State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission
Rasikbhai Ambalal Shah vs National Ins Co Ltd. on 19 October, 2022
S[; NFB, TFZLBo !&v)vZ_!# S[; O[;, TFZLBo !)v!_vZ_ZZ S[; lGSF,GF lNJ;M o ) JQF" ! DF; # lNJ;
U|FCS TSZFZ lGJFZ6 SlDXG4 U]HZFT ZFHI4 VDNFJFNP
SM8" G\P #
V5L, G\P !!#$qZ_!$
V[5[,[g8 o Zl;SEF. V\AF,F, XFC4
ZC[P ccS\RGcc4 XF\lTS\]H ;M;FI8L4
S[ZF S[G SJF8"; 5FK/4
D]P TFP HLP VF6\NP
lJZ]wW
ZL:5Mg0g8 o G[XG, .g:IMZg; S\5GL ,LP4
9[P 5|YD DF/4 ;}I"NX"G AL<0L\U4
lSXMZ %,FhF4 :8[XG ZM04
D]P TFP HLP VF6\NP
SMZD o zLP VF.P 0LP 58[,4 gIFILS ;eIP
V[0JMS[8; o V[5[,[g8 TZO[ o lJwJFG JSL, zLP JLP V[DP 5\RM,L
ZL:5Mg0g8 TZO[ o lJwJFG JSL, zLP V[DP H[P X[,T
C]SD ov zLP VF.P 0LP 58[,4 gIFILS ;eI DFZOT[
!P V[5[,[g8 v D]/ OZLIFNLV[ CF,GL V5L, D]/ ;FDFJF/F ;FD[ lJwJFG
VF6\N HL<,F U|FCS TSZFZ lGJFZ6 OMZD[ OZLIFN G\P !&_qZ_!Z TFZLBo !#v&vZ_!# GF ZMH ZN SZTF\4 T[ C]SDYL GFZFH Y. V5L,DF\ H6FJ[, SFZ6M;Z V5L, SZ[, K[P BORICHA APPEAL NO. 1134/2014 Page 1 of 9 ZP CF,GF V[5[,[g8 OZLIFNDF\ D]/ OZLIFNL TYF CF,GF ZL:5Mg0g8 D]/ ;FDFJF/F K[P T[YL lJP OMZD[ NZBF:TGF SFD[ 51FSFZMG[ H[ ZLT[ ;\AMW[, K[ T[ ZLT[ ;Z/TF BFTZ V5L,GF SFD[ 51FSFZMG[ ;\AMWJFDF\ VFJ[, K[P #P V[5[,[g8 v D]/ OZLIFNLGL OZLIFNGL 8\]SDF\ CSLST V[JL K[ S[4 OZLIFNLV[ ;FDFJF/F 5F;[YL V[S D[0LS,[.D VG[ V[S 5;"G, V[S;L0[g8 5M,L;L ,LW[,L4 H[GM 5M,L;L G\P #!_(_#q$(q_)q(5_____&$* K[P H[ D[0LS, .g:IMZg; Z]FP !45_4___qv JtTF SI]DL,[8LJ AMG; Z]FP !!4*5_qv CT\]4 HIFZ[ 5;"G, V[S;L0g8 5M,L;L Z]FP 54__4___qv GL CTL TYF AMG; Z]FP !4#54___qv VG[ SI]DL,[8LJ AMG; Z]FP 5$4___qv CT\]P OZLIFNLGL JW]DF\ V[JL OZLIFN K[ S[4 OZLIFNL TFP !5v(vZ__) GF ZMH VG[ TFP !(vZvZ_!_ GF ZMH 50L HTF\ T[DG[ zLS'Q6 CMl:58,4 SZD;NDF\ NFB, SZJFDF\ VFJ[,P D[0LS, VMOL;Z[ T[DG[ GMG D[0LSM ,LU, S[; TZLS[ 8=L8 SZ[,P VF CSLSTGL OZLIFNLV[ ;FDFJF/FG[ HF6 SZ[, VG[ S[; 5[5;" S,[.D OMD" ;FY[ DMS,JFD\F VFJ[,P OZLIFNLG[ ;FZJFZGM S], BR" Z]FP!4554&!!qv GM YI[,P ;FDFJF/FV[ OZLIFNLGM S,[.D GMG V[S;L0[g8, S[; TZLS[ U6L 5M,L;LGL 8d;" V[g0 Sg0LXG D]HA Z]FP !4554&!!qv GF S,[.DGL ;FD[ Z]FP 5!4_#)qv ;[8, SZ[, VG[ Z]FP !4_$45*Zqv GM S,[.D GFD\H]Z SZ[,P VFYL OZLIFNLV[ ;FDFJF/F 5F;[YL Z]FP #45(45*Zqv !5 8SFGF jIFH ;FY[ D[/JJF T[DH DFGl;S T|F;GF Z]FP Z54___qv VG[ SFG]GL BR"GF Z]FP 54___qv J;], D[/JJF lJwJFG U|FCS OMZD ;D1F OZLIFN NFB, SZ[,P $P ;FDFJF/FG[ GM8L; SF-TF\ ;FDFDFJF/FV[ ,[BLT HJFA ZH] SZL H6FJ[, S[4 5M,L;LGF V[S;S,]hG S,Mh G\P $P!4 $PZ VG[ $P# D]HA H[ JWFZFGL 5M,L;LGF ZL:S SJZ YT\] CMI T[ S,Mh 5|DF6[ YFI VG[ T[YL OZLIFNLGM S,[.D BORICHA APPEAL NO. 1134/2014 Page 2 of 9 D/JF5FT| GYLP JW]DF\ ;FDFJF/FGL V[JL 56 ZH]VFT K[ S[4 OZLIFNLV[ S,[.D OMD"DF\ BM8F HJFA VF5[, K[P OZLIFNL K[<,F\ !_ JQF"YL CF.5Z 8[gXGYL 5L0FTF CTF VG[ VF CSLST OZLIFNLV[ JLDF 5M,L;L ,[TL JBT[ K]5FJ[,L CTLP JW]DF\ ;FDFJF/FGL V[JL 56 ZH]VFT K[ S[4 OZLIFNLG[ S,[.D 5[8[ Z]FP 5!4_#)qv D/JF5FT| CMI4 T[ ZSD R]SJL VF5JFD\F VFJ[, K[ VG[ AFSLGL ZSD R]SJJF5FT| YTL G CMJFG\] ;FDFJF/FV[ H6FJ[, K[ VG[ T[YL T[VMV[ OZLIFNLGL OZLIFN ZN SZJF H6FJ[, K[P 5P lJwJFG U|FCS OMZD[ 51FSFZMG[ ;F\E/LG[ OZLIFNLGL OZLIFN ZN SZJFGM C]SD SZ[,P H[ C]SDYL GFZFH Y. OZLIFNL wJFZF U|FCS ;]Z1FF VlWlGID !)(& GL S,Dv!5 C[9/ VF V5L, NFB, SZJFDF\ VFJ[, K[P &P V[5[,[g8 TZO[ lJwJFG JSL, zLP JLP V[DP 5\RM,LV[ N,L, SZTF\ H6FJ[, K[ S[4 OZLIFNGF 5[ZFv! DF\ H6FjIF D]HAGL H]NL H]NL ;D.gxIM0"GL ;FDFJF/F JLDF S\5GL 5F;[YL V[S D[0LS,[.D TYF V[S 5;"G, V[S;L0[g8 5M,L;L ,LW[,P OZLIFNL TFP !5v(vZ__) VG[ TFP !(vZvZ_!_ GF ZMH 50L UI[, VG[ T[ V\U[GL ;FZJFZ zLS'Q6 CMl:58,4 SZD;NDF\ ,LW[, VG[ tIFZAFN ;FZJFZGF BRF"GM S,[.D GM\WFJ[,MP 5Z\T]4 JLDF S\5GLV[ DFT| 5!4_#)qv Z]FP !4554&!!qv GL ;FD[ VF5[, VG[ AFSLGM S,[.D GFD\H]Z SZ[,P H[YL OZLIFNLV[ Z]FP #45(45*Zqv !5 8SFGF jIFH ;FY[ D[/JJF T[DH DFGl;S T|F;GF Z]FP Z54___qv VG[ SFG]GL BR"GF Z]FP 54___qv ;FDFJF/F 5F;[YL J;], D[/JJF lJwJFG HL<,F OMZD ;D1F OZLIFN NFB, SZ[,4 H[ OZLIFN lJwJFG HL<,F OMZD[ ZN SZTF\4 T[GFYL GFZFH Y.G[ CF,GL V5L,4 V5L,DF\ H6FJ[, SFZ6M;Z SZ[, K[P JW]DF\ OZLIFNL TZO[ V[JL 56 ZH]VFT K[ S[4 JLDF S\5GLV[ OZLIFNLGM S,[.D BORICHA APPEAL NO. 1134/2014 Page 3 of 9 OZLIFNLGL ;FZJFZGF SFU/M HMTF\ OZLIFNLGL 5M,L;LDF\ H6FjIF D]HA VS:DFTYL .HF YI[, G CMI GFD\H]Z SZ[, K[P 5Z\T]4 T[ S,[.D JLDF S\5GLV[ 5M,L;LGL XZTMG\] TN'G BM8\] VY"38G SZLG[ GFD\H]Z SZ[, K[P JW]DF\ OZLIFNL TZO[ V[JL 56 N,L, SZJFD\F VFJ[, K[ S[4 JLDF S\5GL TZO[ H[ S,[.D OMD" VF S[;DF\ ZH] SZ[, K[4 H[ 5[H G\P Z5 p5Z ZH] K[P T[GF 5[ZFv & DF\ 0MP V[DP ALP WM/SLIFV[ :5Q856[ H6FjI\] K[ S[4 OZLIFNLG[ H[ .HFVM YI[, K[4 T[ DFT|G[ DFT| VS:DFTYL YI[, K[ VG[ 5[ZFv*sALf DF\ D[0LS, VMOL;Z[ OZLIFNLG[ ZMUGF SFZ6[ SM. .HF YI[, CMJFG\] H6FJ[, GYLP VFD4 0MP WM/SLIFG\] ;l8"lOS[8 HMTF\ 56 OZLIFNLG[ DFT| VS:DFTG[ SFZ6[ .HF YI[, K[ VG[ HIFZ[ OZLIFNLG[ VS:DFTG[ SFZ6[ .HF YI[, CMI tIFZ[ 5M,L;LGL XZTM D]HA OZLIFNLGM S,[.D JLDF S\5GLV[ D\H]Z SZJM HM.V[P JW]DF\ OZLIFNL TZO[ V[JL 56 N,L, SZJFD\F VFJ[, K[ S[4 JLDF S\5GLV[ H[ ,[BLT HJFA ZH] SZ[, K[4 T[DF\ D[0LS, 5M,L;LGL XZTM ATFJ[, K[P 5Z\T]4 T[ VS:DFTGL 5M,L;LGF S[;DF\ ,FU\] 50L XS[ GCLP JW]DF\ V[JL 56 ZH]VFT K[ S[4 JLDF S\5GLV[ OZLIFNLG[ VS:DFTYL .HF YI[, CMJF KTF\ VS:DFTG\] BM8\] VY"38G SZL OZLIFNLGM S,[.D GFD\H]Z SZ[, K[ VG[ T[ D]HA HL<,F OMZD[ 56 T[ CSLSTG[ IMuI ZLT[ wIFGDF\ ,LW[, GYLP H[YL lJwJFG HL<,F OMZDGM JFNU|:T C]SD V5L,DF\ H6FJ[, SFZ6M;Z ZN SZL V5L, D\H]Z SZJF ZH]VFT SZ[, K[P *P ZL:5Mg0g8 v D]/ ;FDFJF/F JLDF S\5GL TZO[ lJwJFG JSL, zLP V[DP H[P X[,T[ N,L, SZTF\ H6FJ[, K[ S[4 OZLIFNLGM S,[.D Z[%I]0LV[XG ,[8Z D]HA OZLIFNLG[ H[ .HFVM YI[, K[4 T[ .HF HIFZ[ VS:DFTGF SFZ6[ YI[, GYL VG[ T[VMG[ CFI5Z8[gXGG[ SFZ6[ YI[, K[ VG[ CFI5Z8[gXGGL NJF ,[JFG\] OZLIFNLV[ BORICHA APPEAL NO. 1134/2014 Page 4 of 9 K[<,F\ A[ DF;YL A\W SZ[, CMJFYL OZLIFNLG[ .HF YI[, CMJFYL OZLIFNLGM S,[.D GFD\H]Z SZ[, K[P JW]DF\ JLDF S\5GL TZO[ V[JL 56 N,L, SZJFD\F VFJ[, K[ S[4 OZLIFNLV[ K[<,[ H[ S,[.D OMD" EZ[, K[4 T[ S,[.D OMD" 5[H G\P Z5 HMTF\ 0MP WM/SLIFV[ 5[ZF G\P * DF\ :5Q856[ H6FJ[, K[ S[4 OZLIFNLG[ CFI5Z8[gXG VG[ 