 2.DO8~{3$. A chart.

has mean Vgiven to show thai in the year 2G8?'--G8 tiaaa azzmai

.-, -=;- r\'

s=.a%!:=3 wazz; "i.>;.»-.:.5'? ¥'si'é'U'S' '~N§":§i€--2 ihsss ;»3ppmv'ed  M233 

idms and 1m. the year .';:1Qi3§?_~O§ the a~:=ma2 523113 was '@558 Wu.

{)7

but 'the: {3omn'n'ss.§<:m apgp:':eved the 52356: at 1820 Mus... The
ac:m'a§ Cf0t"::¥&..ts'1":;;37§'iO_n fan?' .e:*;zs2.ry-- year  been §:sa=§_~§w.e 
-estimarizaxé $s3.Ees= in HT categasvy, in the 'fin=e.::;"e:m';33 }'-€EEi{i" :Z~3{¥{}8+
{F9 maria    §«'awr';ing_.; 'gap ft)?' firs'? h'a.i§_' ya', the yezérazr

'; ';:,;ai.rs@ -::':a'n.:=.Lz:3~:gztimfa smd a'c::tu;ai

 

'b'§'~':'§.'«,aK_:'§':'€?:',¥'i' '€;":j.s?  7  7   '

mezr:_$;:,:m;_3§.ic2':?a-- . "  €.1'orf:1':1'1'£%s$iA0r: hja's.2  Vr;,:1.§"<:::;:ifz2s"img i;'m=.2

'¢'€s--'~1é%am<¢;=~;h'§'g}h:a%i' Si 'i§"¥;é§h' the A;::;'i:'¢:é31';€i€3':'.~:s £i*;8;¥._Ema?._=3_; \:'v%1i'a%;%":

S§:i£"ﬂ€'



,.,.-.

1%.

'J5

far  t'he§:?1::' the? aiém-as .re.«;en;;e '.?';)avsj£s::§ an aei.Ls_aE_

¢:'---:ms'um;at'Eos'::, K!1i§'?§C'%": me2za'_n:-:--  ii':e2_;3--'x.;:;>.t3~§iis:rai. wag :--::2e:a>.é.x.*§.2'--ag;

2"<.=éw.:"--  frtm":'-- 'xthée {E3'~:2x1£¥2't:m=;21:=::t 'which   mar:

wh:;«::t.-- it augiﬁ {:3 Ewave r.=3:oeive_:i. é\ce;m'di11g%y:M ih'

('Li

C_';:m"m"sEs5s.~:--§§;_n'2z: esi§m:.+iié(m £33'  's'e$'u'i¥'E~;'=,=?d §:t"s time T"£'3»'e-*+E§:§'siJ:?3

has.-as of R3.2E3.8 ssrrmag. Exec-uz=din.giy, ma <;'»3m'm:s.seLi0n's

rn.Leih.a::£i:Qic::gy of :;a§<:u§;a:t§2'1g »'3{ﬁCiF3¥1Ci}' Agaisn anzi -the  fun'
HT categow is wrong 'anti it \:§r't.ua¥'Ey affects the subegéciyv of
the State (}T«Uv<=.=rntn«2mi itmhe Appaixtam by as zmziuciion cw?
;:a.z's.:>u:';c£ 168 crcrres. The finding of the iT3c>rnrnés:$§<m that HT
c<:rzs;=.m':e:'s have: mm'. beezw treaieci saparateéy is ncai: based an
"£33-:=.=st Estimate 83_s:is.="' and to tfmt extent., this fincﬁinég wauiafé
heave :5: C&iSE&§d§:*Ig  an 'the: A*we§E:s:"n:. The L;o:*rsz'r;§:=;s§«3n
wars: i'}f.1f,;}_i,s.<5ﬁﬁ£_e:;§ in m';--§d§_r:g W221: the £38-'2'=8§€i?§U¥'1.BSf&b§§$§"EB*j by
the--Ap;::a§¥i;antL i:\e'-V:';'wé.=x~.én  r'edu@t§on in @fi%svirii3L:tio:n iass-am?

 {sf :-:,<'.ii::§:'té<:»;ma_E  is swzéspiaeedx The ilzéinnmsiim

was gigs new §a.s;s;}fifier:i in hmdmg that x=3::ic£iti4::»r2:a:i avai£:ai>§'Ei_i.y 

pcaxwer an .a»:x:@ur*a*< of Eo'w:=ar ics.ses- wﬁi n=eii:ﬁ~=.er' Ci'3Ei~§'i§j=E3 ih-:~:~=

mg:-L:r:s sa._:pLpi§e{.i Hm' ms: 3"-.£..F  thee: met€::'ec£ %,u.bi% 

::o1:'}SL£m'e;Z=i'S  mus, \.=srm.m'.'¥. mt .im;§a*ct-- the <:a§m..sEaii'::m 



 ix-::x vine us-:'n'1>-:-2t:::>.:':2<:i  weEE§ <2-c::r's::+s.;ms:::'e: saw :'as:_:i:t;~:m£iy
the  vr:ai'=.;rm:; ':13 «me: aa;g:"'§(;i;¥'£i§:';-3< iuhaa weéi CGﬁ5L1§'1":€3.¥'$ wiiji

\

r:-"5:  {my <2-}*;a--av.ge,
Th2:3s-- R913-pom €e--mi~--.C'am;s"mi%as--ian did not fiie ;;3.r'f:}r ::.z3L:'rs'%@t' affiidavii
hm. *'f's§'ea31 w:fii*;'5w' v«.';'>L:'.§§E'3T'i§'.§$'8.§i:'i§"é ;:n;:.éir:t§n§; am.  "'a'L:=:§'Evcav~:iTrzg:

K)» xfxs :'eg'a=rd_s {he ar:idf§i'ona1 §{}{§S i'€3f;fL£Ci.iD§'l tmge': sf '§'°3-E: {he
Ciommissiom apprc_w.<.-e<.'*;  ﬁegjhéer amcaunt 'oi' czapétai
€:'>(§'£-f;°.*f'.~(i§'§L,I§3€P. piem ;:rQ;ms€:ci  'the;  
sezwésing Of such t:Eapi3fa% r3':<penc£i't:;:z*e L3.ii.:)w=a+:i by the
Com.missio"n is t§':a'eLs§;h tariff cf the ccmsnsmers. Efthe. saédé
.::apita=1 S->i§»'.1':"3f'§iL.'.ﬁ-§'.i._Ei-'.1;-.'2 ;orsg:'a=mm~;:= is e»xecut_»-ed, it s.-x»-'-;3~u§c*;
resmt in more icient ogireratim as? the c:¥istrébutéo»n :§3ysi=:~m
and 1c:w».:~2:' the  ieveé in the .s§;sta:m. Thes*efares, irsigygh
 Qfr<L*E3§:¥7I'aZéa§ z=3:<pe.:éu+J'i'i::;zre'  r;~:Me2;i.ai:~<asc¥ ii} :;mm»s;~,g of
.;~."u:i:$iiimr1a'¥.ir::~:5issue? cs'? 

