New India Assurance Co Ltd vs Sri Waseem @ Waseem Ahmed on 28 March, 2011

[Cites 1, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

New India Assurance Co Ltd vs Sri Waseem @ Waseem Ahmed on 28 March, 2011

Bench: B.Sreenivase Gowda

13*? THE HIGH CQURT OF KARNATAKA. AT' BANGALORE

DATE!) 'I'H3{S THE 23TH DAY OF MARCH, 62:91 1
.F3E11{¥'{}R.E:i V. '

"mm I~iON'BLE' MR. JUSTICE B.SREEN§5'§A-SE': 

M.F.A. Na. 3439 @2003  
cgvi?  Ti   %V   
M.F.A. (2303 43.» of f2:-{1(}9V{;\zI'$f?£{N'\'--3lVVV 

IN MFA 3439/2093'

BETWEEN

New E:1cii21 --.5's;s::..:5{j:-:'2zrégie C :31 E;t<'§'.',~i_"~ .. _
R€'.f.)i'€?S€_",1'3Tj~';'fCi 55:}-5 --.1E3i'a5iA<;i{s§:: 2.1.1. ._M.:;;;.:'1 21 gm; :2
4"?.F'Ec><ﬁ1',"F-zjwziér'i%1()ij:}%;;j,¢ '   

U :'1_it._'§;f__VB:riE(:ii1':'<V9 J .  V. Ro:£2,d.. V  

~. 2

B21ﬁ§:21iC5F€.'V:»~_V   .
Vv ' V V  ;%;3;)é2§1z1z1i,

{.E%§z"  ;  J 2'§:'ig>1j'72:-.:.gE«;2': Advx}

"  '  i?°;;3";e1Vs§;»;-3831'}  W2:1:s<5é<'-:31} J-'a§"1.r:'1«:7:ci,

%-> 

S_,f--%;--; §::;%:>aE f§i:1;z1e«:i._
 A;;;j:{:<§§ 2:'%:2<'mz': :21} Yazarsie,
EE,;'2:*:§., Ne:.>x5/E. §.4'* CE°€,}Eé§f='S§ T?'"-3 'ii/Eezizz,
" i3'21ciz1r22:;a :11 21131,: $23.,
E321m§§z1.E:m3 -- E568 {E226}.

Siri. 'i?£%:'1ia;:%€.:2:'z;:23': E{{é<§{i:,-a

 ;' €13. L2'-:E:z;$E:";_::2.2.?:;": E1?;<:r<.i<.'§j;»~",
3:-'§2.'%'§'{i_}*§T'a

E33' 25:3 . {If E"; §_EE:~2:;*2::: 5:322': E SE "'*%f§.§§;.2gé:x





Ev

E'€;;1yzaEp21c1:1 I3<>:sL
Sri.1'1.i.\-fasa.pz.1:'z:2 "%'2=1h..11e;,
K0_1a:f I1}ist.rici'.

. n ..'.;';"E'"',?':VEf:'V}.')*"'.:';'>:f'v7£If.ixZ"', 51:15,;

(83? Szist, P. 'if. K2?§..Epam;a, ;'»'ad*s.='; fax' R.  _ . 
R42 :'2{:§{i<;%£;% c'1§:+;;'::é:;'"1:<;«;&?<,ijga§iE'1 'i=',v"'();"(3z§1'§1'vfi%£i'*3 I 

Thiéga lvzm  ;{'iie«:i U/S 2_i:2sf:a( 3-3  :s;;<x.:r% M g-:g_:s§;:::.:;+;:«::.:::;T_t.he. 

