Karnataka High Court
New India Assurance Co Ltd vs Smt Mahadevamma on 26 June, 2009
Equivalent citations: 2010 (1) AIR KANT HCR 202, 2010 A I H C 1263, AIR 2010 (NOC) (SUPP) 91 (KAR.), (2010) 4 ACC 750, (2010) 1 KANT LJ 304, (2010) 3 TAC 532, (2010) 3 ACJ 1579, (2010) 2 CIVLJ 125, (2011) 2 TAC 204
Author: B.Sreenivase Gowda
Bench: B.Sreenivase Gowda
3; mg zizaaa iE€}"€,§R'F ::3;:' KAE£'€;s.TA§{A, BA:é.§;%f;é§%;é%%%k
§}z%'E'Ef_} 'm':s F333 :26;%'H gzsasg' 0;? zM}L?NE2A--:é3ifQ£3§~: ' : '
BEFQEREE" M' V V
'mg; E~§QN'BLE §£E€.JEJ$?£CE B.$::a;E::;i§:%s§wgs;§; :*:T::::£sé%:;'§,A "
E'vE§5§;..§*Jo.4ée%?';,fE2€;:{}? gm: '
EETWEEN:
§'%$$%.§2* Erzdia A$3¥;:§°a:;c@:.'{'":<;.E;E;{%.',' V
?'3G.,5'23, "$338.3; iizfgfgpifixg g
Ggip. Naiigaaj __
Basavazlgudig-°_».. .
53fiF1§é¥i.G§'€"u55{3 'V "
By it:; §;:Zal1?2ag3;fi_;"»
{B}; 3r§;6'.M:hs:sfi;}jV;aé%2}'
» -»S1z;zii.§u'EaJ:A:15'aa:€,eva11*;:§:a,
' Aged" <§_'?-..:gfc:3:as,_1.~
2%' ;':':s; late 7§?'§i9;g§;>3?3.3f:2.
2.
--« .. V gégeai 24; fyfiars,
' .. ff ~ X G4..E}é'agaz"3§'::.
% __ rf21.SWaep€r {feign};
" ..,_3f*~3'$ar Yefiamma "?emp}€, Anekai,
Bamgaéare §iS§i£"§C"£'
%
N SAPPELLANT
3. H.§fi'.G--apa1 Redfiy,
Majorg
S / 0.31% {§i3(3§GS§":{§,
Rf 3. M . E. Efilectmzaicsg
{'§%;a.§1::§3.p":1.:*a.,
Anésiiai Taizzk,
BaI:ga_EQ:'<3 Biszrici.
£33; $;é.L.s::e;m, A.{f'xv.. far ;a*;:, &2; B
3ri,Li3a§i:"6{idy, fidzz. far R-53}
Fmgs fiéscigu}'S;'«:i}?§3i€:.}..._¥%i' 2%' $29: agairist
me j:%;§€§g%::t:I.fi§{;i::3;i$é :21~:2«2a% pagsed ix";
E\.<i§i§;E.?é{§1-*%4%}{,E§fV2§§{;£%; me sf me xx; gm}; sea 5%
"§{'%is"-E*.f§:€:_;§:;:%2€r MAST, Cgufi: £3? 83133} Qiausas,
"$;t:":3§%e;E?g:§f; Araa, Bangaiere, {S{"":€f:§i.N9,1;§},
":3:é,%r:§;*é§fi§jgjéiiégszisaivéam af Rs-.3,%§,6{"}'Q_f ~ '§%'i?i§§"i iaiersgi?
ai 33$.' frag: ms {iaia ef gaiiiian ifii flats ix? éapagié,
T3133 §aei§'E%. agmmg fer heazézag Ems €13}; fififi €1";9:.§;*£
V» ..--.fieEi¥sr€& {ha f§§.}:>w§:1g:»
A 9, R §:¥S§~'{§¥E'¥Eif3§:"f§€_'A§;*:":V. ~. "
JK}'BG}'§EZ§'I'
E? E3 3. Safiii {inf iifiafiah 3.? 0:26 §'€a.g&raj22 .§;'.§._,2;:. 3;":;':e:>':§;:>§;" V.
