Karnataka High Court
Ashok vs Kusumadevi on 13 March, 2008
Author: N.Ananda
Bench: N.Ananda
I-1
. 14.1 urn ..m_Im or KARMA AKA AT BAN;GA§;Q«§§l§ u
THE HON'BLE MR,aa:sT1cs31§; ANA1szr;:.§S'V °
CRIMINAL PETIH(§'fi.TV 3 1 73¢2fie?i
1. Ashok * _ f '
SID. Venkaznfidy-Niflgfiladiijf.
Aged 0<__:c: gB=:{ainesisf_"-- ..
. V
Stlbixzaslsimgar-5
Hllblii
2. "Smt.Rekha~.__ " _ _
fijG.._f€inga'«Gc-'fi-'da'*--. '
Aged '.28 yeisttty Obcé; Household work
R] o; "4ih-£31033,' Tfieaiipandey Ii agar
Hjlbli, "District.
$[ o._'De:varaddy Ningaraddyj
v.*?'«.."-Fe-' afieat 58 years
Doc; --B13ainess
fi'i'~fI_. i5iibhasi'u'1aga:-, Hubli
Dhaiwad District.
4---
Slo. Venkaraddy Ningaraddy
Agmi about 38 years
Occ: Business
Riv. S-c.bhasl'.a-=-'='ar, flu..."
Dharwad District.
3 J
I' I
3
I
I
SJ!
I I
-
I"-n~|n}1 W &'J'll S/o. Venkamddy Ningaraddy Aged 36 y'car.s"'"
Occ: Agriculture « Rio. Subhashnagar, Hubii Dharwad District.
Shashi@Shas1u'dl1ar S/o. Vcnkaraddy _ Amati 36 Irpnrg a canal. \r J 'V, . VA ,- Occ: Business
1.. .. - ..g..
n 1 _ n-_1_1___ ' 'I,l'.'.-L.123.' ' V "I0: DuuI1aIau.1Lagi=IL,n. , Dhaxwad District. H '- f Ramesh"
S/0. Vaiakaijgcidy Ayi 34 .
Occ: Busitmas, E?"l'.'-§V ';C!1iE1hnsfljfi°2;a¢i.'ar"- II' VI l--D$VIl.o-'llJI«I|I-rusunuun. abs'-' ':e_1uh1:, Dnazwanj ngmcg. % S] o. Sisidanagxiwfila; 'Hoaamani * ' Aged: Majo1',Oo(:: Teacher " R]o__4th Cibaa5._ADeshpandenagar IiI;;hl,i,'w§Jl1axwad District. L_«.a}:%:.*1-c.-3a A S] u§"LjNiAi5afianagawda Hosamani ..-..........'l.» itfistjlofg Gee: I-iouseholfl wuus. x R10.' 4" Cmss, Dcshpandenagar Hubli, Dhaxwad District Siddanagowda S19, Nimgmmgowda Hosamani R] o. 4'11 Cross, Dcshpandenagar Hubli, Dl1a:*-.-:5-.6. District; fifi fin-A find !:°
13. ' I-5| .
Hanumppa S/o. Govindappa Hosamani Aged: 58 Occ: KSRTC Driver R/0. I-Iebsur, Taluk: Hubli ' District: Dhalwad.
S/0. Govindappa Hosamani ' _ .fln.n.n-1. :2: trgnmu nfivmco uu In-Cl-ID , Dec: KSRTC Contjticmr.' V V Rio. iiebsur, Taiuk:
District: Dha1wad,_ ' V ' ._ . vA S[o.:.Gdvjnt1gppa V Aged: 'W,-...:==-1":-:*-- . (Joe; Kg1ic1i}.;ure., "
"D1... '-ugh 'R 'Ix; u. m;usur,; '}a1u}-1: Hub}: 4 V' -!:_)is1_mEctV:' 'I3hg1V-men», " - .... __ -- W/o.""!ia1::111I3ap*--pa Hosaxnani 3_ ' 5'2'. years, Coo: Household work R_[o...%_Hcbsur,.,f_!'a1uk: Hubli I-I-III' magma: 91-.--wad.
¢ ii W/'0}fj_Hé:manna Hosamani P;gt:I;i:..~"49 years, Doc: i-iousehoisi work 4% mo. Hcbsu1','I'aluk: I-lubli fli"strict: Dhmwad.