j't.:c15;;.11f1e1':t_ eimti e1wa1.:*cI cizigtt-"~:<:.i: 1,_£3 .'iL§C}U8 ;3'_;2,é§s€:i is-;1"'v.M:"~;:'.C
Na 4?"'?5/200'? 011 t:i'1e'~: i"£'I<:-:*<:,>_f i_h.<=3:'-Xfif Acivjl. »{}'L::iVggr:--€, C'<3%.::.1"i'
cxf Email C221us:-;-&rs., }'\«'Ic31*11b£::v;;"IX/IA.C'I{";' ._E\e*fef::.='<}p:}Iitan. Area.
.B£fi,£'}§;E1§{}I'E?._ {SCCH.1\?<:s. 1.5],__;%;u:;1z*:.§ir':gg Q21"«r:§}mpé::>:r12-2sz1%:i<,:1'*: of
 $24,600/-- with..jIzt€.2*é$t'  *E'S%..«}3.aa. fr<53.':%_ ihs: daiie {if

ptét:iti{;~1": 11111 dt:3pC)Si'i' .7.  _ --

IN MFA CR033 143%/:2aQg' *   

BETw"E§;,;1§g.. 4' if 

Sfi -,.\«.-Rf--'r}},¥3'.'u'£V;V'.fi'3?,I_I.§ ;;W21~:s_::%«::Ii1 RE:-:1a.r:"éi,
$j[{:V}V: rq132;._:V;r:11:::::ci, 

Agéﬁi 2?;';:i0u ti  -~Y_'i<:..~.i::'é§'.-T.__  _

R/aiif Tf\E€;}'5/'E, 1-«féii C::g>Lss':s-Q W! Main.
Pax.<iz11"a}:'«r::gr2apuzfzz S . 

E3:2;.:2g;;1.E<:;:*{: vs 53:1} 026.

, . . C £'{i>S.f%§ €>i'3j<:r{tE:(>r

  1  R V} E*'§a_Ip2;':.r':a-L, Aziza}

A' X $379. -A %  V%

E. ~~ "F1336 Ra-,=:g_;;ie:3:'"2;Is.E iVEa§":2;z§_g<:%r§

 E'v§f§:::, News Ezzgiia As3s'«:'1,2:fa:'1::'*é: C53, E,-£151',
B2::.:T:gg;222é{sz':::. R6 {,1

2~§:':'§ "E3 1113:' 3:' E13va::§'§<;Ei:T":;;;: F%f_'3§.Eé:'*.f?<Z;

E? E{21.£_i:'1;;23 E*3&:_> R{'}é'-id E.?~gE§s;s;i{';:'2 E%i<3a€§}§
B;-z.:"2gz¢:E<:%2%3 «M :3?'

13 1 33:'; Eizzé. {$2.2 :3: 2'1: Eiizitsé {$321,



E-3/0. L2::Iv<*s5s}'1§11a1':;§-1 R€;%{:E{i§»*._

M zzij <32'.

}2;'z.1'i... (3}1iIlz1:"21p21.l.Ii Vi1'121§_§{-3.

R(,):s-$21} Peeiahi Ptjzsait, Sri:'1iv21se:z.?x.§:>z..t1'2?i 'I_'a.I1.:.I=:.
K<':s12;u:' I'.)§5~;iTri<;%'1.

 1 " R.:j>.:s;.p€:;.zi<;§  €1.35 «. _V

{B}; Sr}; R. Jz!§_;3r2&.§<:221.s31E. _g'1;:.ii'{r;1'«. '_ 

Thﬁ]HFA(Hﬁ3B§n£WFAi%i8439;Q3$ﬂ€dEL%}4J
Iﬁzle 22 of CPC. 21Lg'.,j§'zaiIi:§3£:."--~._t..I1E.= v:.1d__;_jerm5::1iV«:._Vmild .2:1wa1='e:E
daﬁxt agxxagoas paaaxijn &nK:_%34?75;2o0? on
ttim file {if XIII Aci__<1i'é:i<.>11aI... f;3'iz1;¥:1--.i Cf22_1.1.5<3.__;I;1iige§ §\/fiaimér
5-'xc:{:i<:1e.m'. <I3§aim:s 'f"3:*__i'i3':.,z:'1£1'I Bv?,'},I'i'g;'§i§£:}"I"'\'3_. §}aFi'.§:,7 211I<>wizT1;{;j f;;I*1<;*.
91.211111 p<3i;ii;i():'a f2:;1ﬁ- i:Qf'1?13V;:><e:1i:s§é;1€;i{'::'wV emci s::cki:'1g_§
<%I1}'121:1.<?e111e::1':i01'c:n:;>1f1':;;1é:I1:sati{;::'1.'°"~  V " 