'* Ejaifigot wig _ .» . _
C,m~:«,'-{Z San éifff {Em éftiaizziagizts hefiirfi fizz? }
dL¢».i":3~*iM3
2. Bria? fact/3 {}f 3115 E:z'~:..=:,1;fs':.§__;':*x§"-6',' '£33: Q;é'1i 39-E.'é--~
23% as abet}: 63$ 3?;;--§:,.,.i%?%1é§tf1t}*ié%,f£§éc€_as€<% fiagafajzi
WSS pr{>€€€(i§f:1£gj_§}1 1&3! ffigifitfaiifiil
fig,§~§;§4§V:é'=fi{l§84%?';' :§*.ié%.:"%Ie%;i§f§}éV was érévezl in a i".'é§;S§";
afld E':-.:.@g2ig&:2":: by ifs €i:'is;€;i :31: A§T;e3«;z§§ »
ifihamziaiézgfa. §€§:::::§A._a'l§§.;r§' ii iii': agaézgai 21 Efiazajgarz {F86
. fzieéiggg' ;§§~:».ix:a.{}§<§@:j:a§1a;,§i§ yéfiiaga' T326; {ieceafiézi §'§aga3ra}23
Aggifiifiiilfifié; ~ g1*5_:3%?@%_1s iZE_§':_i§'§€S and §T1€ was §§;:::}€:{%§a§é:1§;
. §§;%§%§:{§:"'-égfié {§"{%¥fi§'151EZE€E1§ Eiagpéazé, '2¥%"i§E'&f£E"; iérsz.
gig: Eresiizz-"fizz: wag §§¥{i-E33, am: %;§;€2*eaf'{*°;:* E15: waag
fiifaz. éizi ta Efiagzgaéara §+£s$p§.w.E ans} ha gzzcegzfiheé is
V' *§a§4:1;"§%e"s GE": iha W33? :9 {ha }*:ar$§i'€:5§:
magi 3.€3€':'iC§{§§}?. ::;c<::.::'r€{§ an I_"3~$-2{'§€)%f>., E-£33' 's§::_:Z% "gm; "
- --:= * L'
'~".,.,
3. §--3<>:h ihié {mixer af the zzefxicifi 3.r1{%;___ $26
E:'1$:§;:"a3'*:<:€ $331951}? have: fiiad {Emir iééi'
§~§a'i€E}"i€:§"'1'¥f. :25 abjeciiagzs; "§'h€ Emguransa =:.§@r;:pa;§.:f;'" iii "
3-is fitataniezzi GE' 0%je{:fi@n$ :'r1€;s'a:g,?; Ems,4'éééiigisété._f§.%1&:.
cage 9%' the: ciaimants, but aéimiitéfi t:1;:e%~__'i:'132.::*g§i1::é;~ ._
siaiizig that, its fiabfiity 'izg-..,%["';'S;"=L.:A§»3j$c'*'£ 1:6' 'érzii "
cgnciitieazs af {E36 §.:13:j,I;1"*a11:::6" §3%_:§'§é<;'-'y L. 311:1 i:®'-fifgxi' Vafiidiiy
91* me Rm resarés', .;';:s€':$£i'3.§f{, %;g;;~:m;s;gnS 9:' Ms;:;m~
Veéiicéss fiat 'agid aéfaciéfiéfz ~_{§:**iiéji§:g iisezmé if @316
sirizzér §f"2:%3.é: _v&:§§'§§3_ej'i;.;':sfié@E%:<3{§"§L:9; 'ifift fifiétiéfifii.
" , (fig. 9!.' {ha plsadézfggg sf ms":
§:Ea;:*%"5:eis§ {E33 ,'"_E"':*§'m;.:<:a;.i bag §"F?§.I§};€§§ as ::;3z;§> 33 f.§::*eé:
' <§_§$'E}.é4l§', _
f"_§'E:?€ {§§8§E1"i3§1§,S, E2': Qifiez' ii: ;3:'{;%;z: %E";£~':é:' sags;
?'§'£'3:i?5=..'§X£i'E3§E}€1?{§ {ha fi:*;<~:;i'. z;:Eai_m§§,m: §€aE':ad¢:¥'§i::§::1a as
AA .1??3§v'.'3',"z}:3.€ i$:*abE";.a§§a3;* §3€§{§fsf a3 §%i¥.:'.;2 amé aiaafizaar
%;='ss§§;i"§:.e3%§ E2539 Emma €3%1ar*s.firz~§$%z€kar $§"§€§'§§5 3% ?.,¥.§§'..;"% €§E"§{i
§3f0§?_E€fié {£233 <§@Ci.:_m@;{§f§$ whfich 33$ fizarkttéi 21$ §.§x.?-E
SEE?»
