Karnataka High Court
M/S Evergreen Seamless Pipes And vs Nil on 30 September, 2011
Author: Aravind Kumar
Bench: Aravind Kumar
Ln) !:;>;3ii<'%a:*sé: <;*<>:"1':§32::':§--' wzrzsés _i:':.::<'3:"p<>m§(iii >:;m 2%}. E. iE_..2éZ}{}'?' in 332?: §§5'§"ET§E'€?? {sf §*sZ;=z:°.:'z;-:,iT.a}g22; :;:':'1'<.'Ea.:9%V;_~--. ;:m;:v§::;i<::§'1:s =:.:>f ::.h.é;:= Aati {'Z€:~:":éfE<?2:z:'i<;~% of E::':e:':§'s:<';:§:..a_;?a.§'i.{f:.:j§ «é'i§''.ié'§ "
'Fv§é§'n'2<>:_*z~m'":dum zzmii A:'€.é<%E€&3 (2.25 13:$:<5<}:':§.:»ai;jE{'m ;3g;3A;§€-:n'c:i::s:§ figs V i.E':.::r 2';:p;,}§§<::1:;*<m at ;'§_:'3:':e_xu E3;2::'§__ %z'*:::*:"s_§2é}:,;':y wag i:':<é<>r;3:):*2;1§:£é<i iii} c::1rr§;' :':§:z1~~..";§_,§1:=.*fb::_$§:*:§ of" :_n:_:=2:".: {E fé2§s:':t.:.: :"i:1g;, bz::y:E.:'::;;j§ ~:'%?a€?§i2'"3§~,§ Eifid {<2 "2173" s:':§~i:s4*i'.:"ii;'Ei:__2:7~:[.::f2:':~:e;1 21gfe:":§:s., i§fz1p<}_r§'.::-rm; 2:u';cE' {3';%=:"k::*€,c%%..°s§ =i<}§" E3é£z:uf:1}%:$»sg;...Pi:§:>e:=s .2m_<:§; '§"uE3:;=:$ w<~:*.E:E€r.e:§_;'§'ah%'iV{:21§._t%:i 2i%i73.:3:§'i:g;:§_A {_3%i§3:{=-2:" "g:>§é"§a%<::£.s; 2:55 mxviszageii Ei2'.1;{i{E E" : :h<% _§'§'E«éi%,_:1:}V:*;3:.;"s{§--1gm a:_'1e:fE E';:'i':1E_s':§€3:::a {>15 Asss:~;<;<:i2::.'i.:<;n, Reg-_§§:&;;E':<;t:"<é*é:3;VV_ <:§_§~fi<:é:t <2? é:§1v:j_ é,::_p §:~E£é:*2z1i:i. <'*:<::;m;::;';m3;= is; :+;;Ei;:..;.::i;§:':{§. at ?%E<>f?Z?;'?" }%Zverg:"e§%:': :§:_<>:T:ss2:-1; 2*" Fax-"§'a§:L (?§'1§I§<;,§§i;:_Ea:a:g.:2221.22%}:
;i;g":§;€;'::%;.€ §f}§§{3«._._?3{:s:e~;€:,g {}§'fE' E"ir3:~:s'L2;" §%;e::;:';z<,'§, E:§;'mg;,:a§<i>r«<;: ~ EEEEC: A {K'-
V A ; 5, " Sim :"::,% {:;2:.;_3.%%:.;';2.E ::::~:f %i:§':2:%: :,_%:i2::'1:;>;m§; £25 s:%§'..;I:i.€<.§ aé; §':§';;:.§*§z:;;i'2:§}E:E i§»E%{:;_:§ 5'}? EE;:: ;;§'}§>E_§_{:22ai:£<:::"*:E E;;..'§'§:2T'fE§§ a»m=:"§§.§£:.£§ ~ u 'E';é.:?;§.§g':z'_':<'_::T-_=;\: gs? 2z'§2§_§;%<'%2;z..::§'i: {':(f§i'E'"1i§i}£fé§'§ ::§::.2.':é.ia~:t 22;'; ézis» _r/ 'E' f3L¥L"§£:%,2{}} E. :'~:§1{::ax-*i:':§; t:.E":€ asgssmts; zmgi E.i;.i%3§E'§'i'§s3s~: are %;E'r':{:E<;}sse:%d 'ii'; 'i'.h§:=5.~: £;2pg>'§i:7a~2.E:i{;§'1 255-: ;':=~€::' Ar::2e3§<:a::'€%«EL} E)» 3., 4%. §%<:;n'{:§ cf <.i%rz;=<%€.:::s:'s%; <::{ ''{:%.2:;? :';».%}E§§}'§§€?.§3§'E.3§.. :i§,3::'i;:é;.z'"zy' --§§:.2::~e5g éapgsraweai am<.% é1€.§{§§3»i',e';",{i 'ihizr $:%%::%':"§£%::__ Efiatzié itsa :11e:eE;i§";g;' heégi $2"; w'§j1*£::*.§;2:"_:
M ,1' 8 , F'v'§A$? S g3<3<::ia.iit:§/-" ;3;V_Ij'><3ss '.VE'}'i4'§x;?;§ u:E;i;i:":i?;§{:§ VV€"E':';?§%'a$§e:*{3r} ;3r<>pe:,s.s€:é is bf: E-"i..E'E'1£?9;E%?%é a:<?>::1pas1y $u.bj€tci; Eli} 2:z'g3'§f>':£:=;:f>€§?a.§ §~{@'z'1£t€; p§°%:%:-5;€::u.?E'.
