Central Information Commission
R K Jain vs Department Of Legal Affairs on 16 October, 2017
x {IEN'E'EML .i§§?{}§{§§3¥f§§i\f {RENE} :' Emfi fizmr, '13? Wkth Angina Emmi fifimwa} 'mixag'i {lama images, New Else'ifiiii "mm "m : +§§§J £«2éi3fiifi35 fipjgmai ms. emissmgm mmamm figpeflam;
Fitmmm W i: 3'; {3:} ¥ it}; flank {if 'iZk-éfemw CQEQ:£'1§",_ magma: ii {EELEB "{ 1'. J Rewunfiem: ' Senna}: _E3'uif;§.;i§: imtfaxmatim: Gfiimr a {if Law Justice; Dapm imfiemb Ream Re. 5:438? 'A' Wing?
:13 R32} Bituéiwafly 2:33: Regé'eéz'zdm Emacis NM Ema:
Base, :35 {3'33 £35, < I?"
Dafi'mai {3f Bmfi-Qiem: {ESE} J33 ' 213 3. "'3' V fiaaw:
L The §fi,1§3:§}€fi§§£3.§it RTE ezzggpiia-mmn BEGISLEQiC-i s-mzkéfng infcmmmiam: iffia} {:an anti (flax? mmmm' umfim' 'Whifith :i'fizgxfssentafmn '3 L, ifmm. §}3'E1C'{E'ii{.li'§.§if tiémaiezfiiams Bangimr': making: Examziemm: fey mmmg mnwmm gas-tifjxm against him. {IE3} Mm {iami'ss a? the. gamma an the". mgr wem'tsfiion amfi {it'ggzifizs "(ff ail {mm fiifiififitfi anti {33:'1'64833011dmime Fifi E'eiaii'imz in {he i'ifpfsfiSfiilmfimw mic. gig-ted {if-£53 'ifiéspmzrimi {m 13%.63'. ififl-EB that the m RQE'Qéfiscgfii :13 Km": {l'éiCEQEZZKfi' m '31:": reca:mt§:.s, aAp'gsafiagim med gap (by; iilém-flzifi-m «aim Firm quizirim-m'ity FEW" rmmwdmfi on 236%332813 'ugfihfl'si'i the .{ifjfiifiii'fi} of {ii-733$}, 0338953 fifikc}, magma {m C:3.1§.3§3§3 befam the. Cmmniigsism on 131:3 grammi thafi. iiifflfmaiifin 333013.181 pxratsviésd m Etzmm flaming: . W_ 3% . ..
W» ;- .. n M am {is E3 w am i i 33~ REE?
(133$ ' "In-an)"
"' a; u' ' grkfiiiv§3i§>"~f"'"" ' .... ,. V 2 V. H w, ; Tum; _\ H. 3" V . H .
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ \\ . . . . . . . . . . . . ..
him {we-:1 i223. Exiles zagmmi 3p~ecia§ly :zfagues'fizaai fin"
1.\ pamama'fiy.
*'Em 'i'lhf: mifiefiaui'. mat he: hats fifzmi RE? & mafia-:1 with $133 {3? j} * ¢ PE _ .
Qfo Li'i. Sceiicimr Gamma} {If inciia {$331, Bfifiifig but :13 E'fifififlflSfi "x h}? Eats}: {is '91 {I}; 3; ft;- Ls: 3 3:'$2t';tt:,iw-:C§ . f'iikafi'Vffi'; fiat: Ifii}.€}_§ 'WI'QRgEy anti. ifitxgafiy 'i'rmm'erz'éd thaagyeEiant'S RTE agpiicafiixm 12:: m: {1?};{3 , 3:3 13:35; 6:23} a? Am 'Ei'na CERPEC} Life Raga} in t?31'1&§éfi'~ififi8§ ciaiihm'mafiy and maaizfiiiieiy wmcegied Em fact {a haw x whim. aim {BCEiV'rBii this: RT}. agzgéifizatien; which migimfl'g" iiisd with the {JFK}; 0;" s3- 8&3: 115%? Ekzihi.
.aipgia'iimzt Smmfi that. {Eu-2 CRO, DEG by listmr , 1,3823%}.3 transfermzi aggspsfimzt's: impiimtian bark {a (swig, '33 Again? stating that: fix: marigstr 3f the RTE" aggfiiceztiim mars:
{:Eflssfiy' mimfié is {he fife} Law, €34 ' The ammflan': Smtfii Khaki hf: Wists":- ifi'ifim' {iatstnii 1'33 1'3 ELE-gsfii Affairs yaquéxtimg her to mam aim i'fl'fflifiifflifififlifi {mm {Em mime .'Lz'i; SGfi-eitm' {Samara}: r32?" hadia ta @3331 the apgaiimitimn WM Brigham}? ' mafia. 'Yim appfifiant s-aimi {hm {i'nfier ngeétary; E359 Affairs him, ragsxiwaatsmwx {Ea'izfist'fi £3 mm: 'inrsascaahie'. E'if: admit.
thee 62::an ifsif-Sififlmzfifig t2: the. RTE apgsiicatieu, The zggpefiam that $3313? :'E'Eing :31? {km {:Qmmunimfianflaiafi ESE-\fi'iféifim {mm {:fiFKl i}; a ngai mam. in m:
(W )N' . Csmmmxicatian, {5.23918 Mamet}: that {ha .Elragxz'xrmwm SSEight in'ferfimtiwn Erma. gill. ;2{}:}.{3fimfid fieciians ixmfimiing Agénc; Semen, T3118 apyfi'iiarlt "that: the 3mm 0f {Ema withau: am}; witfience cw- matmia'i 521:2: wag rzeVer infer-rmefi firm: which mcfimn imfmrmmtimz x Samgh'iz by T338 mammary: Mattias: ma: this: saung fur infammtian mat: mi. :0 him' Thfi atypeifiam Swami mm: First Aggéfilszitti finfiwrity Eiaisaiflssii the atyptzai mgarte Wi'iiumt zifféz'dmg 53:1}! mppafiunfiy {if htsziag .'J .x Emaiimq "km-hm dacifiing {ha 3213:3323}. (31 Tim awe-112133.13 amt: the maymmimt participated in {he \ a"?
