State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission
Chandrakant Annarao Dhabale vs The Dy. Ex. Engineer M G V C L on 4 March, 2014
"§§£1§"aE§ ,: 3Z}i§.>Tg 'i~'éEii5§3s:§§'§i§3:if§¥.
m.v;?.--'»-im. 'CI{3=M"§s§; ' V 23%? '§."35§f§';;§§g§~}£;¥'§*§&.."-i¥- '§§';§§5E. ., €i§5€;?;5'.$&}?2'§§§' :§&§f?s,§ {%3'%§:>:;;§.,s§=:;
".-,~.;.,+>-;\ \\\~rne~'-Iii x .\.\\\\w-an .
§3?%1§&:i'E:£§§"§i§§;:%§§':§ §§l~'.'§&§3.§i§i§:.£§ $>:.:"::: ' * 'i'.3&::-airy. 3-in 'N§a;,:%::<$m:§xs*_*l §f;§s:£:m<::t':r:<s. A Iii 3' E; -{Z§?§§§.¥.92';?l ifiafl-dfifiéifi '$'.~:'.'t~£'v§1§iE;*-'*l.'a ".i!°3m:-- 'EM:-'* }'<.=';;:°:wg;é':::<»asaa?
_ \,!":.ss;:§:;im K.'-:s_--¥:~.s:_::'§§§_§§:§.§g. S;-1m*;~.. «;i::m.:2;§,L,.'.Is;§:::'m'i;*:~x*:;:"
' .-ifij-_§ §§~.:*£§t¢ x§§*~:i+§i £3. ;._§.sm';i..= Van-w :.s;':.:z't sas_!i°_ms-- fii ' .1 V' {i ?_:sfi:i?::3§:"§é fits? -'5;f--::n:»:«mn=m> ilfiiiszg-2:;z£§%sa E¥*a:::*:;;§m, sgsi f¥~*=a:m::: gm a::mm;s§ai;r:s'. ef s:3::a:t*:x§rs%a§am;:%:": {§.§K_'§s3§"
'E33; Eifirisstsfirarti 'i:§m' $133 j§;3jm§:'m:'r_:a:i 3:1: 4~;2s:;3é§;«s:&:i§ ¥"'s' *7.:§;§.:-six"; w~.;:.::§. ii: iizssté. .;:;§>gev§;§2;'§E, §§§m§§§; wifix :§a§ .82:
{ha -ap3gz£.i_E.é§n>ir .~a.,,»ivi:E. iviissiz, :iT:_:"--:s'~* 's:§.=;.%>;',*;:s;'§§:3-1'§s§as§-'Sim. £13?' :1-aefma ".-"'.'f».Q,§:i§fi.;'$.
,.'°°'a IV 4 I .
..z«..~ £0 .. '-3-_ §x:::':;m:e .if&'>:,3«.:'€3"§;'~»§.":'i" §3.§;:I§'3m£::. :m:i_ ii: §%::'x* §:¢§mi§s§a:\;§3 = ma i=.'%§.::.;:§.s* §:;a:;«:e 9:". the: ;:.mms;3%ai:%:§m_.t a. 7* ;«.¢:%,?
§a*s*::'§*§..ws$$s 'm 'tim: mis:s;r*s;'*§:3§; Sit':
ma {Em ssf ¢*::s';«§\t1.§Ze§§&iéi:i=§§_;if§t itf§2§:. E3 in yxxfikizsgg »;§:sa;;;s%'§n.=r::x§. srevm it is fm:i;£~.:a:::$ -23% ms: ::::':£3§§;%§.§§i§:§9;§:i.
iixst za:;§I';aa;gi;+§gg.§; in ..$::::fi ux'::§'%xfix* mm '§:$§3;.zT'3£ :31' {Ems «a:s§§2§:::§2s.:x: figs: that Esiiéi miai.
qr) "Em: <:«*:s£3f1§,3§§s:§:2'j§:§mi:f§§3i§§:3--iiiam: ;:::m;:f3é@ 'i*§m. .?£L}i§i:=.:'§it*:.
