Karnataka High Court
K S Vittala Shetty S/O Kasala Somanna vs K S Nagaraj S/O Kasala Somanna on 28 September, 2011
Author: Aravind Kumar
Bench: Aravind Kumar
'¥.§§Vi§§{'f§."'{',£.'t g:2::.§s%é3{§ 2éi?:f_ .:?1%i,§%v§%é%*E;;i»"i{}{§£§: {'§é3.'§l€;'f{§. 2é§.{}Z£2»Ei}%f}é§ E3}; E<""2:':é::é'.
_ '§T;"*_;';;'a_<t':§~:,_ {:{i}'z.§§'i..-§§§: E%%2§::";:3g.§:-2; %»*$§§.€i.1'€i%é.§§'"E{,§€?:? :§EI£€§§§:§EE€¥§}§' 22s::'*:{.§ {§€3{T:§'i?€E 5 §}j';£"~«E3:"i':':<#.§;:>;:_§ §:2§:§:§"3.s~s§%f'%;} 3§'T:§§"E'§{f}§_§2'::. E32 €fl?a§:"£s< 'Ei}'%,f§%%§?,% {E.z2:€;é*:<£
3. ':\»IE2f::';;'1,::':2.;,E:E':
;"e:':'; E%_.z':2':2;:.:':'::;1ié_ _E'v'E:ig§:";§:
Baéiih a:':% %_":ui.E{ii:2;g; {?{T}§'E§§°£.%.{?i..{§§2 REG E'~J{:§§§'>%¥ {E:'<:>$&§, Efizkgaiarzigaa-:g:.2<§é' Sh.§.m§>gg;2": ';§'<>W:'1.. V ' Shi':m3g2: §'}i:+3E.:*;1?i2£". ~ E§'?'? fgfii. .5:%:E:§§p{_)?§E}EB€i{'? {BY S§€§,£:w.E£aKS§~§E¥I EZEZSEE E?;.»'~':{"}§ AEi1i\?C}€3;<?§J§'E§"§7i€?}}€'R~<-"E :3 ' AME} Z"~{--~f-3 §i)ELE;'E'EEi) V/Q E};-%;"§'EIE'} Gfi-,99=2'€.3;E. Z7: " " ' ' TEES REA IS m,a::3 UNE}'E"ZE§"*SE{f'¥7EOF€ _ ¢e%:§{7éi.Pwc £GAfl§STE?§3&{Hfi3kfifi$ffi$$}EH%§REE§3AfEE}2é£Ei2S86 ?ASSEI} gm RjxN{L98f2QQ4_£3M.,TEE:"EE£E SF 'fi%E ?RESmE§G-GFm£gR%FafififififigncgugfxgfiSHEQQA, AL&8%K§G-'TfiEQ§$P?E£L'¢fi}_E%fifiE%§ ASEfi§ TEE J£Hfi&fi§N? A%§§:}E£%fi3E'B§§§:§_:3§§L19@? RSSEEEEN {lSfifl}§3/8% é3§'*fi§E E%LET43? :%§§ Ffiha NfijNS§¥i Samaaaam V """ * '= #= *3» "~~ TEES$§?€AL€fifi$EK§§§fXfi€AD@§S$Kfi€TfifiEA?
THECGERY§E§¥ER§§TfiE§Gfl£R%Nfi:
_V "_ V§§§§§EN?
"'"§'"§T§V§~:¥\i\\~\._ §%§§':{:_':{3'Z:§:?;.i'§.'. é:§;~'pé3=§:s_1 E53 :fiE€:(.§: Egg <.£a*:§"2%§:{%;;m§;. §'*£'<::,E <:;:.;:;::;3~;%_;_>:;1-:_:.;';:.g {,5:*§j€é'éé'..:':.€:+ss; 2IiE"§{§ Ee;.;j2§E§i'}; €35' §' §".:€ »\_§:,:§i3£;§.:.§':{-:%;'1E: gmii
2. 5
£2,-wa:.2:° Q? §1i§:«; :=s;<:}':: $z'é.E{.\«',E-§2m:~:§'1 is a§};'}<%z":{"§<%<:'§ iii} the <::.>z;2§:2"::.>:*:':i:~;z: g3<:%i,£.§;:§{:}':.':a E3::sw{%:* {sf A§f.%<}:'m+::3_: E*i:;:E«:i§e:~.:" ais:'::.{§ E%':':€.}§E. «:3?
::§};:3&%§_§22:_§';§_ 2?:<:,§m_§E_;<~:. z;-:§<::<é:,.zé:?<§:'2 <22? <7{1:'z:2;;§z*e:3m ;.>é;_%'£".éé':i<>.§.; *~.;.-§:t:{§ :'~':§'F.i7F.)1'1E§E'.fi% §'§'EE'£§. ;::§é':?:* %":;~1viz'1§;: 2.1:':{ii*::"s;§.<;<§i§ i.Ez{%. {'.{.'}§fiiT3{'?§'.E'7§:i§;"~. .
<=<;§;.1§;;'<}211_£s%;e ggx-::'§.i"§'i<3:': Em hzizsz; 22ffi.;<;::?£E 3;'":§:?;'§M bs§:g;;.:':z'i;.'€:':s':"s:é--:'_a2.:':{i '§,;:%fi;.
i:§m:."z":b §§:"3§:>z"€.:;;sim1. 'E€{:s+;§}<>':1{3;s:::'1i:_ Nazi ai'Sz;.";33'%:$€%':";i' 21:fi%f§;--..
§§i.i§{}§E':E'{:'§ {hair he _"§'2a:1:e: {Em}? é-t=.x:3{%:,:E1:>,:j£ '*~Ié1}2€;% {twig}§;zf<}.§f::i:§::2{_'g3-s:Ei"§i::>:'"2 aft 6:" E';z:arizz§ :,::'*:da=:2's::{><>(§ Eha _::<>:'1%;:€ez:';_f£:é% i£.s:%7_':.:r?..:_f:1":s%; ;2{:":«:.§.,§>.;}3éd:E:i<>;:T:§::
e:'mzm;é§"z,-2_E.e{i in 33:? i:?1e::"€:%z1.f3:.€:r Em §';:;:$ .2?:_:§E'"i:x§§:§i big Eiféi' ':':;%;>2"€;%:'s<£*:1t.&c§. £3}; iihéfif E022r:s:<:{§ Véi§§£*{}e¥%:§.§;%,%;';:;'§§Q.i': hzavézxg; ;飧€:1€;if3€:{i iL§'3.€€ §321§"E,is;'::e; ézimjg 22E,:.;1*§»?5 :39 §j§'E{': <T:<:::*:'1pmr:*:§:=:;z3 g__";:§.=%':':§€é,i€>§'L F{§;=s:§:>Q:'2 ézzréfi. §}¥iT'.'F.'i'i"i.§.€1€',€%{§ 'Ea; Eéff {i€'§€§'{:'{§ by ff}?-*§E€;3E§4"{é§f %':éi;i_,s§§21§:%§{iV"'{}'{3V€3§¢2{}E E ss{.>:.:g§":§: Eb? by Ea%a:";::.=:*:{i {?{§3i,31T32§-;§f,if§ 2;;.g:§§;;§3E'§;;%:"::1i 35:}; 2% ::s1s:n2e:} 9:': §'.§'m §_§;'rm,::':_«.:'E 'i.E':::é..§" 3?; :13; 22% ' __ §'§{;é é E"§€;?{f€i':$E:3.;i§.'}f_ :3} j 5'; '}E.,_§::,_;é3: E'E{1*E éézézfi §;:§':_§.}£%{'§iz%':r"2émi. §i.:=§" 52:3? ;.:.:::3<"%.::;3':.i:'3;;; ?;E'::%:
<:%<'i;_':"':':§3§f;';:é'2iéaa? g.><,%:.3.§,§<'>:.'; 222.3% 2:§%:'=<.;t::*::.§§;_§': s~.;;:2.§<§ {TE}E'"E"§.§_Z}T§{}E7E"§§f53{:? 6 §3ei§i'.i§:>:'1 kg E':e-:"<?¥E:';}; ;1{?{,'.€%pi1t??{§. in xziaéw 3? met: s_;e::::":<? ;':'i}'}§T3€::E§ ifs-2 {?':'§*és.+;g:z('.3::e;::%<% in '€:€':':"m$ <1}? i:E':&? €f'{l§.§.Z?._p§'{'}.E1'§ESE? §3%;'f"i,E.Eif§{}E'.3. __ 3 3:": ;<;u§:2§5§§E,'2,::§':i<>:': <3? J:.:{E§§:1':;e::'.:i, zmié {:§€r.:;?m<: ;.:a?:ssssz-%:§'»TE3§,:-* L<}v.->'fa**::" §>s;3;>a=%E}21f1€.* {i<}:;.2:°L £;<;%:'§:';:a%4; Q? <:<):3'1§}1'<):"11i:~9:% }§i;:'*.'i'i.§_j.'7;<f?_3:_'_'é maieérezi §'{i} bi-3 i:'_1z':;>r;3{};*21i:&:<E zmfi {§€{?E'é?*€f baé {§:'zm::%s, _;§r§.<:¢;i::;:fGi§;;;";;;§3g* E3}:-* '§.'@§_;.§.§S§1*y 2:2? E12136; :.:<)z:r¥;.« '§'2:3:'é;:i::>S "€i.€_} §?}€f£i'§'. *:'E=':.§=3.§'_;s? mu :fé;?3é.p<s:'a:t:'ix$::;~.é:%Q31§:§;¢ §"A£\Es:34 ET g'2C>{i~%} 'E"<';éI *=§éi;1g_,_:'ir;§%é::e ':'aQ§'_t, $;iz"viv€ 3953:' {rimside:'z:.t:i<m gi_:';.«:.§ 21{:<_:a:>r{§iI':g.Ey_ 'E,F:..V;fZ?;£-Q8-*§ §':=%»:T ':':«:t':°éc'I%3:,r {§§$':§":§s;;s~k;<:%fi;