' m 5 h .\ H .4 m: A-
'33. The Vang--33am starizasi $121? the. fifiF-'ECE Kim-:3 mm: that: mam iszfiiia'iévi} 1 {1? mt: imiimm Tax Fx'ezaétiomem $$i3€i3§li€¥3315 130?; 'rgmivati in (fifths: the: 33%: gm: Genm'gi at" in€iizz.«:.. The tiaém mat it wag t:'::3_c:§321'§1ia, tai'wwsz. that was Vz'eceijvei'i"but: {Em-gums}; {26:31, i: has "man such a ham: {mafia affirm fur: ii'aermg (3133:; m: :'t-pzfiasntmian. azmi Emu-gr ' :3'31'1'33'1'33aim}: ii) {ha Amkzfiit fimthurity m Lawrmzrat and: mad iiiaiifkig m b8 aisix'ie and the: \r. .~-
\M'Wi} {iimct'm gkrmaii'ie ma inihyi':1afif'oi,.. i.
ts:
{Emmrazi {12f Knififa. may 3mg: absiyémce as this; itamm'simifin Vida (side's? 3:1 "Eiliivi- he'm'd the Ema-aim." eeafiiar' anti '. 1' \'stww t" «1' fl 1' "1: y.
m swam: :3»: {32:33:}, 11' The 'i'tiffi'gfifimfiéifii Swim that the. {mm-1mm: has been mpfiec' to with 3633: (1:326. QEQIXEzQCElS that; the. :z'eprszsmztafien {Emmi ,1 my: ii'ifiifiif'féfi'Blfi ;
mkmiszfim} if; timid Shri Su'tshaSh Cham'éer 0:12.31: 29:; ("x J k.
géimmsv at? £m§izs., ma»: 0f 3%.. Miamwy Samara} ("if mafia 1%: mm a R: biic A'thimrity umirfiy {has act, ,V 13" . Tim i'fismmfifim \gtéiixéx'r'i mat gar 'i'iczszie Eikfihi {1:31:11 flair:- i'is §'Ll<igmcmt {Emmi in 1.19333; 1'80. hem. m»: L {sf 0 ML saitétstnt'tzm {Eenmai <35 imiia as next: a R3333: .Sfiafili'ii'XE'iiX Elfidfil" {iii-E: Rf} :'Ks::t,., f, ' y ' rag-yangiexxtMatad that that Safimitm' usmr'a} m". felliefs 13.1mm tbs:- mms 'fOCsting $13.: a}? the Uffiitfi': Lat? :Kizizsm'my {If Imiia'. Effwimfkam, tilt? I'wganciem: degm'tmflni; did. 36:33?st muy infisrmatiam {mm them. 1:2». 'I'E-m 'rsxapfisflfimfi: {hat SEE} mgr: $33; figmwai hm: wEasfiirmr the fiitmrsiwjg {'meiezmi a. "E'uhiie Afiamfiwrfiiy, pamiing imfazmz- {ha fian'bk: Supremfi fi'mfimianj 'ahmmfitmn:
N' Th: apgaefiam't axis-n {m mgémsentat'im: 31' Questixm as {a Whmhmf ma fitifir'fiéy General 9:" Mi -'~és:s'§_§.s:§,§:stn* h 3715 as gm: Ordgar fim'atfi ' itflifigififl {hf {hm 3 z "¢ Tan!" ' . . . . . V . . V . . . . . H? ' ' ¢ \ _ . V . . . . ' ",IV1...SS,,.,'.., ' , ' . Q W ~~~~~~~~~ a Ekahiigg fiuthmifgyg Siam nest mama: m}. thaw ahiiity in fun-1&3}: if ' mf mughtfar Enthrmatifiu Fairway, their regggarmdamt may Sfiek: fife-31:; officéaisfSame-2:: cox'garamgsd far pmvidmg ms":- infammtim m the aggpeiimm flm-isfian:
163i 1t'fit'if-{imvafim'zi? m ignitin'matiam :9 aimsfizifliaji mam days; Csf mm. arcimx Tim rmpsnzmmzfl: ciirmtiteii {£3 iaémwcausa m why main}: ask-maid E36: takfin against: {ham fix CO'Rfi'fiVEK'iifiig {11:2 pi'mrixiens :31". this .
:mmferrmg RTE éAEEpEigratim wrangfiy m {ht-1'; {KPH} fa. F'xraxm-Wm WE {£513.55 :3? mm {gr'fiezz \ disgmmi Csfi {Dogs}? 35 emit)? gi'mn is {ha free: Bf {:{33'fi'_., Sfij« {Rafiha Kfixhna Mathur} (3315M Infarmatmn Cammiasinm:
'émtitmmiczatsd mm Czapy' ~ ( é . 5" Ea} 333? . Ragiatrar ""1? > 4 «we?
€EZNTE'§§$§¢; Efii§¥f§i§§¥§fi7§fifi {IQE'tf'ELMESfiiQN F&$t$t
3.. Tim eazriim' mafia: a: ham} was hmxi its-y {fir}:mmis&§éun {m Er:V(2:).3'5'1ilfiiim:as: up: $316; {iszgrrmnissimm'3 6a" ' ,4;
89.€35'V">§}Z§?¢ we rfszsayanciexsst Suiémitmd main?
~ u, -.y- H~'»" " ." v a .E'imitmm Mam if?" Mi-mxmyhfia, {Tm sippeiiamt vim: Etta-1' flaw [v >-
su'mnitmfi {hat "was: angxtiiamt E3618} :{mw 'imtimd that {3.13% it?) tg-'gzersgi'agz-hiamzl arms" is; {R} at" his: 'ziggépiismitimts. in qmmfinm me: (lam: Csf aim z?€1}¥<fi:§:£€'iikts3t§<m has wmugiy M52611 skhmm .
mgum, '1 im;w§ {Iii fi'écugust, 3m}, gm (Emmi ref this SEW} than: :10 mgmmntatiofl flamfi. 25'{§S<,2{} i8 trmmaxhia €113 m:
{m Gaunt?"