ap}}§i<t;;:ti<>:'§ 11:3 «:;%<:,>nsm:':<2 'aha :3;::;%<1%i:§:':g§§ :3? f.5§-EE2§ff€%E'}..{§:E'{}:*.;T°§'$i§;,'H .8,/V ., *3 fi;i;"3g7;VE.%<.;3";_:»V':i. ;§-"::a§§ <ié8<:%§:,>:s:~;@<:§ 2:22! 2;:§a'§':::::*E3.E :§:'e1<:':'*{s§ °:"é3:E;%;E§2'1gé;A:3 1:::::';§::§g1§"2§;?":2;;:":<i €::§1a%rr;":§":>:*&-3 ii, ."§}£B{f{¥5;%-E%2§I":_! :0 iiaéé A*:§%}§=.;~33':Té::.::?i;§«:}§}: ;ifs.E.1-s;§122§"€§:{>§<E%'r.s§ <i:>§ a.;::2;::§§<:;2::2:: <':<';.m;§at:.:':§.2' in ;2:i:<":':;~2§f:§;;_:::;::3 .:é;a?§%;§': ;:s?<,>zr'i:eé:'::2$ <3? §T.2:::§:'2§:}2'::'.:i§:s: 5%£.:%;', §'{{'T':E'§€'.€3 E"
h ;:.;2;:;;<%;;%; %:.E'§5:-- §'s:>EE<>2s2§.:zg:
§ ER " ijT...z.%..;?..,?}'2{} E E :§E§<3w::<E;
V :em2.2;:*é:VsZ<§;;:: 21:1' ' ._ E , § 3 2 3 as 2"' "T " '-';L§<24:ma4%<3=V' ;:"3<:§'sé;zf::':;% §}§'€1E?:é{f%:?'3? ii: §;>€::.'s-»;{*:;§": <3? ;}:*{>:§y 5:»? e::%<;§u;%'£2; I-'%.p§}Ei<%é;2.§1§'. <'%{§§22p21:'3.y is; §V§s;T'*:'°§':1i's".tE's:-'.'::§ ii} hzski :T.h<.% r§"a{%a=%Ii§:'1g «$5 5%":a_2_'c%'2<>E<§e}*s 21%. 3.35} ?.I:=*§.. 02:. {E5} 12$ E. E. 2"E':<-"5 E'{f§_~__§i$§iE?.§"€'?{'§ <.>i'§Ez?é% 21% Nz}w?7;"'?8v "£*Zv&?z"g3;:"i?€::':. E'~§<:;a:':§§;e:%.'_";.2'i2§5 1"'v'E2~2i.:L CE3il§{.§£éi§Z1}{§}'Eé?i§é.:.E'E E;.2:§;:_:»:.:§. E'f}E£{f P<'33£-%--E ? "€}f§Efi-:fsE%s;3§*'T V' Rzézzéi, E§2?:_n;gfz.1E<1}r€r M 568 €f§2§} :: ='*;f<1i"<%-.':;'~.i;h::= {E'h.2;3;i:=§;:_127:.:Ts:§E*:§§5-- <3? S:'§£1i'E2-12mm': 3';/f<}h21zz:;1"2t%<i E3E";"a:Z f'._{f§'EiE"1§3;:L:.E"'%%1E?E_E£1 Q2."-.§:V1"~ hizts 2.§E}55s€*;E'}{?£~? Sr°%,S%1é??g_E§'h§:* '%_:'é2zc_:;%} «,¥§€'.f€§.¥j§pE4'i§"V\:'E1.§&3i,., {"Z§'1airzna:'": §'_sf§'1ia:%,__EE .%_'ss$zéé:=~ §'§:c§«i%a§g§:,:'afi:« ':':<;i§:;:«:*,s:é Hi; 2,:.I;.E 5;1«s.