 

T}".1:i;~:9£__.2-2;§§3'";r.I _e51-x1€3§3§?'1_F'A' €Zi4i>é§$"'<_3bj<;*r<i:1:,ion (,?{>I21i£'1§§ an
fol' }§<3.2'1'{' i1'agg,~._ in.;:;}:f1z2f,z'_,'-«i:i'1~<;2VCQtaré.._.:i£:1:iv<:*red ihfs f01.i<>w'.i_:3g;:

 

" §§ﬁGME§T

this :?n;)p«::ziiV.g;i.'i'1€i <:.r<3:-"as; <i>bj<::c:t:i<m 2111*, a1'is§ng.3; (mi:

3:,;£Zgz.v:%:_;rI1:11+:3:i"j1z.(i§§1'vm:%I":t'. a_n::i £1"W£:1_I'd of ihc. '1'3;'%.b:..::':z21i, £.%1€~:y

V' 'are --v._§V:"sV'@s<ei:.1fa:i""£.::>gei*.h<:=::' a':'z::'§ :iiss;><>s;e2:i of 2}}.--" t:hi$ <':<>mm«:;>:';

" . k§'%z.1=:d;§:":é £*':'§T:'1'€".:5;

2' ~ E?'<>z:" i.::1:1€~>. s'~;2:.E~:€ af =:_T'<}:'1.w?:'1£.m'2z':<: g<:~25z;"£:é::'<s--_~: ¢1§'€:'. r€:f"{:=:~r&><i €10

_ 25::';%a_.€'E'"::;i*f/J 2~2:"{-2 ré::?1<;%:":":%::i £0 £21. Elbe? ijtézisim §:§a%:.i'é.'§<}.::':Q



3. Bria'? fa<:i;.3. of ifhe Céiﬁﬁ 22$ pleaded in the Ciaim
§€"7£:§t:i.::::§1 am:

Thaiﬁé GI} $333,268'? 'ﬁfhéil 'me §:.§_é;j;:2'é';a1L§*:f:"Wegszg

preeeaciing in a ﬁ}€}E",0};'{i}--'"C3{'3 ﬁg }Z'.fﬁ'4§.'§;.i:.if1:.T "Z'i'€i€i*"' .:}'z:g_

Chintaxiaani H€§SkQi€ m2?:€:3.; :":e;"%,i°'   V

fzraiétar and f,:"a:;iEr;3r bege..r§ng 4A1=:3.%§istra£§§3-tyV'A.
agtggrztmax $211115: xaa:§'%aI§;:gh s§¢e{:*;:n  gash and
negiigemi. m3,m:1€19: and Q2:  side andf
daghed agaigjisf. i:h'¢v_"£Vi0 the impact the
ciaimzzni    grievaua i11jm"1'€$.
E*£€r1c€z     Vﬂﬁéiiiiﬂﬂ befasre MAST,
 gf R3 :2,@@,§::@:3/~ and

the "'.}f':i*iif3:,:;?:*a.1V"~ E;a§~.._ é3}azsar*de& 3 camgengaiiazz cef

4' {2riii*_: imieresf. at 5% pa.

V  Q3.' _  by this 3s§52"a.rd 0f the Tribunaj; the izmurer

  <}§°fé:xé:;§iA§§g§ vehicle has ggraferrad Mm 84:3§;':2i€iG8

gaéigifiggg reﬁzzcfcian af <:<}m§€:3§3£§m";§ 'i?sZ§'1€i'°€£&rS the

 v._§§A;2:i:::3;:2E; Ems p':'°€ferr€<'E <:m$$ Qb§€Cf.i{§§'} ﬁe. §ié~_3,!2ﬁ£%9

E giéaéiirzgf i?}1§":&§2{Z*€'.'ET;€f}?, <3? :::@:::§3é3:3$at_§a::,



5%.. 33:3 there is; my d3';3pz.'zi:e re-garciing in_j'urir:2:a:
sustainéd by f:.he é::iaimar2i:. in the mad ir3f:f§<%V--':3._c<:icie:1i

