Karnataka High Court
Commissioner Of Central Excise vs M/S Madras Cements Ltd on 11 April, 2011
Bench: N.Kumar, Ravi Malimath
{N THE HIGH CQURT GB' mmarmm AT [};:E'{>.::§ ZE'11':4; E"E2€:-r 1 P" <:§a3; €i>f §'1p':'i1_ 2-{E M '£~>;%z§s5§«:2ié9:' THE HQNBLE Mié..._V'J.g:s'r1CE EVE . ' THE HON'BLEv Mfii. ..JUs1j:c1é:'--:§A$r;«.,MAL1MATH B.I;'1w1a:{«:N;' 7-.
C0111111ié:si€i1'1e'1" {if C'[€.;')t.1~aE 'V'1'§«}C<Ef'§S_§€:? E3a11ga1c)1*¢:%uII; C{)'i'"£'1'I.I'i§'f5.S"i(3IiE?}"éii.{? PB. N0.544UQ§ 'Q'L1€?€I'1'$'..RC321€§i i3ar1g;:10;'£;é M .:'§t'Z(T) 01 E' V" ...Ap_peEi:1r1t:
figy $;'§}§é§*:3:='22_:'3 J . 1'\Ec:s?1'ai;_;;;'.i. 5-"xdv0{:zi1i'e) *.M,«" E'%%E2:;,;£z?a:s €<?2'."s1m'1i'$ ii",-i;.:§..
_ A " fa/11;E.1;E1{>{iL:"
' V'2}--*E<>ss;3<i_'_,1:'g,,§:1 "§'aEu:§< £1315-3%,. €f3§'1§21r21<§uI'_g;a ,, . ( E-4% <%?s:;p<_%.:i1'{i_:%¥'::'1.§. V' ~ .
;v:7?a"I Ei:;i=i('Y§'£%E?
This; CEEA i'§k><,i m'1c:i{:r s§sc:{'r:'.1:<;:11 BBC} <31" E..Ef:'é«:*-- Ce}:
Am. 1944 a:"i:si1'1.;g; cunt' 01' {::1'c.'1s;?:* cialeci 1V~ :3--2_QQ§3'~--pz1&e V _ Qztiéitz' Na),54E3;'2OOEl pt';1jy*i:1g;{ {£3 [V§}Wi,{;> d«:é<:;t1'{i€" S~.%L;£_bvSi4£1,{}i.§a1 qL1.es;Li<m Gfiavsz srsizfleci i.11€.2"€:~§:':: {ii} 556:" 2.isie:j§€=-«_t.1":c;% C ~":';E§f§'A*I'.VvSt3u€:l;;~.__ 2,0119 Béfiltihg Bazragz-1.§{>1'c%, in fi1'12'1"£. <.3:f:cét?~:" NL':v_.54.Q,"2O'{}9.Htiated E./5/2009* ingxppeezl I'€<3.E/4?T'E§/290?' " ' This C CA <?01'§'1i1"1g m'1 "' _ §.fi1E2.ii'~. &f1t%:%1"i:'égg this day, N. KUMAR J1, C§{?iiV€'.']"(j_d $1.116 §'Q'§L¥£)xg&?'iv:'1§§:':-~.._ ' * V «SJ DIG '"F1'ii3}.~s" «s1:;§},;'3<:%;4. Vi':+:-- 'b§§ 'E1'1e _Ré<}-*e1[1 uc €".'§1£1§t?i§giI1g the ordtzrr passssetixbjz ._ihf: ri3f§'t:;1'ié:L§.._fi0Efil;;.I1g §.}1a'£ the 2155835596 is <31z*{.i1,.1ed to the §"J_er1<~3i"t;?:"'<:>I.' f'_'fX§'_"vEv'I'v'£_pA1',:I'f:"3b.{'};"i€;)Lifi('?::11}§.{)i'1 N963/02 clatezci 01.03.2002 as é'.i~I1f,'3f?;d«i":;.Ci. H ' ~~ ---------- ~ "
',4.
A 9 " VA _ "'§§h<:é 2.15?-x::~5€5:3s:3€<;=.<V4; v:='e1'er 2;:£°{Ex'1?z'15.;j ihfz': W01"ds.a 'RAE/ECCF PIZ'Q§)'LE{'f7Ef i.;i.["i;%':"<? iacéai §ZiE'1§iI£ig€T 2-H163 'E',h.c-t:§; wera 2115:} sseiiirlg ihfif'. {?<%r;=":.cé::€,,_":.':a.c§'§:*:' f§'i{?iI' (mm £.m<.f:% rz321:"}=: '§{A.E{"i'I---Eléf". "I"§:<;é R<%ve2z.1.11e p:fa::::::t€:<;is;:'d 2,1§_;;2;u'nsi--;t -me £fiéE%;f?%E?E§S5{§}é' on i"hc _gz.'<>:.2I'1c§ H12-£i she 2.3.536 01' (1 in ;'*':'.1:a'E"
{Em w<}'s*c:§s_as "E'{fi,§'~fi{?{} PR{i)Zf)UC"'E"" w<.mIc:§ m.>:E 6' rm' 2.1.6 "She ¥r_)€.:1<::f§1£. {Ef €,E'1<;= E"1{'J§I'fi("Z21§iL'Jf"1 £22. xf§{:*w vi" am: '£21 the r"1<1:i'.:'f"1'c.>21?£.:i<'}"i§._ d<;%-1'1ym5_3; 211:7. s:~;2_1§d 't3e1'1é:§"ji '_r'..:":.. :'+se,11ir1§ é}1<:*.£1' §31*<>cim1%i ma the (>23.
