Central Administrative Tribunal - Cuttack
Sujata Nayak vs Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd on 31 July, 2023
es S 4 f pees ae GD " ~, x ee on &B fa ay f as ; v7 Lor force fce or wed de 05 Ls ae eet pores nd tS fan my Danes es facet TLS pn open Prent ne eed ad ge a) cys oe Pe me o pent ess) oe « ae = (on pe) Facog, ae % Fay wd aot wee , na! eet gol ot £, > an ey a des an cane a Seed : 2 tos vo im Fae pe, 7 bene aS oe fen peers ane, wee, : nee on Be shod ae - Cs Seat fer ty jana "al captain pen, 'edo ' ' 5 ry i tome borer eet a pa th a ben 2 (he ay Rn, fen Tem ~ ns es Cy ; ip we SG wed Naot , wees aad weoloe and vee e ugk Pay wien pat cad oo pos ae tod Eo 'at ona "en ' Sade ifs wah cea oad Sad Sphinn coat ee ote, pam 03 ee pee haat final" ae nid i Ges cae a -
aot 4 Sed toot St ; Sock ie _ og Te ond oe a. een mer oy ee vo . is bow wath ser <ueed, roy "ew a4 bang - " ra 5 a Oe, na? teats" ica eis a hood Sk oll, book ' An a "
'oo o " ea * J a Neel aol fn. 4 ag - aad £5 . Laaed Pome' SNE oft fon . ove ' 'ae ned my fee wot ay 3 yo a pei QA : j oe : pens ma ; vee past Ieee 'eat ne. wena, tend "hn Ay Le Senet Lee ome pe, gra a be? ind es, ene we £4 Faad wake ~~ ae on Me © ' Ls 4 en oe ' oo WPS wes; ie ra oe. pes roe at: aw m3 z x om on x sgh ened 5 aj here ~, t a cobs ae can f been le von a whoa a " 4 Se a int 'od vere none a ° 5 a yon is we, Eeoad news, ben es ta ee, in aa fon let went nS « baad Peary * ee eat par or om Pas seen aes! eae ove ao pou : one baad 4 wy es ea We ¥ Sede * ree : ww ca ey pad eat oonee fee, i A ed J gk nee taco os va beet od we woe pied ee ie Noe cA ~" oe fog a , : ~ 4 Sed ive Sen % me ne oes, 'et ~ a, ee > ogh r, es ares t ete rages peat rat an fen Leet ede " Saeasd bead ent tet ne inst as cole pe ae en, yee we, fax ~ Bw ee fe, san ret feos A geen nore on: 4 Seon, the fova ond ae ES Lat shea teed bs oe pees Ls ot ge Sah th ot paged we ay a, ~ pee ei wey Sed roo a we ee cont a Bex wes 2 re as mone os, Bat 2s Soe oe ae ies ol L ores MEER i re, oe el Fe GEG Mad or 2 ark tt : os ff % oad en, Re ene re ee, a ie om ne wo * eee den, we ee es esd ad Ot ennnth wey ey rhon L pe. po bate bok oe booms et aa i> east anal tah ben, pen pra OLE : benas wee ye fone bone rok + Nat saad, 4, of ", pets Be ry 'ed tat wee:
dew Sa? .o re Spas: : gn pt moe ined Ae PP hh Ost crane whe ww.
ee, pe Pant Cad fe £ ead oe! pret! tek Leah As my Pe 3 oe a ub ae a tes by. #3 eas ¢ nat svt an ney 5, tat yawn ined neces "err te Paget wea, Paes wr ME oe fo - eed os Poona teed oe ye eet Se Sera If ca) bored pee, ra . oe 3 ; ; es oe : wiped ba Boe oe $ oe, caw mitt eet =, : Sooad A at ner Ay 3 se, pet ae peed pes a ifs ae "As Satine, hai, ; aes ince a . se) on, a vw peas poss a a ' hevbe. oP: Sinai soe deg aah oe os bat % = i ee ' ee heed om wy wey ot. .