{§{i{EL};E'"Z'€d an 03.832639"? dug Sci: ihﬁ rash ;»3._:iiivV"11¥:i:;§I.§g{€r:f

Ciriving 03" {ha {::ffé:nr:1;i'}f1g; vahicle by ifs driisér :1:-"2..ci ' Ei%a;'3:3iEit§;«_V

cf £316 insurer Gsf Qffendingg v€} 1.is:%}éé'f1:f3 pa}; c¢':n_p€§:';Sati'9ng 

the o'I1§y paint, that remains £091: C0n$v1s:i;é1"'at=.ir;§:§A'£:1'ins
appeai 1S:
'A-='h ethér  A q'z1.~3;%.rf:';i§'1§:;§1j4  ._ Camﬁérﬁatian

awarded by"i:'I:ieA  Tifi3§}Il 'ZE1§L1AA "-is just and
remsoiriabie or dais fit icaiif£:\1fu:f'e&uC:i0r: er

enhamiﬁgnent " --
5. 1 fizz? ,h§~§.a1'-i1'§g..:_:h€.._§;ea§:'iifsﬁVCeunsei for the §ar't:'ie3
a31f;i" ?;'§T5<~::'=L:;<g;,ir:';,g 7';E":«s*::"'a§§;?a.r(E  5f" ihe Tribunal, i am {hf the
viexér «t3r'1awtV:i'?zs7?:'«:'}»hi;;:~a_.':*1t.§iT:";rA<' 2:-yf Campsnsation awaréed by the

'E'Vrijbun::iE is 12.0': j{;:;st "énTd reasotrzabie, it is 911 the higher

 theféfbfév it is to be red2;1€:€d.$

  Wimnd Ceriiﬁétate EX. P E'?', saga ssummarjg

"   fjzanﬁiii Hzxggitai EX. P 18, §iSCh8;I"§§,€

s:::3fz;ﬁ;3r§-* :3? Shekhar Eiiagpitai 63:52:. E3 2% and Rgdieiggy

V' 'V_b_:%f%;p@§°i EX. E3 2} ﬁiéﬁ Ciaimaziai hag $2;:$t:a1?:%:§d ihfi

faiiawérzg irzgzzmzg:



'N .



6

1.

C()I'33p('){.1'I'E('i f'x'2-,:«:'.t'.:.,1.':"r:é C")? it-sfi'. f:*é1:1m.z':

{J CI<*:11":p<3L.1:"1e:i i'z'.2;1<<":1'.'1.f12*@ <:>:fb<i)%:1'1 b{'}I1€fi» Qf Id': ltégz 3 . S€T§j§IT1C?3'}i' .93 f*r°2.:<:'::11x'=;? of m 221 n {iii} E8 A §4{z1<ii<)§<3gy I'<;>p0r1' C§i£§('ii(}Sé3E; the fr:-1.<;ti2;.11'c'2 <33".«'I'-;:>r§$&2*:":_1*"~_a.:'1d upper :%:'1<:i 2i«1.:m:i 1:1ec%k :35 left fermzr. L1p'pe_;*§Ti%x§i«g§_' V:-2;-'_§j£"_1:;,<_g'~«,:_)_f~ left' tibia ii] R'_E'A. P 28 :i~;«;h<>wss t.}121::..?f1,{}_"-wziteéfzxdzzwiimgi Eio Sarijeiy (}.21z'1d11i I~fc)sp1't:2;11 c'):1i'5£,8.2Oé:}7 ;:i.:51"c.E:1r:»:i.é§;'v§2é:1'1ifj 0pemti0:'1 w'ii;i1 i:r1t.c;?:':'1.21_1 f'i>;21t4i:<H'1 13:') ~1*€dz.1C"c _ i'.i1.§;% . E.' ':1<:7t£1}:..rc3 and hzic was cii:a<:he1rged.T'<3;i1 1214,2007,»"'7'F?§c'::*ez:'§i.<3f ":»'v'21E§ ;1£im.ii',t.€;'~{i £10 E$E1€k1T'E§}#'V'x£U¥E3'$-£'}i'f.:E3.§V":3.E']'VVé€r2i:?:@é%::?K200? zzmd di.s<:}1arg<éd on 24.(}8,2OQ?'." -.r'v.'}.'V"'.¥'I£V';T'i'»";_€",'£3;i'«"i",f_?l'"" 'i'1€:> £:~;;%<:a}<; 1"egui211"