0FIFAL8L;GL ALDFZL K[ VG[ T[G[ SFZ6[ OZLIFNLG[ SC[JFTL .HFVM YI[,L K[P V[8,[ S[ 0MP WM/SLIFG\] ;l8"lOS[8 HMTF\ OZLIFNLG[ VS:DFTG[ SFZ6[ .HF YI[, CMJFG\] Ol,T YT\] GYLP JW]DF\ JLDF S\5GL TZO[ V[JL 56 N,L, SZJFDF\ VFJ[, K[ S[4 OZLIFNLGF CMl:58,GF 5[5;" 5FG G\p &* TYF &( p5Z :5Q856[ ;FZJFZ SZGFZ 0MS8Z[ H6FJ[, K[ S[4 OZLIFNLG[ CFI5Z 8[gXGGL lADFZL !_ JQF"YL CTL VG[ K[<,F\ A[ DlCGFYL CFI5Z 8[gXGGL NJF ,[JFG\] OZLIFNLV[ A\W SZ[, K[P VFD4 OZLIFNLG[ CFI5Z 8[gXGGL ALDFZL CMJFYL OZLIFNLG[ .HFVM YI[, K[ VG[ T[ .HF VS:DFTYL YI[, CMJFG\]\ SCL XSFI GCLP JW]DF\ V[JL 56 N,L, SZJFDF\ VFJ[, K[ S[4 lJwJFG HL<,F OMZD ;D1F JLDF S\5GL TZO[ 0MP JLZ[G V[RP XFCGL V[OL0[JL8 ZH] SZ[, K[ VG[ T[VMV[ 56 OZLIFNLGF ;FZJFZGF SFU/M HMTF\ :5Q856[ V[JM VlE5|FI VF5[, K[ S[4 OZLIFNLG[ H[ .HFVM YI[, K[ T[ SM. AFCI 5lZA/ S[ CL\;FGF SFZ6[ YI[, GYL VG[ T[ VS:DFTG[ SFZ6[ YI[, U6L XSFI GCL VG[ OZLIFNLG[ DFT|G[ DFT| CFI5Z 8[gXG VG[ CFI5Z 8[gXGGL NJF ,[JFG\] A[ DF;YL A\W SZ[, CMJFGF SFZ6[ .HF YI[, K[ VG[ JLDF S\5GLGF ;NZ D[0LS, VMOL;ZGL V[OL0[JL8G[ OZLIFNLV[ p,8T5F;YL S[ .g8=MU[8ZLYL 50SFZ[, GYLP T[YL 56 OZLIFNLG[ H[ .HFVM YI[, K[ T[ VS:DFTYL YI[, CMJFG\] SCL XSFI GCL VG[ T[YL OZLIFNLGM S,[.D JLDF S\5GLV[ SFIN[;Z VG[ IMuI ZLT[ GSFZ[, K[P JW]DF\ JLDF S\5GL TZO[ N,L,GF ;DY"GDF\ VT|[GF :8[8 SDLXG[ .gNLZFA[G BORICHA APPEAL NO. 1134/2014 Page 5 of 9 DFW]EF. A[0[SZ lJP gI] .lg0IF V[:I]Zg; S\5GL ,LP VG[ ALHF4 I (2006) CPJ 60 TYF GFDNFZ G[XG, SDLXG[ ULTFA[G lJP G[XG, .g:I]Zg; S\5GL ,LP4 IV (2009) CPJ 121 (NC) GF S[;DF\ VF5[, R]SFNF p5Z VFWFZ ZFBL H6FJ[, K[ S[4 lJwJFG HL<,F OMZD[ SFIN[;Z4 IMuI VG[ jIFHAL C]SD SZ[, CMI4 V[5[,[g8GL V5L, ZN SZJL HM.V[P (P VF SFD[ V[5[,[g8 TZO[ lJwJFG JSL, zLP JLP V[DP 5\RM,L TYF ZL:5Mg0g8 TZO[ lJwJFG JSL, zLP V[DP H[P X[,TGL N,L,M4 lJwJFG HL<,F OMZDGM JFNU|:T R]SFNM TYF V5L,GF SFD[ ZH] YI[, 5[5;" wIFGD\F ,[JFDF\ VFJ[, K[P )P OZLIFNLV[ ;FDFJF/F 5F;[YL V[S D[0LS,[.D TYF V[S 5;"G, V[S;L0[g8 5M,L;L ,LWL CMJF V\U[ 51FSFZM JrR[ SM. TSZFZ GYLP OZLIFNL TFP !5v(v_) TYF TFP !