Dug: g'"<..a?.n>':.
"tr
.;j2,~~rc
Meal
'A V 'séfiéik ' §f;{§":i"§§}€3§2.S§i'§T§t:3§;',E6
w§th¢$$"¥
H3 T;=7:§<..'§§~« 1%.)' "{'§t:é: {}W'.E.'"1~§'ii' éizé m::';. {:':':E',:'::' %:.%":5:[E;{3E<;--;_5"-« {f3=::
*- T" 3
iéeéiiaif 2*}? ms: §~§§g}§}€iN§.€é.EE§:~§i"iSi.i?€;i'}{E{E {."::;='.::";"i'§7::§3;*af;:;;g=';-" V'
{i;:§.§..:?:§§%;:.'3;t.%:s{: €§:'f.'ict::* hf; :":a§:1§;€'E3.'E¥.E€z§§;§ a;"";é:':?ié":s:';:_1~€;2V2.:*--.%;a7;:I*;e:
:":xam%.;*:":e.€§ 5:3 E}é3..§}J.§ §§.Ei{§ §§'é?'§;f£i%f:iif{§ 3 C?€}§:%§:' «. ef_§i: "?:..§s;é:._
_"%';."}*s;1::'a:':<:{~: §3{}§.§.{L'f£ azaaé v€:'§;i{:ie'3!g;§€r:11ii' g;{:2s:V?g",£'3;a':*"3:::*;:::i V
as §;'ix$§<'i»»E a§":=:§ §f':X'§{'-'L3§'€$'»j§é€Z3_.§;7$'f§i§E§
E3. Sf 'SE26: Qmi
amé "aha: 'E*~E§ga:':3}i.§
wag ;,:i;§:_<:.;§<i§'§m <*:<:$1:::*:'a:i {>23 1¥--}~E}~
'§if}%}s?§, "{§:i::§ ;:«3i':ai ::€gEi§€:':§ {i3:i§?*z§7:g; Q? figs:
maxé; é::+;:§:;% £3}; £3 {§§"§?¢{§§5' 231:3 tE:a€:"<":§::}; Ehezt {:§&§i'iZi£§3"EE.?&3= fiizazsé-2
j}é3§§:,§§7E'§$§;::€§." ""€%:€?:____a.é:t.iG'§:::abE& m-":.gEig€:3';€::*: £33'; éh§»:= ;";aa:*%. :3?
:?:;aEv..4é3*i'}y=:*:§*' -Cr? 'ifihé: iziaxé 213% am? may aye: eaiztiiiaaé is
"?§":€:?€a§£,§i§=, that "§":'§'m::'}::--:§
i:@;t.:$§{E§é:€:":g flag: saga {:55 *i'E:<~:+ <§®::§§3.$$:'§, E33 $3333; zmé
V' €;_ii%'1§:~:"* §fi&'§fii§'i'E3i €":'§*§{§€i'§E{:{'; ax': 2"$::{;:'{§., E133 aE§E§3'§§'{§§ii'§ a.
Sififii =3? '§€5;.i2,8{},{}%€'};--~ uzziiaz' flag Eassaé. £3? "$333 9%.'
€§2€1*§Z}?"C§i{§iEE'§.iEf£ 332$? §%$.,@.3s3€;}{}; »« E.};E'3;€§€i'§' She {3€}1€'E§"€f3E'}*£§.{E§}Ei§
$
§"§$8"€§S§ {:1 Q3}, iii has awa.:'&§;::% a sum. {sf §€S£.§,4§}»-,{}{}€j3,!~
wif§%: ifiiaresi at 6% E33, f§*£s:";:: {hit {Basie cf
me iiazé af <%€p«::$§:.