 The £:;L::an':1'.:s'3'§ sf "e§e.r:.t:"«i::éty baakaci '$3.3 jihe ag:'§:::;;E.t§ir':,~3E
{:{;{3'$L§m'€:;I'$'  am 'theba.s'§'s,.:c>f-a:s:=s1.:mg:f£E::>n. Tm: --!~\;:r_a-w;=E§ani
w.;«:s3 :_.§i.re;c.=t<;a1<:'~: $233; the: '£3C%r7ﬂm.i5£si{3n_ tea *fi§e~ data an

   sme:§ imam: i?x«*Eii3*i rm.  to

.«
71,7



 

    

E'§'~,1if;'i'.'si'iZ'l~'?.§',1t'3 fiiaw mi £3-3'E$§{Ii§'iiC-iigi in 't§*-we a2s§;z"§:::.s§'i:,:r;;ai Vatara-sv;.:A:':1s2s's
iaa_2f;.'i:'1-\sI>a3m. A;r0t:--n€:? EH3?" of me. agsféaiulfuriafi G0nssus.'nez'$. in
ms»; State are L:s':rer';€:te;s'3€:£§ Land "ii-"us sL:p';;&y' to sum":
im--n'3¢:3'ifr?'%'i3d $O>?1SU?'s§€%ifS is an we: basis' of  WEE';
i*aé'%ff on  "fiat 'ii.i;«'5=5;.jé:~";-- iirs'es;:3_e.r:::ivs3' Bf i'§*z'€:'* uni'{s-- 's3_:.:;}p§ied;

G--ons_i.c%.a-faring téfse fz21<::=:--:t%m:s_t' agricuiture saies ac::::31.m":. ms---

'2;:§*;';':::'Lfi'  cf'  Mia"!  0*." the £\;;1§.i<e'-E§Em9E., i'h&f~;-*

assuimpticzn of ag:'i::ui.'Eurai -szaies di2;Vt0r';s the ciistrtbutton
3e-as  figam-as and rervztiers the aarne L:m*e.3Eab§e.

ij)e;-fizﬂt in The ags'7sCL.:¥iur:*:--3 categary that is, the dEffe:'em:e
betwerm the reverme geiieréated and the ::»:3.<3t in same the:
;3:_;ri<:L2¥iure':2  weii Vcmsurnars whkzh is Rs.  ::r'm'e_e

i?as'§.:si3¢:?n 'cc::s1sé«:iered  the 22gs'icuﬁL:r~:e subsirsiy pa§ga'::»£e

;v-xv"

3:,» the i,?30vernEn£mt a..n.--:.€ the isnpact cm the a«ticiEtie%na%.

;sa§es.vGi=L.fme jora' ac£:"¢sL:rsm;€" a:i_;i§'{iom?;2¥ 'E% E02323 r'r..;.du£:~t§<>.r:

   

vwaE_i' -su;--:{.:_i'-3; axmzi we :;a.::?;:~E£én';.»' ,::.'e:ys3bEe by ﬁx:-2 f.3t3ve_:i'sm:er'2'<

 Hg:::;f_§:.a2--n:a--..

K

;m§y rm  ;:>._r'-_<::;':§'=.~.«:3:?:io._':':.  in  v$.3§3'3s£3i'?£iE3 «sf n152=£e:'én_g.,

,;g 'The :~3gz'i?cz.zitL2rr3 'tube.

£'.%'.*'.%'1§,'-223  'sa'Ees"~'m£=_¢;;.me ta ziihe' 3Q£"§.i3L1EiL_3fI3'3 <:<m=sums;«.rs 



 

i't_%':az:z'e_. -ca;-1  mzz aa'{_i§t§':}r1'I~3? Saias' {taken in thea ca.ts9:€¥1<>;7§,<' 

:a.c:=;:Q;.zn% 0:'E"' :_ad.='32i%--icma§ pcwar a>;rsz§'Ea§::é::+;.V Tm: .ia'»;$'::'§:.§;:-m;:zi
pow.ar-- ozijgﬁfsﬁi ta:  2:i;ist:"--i';5jLst§§£:¥ its ihei: remaismihg 
%c;:a,t}eg::s:**gz cm ;;:-a-.9-jg;-;j'::--.:'t§m*;'a*ze. ':3£':$$§s( Tm t§_L1ar'si§u--m 07$' 

-r;2r»:;a':'€~'s:'~; -;'---.31' .ad::§§£§'r3'n;a:E ri'S'\.»"BnUe has 'E:r_rE:~:%n »arrViv'eaiE  an SL1?:::§}

bask: 'cf .aadd;étie::xa.i ;';)«;n.«,re=r' awai:¥3}b%e in sazppiy 'its 

.rem::~sm'i_r1g me.tere'<:' 'catagary inf <.:«3;nsL:r'~=":sIs'r:'.~t.~ an

:sm;"JrJtri'Edmaie ibasiés.

 *3Qa.'z*.m"§S;S_i'0t?; :*~:=.s%tim.--=,;":t_.a:-2:23 '§§1.€:tv(Z§.LivEiE'1iLEi'i} mi' supgiy 11:3 

   

(-41

:.sr'*.me'ié id ;42gt'1i't;1§'2t{i'r'a£ c_:_z3nsus'n_e,rs an 'tiiugé basis {if
vim:-,?j:*z2ge:.h::.aax:i'*'f':mir3r wf *';m:>i' rne.terec:' if;u;b::3s--'w'a=2i§ ::*0.:'i$.££I'I's$§'SJ;
z-3:311-s§,I=¢-;'u'€s's*:t¥§3.;_ hi:-'1.'st"5'. of'-sup-my  mxmiga gm" day is ;«1:":'i've;e,i

E3i="?S2" i_§3'f§ ujsmieftered <:a1fe:§;jow  i¥'--n3.' svanw»  appi'ics3d ta

 gs" 's%a'::1"--ed-- --E£QE'§:"I&§:C2§£€£'§ image: :33' the ur:;:'ne%3e§'8i§ 

s

{:3 .an.~;s.~:e. at {me p:'o}ecte_d saies veiume iizie the: a§:gsiim,=LE'tuz';2e._i'
consu1m.er3,

On the issue =:3fL acsatimatésan C2? the agr§«3LsE]<:ure3E :3L.:::+;3%§,:
-:".},t3l£~.i,:"?z~}§_L2F1'?':,- ihe Siam fiswssimmisaim has Esueci smeraa'
~di:rec§£'va'»;_s it} {he ;e"4gppe_§I;§j:1i maxi 0572113: r&=§g:a:(;i§ﬁg rn;af'es=r'_mg_ <3»?

thrirfs. .c1i:~n:'~3m'f*ms::*3 itmat 31:59 .§33:'OT»é'.5'.d.§H§3 aLeiE1e=ntEr:' clam ir°.:.c:.%':.sr;i--ir2g



t'h_:<:ss's§ ﬁfrcsm. *:ha+ $eg;__t'eg;a3';Ead agrilcs Létuna fe~az:ie;=~--; in 
-abs;e:';'r_:e of he AppeL¥ia:*s:i pmxxirriifsng; swh  the »8€ate:

--'C::?;» as-;*si:'3<,a_i'a*;»a-5: \.ha:s _e.1c3>s';ﬁr3.s.}s3a_i:%i' the_ t'netE3e~d?QE-$533» f<:;_§ii':': -_

 

--'fj¥'1{:=; ;3:'--a~&i'i0.L;s y.r~.é--a:'s 'f':{:.«s' _ajsii'rri.&i'i:':_g --Ehe;-2. Lsifaiisaé Em ih3:~3.
.'c§.QE'.,§;>',;?.5.,3;iii'.,i:!'<':'3;§ (:a.i'.e,<3or'y;