'iraciéé E'-i£:l.I1\1€:?u A.f'£:€:':' E1é:r21z"'.i1'1g_{ Vi}§'1.g z;)ve3:'v¥V:*g§..1,i::'1§ the Cm:11msss:3JZ0:'1er° <'m":£'i:';'1'1<-rd V':.§s3:r1221r:€3~.gag?(§ 5i11:1.f;pSéd ptmaity and §1'1i,€'.1'€§31'i. Aggr"é€ff.2¢:§i 2 <31*c1; e§9. Hithe azssesssee prefcirred em. apptsial Lo 1i:1 L:'? .~'g§Bf§;*>.:':{7£j§.IJLl.§'}21§ held ihaé. the ass€:s:,s:<:*e E."1z1c.i' i'§"1e§=;1'A:" ti.' ~§';Aé3;i:é.'j1jfc% on HDPE ba;{_'{s Ccmiatiilingf {*;a":'fg«z.cV;::A"';-*:'."? __ PRODUCT' were also sxr2'i'1t:€}} I5:)<:;.>2u"lT:[11c21'1T. 'I:I;1aI. 'RA'§\fiCO' is the branci 1§a1:';i:3 :;'§'€?;5sc>:T:. £1: ihe s.sh<>w czéamse 114:>1;.ice issLIfC"(L ii, is rm?/,,iz1c%':2§.i(§1'1€*d wha is»; 1}'1(', on-*1.1cr <>E'1§1e 1.313.115! Imme I-}f+i{:;'_I'}?.l'(i.'.'i"""'."'« "flue. E155S'§£:'$%S€?£:,' a:<}z'"z'i<:>.):1cEs; 't'.h.a.t. 'RAE:/fCQ' 1:33 ifisir xi?'-%'~;'§-"Lt'.512 >vf}?,'}9i-E';€i 1'1g:;,m<-2. 'fh«:?y .<sz,:'%'3mi§, ilmi z~,:pp'1"(}vai for {ha b:*g;3j_:.d §f§a'Z'1f1€;§.~' 'RA.'MC{}' W215; g};fi.ve:2.'3 in ihc },/éféiéf' iE7JEfi%"?°. 'E'%1ey fzaw s;L1':):13%fiA_<E:{i§ 31 mp}; af 1.I':<f: 1'é;:g;is+;'§.m1:i.«:>:'": <':<3.1"1:§'§"i(:ta'i..e. Era'; t.hG;~'se _ Z'§If§3L.Ez;;11fSliaI'i{_§€S. '£.1'T::: '§'ri.§}:.21":;:'1§ heicjé 'a,§1a.i am-7 ;1;:.§;s':;es:s£2<:% (iii? 2'10:
V v§c}§23.E:€ {E19 <%<:2m'§ii.£<>;:1 {Eff :"t:<:}%..ii"1?<,':;i:£'ion :«;m<:.§ a:£:{':<3rdiz1gEy £3 €:":ii:.1<:>.d {S3} 'e.-'\;'§*1<?E.§":é;i*:" '€'I'1f;'.' i.1':'1;d>L1.;j{:;£:{"3 <3'z'::§c:1.' ()5 {Z i?S'E}'¥I' is-3 {..'(.}i'i"é-".("§"' zmgi Ic-%g;{;::i in -1- ihe ':f3€r1efiE' :3? 1'20L§fi<':<ai'£~::i1'1 N{:>._§:I_/ dz-me-:§. 1.--3--2{}O2. £31.' '§.2,1«'x-:'(..>%..i%.1' _. ;"e:s;.> oz": {:1 (wt: w 1': an {:§'e::%1€%r& §:~.-5- é':<I>° z::1iE:?3 u «- . . iv T A *£'1'1r:%116%if§z_"'2::.1'.ic§:':':'f»' V V_ u E4} W}E£?i..11E12' ihr;-2 <.>'1"=':'é'e:1f?"'~13? Ehé:
h01r;.ii:'1 £31 2311. E'.§""if;:V- -E2 :T~£Ti'£'} if * -. 1121 11:6 ' E%1?xMECO"
belongs Kc} _;.f'e}sp<.3jj;'1{iéi'1.i: 1'1c;>£. 2-1:2}-' om) <:p)z'1'ctCE. i1'f;_§_g.i'u-rff ' h' 'V 4: 'I_."h~-:«i,_szJ.ic1 §g{_L,1ess{:i::1V1-sag C?'§1i11"lf)[.'V"i'J€§ gone 1111.0 by this CO'Ll.i"1"{.1fiL§;t3Ej :5&3£Ti.:i:L)'1?_ i%33{3- of i'h.':;.=" Cfe1'1t.1'a.1 E-X(?iSf: Act 1944.5 2155 {ha s21fm€'i;s 15:3 _}:)(: :1.r1j£.1c§§{>:>g1E:{1 by I;1.I1c> Apex Cozjwt: L1::zder Sewtion 351, of Acf4;.,~__ 2;i':.;~i.V S §E.!:':IC§ E33»-' T:i'"ii-Se C0112'! in the Case 0?
-- V. C_0;%.azM1_Ss{om:9i%-V -:.O:E%.'« C'I§f\f"!'I2/ii, ESXCTZSEC vs. MA_NGAL0RI::
' ;R3;;éIA:;;32Lrz;S'M11; m7:;'r;~e«:3c:H.a:;L1'1'CALs L'£'I3., {rm 6,/O?' dispesed '<'~$;f"a}%: E. O. A$§i§3Si'fié"i§j:§'.§E1§ {§L:ti$i§{>n {Ef Eaxaz whi.(.:h is iii;-2;mc?d in éhisa z:a;3§}<::21I, v«.2'c r.
. LE1 Ehzié: vi.<:aA,-* {Hf E.hr;-: £'I'.'§é-l1.{.€1'1 wi£.h<31.1£. d(i<:i£§i:11g §.1'3{: