Karnataka High Court
Sri Shivaram @ Bhadravathi Shivaram vs The Police Sub Inspector New Town Police ... on 3 February, 2009
Equivalent citations: AIR 2009 (NOC) 2297 (KAR.), 2009 (4) AIR KANT HCR 146, 2009 A I H C 2409, (2009) 4 KANT LJ 264, (2010) 1 KCCR 532
Author: B.Sreenivase Gowda
Bench: B.Sreenivase Gowda
1;»: THE mzjia {w:c:m>2%r <31? .E{ARE'\lATA§<;% AT E3at,€.:dtIé:1i§; fht: 3rd (£33; :31' f£vE%:;8§a:ws§2:?,.:2_é§;%--€3E} ._ BE§QRE " " % ' 'FEE; HiZf.rN"BLEi'; i&iY:'~L_3'¥_fi':*3'Ii"iti1}§": £3, :§§;%£é:§:;:*xé;x;§é':";_§ »é§Qvsé_::;g* C w.;:=.:~;m. i?1iJ§;''i.$§€L}*€§§? { fms-;e::g.;4._% E3E'FE§f§;§EN' A "
3:21 S%{%'¥§i§AEsi B}£A§2§éA'=:Ai';4: $:};:%;g=,§2A:s§ , :§.;sf:> C§~i§N§*i§\{§'aE% -. I sa<3E:;::» Afazgzs? 4:3: YE:m$_ ace; PARESARA §-"{3§?'~;,:'.~.:§, _ ':~'iL1:'i"%'.:%.S'E';;'%§2'«E.'"i"I'E-.§}J£?=E§L"F~f(3§=Eg_ . _ E§;~§A:>EA'¢A?2«::5?? =i * _ * ' ., ,.K?E"{'ITE{'5i'€EI£ gas;$2-§.v2::~:z<9;;*:i%*."%s.-%~::1§;;;':af;2x;A%:A;vvé';3§*;;'V éfifi:
R '"i'E--iE,~.?ifiLEx'Z':E'$I§¥'%§ fi'-ES N525; ':*<i;;2m~.: ?a:s:,::::--: s<:g;..*':;<:;:é' _ -- BHa§3R:§'.f;%'"i"£--§§ v:}77v.3{:2.
' A S;;%e%:7'£' :2%:3§<:a.a:iz~--s2' ---------- -« "
A 1:531: 2z:2:?f:'ALA Nayzawa 'E131-;UR " ;;:;g:3'z2%E£;z;T 28 'fE3:'3;§{S..
* §?<V3;-':i'3_Q¥.}J-.}§%f$~EE_}E'Ui5?;:'%.. L%.ST Rcpaa, ' --. s§::%:';a::z ';;:2m,:'{g.:si2«.,m ':*;«::»am,.E,, §?>R<';?§'.&~: *1'C2W2~£.
§%§"€;5.£}jE2§VATH§ 57'? 3:22;.
7 1») 3 ":::¢:;é SB{ZR.E'E'}&%§'z' . §:A,§aN:;:'AKA 3"P2%T'§, W{s§s:§E:N zr:<;;:;z!§:»§§na>;3:{;éz=s; z«:ar;2.:<>§, as-T %"§.A}®E, K.a§.NA"§';%E§:-E ' §£<>u9,z2~z<3 BQAREE c:s:':r~.g?;:E::»::
2; 5;» mags E:'»':l'~§G2%LQRE~'?} §%E$?i'T}NDEE'%'?$-
£33; S§*e=i'?".§*«»I.Sz"%§{;:JEE€§ §i3I§,F'§'§~'£AE~=II'{é'a: RG15; §<"{"}§ RE, R3 E§E2§<3,\é'E}{}} has 5 "E'%iES W',P. §'iLEI{3 U?~§Z§3€F{ A§€'§'1CLES 21.253 3% 1312'?