The amt-$33331: Eei'ijm aimed Bikififfiiéfi «mummy: rvafint'icxxi'g afif'imeméiiiml chimd 395353231"? "filial 315E153: mil-km} 9:1 Ema-"133%:
3'. The 3m: _§3:33*'§'§,§:i§)me 3L E'mazqr'ing and 'Viifi'lfi: Effi'tfilfl-i' 'iated infmtmecfi the Cemmig V km that stints if} his; gxfi'éafi'fii'; {3ifiifi11fi§; "m3 mmfle (m aifiiasrv'é the .'ziwaring. "i'hai:
-' m refigaamtiééixt. yafixa'fipafixfifi the: i ii: gmrzéfi-n...
This: rfzsgn'aziximxi that: 31% $317K: A my 11:31: mimic:
Ruthmtitjg 1113:3131" i111 {ha Quart... {3n query fer the Cumin-1&5 "isms. {that reapsnmxisrntist'xtfiti @385" have mat: the: 'I'\ mmntar writtem mfimfimfim :3? m éi§3§t3ii£i§1i m thaw tixpiamti'ion in aim mfi'tiaf, mgmssmnf absemtium The: a.z*gumemi am. 'zmziti't has ainfrafiy been {imam in {kg mafia}: mmg that: £116 00?? at". fir: fizixiifs written. irubrszigasian has; U1 sugzspl'ieci magamimm hi aggarmgsriate fimi: that apgzwsz'i'fzaszz; 1' E mnsitiez's the app; ami's repressm'satimz Liam-:3. Bil": Maggi, ESE} :Sémteafi 1261} mm fusrnighea a. mp}? mmrdéngiy fificisianz '.
Wifi'fin {flags m" Kiwi-gt 5:? this {Edi}? . resigmztaden: may me. finiamisfiimx m appeiiant'g {Ea-tad fififiEQlé within. ciws GE mwim of mix: (misfit, g {x} 13v. mam-tar i5; difectmi m m m r Ear 3.8 @f mm {393:3}? :35 the arcim kiss: giver: m Rim paying frag? {3}? carat "
iMdha Krishna: Mathm;
ahiaf anamzatian Cammigsinmw 3m {me {rap-jg ' ( Shanna} Ragistmr i6?
/ a.
"J "am a? haaximg:
{Rate at" flacisian:
<3 54"?"
(37-?
Was Heafing:
3., The: maize? a: Mimi 63mm Emma's the Cam-missing 011 i \ .-
§1 swag}? the Csimtimismmi's arms? riatmfi Efiflégififiiifi 'stha i'fiéfipemdz y»;
Eméi' {m m-rx'mi may Within submissiicmg (Kama? :3 {Lia-ms of furnished tia- the :fiagmfiam {i arixtzg' tim- hearmg.
"\- QW+§W a '. 'a: "if ' '3T> e3, -' *< v. . Wr' {Ev flown" 'v "Sr: 3» fr' 'w:' .4). m, 11:, gm: 15353 «(an ytfir'mmfik "y piamui 1M. LML Jam"
Tim: apgmfifiaflt Sfizflfifi. mist 1:335 resgmmiem has mt mmpfiafi wifsh 3mm 231' {ha {Summissim'a {E'awsi Q?§fi§3;§£§i?. Tm agpei'imfi.
i'hfi'; rtsszpiy the. mapmicimi m simw mm mentémxefi 3.: pam. m}. 1 Cmm:m§$§;ie:<m'& Q'fdfitf (mam: $23.03.,RGNE aeézfiigkctmy «<3 \5\V-','~:~:i3$:"' '3 ' "' 1 ,1 ' "'"z' ~ u m a d. ' A, =- , -
filfifigflaifi a;.u.§,;gm .
a * ' - ' app-anew: in h: Effitlgfiy is the: expiammm {maxi , M ;
am:
wa M \ {3333.8 mm Manx" {133: "CIRE RT": ezzppiica-him; waa W33: it: FtEm: offim: ai' Seiici'im fienemi E3}? tipaeti-L'i .3305di. 3mm the yué'im} givm'; in the:
{12f figs» Sssii'ezzimx' {Maia-15a; w: imfliafi TE-m appa'afiam "Emmi max: hi? has 31% var dammit? finatis'mmi 5:113: ii{Rim-1mm: with RT? apgfiieatimn {Kim yastsfi {yrs/3&1" tmvzariis {Em EH .fcmsx Ba: that ' ' 1;.E'xu3itsii \z-a.='.':.iif:810:= mmm in: m l"
Kurtis; {1:33 "fa-z: {3.37% ;;'.§33:a'§.icati:331g 'The as'gsgyszfiam matrix} that the rmpzfizxciexgi: hm: afimfimxfi i1: mm wrimm mhmimsmm daiéxi 1'3 flied, Eggs- fins: $011358} (sf Ewizrvamis'm'c «4 of ms: SQEiCiiBr fimmmi Sf indie; {if} {the {Zflfifia Mg. 531311323 Days-t; a? LE3§§3 3 fifi'aim. "£33.15: apgi-tzfilfiami mats-3:93 mat me:- statamrsm. (3'§ CPR} him? {he anEXfifiant ":an mm: msvidfizfi {gm-gay of magma wmtafism i3 (3:13;? am afi'iartkmught smarts: cmfihsizsn am? migifizmi me {:mmmm. a?