E'. Tixe Lf:S%SiF8EE€:€ {Tbfié.j;}:::r:y'--«A hag. {;3<}_;?:};}.é:;§i1g:§s_§;
the afizarai is? 35% '"§"::'iba:1";,a§ if}. %f&§::iée--.;§p§3e;§§;_; §<}**;fi'1 <3:.é**;}":<:
gyauzzd af fagmgaiag {>f~-. i§9.5%1i 1§'£;r agairgist U35:
§m3m"a2':a::€ €:{;:::;}§;zé§i..aS ?'3é{i'é::=;4 E.a;%;»¢..éa§":{§ <33': €316 gr-<m,:":{1
Eliza: the {§§183?:'§§i§IE {fig $<;?'::5p:é:'::~§:a;ii£%;}_1 __;_"m:a1*d5c§ by the
fribufiaé ;3:§:.,<%c:$$§='§:€.g ~
V _ §*>'.§f'§;§I};E*g%i?a;;£';Zé':":3::,' i€a1';:z€d {:&m":s&:i a;:};§2@a:"éi":g
€03' VA §;:$:z:"a:§;c7c.. '.iC::3m§3az1y, cazsiémis 'aha: ms:
»E;%'-.g'§:§i}i%'}; <3f iii*:€V___E_;f2;sz1mr:se Ca:*:':§sa:1y is s;ubj&{:€, is 'aha
' §s::':3_:9s. '::;:f§é{§ ___£g:":{§i€:i&:'13 2:3? ma Efiazzzmzite ;><}§i<:§: 3.33:?
Ftéze zgefziztéat. Evie €:<:§::z§€:';::§:§ Qzaé: a&z:§§€"%,§':{§:§'*
:%:§%:€§é§::i§ §E"%"é?Q§'i?'£{§ £2: {E253 ac{:;§é@.:3E; E1323 gas: €:s3z:%:*as:':%:
V Liaarriagéz pa:§*:'2'2i"é:, Emit éé gjsiéééai as; a aiage €:2§:f'1'€a§:;a, 33 §}<::'
$25: §§"i§::',i§'§'§Ez2i§§G§'E fzigizégéaarzi éia §§}€ 9:23:35: E23: {szge
S§é¢E*¢Ea§1§u§'2a:E}:: z3;§:<:§ as $"¢.2::E':, Eézeyfi E3 %?§l€}§3.€§{Ki {)5 §,€.2':::$
5%,:
<2? Eha viiézisiizt 2' :::.33-$3 §}ii§"%f§£}E'€3 ?_'E"::*: 3;}f»;V'éi':.§'§§3":€ifE
s ' ' V
€;f{3:3;:§2@3;;.§.' ES §§':;<:;"i;'. Eéaigxété $.15} 33%}? <::<>m';:;%2:1:§:+;;_§i:f:§3;,T' " "
$53' E363' :':<3§:':3*a3 $:€.§3*a;';§=.s;_"€<§:?é§s; fivéiéggiéggééé. {:::;%'z;sL:;":$%,:.*; f
§i§§}€§3E"§§?;§§ far aw: 8§~'£§"'§i"E§' «::}§=.f£i':€ z%<:=hfi<::3;:: ~:.t{:'2"2;:s:':_':sE$s:;€}':§£-:
saavmsr figs eggs fiisfi 0%'
a%:§§%::E,§;<>n$ c@;:%.€:':a§;é:2§jA' iégéfi 1Ti1{'°;§ §>£E3:Z£': £3.31
;:a=:"::<:§;é<:3;;.'i-:. <%%.1:§_é1sf> §£§iL%E'€: --§}i§' :§"§{§.5 <23; a::f:<:§::%;:?zé
af '€316: V§::%'é*§:f§31§ 53%' EEK: $6-;§§§z,tE§*
bf: ;,:_ iE71SE.3§'€"Tf€'.§ 1-=;§é.E1 $33.5
"'iTk;§é:§3a:":}% a:;:s;% 'z;§2::,$<-é.:i'<?:§"e %.":1{=:
'§:;§:3:';§§f:L::§3M ?;;.s:} zazmassrisg' Sig': €f§.f%.i§EE :3?
. E§i4:&:'f:::*%: 1:5? ::":<>::%:,$2:§§3 '§.h:~1%ii. f:>:g :;;f :42
_ 'i;<;'~:h.$:vr:E§:A §;%.T} §:'§a{:§'2 £3?' 2: "gayzzzéfii ::€}:":€%;§'{;§{}"§':§:: ::i%:}:'-:3 :§.z{:*:i
E.