§'<)}Ei.f3w magi'5€~.:*<:;ii;m.<;:=rf;ij:-.,.P'»7\z'_' 4 O;:*E;hepedir:. :+3t12"g<t013 bass; dep«:3:éi.{.i-séd ab'<;m_i,~ '{,}"1£;f'"E1f{,}Ei7tESé1id muitépie fI'é1(.'Ii1.11"€, i}:Z'1{T'. of i';jrit2'1i,.::fz":<?: :1: 'z:n{'.iV(.ii.ee;é;,1r3iEi*:4j§,,r <;:;'1'us3eci i':<;> 'i.}'1<:% {rig-'ziz":12;1.rr'a. at {*§8% A _§.'<; '{E5i.<;§ §:i._1j:"7;'i_) atmi 265% is {£167. wh<)k-: b«:3<i}-'. 2 €:7:§.§i'1§§§i:"3i'€?§'§'I"E§__§ ihzs m:~:.'E:1.2m <3? %:'T:~'§:2:"i€s; E%3s5*E§{}.€}{}{},f ~ $1-?ai"a?.jf:i'c:::%_«--'E33; i.he 'i"'r"Eb':,.::';aE i:<3wa:*{i$ pzezzizi aamgi saufE%3.ri:'1§§ V . ,<3z': § §"£.€f E':ég;§1<e:" :'«i;§::§:é 2:-mzi E a,*§;s1:'{i §€s:sX?{3¢{}{3€3,z"~ 'LEZ'1{'i€2' iizig; °. aéa&,

9. R:~3.?'i..8€){};'-- awzI:rctEe.:_i F3}: tizm 'i'1"i'b'L'a3'}.2.2.E i.:}v.:arc.i5; }":<>::~:;p:{I'2'1iissa%§;i<_>r:z c:_*§'1e-*:.;'g:..;;{::«: ;13:1_d .mer<'Ii<'%2i1.1 €;?X}}€E'1fﬁ§€i&.9% i'1fSi ?:32.as"s€::{1_ cm i:%'1.r:>. bills p:'<,3{i§.1<'*r:3o:f1 E33; i:h<:? <::1aim2:1m';, §,:¥1ﬁ?.E7f.i"§£é§ }',[-iii' s§{::g:a;3£:? fa}: i1'1i1t%':'f'e?rté1.'2(rt: §.11'Ed€'i' iihise heaii.

10. ﬂea? was»; €_z*e:ai.<5:<i ir'1;3é:i'i:§c:'z':i:. in. ' '--{}2:.i:;={I%1éi' H'c.>sg3iI'e21§ 22n'1«:i S1"mk1'1a.:" E*i'<_:»s_p.it:z'i1V_fc3*:f 43 ciéjgzs'; »Cl*<3§51--s-.§id,§%fi~tj1gj {he sa:.11s3 Rs:~;.1€},OOG/-- §3\*;"é1»I;{i¢?Ci 1:3}-*¥';.h?;§ uTI"'§i:ii:2i.:;'1;%i}V tiowearcis iI':1c1'd€:é:r1"i:aE r3x_p<:2:'1s:.;<:'&:: s'uc'.itiW23;s:;.:'{?«:>=i*n§ey.211":<'féé'; '1*§.o:_';:'ise;Em1e:'1i:

21116. zH:i:enci21n*i: <:}1e::rg<'«':-s'i:§';j:::1?t:.I1e_Z1'€:¥§1?€1E'_..sici<:% emd 1 award £26 , OO(},' 4 « ,§"1dc%1:?__ {hi r;%'.2;u§'. -- .. V' E. 1 "§'Ef1<:' {I?iéié}R'1?1.I'1'1"i'E'i.>>f§§1p}3()2"f. of .h.iS (fC)£1E'€3I":TtZ.i{1H'1 111123. hi":