C£f)E'*§$'§'¥'§'iJ'£'{{}E'€ £3?' EN'D'§.éi. E3'E€A":'§i'é'e'l'} TO ELEEASH '?§~{Ejm{E'¢EE?i;I€.§_I'$¥;§L;"3 §*'R{;>iTf§Z'§;%'_}§'%GE3 QT. §.4,5.:3{)%'}'? PENQENG %}:lP'{Z2§€E:1 STfiTE"'--, M' 'i}s»'(I§§¥iE"£'€ {§{}§eEE*e'I¥SE§§{}i'*i'. 8Aé'3CE:3s£,{3§?lE VHIFE AE'vfE%§3§={.E' AI'%D"€.} S'?.='i'~£' --« _ EELL F1}R'i'}~£E{€ P'£€f,3€EZ§}E3EE'*E<Z§S F'E§'€ET3EN{} §}§Ef"{}E~?iE "
'i.%.'(}iwa'§§2?€ aCZ{L3E*JI'i-«=fiiE%SE(T}i'%. EXT §"3z:3x.I\E{E£5iL{'.}§-252 375, 14,33 2{){;':'?' '«'_"§D_Efi.i_€NE}€..El. This i¥.E', ccsming on far: p1"é§in§§._:ia:"§; i'£::a_'r'ir;g "
Swap, this (E33, {ha C§::1141{*t»;gi§.s:.§§edti;}'V_1<i¥ fgélg-.s';f£L-*:;g.tA_, Qaa§§% xx' T136 pcatitiaiaer iii has. smzght. far 3 'fi?E"it Qf Cerfilerafi. tits tggzasgiz ::§1i3§':* E (ii. }4~8-0? issfafié, 44 '2. ' ;;§i3€:»-Evfiagfiéfiixéaés.-I:{:§;33¥§Hs€3 a§i:p€:a3":i:3g fern' i;E:c=:
p:»2rtie&;i7s:e;:':{;i" i:1£;h:ding ifm': TE::T:;:smg:1§{§ :10'£ic::<::
- V. '_ 3, 'I'Ifit:: seizéifii_j;f§::§jg::<::':<i£3:':'{. iT:}€:<i 21 €?€3I:}§I3§aiIf:{= 322 E36? £&'Eii"z:«E:x:_V;;.1fi'~E}~_§§€f<3:"€: théi ihigstzfi i"€-:S1:1{;:'1§i$:"3;i 1'€::qL1€si:"1:g ta: {iireétf firifi' }j3é€~i'§i:3::{é'r is hand Csvfir '£316: iiiliiii :0 %;:e;::' §":E.1S¥.G{:}'! Thfi third 1'e$p{::1:ii:im; €'§z3:m'::§S8i0:{1 by ' _'E'%'iV§V'§§;f§Z'§I1g {ha itzaztzpiaini 21$ {:«:".}I§3p§é§§}1'E= 2%}, E{S§Ef{T3;' ' €:C§§::1p13_im;,/ 14:E3'?'j2{§{3@~i}? ia:.:~3d_,1:--:{i z':0i:i{:2:i 'Tm 2:125, p€tiiiz:):£'§<i1* a§;}§§:;g §":i:':f: '€13 appfiar 'iseftrrsfi ihci: {Ti<3:11r:ziSSi€:;3 {:11 SQ-Sufi? J ai. Z L:~.%{.} ;3_.:i:, ami ii: is; {§§.Efi,("3('§ 17:1 '%'f§"::'t7: i}{}iiC*»f.'i Vii" ijfié -----i'(A;:-- €¢i§;}§}%ffiEi1" 23:1 '€i':€:: e:.3'.;<zi"T~:% 221_:£:fi ~~§i'i".§:if:§ j'i:':':::§"'e:k:t{v:::":'13§:;-§;3;i:':'i-._*5' z53.§'i}"}fi:>s'.E..:§'€i 3}} xnaiifi 33y ':'.Ei1.<: s_~:&{:<;';I':i::§ :'9é3:$§f:iz:;:j'i%;i.a::1':'§ ?:2§ {§€3I1:~"§i€3f3i"€.'§tZi in a(:{:<m3:'{'i2a:I1£:€::V'§%2{3.ifé';_ 1a.w§" 4: Szi '*J€:T;*%:aitt:r$%;.._A £}§31£i.?;é;i_;. :4 tflégj i%22;:*ii€:£:i'; ('i0u:1.*sc:§ af;s§:>ea§i§zg }i}€§{§§§§}I3'»é':i" '::':i:$:::i*_'€:r1§:j;i_§?