Jharkhand High Court
Be vs The State Of Jharkhand on 1 March, 2021
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI (Criminal Appellate Jurisdiction) Criminal Appeal (DB) No.1067 of 2012 With Criminal Appeal (DB) No. 1189 of 2005 and the ard pans 5 pow Bs fee fee god ot a oe rt oot * if Be son of Sa la erat "Ansari resides nt of Village-Sundry, POW Kuru, PSLohat rdaga, Dist. Lohardags . Appellant Versus The State of Jharkhand .. Respondent AND in Criminal Appeal (DB) No. 1189 of 2005: Mobin Braki, son or Late Najmul Noda, resident of village-Balsokra, P.S.-Chanho, Dietrict-Ranchi, . Appellant Versus The State of Jharkhand . Respondent Serhan -- REY gebayryaokeye, TES * Pehy LEP, tt HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SHREE CHANDRASHERHAR HON BLE MR. JUSTICE RATNAKER BHENGRA For the Appellantis}) o< Mr. A. Rh. Kashyap, Sr, Advocate fin Criminal Appeal (OB} No. 166% of 20 igi Mr. Jai Shankar Tripathi, Advocate fin Crinsinal Appeal (DB) No, 1189 of 2005} For the State ; Mr. Mane) Kumar Mishra, APP fix both cases} JUDGMENT
CAA on 25/02 £203} Pronounced one 3 fas a0 3 Y oxy "yy AF ye x ~ x Per, Shree Chancdrashekhar, Lohtardaga PS. Case No. 7] ef TGS was registered . . " wt ; 5 ey" EQ Pots ' ef RS fo thie freosfisor Deast Cartes urider. sections 363, S64, 448 and G8' of the indian Penal Codes against sever unknowri criminals. Narayan Oraon who was ome :
or the victims gave a written repart or 15.07. 1998 to the officer<in-
i me "oat dF " stoht af TYR TG08 «>ver charge, Lahardaga PS, that in the midnight af 12.07 19S seven a z ae 5 mS 2 a oo yi, ees , 4 SB. 4 foes tee! we rapes 5% toe vod oad shred ae "at oa a aos oa es .
ee " # 4 So vee hs ve Pn S yo oe aE fe a5 a3 gre we # ws AS, es oe ws a2 vs oo "3 by a oa geben ree we 2 Sat th ~ on "ed Sed o 3 u on fet be TSE hp neues ae gn oe hie TS Boo OR "g a OY ge = ae i ne Se oe ae the op yes is a sy Re fend ped eh phen ve sh ee em > z "eet, cee) oe ve aA ed meet we aad yee ge wee eB roe on nod 2 yen Tae rors oe nett , a eteee ° Be Se 43 pee es see: a fey WS5 ft. " aa shock rh wD zk ca ; r 'on Sod 'bed Soh ot re, aA he we pen one nape mo os "he 03 "ae as nes car Gt ms " mn ret Sed ae a wm ta rea mn Sed oe os pe hy ae "et Cg an ot ad = = c oS ven et Ly tat goes. deet it Sane 2 oa, os fr aot "Mor % g gg "bed Sones 5 . wt rt cr fam a lad asl 'eed si ye B me fp ne BS : wt bot ve Fae th 6 ies LS Fe:
2 2 gk te ie Bo. UR CR rs peg est ae ae " s S Bae " aA orn wt x mt " ok FE Ca od we se wat ' 3 Mee ee xy <4 My wo ed aaa _ a ie ode nee tae io nm, yet "i a " 4 Fa : ; £ oe ; : back on 4 / % a s 7 got the 4 ot nm aS Ewe iy . " 'oat +7 peted & 2 "4 hy, whe , 'ee, f gS pink i! re we tad . pod ot e & 'ed Ur art : can if ws ne L tot id a rm oy Ose £3 bey pei BOG as Shad 'mh al "s " os Be uF 4 Bs rye ht Meo es es = aS ore co aa os SG G se os oma rx Be ops tek fn a coud. ye a 23 veyed 4 od oO wv, "rs be be 3 Ld i ae tw nd ve ret ee Ge ort bed os Sines we ne my rt fy wes ie, i re Sd a nad wa fobs C3 "ot a a " wh ree * oN Se me oS Se weet oe aiid 7 reas wast ed ae ad Pes aed fs : . ® fet a reert 34 ed ns rw Sone we mS 'eee ay yee a3 os were pes et ar "a Paes tat Lard a hae "af oa ~ en OG s ww pa eA oy vat 7 ees ce i Fas ' nn oy Ee Cy Me : feb) :
a Sune 2 g Ms eae yee ned yom z ~~ uA armen os ey we oad cpg, eget ne So ~ eee ng z , ork bee, awed me ne 6 ae . t ee ge he oot Pet Bn ne tg 5 ny on ben ft, ' oot a 4g he ue oy: os +9 we Z a z vod ne By ta : i. Sa z nae? ee eh ~ Z Sine Lt oF wt wy rors rr 'od tae' oo a5 ew : 4 5 eos k - as ¥ i; 'i? 4 rm '5 rere z ae 4 * he ot ae of. * et : Bee 3 0% ps tS pen G ae LA Snel ws se: % he S re "Ty eee rt ve vee a > '3 " oe ad : 4 vA poe a See oon Tees * wines oS & om A CB f me fp eS os cong RS bo oo BOS woe ee Si te "on & tad & Oo 3 "R th ee hes wet ree get od od Ls i ae FY a on , oe we fe we me ne By Es rs a3 +e a ge LA ' oh Oe boos Go Tn sad oA ; fh, 35 as re ee " oe pon hes ae nm ; oe 2 aad teed, id ret a owed x ne Ay oo ns Fi not. "hed = piers rs we bre wa . it ea ~ pod a "0 ae G . we ps Re Gk phen as AS ae ee es we bea oe coe oes = tt rf, arnes ot a> "tet tnd rane, ot ae tee th Ay gt 'aat ° ae ood: . oh Ln ret Ze, ye Noe vers La ee ; Ss cont % ns z Teg rth ; ae ed £3 5 a NS ra we o the res Lad aA ot rt Om 5 ot wot Sh, be feet oe ~ ied 'ast ' he we pant vo t 'at ay me ; we ges be at : mY a 4 ' is =~ pt : a 'ane thy Oe shod we inn, cee AY wa sae ae ot % rorce ood at ed Frnt, cee art 4 a i af. 7" " be, fr yes aA, } Jovi oe eA et NF " Pa A ms oS ay mo " a we oe Fae oe ow Bb a & we & re a RGB Be SB 2 BP © 2a 2 a . as . ' Cc o be . : fe a b J : , ws weeeen, ot en Bad ae y ey r tet nt teed ret Be om "boat Nim pee , " gt ge a So ry, go a4 wn wt van beg oS me Su Net 4 bet ft bet a vend pep. pera + r ero weet toh sons vor ook res, Sad % a, 4 o tenet wea on Nod? Zit ind "oe bee 4 cheat ' one ~ ns os Seanmnl
a) sok CAP "* "ae? Sot Se Lt, ar, on oe op a . ot fon it * ge 'ne? LD. ~ a : a as re ' "dt wee z P / pots oy ae ra} oes we wes tect Faw vores, ay wy he oon ; ees wn ss 5 Manny pe wed ee , teat: Yh bh Ow ars mr wy Set } a a ey '] ons, eed aboot tft -F 3 ae AY yea, pe 'hee ns "y wD . % x ma ped te ga = a we te peed Bae C boo wy or wa oom ert we ge OS Seb E e's " vars pe at ae Fate) ' eens, g . re ws ys g on wt = feel << z "ph : v4 5 : wet sot tw eee On rie we oe 5 wt a ea peers weed ae 4 sy mf wy HB 2 G&G a SS oy FO me BS me SS ad ae £3 te : ' Ch, ' ' : : "hee ' . "
ey he ge ct ra ty ay ook oe + re ty a t pe YES "A ir oO oS 'eens os - i, reed shod a we ve pea oy ipa porn wt ¢ Cot ' fet $ robe cael fat we ¥. py he et * " me "yet toa i inte oo , ap wy A me a baw Gad oa Fa , G3 "lt on gt teed me xfs eeoed, wa nade q Pea ee oma Ls et Be oO Send ¢ 3h eed % f co ae :
a4 we wi Senet od ned net ot reen 2%. hg ' +h a wee ot 4 Ce ves ot ped we 43 ngewe, a3 i new grt we 4 z nod &S ee ~s St on a See oe "send 'A ve , nH a) pa seo ° ny a ot "ee? al CS oe a ' 6a, ee we - he "3 ~ 4 Ay rm se fod Ket i ~o pred "ry See d ' wi Sip pod oe has int . vhs f ant? re . pe Lines epee ' es fm ch Wh ap whe - ry en tos *s ag ea ih get ot ot ge es ted to tf tg iy 4 awe vo ws ene? a ae he nS m hoy ws oA . a ' oe fe ret By sod Saal fey % pet teat ret ay A ae rh me bg ia vet yes Qt oS z es se a a"
rat wey we bee ' er ve, ae went apt roped, Lae 57 os aN LA om nee yes ae ay gry id veers 2 nn bes ~ ws aA ont 'of set a +4 uP? ge son wa a os a eed poe bat oes gen + pent ret ge t ye ira ws Sead a4 whet 2 Xe pores Me ges ae: th 7 ae rheat weed ae fees ps Pea ors i, OS on wt hy 5 anne he oi 43 at poh ead ca *E3 nm hos wa Rapes SA + 3 yo ore oe my oy oo ee ios ot woo, ME om me a ae bon oe a % me % po Cue ae a " a td a oe Pe, ren ret ne 0% A ges CA abe 3. Ks a Ae * abt * < Se et tated ~~ ped es we : 4 bes a ' a rr as 'het ns " seg ™ a aa ro a ome es on wd teed ak whet Oy bee ra pt bs " nA habe beet gt ye opt a ee ha eet At Sere tee, ct pet as phe ope, Iapnad wen a Rs is te "aera os £3 het os peg a en ry he Fae oe bs ood Rr . 4 4 or id < , 3 } : ! 4 aa : . .
