Karnataka High Court
Abdulghani S/O. Kwajasaheb Athani vs The Belgaum City Municipal Corporation on 31 January, 2012
Author: Ajit J Gunjal
Bench: Ajit J Gunjal
'fig'? E'~E<:}.§>€;?{}?>?:.2€;3 E 2
TEE; %§f{}§§ C{>§;,3§€T CF17 .§{;5\.RN;%"f'AE{;/X
C§RC{}Y§ SENSE A"? DH;§R'§x5AB
mgmg TEES 'E'E~éE 3 W my {>5 5ANUAR':§_.--;i{é:2'.';[g-- .
BEFORE _W_
'§'HE: HQNBLE EVERJ US$163 ;*:,J1':f1';,:;;G::;%$;:~é;':.
\MRH'PETfi7QNF%16OG$S(fl?2G@2'LBQ§E§ym"
BETWEEN:
ABDULCEHANE
S;/(L) KWAJASAHEB ATHAI\§§ _ . '
RXCE CTS N().3€}E§€>, E{%§PxDEA'Bf4;'EE'%;:?. "
B ELCEAU FKJL [)1 ST: 3 LE
{BYSE31'.F.\/':_}?.F§T'§'~ii,{"z":f§':§.3 '
%..PET§T£GNER
AND:
rm
, "gag Bgéiiiéxéjivg
w:U91:c:?aL%@<;§::E«;>';2;::':<f:<;r;*.éL'
RP'§'§;«;;., 'mi ETEE '- '
-" - Mi} 3%: 345:; $5; .;fC<;: £2/.% éygi <3 2% 5:2
'B:<'::,{';A:j':2.;:, §~:s_:§: BEi{}AU§'x/E
.
?z¥%:.E;":§EL<*[;;W::zé1' <::'?'a:' Ev? U {:2 gag. {:{}R?{} R./3J§§<,> 5:
'. B€:i{Z%;',,§J§'§E, §%EE~§'?: B§;L{V}?:U?v§ }..j%';.4;%:;:+2é.;'§<:§-E * T as é<:3%gs;L:+;::2s<V;§-E 2€;a3;:>2_,V§::.;2:~::?*:* * % WP 'i 2 MI _f%§_,E§{.} §€ELS§i}EE'\E{§ A?
SHRL'R}'~;&PUR€3§'iE'T SWEET ?'x:"§f\,?€'? {f}P?{/EEWTE BUS STz'%§€D BEi{l}E%UFv'1 BEST: 8E§,{}f5:§,f?'s§ %.$URESH 3,55) i.:<'>HA§e:a;:N<;H RAJPiJR<):*H:'E' Aiéii: ygzmes -
<;<:<::: BUSINESS 1 R;<:) N<),2, ::v,<:<;L<>N';
<Lti)N€}REZSS R()g~\E:) .4 ALSQ RESEDINQ AT :3HRLRA3PUR<>H:T swam' M;i:R"'*»:if_ <;P.P<>s:"§E 5252+: STAND SEL<}AUIV§% 3:81'; _ ~ - 2 :¥:{E,:§_PC>N§EE'€'E':% (BY E~§M'"E'.1_£AiZ}ADiSH'PéfllL:ADV.fE'<3R._E?£ R2 ' &:R§.RM.;:U;:»~:;:;'2?.,:§%: gE'=i§R ;_f "mus PE5'r:T;:-ii;N"V:s. F§LfE3F3"':3E'§DE§}€V' ARTICLES 225 AND 227 <5? '"m_g_V c:<~21$é'::i?:f1fLJ"-fl,,<';Vrx: "er: __I_ND§?A 'mm A PR/1:':"ER TO DEREC'? ma: é<'E..:;fP<,>N'i:)'EN"':'.Ns:::.1 AND 2 im C(L}f\3SEDER AND 'm TAKE: ;gPP.R--<fi>p';<'§.;:~$,j£VADEC':-§:_1(>N ON THE PETITEGN DATED 28.12.28: EFELES 8vfm;E9::<?1'1:;<>NER 1_fIDE;;%NNE}<URE~B, PLE?T.?E'§§{;}N-_ é§T{}:":ELVEN{§V {EN §'€j}R ?§EL§§v'E'§E\:Z%§3"5' '33-EES %f}'5':.5§'/,VVT%%E' {Z{}URT Mz5':E>E1 "§§-E3 F€f}i,L{}W§§'§{}:
{$333 "§'E'":,e "--- §€'::é%;§,e::e":" Césfifms {Q bs E326 aswrzez" :3? QETES: . E-.3 'i'~é:@:3§:}k3'f_é 2729:' Khaévs Eazzar af" S€§gE:1.},TI'E Cétjg. T325 psiéééeaszy WP ?=£<>.§§<}{}?>:"§.2{}E2 LO afier C§€mé;;§és§':§:1g §h€ e:>§£E S'£E'1£€33:%,§£'£2 has <:Q§és;t§L:::':egi 3: zresiéésniéaé cum c:>z:r;m€:*<:iaE buiiééng Er; Ehzf 9 H: is 3:116 C388 <32" $16 p€:iié<'mer' tha: '.§7«f:VfS;;*¢3§'3*'§T1§'§<3i"§'E-.'7 K"
N033 85 4 age ciaiming ti} b€ jSi'Z'f"£'i..Q1""fiJ]'1I<'i*1?':§.v « N<>.3@5E":», which is; siiuazed at _KhaC1:3 E3%.azarj.%.§.:.:BéEgé{:uf:2 City, Tbs said property is :0 <§Vf [:16 petitioner, Th6 r€sp0§1de:r::";3 1 3'*E5v?v}'?A3Ai3'§a'--5'§91"1 39 respenfiem Nol far g;f"§fff:€; @_f Th€ samplaint of Said gran: <35 pérmissiorz ié ths true and actual €i'§.:€:'V.}.T!.1i()3§)€;?F1::y' 'LE2, CT NO.3055. E': is alga big 'gags ¥:§'2é:'t ..:5<%----s§§nd€n:$ 3 332:1' hays _m§3:*a--:=p:.;:es§e:1t€d V'?:§3:._§V facig {:3 {E26 Cefperazéaa 3.33:3 E22956 *i:,_:b':a'i';:§<:E 'LaV«§:§Q"€.§E'$€a 3:; is neiéceié 22:3: 3226 §:€'5é'::'@:":€:' hag §*;8.:*::a%;é':§«:3§'*_ hféunécigzai §;'.@r;g<;ra%é:3z': 33$: bsfma ma ;:;=:5_*;é:§é;;*:" gags? Ssszéazzs iféiéfi and f;€{}8 Q5 {:{}E'§*:{}E"'&'E§{>'§E. TEES saié psiézisziz. 9:: agpaars £3' :~:é.«;駧 psfiéizég €:<3:":Sé::%€'§aE§@::, EYES p€%:§§;%;<>§:€f$ WP N:i;.§:i}i3$§.§{}E2 appésers E2213 a%:~;<:= filed as ::<::a_:"£ £2': {}.E:§,§'Ea:;.E@<~§;'%€§ and be 323152 9330 maén'€2:i?1€d appE§<:a*;§<>r: 5&1" gran: 0%' énjtgaéi-i.;>T:2_; T335 E {:GU§"{ as we}? as 2316 éppeliate CGLEYE {F16 gaid :fe<:;u€St and the said E"<'3j€C{§QZ3;..iE;_ :::o:--:'f§:9:%':駧. V Cant: in a wré: pétiaéonfi 3' ix/13.? ,1/'_Pa:iL Earned a§p:3'é;§"'.iVhg. ':f0zg the pstiziener i~'€h€I'n€ET§1}' prévfiéigvt $6': :3? €'i1"CL§}§1'iS'iE:iE1C€S :0 cengiéer {he representaééifgzfi.«:A1§é'§{eg::--. Wfzich is flied under S€Cti<3n: ACE, He fL::th€r' aanction is Gbiaifi€d by :*€sp0':2d€":":*;s arzé "4 Szipjefessizzg {E26 mazsréa': {gas as {1r:€_z§:::*::::Aa% :*né'a$5 L::*€:n;:<3ni and wiihaui §,€a<;ing ihfi sic':