§'fi"i:a1:', thr: im;:sugr3€€': .:'1£:i.i<:s:: «5 $35.1': :::§:té§.::1::': ES'-. _%%==':§i:iZ§l.§':g-;s' E.iE:'igai anti wif:_"E'1c;auE. a":;sfi:.%:31'":E"f;s.f" Gfj53axa; §3;:":d_ 3 '§}§'£i}:'SW{ti}3' ésétifiiig as5:_<.'§{-: iii-i"::é: 533336,, §?::1"- «::i;:';iV:9éi; ;'S:'i;._A_}asE}§;1:§.::ar;a,::";y £§<3w{is:1, i:i1:;% it;%z»:1':'1€te:'i {:{')§,3i!7i?3€i §§jp§u;§<%:e2V:'§::g '-":):"9 fi'}f?2 séiiiozitji :'§:S§.";{>:'1s:E€i§1t s3:__:i3:7:.:i§$ «i§:::;--ii: "ZS" 532$},-=' 3HHfi§'i'3'.i3fi is$i_.:6:i:i bf; i';i"1r:~ "%::§1i:':::E 'I;'fiS§'3c'3f:":€i€I3.i'. 1 ngwggfii' }:;:=::.§:.if:2§:<i::' {":a§'"E v:":§'y W621} :aip§:;:~:a1" b§i'fQ1'f;i tbuti i;'E":s§1':ii 1"e::.:§3;T:s€:s_m;~:3":::1'fii;i'A z=}_:";::i :*:::$i3i: mi: paéiéitéail E3}; itiiiilg €1Z9§T3j€"_t{:'?f.f§G§E$ if AA 2mg,' "i'1':'::~:: i{:aI":1$r:i éffimzasai €02" '£336 ;:s:%i:i§.i{;§:si:r i'::;i*Eh€::' ' --.. '::s»*:._?.'§§11':i.'5:.§s '%_'i.E.:::~3E£ -2.13:: $t:<'_:<:;I1<i :"$s:.})®::'§:'ie_iti";ii'. an-zi £161' husliéagzd --
-- "::'§%'i,a.'Ea Néiyaféfjéi .§"§§3"}{E_1I' E~Z{£"E3 €316 :.:a?:.:,1:"ai §.'::;1:'i::1E;.5 of H16:
r::E*:iiz:§ _?v'is.i:1}:.:I1z§§§': axiii i:hr::§; Ezazii givim fiat: ifiliid in U1 6;, Tfza thirtii IfiS{3€)fi{i1ii1TE'€ is 3 {7i~:>;:"*;;m=::i_5r:5i€:«:f1"€:ar}fEi§'i:=i%Ei;:'if:~?;:
:.::t1{i<'::r ihfi ;':mV§$i0:3§»; cf i{a1'r1at23j§a"'E§-33:67_{1:i>::aié*;i:i§35§03:.€62: Wfimfiié Aijii, E998, (h('2--E'€i§I: aft:-:19'.:"é§::91'1;:::ci 'i;r§. as SE:c:::'tf§¢ E>'t:m::Efi<:«:'1$ 0? $116: '«::,§é'E:1::1isS;i<§i1' Vgi';-*;1vé"1T"1"':.i%;1"1:?{.'§ V u:1":i:'i&:" Sec}? 2:2?' E3716 %;ai.'i3i::_E?: 1f_<':.A;:§'x;i:~_3-."i '£":=';:s :
9. F"L1171Ci"(i€}1{'1$ <9? L '.1€i?i;%:;€:;::§.5V*3':§f::r1:» {1} 'IChf:
agzgxxazzzisgédgiz 511332 'p§::'fQ'r}];3_ 5233;. 131' 3:23," of 'ighe:
i'e::£iG*;a?i:"%_:'g i';j1:::?Ti<:::;1s1 :3?a::3€E._x,_=-':?-' " iafi iI:12:fi5:ftiVgs;a.t€:§" 433§i71f&".:§fi3'I.£3:I§l:§I'1£'éI; I£}£?§£§fi1'S ::'€}ati11g tit:
---- "flit: S£:1ffi'§!;¥..£§1'''£T1 '--"§}I'Qv'§i*5:n:E"' fox' '£'3QZI1€1'1. Lmzziaz' file: CQ§i:~.?i'§i';§?.i€}I£' Gihfi}? Eaws: «-