*t<.'ri_;:'} .6:-n vtmg'. i_a$u'2::-- :3?" §3§'0je.{:f£%s3r1 :23' ':°:2f.~Ez.§«?$' to  High; "1:"z=_e:»is~»;<él-';:»s':
::a'>:e2s;g,mr*;,* G2? {;r3n_$3&.:sTn§:.t'$ mi? of the ad:3if_§v;7;«:'1ai% sesias
'~;*'G§~,L¥;1T1'€5-~, the Siam C§1Umrni$sie'--r1 has striciizg dis:¥r*§b»uted the
a:.?£Q'§.%'§@:'1ai; powar amiiabiie z3n'1.«:3ng mu': :§'6::'nz3..'m'sn{,3

C:3§a.gs;>:f§eS  ';t)'E':::«§>.€»%f5"s§«f.?.I"':';':3ii~'.:§:  'to (mix? 'c£.>'r'.<;«:--:;s:n:1;;::Jv;,:n.L

£13

 1_i'f'r's'-e.>.'~._:_=.: _:='§:s::L.s§t=.u'a§--. caiagzwgg fer w}'s§c_h the sai_es.- 
if2i9=.;3\?§=is§«r3I a:2':'3_.:-§;»::%:=;m":i3;:.-i=é_0;*3 in the: aé:?3sem:e di' rgg' :'v1eter*§'n§
 Far 'the-. afhsn.' c:aieg::n'i:,>s., the gsrojectésns 
an  basis; ~93'? me a1c.+;:.a>.a£ p'ro;>c:Lr1io:n ca?' Vsmippiy far the
$:}ff:§3?\E§'§:1_LE'S"?:,i.ﬁ€1{, in {me :'C;'.ﬁ""£t'i_£mS§'&E~f)§3§§:3v, i'¥§'§§:'_e§«   'mi:
§i*'iexrar1=::e'.. »:3'§*a:is:.3; p;«'3.:"l"§C£.E¥€;z_'i" ca-te3g;:::*r:,:f being eSt§ma§%a;;i with

 S;§Ei¥:.E:.$ f§gur'ee's as con~1:p:ere:§ ta utir£1;<3:r"<:a?aegr<:r%s2:s;1.

  :h;«_m;:,r5:e,rti'ate:i '¥.2'{'303'ﬁve-£3.amn:Ess'ic3n'fixeﬁ tariff' ufhe

Ap;QeE¥--z:2.ni fax' .~:3"§TSii"i§:3.L;i§@'n anati: ¥tE°3{Ei.§§ sugngsiéy' :buS'iri:e--ts:_s fer  f'é';*-1?».sm-tjai

 



  azmd '~';*l=i?si"r?ift2':.s=i§a.n' afifii m'-'a.i§ 'E3i.i:}f3§3¥y *;.sss'i.f_f' in  
  .453? 'I_33£}'Q:8-; °T'?:1§.A.§p'$ii3_:xt --was --agg:'§.e:ued -:;.n.§';g 
  0;' he .C£1§1f3;i7GiS$§C>f3 an 3 p:3inVts..'uvr;é«c%2, t'here?r2:a":-.:,  is;s.u'as
 us; .:;:.nd. wi"--i.é<:h have bxeer; m«3nti:32r:<e~c2' 'in ;:>ara_ 2 of  cities'. in

..  order the é3A.c2a'n_m§Vs5ai<;>_.n deaii with thasje isjsues  am'

 

:.j:':_»:m ;?:2"sa:i3tsi_:3  {F18 sarms  :2-tuc=I<= tn: the;ee.rii:3rLzsrciiar. 'I

{'3.t.§:'n:n':°s£sséim .ma:nia§ned. tiﬁaiz  :'~;--uiu-s's§t'3t';_' was micaiizated 
~CaicL:iai:z3n cw? ihxe %':n1:;rs2;;r:*ef' E333 :'ed'LJci§.an  Time C1»-3rs':m§Lss%an
_::;;::nss:§-c:'_ere:Iil' an ~amo;.sz--~eﬁ*£ m' Rs.j;E35$%3 miiiiéams :0 be a:  §Z¥E§"EW€:'E>'ﬂ

 zsano 'c.::~:2Ss.§ of sarxxe 'ag§'iCu§'.'(Lsre tuba: we}? :?i:)V:'e3=\L.:'s":'::eLr'--::;: in 

§?i:n_a-nciai. fyi-ear  wiwich is pswazbée by the £f%c:«\."a~:%:r*:*a{"ﬂ.£.«".;:.-"it SL£.§3S§.C§};?,.

 {32::sm:vis«>:=ii;o.rz af¥:a;s':~:e.n;e=<;5 ii-:1-5-,:;i: :m.i'§::1.':_ms .a»:~--aE§a:s voliume to =:E*ze_

 1  cI{.sr?;js--L;::'n'sgz'ss--  an gmnuai  facimi was

 

::"ejfi«°32"mina~:i;  such j¥'im_:7'i§I":fgj_' hQu--'r'<:~.-- :3?'  Ii't.i.b£§ waif ctc>L_.m:§ ncaf ix-:;we=

::§:Ei»::1~.-':za_*;&é<;)'_  Ei§3{§iT.E'Oi3€-15  to this ~:atr~.21_§.my amt' .::>jf {$1.9 p<:«w€:s~'

 

.=_»w.:»_s"i,i;:zib:%:~:;a; gm a~:;:'c:m_mt' nf :.«:~é;1c§1é%i1o'na¥  'dist'§'ib1u'£§on' Eases  T

  mi: '§£?Q'~.f'63EE.ii¥Qf)' be%>w1e=2~.r1 We

 

§*,.0:3a:«.*n--iv's;sic~;: §:_;2«ja's:'t:;m~:e;:§ 22%.

s"a,=e=;iL.=:-;.%..i<.m Lin ei¥:;1i%'3E}:)t.ti'E£3rt  ans:  Ln' additionai s_Lsbsidy_.



5. £:m  i$<.,-=u§._>'  =:3mrmmis_sie;r: h.e:--is:i'  a. i:rs:>o{i':-szry :5: the

 

*.'§:'s~:*1'a'm_§ on l~'.?'r_1<~.:~ fin.'  éfh-3': so far as n'1:ei{£2sia:;1~ tLsE:se%: Ws~:e;EE 
 Carucuerymzd  --vc:§u-rne  ca'EsL:§_ate§i an  §.--')'€::§i$ of a..n~n=.:af4 

f;-'.:i:;ior  the same.