a ee wo fe ™ ie ' ee "eg Oe a 2 ~" & a nn ae tt an Se hoe ra! Fapen Mt Saipeet: 1 re 4 4 aS Sy A LP ny ob eat . . tN va : i Oe ~ BB 6 be Ee we 4. "tty ie ce 'ee 5, Rb ton ey Me ree ee a aoe os we ' £55, yw we pes ¥ 84 loons, eet riers " ek ' "- of yoest. pss ob ae % os ngt os pets ree oe gc Fo ms oe a "S va EE Gee my Ct a deed ' bot a Sinee ty he oot = Sh at f he a = SS we we we a . 4 tea on, m4 oe a Oo oe aot Pa th oes o om pa wee vont ya 7 as ~ be 3 a gs lon, na yo : . = a ed ost i ae 4 ae porn pee Sh ee goes ' : re SB Boe BOR i =O py ¢ de gp VA gg Be oc Bow £ SB ot no areas ben re" 5 Lp a phig core toot seed j Sha ty nr wed ed z, Sent * as SE £3 ES ad ~ net week Sw « LY x, ' 'ch Lf, ened, deed hey 4, ted ont ep hed ot 'nf ret a ; crt os er. vent ' "nat aed xg hy bade et aly geek bet ped vee fs n ' ws ws peed Sw seork os os % id Soot to qe Fapers > ee C pe nt , gS Nees ene ' : 4 'ee! a ig Y Son raped Ba ; : : 5 4 pm we bon tp a of tes yet $0 * we bs ye od ped 5 ef? ae et wok ~ m% rem Seek 7 ors z is a3 yes : 2 2 i soot : 7 fet M5 tae bok Maat sree my i fo Bg me Bo "G Ee nc a re £3 wa Bm CE 5 ' ZS ge '4 e g ae i es os , teh wed el mG a The Oo oo ies nA 43 eee a3 ae get spot mt baal et fy ree wie 4 'in ged x oes tree es wt 'het i cy Sah a wed poe San 's re ran tad ws ott tA nn, oe Meet aoe Yad te ried yok noth 43 ~ Neb ees " - vet peek «eee cb Sane gas oy os ved yr iS %, oct 0G fy a ee oe en hep bes Bares fee C4 ee yn poe a i oo gh i" ne "a a 3 ees . " wooed me 7 ot . ' 7 ~ Sobek L3 ms , vn on ee i vet a Ze iE Ge yon ed poeet foot pone ths eae * og wor wee vo yeee ret, Ls eves, ny a" oS ate Sone . %, : os "7 SD OM 6 BB a Urhrbral Appssh Ne. LG) of BSUS Wish WNEss WAS eNatrined on 2O.09. 2002, Islam Ansari did not aprear DAM pee s * BY at os . lee thie Rall Banca tov ks ceed im thie trial and oan tiwwo successive defaults the bai-boneds furnished by Him were cancelled wide order dated 26.07 2002.
bseent far rare than i%) years and then wide order dated SE RON A Bie tetat rac 2O.08, 2008 his trial was 8} elif up. in Sesstons Trial No. LS88, Mobin Eraki was found guilty and and Ne was cormvicted and semtericed to RU. for 1Q vears under section 488 IPC, Ri. for 8 section SS IPQ and R.I. for fe under section a. Jsiar Ansari was arrested or 30. 1¢ up record was re-rugurbered as ST. Case No. YS?
Procedure and offered opportunity te lead ewiderice which he dit me ee vide qu Sigment dated 21.08.2012 he was also under sections 458, G87 and S64 of the Indian Penai Code and awarded similar sentences as suffered by Mobin Eraki. 4, Criminal Appeal (OB) No. LiS@ of BC Eraki was admitted for hearing vide order dater his prayer for suspension of sentence was accepted on 1.0% by a co-ordinate Bench of this Court. Thereafter the ~~ eal remained pending for about S years and the lower Court records were sent back for the trial agaimat Islam Ansari, These two Ne my a ate seheeeh meeyeyerss Fea: $ rye eH PED Seeley LEY } ue PRAT appeals which are fa ed against separate judgments written by wo + ssions Judges could have been heard separately but we $ red suegestion of the learned counsels for both the these criminal appeals together, primary tor the POS SCUTINT, WITNESSES WEPE ENAMMCG i Et oresence of bath the appellants together and identical WeAS are ureed before us on behalf of both of them -- thease Appes were listerl together in the last two dates. Both the % a ' . yh ey Sessions Judges have accepted the testimony al f father and brotnes ~ 2 a tin nt RY of » IEEE af Shiv Charan Qraon and held that a part of the evice hostile witnesses who were the family members oF Omi GaN : ; 3 it oda ney oh ee ets geese ee are rye firapn ig corroborated by other independent evidences Ana Ure OP REO 58, SSP art prosecution has proved the charges under 8c stioms GS8, S6F a 8s of the indian Penal Codie.
4 Urhuinal Apors! (AR Re, LST of BDES Wah, Rejasingd Appeal (OH) Be, VISE of SUNS tt . The appellants with whom the prosecutlan witriceses claimed previous acquaintances were not mamed mm the First Information Report and mo Test Identification Parade conducted to find out their involvement in the occurrence, In these facts, Mr. A. K. Kashyap, the learned Senior counsel who appeared for Islam Ansari has therefore contended that the prosecution witnesses merely making an allegation In the Court agaimst the xocused is mot epfficient to hold that, 'yes', the accused were involved in abduction of Shiv Charan Oraon. &. There was never any doubt om identity of the accused whe head abducted Shiv Charan Oraon from his house in the might of 13.07.1998. PW2, the informant has stated im the Court that the accused threatened him and due to fear that Shiv Charan Oraon might.be killed by the abductors he did not disclose name of the accused in the written report. The informant and his father both have specifically named Mobin Eraki and Islam Amsari and other accused in their statements under section 161 of the Code of Criminal procedure which were recorded on 18.07.1998. In the written report also there was sufficient informations to the police an the identity of the accused and within two days Islam Ansari was apprehended by the police. In course of the Investig identity of the accused was net in doubt, non-bailable warrants were issued and processes under sections 82/83 of the Code Criminal Procedure were taken out against them. PW ana PWe have stated in the cress-examination that they had previous acquaintances with the accused, and they have indicated the place of residence @illage! of the accused which was not challenged by the appellants in the trial. The informant has given description of two accuscd persons in the written report * and stated that ome of the accused who was short and aged about 20-25 years was ~ carrying gun and another accused who was tall and da eormplenioned had a burn mark on his neck below the ear. in U yritten report involvement of seven unknown criminals Was indicated and on the same day name of the accused was disclo sed hy the witnesses before the police. We find that in the afaresaid 8 circumstances explanation of the informant that out ol fear Re oat Criminal Appeal UM Na. LOO of BOT SHEER Lotminat A pgeat (O88) We. FLSY of BAGS not mention name of the accused in the written report was truthfal Sy " et Sh PEON te § San vy mo eet : 438 Hye se A PY EN: } e Py } ard yy CNY cs mye CAL SES ECR Pa. Met Re appel AESTILS WERE RYE ows £Q tt te Ow itine SSEN ext eck therefore, there was no need to cond cf a Test [dentivicatior Parade, though the appellants were met named in the Firs tsaios > gh " ¢ § of AY ¥ ae ees Mae ay PP gee uMormation Report. In "Nori Nath and Ckhers »v otate of 18 Hotble Supreme Court has held that absence of corroboration hy C assume materiality sarlier or where the rm the mind and pee the iden hey msriory of the witness are otherwise brought out. Above all, when PW and PW2 were examined in the Court the appellariis remal absent and in this regard we And a specifi deposition « the learned trial Judge has writter MB Set Ba herefore, the intrinsic value of the evidence of PW and PWS would not diminish because acrording to eines Seieatliawta oe 8 ase el oe rate ies Ys ex ere ine appeuants for the first Nme in the Court these witnesses have oo heoee a e bee ar eet cast ae The rt ae) om entity them, and as would appear from the evidence of PWT and PW the plea raised by the appellants is factually incorrect ~ the appells arts $ were known to them.
¥, PW and PW are star wits esses for the prosecution.
' PWT is the father and PWS is the brother of muy Charan and they have deposed in the Court that in the night of 13.07.1998 when they were sleeping in the house seven unknown criminals stormed into their house and asked them to hand over guns fvh the Tamuly was possessing} and in Heu thereof Cn thelr expressing helpleasness to pay such huge sum they asked them te Uring rupees sinty thousand at Chapi Hatt Bazar. They caught Nar: ayan Oraon and EAA See . . Seyrake Pike epezreyyy oye vy ghee eereyee shiy Charan Oraon toak therm away and on the way they apprehended Narayan Bhagat also who was trytrig to raise z 3 Tis Naas RR say se Pes es Lay owen fa bay og wee RT eye Se fuga. Near Banjar Kiske river, they let off Narayan Oracn and " seg et Tessa e gran Oraor and kent an Bhagat but did not release Shiv © ody for ransorn, Next day, Narayan Oracn paid vv % N iy £4 » Dy epee es tty Sys rapess five thenisand to the accused at (he au Hatt Basar yet Shiv i Oreorn was not released by the abductors.