€733 '}:_:i'<*:é$€:j:'é_ 1535?: i;?ji;é; C72'-::}1:€::'r::1':€::1%:., a:1z"1:_1;:fij; anti at gait}; V:;%:hs::' iinahs as $116 cr;2::m1i53.i0:'1 ma}; dc=:e::1 'fair, '_1'<3+p¢:»:'f:.3 i_,i}3€_}f'£ iihfi 1»'\?€i1"§§i§i§ of Erhosrz ' sa.-:{fe:g:.;a1'é:3;"é;";' A :3:-v}:"'~«:i:i?c:§..7{'*c--'i%31 S1_iC_§1 :'¥::p<::ri".s5. .1f'f3(3C9E'11'I:€i'i{1%1?§€}I1£'3 far i:'1fi effesiiivez i£}}}3i€1I1€I'}§,Q.fiOI1 {Ef izhggsse S;-a.€gg:.1a_r<;§3 ft); i.m«=p:*0Viz:g theii {::):'1::Ei"¥;it::::::s Sf 'é-'v'€33:"£i%§I1 by iha ~. 'g_S!:at€,;
{{1} 1"(iVi€:W§ fmm iiI'{1€'": it} §".§I1'ifi§ {Em €:xiSi;§::g p;'(}ari5»i0r§s <;=f the {3o1'1$§.iiut§Q;1 amt: sgaiizezr Eaws affetsriiizig 'Erie 1239:2161": arid 1*zi:<:t:;n11f21$:"i{i a:me:1d::1c*::1!;.3 t'w::1'c::(; 30 2:3 {:0 -guggcstz mtrnfitziiai ifigisfaifivfi :§1t=:a$1.:_re§ "tit; fiififrti 3:123: Eaczmfi 03: inad-::::§ua::i£~::-3 :33' Si'19:'t:::emiI1g3 in sash Eegisiatiensg %.
Ea} i:,a_k:a 1:13: {he casfis Qf v'3i{:£ati<>:': <;f.§:}'§é:'..;;»:'::§$;risic.;3*:':-1 .4 2 of 1315 Cezistitutieza z~:z:"1d ;<>£7»V(::ii"1e1'.' §az§§S'*:i€}at§31;g: ii: vmm6::: with the aJ;;pr0p::%a§:t:A2:::i'jfm:":ifE;isi'::3;2. f {f} 3C1{}.i{ ifitii} c0z:r:pi3iI':f;s--..a:"1{i iésééé: §'E?=1~1§;";'?f*1'1fa§*§"£?é.V§f3'f§¥?J"'§€L'{'; 2 L sf mat:f_;z::'s raiaifizxg i\;<;,:;1- ' {E} r:3epriva'i'.i:;_n {)f'ié§0:;;§ ?cf::}.f'§é§' E'égh€7S':V iii} :':QI':--§n1pie::'::i:?i1:"gg%;i::§1_'o:£g§:§12s?s fi3"1a<:t'€~:i is §1f{:A:is;ie §3?.'QTLé':€_.'fi§i{)Il m"v;vG::;«:é1*1 and 3150 in VE:.<:hé«::v*:;_ tzifnt-: :.>7:;j'€:::_:i_v¢5: 30f éqzaality am: :3::§}:a1r;§3i:;ei{;{T;
it '_ {_i;?.§}""v., §'i{';.é* V -:;{:::ii'p1_i;'a:.:ic:t3.,_VV_ .€V:a§ p:::§;icy (if:LiiS3:C%Ii§ "T'AV.f§g;11id't;§i;j1¢'::..A' gr. ir;si:'u,«:'tir_311s $11156 at . :1;:i'§7E.gati:ig._ "'---i"i£air(is.%1ipzs anti <':'§19§3'£J3;'E}.}fZg 2£*§Efa:'€ §;:?1_d"piz3v§cEi11g reiief tr) 'W{);{};1€fl 3.13:1 % ffiaji-3 i,f$1::'.:ft:r3 iSfS'i_,ifif5§ arising (mi, :31' 5115:}; ._;;z1§3.I:'é;$}'$- ex-iii"; app1'0;;;1"§at<: az«.1i3T1(;riti&s; " '~ ._{g} -:;::[»fiE..AV é2::3:* spfiactiai 3'§i1.:€ii€:s. <31' ii":::<is'tig&3;ii0z1 igiziga ' ;31'c;>bi€::1:ss 0;' sim.aii:;:1:3 a1'isi1':g Gut rgaf €§.'i§§::rij3:1i::g*:_ii{3n amt? a.t'1':3e::itias &g£1iI'1S'5j', wamfixa iiifiiliifi? 