pas ies a. Se 4G ad we pk eg ts es ye Ie bot 'nttere soe. pate ie cant we yn 2 hed . Ss Be Pe he ry ng Pecan' rand t "see. : heat vee ot 'sent ae ees orn wee ger aS, Peogt Le wR wr lance pane the a es 'eat pers ede, iano bot i anal Dae weet Paes and en Ss bos pat Foceed Saat! srten. iced ; et ee ot aS Sd ths oe, foes Tee pa rs oe es roto A ae pen es toe "dl Se ps ae et, Feige way aed cases oe OL ews ns ood pose he nod yee ea oo gore. et * Cok Paod {3 ; hee. as By ayee ons aceed ao bo fad aa io on, abet fy pea ies ieee we £ Cpe 3 ae A os «. Sad ben Tae noe . teed ee pews Pa 3 : fen, yee paane, St penne 'se 3. ve ~~ peed " weak oe aie tt, "ale baw, pee he book cod 3%, wa te wo whan. et aaa 'eet pee
- CS eon. ong ge we
- See det oe 4 fi int is ' oof ve al Le om ee Gy céi fae) pon, hy hk fine aoa Pad "maa -. ye Ay bese Lec , baad repens, $enees 3 Se wt Shee deed ie 43 ie sel ; toy phoce <n pen Todt eg oo bor 7a 9 Pact hs fees, eee od ¢ io, ee Int bah, OG hoe aad s ved 6s peed 4 SE . eee ws % Be wa a soe Past te 4 oa So ton oa wee Inet on Ye eet oe "na eee vn freee wean Slow Pa ees eet eed at pas Pees. nt fee oa ae 245 aa eseg ans on ee ce pss "a oe. San oon Raed, viens Par te ae we pn : Baan , pana' 5, $6, cae we eg reece adh eb d. a Se ee a S 'a yen at heey weed ga sete pest a % rye ed ane eas Pay, oe tng By pect . ¥ Se S,. Sy taf yes Lad pe a iy gn et 4 oa ys % gu, tenn Bah Bee wet ewe Sea, enh bok ae, eee, dias pt a, Dost a were cad 3 a tons epee Kes Bet ae pais oe jae en 4 Ess Ltt Rana Rd Few peed sree a <3 wen he, $v pe ae et basa oe eg bed paced Pas ee Ba Le aed 3 % bese ae baie A ee 34 oe "eg cae ae ee. a ie ween ree) smn oe, ae pasod rey B ieee net oe Fy a ped, rane acon oo, ee bated eon: Lae > 5 x ead oom ft Poet z ee, a, ory om a ee owe Faas ee ¢ 43 ' Pak we! wee ae boss Aes reer' bans sok os te fetes pevind: ~~ = i, oy, ft A aed eed. oo ws ae x a ears ;
hy et Son yr. ~ Oe & anc Befe yee, ; Boe Oo US: S won te tok pane gr, aren.
bond pea "nat ge book ye Seer Lon yt fon and Mee type Sb ve nee ae w on Aan on ase raced re ee, panes ity pen 3 7 Pack [ae whey, Les Mae id 'det ed itd ; oe we po fad ool we en vee ea een ne ores ceed eg he m weet, an Paaal Pee wares Ate ye 'mah a ifs wee ree ae aS Poni Loh ea ort pit gee. aor apes Le) aD Geb ~ tet . ames mn ' it neo, i, 'et is ead fans wnieng ae gee Sas ent ment ewes 3 2 oo, s oy et nes rere, send prs aa Newt Wee es ot
a) LY. a ns ed a3 ae peper 'en ne ae Shr £64, we , : a oi oe rd ames ae Paves re % age onan 'anet ween. "ae 'ee : os reree we 23 : es aes ¢ whee if weer shoes, a3 oe can Pad ee i cs a reed re ; 'ors Pd eet pm Esp) JE 3 va 4 aan one ve ese rae ve a3 Pag is * "tes "43 wee 'a enet fee whee owen, wn, wares ts wee, By wn ~ rei ty = fens Pe pees tad Joo, Bae ten caka fink 4 pn pict enone wee vt <A Katoh ramet poe tes ~ teen [a5 ' Pod nd oS es oe me Sf fe BB fs x Z a pon, wpe pars raat re faves wry baal oo Past Seana na ae a, eed toe Sad Lo Fang a rae ree pon ars ' Paes eek Ea eo pies on ane Dae feos g ' at