oe ee s stew Be wen re if v on f woh a Ss oe hh bee ee ¢ "aid we " vft :
1a mS wee nm _ ewer init we tif wbret weeed ne _ gn pont ae os os an cet weve poo ae rg Le * et ee ies a wt oe a ' ne sehen yo Ce teh = ee a ety ees % % " Se a we rd vdped ches feat wo ve fet cant oe wee ad we ents a . bs 4 oS * ~-- Z seer gent bet pet wes ee Sat es ee ves te FE oe wee Fie deg ER weet erg oer we fs he ben Sol Sm 2 we pas ' ¢* ~ ae co t 2 aad "pee & We ee a o& @ & DUO we feoee wt te % me a ae eb ping om -- ve ore to a he me jue ™ om ihe eg : poet os Ee we q wf yon ; hp "a! eee Nat " oe chek ar act a i if, «oo 4 sn Sat ee eect . re os te shoe 2% ~~ oh . xy ta ae pee S Ae ged pee. a ne eet ie . Set wee ne oy on ' oa) t re 2 wes ZEe me) me a . ae t a vier 23 oo bee 3 a3 is is bh Ra We pa rt os - ae ae wn Cos eee bn oo oS on, cs he ; « ee & 4 pened r be "be be fh Sh ny iv "Heed, a a, nyre, - yok ; MY wee ." aa "a et EE ye oi th Sat fh ra c, oy th, Ge son rene agen ue a ba we te S a . a3 a3 As st ot me te i = "e oA Se? 42 ees pets pect : " ei ve Be font 43 w hog, et eg = we . ad ho t mt som pees 7 apeh oe vee 4 bens we oP J : Nee segrg ace on, ih ~~ ree aed 'S * wee £2, he : oo nt reed mm es Le c red "pad a he adew a Oe 4 Et BD 'eet at ae he as "a3 es ee x ; Snel "he. wos Ary * : : rae wpe * "ee ay : a7 : ' % a rr af wh --s wk re @ ane) Ry ret reg % 4 As eek "E4 ay "3 ae 'os the os ty ge + ot, 2 & ot totes ag oy we ve, edeos Sine . ve 'he, Aeod mt me phew qo : pod a Sat a yon ety" oe 00s wees, 3 a # od 2%, a ~, wet we 'gg a cit i oe a i . edt ify we A La aa oh * oeeed os 4 A a3 td we : wa a ws 3 ee *, "s 3 det "at oheed ' Ne wees . . Pepe Sa ' ' :
g OF fa fas ie he io a ey os a ot hee a es Fast mR m0 UU ms be. 2 " 'et po BOB -- hes veh é went re, ce ay ed te Coe At eG ay we fant me oo ms Lo ay Bh me fas on fos be 3 g 4 eB ry os ae oo a 24 : ma he z me A re perk foe o.. mt, oe ht Os ws ini teri 4 g & o 8 D2 Voo& ee fin RR Eg we EY re ye oy tee sg at o es x i yo : ai ae ony > LA ws : ay wt é ee " rt "6 Peal tri, fy * £4 Qf Ke ee ", at ne an L an " Se et ape ed hh eek Bo ome ae @ nt im 6 CSS toed s a" ol Ma oe re " as tod Si <s fo et we kn " ue pe abt a et EO ee hawt I ge a oe mm AY G a oS i OG hed: * ry stork ok £ ¥ a4 ree atone es ~ cA phon fee oa a oe ed we Pa thd a ne : wire' oe , ae eee, 'ag! af ts fe he i teh Aneel Pe nd 'head as ~~ fs ee '. be peers wen son ' ga C3 seed ° weed 4 4 rh 'es sy Po wh ad Gy fos on - gf &, a on wef es a, da ct Saal Leas ere, eae whe wo$% , . eS ' A s . , "ae , . ", . :
ae, rm ya oe es th onan! won ae wet 'eas a4 te hed et oo ; wy, eh a om C5 ea oy eo tan ed foot wh ee Shoe on Z peoee os ry ane ard we, ot Sast : ZL ~ ; - aS "at ni "ot ¢ sped ay P oched, iy pn os aye fea wo os ; bow weed hoe cet see a - * on fee mt "" 5 ga rad haeet %; om et "goed a we vt 'Eo wa % wen eet oS fs By cat et mm ad oe et 4 on ba bond ae im we % ven pe bes, os , Moet = ve ee vot Fee ares bet ee tek napng hes "ea yy evil pod Bea ae 1A " a pe OUD rs het hog es ; gr rc Na Lang weed os he "nd Ake ae » gee " Ww pa Soft " yen: eee hs a dnd Ae Se ee ve heb ha snes A' * . 4 ny ge Ba ft we "74 we as Fed bee: Soe an, , ye ed a aged : he re S we we de peor, Pees ory weres F BA "5 bs 'eet as pe oe a a on Toe hea Ye aa Lat eet re a aes wen teat ry oc t&% 2 tf e © eS a 7 ee a: BC De eo ve yee wt oP me * et pot aa : 4 ne 4 pan ren oie rd es eC, in, ws LES ot 'net ee need reew one bet we cea) Pe wi a ! a sos hs a a wea 8 apo = ee i ' oe uA a , a gS eons i ee) oi ett Se Se fuk ' aS ood *, Sat x os aa * Mat no a a4 wy sted ad Pad ee ge a Z ae . % "ee oo wn ny a ot ~ ad ~ fete oo oo os x ted: ee ct ral 43 appa a Ne a eed ed tt a "e4 wy + ts °y o ie ; pak . : x oft a, a ws ty, : % aad : . ' " bod "% : te "s ¢ x tot ac 8 i i ge eo ~ 2 & fg tv kw E Sob gg Ph 6 BS gt we Rg gt eters G ad ft ~ sow teat ' toe os « ey pa pas Pe i ry nae rs a parse 7 hed fas " . oe nA . Gs peed ds mm, sh oom Eom & - 5 on & 6 2 Le OO fed mB on Bon B® QO OG it Mt A ED ey Pm as OY re ype oo ot om OO weed eae a a pa "y pet hs c hed, alent ne Ye ae ze ' wt "nen bet 5 on, "eat > 'ae y 4 'net ms "3 oot "he geet os 2 og 2 2 OM @ ma So wm Se OB eo F © 2 - E 2 es
-- ot ~ be * 3 4 a ' 18% a pet rt pee ae ns £0 " fees Ls or wok Cae 4 "at wed Cs fb hep, at ms bo lek "a bs oo OM ae se . ee iS ey gO we a " wt soot fad aR ahes 1 gy Ee 4 me vee os fet Ge tee " ye a wah, . 4 pede Sens ad f in 'ae o head. Te eee a, hk wars we "4 ark. oe Ces he a, Sere wy te vert pen wm oes wt nat am oe tt gra oO ew aA mae hy we ws G3 oe OD ee on na Yes as a one he 7 or oi' re 4 on et york, ot ae wee re ot oe we ° wis eae pp. yee eg Le a fo x, ad yor spewed: Loe tages z on 3 gt y % rs inet 3 ae pare beets of oe ae] seed, * os pore z Saat s pee Sag. oe Be web we, te aa " ws oes Re Ning , Soe ry i. © "a cae OT jen , : ated Spot me wren LY yl es Bana ro "y o 7% aS we OS sores oS a : Th "CS a es w ob or ges ea pone a at * xe oo ee 14 Z on ek 6S oft Wig . Aw "
a7 ts Line xs a a os A oS hee ap nos n% ee" ne! go tsp Re ot we %) cae tt pos _, tS ue "at me on net 4 be Ss ee gh ny et , fs, voor bd ~ Be hes a ~ > re i + ms m $e wegen, fot a whecd : inks ~~ eS ie este Mw a ed ce tS ~ a ws we ' a3 we Se tend Po "Sood 4 ty get a Nene x = 4 wy . on Laaxb view ms pet a ew we ah oe ae me mf a oa) ag me mM 3 ww wy ea an ye, oc, me RG io as nd ve f a weed ' 2 3 a toh a r, eer = 3 : ; a red Ne "4 ' rt 3 BS As, So oo Sg Goan a a moO Oe pm "ye tk ke a The
4 ~ f mm ry Ms % ¢ é . ; : i * tipo: ' db * f ' ie Ea oh eS Be m 3 ret oy. os we OP OE ae org hee "a & Bm ¥ 3B me me mt o 2 # eB e & S tien a oS hos. poet tft we a hes at we i et : os BS, oot oped oo tos Sie peal hog we oe a "hee he om Sood 'hg B 2 nad at P% ad ao "pe, g 12 "et Kok ped Ay ret ae S rm, ret Yee? ty ae we, :
wh wy - won Spe Bod ge LA ae os ty, eters ie Nt me a as ares w& ted rm, hed dt be red . Gis rm 3 ms ch a ol oh 4 as * te obo ~™ dest ww Cc % rn " nee be Sp fa ved" a3 'hd eh feet ae ne es " ae - rs Fa wp es won yo es me ws ae et ens oat uA 4500S --t tA Ne » me Lo cm te ~ ard et beg ad tt we pie, ys bee es wah ye ts ree we : "sit et on amet noe ve fat oes (06) Re vet sat red : ea a " neh ges ° "yer "get hod cad ae $ " wa -- ee gt ge a "wot oe boo we tock be ay es foot: i ea F a yet bes bere me 43 rm ; fy ~ 'nat 2 BA a; Be at a3 £3 aed he Mae hook PA OF - ag re bod ° mt we tres bed oped aoe A to > wi ot re 'as ae ~ ER 4 rt * AR mes, y ms Ta rest mre oe ae lad xe . perk ~. tori Cron wh wh a rot wn os Lp veg ok f yhnd hh Py: mt ad re, '3 ont C3 py ot 4 ween, a3 es gl het ry 7 as ey ty whe ete pa . * 'i Ary. porai: Good 'eed oe "peed RP A cont 3 fei al C3 ™ we e eb a ped o et ee ce a - x et veg coo fed tee weg Be OR 5 oa fs f ' 'ini ry _ fn oO" mB 4 4 tees "e 3 heed! ook ae at rh "eet &3 Be "ded a poh bedbiet vA * a3 veal $3. ay Saneot ne o. pani 3 es 5 ms ws ' tad Boot aga is , oe "a heel i , Le wt a4 woh Raed ot a) me oS 2 st fo 4 bee aw v9 gee deed: ~~ 'nat ThA ae ee ad ya te 4 > gt "vaewd 5 we C3 ' Bs on tn Pd oe o% ab ome of inne ot does a ws Oo uA bee: re 3 Co OG & rw wi IR Be ogy tet oO wt Bg LT nr an hens . "us Be wt ed (ES a3 wv Spat i ing Soe a: AG ed na 'aa hed os 4 ay be oon a) 3 » 6 BE ee ee ® OD a % o£ og Me 2 © & i gs Y 5 oe "boob "3 ' Seen we me Se yt ae nae z. font lone nee hp ww er ye "
ah * et ns wer agen : eeet 5 a ae Doves, oot re ad pote ae gt ae wh yee Soe, tae 5 Sab " ens hee pee 4 beh f" wb © re ag Poa " tA beat oe wt bs ae - eek fon oe "dev? Le Sad my yee Gee sgh wee oo ; Ay pol * " at te an ot a ' wee ore wee ot he we shee' 45 v4 he ae oe $75 ¢ 4 "4 aS ry sored wget ty ooh 63 43 re oh hy bes fed Ges ed ts Sa Lo a a) Uf w Co Bow o oS me , oe i m= © & FE Be 2 #2 ee eos mop ; vs < F 2 & oa | ee 1 8 A ween te pe reat we KS ew he 3 bes oo a eget vd a gt ween a 'he ve (kd Be 1 , "* et hed "h, on £4 reed, 7 Ly foot Net eid a geet bo £4 L. at oS "4 tat ; a ro to CF on oh a3 oe : 4 "oo on "deed et D bok , aod . "4 i leet ifs oe " "i fant ye pan eo '3 . a a Be yy one f heat. at fe mn, " > nye "har fee of s t bit, Ee abd of 8 8 4 Eo Be Bom | wed A aa neh £% qehen, aie feet Le cy ; 'spt saved GF fevee rh ee :
a haf ' Z yea 2 rng < fDi No. PQS? af on Sat PM fobs, > 3 the i x r 4 1 WH plausible uri was we id Xe 2Y offs the ¢ e arnt in sheet:
rae "ne, on fos mm inige ¢ suforma tfen Pee 1Q, ¥v ny yy be ee * ns seed Ge Ae PASE a in Facts of 2 gase should:
Ae ee i sand On PE & gd7 oth ott see a NOU & pete 3 mn soe fe ALS KS ens te yy know © hy Ak KR eh Cerurt the Le ae wens wey Be oe eteing, thf oo Leper + es 7 Ly gen 4 Ls Sanne ley e is ad rier mt ot a iA . os ae fos vm ied wend fae pe is "eS pee Sead ye 4 ort cee fs pheod, od es 'in * . ay