2.v::;wrkis:;_§ 215;' E~Z%'é1.1.a E',:1"1'i:';"§.,' illctrk in L.21b<:>:'zmH3z ..113151'§§E§1'§'{41}'§€:'1'€.'éi'E"};'£§"'{fEEITI1.i£"1g§ Rs+s.5,0C}Q/-- pm. 191.2155; p1'{>£E1.:.:::{::ci _'q::'i:E3v§€'{E;}L1E;2"'¢€jl?f§.i§'i{T'&iE.@ at; Eiix. E3' 22, 55£1IE.§.1"y C<3rE_EfE::a:i.€: 21:"

' fix E3_'§3,Zé i--g,~z,2'§ :1 'E':'z:1':$E'k-fr €}?CrE:i£'i{%2'a;f::2 at EX. P 213 f':'<T)§":2 wE':i<':E"; 31$: iémzizai Q1211' he has; §3z;2:%s9;<€%{:1 SS3,-C 21.315} Ef}§;:}.E<3mz:., Eéui:

u _»_E:§': h;a:<_~; ram' §=x2.:.n1é_m"*.<:E me §.3;'£§§".§'1{}I' <3? E%3;i:E;::.:*y {.';¢r§;§Efir:*:.:::{:<-:2 22:32' €:{:a1.:':1i:'::::i *::;E'1a: £'.I'.'§E§}§\ }"€f§2 E2"; éézs 21b:~.--:;:%2':<é<:r G5 §}E"{.3{7s{ <35 f§I£'1{'T{§§'E'2<'t <'?:_>;<":.s*--;%z:§<;'%:':?rag E_:_.E:s :e:;:§:':; g:3:*:._>E%;%§ss;§<,}§: ;.'::':<i }%'a:;;:;* <2! " "';--"1é: 2116.1;

21<:?<éi{ir3r'1i.. .'r1.i:~:-: ;L.1'1c<m1<c. c':<'n.2_1::1 <:~z"1::~';i§y 't:v€: assessssed at Rs.4§5{){),/-- gm. 21§.§€IiE3f'§i'. §~1s9s.5,{}C}€);3 pun a::;s.e%s;s<:z<:i by i..h<'-: 'i':*Eb1.::121_1. €1(3'12s3i<i.c;::"i1'Lg§ the 1:ze1'£1.:re. of ir*;_§»i.i;*iTf:::3'"aml €?'.ViC1iEE§'1{ft";? ('31: 1%ez':(.:«1'x:§ the c:£2}.__i111z21':t. r:1:.f;-sf .I:'i*£';1.";-""€."' *P.i<;%c:?::3 :.:1':«:iezz*g<3:T1_e i:'€:?2'-1'i.Y1'1€?1"1'ij arid 1*::§é;f 25:'i' «}:f:::f:.»S'i'i .;ft::1f" p¥e:9i<;}{i". -:.>i"§ erigklti 'x1:«::ani;hs and E a.waafd E€:§.:36;'fI.}_OG/-- 'j:_g0;i;z:1:*{is;;~;.'1.963%~{;a'f i1'1(i%():ne3: (i113'i1'3§; laid up ;§'<:;1tfi(>.(.i 21$':1..f;§£xiI1;ﬁ"sf, "§{$.V:V5€},GGO/~ é1Vx-"'£"i1'd€':Ci E33; t:hs:: "I'17i'*m.;':1211.;' " '

12. C(>n$ic:1e:'i1'1g t:.he.;i'1_2%1'--:;£"eé »:ﬁ2:'f"'ir{1§Li.'1':2:3:--3, the di$abi}:£iy si,a1T:<:~:ci_ 't3}ﬁ.§E1'e_Vé:}.0<:i}:}1- azzéii 211%'é:;r3';(>i1.§;1*i; af <ii:«>C;:::11f0:'t, E115:

<_:E2::ir112:t:'t ..1f:..:>ua .!('1'a?}.'é1' gm i:€ 1'2i$ E1,1E':u.re 1£.f<':*: Rs,20,000/-- ?c'£"9'«.»'-"'c1§:'iZ§.i'E*.{i by f£:E"3;<-{"§'fi*1b_::i':¢2.a.§ €,<::xx.?2;1':'£§s 30:35:; 91f;-:.n1<3mt,i<=:s; 1:3 0:": tin? E{:>x£>§:%{..:»§s.i:%.éi 2.i;'1{:i ' E award E'{s3.3G5.G0{}f- :.m::ie;~ér this: §ft3.'<._ "E'E'*u: :::§s:s<':"€,<:>:" Efz2:s_%; s.§i'2:?;.€rci UT"I€%§"€' is éﬁs,-:»;1't3i1:%tTj; mi' 618% £15: 'A Vifém E%:':ﬁ:a.?:' ﬁi" '§,_;"3%'<'5~ <3? the ssarzzce £59 <":<::}:':s:;3Z<i<%r<;%cE E18 fa:n{.:%'£'i.<m23E :1%is§;aE:}i}§I'§; ii: <':<';s:3"1.e:s% ix} Zﬁiéaéﬁﬁ ;"<,;2..::':{§€{:§ {Eff :19 §.,:::§?g.§":3<-:?{:§ <Zi<'2:,::'§${%'E §"£_:=:* i..E:"x€5: {7§2?§Y:"§§T:§'}% 5:.§'::::2"§§E15%s ijhzﬁ 9:: 2;:<%<?<'>z2§'1.i. <is:§' "é:%f:.s'.= ;°.::':_4;?z.:_:;*";?.s::2:~:.'~; :~s::;~§£;2:£m%<:i '£3; i'§*':e {ii;-i..i.EfE'.i.£'E.£'"i§I.§ E1".§§I' 9 1% net abée ta ::on"§i:me big jab and ha has lost his future p1I"<::Sp€:t?;$ as I§:'1?(€,E.§-16 i?s?h€:~:*e:5:ss Eﬁarned C0mr1$€:} ._f{;r the insumr $t.,1hmi'f;.3 ihat {here is; rm ezséétsnse ta- §§lri{;a§$"*:E1ai. E336 ciaimarat has éiscstztimued hi3 jab Gamma: <::£mti1'm€: his job i}1€3f€f{}T€ 5§.he '§':fiE::'i:;:<1a«§ 'E339; ~ semmittad an :":r"r"c:«'r in axézardniizg future lass {f)fiI1C:£}I?f1€. » I 9 A . T A L 15;. Censidering jthﬁ 1r1g:1--t:If€«_C:§_._i3:xj£:fi€SA iiffcannot be said that the c3,ai11;£:%f:.:A hi3 jab affectiveiy as he zvag ¢i;ta§.:1g The muitipliﬁr a§]:"}¥Vi'§f3'3?1'«é§ ?;éé' :£§i£§3 the Ciaimant. is 13. So. E0$% .$f1." ﬁrarkg eat is Rs-.:.2,23,55®/~ {1ii';sV,4,5§e;T*;f_' §;f.ViZSA9;%'E: §~:° 12 X 18} and it :3 awardéd as ' :{:a:é'8;iii§8t-.g/- awaréad by the '§':'ibu.:1a§.

V _15»:"=..'V{L:::é§;§§:f:&r'i::§.§ natare sf iajaries aﬁc': evidence cf tbs 'A -- awarﬁzsé by aha Tribunai; :.ewa:~ds fm%,:;;._ré znedicai €*.X§}€I':S€$ is jusgi, am grape? and it: daeg " ':f3£;:€$. Cazii fag" §3:1'%;:€:'§€'?@r:{:@.