hap thee Sree, ree sedi pee as Paat es Poad taf oS ina yee bs yn ie tat an jon ree rs + aad or aot poe eetes eed eae "at? . -- hed fig fies e. bess bared ; he, : oud thos Gs ~ a es i" ty 7 ee ~~ & «© co OS oe ae eat Yeet tnt rn ra ven tee Fad the ane a =o "e on eee ~ ry "ae poe he a, nae en nee wos, 4 shent nes nore: te rar ot lon St Cyd ot ft, 'ent Piva a "ant 3 wt 4 "al pot ee egene rebnk Day hy pore th ot ca pis ta ert og St ores good, pa poe ea wort base yo aa ma ry ied yatta, "y 4 sd < va as rat 3 i % Bite Ss WES eed boars fms be yea z ag) ome 4 me ewe, deed fe. Fe ~ ee bie Mee bas Ww vee ty po bead eth Ay ae a3 z By pa ceed ac cad a be Lf yp " tn "6 ve oo a es, Ft "sp, mana oP, to wires ae ™ noe gf . oes ed ee me ; z weet bovis re yore ae om, ne, we Ya pera Mm ee wees eat ines is ow wn feud a deed fore iad hoaed aC paces. na & t 4 ied speed Faas pions 'ee, in ho et 2G OC io z Bae Fe a aes a toe bes rie % bom) Bea Ss Seed "
pass r ASG hb iad no Beli wee J os ' 2 tet eae heat aed 'hee whe peg yn, "a na ver : Saxe base a3 coca -- is aed Spr ee a go ee eed eed oe you we; * ie lee rnd Ps "7 ee "abn yon soot ok pelea a Beg Pavacl Oe nal Fant ty ee? ae a Ley oe esa heat pa ceed Poon pire on geet, we on Mie nee ; on 4 veal pee Road we ordrd, pttng, tend acrid ot a > Let css iad obs te, we tone, hag ans * re Bay oer ae Saee! my Ears 2 Psa Ay ret ty Ye be La Se os g oo need, . we ow em ee? ce Ay penuh if tee a" Le pe pos "A 4 chews met oD 2 ¢ 'ae 'ern pean oe 'ad i Bae need, . yee weees, 2 Su wines ee Aeod bet "abi, reese ica pe ee rt wee ped an det wile wa De aad eee nw fe "ee! ys rat i ee " pen "cot whee Qt gree. at vier, ieee pa an on ms 'sod ve ted oe 43 he t wee oot pa Mood ea 'dob Pa wae, rhe at owee, ae ye id as Sa wees : aed ree on sy a arn ve eed 4 as 4 ee) "ned coed eco heb "ye £ rae pea se a eo my pee, Py ; Se Au fee. the we 'net Lard wet . fry ae foe' warren, fas "4a oe, sonal sore i wey but wae "4 ; fre en ne we nal te a Gp ms yas pen ai pe ¥ hes "aes ia ; ewe, Spee be pon pod ohh Ard pers ; as howe a yes ween oy bad bovi Caocas ° 3 ra Oo apo aa aed teed. w fad yen vine 7 aed ~ tae "nett ; wot By ns oe ns eae abo qertes ty : ae a m, a ¢ oe 4 heel dood =~ eat wh, en yer vee ae Sand ed coed? Poa ow on Nnait Le ore, oy wen owe ® pers ? ees peer £ cf of Z Fencs Paced meee ae Feaat beck je, heed pe. oe EG pen yt ome? _ Lat * Pad yee »~ rand Fak 2 pans a "ad porn ie 388 3 ee ft re 'ab foe * be +3 tf cb CD He wy owe go a ee + dk Sa ms . tan epee Pon nA wer saneny oe veved, ain St poaad 'eos bead my 3 ye, ne oat ren cae Fess Bh bern Peed Loe oad Ee none, SE x3 a ae wtadt Lt ret: when aK ne, pa. wed " beh "eg iS vo ie "A 'seid Seong gered of tes ae, wa, Pea int roe poo ee. Baw veer pene pats aan, my bios oe rs . sped he haat ead beet Loe < on a fae a 7 oot saad a baa Ngee, hes we TeSooe ie Be ae shad ee oh, cad Se acne Si ws vi a be ios eS, ae ae ected es, ee eat) aon tne. wee Py, we, on Laie fet Es if % phtes, Ms a4 Lot tee ty end Prod esl ¢ ne ", ent nope trait?