5 a wet oe tf wed a he Sent ee *, w we an am a cone ed ee ae Fog, Me shee sled 4. ee set woe hy ve "5 ves oo G3 cess 7 ; ny nee * i", bed At Z oy . y a wa "nat %, _ oe fof ra ' oe Go hae nnd 3 has eye feet 4 4 mtn oad ead he Pe] cree LG peed ~t ¢ ry a, "eg Set ae fy ens ay Hines, Moy hong By . Ses Se : be, & howd * ea pana a he yes yet a, a oD oy roy he "ey on © tees x ree Ly a ' "ange oe enh uy os Sea ee Nat Zee od is os wa hd 4 a gt wd, ee 7 os riged teal fot " ve poate! mm «res ae ee ieee yam a3 rt vee bes Cp Meas weg oo teed tes os art oS wee ty i een sesh w 'ha seerh a, ot M3 'he C3 eee am oe wie ; Pat wep Nat "nat £ ya wn, rads 'at bet 'et ret on pe. a on 963 peeed, ges aa a4 e at Ch a weet Lug one, { wo 5 ry ed pe a fer ed Lenk: we re \ Ls ann oat "re yes 5 bode te wt eee ca Si a4 we gate. cabs ned 4 et Bly 'neees raed whet vey, a et ved:
2 % os a5 ' " tog a4 "p4 be La t Mees re i aed wy "tes Sy & z rot , ey m ret ns oe 23 ae we oh in peice 4 Dt Ste + ' a3 pt EM sy Ch 4 3 = port ge oe LED he rs "a u ems oe re i hee ER ey . Bs wt ve beds oa tapes SB ae oe io os a ay) ret ; of mo MR a os Qs wa feat cn a : george etinn my en pas z oS neat SA Beene owe ? nt is ras ae ve ws % had. Meee ~ we > 'a my Pat Oh tee ek ES pm on ten hey, 4 1S oe wy "
" oe wee ae cg shod haat . EL ad wt a wg & he Se, ch yea det sai 2 os an we wenn BF feat he we be as QC 'et ro ert one Cr rey Bh oy oe ed bot ae See CES me Poa BS % ft We - y ' fare, yee . ae ae ye pa 5 . a * Zs a5 vat, at ts a Shy vie ns ms Pe tee : a ie ' gs "3 Fae] ee * 8 2 tet ep et oe Foal ted ves me ; "nd at set me weet woe kt en, Be Mond oe «es tft ie BS rd a me ne io ties t a wt pet ms ti oN ° we 4, he OR n ", 3 om eer: 4 yet ns ne cS As ce ay i et 7h sont et eg fet, Te oe Nae et as ood iy bn Cat ce Saat 35 ped poe Sat a 'inde $e, od ¥ oF ot rend, we Ty eg ALS pee vote ns Se » £5 * r ai aed aa tt Yr speed Povey we ¢ whet pl m ts & Rae war Cm BA Ay teed, * pee Sead on pak So spears ee" 3 eo veces, &e a a oe we iy Me bey -- sao GY os £ Rae ot "5 pend ie 7 ene nied > ES B . weg pS wy oe Agee te rer 'ees 2 weet ons rn ee ost ' Sed oy ne deed te et ? ae ork re rd Yabo a ke gy Ae T% "ie vee Q Li f 3 . ms me x rs ra ro a os rip eo ot ~, " ES aoe mt a 2 ans, "a ot vant ie bt poe wy ae ve be, 'said a os WAS 2 fs we ge oS Cr Mn. re ais wt gra wy heed mm na Pad teat hes re Les me ae ¢ wea gt tee 4 ; wa the EE Tb iB rd z pe ' ves ee od ant " $y oe ve Peg a Sao ese ~ wpe ad ry eet Oy as we Ne at ws poe wh me ret vey Ww ome, . wae a 'ot pet , * wa dane ok Sa aired Sade + tot ate we Hh oo ns *e4 ba he So ees pos 7 pod ge bred "abe wre py Ye os res ate om ee . wae wo gees Shek ne Neal ee a is he wee finde peed 2 'tek greed ped pap ne ge ls ae ; ; Bs $ a4 ; ohn o ct at ie Oe pa OTS repo pha aS fe oe gee : iy fe he os * ' * Z : ; ; 2 = 3 f i sare 2 « im te pe 2 tet BR et a . sd foe Ea wt te ge be, i ~ m, an ee o Z ye ms : we at "tot oS # , Bote ger dg go Me a) S a me 2 pe, pet pn Me Qs Fad Th, epee phn tt ag) ~ bo A on Cy Ser ob, ke ae ar Whe, Aa poe, a, OO Oe oe me, OE = be "Se be EG ps sheet f et rons Sh ry. " ot eee "ed ye ; pet yas fy ~ "4 we re, t sche ca 0 oes & g ca ab Yat s ' 4 , eo tow @ Ge pr & Me pe fe gh ei Qe Ba uw Ct ee ne ~ ed me Sone x "dead 'nee ; ph Soot crt we hl Oo a My, yee ed wy a ' 4 £08 poe to we pa is "eat $s . rae vr, vieg . ret 2 z oe Gs , he $ x Oe nerre aM Sede coat 'ae BP os Nw ences, c reyes ine ct a A oo red n & r wet pened " oon et sed > te oe A aa oe, Soe ~ Soe a a + ( he 4 ; rng 0% + Se 4 * oa : a pe F Fa Ap rit, oo oe sped a he gh, nat Bey ee £ ~~ MEST ~ es ae *, nh vee? es honed os wes ot in ony CE a} on fied oe Boy fs iA oon oe tad om oes p piers ke wo the ye aed NM ae . ari aoe BA ' ae wt. ' = Sean * & A food 2% ny ~ we ; ~d an hee Ze 'iat " wet uges we te, we Raters oy A ores he, ws ae 3 aa heed aod ps : fs oye Are, "vi we toe ea ae eee ot 5 : ery Ge he * fr ae ae Book eh Moa Pee a 'eal phot ne o es Ch Se gee 3 tee ced ay As 71 5 . net oo een ses a Biba pdoet fe ee: od a ea PY on ed het a Ly 4: ot mo * ay * ee 4 ce ay 'nad hk wy oh ed sev gt net ees wo foe BS ; ae x ied non w ° io ret oo % ween See nent ee » ee ms "pee ~ yy foot a gt we a mo x ar is ad ping end, Nad Bt powers aed . dea 07 Brgy m~ few hes os fe "Sh pat seat re i ye LS & & we wet & eed oe aa - & a a 7 we Ae a " fa o "ey - re ?
eee Lets Fa : punt ea Y x go Sat $3 whack rin, it ca yes VF 7 8: ' 4, w a4 sre os a ms pe were. ns o er ay rs LP Bod a Li ey Pa Sag oo So . os 5a Bee whee secs geet ret wrens fe be pet v2 Ly tet a wd Ses, oa " Ch = ad "ses . ae 'et Bed aoned, * ed &, seat Sat we bf a: é. ot, ried i os Bf ot es Ls fone 2 ne ge 3 ret Rt hat : ayes. ae 4 BL "nek wet cyee erred Le ae $ we Hink A ea a we et ' a5 aS «nd a hy ' rae vot owes ao com rr napen a4 "heb B.. ot ar rt elt Sd "ord we wae aa sok x Soe ne He Ly Dyna te, net Z wt fs At wn we Root . Teed, ; we : 7 - aries ot ie 'nad? . os ~ sete? " brad Np cn, ae sed '. ~ ron, el ee ea ee et ae ne gees rerees oe z sened, ~~ r ws ee es eet, re tee, ot , Be Pe "et oe fea ty "ed By ore 4 P re td a vont Bp "a Be aS me fy : . = ay "y 3 we $reg me te oo wo uf ne wu de Ae ne pe we "ae ined as wo y om andor gs 2 4 plot 3 Ewes hae whoo, a "3 3 & 2 $ mB bi "mp be Eh wee het 'ad Bs yee oa nah L . 4 £ 4 a eS Natt ig ~, " / os ood ne bet a wd bad ae bee ; ee $3 tn Se ee: 4 a book panes re nae pine ae reree wee "ees wat rye ont yn ® SA gone 63 * aaa ot Danes Bea aed w%. sheah ad ey Hee, re ne paek n ; "ait re + ek , Tolped, oe ¥en odes ae rs we rt ated Ae e a ' 4 ces} mS che res wiped on ey <S oe 'nad St Sos yn treet os ed mS os aoe th 23 fat nape wiped a yo sheet ry red a vied ee pe ay a ae wk to? 'ad Pet en os "het et Z wee hepoes oY te ay A ¢ * f oo re ¢ hineoi td remed mr pated wiped, not ones, ae t ays os, re tee 4 . ig gt EE , As © ot sheet as Li fi 2 at 4 'ae ee he he a on re w ae oo "yy a4 rere rae ad wh thd Bena "4 bow "dod G ,, 2 ped Sane ang yor) na got Sat me 9) rere rm * odd peewee LG fs bh 3 as iphans ee font Be) Ox, ee on she * ws oe aan oe ye mA tend ed Veet 3 wey a seed r4 Kone kere . rt fh acd res gee we ik oe Ro fog teh gd foves oe. ae i tee 2s wee were "4 ee , % BS ws. ere ra te geet } 45 A a te 3 xfs re io fey ah wy et pees : WV mw Mee hd ae sr pe "aes Fey, Z Vv + z Gio ay OS j we fo O# hee "4 * bet «es, Bow Fm vid tay yee oS oa 's oa An ben wn "eel ty re Sat cr be ano, 1a a os, 2 reg 5 '4 y a ap ee Le 3 gee oh wey, "pag poet . pees, Ned caob a oe a 43 id te 1h pee i woos $7 weet tf * ges ash gre ra red grt yet teed pot "4 ao a "beet oe eaeks eee: ww bee we whaed ven hes ETE bea ats & i om og ot Q by me tet shen i a ns a mo pe Be gg oe pet ae roe ah bea f ite ot % bebe "bed a "3 vee tet eet ot ry Sed o aa 2s Z Tapert pee x. ° 'bf "A an £4 43 oy ed pos yb ee © 2 fred aa ne Pe £ 7 Tey 4 : * SE wm todos bone are ars SOE 4s We he et we thy a be oA Sek ve , , a 4 vee te font gee oe 2 hoot ren ae had aS te pen "ad 0G be a 2 % aes ge rf ty we p oe ' 0S 35 few ceed, feoe ae ve ", . ree Goud oe ye 2 Rn * a ay hoe She 2 dt a ™ shod we fed we wa oes a cg we aad t pee, % " Bead: oy cor 1 we ge os se tos a ool oat ed nn thet we rs ees cand Gs deers r 4 feet af vy ws, oS od Se ree eb yt ' ed mo, hed x tee phot wwe Ly se Ke whed - fade an tt oe wee i on , te ms Bey ret se os on ote, ze , * on nt " wan Sopra rm on eg & i beideg got "a BEs 6G eee a 6h s pede, Vw mam Se og * ine) at ys : ret the ete eae a 4 "4 te 5 o en ; 'net m4 a Wo yes ee a we fs, tee a SS z , & % * oe, gy anes, Aral bee eed Ey z % raed ws St an ee . ot wr "geet os ret me a ned, cra a Fes fos a3 Ae 4 at 'chk a ay Sones ES 5 es het eee OS 'ed re 3 " ay a " ered . we, Sead ws 'hs es, oot a yet rt f Se 0] a # GF ke Ch eh gee "ee uy os ee 2 eh pS: oon ee vt oe rt ee e Yee od bod : ay ite a ok: " cm wie a te fore a he e% ges fy Po 5 'ote t aac ; y z z om Be ak as ee NA reg em pee we he ee nS re a ip of "yee She, nt . o % yes pa z a ne if bee ft we oe A' hee a we ee feos oe Co oe ea so wo be ws ae SS et wood a 'nt ee ry eo TE OSES oe Bom © 4 ae eet Be a nas got ue Se ard pe 44 Sd the 4 2 red ' Sos Soe pot Lot " Sha < dng , a St 5 etre ets Saeed 4 weet hs powes wm a hy hae dod ne: sft 2 net * Set 57 é 'et sow ome whe beet eprt wore ey ayes. . as ~ 5 be co a 2 OG & 2 SE is od i 1 iinet "4 i & . wee % rm ' oe: By ge aa Sees pied ; ret re ne ts sped rs a a. 4 , a aS es hed Re York an yee 2 we he ered i nent rn het y : ere nae See t te na 'ad fea at gt oo oh bye od he : et ' wees oye aA see oy 4 of $ vee et eng 'tat 5 eden ot a % + ent shea > hd wee ' @ FF en P he bt ed aan md roa Fe ' 4 oh Searet tA 4 4 Peofs 4 . ns 5, 5 4 'a ¢ ies 4 oped, ot a Neeeat res ran os, is wey * "na? we os vred he nee " a od vr ve . "E rt ret 'wieg ear Saal ns ca a i om 'EA ens SS bee " ps We a "Th +e gt peal ; ref 23 ges Sag see an ge th reed 4; - $ ss ~ "nll os pees * fas fr, TS pneap ag os Hee ee 245 wierd we roped Sov of, = dees os a3 * rept oot i me Co ge CA , > & 5 ° on "ee ef cd rs Lh. he z cast t Fea ' os 'e eed 'nd SS woe 7 aes ie e 4 As oD al ~~ we a ro a os whe "% hs at ws cheek ot reed rand rare peony Sry he hd As Za cae Kent ¢ ap Sox pete ae £5 eat fog pa heed eee wo head! tt est ne pan "a ot al res $ ~s "