31$ C{.)1'1S'§.I'3§I'HZS SQ as ':9 mcemznerari st;'a.ta:~:gie:~:. far f}1::=:§1' reitmavai; ""§h}1:I:€it::'t.ake pr0m.e::si'3?a1'1ai fifiii educat.i:.mai ' " research 59 as ten suggast. vmjgss Qf ensurirzg due .E'€}f31"€:SfiI}f{:3_'§I§OI1 of wemfim in 333 $;3}1fi:'€::-2 311$ idr3n€:ii'y fagtars z'espa1"1s§?g2}::2 £231" §mpe1'::di11g fhtiii' E-3_€iV&}"i(.'f€£i}€?l'3j, szxrh as} iack of accass 11:3 izcusing and basis: serviea, izyxadfiquatt: sr_:pp»::):'I: sfifvisztes glad israzéznaiagifig far r€:':i..:{:iI;g £§i*us:Eg:=:I'_;f 3:153 Qciéiigaatianai heaith ha;»£a:€iis..u :5f1{j1'e:7£' f'<[:3:-- ixxweasigzg ihtzir pn:sdL;ctivit}%;
{1} insp-fiat :31' {E1336 :0 ha i1é:S.p&:r;:i.6(i ai'_%:a;i*E..3,"a::1::1,ér;i'1§i"'. V' $101118, won1e:":'s i;1's-f:l.t:1tic:;3:_ £21' Qizijséiij vgfiacci Gf , L <::1$.§.0(§§; Wham E¥C3I11f3i} "gins: kept _f;I§I'iSs'GI1€I'S er o:§'3az"wise azlgi {aka x'i;:g";i x§.s*i:E1 €:ET1€r C<_1I}'1c::I'm:d azzthoritifis i'::>1.*.:f«ii:";1¢§iia} giciimg, 2§*h{§rr:m'?:::' f<::11m1 11e{:6:ss33'}'; V {3} fuzati fifigatiern."i:év:3§j9*§:ig.:';:"s$;:§~:~3Azfi'e€:':_i1':g a 123%: i3oé}=';r;riL'é3;§:;13e3ié__; 2: _ -
{ii} 13a:-*€i<i:§§3%i3_,§'.tt §.;"f_1i."§ §9';r:3vLe:%é <:>:3;jf£ the ;';23a:111i.1"1g pmcms '::'i"'§@§ii§3ar:é?:2:1{):I1§C £§€¥¢:l{§};}ZI1f:;E1f Q? wgzzzeng {E} €::xga;E1_:a{:*:_ :::~f the Ciflfiifififéfilfilfiii sf m:I§.t:;€;"1 Lzgadelj iE3§."'Stat€;
_ Blake :§€ria::i:¥.icai rfipert. ta the Cmvemxneni 2:921 341:; '=-.!3;:at.t€;: per€aiz:1i:1g £0 Women and in "p.a.:'?ii:t1,1fi'a:§:* ¥a1'ie::sL23 difficuities :.:11<:'i_€:* witzich ' %szC';~z11¢:';' 'tefl;
{1"1}'}iI1'ira9ive Wit}: ve§L:r:x':.ary aI*ga11isa:2::ic;:n if} this: vfi fate, mare parficuiariy W03I:t:x'1's 0:'gaI1isati0ns besiaifis govenmiaxitai {§f:}Z13;{"{;1}1€I}i7S éifid its age:m::ie$ in me discharging cf its f¥.E.I':{:tiOflS;
{:33 assist 5:316 WQE}€E'§ ta -::"::r:$:.z:*:s: @q=._1a'i and fair justizze in Izgatliizzazfiai siispuftézs ¥Jef'ere the fanziiy <;:s:_*:u1"t:5;;
WC.