§fam:ring; _§%§§;'-- §>:§§*%;§.é::é§ at. mg: c:s.::«§'r2a_§§z§$c§%::t:\;f%. m;~;:§;.:':§};->' ggmug-3:3 mi' ;;;a:#;:s:1:»:¢> §1§*r.;'§a age-sgmazi §>:§ ::x>s:x:cg':§§:;;§:~::;121a;. herfure ifigsgxznxfiszsimx.
'Q __-.~.
X csi' ;§3*i*m"%i§3%'.~*iii'i:- §'?"m' NT. 1a§a;::.*:€;,§e:<s< ta '§§?i§§E >;:g)§.x°.2{a1 §7§.i?i':'*E"§£§§i.§'7t»2E"r ma .?ts_:§ aurigimsi Em ;¥?s:::*' tg w§:;~;%';;E:»:.<::r ea gm: §f§:«s3§§i'&tfi¥t:Iii§§;§ s:;:«§° :<z>::'»t'..\ is: figs I§:¥?S,£§§1§.§§i";E'i1§?$§»vs§&§i§%fl§)'§.E1§§§§E'§ ii} {Em W M?
\\\w!\\ , nfiiiii mi Qt' ~.*:;a;3;§§g§§§~*. ms ms. 33:m{§2. €32"
'its ::.~;m§; ;~::mn:r:1§eN,:T:1:sa§ --§1+:-i.§x~*:;:i§?;.-. in §;'§':.§::§ s;:::;am§e:r.:'ti.~'::;n.\.. tiw s:s;;§:n§:s2a:im;:;::§-- §,1§<'2'i$ :;:14ia§\.:<2:x$ w§i.s:-mm an vs. ii-.~:x::-r§ i?€<>:':*§é:£ '.§':'?§;*;§3:$:m°<i§::«~%§::§ V' . 1 ~« Qiixsii. -:2? _ 3'' ;§ .-.\ 3&3
-'i§<s3'm'{.;.
éififi §_;~' g;:m~>s2t.s-- smegi. 'ism? i§'~i§".~i&2*t§§ 33Ii§§3£§éE&§T§i§§§§1 iiszsmm. it waas xix-§§§.:.tr:x:§ :m.g:s§§§§e*-- %I_m*' ;m:~:'§3.~:>.§§§: §_m.*t:_ Em ::.fs:;:rmfi:m '£§'a.:s.&.
;m:sm::.i:§:i:s:x. fw:t2:;.'s=::'§ £2::§>._'1t31:tt'§z§::'$"£.=ss21a§i §3IP$7c?.§.°?.i'§~:5.T.¥5'£"3.:;"§ -:m§;%. V"
ms ha: s;;§im.:t ms::.a*»::i.:.e*' ikzsés' {$3 sfifi in Ema: =sm~:.§. xvhfiii .--m§.*s;g:é§:g=i':3agA.w§:$m* 'gm s:ix::%§-*., :§.:'?e'§e~:m"£;:;a§3:3: ix ta ';::':\':$fi§*.; Tfizmzs :§3;m=e;§'s;§::'.z*C. rm' ami. :§f§2.:m3$: mxszfi am fiifimi '§+'m*§::3:as, .§?%m;::~;>: _m::::*:.-;% Ems
-am arxugistastwzemztizaaii :;ssa;:r3:3:::~s¢:.
0"?
is» §§§:z:--x~ mg. g:N~.'::*'€§e£fs§':I *<~§_*§'.:§';s «~ xxm.
\ s;"ifi§' §,§fsi:§'°«§-3 mw:a.i§;zé' 112$; $tZ'.'§."Se'i$;¥t2'¢;'s_? §.% >e~s~'E*;a"i=::§rz: §m§s mi-:3.
zaf ffims "
§§is:§, $2' §3IY.'i3§'§'§i:$3s:¥§., «:3:
23%.' the ziifiili :im:fi~z_.3::§»s:v a«;m:§E:$ ' ;§':§:r _m*.:2}=' :::s::::t§::§:s2t:"_<:isa§ ' -. 1&9 §33.T£§"§3=3.3t$?l%'- '5.
"~s$é'=s:-- 3:;s§::s::~e3< --s:s.~;1 .§a§§;7.§>§&*ir1.§§°; t§mi.;»:4i<:§3:«; ax? ii'3:$' »w_§3§;:i§:
{_;§.§ in 7 E:":§;s:isfs:fzi$xgj ?»;§§§§é*sa Liszi... i--{:;:%{E :i.'vi§+_§ {L KE' §E't§.§'r if' En.
iLt=.:i~. 'iffifglkfiéfififii? E E1! {§§?§§§§¥ tin: 3t:<'<z:3.:§§;=2;i*"t';i§*'%?3':§§3>r:': .§?*Es§§is32§_s:ai 3:13.§%t;&2.'sf§.«e§?&? {3§:«if;:ij£§s,:i§_mim1 1%ms §=m;E:§ 'am s;:i§mai+:§§i" in iiiskixfim ws:s3:u;§:<§ f€Z='ii"' ::?£%r':3::m:£%:{Ea§ i§' it _m§a:_ 7;',3L§»%2.h$&_:§s:=;'i. maatfi. 33.:-'xezfi --$lk*a?;<*3T3.
m' ~:mau"st= ism" .t':§i§1i:k»:t~£i.
'*3 §?>';:r:::m 'saws: -smsi. a.§§:~:.=« m::nsi§§i+:rim.g "
§3§:;%€'.;$.'ié&i:--'§ it: :::'éa*-mm? «.3:.=H-um.:;::;:mg:2i3§':1zmi: &f;.;>;a:i £t.<;3~m'§.-$:$t¥;§e'3§fs& fm' ;:m.:., * 'msri? t'he:_::g>.%;'am- iém .mt a::.:3.:::'-m": w£ii:;i:;. Em' :~:3:ea::s:Qin§§ §1.§' _>a_§ 'i*m:: §*s§s:x<3:::§§sc*:i_<:m £3. fs:2ma::2.«;£. e:c»ss:t:rm;:e::g kw tin: as 1S§¥3I1§§3.Q1.§25$.§i?§¥i s.:::§ .%3is?1%l?§.§';'§fi.§§ F '¥:*.e'§»* '§§2<£'.'. s::mnt§§§as:§::: iaso 115757 aa:1:::§ §$33"£af:'s~i.fé:fi:{ :23 in 'izaijihs... °}.'E«:s::
}:'$im§$;§. ma: ,::sis-m§:»~iz§iimat is: ;¥T§2:e¢ §:§§<z:£3s¥ii'%.<':£*I;€§£'%;§ massti ;;:2fi:r:§mm.:;s;.::ci ia iixakiéii iw;
, aw. »i:ic::z::~:u.mm:r' ::§i»~:;=:*§ iifiafi; s:«m°$§;§3i£§3§s'§a$'i.t. ha §:s§:;»§ '<_ms§.:;n.§:r.. §'a~l"f§€:af
-:31-;.i;' "::h¢-gs» §3z'§::;'t1:*i§:~:. E~t*é;~;~:mm: is §u.:§t,.- za;::?§.§i 3§§§'v:?«§;-':£33t"' fismi .;i2:r:'i:>'e'*;:e.s_>§'e:«s.-"=~eé::%a:~*..:;*.i:--.--
€21.-'E §m;v;a= :=.:i<.-§s.;£ wiih. :22»? «im .=::+:§m;:駣~izi:r:4't.-
Q R E32'.
\\\\~ew.«x~.x-.->9:-*-xxw-\~'»5 .£&g:§;a£::ai& at s32»:i:t:*;i:sa£--i;e*s:1 :if.';s'=§:'::i;§;-'§" ;§:m$:%§i . E*§a:k§*'§*f_3 mi ::2::~:~:§<;é 3':3§i.s%;;s:§'§:~s-.¢s§ .
=§:+:?s £.§%.s2§< .m:?'? V €§§§_§'€f' sf.:«§ 1&im'<:§:s;.. '§:€;§--§*%.
i'3e'§§.%§§i§3§3f