" . a«%;E:s${:s§%;¥:i-"Lj':%,if::§: §§:§;2;;:'%::' frzézza iii; .aE§.§I}§§;3:fg' '§_;E$. étééfi
{:{§§?:i§i/"?%§?§}.7§§&'§{..%L{?3."§ &'%;%?a:'§§€'E{§ 2':e3:" :~:;'i,2s§;, gfiag E22; :x%@:;:%§a'%:§fi 3::
_ V §.E':::*: $€~f;%f:§;<,%§: 3<'§€§*{f2§ {:25 33:6: §if§<§i:.{:z'* ifé3§:é{7%{:':$
_5%.{:%_§_ :i'0.z'* §E"1a:}:"€, "§':§§.{: ;%::_:%:", am? $§§§}§}€}.§""§". 'efzsf Efia
§zz§§§:2i$a'%:;:":, Em ::*€2§§€r:§ a:;3a:";=:': iizs §'§}{§g4i'}Ii€i§'i€€; sf fiéfés
may: in ths case af m~:";'rEn mma 11~z3t:aA;:¢§~$;E;._ca.
Ltd" 35 araggs vs. cmmmm
reperssd in ILR 2099 EAR 1392 *a;h§::i'e§;§: E;}«.:.:s-- A}t::<::%éI§=
Eaaiii; as 1m«:ie;":--
"Méreiy §€<ié;_i;§e $34536.
were Stated :3 haviéi' sifiggééfl
§%s§{e{% up ;§E&LS$€fi_g:€ I§ "- <:é;_:. €§3;$ yeéiiéiiieci
§"€"}?.};E{i3, pre$ui'z§{::9bi3}*--. »__::zf thfiir
perzilit'c_§ndiitiéfi§:fi';$z:%3y (ices net
::::.r§3t§t§§:"§;§ 3 S_t%:§uiQ:'yj-- ,ci::'i'}ie:*:§:e avaiiafiié
-------- -~T§;r." T's;:§§ii$a<:ti<§:fz-. 2{£3231}€94; sf 36{':EL§Gfl E49.
Er: Av§}é'{?i'gv._V__ 149(2) fif "aha New fiat
._;i'€:._, 'bezvespczxés $9 $&C§§fi3?}
gésig} 3:'; "$31.: k::::s'ia ACE ma, Act Q? 3939.
The V 'sa.:f::§. éefenca gT{}i1Z"ifiS as are
{i§§£3&§fi€€1 ii}. Seazéorz 14§{E) 9?" the Efiew
' ,gfr3;=§:§V':'.T'V;S£--§a:*e exisfizzg as 'me éefezzzsfi g"@uz";§$
V. .%f:%j1:;€;{:r gzzbwfiactisfi {2}{%;} am? {C} Q?
Seafiefi Qé GE' fahs {EM fifji, Siiiiiiiar
qafigiiiaa £29.53 arisfin far sanaififiratian $3'
{ha Efivisisn Eéfifih 9? this Cam': in am
9336 Cé' §{.§i'i'§§E?»fi%éE3G{}E¥}E}2%. 15$.
E{AE§ALAE%:EE:é£;% and the sama haii beets:
a}€}S1§?§i"Ef§. *9
E5?' E :5;-{:2 E.§§}:;§}}.§3 is éigéifié a..=1?é*%:".h, Eééa $s:2:i:.i<%%:%é;s;:3
:;>§ £':'§,§.2'%%s:§E1§.&;§:, Eaarzzééié {:9zmS$:1 ;s:§§}:3;3;:*%z:g--.
apgyeééazzi, 13:}? 331933 €F;:z£1': €}L{'?;fi ffififiiéfia _.j§°'fi'S.:E§ S";-{::' "
*az€E1%e§§ has gas': 2: c@z:::'a§;i {Tf€i~;"§'§agé «.g;;=;<§* "§};-3?f€{;§.x Vgé
smgs {3&§"E'§&§_§€ 33$; !,§1:::%:T§::;? _ a2'io%aé:;€:{E=--t§'2s '{>§':';§h%:;
Véhifiifi p€i.§'§§}i§Z, ii: 223%' '$6 z:"?g:i§§%;::1<§ 1353*-.§:fic '3'a:%;%'20:"§*é.é&:£a
iiifiééfi' $33 Ac: Ea §;:%§5{'e::_ 3§1é}:<$:f .,:ia_?';s€§aEi{:§: :3? ms?