. Mallawwa \'I'I'I:'_}. 3.-u__;_n_9_|_: 1-I:-Adv I-Innninsani B 'I4-IVIFWIB J lfl'lIl"vI-I-O-ID-I-O-I Age: 50 years, Occ: Household work Rio. Hebsiir, Taliik: Htibli District: Dharwad.
17. fvififiiiifxafli S10. Hcmanna Hosamani Aged: 30 years Occ: Agriculture R/0. Hebsur, Taiuk: Hubii 1 District: Dhanvad.
QB Shi-.r9.ppa Sio. Mullura Age: 38 years, Gm: Agrics..11t,i;1;'_¢:="~ .. _. A Savad.atti..' hi Rfo. Chfldmmbi,__4'l'a1uk: District: Ecigaum; ' * (By sn C.H.Jad._ha,y, Adwmigy A - L\.N_D.1 Smt. Klnaumadéai V i 0.: Ashfik». :£mga;:'eady. .A Agedfil * _ Occ: Household wdrk"
R10. Sui:2ha:ahn£:gér,'H1ib1i' Now _at Ha11,i,'Ta1j:.k:A~Gad'ag. Re-p"*der.t V' _ F!.--Chandanagoudm'. Advocate) = 3 1 petition is filed under section 482 Cr.P.C.. . f:i*a31fig"%§ quash order dat-.=_a.r.i_ 20.11.2003, passed by the District as '.Sc'::4sions-----J:u.dge, Gadag, in C-rl.R.P.No.42/2003, thereby cpni'ii'1'?r1in_§;<j':orr}*us1* datm 05.03.2003, passed by ll Addl.Civil Judge (Jr.Dfi..) Ba JMFC It Court, Gadag, in C.C.No.33/2003 {F-.r::". 19,"2oo2} 5'. ate. This peiitiofi Mm'-as an .92' Ana! h..J.=L'in_g this day, the Court ' 't:1a:de the following:
9_8.2§.B The p.et:i..L..:I...1*s arrayed as accused "in V' secuons 141, 14-", 17, 149,494 rfw 34 :90, oat..- _Ie§';f_:
Addl.Civil Judge (Jr.Dn.) as ii Coufi="t:G"ffi;*g. have filed this petition to qtiosl; pmncn L ;"i11g',,nt,,,:eig.s e ("5 . I irve h.'""'c'. lg-.;-.2t.*--'.o§d ..o'_;5tse:t§it:ione1's.
3. 'I*1ie'ti:«e;§'xa~:éc1J%Cqui:a;1*«s";o¢ petitioners would submit comp}aint-- allegations to attribute of fjfsetifioner No. 1 with respondent. In bigamous_man'iage or ' tiniu 1-? No.1 'm-ltl'. méuoner [es-...-..a1.-_n_ir.1e1ation of averments of complaint in 3 of orr*'"}.aint, inter se m3.a....r-.....ip -1' petitioners is V' v as follows.-
Petitioner No.3 is the father of petitioner No.31. Petitioners 4 to 7 brothers of petitioner No.1. Petitioners I'fU . cw'v'-W _' \ _nts of petitioner No.2. Pe 'tioner 'oroth'-1* "f fititiener no.2. . ei.i.Lon..rs 11 to_.1.6v_4'aIe'niateInal _ uncies and aunts of pefi'rioner l'u'oj.1. Petitiener' cousin of petitioner No.1.~_ "Petitioner Fio;'.13" 'w*'s management of bigamous
5. in "iew ef "else: between parties, submission of _i"»fr the... 9.... I1... avennents. . or "'oet:Trnt of 3 to 9 and 11 to 17 be does not reveal as to how 10 to have actively participated in bigsmous No.19 was the priest. There are " that petitioners 10 85 18 were '' snhsisternoe -1' marrfie of petitioner No.1 with respondent. It i "'sfi net state" as t... ..-ow they have abetted I-'nu.
E:
32 3
AA to fierfolm bigamous It is fin Lu: '.1...,...,......
"order. the learned Magistrate has issued summons to aoeused 1 to 19 under sections 143 and 147 IPC, which betrays lack of application of mind. it is defined learned I
-1| 1 framing charge.
6. In View of the above, I 2 n The er-;.~.-:--1.~.a1 '%a¢;«;pted'%' an The ixnpugned order as it 10 Ga 18, arrayed a accused 10 proceedings as it relate ta;