Karnataka High Court
Sri H. D. Kumarswamy vs Sri M Vinod Kumar on 8 September, 2011
Author: L.Narayana Swamy
Bench: L.Narayana Swamy
?'€{L4§§324§/203$ .:.":2.i5+;a.:.:~=;<'?d hi5»; Gffiiifgf in g:}a$s;1?:1;:; {hat <>r_§§_€::° 0:}
4', I€3u2Q€}7 ap;32:0:ri:";g§ Elma": B D A :"<::%;<,}E'ution far ismk
in <%{>:'1.s"~;§de3%r21£:§0:1 sf flats? 2;&§§<';i.r:'2em. <32? Siffii {}..?€§ 2" :11«s:2§i$2,fl:r§V§':!gM"»
11$' X E50" 0:: '3 5.42908 in fzivaur :>f"h"iS"wif£%'..i-S Erréi-$'<:?.%<3ss§'.::'«'"i'§*;;§%
p:::€:i'{:§:>r:r3r in Criniiizai 'P€i;i'E.§1<}§1 N c;x,4Q2E3.g_" 2>'Z}_1.} 'a";e:@;2v_::1:11vs3'~}.';;i@::*::Ti:sé:{
qtziiie <:':2%.r1.i§-tr to his; hussbzmd I*3e{f£s;fi€:c:. CE1i<3'f.Ixf17i;Ii'«:~;tt§:; éhe has
paid $136 {3(}}_'15$iCi{'3i"ElfiO§"§_ Oi?'~~fi§f1§'€$i°4éj§J§. --:§Z§:§3u€{':S"£i£":{:V§3":V 1%}1€ Lisguaé
<Zf{}U.§"S€ the Exits was a11Ut,i:¢:§i{_ the game was
{i'c1I1{f(i'1€:'..C§ by regi;$té::§:fi 1--'Jh§Ch Xfig,/55,8
re§gi:3te:"<~:d on made by her were
refunded v[#3re3dua::eciK Effie {~i]T1"'i;i:"€
proiieedimgsé':;':j.%:'i.iefi<é&.V_.£%£,'A€;§i:_€-:§}§é'é:f E9'?3 by the \7éshx>2zabhg':raihé
H<>uss<--: Bagjaifijirzg C@{}_p'5%ai',i'«.=*§-3 S{){3i€{}" §,td., azzd {he r€a<>EuI,§{§n$
:'§3_:;1;3§<¥3e.(i "by "B,E).:%. and i:E1s:% dir:;*<:€;.i::}:"zs--s iaaaazzed in the 'ii-'I'i§i
p€:E.§'?::%§}§§;:-3 §;é3':?:"_:§. é'§:"'{": 33%} %'E1%: ma*:.:3:ri2:ES w'r:3'.::%'1 §3'E'0':7éE {hat
;3eii«€;.§<}:':€é:"-£3 C3*:i.m1?:1a_E P<§ti§.ti{}n F\E{3.~<i§214g'2>€3'i"E has me':
£?4§"§¥E"Efi f:?%f§fE_§3{3: émy {>fi?3r1{?§% 0%" abu.SiI2_g his-3 ¢:)f§ic:s:3:, Aftar {he firde:
{§f2§1;.é?{§. '4€é;'"§S.2fi{3"? ::§'s€: %;':°:ii: }Z%i;'f'Ei§§',§{}I.'i;'E-=3 :"€:%£=%;"§':::{i a%3<>::$ {§£:2;'m1?s-;ss;<:€E
""'§;::1Vi:":;:2; §'.}é?{?=*Z}§"E":£'E §:'::5"z":.:{fi.:.:<}2.::~:-; $5: E.E:ae;': <)':°€i<3:::"§e {"§22i:s.%€§
;
A.»-'9'?'