§:g1r€:§"::::.1{j'E<:%i"$ EE?r§IV'_§5i:)§§§,i.._};2§.§'T1§{.""§?(:3IE"§'§}_5jT§3"'2:£ :1"::3§1€.i.<>§':i:1;;' éémt {f¥;2:aé',.a%,, ----:i:~:'vm:;§ ' 'gf:a§:{§': E~2"::::£;7: . 3:57 EH g%§>g}Ei{f;:V;'i€', _ {T:€:.>i'i'1§:E§.Af:}_7 'i:?%}§é:?;§§ 2:%§S€} iizzigaé <:}:.:*é. n«:>i,%<:a% $5 :2'§:;%?et:i:1§§ §'i.'}.'" 33:53: §%;§{';:': :3? "E--§é:'}{'§1.z";. .E<2:1g;:_Ei.se}1 §"j>a§E.jy-1 ' «7'S;m§'%:.:%::TE:s.a §{;;:r:':a£;;:*&§2.§1 §§22n:"::'§2.:{E;=;: éiaéigi {Ki 0:" 'E:;&::::%'£'i;§:"'é:
.3' .' .v .,
-3:: :€;.i2§,} E V V §,}é;:§f::':;.:§é' 5%' E':E:":§": :'m%s:E'.§§':.;.; <52? E%E'E§§ii"{E§E{§§£§§?E'E% s;.§'2z.:E§; Ex": i~':t«-E":z%.;;*{f*:§'§éiéaffifisi; z1:s:§" %E'§:§E.'§§%f%if§"{Ei? §_?.=:";§*,::§}:[::'2y, §.:a:"{:};>;}«' ii": gr-M' =2 €25 'i"§'}.<:% §3§'<iés<:ri§<3€<:§ ferry'; aiuijg f§i§32_;§'1£'.{'§ 211%? 'ighé:-.*; &:}":;»2;"::E'mE<%z3:.' égiigiié be? e:'ia=:g;§<>si;a'§1:9:i at: i'.E":<: 'f':'2m$§'%;32='éi:£é <;'a}:':':g:2~3:'1}-' rim} §2;:z'.:::§f '£23222': E'1<:;a.:r&.~2 be'-.=:§1:::§:7 EEK? fééiiiéi .'£§'Ti€;T'.€iiE'Eg;;:. £3. {Ti}":a%':*m2m 2'-:=;:h;2i_§ s5a;'::smf:.i€;', 2'-1 mp<>rt. £1}? éZif2'i§.:. z:*é€:&%;::'§:f;§g-.-- ~ *«..-5.;-*i£hi:2 13% :i2?;j._:-3'; E?LfE'€f3T E'.§%":<3 {ii{}§'§{';iE.1$§>§A{Z'3?£iE {if §'f§':€:'. ':'f:iz:{§§;:%:.i::;1;g§_;A jmi §}€Eifj.i{Ts§'} '%.x;,it.E3i:': i.E1re€ '%.F%,.?"¢i;§€:"f§.§';:'-&=':«..,§§"'{,"Zt}7§'1" *€iE_1%:r eziazié:""'<7;;'.Vf§:E:.i.':'3§; £34? E%x2§'}<}ri: by Chéiifffiélii <3? tfhe §§*i"<';%.;<.-§%.i:é:-:;%:}T§.f._,§. §%.ppEi.:.::2;:':'3E'. stem pzmy is; at 3.i;%f_}t'f§.'?§:s?3 fig') fiE€r. 'i3:>':'np;i§:=:jg[ .' %%§p isx '2'z§*<§§$§e%>>A . =. «Na