 

1' .9 the ;3r~3jec_-->:e<;i eaximecb-35.'!  
the {1,='1.iT':'Ei'fa3i.'a3d cz2te;;<>"ryI :20 .em'i1\jts~: at gt-:'»::;.er:::t~;=.,>:::i.   it  ms
;:ie'f:§3'§iv;A '§'s:2ai:iz's; ca? 'the '<:3r:sm--mis-s.i_on that 'arr; ad:£E'tionsaE a2ra.ii--aE3é§%t§g Q?

 cm ..ac::.~;#1.mi sf ::%_i-s;'€rimsfi<;3_:r--*s $323355. re>ducti::n§1 wawci haw; no §'mp--1::2::t

 

  pi'"éjé£:ﬁEi.0':'a   'r"_3'g.¥7§"(T'»'.U§'1C:Li!'.E*3'.' i.z.sir2>'-35 weii
»;:jQ;wsu:ne.:'$,  s.Ls~c3h*:a:<$;i:i§mzs3i §i¥_QW€§=Ti' on é1£.2{:I<3uz'sI1' cf §'i:'33:§i.ICi§;'.::n :2? the
::*Iis;'s?;réb:.;'s:2's"rm'  w<:~_u.§.':;i --n:fe'ce>3s:a:*'E¥i3r*  ie.ii=Eo€«a't:=2::i to other' 
 ag,zgaG;.:'§i5_L:Erta;a__ Tim  0? ibis 'f'ir'I».':léng E33 Ersuseci'  
<:2L§:..c;.s.»:'*;raIii@:s: Q? the. C.o:m-:'s1'issics:si: in .ii3 mder ciaie-Li   xsxﬁ'-are is':

\«z,':'8}5:¥ §+e>a.i"~:3' by.-{€13'i1<§mtn§;ss.i0'n "the  i_n:2n:.:' .::£&3L:"i%<3cY --ﬁ'c:;_:r_? FF' 2{}{J;;?~

 amj'  ,»'n P?' 2G.(J=3»»i3f?} T£a_:'s s:>am'2;3e£§;'e:a::=' iffm     %?  2'::~

 

4'

 £'i"na> u_;*:g;:§§a;"}"_§,x',9Aa*?g;7 ,£1£}"  a-:sf'r'f:sa .rm:2;_':c~,v's;>:;:' ag;'f:'.-'cr;;:1:"€:..+'.r':§ :'us::<e

;=-..r_ei;? v3c3;.*:.3a.rr':'s;_2:§£~r3;:': a,~az'm'c--!.:~.--  ffae.  o;F;:2;-tr,g,ias\::£ing_:} u:3'~:nL,s.§;r;>;'s2r3?

if:-W3 --L-'-:.f.%.:','i' s_':v::m_:<:;:;;*iip£€§3rfL The' 0.%--:rm'3is:sj;'m:? *)am.m'4s;.<;¥ ::;r-mi' j<;_::;'e=--,>.~£

 

'agncuﬁa
a  £3': ct:»:":s§:'$€encfa='s' in the --a':.az';:2 arsd fzein-::e maze me r=:;:r.+m':~:g iwows
of  ::r2.rrref5=_*eCI a7:a.fe.go:7y* in FY' £'0i)I?'-si3:E'i Eff: az.1f?3emic ffafd da:',=_:

:Tz».:';re fa-xzasmér  .rm:.:di:,=

 

;':":z:i:.sa';'.::*g :":'*::;>:5~£.e .~"m.m  segregzsfaaﬁ  ..



 

.-*3? -s'fié?-- é3#';?1Sx<3%s'?§?.£?e At'?-2" €?'i:€f£7é§«i ':=i':.=a'i'.re:r3;:'§:;* c2'::sr'--a_( '-z".<"'m.2 £':'::s:=mj:.2_i:s;_ 4;-.r;.=* gee

 

;<.:F:*2«.=3;f fa 'c:s;1::-:?.Fz;=.ua--- .:'£--.~3_. :;s:»>=,$c;:':sz*Iing 1a*4"§\E'-;'1'.r':T.f(73£;3'C1'§'<:'»*§',g*j_-f'  :a;9f.ir--.>7ée-:*a'ifr3g;f 
  eff:

 .- '¢.'.v "'9'- .\..,-"_.-.." _' -.  r- v,-"L1 -"-ta-_. ,','-_,,_,_'. . __ ,_ _.
?*W.ts\:~"  L«i3n=z*=1is.wCf1 fa-L=ns.i f.z'3,<:3{ giid? at me §~~.--.£§_*;i.,-1': ta time a-s_2-km ~.~v.z~;ss§

'»;js;:..:z*'_r.ssr=.';:-- ass L-:_z*i;:*s*s<::ie;f'_e--=:_c.¥_, Thf€~: £3a§mrvziss--s--§:3n heist!" ma? ad._di~:§irm._.ai

 

 

1s:~;r«s:§'§3aiﬁ':£'Et;I-- :3f':3.s3w'er -on :a=J:*::':(':~t;s2'3?E_. of §{)s,'{+'e't" .i'€_~>:?%':.s'r3-_ﬁi:m of" =';i'§3u'i§o_n 
'MES   .%':;imr 0:' $;s:p{Ji.y mm' 'the. armL.=a"i §{;>'£31(3I _1';:a:::i-rm cf
 nwretereri t;:éa*e'- \»~a;.':aé'i ¢c2':~;:su_m*s3:*s:»~' anﬁ Wm hams 'rm  anj 

i~:m   ti.) .t§"IE's'. unsjuetezred tube  i'e£}s'i;23_;,:{;;7;~a=:_.rs,_

 

 

$3.. ~'fI'.:=jn'    the C:mm':is;..eci'e'n ?:'='sf'--z:5 that' t-ha': 
czmnsunzzesr categmy' wise saies 5 time on ﬁne   sgfmizai %o;a:;<'
 and ccmneciec; Scat: ;:=s'ej:a=c?:e::i an the basis :3'? OAGAR an
consumes" caiegory«w'ise past  cm saiess 'mums anszf cvannected
%t;~;»;=:;i an ihaé demaanw:.'§  Cm t':*::~3 .<3ue_,0p§y sicie' avaiiab§Ei':y Li-"mm
 sau.r<:_~+:3s  '»*'JC3.E':'r§£§C5 (mt after 2-.:d,EusiEr:g for tra.r:=smi--ss§;ar: and
ci§sLfri.':.msi§oT:-3 i.a:~:.s ta arrive 23': nei avaiiabfe $3¥eLs to the :is'3tributi--on
Sicensee. We  bt§'iW€:€m the me?' avaiiataie units   and
 pmjezztcsm' on a:m'ua¥ icsaci factor basis is than aiiaéatecj to 

cim3u:'m=;:'$ c:~;tegories_ except howex«'er agﬁcuiture tum w:v,>..E¥



jGjS,','.'~i'E.-.'1.'-.5...i1.T!€'.'.3'.$-,§3"": ;>r§>_§§C:%z't3E:::»:*s Zia fha%i{'.g>e1r?tt§sr§ia§§e.' 'in  in "~;é'1%é:«.'&a_r :3?

.;':§j§3'$~:

'_ .51} §::=r:;3xii«:3aci' in the  -'w_e.i§ §".»:C.?v.%'~'1SL'.§'~""{T<5..v'-ji".5;'-.*'

 

'i"._ z?=.;z--r_-m'i%.=é1;§§;__= %_mUt'8 

  

 w;.3_:s: rm :§ga.::s:§::€sit<yi  é:'§ia:_;a't_i:hg adc£1éLti'::<n:a_§_ vsiigzme to vthaism TW3'