E'?
{1}} am}: {33.'.h_f3I' znafier 2¥hi<::h 111$}-' bt: £7f:i,§fiFi?Fff€i{';»v.§:'i;'8 by the C.'()'§!€I"_{111'3.€iI2tZ pmvitiaszi t1'1a§__:f 331}-'._T.;::1,a»ti::::'< Sp{iCifif:{i in 511$')-S~?;§'ii'i{§§3: ~f1.}_is fL113:i%:§'§,a'.5:1z{t::i;E3§?_V C0m;:3_§ssi§3fi: fér' "W;:_>i:i¢:1' censtifijiéd 'L1n{§€:r* $xecti':3:1¥__3'* "<3f"~f;'§":1e_ Esiatiitaijégii CQ::1m;is$i::a11 fm' W {3»§"_[1€I1 fiy:i:Ti:.,'=i99{}.v{if:§§§1';x*aI'; Eifif. " 2f} 0? 5£9"~3{}},, théz Siafe. _{"301:.i;}:_i.§;a$_iVc:%:?1 1"'Q:"' '21;<;:17:1e11 " {ha I'~§ati<3;1a} shafi cease iii: 1'1.a?.e'af:_V'j:1ri.*5+ti*i=':'{'i:}:'1 13:1 $13011 E}1att€}."$. V " "
{:2} if a:1i'.£10riti.€;s 3f'{;5ft'i3."3'€;":f£§ib :i:<::'...i§; ;é:§.a1;;S& {6} cf $1.:.b=- 530301": {I}? £3353? ??':§_ci::L<:>;z3. an the s1,:gg:5:%5§i{:::'":.:3. ' ~61" rf:g:f}?:fi1II2.c:iii{i':i1i§U1fis 11:33:36 ':23? E116 {):3111:1,1.i§sVsi:$;V*i,.;_ 3:'; '«:1§;;3§; ..:.~afg_3t:>r£:. fiT1c: same: iii} thf: €}:}§:sfii"I::1_:'t::3'i§" i=shiéifi'.--,ta§,:a%:~1'1ec¢:ssa:j§; affiiiiili Q8} _ '§'E*:_--':A ?'s<:~37é:?:_n-31:31: $31311 eauszze £316 ré':;:Q°z111:1a;i::ig€j{>I';.§'pgf' $13: €_'.i01111:1i$:3,i.{.:13. it: be iarid b€:¥':.:;_:"f:1_€a.{:':,1 §v.~i'm:1l*;:;.r:*_:"i.:»§' tilt'): Sizaifg L€§'s1a%:;:..1:"t: aiarig withtigxez1:zzr:::m:"§13.d'u311 ¢:a<;;:z}aini11g the actimx taismzg ; '«;3:~_ §)I'{}pt3'$€iZi i{) "ha takén 0:: 1:13:16 i"¢&ci;1:111:€:§1(i3i:.ieQ:1s éi,I}Ci %;.I'1<3 1':5:'a;$r):sT.1:3 fer 1'2.9I1~acc€ptz2_I1Ct:, if ail}.-3. 0f an}; s.i;1%i%}:1_ :f*c:?:f;::0:z::I:t::'1(i3.%ii01:s'
- ,"?hé'_"_'3_LiL3§é:ct{ Inatiiiir ('if the Campiaims is a 1'€i{}1.i€S'{ zziarfiia ':3; éiifi :21-'ié r@sp<:;:1dv::3:1tA gyrayirig tha <§§<::Ii§1::1iss§<3§1 :23 " .,ciii*i3§'t {fie p€;ti'i:.i011E::" 15:: Email aver 1:316: Chiici La, A3x§é§_'r:;§:;natha. :0 the (":"C:Sf3i}€i§£" {if rim 233 2'€:sp:3::uf£e11'i. it (£065 mZ 1{3f fail wifhin tlaf: ;)1.1.:¥*§.