"gm
13;, 3{§.f2:G0'? in 'J1?' ? M}. 2.22.38,/2{}G6 22:15': <'}2'z7£:=-éz" <i2;:.:.<>,{§ %S,.ii__._2{§€}8
3:1 :*€:ss:',.;}e:;%E': GE' 0€'§'}¢:%E" {',{,',>E"E1'}€{.'.§1€£§ _E}€;'fi."§'i'Ii.()I'TI::%= E?\le::}';}<>::'i§€;'K1235;
<;:hz2E§e1'1§ge:éc% E'.%1e :3:¢-ziti tmzier i};1{?§{,:£§§i'}g 3.115: cam;:»iA:>g§.31a§:%.Vi;:V;L'
§€«i%}"E"§.E3(i {?:<m._:'z$<::.I 55uE>:1'2i1ii:e:d $31211: the"€i§)f:':_p§:2;%:'1i:.;«éfifséif Vsfl";-%;3ui'<§
have '£36631 {"i§s2;1'§3;_i:eas_%ea'§ E=;£§'3{E€ frhe §}3?f{§§£EfS z11*9§:v_% 'p:;3::=5..€a§:.;:'§'--~.§::,
<':0mp1iane:%{3 of the «:Ei1"€{:t;<3::'1 iSS1iéE€'§i"C§V3 :f§?'.E'iIV"§iS {Em.:1*'=:-'.=
8, Thé iearncjii eta:::{:.:3$eE _? :f<>§' L~-f_£:{;¥}'-.peé;.iU<)fiei's fu'r'{._he:'
stiibniiits in £'€'Sp€3(";E. of a1.E€g21_t"i~t:t;1 t--:;€_2< fI:}1ve:)u:" :'::h{}w;n to
:;'is€E:*ay '£'%7:a"fé. 1'§'&'iz;1Vi1<£:gjvF.,¢:;%a;5:e was gratified iii:
,2' 3.3 zmth akai £5
famur «sf Mr,R2;ha*:%%4é§;%V§§§§i t3fiL'éIi§<>V§'5:93 an 69,1965 for a
pgeriod of i'ranSfs3:1'r€d in f21v0'L1z* :)f
M ,/S'JEiH£hE;1A§{¢¥V: ""'2.«r.§;":"£e'::'.'.C%0'v€::"rm1eni. {};:"'d€';f Ne. Ci 3 248
EMS 89 5§a;i;é3c§ 'V Subsé3qu€:m.1y' 3.1": §}iEE'S%,E&1m{1€ 05
:%;1i:_1{::';:,E_» E'v§2:':é.Aga1.;ées:% $1213 221%} bfféfifi $£iIi€§',i(1*§2€d fee ihig Eeasséé
2i§£?;€»:" figs yéaz" %3a:":f<':rr5: €;%x;3i:jy* emf ?i,E1<--': Sésasaz
Lx/E;'saJari'%:%12:i§<a§".E:1*{.€:"pri£-%;e$ mafia gm 2:;§3p§,i<:e.:';.£<§:": f<;>§* zexzeaargii.
. "§""§"..i:;é:;»., s§&j;:1_£ {fame {,8 ha :'*ej€eé;':§ied. A.g§a£:":.s;:.i. iihi-re aaid mdsr, 3:
._2"*u'rii§<:%:%;,f §§e*:%;',i'i;.§{}:2 "<£=£':-35%; fikxi b{if{}.¥'{? §:'E':5": {}{}1-"€t§'1'1§§E§ZZE?f, «:35 Ertzfiéa zingé
G{7s*;§:r§";:*:";s:%:'}§.; {>5 Erutiiaz 33}? 'she €}}"{§€3I{' IF'§<:».E.94;'§%§% {§2:§s:<:i
$5.
3
-- }.{:§--
§'}€ff"?'?"£iE§SiOE'E 2:./:.>E'2i(.?§': £5: 330$: 52:. 5,235 pc=;é;s~;:iE;Eeé in :iE"z{.= a§:>5;:%t;*_2;<:€ of
varieus <§E<3(,ara.n<:es, E:'zv£ro:':.zn53%2:. €33:-;>:(;r{zz'z{:a{i%"9:2Tz: zizsgr. ;'%Zf:':*?:.{§s;§_;{z;A<a;j'
E:2:;ir0:'2:m>.r'2.: mid. Forgn-'~::,§ (}g>s2ers'2:':':e>;2z: <:g_j'
G<>ve-rmimrii. 0? imiia by itisg <}2*{£m* d23.*t.é€i"i.2?,8.2(}f}?"v'i;z1&§-%I§é.'.$:";
pf;'E'ITE}iSSi()EZi :0 iii: E laéih M T Eoaw grazfeg §;§_:'{_§:';'TVGi;é3..
.§sza€§a;_.' ~ ' <:*;r;;e v
.
:a°<3.i"e:1'1*&:<:i by {he Commigsiiirmr fl'Lz1_f"~E7§<)2§'bii%_ <3%"_:i:3'£i'_ E'R}i.i;Vrii's;*z.ér h21s:* giver: 'uii4inaa{:um that: ;::er:_a;1§ssi<)n;..ss§i:::u;.1}:'§ be gf-J.ef--3':_':i; Within m.«"<> houra a,vfi:l":<>ut. 105555 of i'iI?{1E3,. A;.s._ a1;.j_1';-é5é1;:i§., E}_§:puty I}irec%:0-1" 0? Chitmdlzrga W213 €ii1°{:<*:t<id ::}_é3:E»i+:>\?é__ £<§£5£--'a;é€: €1.25 jV_§ifiZ aid S:-3§'.f}{?§<S asé aE:t'<«:a&.y it is; pe1"'H3__i£:t.z§""'by €}(}%§é:*I11"fie.;2f:;'é}'§-'India on 218,208"? . This Qrder E1215 Egeéii ;'}j321s.é<3::i i'EiéG<f§\r<:>1'nme:1t sf Enciia. it ES zifieged fi:?a;'{ {f}1€§ §3'<;f€.«i_i§;«:::I1<:;»"a_:~3 af Chief E'sr'E§:::is's'::<:=,1" gut bxeavy praisgmre ta make 31"'-Vf'e3;i>"r§'L:..:°."~-- .33: is m;v¥:.ic€e;§ ighat. '{§1€;;"e wag an &é§3E°ori; by, M;'$,a§zi;1€:h:a.£:'21§ "EZa.E':&r;3:"§s€%$ .E:§iH€éf3 fr::::m EQ85 §§-:$E37i;f€% ':
j_T*§"V_%V2;€"s__i£;': '-"'«:?'y;%if§'§f;«. §{1'§.€E"'E'§2?;§V'"{E'{}E;'E°éiSpGE§{1§€Z"};{7€f% §}%';?§1¥€{;*.§2 ms: Si;a%ié3 $2213 Egg {ég-"::_V % <>:>§i1r::«:'9_ ._.