{3v:3E7"..m§SS>i?g'}iT'; C>ii3;%1£.~31:"J;3<(3i,;  aa§'E@<:aé.§m'= is xrzcm agt'ir:;.a§':.La:'§;  
~:i*<'me' :es't2'ia:t1f;,«'-- in --;3r':3p<:1"ti<3n ara;<;i xzvithout. prej.u::ii.cs mt  z:--;:ns:_an.
«caieamrgg. We quantum': of .saEe<:~. inciuding HT intiustry  2&3
p:=::~j+3<:tec§ on a bask. Lest'irna_tfs: basis ?'0I§2mwi=.ng ea ccunsisteimi
mei"'mdo%Ersgy  Vitae ¥.:€--:.ginning of the financiai year, Thus the 2s_r:tu'i§
::L:.ms:~.:¢sms5ss- iT3€T{~,'éQC}f'y' wise saies, \:vé'z2Ec:h in Haryana, is; largely
d.*3.§:)E£i'E{.iE3{?:'i an aciuai avaéie:i3i§§t'y cf {30w'er as Wei!   :Er'%\.=ea*: sham"
i»9rm paircinasas ffcsm tha mar§v<ei and gscmxer' :'eguiat.raz'y' me.ea's3u:'€:s3
am;-gated Fog: _=he~ mikiftia-3:3 d:._.s:'ing_ 'ihe year_,. away waxy vis--=£1--v§s thczaa
:a;g;a_;:2r"s:w'e{;s' by fihe    care :2?"   a
 :15? m=ej:3'i1'ah*i$'n1' .12'-.:=<.ists in i%3x}a§'E'5::rs'n 0.?' :Fu:€s.¥ °f::'3Ls'z'c;.§*.1_'~?~'~¥;£3e' §XC$§'~'~'é.S':'i'i3£§i1§
1.

. \ .

z--;>»%'&_?_:~ ~x8s'§~ie3:*ie*;>§r: ﬁGF':1S€L3i33iE§F. »:;a=:§f~:.g0:?y W'i_S.':?3 }fecr33'{:.«;=.§.ryi. is ~I®a£~€.---d an' .3=s:=.--:-'as! "E"

X

 

  wise     .:m:».m?i:a§§,r  it

a~;«j§da:f--2E mat HT -r:'»::r:s:.xrm=2'ar's; are mz-i treated aepa:'ztteiy* and nu regzc:-::ss_id_s,=;*jg<;%i::en cm this gamzni isiwa r'ra:1§ted"'A ?. ?~;':r':. ;V'>»..r:.2na§:;"*.--- «i'.:»'f*¥s'.3'i;§€§3§'1'L?75'§',\*':¢ ¥.~=.3ame.::=:' .£Zia'a-.mse¥' ?.;%"1_<=;.s :;;_;=._2';*_::_:':1'§iiiafe<:*;' 1'.-'%"az.:2--*£ .}'4\;{T};'}{:§.§'§3E3§'3~'I {;3§'{_1m)SE3{3 '£01 {e€.:'u.<';E'a'{:.;§ bag: f::'>:_:'mr:*§s:_si'a;«:'n é'mre2;aVsied ii ta ~<:.1_¢':'i"'":'4'§'. Séruce the r;»f'r'c3e:*=wt=o:s s':'f:z.:s3§?1_.;4;f.i:-3.?' i'hs;:_ mmm~:n_c€:rnem 'cf' f§'rea;.r3_{:§S! ;ye»ar §»?m;:_>G$Si§":~§ss2_ far 2% ﬁ§;::,€3'~i'%:§iz3T:'17t 'EC: meet? the target. Mr. C2h:Quci%'3L.rr\" referred to ihe rIe=.;.m:r~i 0%' .i'v':.z_r.a%13rn* Com'r1:'iit:~3e rwhicfe *§}§'}C?&%a"VE%1£'§ that {ma uiiiities ::<=.srm%mg b§is'Z--W§sef3 2%'; his i3.iC3% §:~;3I"§ :'etiu:<::e 3:133 n:<;:_*»:

in V2%?n'.;'z8~{.1=$3, t%';e.= ::istri*i3ut%<>:": was i:2?*.CI2'% amii to ifiaéi 'ﬁ*'j§{}jI7E3 *{}':ar1. 'h'§vg1hf '§nf.v::=_=;saf;§71_e;.a';t'E531 Q 52>?' » mg;

. inn _E'1v'i_';'; --s::;~;..;--uc:'.s~;.m+:,.+ is témzzi by '§¥"z€:':-- {if 'ifmé A;§:;3'eE'iar3*:--*5ﬁ<3t.e§d f§%1é;eI:.i'r'z:3:i'ét:':::$§§,1' save' . jag: -S;a'r.::*tG;z: 12(2) «e;~?€~3"r'a**s '¥'_\§i*¢3~v.«g,'f:'h_ee_,=*5s;:§s:s:§§ia'a*:'§s iaéx tit: ;:2_n {ha <__§;}*£;1'i.;is'}i3. that the t:'am:%:';.isssié::.n_ égnorédi g:i*:~.L:n:d: .:'eia'ied -.»*..e:« iss=:'§m.%::'z;E -theft. r.egTanjss ta-china? i0.:ss:._Lw§'1ic%z 0'.CL'._::;:-.r§'s 'Earg:ei:,e in t i;:a::=2r*=e1;'faiv»~f(.:i=*t'ét:e.:é.r3:3' .r:--,0i:*:-sume=::*. ::a::aeQL:e2nt;'yj-- i?§er:e*éés mi :"sewi'r1Q_$.i°n ::?:*.ji§--c=u_i%;us:¢; it is ssu'3nf:é%t~9.a'_ iifiai ¥'I3Qu€$§iGiE'§- af me:

;:'z~t:r--'. :a;3r'ic_L:§t1.;srie zaecttmi. Wiih r6=.5§3E%»'33T it: fhé-it ii is *1:i*is3- 'end? -L:s»;4w* Wm' =»:?4é3.sf::s;L:m§ess the same-: Eif}":{siii.£m ca' >;'e'§v3<:_i:'EcE_E;¢~' if)' an »5:1_E%*aji__-i:¢se'§ 1_s'}1f"sj= 3W-.'_ﬁ:3:"'_;, in s';-."-=3aiE_tg,';' c;oL;§{§ LE: {:19 :3=.=:afiz':~;;; i§§,«'.£i'=m3':'§Es'3r;; ﬂ'iE3..i§i'§vE3.£*«§j§.'. as:i_~:a_g=:*§~::uI?u;:'e 1; 2: _'j 'E1?3'a3"E"{3fFd ;;:+e;sr_'=.i, ii thje: _I5?1.ﬁ:3s'i3§S»SEOf'§: .9? fine ,Ap;se:E!?:«:n: 3 'that HT mn::.3z=_sme«.r cV3t=a.g;_0ry a*:s:;::r::s«\.»'e>€i" by i':he.Vf:a:='::?1¥ss--§on ' ;';=n_ ;::3r1s'ist£a:';.ii:§.i- an 3 $'"aig'h'_e:' sEde--. Thee {Z-C-zrmnjisaiorw rec_mm:iEed the _s,»"a":2>e.3ar :3£}L}8L-GE? and m_Li;'~*f 'rm: iiésregard its-::« ;:s.:'::si§eci:i-xzm 3r':'§§s:ji{~_e f:j;~_y'1i§':§si}3 i1,i'i§'i?E,§,;' wiiﬁiith £;3j'n':§ :'n:~3(:I{~: 'cm mfzéz {$3333 mf'a:3_jz.:3ifm£ér1i5 \:1'f'§§'ii:3 'pre:~.rE_<>us:

W; 'T%i;e:: €3x:é_rram.Ess§'on"'a: 's'eaaoné:1'gs f::»:Lm<$ in {N35 ::.:z'c£=ssr 'iiI.zg:3=,;_g;_§1--ed' are faiéewe:

.>'--%ijc:ii%'i§{3:--1a§ 3955:: {'1-T2£'§Li£2ﬁ.C¥;i'2 Eevvei cf 1% by Ce'm'm1sa§::«'2': firms' its >:sup;o*ort' from me fact. tthai {W Commisgimn at iE";«:»3 szznwe time rséiowecsi a ciQns§'a3erab2':e ;«3--mmmt of cayaéiai ex;3endé'tu.re which if pmperiy incL2rr=;m': ». ..3 Q' ;.= ~.a.«m_,'=_£._ai:' ::'-<2_:a_u=£t in e'ffic=i'er:t. --0'p§?:¥"a€i=Oi": me --r;1'i».sir§;*,:z.\=*r:é=m~; ::.gzs:i-em --a§m_$ 'ir:w--£:2=.f '::E1'a';-:,- 1'.;=ami'm:3xs':rs s*:€f'%tf:«a Appeiiaizi fmfm <?::s'mtf;--: is --i£',='ma, we bazatk wai:; :;;E've.z':. be-' i:;";sas'{3t:mmi_s--s§0;--'; so ta ;\:_»¥3m.w' 'the actgsai £';ua~a.*:;t_i,a:7n zaf :::ai.%:-- to ihg': ;;:r3~I_'::2.8.::itas:-exai i""'.

e.

a§;§'iauitu_e;e .c'rms2_am':=;-':t'ss rzmziw.' 50 that "s:;:;:s;;'::i_y ~'C§,?':f13$"§i3ffE'L(7§ rmir' t:_ua=m't1§i'i€~:i ;=,_a§s"u;é. was-' aii iiéwe t3:st§'s-xataﬁ 'figures.

e'if$'§3L;'§TE,i'3ﬁ():i'§ azgriéuiturm we: --re'5:i.§§;r '>§¥":zé.=--_ ' . '~.

> ;_z~:im <'.C;'=--c:.m.g::-;,:::'1:;;--'_s=:hzseaith. "me :-;:s'n'1w:3:ur:':--c2f--ag:ri::a;2.I§:me ssuhsijdly be pa§i:.i -by th.;~='2 *C:'-.-<::x»-e,s".rV:.rV_t':.~s:-ant was (My and Vta§ie'n mate of';»ma" maze a:«:timai=irag az3Q'iii0i1e?:E vaitxnxe on éczczmmiz samajiiioswai W'; Seas s'€ec§w:'E§On.

Adtiiiizznai r*:;=.'~v~.r:>;m.:~<3 an £~.%CC.C3LH';i of adci1t§L=n:a§ saiass has in 13;; iéawkved 1io2',hssi2 ii; the mn--ag.r§c--u§tu:'e setgw. C'cra'nm§s>3£cn div$?irz:}L--:ied {he :a::i::iiét§oz*;2:ai ;::mw:ar-- ta: 3%; {ﬁe Qffhe 'c:3:'ns'L:m'ers on pm_p.o.ri.ao::: baaiif... 'Q:'~,r '3Ll'{31"s= ?'53**35?5iQ 'i%"i£~3 .St;sb?::1i$--sie:-;.5»-- (3% 'f§3e~ iiearnad C34:Z2sL£ﬁ8,€§_§ far am ;3.3I"iie.E3;, id aazasicier three %s}ss;:e:e~ i"\ 'I:§_c~3i%i:s':::?:=.=';i£=:ci at jg: '€31?' 'E§}i§~ jud_j<;;:72e:1_t: in :;~0frs3_:3:'e§§1e:re:»3.i;ve' n'za:~\.ne:'. 'I'M? Téuiff Pzzséicy of *:m'.»; 's'E3"r.m;~=arr1:'r\.<3:r;i" of Endia fra:n'zes:i La-m'.~:i-er sezztims 3 of Ei€:~:tric§t3i Act 2083 have '§(>.Lf:rfD¥d

-- 'bésacimssz 'Ensme a.vai§a£:>'iéii*~; of eivazsirécéty ta r'c::2'ns2.s'm=:sra evi re3;s.:mab'$a amtx' ..::.a:n*1p§>,"£i'ti\a'Ea- rates". :21» E-".:1<.au;:'e f§naVn=c§ai xriabimy' of me =se2c:::3.r e::m:! aﬁraazi. mve.<.=.i::1eLnvt's., cg) P52'4:it"§.'e_'::;i€_: trazis_par;2mcy; ¢::.:_-Miatency amil ;}i'€>C§§:37fri3;'§§§§iy:

s'ni1szérn:iV2«-3-'A pe='s*ceptisé3ns----r.:-f re-'g:.--:£a--tmr'y risks, M _;,a ?:"¥'.-{},ﬁf3Q'iT§§ 'jc:;m~1;:3eiE_tEgzsm _-e§}t"f§::.E_:a='nr:;.( in r3;)er'aEér_yh ami ";~rw.'*:;a".:r;¢3xz{e:':~.:'e.:tz't "in 'c;'L2a'£iI:y §s1;::f.'§§;i¥y;

.1' ix .:€3:ac_tm'ra' 'n'§"ﬁ_*.'e E§ge:::r'i'cii'y Ac._i'2£}1Q3: --ihai_ tﬁgéaisv wiiifz wiff i'€)§.t:§i2aT[E'£3t?:L~; im:-er«aié;:.i' §=%F'Q\.«"§d~:i=S §§'.€'iZ=-"?D§§'C>3.r'«'§'F"'f§3:

"~?_i".Q.ry a_;:pme3_:;hes-- awevss V_i\.L§'E"§'.3L'.}§'iT$3';'§.£.VjE'§i3 em.-;%. :13?

Miiie _§3.;~;=r1sz32r*a3i3é'ta's'i_,. E:am'3riri§--:ssia=a';, <3:':s:£:'§f;3Lzw:'s'<:3rz' a:m'#c2 at-.'§:§'::i;¢ ca? s2¥_e¢:s=§::?nty G-mdurgted =:;mmne:rc=iza¥ ;33'iﬁ'Ci§1§ei§§ km faaf§<3'r'$: W§'zjié:é*._ --'w(;:u.¥a::i {:'?!":i3Qi.£§"E§~f_;§:$' :3»: *;;;.3&iiti._0n= '23=f'f:e.i&§:zf;A€£:§e.',-- 'esonovrniziai. -of the :'e.<s::s.:.s:2*~::s3a, good §.:*g_>:*.'c;;*_s7nasf:'ct93 ;t:§$i'r.jE_rv*:1,1rn._é:wse'estrr1&nis; arm' at 'i'§'1.§: s;:=.;*:~...e cs? ::0::15um§e:rs" fm:t{~.