The a:§3'§;ss?§ii&m Sim: afi fine GEEK} bafimi (m. wrung it:
'v 23351:? imatmanfi rm: {siffaz'ed '33:}; 33mm? Efigflékfifiiififi, 831' was sf " 11km is: the: Eapsri'mm'r; :33? Rafi-Yawn: Wififimfi mm Si fins s13§i3§ts§mmfif 31h»: afimfi {if the M3. Sasfieitzm' {Iém'semi if": hiaiigéfl exigent Wham {hit ~ .gv inimmaiimz mug .t;
The zippei'iam mfg-me: {if} Ekaii'bké Supreisme {Emmi .iueigmtfi'zt fiafitmfi 'i in the GE indirest Fractfiimwmfa Afisat'miaxism Va, RR. :3 in which. if; is WEE-2'1 "'Xhfi. yfiifiimmr 21 hm}? g.'§"€§'7§t&sz§mz3.afia win: item muse mi" " clients: bafam 3:116 may "as: @3133" (138,313 anti. iii: Ersm'igeii in ' 3633*" am: .mx-'xg' V 'it'a'g'mfiafifim'i hawk-min {3f Efimvevxey, irmtami 0f slain: Khaki, mm 3:." . . M . * haw: may: i'otfwg mi. {:9 {iE'Hfi-'E'iflflfi {Em fifii'iflfi'fli awfi' in 'i'hfit 'pii"£}€;t€€$§i mfisisd :Xtissrmy Germ-mi 0f in by wgpmgg'mg the {afi'z'fififl at" §a§p<§éimmsnt m"? inquiiry {filnztmuit'tm by "£32135: Emma-mg avpeiigm tagfé that Gemm'al of" 1mm {33" Lu ' a 333;? {Emu-mm as)?"
a the: czcsmgtseim'zt a11.t1i1;;3rit§; E0 give. {if} aezjgempiz. N-
52 'f'ha agwiiam furiiéfxer referrétzzi ta} :5; dasmmmt {aesmzami m:
gktfim'my {E'f'iflfiff'a}. GE Endis-ié, wféizici'; he: had Q'étfiraimd Kama)? fiat - {mm '1 i: {tie-at mm: Miami? {;5~QI3'£?E§§,§.SL§A SeEiciiigr {3mm} {:53 mafia C'Crzxygsésmifi ,311'ti'x0-'x'iiiv {,0 mkf: dazfiimm it} 5131-: contain}: 3353iitig;s;:
.; A hem-w {ha E--i'mt Mg: flaw:
that termiem imftlmmtigm Shank} be: pram.de to
8. apng'iizni; Siam-S:
\ 1'}, £3.33 :.x;\\;;)§}m§_ms£ lfiiififiaiizifi {£1821 Lisa? i31t;_::k£:.1;i_ gum} 13:31.? 15" {£36,}: inc; ,z...-\,_;, Ais'tarnfiy Gfiszerai', (Emits: ami m. Adfli'timna} $33 are not 2% :Eui'imri'iim. i5.
"by 8&1, figamva'i £11 Ei'mifis Suprezme (Emmi: .3"
a?
x it: i. {32mm is: wiziséh it .'riafétf. {karat girls: 31;}? Ekibific. Aufi'im'itiefi azi'mi the {333.88 fias'fiiufiim, .
'Tim impamiem ssirami firm: CPR} m? Empty as}? Magma a. 'sti'i'S'L3F:
mush. Esz'ér thin"). MEL 1312' ASQE szmsfi {harsh-m {tammzt lide {aficiam {mt M}, Si} am} at mg}? m £316: {:urregpmmé.mta$ patrtzmaing m fighézir fflflifififi 31- 33335 ffifi'ifiiénfifiifli waived: :m: {mum {3'}: Mi. Atmmfljv" Gert-1am}. m?
Lei, Swaith Genayafi af Ensiiéa Bf it 'ti'mmfwes fiifficuii m is";
x dazeumanig pertaining is}: yes-{3f 123333 fliscussiemi Shasta: Miriam 37': zaimziéy as me. ta: Kim mata'm a")? the. i:$:¥lfl3.i.83ij3fiy mfimzim'imi :13, \ {'ii'flsflY 158.131? the agspeiiatm same: "Eater da'imi Tr"
submitted time: if} 'i:§;r§tszi3grap§tiim§ imam: m" RTE, appiiatatim2, {ti-ate fiat? mpfiemntisa'tim': 3-375 wrcmgiiy imam} m1 mstmd csf {Esvfifiyflfifig Théir'éfB-ffif, that {kmzunisaimi wide Maia:- {i3};
28.€E*§§.L2G3'?
dirmtefi tim consigiar mg: apps'fims aimed 3813839€3E3 anti filfiihéii' iii-{fitted ta pz'mvigir': ixfar'znz'i'iisgn tit»: apgwafiamx
13.. "Sim Cammimicm ahwwed that {has aypfiilstsm has mmfimefi himseh'? tats. 'zasues mffimnatien 52229212253. he, gravildefi {£3 him- amci partafity swank} impemcéd an Em: mfigandmt.
The L3i31{§3.311§§€-$3GI3 nimewsd {23.63. :E'es52330:1{§m1i2,in {hair writ? '1' Submiagiam: tiaztéd LEI? :'aizsati me mntwfiifim Gm"
;}3:§3-§}_i':istts?ifl0'fi was nqé Rafi:
{i w {xi Sairifiitm' Samara: mafia" But, «in: (a @'sr'iriitmt {mm m: writs: sigma "RELQQZS fled '13:! A magmmjem {hat mama? E'Sfii'i't'fifi by 'fi'ie {3E} "' \ "raw «A r Qf 1mm #33 mamfi}, kits, ASE-"155.. Swim lflap'it' {21" Legal} .53: aim WAG iiwihmr t3'£':ii'1$f§:§i"£'fii§ the: ta LEEKEK'Efili-Sflt {st Rwanzm. T'm': 12mm: m" RESVK'E'ER'EE' n .. .' {mt Silaiii'ifiizi' m1 113 tQ {33%. SQ, sggf gaffaim. 'i'§3.:%3 . . s {Em-mzisakm max-1e: the: {mat-.is-niian $.21; 2m: i'frm mma'zzflemt Etsmi ww'msii r trams-fassr;rit*§. that RTE em 3 Dirimséfltknf: 3353' £338 {fiansar'm'z'ifim m'.' x w ~ ._ .vtxezz-z {31* C:prng 0f 'iihé: rfifm'esm'itatian am WhiCE: flu: infmntz'iaiiam $i}'{;{§§3§1, amfi 0133}? {m that of am fivm'aii itie; , tim- ziggfiinaiiasfi wzzw Em'wax'dmfil m cam}: {Emit timeiy ileiin'mmiissn amid his mevixiimi m figségwiizmi mini that»: m3 maiafida rx' 'im'ifii'ifiD-fl titsz part. {if {km tax-:13. £37910", h {:{mxrxxisaim ahmw firm: {31$ c1.aa.ifi'..§,ejsafi:311 given is}: {he wmymflemt Si'tt'lz'nfi t0 S:.;i:§.s.'emmz§r. LNG ma; :"-:' was. ghaswmi (m £315: part: of taspunfiéim;
{ismmimigm aghzsfimrnwjvci £1123: {ietfézme by the mggsmizdizm;
during the 'ma'ring my}. 311 mm writmm axfiamfimimm 3137552333.?