_vZvZ_!_ GF ZMH 50L UI[, VG[ T[GL ;FZJFZ zLP S'Q6 CMl:58,4 SZD;NDF\ SZJFDF\ VFJ[, CMJF V\U[ 56 51FSFZM JrR[ SM. TSZFZ GYLP DCtJGL TSZFZ V[JL K[ S[4 OZLIFNLV[ VS:DFTG[ SFZ6[ YI[, .HFGL ;FZJFZ AFATGM S,[.D ;FDFJF/F JLDF S\5GLD\F GM\WFJ[,P T[ S,[.D JLDF S\5GLV[ T[VMGF 5FG G\P #_ p5ZGF TFP ZZv*vZ_!_ 5ZGF 5T|YL OZLIFNLGL ;FZJFZGF SFU/M HMTF\4 H[ .HFVM YI[, K[ T[ VS:DFTYL YI[, G CMI4 T[ SFZ6;Z GFD\H]Z SZ[, CMJFG\] JLDF S\5GLV[ Z[%I]0LV[XG ,[8ZDF\ H6FJ[, K[P JLDF S\5GLG\] VF S'tI SFIN[;Z VG[ IMuI K[ S[ S[Dm T[GM lG6"I ZH] YI[, 5[5;"GF VFWFZ[ SZJFGM ZC[ K[P !_P OZLIFNLV[ JLDF S\5GLDF\ H[ S,[.D GM\WFJ[,M4 T[ 5FG G\P Z5 YL Z) p5Z ZH] SZ[, K[P T[ S,[.DGF 5FG G\P Z5 p5Z 5[ZF 7(i) DF\ VS:DFTG[ SFZ6[ .HF YI[,FG\] H6FJ[, K[P 5Z\T]4 5[ZF G\P *sALf DF\ OZLIFNLG[ CFI5Z 8[gXG VG[ BORICHA APPEAL NO. 1134/2014 Page 6 of 9 0FIFAL8L;GL ALDFZLG[ SFZ6[ SC[JFTL .HFVM YI[,FG\] 0MP WM/SLIFV[ H6FJ[, K[P VFD4 0MP WM/SLIFG\] ;l8"lOS[8 HMTF\ OZLIFNLG[ H[ .HFVM YI[, K[4 T[ DFT| AFCI 5lZA/ S[ VS:DFTG[ SFZ6[ YI[, GYLP 5Z\T]4 CFI5Z 8[gXG VG[ 0FIFAL8L;G[ SFZ6[ YI[, CMJFG\] DFGJF DF8[ 5}ZT\] SFZ6 ZC[ K[P T[H ZLT[ OZLIFNLGF ;FZJFZ V\U[GF CMl:58,GF 5[5;" 5FG G\P &* VG[ &( p5Z D[0LS, VMOL;Z[ :5Q856[ H6FJ[, K[ S[4 OZLIFNLG[ !_ JQF"YL CFI5Z 8[gXGGL ALDFZL K[ VG[ K[<,F\ A[ DF;YL T[VMV[ CFI5Z 8[gXGGL NJF ,[JFG\] A\W SZ[, K[P tIFZAFN 5FG G\P *) YL (! YL JLDF S\5GLGF D[0LS, VMOL;Z 0MP JLZ[G V[RP XFCGL V[OL0[JL8 wIFG[ ,[TF\4 T[VMV[ 56 OZLIFNLGL ;FZJFZGF 5[5;"GM VeIF; SZL V[J\] :5Q856[ H6FJ[, K[ S[4 OZLIFNLG[ H[ .HFVM YI[, K[4 T[ .HFVM SM. VS:DFT S[ AFCI 5lZA/YL YI[, CMJFG\] H6FT\] GYL VG[ ;NZC] D[0LS, VMOL;ZGL V[OL0[JL8G[ OZLIFNLV[ p,8T5F;YL S[ V[g8=MU[8ZLYL 50SFZ[, GYLP T[YL ;NZC] D[0LS, VMOL;ZGL V[OL0[JL8 G DFGJFG\] SM. SFZ6 ZC[T\] GYLP VFD4 OZLIFNLGF ;FZJFZGF 5[5;" TYF S,[.D OMD" HMTF\ OZLIFNLG[ VS:DFT[ .HF YI[, CMJFG\] DFGL XSFI GCLP VFD4 OZLIFNLG[ CFI5Z 8[gXG CMJFG\] VG[ T[GL NJF ,[JFG\] K[<,F\ A[ DF;YL A\W SZ[, CMJFG\]\ :5Q856[ Ol,T YFI K[P !!P JW]DF\ JLDF S\5GL TZO[ VT|[GF :8[8 SDLXG[ .gNLZFA[G DFW]EF. A[0[SZ lJP gI] .lg0IF V[:I]Zg; S\5GL ,LP VG[ ALHF4 I (2006) CPJ 60 GF S[;DF\ VF5[, R]SFNM ZH] SZ[, K[P T[ R]SFNM U]HZGFZG[ 50L HJFYL C[DZ[H YI[, VG[ U]HZGFZG[ AGFJ ;DI[ a,0 5|[XZGL ALDFZL CTLP T[ S[;DF\ VT|[GF :8[8 SDLXG[ U]HZGFZG\] D'tI] VS:DFTG[ SFZ6[ YI[, CMJFG\] DFG[, GYL VG[ OZLIFNLGL OZLIFN ZN SZ[, K[P T[H ZLT[ GFDNFZ G[XG, SDLXG[ ULTFA[G lJP G[XG, BORICHA APPEAL NO. 1134/2014 Page 7 of 9 .g:I]Zg; S\5GL ,LP4 IV (2009) CPJ 121 (NC) GF S[;DF\ 56 U]HZGFZG\] D'tI] VS:DFTG[ SFZ6[ YI[, CMJFGL CSLST 5]ZJFZ YTL G CMI VG[ U]HZGFZG\] D'tI] cc;[Z[A|, C[DZ[Hcc GF SFZ6[ YI[, CMJFG\] GFDNFZ G[XG, SDLXG[ DFG[, VG[ T[ ;\HMUMDF\ OZLIFNLGM S[; GFD\H]Z SZ[, K[P !ZP VFD4 p5ZMST U]HZFT :8[8 SDLXG VG[ GFDNFZ G[XG, SDLXGGF R]SFNF TYF OZLIFNLGL ;FZJFZGF SFU/M wIFG[ ,[TF\ OZLIFNLG[ H[ .HFVM YI[, K[ T[ VS:DFTG[ SFZ6[ YI[, .HF DFGL XSFI GCLP T[YL JLDF S\5GLV[ OZLIFNLGM S,[.D Z[%I]0LV[8 SZ[, K[P T[ SFIN[;Z4 IMuI VG[ jIFHAL VG[ 5M,L;LGL XZTMG[ VFWFZ[ SZ[, K[ VG[ T[ TDFD CSLST wIFG[ ,. lJwJFG HL<,F OMZD[ 56 T[VMGF R]SFNFGF 5[ZF G\P ) VG[ !_ DF\ T[ V\U[GF lJUTJFZ TFZ6M VF5[,F K[4 T[ SFIN[;Z4 IMuI VG[ jIFHAL CMI4 lJwJFG HL<,F OMZDGF R]SFNFDF\ 56 C:T1F[5 SZJM HZ]ZL G CMI4 V[5[,[g8GL V5L, ZN YJF5FT| CMI4 V[5[,[g8GL V5L, ;AA GLR[ D]HAGM C]SD VFBZL C]SD SZJFD\F VFJ[ K[P C]SD s!f V[5[,[g8GL V5L, GFD\H]Z SZJFDF\ VFJ[ K[P sZf VF6\N HL<,F U|FCS TSZFZ lGJFZ6 OMZD[ OZLIFN G\P !&_qZ_!Z DF\ TFZLBo !#v&vZ_!# GF ZMH SZJFDF\ VFJ[, C]SD IYFJT ZFBJFDF\ VFJ[ K[P s#f V5L,GF BR" V\U[ SM. C]SD SZJFD\F VFJTM GYLP BORICHA APPEAL NO. 1134/2014 Page 8 of 9 s$f ZHL:8=LG[ V[JL 56 ;}RGF VF5JFD\F VFJ[ K[ S[4 lJwJFG VF6\N HL<,F OMZDG[ VF C]SDGL GS, 5LP 0LP V[OP OMD"[8DF\ .vD[.,YL HZ]ZL SFI"JFCL SZJF DF8[ DMS,L VF5XMP VF R]SFNFGL GS, 51FSFZMG[ lJGF D]<I[ DMS,L VF5JLP VFH ZMH TFP !)q!_qZ_ZZGF ZMH R]SFNM B]<,L VNF,TDF\ HFC[Z SIM"P sVF.P 0LP 58[,f gIFILS ;eI BORICHA APPEAL NO. 1134/2014 Page 9 of 9