":iT:s:m_*::\.«-- r:=:sr::3'w::*.y' cf the :23?" e'ia'ctri¥:ity in 3. :€e::--'s50nab§e .*§'mn:r;=eé':' =i§1i:> We p;'r1Em:i;:«.§es; s*e.:a.r¢'an:§_§;r':>'g,§- a-.~'.f_ﬁu§anc:y in perf'm:"aa.mce; :3_;&~:_'~ .;~:_»he tariff p:rogIressweig; reﬂects the (3013? sLu;:.p§y of y ::m.:i 1a§--$Q cross su:tas§d§es~i:1.the manner ;a3£ss~.:c:*:r%z: t

--;=;::e::i.fée<i-- by 'me Cc.mnx':'s:;*-:4ia:1' 'i3«'t'sc:d.t.--zz:_%i'§_;::=_m' r:-f"€:*a_nsm'§g;s_Ec.;r: and:c§§;§:;i§h_u--fias'; was to ;3=3'rn".:iss.§§*;si'z=.>. t:>'¥.=r:,=._af;.'=.j=1'.§':'-.§r~3.. §ji'mi'§'--.ar?i:3 :'s;;»=;iLIs::.tic::'é in .«::'a.ss sigsbsicéy 'the. ?';.'=' _ ..*::i_xu:=.s of E.¥'~3-C§3'§.Gi'ITy' .E%c:t'x'-.i<:£_ia::wing: '{h§':- £:ﬁit1:._mt.?'iér11g Q?' It-ﬁat M the 'én;ité.re;~<s:t: cf the t::22n:=w3's:=2v:'%a: and Em. Cs1"It%*:e3 --utiii:y' ;>.<:vw_a<;:' ~;a<3tor* gets bOGS'§f6:?f.'§ =;.:_;1:.. Him if task. fa: W3: o::de;' da%ed--:2¥3"' ?\l'1x'J.'~«'t9m?3=':'3é*--"= 253138' WE-.~ ﬁnd '1 § (0.

9. 9

3.

2. ..ﬂ .. .7.

. 3 , .....4,.. 44 .4. .L 4..

. 1 ., u my. ._u.m.m ,v Hm. mum,» .171 Inn .9, mun «.1, ,0, .

we h  A mm h .0
mW..;. .JI€~ 8. .1. V?» .7... .1 w
.. an: vr
 m L. s. a    5 m .
   M... 4. ...m  m. .7. ,3
.1. we ...H. ...v 7 mm  6 1, ( at
.»l. :1 ; .1 ;. bi. .5 at .r
  my      o 
 ,,,,,,....,w..H,.,m,..,,m,....,.W 
. ,. . is ...r A ,, , .1. L .7, V, _.i 
. €42. . 3. .f4 F.
 mu  .5 I r,.. 3 .3 n    
nu .r.   % .28 .3 : W 3 .I . 8
Mn ".1    am .0. ,0 M...  N. 3
3.... .rL ..., r 3 ...u ..a.rH I .  I! ...mu
,3. .m.w my a m    J V  5 3.
 0» V." d ? .... .f V. C @  
 w 3 .3 Lu" W  .1, : U 
..., :. I: I. . ., C an ...»..»
i  3:,  ,0  m, n I. ..
(A .../.w.. .9»,  ,   mum L 3 , . ,4
J  ,..,.... . , I .1 i...
 am  W.  0 ,0 ,9  H
.....u, r: .  .¢.m 10% on
m M 2  H  9 
 A   L, 4.  ; .
n... in   a AM ..
 Lmm it .1 mm. ..... ,5
.».N,   J... (P.
. J, I 7,2». .,.
4%,

3

w_;"xc;_--.a_z:ie'a_ ia_IigeEy _L_:;_a.'=mt.=--,>3*'.e;a*.»5;=a:i.. _i1'3a:mn* aissieyv w;e:::¥. 11:3?' wr {he-.:3'.v%:~2';:Vaga u;,:m-;;:ng h'aju:r::s at %:.%":;::..> w'ee'i;%- 2:1:-«gay e.g.rémaimzfa_.¥' xvaii a_:«on<sL2:m..a:r--:s E-mjnjz _"ns:>u_;stg in Y if-_ :5,.v5;«é*3_= %1_c>:_£r--s_ in FY" 2G1C:8+_{3--*§. .iI_'_;br:>s'm=e;.;;§on E!ji§:3 wsaamesci 't§1.s't' me ;'_m§m=mtiCity-- sf" 'the r"s1sa.='zEs.~5:"»:-s=i.n§= a'=1'£3<.=3d§=:t€§ 1:3 taer pm beyarnd .am; qu.e'--;_s;fi:3:*a_. be:.:.a;;:.se. ia'r7g3eé .num.be.:i' cri?' n=:ss.mz-is e.§iih'%=r <':£:.&=.'_ <::-"r er E-hey ﬁe'-.* air ihe miss' rem-z',»:3iin1g.'%.mra.=;s_ u.st12*a§?i;e;:i3¥3s=. A3 g--r2a,;i;_.E*:1.ha5.; ;i:~;%p=JE'a:fi..r~2_:<;é_ ~1::*;s. show. time.' sii3sfn;;_ 'tj:E:s=:.ri_ in agx'ié'Lﬁi_Lij§'a3§_ u_n':me:te'_s'eI£2' ' .-5 vzseii (;--:'JFI:3Ls£T¥'_:)'i§<)$'§ graduaiiy fmrn Ltha yeiar '2:302-- ,:.3 'uv%'m;t:

-com2pe§i€2d {he C@mm§s;s§0:n is scrut'mi:;.-ﬁe the Li£Ts'i&?§fy'§mg ad~di§icna'i 'mad factor dam in' the Isneteréd ag:~i:cu1%ura§ mzzsaznwpticn win'-oh 'farms; iihae basis cm' the: ;:>r'0jeméng ur:r'm~:~tered azgric-uiture tube weii consumjpticm. The: ARR of t'n.~:~:v A;:s§pei§ar:': En the :'iram:éa'E year' 2i'3{}?~G8 was based cm :i.isir§§3s.;iiore ﬂoss §=.=3v=3i of with aciditiazxai red' smn by anci: Lithe C..On'.m'§i:7~;E3'iQf'= basesj its caicu:Eat--ian<3.. for '3.*{~sr;a.;:"' rat was ievstel i26%. in .5Tuch' a ths 'C:.:31*sW;:*:zivs.~3.ii:9*"1: fi':<e2as3Z. di3iriE3a;.aticsv:1- 395$ 'ET€fCh,.$Cﬁ_{3s"1 mum {$13-1-gsxsszi at' vamga ad{§it.i_c~_:'1z:2§ r*aas.r--'em;s'e 23;_3;§_r--<_.1x's {U _ 'mifman vshiah was ax';3eeied be' ge:ne_ra£ed an

3.C:G10jL3m of 1"}-3 '(?§v§.'-3-'(}°'§:'i3L3.ﬁi:Ii'1 ioas. i'a~:L<j*L:eiEt:»'ra. :3.-suécé km u~ti§i:/.eA-:3' 'gt:

p;:a:""E;%3=' 0:'? meat reew=.3sme Vgzapﬁ ef'e;'s'iLso:":éezx' in s:~=.:Q3iiy ef' '..awea* to the ag.r':%:;.L1¥{u_r.e co;r1su:nez's$ the: {3a.r'mniss=écm.--a§i0cAa:e2d gafddi'-'£iGna.§ cg': :ax;-mm-rat' of a,0Id:Eso~na:§ rez.-c1'Lsc_i§ie.n §135~:s-- ii}. n<::;"'= ~EE'L§§'i'uT¥?$ setiisssr which we do mi firm in mjjusi. ,*»'».;;:§ps§fia'_:'3t u=n=d:er m§s<;cm.::a_e:si:E~o.n than if ad€i3iti?:s'i11a'i is:

«:*r'::;:'::*.sH:§anateévy .s:E%oc:a*;s:::i_ to the agricuétm-2: +3ec:'*:~<;--r 1-asgijﬁea-st iiI?'t€.?'e wfzi: be aazéaziiiémrwtai vsasbmkiiy vavaiiaizzie f§"f;m1 ﬂue. C3;Q\v'.€:i=:"r*m'--1e;n'f.; .p'emaps mi.s';:ai;ac:s::5. Eémed an the Ianmsai mad ffac'i.~::_; the i3'o,m--mi:,as§§:;7r; deter-mmec3 the 'r;:ng;1_t--EmLé'm 333%? \é1<3.Et§m'i£°i '£0 'ag<r§::§.£.i}ia_;Aa?e usbe wrzﬁi c:_€}r}:=;L£_§--'x1§evr:"7; as $3057? "i§:"zEs_s'§s would he?' .sc<:>g;>$ 'fur:tE'3er' 2:). a§i.a.c:at_e any Ta.dg:*:itLiez*:a¥ 5533 7:0 'ms :::.233:sag»:3ryga1:' mu: sf the cm a:::~::oum -of 13:.

'*2 --:€§s;i:_r§'i:sz,2;_fi:*:.z*s msas: ia:'g_e'~;i'; in fact, is h;.}*;_n:Ei;¢ mx'-3:5 ¥3»i°«'i':'v'€E:8E1 '"I'3«'f«.; reﬁuciian in disi:-éb:.:t§t:s1 {ass and'Eos;s ts? subgiciy, Tm a-1r.ic.i:'téc»nai 1'-:1'; .rea'u::ti<>n in *4 (Ir i§"s'ﬁ>:§s'£:_:éi cf the hsatih at' the Lstiiiiry so that the revr3:we gap we find=,. ssaie xraiasnxes for r§cuit=:.rr*:aVE*i;:i:sa wen -caénsumfars' is «caﬁcuiated? an the .f-KL3'-"--- «:3? tin? :w1ai*-med €L1if£3e"«'s'<?'§¥ G0£.':$L§miE.°£'S_Z and (Z'40t"§Sf<€f£';L§€~:i'i'?§}*' 5§'tQL;r'§'£% -:3'? :a:;:pj_:>i_§,r pee' _:t;-um,a d_23},r-- is mriw-;_ at for the mreie Craiegmjg the ssa;m.e: i3_ ..3;:;3_§'§ed {~53 the pro}e1c.T~;--e:d a:::mir2=1c't'e~;? §:';2as:;:'* fhe: unrrxete-u i':sai§,=_§;3§'y in 'E3i'I'§\r'€= at a ;3m}_ect§3s:-.é \:g=;§'u~_:m'. Tiv.ije'2':a=frcé;s'se, the af§_d§T§Css1§3'i power -as it wmzédx §T}fE.°~ nwatila' ;a.'fx.=f:':3'%¥;'.«2--ié.2"Is.=,-_--':«.:«'n mi. :3?' r:aér,i.:.s.t.:*c'§uri mrozsid not ;.:~:2»re:<E2.s1E~;s.=r is-' the R3 ags'i_:n,.s'iiu:'2_a .cQ=nsL:m_e's's;_ am: E3<')<Z'x'Z1'_?-i'.'I'!':*'s§3'[é,i giiv-an. a :e;_~i:an_a:_ri':1 i~_:1H€i*:_1€_-;a {:_¥'ia_(:)':~:';3n--r.*I d'i$L§:':.{e._§', Cc«.n1m.5$vs.§m"h YhcmgE":t it fit is. adc£'é€ima'%t3i r'¥3ws;n'e;a.e to the DGﬁ'a.g~$"§CLi§'f.L£f€. Te repeatadijétionai newer as itxnmuid be axxaéiaéavie cm a:;::cmrn: -of h3ss.:'.+3duciio.n wiii not czhange the suppiy of power is the 21g'r'i~c.L:.EtL2re sector'; mar it Wm havé any heéarérag an ihe. ;addit:ioz*:ai ioad fact-01' for the metered tube weii L':€'m§L£i"n€':'t'S t'i';rs~ Lznmezferesci iL:k::»;*: weii r.:cn.sumers; Thirdiyy we fit} not vﬁvci' ary .q'isc.r§mEnatio*n in the e.st§n1atinn of the to HT ca:-rsume.r categc> ry becatme the ailocaiiun its me man- agricuétusre meni was wiiihczut rsriejgucziice' 'to any ether v::m'=.&'»a.U'ﬁea{ aategory. it is Lsncieniabie 'mai in s.«ug..:_:.::g; takes 1;;

.1:-.

tz;:r£.;§l~:;:?%f}<". W' f§;;:1.a§i--Ln7E;--:S<3C.i&i7",. WEB it wa)]1';_¥~5_5£ '*:)e':--"'3ra:é' mg?' , ,, x . _ . . . . \ §, , §.

ihaal :§_.L._:':3§2'Ey =0? .r:_r2we=r ta agricL:_§tus'-.<:.< v.s'<<_§¢t:~.-r' . .

\._<_§:._. *g=§'i§ii{1g_t:E*.=c": it-ir.=._m-T the '§§2$;.'_§g;g.-2; Zf»:,'\'ui. i.sr=.<fir_:2r' -'t%?1:«:~3 ::¥r*::Lsvrn§sis:n-53$ cm.-'u=i(3 nu: thee; £:m.am~_:s3f' Eli is siisa' su7t:~mié°ét' . .e°~J£%i3 tiwugifz' 'E§}.e3--_;:2rai§i§a3:_n im:,>; 1'-.i._t'_i.§'i%:.\_;-"

-:;;Ls-bmétitecé an fai'm.za, i-E--':s3-. 'eiioiey-_h,a;~_JEI3§ mmcgs ¥z~3fijsi~s'1Ez': year _ 'i'--\.i'£i;:1'\s*.§e':1'-i'fs'€.§§'_,_: the U--'E'iia't}.=' 'w.-3;-22 moi givaii p'e.s'_§':'s_-zii . St} <--'JI:§.L§§i<:¥i mist hzwga -«E:-earn EEC:}'1¥i:Z.'?u1i'ée'i "in .=s§;t;:m :3? ir:1m..:'>;t%zs'=.... o"«:a=:.s' and ii' open tat; ihe A:J{,sei¥ar1t ic: agsprmach the {':am'ms's3s§o:1 dusrimgg the. tram us of with aemai data wh:E:;§is L2--nde:'sian.dai>§y avaiiisbie wiihths .é\ppe.%%an£; as such i?'1sE3§'E3 is case of e:ar:";a' gtzrt-e',i:t.a<:!?i:':<f~2 bang to the by mg -order impugtaexi Having thus mmzsiziered we g:'r.:um's of aappeai, we fins; no éc_:sti's'ia--i;«i:2 a'ne:r'Et to Enie."fea'€: with the findings of the t;';;{,smrn§.ssa'o;w, .v 'tats aazﬁééise .2§.g3{_}r'C3N€3§.3' Vfig_z.:n<~:= and *1;%3FiE:5E§3§Ty' the M. We -:3éi+:smi'§:~:s--'iiw;*a§>,. a:;?;';:e:aM£' wit§1s:.*e'z.=:i: , §J_us*ti:s~e. i§3.:S_:_§.a&%3'§ {Emu ﬁaakesh §<§a:'h_§ J§3§§§;i:g§..A§*§$é'%¥§ ﬁxer '"é'ie::§*:n§£:a§ memhar ﬁaieti 2éf*f'Tf§e;§rzsTarv. gm 1 i§m:§ex: Re2ﬂ§r$a:bi§'§§ mﬁah_§e

--P§§§

Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Appellate Tribunal For Electricity

Uttar Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Ltd vs Haryana Electricity Regulatory ... on 24 February, 2011