*'*'ifi.§3e "k of" Bapfix Csf Affairs»; is a 'gféifif'S-GX} much Ezlm'aii' $1333 L53» (fisfifli'nflfligfii. S'fi'iifiitfii' {L's-emera} £11553. magi mama"; hind m'ffiafiaiz's ta: givfi a :z'fzp'siy' ili'} {Em anti Wm Maura 65f hi.
'Mmm--my {:t'si-'intli'fe:i §:3:§ §§1{3§8§1'§' 1&3, Szxiiitiizéfi': EE-enerm m" Emilia is of" '3 yaéirs; 23.3:er );A o:
m ,..M a."
'"n'x arm;
M a":
J {4 CM.
' g i: a; mass. {33:2 (iwxmmmts gffiffii'ifiiilifig 'iaha £132.38?" {:mmmf ' - y {3f the Vifi'w that, iii influmitmmezy {EMS >4 mi: mam; ms: mm'fi'i'fis Furihezr, 83.1%: mm. Qf .Afi'aim xv"
fight its}. igzigprmefiim 3mm :The .m-E--fim S's-siicimr Gffi'ilfiiifliy 33's,:i'icaxia'2"? gimme $123 apgfiimfinn mm $31231: fiffififi m it. "7", '- it} in tart: x T}. a; pfica'tmn were {sf Legai Psiifaisrs aunt? {Cruz sfimmxmenfis mi 35:19: 531% fiexgmttati ta savaiiabics in. the effiw of LCL 18'. "'fiammissimfi mime-fwd in star? ariisizr dams: {33'3'8352'231'3 is; whethfit' maxim}? flew-3&8 m L211. Smfigimr {Eenfim} P1111312 .Mfiimrrityg 92:23:23 Iliifi impact: an fizz-2&1" aiyifil'aty firmifiix fizz: saugfhi: {m i infarmeriitm if; QEE'J'L {if Fmfimr; regggJ-mxdei'xt may ' {mm Samimtx caneszrmjzi fer pa':&:i::iii:1g the infcsrstrzmtix'm 3:33 mi: ampefimiéz". ' ' 33 '3 \ * * \«s 32:3" v \ - 1 c i- .
,\ {lammigsian fm'i'har abmrvm'i that as 3353:." Sectiim 2i; {Em RTE? Ema which waits as; feilmw: "anm'zfla'tix'sn Inaarm at}? ummria'e in may fem; mflufiihg magma) ciaaummm mema& $313333, myimimmx aa'i'vims, {,rrtims, Eagbwksi {Zia-mizznsig'1t5; rapnyiss aim. . .. V , ' {1:335:5in I'flél'ifiili'lai §i§f$ifi 13'}. any t3iiii'li'lvilfiiil iii 71. u ' may _; baciy" which. min Take Wei 321:}? a yuhfiis: Rliiiihfifiii}? mtgdtrrr 93': t, iaw fit: 131:2? timr': waxyfi etiemfiy 8; ma: aim; inmrmatic:,z:a {:3 Wham hwy WEE-i0}: ha 3'35; 7;; £31133:st allfikfi'fl'ifil}? "an 315:1»: immishafi umier tbs: RTE Rat, "f'me Cammimmfi he View that (mee- tiw: RTE afimimiticm €23: {mmPazraiaaig'rgaiarwzi {mm 1:338 s'fifice a?" aim Smiixtimr Gitmg'm}. {3f Em?) ' rm: duty 01" {ENC} umfiar Qecimn 5:39;} (355' flu: RTE £3.33 fr'erjm Di'i'iatiaim"53:21:33: cmmernail it} Gi'iifiii" it} fili'fifi'ifit': that infammafixm. Saiziiisgz': M' »~ {4%} Of the: RTE REE mam "FEM: Central. EF'uhfiséc: Ezifm'matisn {Efficer' 2?