§€:"§:.§%:, biz: it c;a2;1:2:}:V_ %';:*5._ 2}._ ' %:"%:§:¥._:j ..%:_E':€ E3232 *2 373::
§';;*s::¢%;§§"§%:£ §i3S§,:~:?_§§§§=' _'{}&jaf
-("W
B'-"'*'$"'
ir-M'
5'":
. »
«£5
mi:
<t{;§z;§2§;::$:«:iiE:}§'; 3:5: iéégéé'§§::§s.*<§.V~*'§2z:§§:j; 'é§'§€:"a»i-" <2? :'~§<?:a:t'§:3;:: E ;
azzifi .,§-45} {$5 ?g;§91€*:.,55:c%. '- S'f;>.{::>zT:{§.§§;, 2%:@':$i§':€§' the zziaxi iraéfi
A §§'};é--é':_:§§ é:*':=§; E51, Em: gzigféftézééiiii "zvaa gfiiecé 9; géags <1' "ziagzs:
€235". 'V '*a";:<é*§: fififafiiésfiézri Em"-«:mg:%: $3353 §.:§"{§£€::§ag:_:'<:
'%';s fE§:»¥. §§§€}'€'.i§ja' ?;ss;:z::a':1:;<5 $325: T§?'§¥i €iZ'{}I{.'?zE§_§§'§S am
x;§§};§€}§'f:*2.£f{€§@:"2 ma: $.33: '¥£:?:§::3§: svzafi E%§'§.€}§'}§){'3{§ 3:": §'}f3"§T%§"€§f§'}
A' *z.?:::s\:.A'¥3:a:*§:§T;2§ §}&§§[}§. €;':E"§i§ '%:%}$ s;§::3E§§3&é.§{:s;:: 9351?; '::;:§{:3s<:é:=:':% 5.2;;
-.'i'.T§1§-: j§z2_$§%:§":g@§'s ::a.zé32<:§: E126 {:s:::§.S§:'::ii<E 3:1 §2<§2'::§2$§e§":.
an ';*E"2§;i %;2a:'*'§: sf ézfifzéé gm-':'§€::* €;§1a%T 2:22:52 ¥é:§3§{:§€ was z.:;.=:~::e:3£i ag
am
im
:34e'*7
;"%'§Z€i§_§£f €§};§'§'§£'2i§{1 if 323$ {§%%5'§E€§." §';%8;S ERTSE. §:§%5:g::»§'::<?:€£ §§1'{l{}
1.J{'U\ $9' $7'?
'£2533 ;\_%{::%:§ iéfzit §§::»;z::'2;:§":{:s*: {3:>:}.'apan§~' if? 233%; ;3:f§?::§":;;§§§€:{i fmgrz :~§:2::':§:::3:"::i::g %:,§}.<: {E1-¥EEfE§' :-méii ::::>:;':'§":*{,:§w":f::§g.3i§,'€:.§:T33E:' . Eli) Eéfagzé. .§€.%§fi, 3§?;.{m::' if}:-3 §::$:_::§'3;':¢€-- .:éf;i?;}é';3.§::'::::":;gz &:$¥:.:;:_§3§%$%'2§::§, $26: saié fzgaita §::§§:§5§§$§},i::;?, "flat 21:35 2s":i§'é._é.:iEa:: 2%.?2'£i+«; :;_;;::-:;€+:§j"._ {;'ia'§:?éags: szzzéé 23:5: T§3<::'.:3:§§, "£21: %§.;«::_':i3§'~;:,_§,:}_._§';<": €.'§§~1":§Z?.{3§i§§i§§§ '§:::%_:'§: ii %,%~'8§'";f'i §;%.§'} 33395:
$3253 --f§_:{:$:é;*2::é»t:§3 fmm 2% §é"§{}§§§§"l}" 15$; pa%§.«'93{§z::§.'>:~'§:4:§' %.:§..:%_3{*. é}?é§:9{"i _'g3:s::"?;3*' E3": "飧€i%=' o :3?" "'<.f§g§'.'V7.§'{.":E«r,'"'_'E§::E?:§V',.\':§ éfigfiézig {fi{>7'%.::'E, E3': 5, "iii 2;z§'<:ci*::E;§§::<E :%s§:?es:% zazzaé <2-5Si':%:j?;.f%_:§§.'_;:;;"'§5&5? :"»§_?"§{§ E=»-'E-'A; «:3? 'z:E'2€ .