ey vets G <a 7 tet caer bod ar pas : et re "
pa th % ener [tes ne oe ; nbd ° aes aa' tes fend rs rans OG nes aes s te, ae Sana? opine Soe, sacl on Raat, Pees ad? ;
bs a Le mee teat cae, pie 363 Dow ead 5, oy Pace we "reel oc? 2 ah ZF. bene tee ¥ nad ° dan 'rene xr hove pe a ra tid x Saeed fee, ee, g, 5 wath a my Fad a aed. pack sages threk ws sat phe £3 aS & Sit a ee & aacas -
pons s tone:
"raid th AS re wt Ns Be oe , oot i wapne:
wom, ee & £ Dawa Yorker net shoe pened Faas [prens, ot wee Sed ' a ' é ~ an Sow, 7 Sar ised wat ca fay poe " rs, nS hy, hones piers aed et woe ro ey "3 ed A 'et oe bot re ud bed ' edad.
oe red yee 'fe one papi g ' a <t os ot oie ah "2 oa ates per pon pos a oi fess Sete on wee smh on ies 'cen. bas pov a om vA pt oes we as *, and, pe cos open af ae a3 Wh ae fee « her al 4 bent Sat ad vp feos oe. gone see rae a "Naat ts ig Coaned hed we, er a FS hoot ry 'st pen teh £ wood oo Ps pom ay bud wos Pret £5 t Ave 2 ' id Sad a fod oe i Ke abe wooed pied ened Pat * 5 Co ane faa 5 St 6 at ween Ned' ?
a ; 7 vpn, Ay £ - doch ed we ae : oe aes tw ee ne ' reg Frogs pata a pan
- es Boot Sf : pa " acd ay potas pend pee aaeee ba tae 27, pes a . dors fy Lat heed fat ge eee et "yh, Ye ; wa ai Son Ya My ie sad we vy a4 'net we cm OF of oot mae fea ee anes Z bee th me pes. ae ad ka ft ma at fe steet a es bel yore poe roved. "acid ae ren pe baad 7 ee aor 3 Bs ~ in "ad é oe 's . owe , x hos ce oe oye whee Bes, tet 2, re "at ars we, oe wens "
Seal aren aa bed Fada mw eed doa a ed pane id veers a wa panes We at ore 3 Pe ae pase Set ses jos . po peas ere yee foe nana oe ate CS tn, poe vite ns ad sews. or, LG od ix 'neal mS & a. og on ern, feos y . Bows . Seat tan Pe ce) ey npn 4% ¢ wy "% 4s ane jet dnc bn . "ned So. 2 peas ppeen eacad tei. levees ure pan raat ae aed, ve devon, ? yoos As 35 am Pond wa rs ' ae ve renee 43 . And / af B fod Sy Dewi dead : ~~ pa ae ay oes 5 mw % a Pa 2 a o aett heed ae im, po do ft eee aa ati Pad ss wee bao ? perek ree herd,
- i ry Fed jen 4 fond ned bet ae, ie Fest pot ry oad <a eracs wanes, og es sated pans 'endl oe g F Sab ek a fie re pom tnt a cane vrrek es SAee Spee, pee ene , he book as a toed ad pnd ge eet 43 gon > oes on™, road 4 pe fon pad at oe Daeg a ie woes eed es ~~ re 3 wo oe Heed {3 ~~ nie $ a3 Bet Soa we a s oad roe ee ie oon Ls oot tet x bok aed x sree wet wh od a ri aod Ire Nee oad pores aie pee ad co me Fad pret bpoee 45 oon 'eine ; a oe at ae ma & ; Ge 'e oat me wer Lies aboot we Bey, ba the * pans cook on eo a phok ool 7"
ie thea A om pe vened by Good Pat wee decd wee aes peed, ca wen feed ober Py Sone one Faas' tei area bat teat * an teed oe reek + fs ae gore Ps ea eee La 'he Sead » yong nt Kes is eek: oe Ay 'aed 'ted a wore pee land fab « rere. tee, oot a La Sawa, Pang bet oy gerry ean, ers wee Mies a aa Mey vail on" se ¢ mG 3% baad ee eg ~ ent me : Lab a het we 2 ns my pat a had wines, reseed ' oe ierd Pps ¥ he a Ye Seek Ge werd '