mm»; Infm'zzmtian (35106:; the may "m3, may 'fghéz- aggzgmmm any mfifmf <3; 4 M Eff E16: 6.31" Shir: £73m mefi-mmstx'y prayer {imam 31:33? {if a: he:
.33., 'fiza Carmnissiw: Vith mfism {hated .1331? and had. asked Yfifipfifldfifit '22:: seek; fisfiifi-'CERKSE :zfum hi. Sfiffifi jug: oaks" Li} gimmick: {he i':1t§'{3rrnexfii§3n_< Em. ms: magmnfiem mmpiim': xvii}: m :6 6 0f {fimnmiasimfs {smiley (Ea-md €3§L€3t§2€3 mm ' ms:s3:s:::éfiivaii~< 3101* $iis,1g§rz.€ any Rawstingsmafcerzraegpomchzsmxe it} the mat:~:;~:::'- Emmi this): the. initsrmeztim: yam-aiming E0 m year diffifimfit tar: trace withaui tiff: maxim infmrmmimm "air: that 61:: ffifipflfifieflt sci-was mm: want {{3} Egémifih {Em inf'ammtim, fixmwtian a3 {mafia-r 8 :3? RTE act. fimisian:
in View akin-m {ha iiimmaimian grams {me mars. awnrmmty m {V magmnfiemt ti} aging}? with. {tommitsxfimn'a {ridge}? tiamd gr; :fespazztimt {iimztmi m ":atzmgfiy with cariiisifif I'fimmniggiarz'a m'ziier iii" £233??? Wi'l'hm 3f} 15mm {1122 data at? mafia}: this: QI'd-ffir. {')fi1azrwiaz=:,
-::'_:'5§'.'\:""gg>.4"-é"::;"' V :V"':':""::"' f'::»':t "~ h»; <-
1" "a {lizmxarmrizgfliamm (3%? Qammiszfiaafifi (3:784:22? wkmiii at mme pmctmiim imam? me RTE fifsiih 1",; V fm' fiays; Eta" cmfxgfiimm {Emiha Krifima fiafihux} I fihfiaf szmxmmfian {Eammiwmam fififi'ififl'iiiiafifii trim f u By 'Regi 313': 3' t2..§3:§§gzm:€ fifitfiifigfiffififlfifi m Rs'mximg:
The {fiffiiifi' {Kit was; m§.\:'3i£r $33! me. {iflannifisusm {m 33.x}? matter {X'fiii'i}? 1131' mmpiimme szzf mafia-2r flatter: {34%; , 'i 2;) Emits. the. partim was: pemimajiy garawrm. in
3. 1'3gpmmim3i: film: fix: compiiamm {3f Climtaméasian'x: Swim" {$353321 GQA'BSQSEK if} have. $533" $13 in @233 aifimg' {mm the at"
these than Saféiatitiif immim': 'Rah'in'imi aii an Thar raw-ancient: stafied that $233}? iiiWEiii'Ed fmm {Emir Csffi.€:§f., (in fiihu'3'31g {ha hemmg i'asgmtifiani: maxi: may have vmhaily agism {zemtamnfi mg. m" m: mm; Lei. Saififsitiiiszf Sanam't 'i'hfiy have:
imi'fimxeé £53132? m) mamfiri msaiiaétbia. 'i'hfl appaiimfi aimed paiiity m {immmwnmffli gram htfi'ijfimfi .miwiflg aim? catz'igfiatiia :11 {3f fifliiui'fi Bf Smiiatri'iim' {Mariya in i'asct, {taught it} hat hemiifici {war ta {ha Law :Z'vi'ixixiaz'g'ry, ................. .. ' \\\\\ fiimfifihnfa'memtim:2 H; .
a has: revfipm'zfifinfl Shfmhi infiéf'fil {3:15; Cammfiasfiam inciiaatmg {1:193 Qfi'fx;¢¢;~;fi}'g3i;m :3.
Sac-1'93 {my :fixsxaiirig with {he ta Offim {if the Saiictitmr .' {335' Yrasgsmmfiam Shamm 22 mpg {xii mfier m the; gjz31';s;ts:~:{'3'}&';{;§_ <}3{>,§::'1'it Mm is;
Erwin :s'k';s'.'s'13_§;s';§ amigzzmm ti Mimi's:
maimmmnm 'st afficiai aim? 27m immnmam I'ifiid,' SGE {Emits} The: (ifficarfiiiaimi: Sacretsazry xvii} the ciiaammi CPR} in itmaiaicm: r 'i'fififi3fifléfiflt is dimctcci t9 mks: per ne' ahewa 37w wszpomdam is fm'thm' {0, mm} :1 mpy gsf" yap}? m a.pgsfiiia:ng. I'ECEiVfiii {mm m: affim 23:?
9.
€3§§.1§3x2'§3§? 3:333 $31511; Wfi'iem the {texticezineci Jami Smxretary xiiiLt":3-s:ms:il {(3 Ext "E'hfi Begum" Regism'ax' {Eiree'tziii "m fix immimg in mafia? {m pcmz3ziuzzffiiy bfiibrfi ma {Etuzrimisgmn at {Iggy {If ma if)?§ffif 3'36 pariim {me {:5 sq:
8d '« maxim Krishna mam»;
maief'infmmatimz fiammimmmw n-~ Ru :1}: an ticmeii mm mm"
Seij'-
{fiin Shmmai 33g. Ragis'mr iiygmai 33%, C313! 3&ng! 253 13"! QQQQGQ' fiflfifiifi? QWER Bfiffifl 353.16.3{31'2' .fiaarfing:
1' tam}. me §Ba_:t't§.<ifi;i§3:§t€fi hamiwzg in 'gé'tfi'i'SQIL My. :1 Y'miav {;é'x.<3::'i?i, Gwyn}, Srivaatam {Dy L-ggézi 'Azfivmmfig {3:113:31 Eirisfitznaxx T. {'{Jndey key}, My, Bsziimdur (Emit; fidwcaia} zami 'E.' {Piii-ugerinmncimg Eiszgzzxi} regaresemsfifi the 'I'Y'Ni'p-Qfiiifirlt. V ,6} Aug. .