€3¥ {if {ha f:,3,1';{fiir311s cf the fifiuiziiiiissiitxzi :13 eI'm:"r::r::1'ai:a$:i unsifiz" St"-::::.9 0? the £1C'i;. Thfi éjhirii 1'€:$p{;»1"1{i{::';t. Ejseiiiag a a'i:.a§:,:it€;:'}: 'ixzdjaf «::::,¥:i--:é:ji;ii_j§}j1'?§:'<::éf; Elifidtil" "ihr:: fliti. §::::?:f«::a:'€ '§"'€gi§*§i,{',.};'ii"3g a:aj§;' ._aI1€':" iSSL£iE"ig 1'1<::iir:;€: i3f:a::3:v:e§3 is :"t::(;ij;i:'€':§;T A Fit)'-TT9ri§:é3;i?:1§:::*25::*..L%__ ifiitef {.'.€)}1':}:3§3_§I';z'{. azizji fins} ::22.:"i'; xa%'1é'§:.ii':er {Em " 311'z;fg::"C?;'VVA::;3;%:t[é;r {>33 'ti';t=:: <::0::1pi:§i1':i? fafiése wi'i:hi:1 §"i,S V§}1:11"'-.f.ifi¥¥ .7<::";*._ iiétm 13:55 :"t:at_'ii:';g waif' §i.T§1€: r;i:~:I1}g::'i.aif11":}: _ S110¥:a':5 ff?-:.&?, i*§:.,»is a. fa'-:C{ut::$tT fer the cmsiaqiy of :1. §ji71i1(:.';'j1Eixf§::ifl V(L3;:'}'fZiS :1%_:_:i: '§'g:{i,}'u1:der an-3; am: % {sf Elhfsfi ":11:1Ct.it::~I:j:s5I§§r:_:13;:i§;v?:*é;:§ci._:g{1-:1€1':Si.§Cti«:::"1 Q 935' £136: Act. %';;':z';§ ':3§j;§'i::i_<::.::*.i 'i:»§S:.it.:{%___a':..? A1'mt:xu1'*a ia whaiiy '".§'7r:»m*«3§;¥:e:?:%'i.; _ E?»-'j,'§§1€}1:;§.f. j--2,:i3'-iss:'£;i<f:)::ie:§*1?:._éiggi" --amihQr:it}; Bf Eases: T1125. ':;~e:i:*.:g $30, if 7:3 uV:'1:3?; 3f1€££;fi$&:~;:1;i'§;"'_.%:4{3 aék the p€'titie:1'1€1' ta appfiar __i:i'2f: i;?:1§i*s':§;. ,1j§;;:-;{;«{31*;<:i®:1*t. »- €.':x3;:n1:1§.s$i03:1 anti £136 hi:-3 ' .t:}§jN§:t<:i:i§4§'n§ «vM.i??'E£::1::':$, .I%;:'131€;:s<:u3'e E is mm. ss.1$'§,ai§1aE3E<i: in 3355? ':«;;;':'ei§%«t,'i':&A:"ii':':a:¥i: ii: is Eiabia ta be; $6: asicie, ? §1" the raasafis s'£.at&e:Z i1eminab<:>v€. @216 W???
"T fIi'¥ij i'§i{i}'I1 is aiigwed 3:13. impzxgflaé nesiifrte ~-- A13:1r::x1;3:'€ B "'€Ea.t€dw f4»~8~';3{3i;}? iS$§u€{1 by' $116 31?': :'fisp0z"1:;i€:13: :0 the, E0 ps::i.:i:§~:§:1€: (:afii:::g u§::r<;:3": %.i§:i::é. ;::6'iii;iz:>::1r31' ii: E§§?s}3f§'€'»:37i}.' Efiafigyfit ihé f3Q1:m':i$r3it::::1 is 56%;. as-is::E<:';.
?vigni-