{§(>;?<::j:ér:'.:£::vi.v ';':'::*;'£?: %:.vh.§s3 €fi€n¥;.§9_E €%<3v€:rr1:z1€g:i'.5 '§'Z*a¢:: rézxfiiéms' pewfiz"
,r ~ §'§";3: this: {:'(}V€1"§1£E1€E}'£. {if §E1{§§é1 :,::.":{§<*;z' M .3'? R E} £:<.E§. €::?f1~<E '?i.:%:{fs' "Writ: §}€%'f.§_?;.E{}£ES §§.§é;?€§ azzd €;fi:'{-%<:i.Ee:;z:15:% 2>;€:§'e 5§S:T;:.::%:ri§ _?i;<> "§2--§'§€: €}<;:2?::%§_":2:rm?z1.E ix} rééifiéfiaiékz? é:7:fi.§?i" §§:"<::'%,r*§z:§£':':g J W;7_ {,§§£}:§}€)E'§'.E,1Ii'Ei€:y". En i'}":é:'i §1};é?£:E.EE£':-'}1i§€f {}<w::;*;'1§m:%:T1€: :12?' Endis: :1<:>%';.ifi{:at.é<}:'"2 <iat_e:-:d 2'?;E.%,26€}?' (.'8.I}f1€? p<=rm1§£.t§ng IVE /sa«J;1.:'1i:E2a§<\21i Ei;":i,e":::'*pr§§<::s'; €10 iii: 1 1a}:.E: EVE T :35 said ss;*£;<;::;:}«:; ziumgsefii Em:::_. (31% in fiize ba<:kg_§r<>und af t,§1_<-:~.s:323 <1:{3r;'€rssp<):2_e:iem?:€;*:s zmd <i§:*i*€,€féli»:f{§2$"<a§' €;h€ €0u3*"i:;%, the ps3'§.§f;i<}z"2€r migifi. E":a'n:€ d1'_rs:ct:ee:i to '§)gis5:§ '§2h?€ ?.~32;1T§§ V' « ordez', E pm 21 SffEf~i'€Si1i".E},J§E1TL from pfaaiécziéflg ~:i'"i,:1"jiii":;e.r '.g~5§:::c}§:s izhere is r%3i'sr<3_11<.:e3 "that éhs pe1;"iti£;=t1e:" E335; p:zJ.£: 'u1'1fa.§§*:2u':d gjresszlréz on 'fhé? C{3mmiss3i:::'n€r 2'i:'":€i"V»:fi.~:~;(> V2tb_e:§'L1Tt';V-3RS;,4G iakhss has bean paisi in {he 80:"; §_>£'v~i:he_'VA€Q::§r;:iss'i--t§':1er whmh 2:}: has {.0 be ganéi into in ihti t.§1';:_1'; fi§;};ij7s~.V's€::é:§g:f£§' what can be gzufhered is that. 3&1 f;'**i%c7vas.:f ~1:A>f" :%i-3 tiir€c.'fi<":r1'55 and the arders ggassede dirsattiém C_:r4:ig1_s fgjiirsiiaf' the arciar within 21 §3ar§:§cLz£ar Efiziéj- A}i'%:;3.€::_ 3:551? 7€,~23;;:mCrt be 2-': g;§r0u.z1d ii} deny the baénefit. Sf Seé?i_.§L:§fi ,. 4' .E§¢, _§z:_ , :*@§§:s@<f=.*;. =35 :';.£;téfi<;:e;.é.i{m in ii-bé.§p'i--'V<}i4'EE" {Bf Efish€a;=21'b§1V::::9:§i;15:1'§--_Egidégse E3:£.i_§a:§§ng C@»:;;:»€ra¥:_iv€: S{}C§€'.§::?._ as eihiézzziy iii é5§g_ré%§E-3:"rs3{i§ ::l1§::"§% '%Si?'{-3i'°'i'f m,.:zn'§;~é3;" 9%" axsrii: ;3%3.i:i§:..§{}ns 'vvI'»'V91§.?:.';*i;fi§..'.§;'AA€fi:T7§3':t:?§Z§{}'£'}S W€3E'€f §$.s:sz.':§:=:§ ziziééi 31.3% :':==:s;€;§:_::E:§:};§ pzzgafisi by K