Thai? mmtsr £93 flamed mtiay' {is}? .i'urfimr "flaming $33 "the: mafia: 31$. *-
itha mmnimim'i fut: maturing A "£fi";i€:t.iti fi$$g¥~§3ia'ii£sn, figmgakxa we angmiirmfig Suimequemtiy, {.311 mm; ea-gspa-zmchsd imiisipmtsdemije by Endima'fi: Tax §3§'€£"iiiiifjitléffl"
fizwafiiemmx, Bangafiwe {m the: came .. Samara} mflim', {Em Lei; :3: 'tmfmw ~ «-
{if mam hm giwzx': his. wrismi mmfim Simian-n 1:: {3f the. {jéfififiiflifi}? {Rf Cm'éi'tfi ,xtx'iitiiti'in't ssh Sujgwamg {Smart {.313 mafia, mattsr mm:- ta Siiixrérr'se rum-km E-iazflaia
3...; N23,. Q Q?" .133? in Sup-mine: ifiezmx'i: 'i'yi' $132533 the: E'sfi-'iiim:
{igmfimnpt i§9$tifiam v§_i:'._:"i.'} ;. 53L aagptziféagnt mat the Qfiififfiifaiésflf Enéia asmn'ms aifics if: sxijsitxiigiy :1:azg3;3.c:itya11d 9f" {he id. '8 effime Qantfimm 5n 11:3 {iemits :3f§i£§:.. E'txem'ikmg ufi'icizfi :tezccsrciss $53113;sz with the Ra? maxi 3min wag-{wig aura-2 gmemmxs'sm p;'<>;3€;rty. fiimme ¥i§f,§;i"{%1'{lfi§1§ m" {:e'asatm er m" {:sffice fiiflfifli' a: gimme: it)!" {75: wing; meoz'dsz m: fiestrmziiam {If 'i'fi'iisiki'fifi. fiance, the: e;>:1<i~.:a-n.t $13£§L13ii gr'awisie him. SB {Em coz'x'egpomimegs m thfi': rap???Sfiii'i'ifisj'ififfil in; Quagfimn, 3.54 Simgfi'ii by"
him i331er RYE Riflffiiififiiiflix \ w. ,r'esgmitdfint mums: exp-£23341} ts: E'i'nrflmr, am: apmfiimxt him. ma: pmesc mm r'afiaziing m 1': sfiifi'ifiéfifirififi '03' {$3331}: {iettumemt::,;"fi§as5 sin :Extzscmmikmzi LE3. {$312133 his afiim. musk}: 53 $522-$313; fmm {Sim 'E'fmgmfifififli if rssrizm'd 11:31: "trezittéahfia Erie that. i'hi'} €3E'§§}'131{§..Eflfifi'fl}him}, to howfitfm ITEQ'S'3K'CiS Li £311,3- VAG am? hi affine 3m gmmikwi afieszr tfitmg fimm their artifice. Arie. gamma} that: rszagmmcimt simuk'i specify maefimcioiagy fisxsirmziim:fmmnfinfi m? ram-r228 in. the: {want ~31 {thfii'igfif in the inmanbmxagy; :37. R'ifirfiavm'! A. m: EAL $33 $333: maxim {38' Waugh: the. ambit 'E'siigxffl'ii amazimg agenary'; $319.. &-;§3§§~§:§}§3fi§ has; ms. Cats,m_mis3i<:sn'$ attamfim} €16 {-33.8 pmrmsimm six? Stamina :33} of {km Pulia'iit: 3km, 1%}'333 which :feaztig {@339st "{ffi"'re{::mfi$ arrmfing zigzag?" imam: as? ~~ .i' m reiatifln t0. Em? Cant-mi {Email}mam, amy minigtzj, éiégiafiffsfini at: @3525: :33? that {Emissmmmtg it im :'eiatian m any Siza'mmry body m mmaomtion WhflB-y m Si.;?qsazt=t:u'1t;ia§iy ecsntmiifixfi an" financed, by Caan G-m-'erimwm GP? mmmiagim mmmé mnfiimmd é}:
{than £3": A": ' ' ' ' "
cmnmiasiim 91' mam
in i'fifiifim'i m a {Firkin 'E'mtri'im'y skim'éniaimafiiflh, an}? £i$§3311t't1t3i$1t1t V w amass: mat Afiministmtigm; .
iv; in. rafiméam fit) any 3:38.35: C8" sitefsfzfipaya tidy: Whaii'y mg. gimgm mi {hrs isc-m} mus xv t4 7'5 9 -\ w ya) )4;
2:"! W:
H;
u;
*v \-
)4 ,M I 94 , mbmnmfiy {Ii}:mi'r1{fli€5{i :32." i1 by main-3:1 mmaw $231113Straitng cemmtziissian er cmmmtmg: iii'fififfiii'ifl'iéifi "a ' mat {}{:mritmm_s'm_t am»: mffifics- 0? {ha 'Ci 'Wu-i' 2' V. " "v * i" '1 3g ' . 5 ' a V 38.; m4, magma arm, mmmim 'm m" itfiiflr.§1~i§ii€i§;"
in mippmt. <33? fizuzxtemfiom agpai'smfl. refiarmd m fimnm'gaimfa 3:136: 119. {SEQ-fifz'sfifr f32§Q§SiE§32 3.333% 133 whmvzm if sfiififiwmi underr-
Saving. camsziszieraééi. the gabxriiwmm a)? ism: Camméaaimz Qf ma viz-aw mg: thwart: 3.23 magi: m gm: can'te-sfsiiiom mm mm. 33:! hike fi'gpflfiéimt that {2% ram-mm remms mug: be availabm at: $38 .Psm'imm Wham W333i; E1 Govmttmemt 133%er Emii fix: rertirimg pafice Anna: hamimwgr the m the 8&0; fiagf'.
Cammisz-simz kamby {3mm 'TE'IQ- m Eat-am smnmrztaed vim}. pmviaié m? mmgmmt wgé'gm mama; wiii'i wkvfixifi.'itio-G'mnénm m ' agipa'sfimmy in. ' V '«Eain: mat 'ii'fliifiabk), the; fiifii} is {Eiwasgad :5; pyramfifi ngcifia: regEy gating gamma if aqu taikmz. by and magmas them-m Tim CW3 Wm With: him: {iirmi-gians Cf the: Cwmmisgim} 'M'i'him ifhmfi {3f {662854323X (3f affix-:13: Tm: d§.$§3i333<i m" 3331 the: {sari {3f 3.3m Ccsmméfisiqn with HE§¢£§§°€§ (Swath): Vsiziobmfvatmmw' \' The: x'aajgamifim that 2111:. 'gzragmm (1f ili'li') mgr: {gm-age mag; 1:3 as;
v {Emma}. figflfififi" ESCE'ED'E': affix" the. ML Afihfifi' 3&3; damx'm his r;§'§i§i(:::':.g?3i'-'~t 3v" cu.
" V 1:83 guiiitifina in place: {a take mmmdy m" the: I'enmimng 333.3331'2; £33. their that ma same-5w; am am: awfiamegf 'fibifi K.» ' f???"
REES;{iifiifiimfimtfi m the. {Tiszérgti'a'fi Aggy: T; 1-"
itsjginion Lei, 2:313}! with me {3&3 and 83m? :3 {matgsmmgxg vi the wiefmm gag-M's m {ha mm we. mas. Tm: gm: m? accesses 1113:3286E§$§3§QRS chm £1113: aim réuezsivfisfi. 5m w: p-rfiwifiii'zg aaztrfitmfia} "She: Privatfi Szésssgtmmy is;
\
- mmixmiy maxim in {ti-m ufi'z'es.