Aba§:é<;',.*»;;h%¢?:.:34é--..C<>rs%,raxf€r::éan 3.? E336 Esuéééizrzg 'Q/*€ Eawg a3 227613 aé --:'%3§'£:Er%;%:% i"Ji23_»L:Vagad§&Sh ?.:;:iéE,. §iE*8.§'ZE€§ <:=:::'u:":s€E aggéayéyzg fer '%°r3S;?;0;';;:%_§:'§::s E ezzéé 2} gzzbméis: {$32 if 3 gsfizéfiszz is §:§"E6?,V_S;:ii%,I'§"i€ sfaaié be C@:2Si'c§€:'€d 2:": a.«:::€0§'e:§a::<:€ uziilvz iaw, 32:1'? ?'€<V},€>{}iiE5i7>.2{§E2 U1 ii ?vEr,R.§'vE.E{L2§kamé, isarrzeé r:<>Lms€': app<3a:*in.;§'----.§er resgandenzs 3 am}: 4 submizg that sérzcé the through his son is aiready bsfere the Cévii__C"@.;1r'if h$ réquired. is gét his rights adjucéisaiszé in ég E haw: given my anxigéizs CO§.i$i_CE€§9§'Ei_®i":.:WES" {he submisssiona made by thgj 1€arn$d.:"<:0i;::;seE :t§:x;:>.:32::;'§ng far ihs §3€EiEiQE'}€3f as W52} as the$rj<3':2peV§§'d»'€n_i3..
7. inde€d,3_ ffi: _ }1o:jV<:Aed 5:E'::;>afE {he petitianer cannot have ..3:;.x;/X9 ;f_pafa11.é}; _' yaéffiedfias one L§'f1d€?: the Eiarnataka §\.fE:»!r:iVC'£g;;§:¢;i_ Co:'p_d'1'3_:i0n ACE and anoéher' béfors the Ciarié €:{3u:"t':;, » 8Q. E€:b_§£-S 2"-IQ £Q::fi':""é§z:€ tfiiaé EEK: gsiézéezasr $3 $39: 3 B22': hawfia/*6}: ihe said 312%: ES §ie§ 'the 3&5; 6:}? £313 f;:;é:é:::§@:":€:' ES ;'{§."iQE"€ £32, ihe izgéazrs £2? p:fG;<:.j;
' E23 ?é;:::_,:'?;h€ aazfirmszii mafia 12:': éha peiétiazé is {ha {is hag s:0:::$:f:.::«::%§d a ?€.§éd€:'::2§e£ Qurrz Qammayséaé 'xii? N<;.€T>Oi'}552,;Z{3E2 Cf:
'S Ed g {V fiat? E99 g::1g!Q Y t 'W2 am? Hf W; pande 1* raj ii} £23 he g 5:3 '$3; / 4\} 3 2 ins;
3 and 4%;
9. incised, as {G whc ég Ehfi' encreacher v;9E2._;€Ei2:§;:»:' ii; is the }:)€EiUO}"i€F or rsspondems 3 arzfi 43.?.'{}%'._f'<:z'I' -:ih:«§:'--§;a_aLtt%3:
the a2x'aiiab:Ei:j¢; of €§"1€ area, _vv'hiC1: 'is :*€[:3i.;giri£:r'§g1*.fé:° cenS':ruc1:ion 3:0 mind is E"€:<:fQsi.§'}3'("§ to 'be <.i'c;:*éséc§'.=:r6é by the Cm} Ceuri: whérs the__é('U:Z*: is
30. £r1&€€dv,,':he_ r$ff£€fS; 'S'<;~Lighi for by {hf} ;:zet;:it§(>ner's sari i':'j~..IV:3:*:-€:"1g::i'£._a:€~~as"fGE§«;>'gs's:
(if: E: jihfi péaizitiff and '€5Vef<%mx:i;3.:f:i: V. ham E;CQU'§E%'€§ ea§@3':":r;:n§:i;;rj§*--._s:'§g§ié of Eégghé: 332$ 93'? from V x':1":€= Si.iig3Z"'3»i5é:§.§.?J%2'S. T. «:§éi}:-*:zdam:s E 3:253 2 fiiséa" agéswis, $s%f<gfa:--h;S4, §"2€:':«:'%:§:2.€i2 as" §:%a§j; acting zhfiézi behaif be E'€S'£E"8.§i'§€§ Fgassslizag a {£83566 0? §3:i'E"'p8'§i,i5} %.:éj;1,:::€:;is:3n 2:5:'5§:"a.:'::in§g {mm «:14 1/ éggézég Schfié ii Eazzé; 312$ §\§€',>,§3{}€'}55'£i:} E mg {ZQE"2SE:"iE€€§:1g as seiiarjmzder groazzzd in C"§S §\Ee.3§5;:E éifrzades Saga? Beigaagm' E3. ;5:§3§al"€FE'i"l}/', if any CQl§SEi"L1C'€§:'}Zf1 has in vieiation Crf £116 buiiding bjwiaws a.__r:.::% is span far the petitions? {Q ss€§:<"-'Va7._A_&$'%t:<§§'éi_§'{;;§_ bvrikdéng and sex as to §I1CGI"p{i"s?_§;i'€V_>a §;"eEi_e£' injurzctien, h':de€d> to €X'{§§i?'£'E2;ii}%;'€f€-»_$7hO.ifiCi'"fiikiibx? any diffécuky inasmuch as Am, W63; which is rsféifzgble @2212' Zaria in the case 0? 9:' in the Case :3? a~V"'$'§J::i;"ri:2V:%ri{§}:"'%<5:":?"-a ff€é'S'E'; 'gerifié (Bf iimiiatian bsgészs :9 i":;:*1._3.i V*§;.V%7;3:';fif:€'z3.: {sf Em: zirzie duéing which {he bréagh er 33:6' 'é:':;r'j:§ €325 €856 may he; cenéénuesg En ;
:. §"1<3.. €§'i7.Ciil?aAE}?s€3--3?€€S; § "" "am 35 the vééw 23:83: Smce éha j;*;€"':§':é<2fE%§§ §%:.:Q'::_V}:§h'§.?:*i§ San ifs airfiadjg h€"{>r€ {ks Cévié C3225:
§'E€ §$A:usqL:'£2r*:;s:§. j'..--i?<:: {aka a éaaégéen Ehereim, Endaeéi, ii is 1 fix' ;i';€€§§§Of1€§ pmd'u£:€ :2L:.e:E: aééhsr :3/:;:4:E€?:'aE E$%'@.:%«.§isf=;'€ Sizéé §:{}L?i"'{ ':9 ésiabfigiz ifiaéi Ehfiffi £3 a v:T0§,a':é:'}n .:.?:$ .E3L:§E»:E§:':§j E3}/fiaxa/*3 and zamaé rsguiaiians she gaaciiasz piam zésssif Es :19': xvii}: ffiféffificé Ea the §'£'1€EiSUi"€ff2€ET{ €31" {he j{}'£"i}p€:"f}7 £1? Q2/:€s:':%anV. Ts') €?i3§§,§_§§'«.fI'é€ pt-iéiiéenez' :9 ésiabiégh me gait? fact ihreugb ?1_§3..§1" @';>;:§f'* can sumrnen thr: Gfféciais :3? tbs C<::If§:.-:>3f_;2ti<}:': iii"s;{;:p§:::"_%:A 0i-_ V his Cenientions' L'£E<:euiis€3 {he said 'is égisi;..resev?'fS*€_é'[-. :0 iihs raspondsntg 3 and 4 :s:_ "s.:_:mm"<;r_1 ";§"}€"._GV§'§§Vif§'é3;§S' '£0 estabiiésh that the buiifiifig is in---€3f:fQ':";<néEy ma. me zanai rsgzfiaiiorzs and E326 E:\fé:hv.. abservaééeii petition Siancfg dfvi:;,t)'c2--sed§:'0f..b ' » apgmafring far respondezits i$3'~ {flew m€:r%::::; of appeararxie éfg wéthiéi §'1f}:,:r'%.?if€i<:»§<:$.,' «' L'