.1 8 £6, T§'11.15§. f§'"16 c?§£,:i§112:11"1i emiticétji f{7}'i" {E16 f<>1I<;w1':'1g§ <;:c:>:"1*;p<:11'1 s.".sf:;:1£:i <:n"1 :

1.} §3*221ir: a;1;;'1.e:'I E3t.2f§::éri':"1g_g:a; Rss.?{}',.C}é}§;,{3vv.< ii} §VEE?{i§{'E13 £I'X§)('.'.1155€Ef~§ .1. f§:i§{}'§3j iii} 111£éi<f1::*m"22:.I C'Xpf.?I'Ei~'é(i'iS _-"Rs-:.":2.0._"ff~3.{)€1« u

iv) 1.05:3 of iI'"E{':(',)1"134E? (i:,14;i1§g_ 4' V _ ' L2':.1.§c'1 up pericisd T V 'I2ss';f§6,£)t'}{3~,;f V) L(')S.'.I~i« <34" z1.z11c;%1"i_it:§<§%':s;.V V V _ I{s.E%._ ";'£}.G$/ ~ Vi} LGSS5 <31' E"L§t.2:u"€3 i1'1l:':<.)vm--<::_ .' ~ RS. 2:23.580,/' ~

vii) E'L:t.tm3: f_;i'iz:cii<:'é3.i <%x§;<%_':::~i§é-:5 i.2,QG{)/ ~

-T."m4;;a" K R-55.4. 53.3f:30/ W 1?'. A<é::c;~1*:'i'én§'{;1§g* ﬂzei; :;:;§3}3t:2i.1 f_'a;.:i1_(_j1__f {.'.r{>sS €)bj€E(I?.§(3IE am dispostsiti _;:$'i7._». V" "'s.'-?§Ez:?:_i'I'x12},:T1t"=_ e11t'.ii.ir;2<i for £3. 1:;r:.>t.aE (ram13e:'1S23€i';_c>x; £.:f*».._ Rss,4,63,f3€iOf ~ as agai:13'i;

R$a5'5':§V%';§$00£f V :<=.a;iu-*:1Vi"«:i__é7c'1< "by i:E':<": '?':"ibu.:1aE with. .11'; t.::r;:"e&'_-*.t: 23.11 _p.n2V.~-.f;4<:3:1'1 {ht-2 {\1&'}{I€? of cﬁzzim Hi}. t.h<: date": Qf ' « _ 'i*<:=:a1}'j'é5§e2E._§::«:j.1.

_ET}?! '.f§"§T14{:.,_§§"s'ff~§i4EE"&?zI'T§CI€ C<:>;.":1;;:=2;3;':}y is :iir<-éitﬁargi H3 {ic=2;3<}s~sii: fizz? '.__<:V::>m.pe:'::§g_;:ii<}:'2 2:::'m::umi",, 21_i'.'E.<=:1' «:'iz3<:'h,:{:{,::1g.; 'ihe am«:>z.m§', if 2:.:':'_'y; ;%I5§.:"e:::<,'Ey {'§<?§}{}-§§§§'é?{Zi é<':g:;-t<'t._E'::<:=.*.:'° Wm': i;1é":'i€:'::s;~*;:T. :x.2i':§':§::': '§.1§:'{:2 v _._:f:f:'a'}:';i:E';s=; §%'{:>:":': *£:E'":é? {ii-'§§_.{E {sf :'::<~:"=,i§}i' <'>f 2:2. <..:<:§g:3j»; <2? E_'E'1.i$ $5 If j1,1c1g11":€:1'E zmd the S°32'l§}'1{';7 s:s1":.e'1.11 be (4115-;bm'1°s&;e(i1 in i':emi1s:e' of the z1\&~*a1*(1 of f.h::.* ']'1".i%3« L.1§"1.z'11., E9 '¥;'1:'}.é;% E11'Z'E{I3t..ii".1[. in :ie}'>{:s5ii. is c')1"d€§1'r;'.~{'1 't':ci§'.bevtV'1<.2m:;f'£3:fi%:?::t K} i?"}:1r3 '1':'§i;a1..1z'121.1 fl:)z' dé.s;E';>u z's§c3311%;%1";if" A ?.\}'0 (}'i"{i€'1" 21155 to (':c'):'sT.5s' ~ " 2 V' x gﬁgﬁt lm%_x %aé§% vb/--

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court