Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai
N T Shindolkar vs M/O Finance on 6 March, 2020
h O4 No ZOi ey
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
MUMBAI BENCH, MUMBAL
ORIGINAL APPLICATION No. 2611/2020
Date of Decision: 6° March, 2020
CORAM: RAVINDER KAUR, MEMBER ()}
Shri N.Y. Shindalkar, Age 64 years,
Son of Tukaram Gundoili Shindolkar,
Asst. Commissioner of Central Excise
{Retd}, residing at Room Wo.102,
Building No.B-14, First Floor,
Ashivana Kalpav Estate,"
Antophill, Mumbai ~ 400 037.
Cell No, 09869454073
maid mandkumarshindolkar@emailcom. . Applicant
i®y Advocate Shri Fishal Shirke }
bersux
Union of India
Through the Seeretary,
Ministry of Finanee,
South Block, New Delhi= 110 001,
ered,
2. Central Board of Indirect Taxes
and Customs, Throngh the Chairman,
North Block.
New Delhi -- 110 G01,
tad
The Commissioner of CGST & CX,
Audit-Il, 8 Fisor, Lotus Info Centre
Near Parel § 'tation. Parel (East)
Mumbai ~ 400.012. . Respondents
ORDER (ORAL)
When the was ceiles out, heard 3 Yishal Shirke, Lesrnecd counsel FOr She OF oolat of Aadrmksston. TIT Favs &lSo osrefuliyv eons through the record.
= oy 5) ;
el (4 qi ws ey wig ce er as beck aa 3 neg teal : orf = as mY nat, os 4 oa re, A / a = ti ® a we i a " o ve ' en red te, a 3 HO oe wet "a ee eget 13 8 ow wy 4D @ pooch ed OF oe hd ee oN fete re good ie Cpe po Wo a oy "oe + £ d 2, :
rd ee oa Re Qt ee oe zs ua . 3 ay Phe Coe 4 pt RS & oe i eyed :
. ors a wa ok $3 sf 63 teas. it oa * yet O96 Ty cs a ae q oe & eee! wor s ap me ts wY "4 Gd " Peace) Bes AD Re Eg 3 a & wd if oS 42 Lt : SI vent "ped a ks ' oh. * aha @ go 4 S we a oot a bee oe Sob be & ra at a : Ms ha a GB bye oD fgg 0 wen " po Ao ma mo i ad "yy 'nthe : 3. 4 4 a a ; - nerd. fe, OG #l See es Fey 1 om BH eg oh 5 ee IS , cr Bona G25 " meg x va mm it as wn 4 ~ tp. a aes Es Bee as o wo i ra a z A g SE ee OY eo AG OS oe th and ae a + oe tn oy ee BES oS a £2! 4 .
ith) we "et % ° ' es aoe ST 2H ne. gt ms ot x in Meee aes ud et sod Oe 2S Sc A eo oe * ~ cee we ba a (4 Qos py A 3d me 3 B a oy is) SS te te 7 On pee EE wo URS oe fot e + ft Cn ra ox ose mp is Mos By Ee a 4 t3 bee "es cae a Bos a5. 7 428 Ey os at iD 4 mS , Be hh eo me Ce EE: 43 woe 4 7 £4 & et; o mm mm oe & oR bore et = ay ae pi wi to ws $4 aed © a uo eS te Oe oe re ae BoE we, pS S ~ Oe 4 fee Q . LL @ ie og gee 2 es ye wt eS a eh a yo OMe ok ea te & = yp Ee ees a 8 id 4 2 oa * ot wera ST Bh Se Oe Fae] i Mee faa 5 et 'af ct ¢ ae wo @ PR om Be EZ28 8 Ss Been 22 S os fe ? E i ee) 4 2.57 2 eh tn "a Ge s = mn ® ' ba 7 ; Ss 3 BOR TS Sg 3 @ et £3 4 . ie "$ hg ps or % tty ga Os 3 sy , fy te io Ned hand cc e uy 3 Ht me a. geo 2g a eo ge UO ee Seog 8 it sy Poca ae "ee J aS fy he on we od pe vo ae i : : wt ke ¢ ot = . BS. fe j # > in #23 S38 28 5 Sug ego uw == & Bo Sy ered (a 2 B a5 Bae me wy os £ Sg O a R ao. % Bee = €8 %¢ ps ny Fh ge as wed Pa wa 3 nee tS 3 6 eG 1 OR aM o Le or, §
a) ' tae - @ 4 Gd den get mF ee TD 'mat IS soe! ' Ser : ba a ff 828 6. Bee Ee oA yD Pog ed "
a SS Lt O F@QnH8 Be SE BR eG i te a " Dp S 4 4 ; 5 ee Bo Be Bos ¥ "oy ps ' 5 i % a © ® ens EE peBEES e & £8 OO :
fy wa week od & oe & BE 0 wf is Ss 3
- od cf Cy Sh : 1 te S ey " q ' Fa Me vat 4 gt hf ae os Fa wet w> wed oC eo Pat Peloh bey ont ceed hd 4 fewe OSF i) 4 wey im, g a 8B G ° Q i q ' fed : reed ty Sats aa @ ch oe a a iS vat wha o * 4 art ro Dhed Pray r3 iB . Oh ieee fal $3 4 a 3 ane het os : ' iD eg ved es gE xy hl %.
Bo ew on * on ; 4 , ity o Ai 6 £O
i) we <4 C3 pe - -
mm = ON ry a AS @ mw ge yy SS ha cst a os tel GS wv a m C3 re) ns a td Or q 4 as ms @ G wh 3 ae Fig ' pf d ad gt ag oi G3 ood 5 mz } 'af GB w 4 ne sy ces ee on a a at 'gel Py B / ph 2 G = oy 4 fol 4 ae qi ey oe Ke ha ve S A? b4 . rd a r at "Sn a Me wed 7" 9 ch nt Lee ss C3 44 3 7 td ¥ ty 4-4 ad oy aa " WwW Po SOG @ aS St c 4 mi ~ "4 a x "4 . pes 3 ny it us) , ject 7 a: watt x ae rs An Mod ted "« af "6 a] ~ ce 3 2 ve @ Ml eo 3 ms td oS a 44 ct be gy a ms be, et = wy @ a oo e & ox "ed my ri rs ba ved : ee Wing, Aas i cy ct oS " = a ~ wep s C i oo ' Ly ie Ret AG at p me men p 43 qs & a « os ~ oes Oo Ae i ce ' a iM eed we wy £ eat ne ig) p23 ~4 tent : Se pond t Li 4 .. 3 rea bes ws we ore a fan . fy, Ahh, we 4 . O $3 o ray Be ay oe on eed Co 2 8 es oa Aa ; re) co 3 of : co ny : By om o it " mt vel = ot ms j * wot 4 . sheng a mt ay ay FY : Pa , m a yt get [63 " ees wy 3 cry KF o mney oe oh ty ts gt re ¢ qd sa « Paing 5 "6 ' 4 rs shot co ot wad "o £ g » . a: my ey EB oo ae "
7 na @ 4 ved tl igh Poni hel rd a pom cof ' & iw Oz et peg He 4 ue > cS Ses me a ry 4 i Me Q Vv ie y a mf ay on c ; : :
wt wo ko is 7 : (s , i : = Ni i ¢ > c a } 3 on Ad od ze et i ot 3 hy - s : wees Ms wD ard 4 ey . fd wee poh > "ay % co > $f 4 w th 2 3 mae C cs gt " seed i Sa det ord my 3 at ¢ M H oo kecg AO ke wo wong rs oi . . 4 tA 6 rd 3 ms i C a i a Ss a ot n & on 4.3 a ss & fl ; Bo te iB os oe ey . . aa DB a % ke ") ' , 4 oh wr as et f~ fs a oo 5 ey woe @ nS faa Be bo ~ me j DB ne $8 oe ot hed So . es "ey ry Fh vd oc Ps x co wed 2 a a Sy a | na ; 3 nd hy wy al eho © Coe 8g lg BO a Pr ga pea os Ml . oe whet go ap wet to Nol bey, 3a 4) went oj org 1 S "i Bd pal : 7 nt uy ay oe ated, Lye » , . LS a ls 7) Ot iG ab " * ms aa S ret i" 4 fey f ad Gg "s ' C3 a 3 ett ei ky 4 BS "a ae 2 oS Le +4 + wn BS ~ r 5 "ne? 5 "b oa) G 63 ae @ Ae " a) if} : ; crs fog "A ae wy G per. © cs Pings: hw CO iG 1G Rs Ibe ° oe i} : 2 ec Aen Sone, Ee real so v we gh f 4 'ena 7 ' toed w on 3 te cot Saad i Qs aa a ete in Q i be is me ps cs ad S $ a do be g cf ; Hed aS ony ite bea veg . a ; & s og rs se Read Ds Oo TS ge Q we t a is ne a3 > : Lat a j " * : ' ~ oo . g o f GC § 6 £ * a SG a § coe & 8 ° a oO 8 ca tei Q wv i oo™ rAd "i (U3 . r 4 - ad ; f £, ton } py .y ew ® mm wm fh s wl ons ays a" . <r Eg io we Aa ut ay 3H wes QB te ay "4 3 { ke a) oj nf ; Md 2 iS rt : i ae -
is ' * r ny a "ef a a i a ~ im ref if i ge dt a tae ped bodes hy fey me ot ae : | : uv £4 = OR " =" I bed " a 3 a ef é. Sd ae ad a 'Se ™! DB Ne ; ise rer) a ad os " , ot > ws i i Fee Cf ith " a ae on o w of mw wom meg) Som gE wf ae B ei xed , hE vod fond aot ww ret "4 4 a at ; cd ia " ay 3 ma & ond nS oe "ea " a i Bs "oa 4 . * f e " > iat yes "eg os 4 et & ry a re eo ay g wee Ps x a eS s 2) be of w as whet i' "ee be ott 3 yen x % £4 ' zed 0 eS tL BR es G % oe ge et Fa oi "ait aa whe 4 robe { vag to oy £ ws a 2 i} pot Mw . & "i mn det ee hy Ld a wed ~~ 4# fen £ / oF os aA . is) z 25 a ;
af ng a FS eC at wen CS oy 4 Lin} oO - ee C 4 é. ee 2 4 ot dit pet 4d i ¢ n od Ss ws eke 4 we ™ it rn 3 cal iD a i3 me "oS Ad wy ws 3 % > me fe $4 da Ba Poo i a # me © " cee aed se eed r a : o G iy cS. sy £ % $ 4 #3 @ p ae ut OQ rage " 3 4 op "5 pe a oO ike .
Soe & om 6 eo # ae i.) ee GG od C : $4 ob 3 * i " aa ref os So & SB _ 8 c » "met! ~ i cc ae o HOS car wt fe fn hat t gh 5 f us Gs é mo we "3 Ms 4 a fe . Yor. a ced w , *% Y "tt on hes n 4 OD oh "cS ay oO Hom 4 o3 & ay bel xt 3 ch ved ed es ™ *. - ' ron : » ' nd bf i <4 ie: 4 ong ad qi @ art @ ad Wy hd tie " Ci % 4 ect iy rye oy wz ms ¢ es bd 'Lf "A a 6 5 OS a ed aa we oe ~ ty a ve Q mt woek 8 ie ~ os ws Bae at a nt ate abt {% 4 Mae 'es oh, si a fe os 45 Ao ved " Ra 5 My oh gt ES ji a 6 #2 = O cs CMe Pc & > a i 1 i 2 oy 3 x " M3 tl a a © iO oo Boge ay ved iu ' zB oe! nee roe ' oat v 6 EB 5 oO os ef we on: 5 bE fhe as Oe. c " ' "4 & ow v eo 3 , a Oo en ° Q et ef 8 Gg & Ge = i sgt , a a ne oq ne os .
rt ~ sos fo at : 4 Ch go a Hoe © ra oo s vp my 55 oS "4 ° weed oO p s oe ee ce £5 * eee ned > i went * i ica a my t4 wet p co S " Moo i es m4 woe ped oe) = 3 ; co Q = c O z 6 Poy Oy . ol o~ ren .
: red gt Soy 4 ;
o3 . eed es w@ lef rey a Nee? mt ors ra . "~ oe - 1 oa go { = aes 4 us hea 4 a . Se, wef beet ae : ; ' pet fh ood 2 ty Se my rt nd det it fed a) ces ve ad : mer mo a yh ' oa tt Py ore SS ; & = . " byte IS Ue Oe ee ot 2 U8 + wy " + a! Noah NS " ie 3 oy Re va oa c v4 on id O SZ mE of os cs oo WS a} 4. era on : : oot 23 ree A Se ote Yen fy bes Sa "Pie ied * hy t us ar ~ a) ci a ceed tee nk oY Nt 5S 43 Qo OU UO Bo te m4 wi . _~ s & mS i Ge. 2 SS cay na = gy SS ub u bere 2 "ae ee Y ai % f Mo oR RR "ty oe ae o oS Beg MS a Co 6 a4 cent ae Fan ay BS i ot S ss x3 a J ~ i . wo va oo we = Se % i ve oS wie is ' gy Pat ei C deed bod bey a os ie a wot Eom oe 3 4 { mh Stee my nat so . va nad as st ij thd "Ep tee Om cs wv Se ae Cy, oI oo oH te Bg CO" = ved :
B GSS dy oni pa SB 43 " i bea es yn CO om OG aed ' Ch i ae : 3 x oe 2 os rs a4 oo a Pe eS OY ae ot C3 hy SE Pe ry i py aeaad io bass - es a o rs Pe ao st oo tea om we RS o ax it be Gh eh o bey rt oS o> Tone ue me te ~ ¢ 3 pon ° ve Sr of agrees aN rr = 2 * Se se & th , wo 7 Poet rt ™ Roo FD o 5 SE & 44 i . "oh ao we Bs zs we, ch ff & Ae Cs oy "te cope 4 ; PA a OY ~ & ar as Mt we Of @ a e Y a am : m Soe YB om = wee ct ot = iB oy coe ned Gi ng ES sy a ee, x Wey 1 ge wd * eh send ci ry on i 7 oF oe Sn at ae
-. ve, a 8 S 7 * a) * ting " eh * cc 4 ™ ey ag Dy ct a £3 ws a3 SO, OG et ae ned ve 7 post f- te, SA, es, ' an rs hey oS top : a " on tegme Re OSS OR Tut oh it)
7) xa ? x eu oe 0 obk, { 2S 3 . ; A * , t 8.0 OS . a * . oa & ? O Be AS et & s oe WP Md hb = iD ves ~ rd . = eS ~ y S fe ES md O o au = m M4 oS i hei mB om OS ce Le & ny i 4 = ~ a iy C5 a' RM Yo Ra Oo De te} vs Rees. Z, a fat rae ' e G , t. be C3 pe SS rag oe en am nie cs Ot 4 Oy ped ct et c, oe ee ce a us as bp ind ia CS 2 wed rt me ty" SO Ped , bed x pM EN ~ PS wa a icf 4 'ad By ' on ait 5 = Gy 2 cp A wy be 4} fe 4 veg Sy a pi ee, OE hd hy 2 * £ oy 4 oh ot pet "ay Ms. eae mt ¢ te ey OS yt > . ~ "f i & pe Re $e An. , of i oh + o om f su 5 tn, {fh ld feos wr ee cat Teh eed bet = ie VP " mo hey es eas oy 7) tel 2 c i a le re geod C3 ee ' nr a 2 3 by, he $ SN aS te UY med nee erg MY Epo Bogs or rhe eas . wes ms "2 Ct, wa EO oe x oo QQ ix] oe ces oe fe ag tL 2 ca mo OS Bee i fr SB Te mtg re / ire ne Fe oni bo Of} rR we hs, ne 3 ud O " cn #5 ; anf 4 BE fe. a Saw " - : $ at .. BY we = a my "a O 4 @ = CS os ~ ea mM my ug SG os a "3 eS" NG OQ ms 4 A ort aa Baas) ty RY Ze os me 4 aa = QB = vl pony SO EE BE oe O G fo be = i "rm "tS v oh ' os aad had Vat Bad we eo Ra ti we OS es : 2 me . te A 4 7 het. Na ip Be A, BSE oe our Bag Bh o Go # 6 Sp, Baw & FEC Bk ae SS OC es i we ss © ag Ga 2S Boe oo Pemegs f 6 as me a yn. : xa ea " 4 5 om RE OO SS vB Pmt & og we +E stb se of 3 ty I OS os ms "t oa bet 64 : iD 7 SE ee "gh ohne * 9 OS S os i Bs "4 a 2 a wt SEBS me OS OS 6 » Bee fod C on ce ie bd wy Ws a." US SR Oy Te S ft ' fee ty rod opt Se Bm, th "ee Vt sg an a oe 7 7 t 7 oy 5 ~ Saf 4 os set "i, o es a ey © td C opt Bog ed C2 a4 'i wf 3 ie es S Fa . i » a oa
4 ' 7 ' oS , C aon) m2 a « u el o is 3 mi OS a Be & od hy I : ey se > wh Sets at red ae) = ; we ae ; mm ra bao tO, = te , H sy 4 " Ma t A , 'ee = eee ¥e
-. tA mm oD 4 Oy oy 5 22S ee eo CR a heed et re j ae 4 * b Ry Und aes $5) +h my ee P ® eet YG 4 " ped ra m 5. 44 ws w pane ra) x prod i "anal rs * . t toed 'a os G ie Oo 6 oe ob o ae v3 pe ng ~ be oe s Gs a a on hou ON hat $3 S45 a w ci : : npn 4 es . ed © o S ry et BG @ a seo $4 ic 4 4a Mee Mee tay A , ee) eS a OS ie) (4 x s ts ga aed oS fey we ORG ti pe hea ee 5 SR oe Se a ha « CG wi © Bea ogy vie NS BS we ios _ Pong QQ So wi RE 'es "ay Cs bs 6h aoe. ™ es ea SO eS O of "% wee Fi us be Be on. SE Ry fe ips ad es "tee ss tre god fen MR gp es 2 "t a . ee a : on PR ae ok Oo oa] eo 3 me wi ae OS Boog o a a3 Set 4 oA, wea ee ; 6 we tea in, ~ oa x 8 MP th "hon ze ~ ed aA es B rack ee < ru fa. + Arges ' , A Oh py 22 8, S ne, . S , eho Be DP go & SS = ie ' . ror co " tn oo Be & we BOS an ths Oy weed % A 3 S om Be ee fl te ree ' w oy OPE ; a aan rh y oo & Pat od = % ny tet XS me Oe Deo a Sy of ue . weet mo AY tes + AR a cid ay cs a ioe me wd je So em eS o rw iB & w ee Bee ORS : . . . Py = © ao Roe o tm s oe = a "3 peo fy Ee Ned we, "ed be O 3 $e ge Re ie sn et : iowa OTS ny 3 7 Mee ORR: on ts 423 oo Bn eee et 4 t my be TG ae ta ¢ « 4 Bm th 43 Het a Nt 'hens ib SA co "at igs Sn ny * wk, if : ; ; te "4 mh raed Rok ay Ss Ae is, » & 3 bo © ° (Se Roe sof Lo : oO me ae "a ta PR ge ND : 4 4 25 = o 4 ty BS UT SS oa O Ay " 2 Sp BEAL o 8 g oo @ Bea, 3 =~ * % a " ¢ ey te ae w * PA, t a cad "a m the yok Pad: Se "ht ws vn o - - ky ca) i ee x By he choot ot os mo Ry as x 4 > ~ é ae wae ¢ te Do ort & Se, & Oo . 2 Bom 8 3 2 Petes € "he vt mn - 'Tn, pe he 3 & BESRS es ° 2 5 . s
--" ' . ® ie = 7 Se S4 ; & Pe 2 ee > Co Gey S a ie a Ge a os ss . Cy ty Se = Oo OR s. ; = ros eo Og wy Cy oT Moe oS a mo hed a qt + Fan % he poke. ies 7 et 4 es a Sad oie Sy " Le ont ve om st . My te et 4 on SB $ ~. it ea cine ae , SO mS i "5 (3 MM i" By % So ow OE or x ae ad 2 Oke reo fe ey gt Ss "P io uy oe ss ; oy t mo eee OR oo as ue Ms 7 cS AS nee ee ter Net . w eo bos a ee eos . brea: a Ry, try eb is oy 4 Oo it wy Re MR IG oh =~ a wo we RES ER ee Saas he "4 gh wu a, Men WEY tee, ie? A a vyeel i Sl te CEE Re 3 oe Be Se eth & pS 1 : ooh era wel tg 8 tae Fe & ee fs ° res ay Re oS * O48 gS es i geod Spee MI fee Bey & St 3 SM Ng a od mee bate me eS oy hed i oe eg . 4 See eo, i Co a) : aD "nd cs fa TR pt SE my n he @ may Ge Bos Oe 3 oy uA vot wy thet 3 wee hy a Bee Bows Soke ct a : 5 ee LO SS a ben a G a, Me sl. 2 SoTee Pe Ry fe et 22 ' ao] 4 Po o& og op $3) agg BOE Be Te A as o © S&S es BESS eS Gg A ae ve Ee ag me PS TB CES @ 6 wt a ater? 5 oe . 4 7 Yn Wren te Pe, ro ty Sea ee oN Coa oa 4 ee wong: Be x. re " mt i oY { 3 OE ot ae og, Re 'a! phos ell os bey my ~ M om ty. "ey S tS mf ° va Geta oY me Oe 3 < 7 :
.. Cal <2 " meme Ef mF sod . et . ; CRD ea ee AS RE RS ae cw) 3 j SR OE O ' ve m wo ue Be EE So Oe 5 De : i u ; 4 Be} ras eof os a Sa OS ni Soe & Q ~ 5 : "A mo ny TR OS & e . So £4 ee: ip - S as, e 'path pie pe OR, RE ke ne oo . et wt ts me a, * irre ees" , pe BS yin pores en reks C % 7 Me , pep . " ; : Pa 6 a > 44 O ty ' 4 a s y ae as) Kr oF un rw 'ot © 2 iD mt yy x 4 a os Ow ret u ev ue a os ed rf ro Ae ia $4 Le Ee w an a ed a Ts ht od hed red " 4 ¥ ey cet ery Sq cca a Sod orl ie ne, et eh pee me y of o tht ; , "et "4 woof eS a ot oe jal
"4 wae 2 Ot rod ee Py wt fda & O ct 5 £5 4 i iat oy bet 3 @ 4) ~ Or by cht st an Oo ay ot A ra " me o en me w a : : cS me eed a GB Sk By o @ rm oC me as ei ao fet ¥ a a t. : wre eo _ " Seal ' © 3 ri + 5 a ye © o Ge gt ce: a oD 3 co 1 no! 1 Jf pt a on ' co ay ™ © v4 ty es Me wed A OQ fs ' M oe © & yee ks - HA as Bord Wo FS Bs M oO ad ved g OQ 2 » 4 $4 w a 0 we a oe ' ™ vA "yy a re , ee on , co 8 . a i # f . y : pH O M e Me % 1 4 a ' M4 eas 1 ry a eo ot te wD a ' ra w ar ; od ie _ et oor oe wed ey a ee iy 'ant a os eng cs + @ a hey ae: 4 " aes 44 a a a > z Mf . a os cs ot ae + z mt a! ' ce oO ' ; ro a hd or Med & ai ' ss a OQ, ss 5 cs ; oe Per a e f~ a = wo $2, we iy s © it 4 a oy cs o 6 4 om oA 1D on t ? 3 rs % c t i ra o C3 a < v ' @ thd a oo m < j Go , we 1 74 t Ba Be i a Go u % ed aes Oh, mae , Ch Q on : wd " fi Ged rs) 6 ie 5 Fg eed os why a} Met oO Cy 464 ey " al ae
- £ * iT mo nh a Set haa La a es o ord a 4 o "a Me O fis} 3 fa a det a } iB * ee OS "4 Ao te og a "ow Shed & ka os 4 te oy o o 3 - al 7s ved oy ee: ¢ . ent vd a 0 wt (2 $e w oy a B "a ee
e) wy Y Dy bey - be io 4) a a is i es oO OO ge eS Be qo © a rn mn 3 HD oh, ws rt » a " # 4 % S ' 44 Vhs } 4 Oo oy A on ae im root go « oD oe 5, is oa - 44 bee 4, a . "Ay wa wR oc oy ' oH that « 1) wt @ bef 43 a3 y wy & sod . roan Gs ne Ae OG hb eo o 8 | 4 . © + eee rs Q v SOG A ae : s . * _ af a4 . . vod wy oS Sy hes <4 el a) ae) oa u a " on ved ey sy 4 bad "4 Se "ed Os uf sed fm G ww HH GS F PG om Oo tO a a eG ed me CH MS bd os +3 a ms :
201002 a.
a4 € iS hy pay rod 3 oH "4 he @
4) ift a hee i cn Kered . 4 eres:
id.
dat ed
2) ee:
@ 3 O ty arf OY orf os 'hed Be wed oh4 Z cn ng dt 3 Sones {Ravinder Kaur) Member (7) a te ' fo