SifiEC'iéDi'l. {at <_:.§3;:3i:a;z:n-jt. it; 330:immi um: the-at: the. éoixczuxnmjz payers;
Y"
{Xi};
\ tbs-air awaiiia'hn .8 R183 m, Siffr- 8._pyrsrsesst:hati and he ' ini'mmzfxi {Emit firm mum's an: mast atwfiafigie {'3 * f.
mswgsimf afimmtium "E'his Cantu;mi.s:3im: m" Em viaew {Ex-€212; the, mmgitzi an: mm; :33:
n 1;" Even if «,'jhg 353; 5'33; 35m: x: off-me dwes net {Emma wifi'im {he gurviww {si' ii-'izfifiig: Auifixaz'diy, {E7153 nificiai :a'amrdss remiwfi in gtsiztliiiflry camacity mm; "£3313 Cf.§-1'fi.3fii1i$$ii')fl we ViEW' that: ,_:an\;1m. ieii umat'ieflciflaii by :'i'hs {imam mum ha a, anpm' mixstthmfigm maifitez'm.:3{:w a? $1393: mmmias fine. bi $3}. LE' $.53. cit-3:33.153 afimsg 331$: Ifktgsafimamz 03" Lagg'ai Nif'e'iir's pregcx'ibe :iiifi'fléi} pygcedtum: gnermimimg its Cifist;r1§.s:t§stxfzfmaim'tanmim ' i"
{if i'&33{1{)1"{§.§§ after am imtam':mm hm {33:53:33.
This) {iasmnlifisiflfl is {has Gpifliafi "hat. fiw '§;¢'<\wz~$iom- Sect-fig}: is)?
{If Ei'iiiiéfi {its ymmit.
in 5:5 Sfi's' m7 {Iivsamempt Csf {Emma Act, 2 "ii, ezgrimimi '12}. 8mm {'31} m the: Bf ('1'.r'in'3imzii mutzmpi; mixing: Exam Q {:{miaempt re,fé;=:;s~r<-:-sr;§ (2:3 in wcfim: if?" the Sum'fima {Jami or m;
M in.
the High {Emmi may aatim: an mam metican. Gr an a 333:3{ti01'l Ezsy'm {a} {the fid'sramm»Gamma, m -
{1'3} whim? Barman wifiix aha {:{mmm't in writing {as {he ' ' if:
x \;
3.3x "' E 33;?
V I _, . t j 3&2} in:s'aiatmnvm {hi}? Rig}: Cami: i: {Ea-i931 tmaritmy six? E'Jwiz'ihL such Exam-'- {fiz'ifiear €13 tim {11m Era} {Eszzvmimm-m is}: wtificmimi in 1hr: {Itfficizz iaéhaifs 6,}? any zirt'hfir 'gts-{itt'éézcaz} with {he Carmen};
{the {3f any ez'immai? canteaimpt a: Subarfiinatt'e mam the iiigk {hurt mm GE 31 mfemmm mafia is: it ma Sizharfcimats eas'zgirt an a 11mm.th by Admcmfi«xiké-mm'i «3:; {m ffléatiml. tag: 2mm '{fi'fifi'iifi'ff} by fiaw {iifiiitar the Ya} {E-{wwfifiizent arm}: by smatifiirmtiim in the foisxia} Gékfii'fi'fa'l'f, this;
bafhaifif.
£3} Eves? mafian an" 13.3%,: made umimf this tséatiefl $332131} aimraztiify {ha waitrsxmfzs-i Wihi-Sh pea-mun athargfifi Es zatfi'iiagmi to ba guhty.
Exgiauatiun.m§m titig Seem-:1, me mprisssiam ":'xi'iwscgamz~ 'mlamw-~----
{a} in E'ii-iazniim'z {:3 the Supraan Cami, {he fifitmgrimy-Genera}:
ctr rim 52':24iiai-k):-€3m3cmig {1'3} in reigaytion Efivvthfi Rig}: Qwurt, Rafvacaifiwfienema} m"
:33" any a? me its? whissh. the Higiti Cam? $393539; astahiisheci; ' ' {C} in reiatim ix} tint: Sam": :33? 'a. fizdfxaiai {IfwarmMiami; ,u' m; itific'a'tian 54111 the. {ifi'ffiztia} Sgéfiaiify in this behafil' Officfir the: {3&2'3"~'a§ Gawmsnmsmt may, '1 1'} .is': {imxixzflisszim ahésgme'fici the: Li? SM} ML ail} had
- '\ gasswem 1,2;2,-e<:::1z:sz1 1:3 {3:5 1' 3 Camrf'micmrf apiniurm whfie 512mm; Chung-2mg}: 93f Amt: £313": mménmii in. 3:22am 33 abmw; 'i'his Ct'éiflfiflt Ere intefltim: {If tha': im?._ Tim Eiaparmmzm atsilhmtiee may 333m his izmk mites, t_§::_-::s matter am 33323.1". such Simémzm aims nus: ream: \ {.«1 T'E'it's aetimg' if $516: i"fi'$§£fiiilii§€1'l'i in. my 3w" KR £38§€3§3§§§3 'Efl Q. fim' E91331 apfiiemm "1 $3,: .aéxctm'y. 91 fieeigifim:
.: i353tfiYVEf'l'lfiGfl at" the Cesmzmssimi first}: farm the: mamas-:2 1* v '3' flimw who ya], . A '. ' oi", ,,. . . H V ' , m, L .. V.:.. . t' 93' "Pm; Wm tic-'in 33(1i3etiiiifi3tifli (12 u imam. (111:3 : . 4;! Sam: {:11 333;. 53: Mimi's" afivimai it} 399E»: first: i?LI§§§I'1§i£§. in. mama; ami 1
- me. apgm;efl 'iifigmaad mi"; {Liam-V ()5 the: {12"
.figfithfiéfi ifiémfi fima flags}? . § _ ' ("g/Z iSXL Skmma} fly. Ragiaimr ' flay? '§@:« B'fifimiwmxt {If J'iiiisiiiitiil, $hafi'ifi Eifihzwseau'xs. Raw I3 emit," 3. 1 wk? ' {33?}? 35:3» Smtmi'szsyy ' v "H ' , A \- " '~'¢i .iiv 9&1; $.13.an a}? £35m h.
.. . .
fifi'kfiflw .VVQ §!' "N to