pee ae ae des Bee es ua heed news pe on, Sd. as yond oe Heat tt LS wibce wn wd a yer vn, 83 An3 aeoked, we: ae ae us wee +e ni eet vf & fobs g et wn 2% ay ad pa peek bos ~ A ie a foe Hod "3 ha geet ed se : 3 foo feet EA Be ms 4 pate a on ey oe on we te, ae, Cr rs 2 fee Spee 4 prey Se i A ga : % oe of "4 <4 phe sees cad bea ' oo 'ae! ae ee a host ot rk 4 oo wh . ae eet fect hen? ee Bt tad " Nee oe wee, 7% der Med rE ne " geod "cy vee ed we pra 44 a » ; a 'Soe eee yerd, "a free sand: ae fee we eet ot, _ 5 aed ww vr ee bed et xe fr fake oe a feed here om ig acl ne oo co pace s go c. ad wy ne pret pen, vend be eee vn fe ae aheee i, ~ wy aeoed, om hed y Bp a EE ve 4 " ty ee Of or. A : we rad pt i on set BG "end get ' we we at " oa nee wer os tots, tn ih ; ve re rood, wet Be st SS et a ey pe Ce AA ao ts vO. fot a 1 tes oe foot oa * rs + 4 fant ae ive wee nae me ws 5 ": weer "A pone, peek se * " s orn, to eer eek z on, ws hh rey nt ¢ oe end 2 ws LPs pee, ¢ Mr ee : od ; m fe Le g * 5 z Bod har a oe. os aed A g Ye oe whet ay ree ay cea od , one ae Foe, Ne noe ne ak Be 'eek ry saat, pond "nad? " Me we re a Ae 'er js, os ge oe ak tt ao aaped, a wrt: ewes eee, wb wdpak 24 6, ie rey ms ms ht ay sy nk a yee Le at Cat as 2p ee pans Ai pede, oe goa we mas 4 've rag oped bed a %. Onp a eer oe Re ie he he ceerd, ma S08, rod rol ets we at ot, te , fey ot oe Dt oe '> ¢ ne we % feed a3 rn ¢ ott 0% we hat aa facet tees oP we "at teed, tn, va oe " get tL qo og bok rt as oe ° Poe mt es Prd peeees So oe 4 pot wot peenn wee a ws os wane ae: vee ook om ws ne tae po oe 'tof wet ee ; rh $ : } wy Pa ¢ " aft wt ort ee at oes, at yaecd, Ered it 'ie " whee . aes rea Se Eas ene (oe eh o es ae se wt ' BS nee RD Dh SS . ge Ea se re Fast a Seog ree ee we. Fons woes aS Be ye nf 'ath bos ta tn a pos wee Ls wot ree Me a3 mG a eo th fm ie pe os oS towed s o ee wig eet by ved os A ae by jem pe ba ° seed rd Nat wes te ee feo ¥ at ye shod sy ed se wy oo Le an nanny vdeo os 04 poh ere he edo, "seen Se a t3 x pe; ie yokes a xy he arent ° ie LA iM 4 P yee ro". : Bs et 'nt ta eal at het eer "eee! oa epee me bos aed Sod eyed Ee} ohn Bs g yee. dont a iat Fa re t S rok a re, -- 3 vA wes wa e ' , ea ye oa ae ed Band wie a3 : oe re ot : ee £3 . o on ree as a) g pet cH, aa oy & . 2B og g » oY BE F mw 70 ve nes gre L3 4 5 : yee ths bee, CS "
eit nod se 08 nes yee £74 bent . ge Le ws L oe oe ' co fees, Sood rae et gt ocd Ths. id oy tet we re #4 os het "or C3 fre 4h ; merge a tet Ee ped a OS ore "ae ~~ we Of 4 a 'ae 'et Fs et z Le ons. on, 'neh * bey ad fates g wae pee a he tnt re x z ts uk Peal ' ay shook ek "4 ger Na cf ie eoree yok Sho $ ood: ~ 'peasy rw] oe oe ae Sant re S % ¢ ahooa deed ' ae! 1% et, phan Z yo , OS fog a, we Sow fp om the wae a pas Salem roe 4 whe Z AY ed oe "eal s ~ % ay need had? we eae: po Frost ae 'nd OS es , 4 * ed int chek > we en oe St ge il, Saad saad ent 4 ws Se
5 % tee 2 wet 2 xy phe, xo Ba "Ly Z tee ee eh nd " a ORR ee me he * AS at ey seed ws ne iA we: a oO £% * weet 7 .
a Na be. § £3 an, es gered te eet re ay sad ne ' 4 ws " Seat Na anh wees om tHe "heed tates, ied ere % "ro ye i $e ; £% pa ge yt a 4, Sa ns et Z SZ wees Sg, o 4 a 3 eB "eh eG wg Ce ae . 6 6 ° hi 5a f"% gon we. oe ae rf ret had yee "at Sel t yy yeect pode os : wey ie Se ae re tt we > ae ¥ wo aa wr A "s ww ae ayes ws he Sen ya wiles SS g yee Ly pot a Oe nF ny pny ; a het 4 ee g : Sang th wed A oi Lh, eS ~ feo +o. wn, bee, pet Sen, tt bet G 2 oe yard bot ea ead" ree or fs < fog aye ahd 'ewat todos, at ree rope "at fant a oo .
"mB veh ee & "ae at £ Ay ef te & a a a Shee ng ee hr ee es lad ay ae oe. "
~ a oy et wa en, se rea] wat ae we An ~ Pies ~ eh gen Nee han we wo $e hy tet a -» ve o _ if sered. on ad we ree, ys Sob ee! Bt "ee . ret pa 2 we ane rel as govt fewn ern we geen ort "aA : 4 :
a , 4 ee o Jon pened z% Z 1 s ' By as 4 .
aS +h So me pek A = ve ak oo fore pees os ped ra vee Bo a oot bg we ve een BA vet Sa oe ay Sree deed Neel chat we we on gt seeth ton e . wa reed Nit ¢ os hae, At weed, 1 fee weed Ce var: By 43 LS of Leeds . gS a at nes oy ' aA on wwe ae ay we 6 % ped BA of ve woe n , ge¢ ~~ a" a oe g 2 Bo o ee ke mee bee 2 a A 2 yoed i os oe Me oS Sat os, ae ay apes eoeot os we wed at 2 = ot : e 2 iss s ' a ae . x . 2 yet ge BA ple mR Mee Yo a Li we IZ ne . i " ise rm YB we eee ¥, nt C3 a Sa wy he Bess a, ae be as wa vod te "ot fed of tet i wn ln ws a a we rie OS ot sh Gp a ee =O , ae oes God go rent ioe oH 43 res oe oes = ann eed , aS os id Pe 'ait 4 ee ped Re . fey oo ot At Re " ns Nal cheat .
% =e 7 get my ced bed eet Be "3 rer re Ao ae eet ee a Sn See hb eb ~~ rt ey om nett oe & % Oo hed Se Y ted Sy a Ant 2 eek a ms t Q a in a, An ee : a; Fea, * fy oy Ls BS Z poet e we LE: ao z Cat 'et Spe om as yee £7% ¥. z Than oom ed weet od we ee a band re ge Gee a jew ; %) we Sow, can ew got Cal. {6 'ant od ee "nn aes os a) oie 2 ' ft Sis, ; x 2 ves " +3 ' Sone, yo . 6 se oy o we ood ot et ! = 4 'i me 1 ' pst ws ee, gt ' 4 f aa eh got 4, thes a Set "8 Set "3 wh = o rs 4 oe meet re Ot be ge er be, Bot wi teed ae a vs B iS os ee , we ah So , > tod Sot ed g va ae eS ye tho a "aeod nd i ie en es a ot ee ' rf j % % 7 "nel Be , +o? py Sot Ay eet a shew snot anes oo £5 A : wt yn ao £3 tf oy ro Swe awe a a ~s ee os, 24 ge yé oe x Se "tt eet gent eed J eed Lad 63 ren an gen va ad od . £2 ' os re oct "te "= £ we ae 'a ge " ~ we ree Suove Kee, ae oot peed om Sead ta we pad a boat 5 yet, pus beat ' wt 2 oS 3 be S. GF ae Mf ae wood eel ; a3 ps ne aS. ee ee ar bef "3 KG "3 xe thy a ay e OG ~ A '2 s weed een a on 4 ores spot Saf e Soe hee ~~ ee ore gah Ww nt "na ned Gt het ae y co is a | ¢ st one wn, few Le oe ndyet pores Pe mm os baat bert pot Iatted x ees " ve Rs 6 tne ne we Seg id ay i " ¢ bE & g » 2» & B & im © tt 2 sa & GQ & @ A: : BA os ay pet 5 'net a os Pes oe ay a3 ce Bo we oh 'he oo @ my bes re ten ng o a5 yew x # $4 pea 'iy e See ; oe i ify f ane 3 "a xa ns { ' é oo owt ot ee oS res We 43 fo a as Pa eo ey fs g he 7 43 ae wt Be, soe , a oS c : he ot at a a ie oe ne ee G tye vee mh ? ea So st SF wth ae an cao ve a oe pes asl wen "4 vied gr een not ~ we re yt ee i om ad = To Co a oa nt re AG yee Ay wit $5 ol od Nt oe ork ws yors + cS La a4 Us bet, : : ot vecued 'ead oo ihe 3 ae weed a3 rn my ag ' Yo on oe fon pe i 'od 4 box oy 43 oO hes oa SF ce 'et tnd ee bes uy % 23 ort whe _ yet me 7% "rg "ed pers saree hed 4g ' rea oS a3 ben £3 ry ree coho a ood me \nae ns a ae Ne were ° dae fa os LP 2" -- bet "CS om ot "tS rn 4 mS om 4 fos we s we whew Der 'ne "C4 nk, fect Roe Gy» & Bk , & 2 Bb 2 mE OG, 5 OS Goa BOR aos rn cre ? 3 > wheel wee nied be. Gat Bp *. a ae or, yet mn ne * os a ~ ; 4 ry ae Ne et oy 'ef % "4 a: A foes Sof a : obo ie acer ¢ £3 Ds ' : a a ; aes gt od we Ct e of OS a Say ree a3 gn a pe e ms z fone "mee bo be. we Sora ante ea hee nod a B, Bo ke & @ & & 6 8 & = & > % 2% ts ma GE * x % 2 g < oo a g3 oo x : ad Sead ae can © : * ie ' ¢ " ua t 2 'oe poo bas ft Le = seal by om w © So 3 ge O& we iO co Oth 4 ~ cn ae nee whet tid Ace Se oo bee ad 2 Ch bee tot ek gt bi EP tes wm oS wy he ee te EG wae , os ' a tet he Py Ayo WE wt , " te ete wh Pm Oe rt v, 5 ' 4 we Re rs me & ie A tt oe a when es Be 85 bak bet es we Se Sa Fa 'et 0S ened > os a eee wok tft ed rt nfs a3 'a oe a yee aroek * As z nt # we wrens a} ~ en . woaket Sadat oS ae ee , x gt «= SE ed nd wy ee pe) pet BS & ee aa ba ae les ow r 3 2 'ae oh Cy, wt - Sond * oA * - a : eet "p eens nd = A * ooh spt bet teed: £ iad nevi we Aw ot weet So a "oat en ae re w wien a3 de vis py > keg ns "3 weg ty om. ween "A im ve wed oe "my Ge 2 RS Se 2 BS eS ye ee oe Oo tt wor & at % be & eS S ¢ - ° ' 4 eet an toot het we Mon * of sy ae «eT her mea po be oth ' , th - 4 : eon ' " i 4 oon, , # :
oo O On tu 9 be Boog - uw R mm S wm & ™ ot GS Bb & yer oye : Baek S z yes ot yt vera os eet he Se . <> XG 2 t cord ah a, a" wt * a ms, Swat Sot sn 4 oy ns So fe os So ce ey : ered mm, he ed ned x oe we we 43 hy obs speek ; fg i : "nt = ¥ o, aes hod Gog 3 3 fe * Ay omy Us t vet oy ° ' Hy iw ey 'a wen ' * Spar, " fs ho ani of tS G3 ren whos SA abet feos =~ Sa rast on vet et fee we whew fet eek = Co oe om ser = "eed fee BM, nm pee Sad oboe! Sy ae i, os & & " we ef as te a oats : ; f ". ; ey ded Sook . th Ce or a ve . =! m w a "hae a im a4 os on ce inte, vis iy art os nat He Bb ih is ' pe vet ae Lena a ee Sune oe wpe Fs) ve poor " , ey a ve fs re, hs Meere et oa foe thea Bee F %. pe gre "3 ry r%4 4 ou tonal ot re ~ i " ms 'ot 'nah "it ° nes Ft a haat yes ihe " ne ai tt 4 es 'ned A oy hat 43 ot 4 . > ort pied, <a 2 pod oe > oat 'pers st see ae fey pee we pet oa 4 " 30 vee Ye ws het Rare Nel ¢ mat es " ry vert ee 3 ret "4 ay ¥ "| et. wy a om woot, tee i ous wat 4 ne ve oy ~~ ms a 3 a eset ane om, CS 43 rey yy : pees £4, send io * poh ea "ey "y Sol wee, * oes chet Cae whee o asd wa nee oof mm ns meme Y ae gh eK my CRE OE * gg > a & ", ye gos ot ft - rod oy hee aa a ge ben oh . & oe x Sat Ea w yt 4 a as os ee .. : yet a $ aad ' af wee 2 ae en s peed ay pend "% oe we, ye Po he. os x $ may shew oe 04 % es ats "et ms a, : we o 3 ¢ ork ws Y & ¢ wa yank 2S we red tne wordt weet aad "deed at oy eo ws "tee 'he aft nate pod new, ee Se" wy tet on, Peay " re ¢ yee % ene a ap ry et * os iad Ww et fos es . J cheat. oe oS roe 5 oS nat x Rat eine ey ~~, "3 fort f yes Ww $e et hg % pet thew fe #3 oe ' id : nee ee, a os ~ fk var i 2 ee By os a tet Lo £4 hel ant ° oom ' i, hed a a #: ~ ; ry ane wt aot od em. dent rf fo " 44 wet Ds a Lb Re at %S ' yh rs te ae he re ix OO bn mt fo 25 bee Sent " et ao 2 & Ba EOS BS 2 &§ €e Bg 7 5 oY 22 AS 3B & 8 w & * ao cnet Ay > pies 7 ty uk - a 9% . y 3 4 ry ? - yoon, pees tet i. rans ty J os of oy 'rag wot a 'ain m eed, " ned . ve LA oS vo we, | CS re bee os oR 'ed gy ki, Ss Le He re iP pan ch yr oe : ved ot rial be rd os re tig Oe Wp ores Vs re pa eet Ae 23 aed heed ee 2 va ie 'pet ze et 2 dpe on G3 t%, a ey ee ge goes AEG to ay oe "aad tf pes "se >, Os Mat a mn a on ryed :: eos ba tered pre Sat 2% wr ae eee Sao vet oho ods evap ft 3 - cheek ee a on ore on os yoo ed peer on ote weet y ayers sod oy aged be f Song Sea wot a * oes fet hot ot Fs " oD Ww Gent oO roe, eee Ses a "A ee fe Be eg s Ro gS "= ow £ & & i BO SE fey * BO ¢ get 2 ns ' ; ' , Ch * % Ione ns a os * Be " m et wes 6B Ga tf £ Lg a ye Zz A vy wt fon % SF "ae a: fs Pf L. nr Co lena "5 ¥ ya Me OS ort on Loa oo os Se et CE kD ms ihe aes w Be os na ve Ay go a 4 ae 4 & oS we spook ct godt St rat er tad *O4 to yet es fos yo > pod On, rs mS fon a Gee, paned, 2S Gy Se Set bon ; ont grt ee . a ne ies St te Seas eo on oS Ww a ~~ ns ay ym, ee re had ° 03 cad need vn ayes ob eo a ay aes we : x wot < eet ce at "aad g Cat $ ee wo A Tae aS ok eet 'hat ' ed aut coped Sas Be et Rag ear fue a Ped feng hy e ones pees, ne as G1, Bom a8 x eo gg ee 4 me oe Awe mg & fy, ee ny % OC * ay | PR ES By ene oy mt bed sad oy, 4 Be fh et ra wot yo, ad im nt 'dé te hed oD Co ss wen te apa oe we ee tert os me Jee ans rt kG seed ae aos he rr. re eh n7 i pope ; heed 8% 5 nh : tod gens he a ae whee eb ts 4 > bed 63 ve of a "be? sored, z ¢ re > pak 'Nios eek ood ge ne * we ae * il ee Cope " ay iy a Laer, aa a ny z ded goed eo 'ae geet rey pet Paes ree oan ver .
% t iN toe, wheel 4 % ra Sat Pree '4 tet meget z ee BS oo ae Sok Sete 'hat yer Joab 3° $ pot sted AG aed ya 3 oy Lh fe, heed 4 vone Res L aoe, r ae weet ' pes ee he 4 ye! a vet &3 : oS Sn 5 y 5 HE me wood we te fonts 4 2 me si wm a a ED nga tp ee # rs ne en vi ut ot is Aa i ad ee eek oe 4% rot Li Hod a pe Re re ox, "ea! . hed ee Co pues ' el vn bee sm ay oe fea oo ue mo ae be toe wo a a me, he nepe, we newt bet Le " ES ben ie Bo Be op eB oS Bo oe ef & 35 G 3 B Op op BR eG ae is pa nite m 4H ries Oe ent an ros al fat Be Cp ya bea "aod on we ge grt wooo £3 ea a ae set whe, he a 3 aed re red eee 3 x yu i £ ed we c ee nord yen es, s weed oe mm"
teat ge ye Bs 45 fe 'he pot ae Se a aan 'cash ges wd 2 Le nh + ee " we ww cos Ve reed pk it et © we a oo i pak' och Sed cna nee oa Peep Soe iy fs on fated a ere mm es lose res ie ths ne 4? a Gea ot % oA "4 CS ret p pe "ee i Seal * g a ry toe al ad Pea) Wie a iB red 4 BSE Z co OS 4b A BORE go og a el fet ane % tet ge, a hs gon " th ~~ @ ree, oA "a ae weed gs ret os ee ed ay fod hy deh eed. 2 ee tet a> oot api! nat < Q 'be 3 ® ea ak ah x a3 on x wa " ae
- 4 : 5 yew ay 4, Ce B pews a es 2 a ' ' oe a"
4 ad Sone pee feet pes z Sd fev * ot As Bes ; vies vend ~ at von pee fee ; son ie if wt Cs ; Z : 7 = ered, 4 te in ore ae Te wee Bs a4 a ed, nee baad a a nd hel BB roowe, at we pt mate Ch = "4 'hed ves "bark * eet ees i vp opt we % ¢ bea a wt * 13 we ~ % aie fet ned a 'pot I tea 4 oh get , tA "S ne Ay beg ae dee en good et ee ay ats a Seat pot " t bad bya we rm x a t ors ee ee ors cook A 2 :
~ he Sg were eo as :
heer yor oe £ " bes bey toes £ Ceininat Apgedt GH N Wa, PRET af BWIA Wikk Orviminst Appesd (DE Ne. PISS at 2GQS ek mrurdered". The statutory 3 Mustrations appended to gectoy gh Po expla sth may nat be a certs UY} CQNSEUENEL OF ty t 4 ye td pants 7 bat wet os ih on poet % fort, at wy con wo ~, we rt are.
poet ne Y ot ms faba.
tt te abehuction of a person. All that the section requires is Unat the an » kidnapper /abductor had the intention ar Brows: dge that abductees may be mu rdered. Section S62 of the Indian Penal Code provides that wrioaver hy force compels, or by any derneittul mcans induces, any person to go from ary place would be said to abduct that person. The abductors had captured the informant and his 3 rath KP ARE "t we rey a ad } Ax} fry eet tye fr "4 + Was } PEP RES Th gi hy ere oy ¢ Pee ees AY oh ? a Prk oY ee t VERE rar Kae 31 pPaa m CPE + YR sm. RYERSS LE pe Grces weld cut by them, keeping Shiv Charan Ciraon in custody an a demand of rangom for his release are prey ed sharing the trial, The afaresaid acts af the abduntars would no doubt corstitute the offemee under section asd as well as 364-4. af the | ae * ~ : x Cade - though no charges under section Sh4-A wes Trame voing through the mater ials an record we are w Public Prosecutor & all have seriously faite ~ Sy rites ey et at" & by x Syn gs a, " gy POLAT sed iy discharge of thelr stahutory duty. Ph WAR A Case User section 364-A oft the Indian Penal Coc fe and TX fad pede.
'o ruistake Was not sought to be corres ted. We would now nol go ints feed.
rafter and lay the issue at rest by OC affective and continuous training of the Hhicers and the tyaining programs in the Judicial 6 be invigorated to meet the challenges faced by gare tewael ty Aoto APSRPE IN Fay gs Vy. The extortion money Was tendered to Agiz Amgare im EAS presence of urkeman Ansari arc Bilash Orson and ms Not pragecution evidence that the appellants were ransom was paid to the abetactors. This piece of evict . rR ' -- yoke VETO PUR MS sipgere S2st when foundation of the prosecu Har casas docs TAN sayolve the appellants they are entitled for the benehit ot doubt.
i8. In abduction several persons may be wivaived Bates 3 Aoraie 3 trherefore The Sie that mMaying their own assignes raie and therefore ths pina that ~ rangom was ret pal to the appellants reir Involvemert gp tae ee : . eae Shy (Haran ce LIAS et} taet iE the com) é eansistent that sn Charan Graan was seen tsk the COMPaNS = tee ;
1? Craudaal Aganal (DE) No. LOY af SES WD Ceimiant Appeal (433 Ra. 2498 af RRS ef the abducters sand thereafter he was Not seen Seow goood wrong ped fn ¢ abductars therefore must 8 By ay what had happened alter Shiv Charan Oraen was taken away by them. The appellants have 4 their examination under section Sis af ee ade af (eireriria ee aye ae . at fod of the Code of Criminal Procedure. They do mot put forth a plausible and acceptable defence excluding their involvement im she crime and in view of the facts p raved by the p JB 'ie ant cased has been given the 8 s well aa befor HD nt under Ih 3 again at sosonianos wih fac There was no deb ay in registration of the First ation Report. The family ofa 2 vietin of abduation for ransom.
mey not rush to the poke immediately. The abducters hac demanded ransom and rupees fiye thousand next day. The worrant has stated that he paid ransom Nur mus broth not released. He discussed the issue with his farnily and then gave a written report to the police, The family af SAIv a8 fearing for His fe and waiting for his retuon.
There 6s muasual in the conduct of a terrified fami 3 od fees aeiogeates Geifners fhe nolhice esineark seen oe OEE id not immediately iniorm® thc police about abduction of SHS Charan Oraon. in Hea Rurmari vp. Gout. of GPP" the None Supreme Court has observed that the object behand pron f registration of a First Information Report process inte ration and to minimiee embellishment later on.
Zi. he fear, anxiety and Trauma Shiv Charan Oraon were under going Can When seven arried crim mats of a dreaded gang stormed demanded guns or in lieu thereof rupees one lakh arid ABCICISS be mbers of the family for ransom, there 18 ta ay ies % ee Rinne & fe. Seaver very fn oe ceed - Pag ge Ky Bees te te eoey ve a wy, we Oe "het "ed ne sd SA ' ce Ge a 0 reed ip GF ne ben pe, "EG we Ge pe, OO on s et gee rere ood yee, ons, oe "ws oe nh pee ed het See a hag see ped: pect a ot ree, 5 % reeet ater ved aa we 'ad hed nd bee raee 63 we va GP ree aa oe set - SRK a Peeee ge ~ "het seped a dead pai oF me Sad fn mn _ ~ on ved x, ted ga a fog hee ' wtaest poe yee eat wees eee Ad ee teed wet vised Ge es oy, tee ee ue 2 Mt Yes qeord, pe wok Sut ¢ baa ed 7h te yee reed oe me we Ly te, De ee "hed bee' Seal! q ee peat on Lf 'ae! Oe ho? soot ony Copia at 4s be m 'hed ope rs * word, wee LS a peed, wee z 17% " a ¢ perc, os vy at me ree . 4 ost ' ve at Le nt awd 5 rs Inet a ; YS pees, oo a? ' fon a as ye 5 » we, Z we byt nk nt om sare, i coat fat ger 'hed hot oA edt set ht a ~ bees Se we vt beat Le roe cote, a ae 4 wet fas " Sud ne os wy a we ge 5 Zz et ; fe we son . : vs os 9 eg] we wet" tae ee 7s th ae ar Sand gd mn Ps eed Z grt ed on ood Ay tye an wy G . vent aed on, bent! Pes Z + ct "3 ° "at ate on, 4 a3 th Z Nee! a : ¢ Aa ae vo ae oe Ved ne a reg ; ie reg kee ae E28 "on sit vor " - ve mb q oF ee we fede cf Sent : ee ay yeh ve tged cre eet hod or Ss oo Ak or x me : Z e , eo . ' A4 oo * " an Age Seb Teen us a rod vie > bed tee on tet ty : = oe Spee * wet bon oe oe a oj M wm Fg oA reg Ed tae ee tet ake EG os a a Be LE a 2 wes '" A he aol ws i os fs Soe mo reed C3 oe wt Gj a get tat f = a Lupeee gs vee tp ge aa nee et Lf ropes my rs t a5 cot a " pies 8 : 3 J Z os a ae = St bee wo ' ae oa pe aft Sn ca ai i woe yy es ww ry jede m ie at wo > a: dee D ta we at Be a3 Feat Wy seer "cy * oe t en at & z eat " Sees i ted ct wh wv 'hed ry * ve a3 4 ys on Fee) e 7 "as on we SE Lm weg Ag "es soon ug on os om 'wt SS " sae 4 A Se, tap vs a a Be 2. & 32 ve GO wf oe OO oa F & = Se og 2 pe * ma Oo ds & oo ode on ko gee Ls co Spee Bee P seo x ms wy, ob te Sx ped ae yo noe awe "aes of wer nyoe fe a: ~ st = a Ras aa Seg wh et ~ * hee o rh Sh 2 & went ae: y SS *y we a ' foe oe : 23 ae ~ 'ab wee oped we jee BB wes eee 4 ot om " a3 goa ed \ x 'hel ws book tat > ret es, 6 sae ' "dk 3 . ; et 2 2 we tet 2 ' % fo ae , a Z 'e ; , a fae gE € of eh he nes pas be, ae ay 7M -- a co 43 es ied oe fe peek a ' Oe it a in npr : oe & Fr63 ret . te bod ee 8 Cy rsa = i, * erent eS me ns fos neal ay bos 'ae z a wa re ' ve Te F 4 fe Loe, ue ose pes, esd nat A 2M 2 ge oe 8B E eM te OE © ke ge fe ra eg ek TS i Yug's ae ope ~ ot whos "S we a * Sod veoh bee o, he we om a a aks. BAe ye aot v geet a ws CBS a a ed "heed "se be Saad as ek ~ as "nad b. ms yng & weet: send wt £% we wee a aed, " ree, 'ne a5 a ee ~ we 2 pee: a BF book wa whet boot As "ead le oy wy ot ay ree be yy oy ra : Spent oe ~ va ot 4 . on, i ro "ae z a4 ~~ oS fos eh tt eae we ae ot my on dea Rn ae La ty tae tere 4 * Bs) 'el aS Ye lap "te fd the <S tec v5 aN ee yi ta oS ne, "ad hat i bes wy vat teed reed NA @ nord my on weed genet . . : : " : : id i Gh fess : d om . ea "
28 » 6 2? Y 2 Ee Bo Bg a 55 62. & & op ge Be %: wos 4 fs 'ty v5 when? 'bP os : oes " wn "pr Aeprot 5 ord ty ees Sawt any ot ras aos £ om Sa 2 ; z be ¢ yee . A 5} 7, 7 or ea get tt y fell N nang pot ' Me e $ een, wens ae a ie Sd in gs " ae ae 2 ia om "ae * tn, bee 7 se os eee) aie mm a et gs we tg ee 'a ae ry vee cS be OMS om tetee : bon me S oe seth eo fant t + eet on at os , a se : at ce ree ve AK mo ry bens ol ey py, rye ook ort Sat ws pais 2 'ee ft pat x vere, Berd oat eid sec ype : a a we i re ME o eon yee ba a3 wa co ed GY % feet . wy we + pe oS es af A wa re de tt " nn a 6S oe mY cs 3 ir a wee ee * am , oan g Nad ot ¢ ot ~ A Ye TS ned are oy pes hart } m3 rs ky, + es oe Og ge OT i BV toe = fF YM a Se ee ane -? = ais Spas ee a> Ce aa rm rea wt my r ee. nS Ms ~ ". sot ri 4 bag tone tet ng St ewe bet Fe en fein ot @ 3 A Me ; 4 os + i a3 ; 2 oe ng Fo re iat rt aed "pt is wh BBO aes fA eg fot xd = we yt sy, on pet re Be ne pies wee pe ree A ws Ce + arr pee, ie ps wn w i me a Gi Ve ae; <o es fog ie wm net oe 'stent " bei ot re on cee 'aha eed x bay Net a fs oo ae a Ls rr mz nm vee ee gs od mR eh agg Be a3 ws a ft won ae ' aS . pee f re 'a ind pet we te n $ oi pe : : 4 a5 4 5 ' tai " wt f oft . ? ok ces " "tet om hn tg fa at os it CS bea xen a as "E48 @ oy Sod rs. 43 vied OF £05 a See dined & ge fet 'od a a a . ro 2 Bs gs a at 4 She; bets bs ae oes eotk ap ok oo as wack a te os omy oe » bey ig eR week: a cana' ef ie ves ane Sew 'ot rn ae roe has spot ws oO eet $ vet et we ees oes she Bat we hea Eo Ws foe A ye 'eet ms eet oo ¥ ~ ee Sed a "ee A fn aA fy Oe . pone es as woh nt ny Sant he goed. ret 'aes woot ze woe ae a Me 4a ves ad ve ey va =" $3 ; Bp Gp oad Gt oe heed fant ou bow
3 ane aft tend ge Lape C4 aad wena C ' RE MA a eS 2p oS a: thers a ae ' Gs oe ares : ; 5 shod : ' ss " 4 < et ee fh :
rs pos 73 ped os ' i eyes ni . a shook s ot ood ? be mg ' a Hee, wh ped te ate fea oe oo Sad qe ot ws. pet wo ° ia ne Cs hy + era Soon bos mace ae ot ry et yan on hems wie awed. pot et ¥ft 'bs x and ws ae oe gt sn na oo er mt teen, ty " Mu ot ne deed We Ke ot Z AY joe. yy ee A Sent "se te nt etl "at rm 5 t deat a bs ae ; ce ; tenn o . . Ay tae wen poet hs vs ~ ve 4 he eee nt ay % ws wt ty Lo veg we a pod Ld . os + eet pan ve we ma Loe e spe $i "real 'ad ne] fee Z aa ia a Oo he fet raft 4 re if We so "3 om aed s9 BE: oes ae z rat eo a ea Pegs tere eet "a aes Whe ee ' By teh : vert pon ay Coss rt t on, Ai Ca wets $ j na weed, 85 ya ee tent gL zo Q ot % a : v2 ' x to 43 ie Oss be eB mr & OC poem fw Tt Sh A ee = a3 RC rm crt pee oe ae ee a oe oy tS cea he Be Pe Ae mn a me OE ge tee ty an eam ae 2 re " ' vageek ghee ci es wet os ap BS tent '3 se , om oe ° ve arene GF ae hens ite pets et hedee ee ores ng red on Be £3 os iad Eb rons ped 'a nn "teal sheet Soa Seve os wn cheek werk went ret fay Sab reg a . 'oad £ os oy a sg phon es s a on Coke ' at as oe a ee ye ed Z . : ie gs en ae "5 4 aod om ahs 43 as en vee ; a "Aeont w ot bet a { vent Sat 43 i Yad Goh " ns ns bacon, 4 he ha t Sa, gs ot a het 2 Pe Ps eit a ' ent eo ye "ae os fe vee Ge a a 43 os wa i gy beet . ap ES ad oe, we ee ce Ay . eed a a ce ey & a3 gh let fet cy fea > wrt iG, 'A mB " he a3 5 * rh ae os z poet g . "% i asc "5 oy, of % 4 # Sagas, 3 hed me "rots wos oS net "nse vet bert er 'a Pe FH $ £3 on ao Sonn, vs " hee aad ma o% as lepeie bes ye tut gs a4 ye "ye vie ; * yet ve ~ * «poh Oy ph aes we a ge ay "~ Lo dee ey em Be M3 ded or et f aS fe ee a h re ke Ce eed of Bem mE a Uh wer Rh a Mig tee os sod can ay <p ho aed x" i sah om ng an phen ae ae tS FP oa gt % an fis gs Meee, pens y ps x 4 t 'sak trod 5 5 ' 5, " r% >. ~ fat of cect ~ Wi eh a me he us ~ oo Os a3 bod we ee 5 43 'a re z 4 ne tert ' ° Sonat of a need, Daeoe yo, read Saye ' 'hed 3 the ha sree ae a m a a Beet on choot 4 get rh ne a ; 3%, + phoned, ae eet pes "nt £3 ne we gy et yet ort aon oa fee fet fot Uh gs As ee Be ce ae we $ P en ; Ce 2 ert 2 fo a eet 5 Fasc ot om ae so oa 4 tp nt oy feo she aes 2 Sade * Ia Le see oe 4 poe ™ > at 4 et me Ee mw we 8 @ wR Re Ss 2; a £ & B me ateat OK eS ps os Oe 'ha aA s oa oa fy get we One See os ios oh ge wy 85 % ant ¢ " 3 gf of ¢ bhp Fane a rn z a "ees Aa oe Pe the aes a ie As i go 4 + vita os ed reer pre a ow oot oe Leper Ws hea oa oak Bees oy / po Seee a he ' bee te aed wet saa OS Shioeh 33 ree, a " 4 3 we Lt Set 74 ¢ ee 2 on haa sped get ; : be OF, grb By : > ' neal io hd 2 Seat wa ben peg we £ oes ven tht wee bh s a re t rt ee tet yl cot mi We wae mi we oe ne aS ee 4 steed bed ft ont hs " ; AY tit 3 eect @ a feet nore 4 my os £3 eet, Me a Zane 'nh nye ae hee oS th we wet sy oe iy wee, ae gt Ef ah Let we wht £3 bee ae , o% we od gee nese Sees ws % on " a3 aed waa 4 % wee we nn on ae grt ; $ oe bee * eres a ea "G we wer:
red ot seh ry, é @ 2% Qt cae nad rope heck y 4 roe Sux % peed, yer feet, int when bee eteas gon oo Fee et f ry van ns , ret narery fet wed ete '4 "7 "A Nad Seed soot uA ves 'naps yoed Lee "dead oe wpe ped Bend god Get oped "D bebe pee } os Gedee Lp Ot ay 3 "3 NA ¥ x, am Fan . a 2s a ee we! "eS oh et, an ye ah "ee She yet in ta ceed os A Fi te e a: wm ne ie Cee 43 oe xe oom ae - viene Lo te "he 23 yor A ; Xe wai te oe teed a4 on raed ce at ge 0 qeeed, eee Bop . on cor on, ree A 2 eat yee feet . eed "pe weed, La "oe eee oh, ee a Saal bed tit a ws a po aw eg pot "pt £5 gt os 'neh 4% y ee rf seo wet ay we pe te 4, eet We peey es % ts teed. i ten Aa ee ve cages et ~ foot f ed, of a rt o o ve on = ved cea ee Seal net a ON ae Gand : ; ye we et ee sere ae z rea eos *, 4, he ge re Begg a ge ge he ey th Sp bbs oe ee ¢ pee 4 z ffs Boot rye ny io 5 a3 m dpe? 'a oes ou Le: Bo - Sd he a oe Ge hy wee, oS he a ws a a oS fon ibd me ows ee rt i he y ba Faget mn hyped ee as eines wt % a. La Sa at i oe te was sod %% * pad ee e Along ded oon a3 "ress whos ne ah ad a Bt Esti rs 7 Sano am ie i eS 2 O & Cw "3 8 +3 tae ra ~ gen ome a cE eww eel a5 £5 see fos a a Be on etree ws KB se oA i wee we tad re . oA Sat ait Sa peer ee me ~ a ge wet a Lo Pa ff et fe he $4 gc es Raeue 'peo, whe tht ne a weed re Le . we pay ty ets et er os bas as we, ~ re ge gon &> I % * rere ; 4 . ho ' if " & wo - es
4 4 " 8 £2 g f& 2 eS ey ihe " "Oe So es gs ee g f ha ed £ wy "9 ete om ed ; wet ae By tral ceed fe ~~ onad = £€ ew, x fe CEs me % me nO Eh tee ry oe te & a Be Eo bee wo os sy a4 y peeed, nd n Ln ny 03 8 " > oS faa, < 2 oS ed 5 ¥ ri o wey pei a a y ee e, os ya re > & Th fon : pooh ay os on a ae Lt to bh " bg ne & 2 : "ot he Sa gs ot % re aes oe ea we whet von Ze Z ran "pea 4 vs ; BB wpe ae ae feet os po pas we OS ot o Ft tn Bp hanes om Ce wont = 2 £3 : wow woes a, ms ss oe wed ork ; a4 2 0h ~ ae aa raa8 = 2B pa 4% aaa' ees fs Sat vee m% ty ; tee *rs red ad £% ges ht on Noe = a ot a open Ost os tet Sod + Sot Ss ' re ad es ve w ped ite mt we Oe ot Ro a 2 wy TS we "aa 4 oe ms me ae a <8 " mS mo oe Bs ee DB wy OR ye as a m & By oo ead ave gn 6 pre, sn 4 ate £ : y y we te on ; :
acho, we a, we ae net ie) ee - ro CS sph Lat "Lp ne os tem eal rot ss ee 43 wh See es a te 5 © oS Bt oo ~ ® ty 43 ; ve pont ont at fort wh pent me £3 w ies oad i. oy on, om 7 Sead rs abet ore % mn ° : x ¢ 2% ag a art pod gm ¢ bs os As an hes, : Sw 4 £ ore a4 " S tert ae oe ee Z: we at wo OOS Om 6 6lUm SU OCG fs Be Oo by wy tek mo fo sa greed 'ad ow ts Qf ten ras Rf > free as us ca ea wh "r% 4 at ¢ oes oe & Na Oo 7; z et : Re ' ae : ' a ned nf ay w we a po ry ue es Pe ca 2 an we eg os ae ie Se we mn Net a Ps > rags) es oS ry oo Oy. Tent, ae fot Ok ened pot ry oe pes a"
Fi re "aed pol al ed $ ts nero? oad the % not pot ay bee 3 " we 'ait es fad ant ~ co M3 a 'et a ae oe 1% got hat % 4 St dae je . , a ad rat on r% a3 (3 we eee went tae 22 2 ' et ah bein & eo Inti, phew Sek z oe ns oped : 'ees To vn wheat Se tee we ge on ; Reins Se: ae sy 2 whet iooen aes SA ~ "hed x BY rs ed . tent fon . ory "eat s tee', wheal ped ' Y, per ew tg 'ad OG pene Ty ome! a ow, Pans Fea on * £4 aS ved a4 ree bY fs nn ro ay oat 'aot orn, a fond kis oe: Sp % nt Tht es os wet be ws ed an font wz fle et net ge * os a eet ae : eee , t pe 3 y ¥ Me Abd Spee ee , _ Ee oS a> i fe aa iD g ti a5 haven, er a7 a tod 7 i a o ek " i , py . Tra L on sheet uf wh f%, a ga as at tS a4 we + ere med aa ht | . pene, ope pho o Ye "ry 4 hee # ay . et a ye "Lat nf a a3 ae aS pete re 4 ' me - re aot £ % see ae bed, ao ae reed ce ort nod & "ab ve tees Fi Be mo ea eR oo, hy ay pot Soe ie GF eet heed sind ie eee é %, a vied oe ' Z ; vie ee o vers : aed on "t oy fy GB ae ene ee OS es we m "et '. shed. " "snl 4 = et ye Saat weed sy . at Snel cade 5 ry ro4 rr . 3 ¢ hs % £4 fr Fe 3 ns grt "cmealt 3 oe ee a won ons we 43 'net feos wood 'aed re ' . ™ ms we ay 43 ~ a 7 ¥ pen 23 Py ye feet Lage a2 on Ba e 4 A Le re oy Fibeos BP ty pete, . 4 "ys Nee ried Z Le Foal "eg pee wees omy ws wont cs Cp ind * es mt hh a ~ oS wens tent he re ii ci ay Tet ct ma "tp me a ; ch ne ' 3 aaa ad L. ty heed het Saban a £0 3 . a w% a ct oe, fo 43 7 'oF oc a "ata re sot Se, tee a4. 4. e a aor D m3 Prose, , a woes ben ™ PO teed ey Be ws y ae th oo a Bi et a te aay SPT Saaece aie th x hs ad cd a " vo "14 £3 ; * 0S 4 es eee 4% * ae 4 i; 'ae ne, etn mR co be 1 fo 2g BB #2 Bw ve mee i 3 we , ies + ott Bb ag . al ie as ha La ae? x ft ao whee oad wee me ; Jee ete tee wow" OE A, he : ba , a3 ga a ot tet hae ya ben ren "ea tk ant he tou, ee % ts peed th Ca. re , On 4 one poten, / " ee) oy f ob eee a 4 wee 4G 4 wn of 4 ad Be oe Few vee £ pet 4 no, deo Be, rene, ead ae na Jee Be 'eat \ ae Ly tg a os a we 43 ea feo Gs we 4 ig re ee a3 is ng Rs yor vied te nd rs * bet Fas we ~ ae a ° Cy Mm yee heed a ebioak ae rn ah wees : oe ae as "Aast : oe ge ween a w go vyed wt oo oe oak beeoes IN tes eed a weet wg & . St sheet on xs pa i bof % " i aes " ; a "3 $i vdeo oe v pot wy aes sons wot Se & of & 2 BS oe NS & wi MS os me a sow "hed seer wt £3 CS es + re eed ant ~. a "6 vy, £4 pes a ro ae Rend ve 'a ve oe So n. poet fe aa Jeo . ad w " a "nad fos 4 anes, ae Mane sae w 4 tener ws a 3 ws ay ced he Ms aoe ek one we how oe ene ¢ wet Ve a "et, 3 2 t ; . ae 4 me oe ead al nT ae: af ot ws 4 oe ; At . ts fet ' hoa Be , Pan Nes om . a 3 eee "hed ' ¢ wt is Go& 8 wp «. -« TF bes eS re ts ; e 3 43 os we ¢ wee en, oe pe a, 5 Se ¢ pod * ot awe % 4 ie Ae at é a oS cr x Roa re 7 Mw Cael ais 2 : ots wah * aed é se 4 5 net Apr . took o poeek, . oa 7 3 oped, at 4 oe 6 of TS es ® i F 'on a: ek ee Tamme ee a he Ly ee " , o "en hoot eet yo re as '" by "he bob , tay; 'sal m cere Sag ; Fs Tne, mf CR fp Heng ans oa ee ee Cs Fy * oo " gre fa hes yo, aA oy 'het 3 ba a ne te fea : a ws oa todo "ad? Wy we need "ss - e é wee ge 'tat 4 ih Feud % i , aap fetes red Oy 2 a pied ans 4 4 eet es oye ' YL? L285 7 he ff" ork fy wy "hee eee. 4 oe, id : yee et re oP Ife , a aoe Fes ye ¢ % ns ateee BOK tt , ae pet fe + 4, ee nn nn on ry OE wees: "dor gute ee A feed? "3 ri at 2 'ee vert ee me tea 'ted fet hos rh ba nal ae Sed oe sos pe a ved af nk > pe et "sel! ret ae, 5 2 ars saad Ae "
tat font eed, ee a, 4 eb ns theod Daten, ; when ct oe oft Lo ob : . el vs oS ron wed s aa « m wk oR gad a Nat Wed a ze eg feot og aS we wy & We net verre "
ees: on Sen, wget 3 % f & i net eet ae ia Sad Sane * ss To av. A copy of the fudement shall be By % o eo pee beg, ot mh COTES Yoty oN , 4 aT SOY rege erry Foy qe ¥ WEALD SOLE RS LEN aay , PES at Ry Yond: Woes 3 oxy eee Py ake wh eye nd ges Le owe ener a, shan Let the lower Court 3 eoords be semi oto the farthawvith.
Sd.
Be handrashekha r, 3o
- gage besa . roy (Ratiaker Bhen era, Jo) encode {(Ratnaker Bhesngra, J.)