§%::%. %:'§"; ':f'i:ga§'{E 31:3 ?.i.§:€i5 ii"§E.i§,*;.§E?ii'E5a§":5E if '-::;%z%'§;§f:;é%:"§§.i?'I_E::..éézézé, :§s:':i:5-':§:Ss:::s:€ % 272$ 2-zgsiaai aE::{:s%.§"s:T 5%} §:s:§,3:§"'$ $5.352.' <i::°§2%;%f 3%: a <25' §€3,§:Z}é3%"§fw §3,Z:«=E AA 9; <::::::%: $22 2% 1%.:z;}%€."§ 2;.§f:'.:f§i::* 3:25: §3:':«33{:%':;§:E{a':"
"§E%s::<':§<"§§?~§E'%£.2x '_'§"'§*:sr:* "§':'§E".22§::aE. 7?;::z:§ :5§$§§fi§§£§€:{§. mg §.:':<:€;mé: .§¥§2,£%§E§{T§€:%;~ g::e:::::* ::'s:'::.,.§¢I?} :z:':::§ fiaiézaciaéijé §_f3?fi {sf ii; $4 ii: .-3}; » . §{T5{",'%'":':§i'{§ A %'3;1_=;:_ ' %.e;§'é§fr:*§;S §a::;'$=;:1";a§ @:§;}:E::"13:':=$ 233% 'Q? falgixzg j :3? E1255 §§E{3§'§L§1%€E 31:23: "2'*fi:é.:":g éiizai §$£.2,3f;§¢'§~;'-- 253E1{§ a§;§E§»é%§'2g'---.§.§::€ :"::::§"§é§3~%.§;::§* 23%' iii hag aa%z:::*-:;;§e{£ :32 $52.23;: 3,?' L-« V' z2§":.a;"§s3;%: %;};::=<:": Ezézazaci KEEES 9:5 s;§€§;3€::'§<%%:§1{%j; £§:?g{i V E: L' §"%83::'£;. 3%,-='az'«:§é:5 E233. §.;'.':»,é"}£}€}/' ~ i$*a;~*z::'::§$:V.%:.;=:*g'3§:Spa§:'fi;g2z:Ea:%:§ ._<§s':"::.{§ '« §";2{§{§?§, §:%§1{3?a§ azzié. =<::%;>"L/rag-*:a:§'z7::Z€'::*~;A ~.~<:€2*:=:::gf:_é:;:f§§*e5~: 'rigiéfi. V' §"<i&E5§%{3{,%;'-- mziééiz' EIETEE ékéézzi ':§:}s;&;._<}:é'§' é'}€}}'§.3="§{}§€ZéE,:£{:, E3. %:E,{};§{};» E{3:%'a:'g§_g./.§_gs:§A £33? §£3'§{~fi "£'..{}é afiieéfiarz 335$ 33$. }33,§,%{}£%;'-- :,:,::§€::* 333:: E:,as*:%;~~.:§;§"~§%:::§;€:§{s.: 333$ 32: ii. hségg §::2%*a§%%:§{::% :"§:fi§§}'§:€:'§'E.§:§§E§'{§0:i;} sf F;s.33.3,é%{},{'{}Gj» {a§€iez° §*{;:u":{§§::g zmlé' %;£':'E.'§f:.i§;*:i*.§;§":%%:~z ai @'?r$ E13; 3:2':-»A3f_.§v§gz%3£3$%1 %;am;fE:iz3§§-5 $331: £1': 33512? 9?' E333 ' , .'§a..%::$:§ 'j;{::.%§:21;:':§§3: <2? iiza E-km fiés §§z,:p:*§:§':f:$ €;':@u:'f: $.21 " i?§r;9::a's Géiféééf, £36 2::z:2§é;%§3E§.<%§'* fa}? éiéze aga gi.'£:";>:_1_§3 522;?' E5; 9?}? azzzzgé ?§£':€§'€§§E'€, 333$ if§}§E'§_§}€§E§€§.?§{}§;§ :::zm;:*éav:s:i V é}fi§§;{§fiE" fix: Ezfizsszi $933 gr}? {%§:§::»:::{§s:';:':§: EE §*${;::§:*§:@; €32 'mi E'{E{'E"§i{:é'i%f:.
$1/T.
2.3, %:};':¥3 §E':'é§:m:3a§ ;;1s§§ss:=::;:§€::§._""-. §;E:*:§e %.:"::.§:<;:':;€~': <2? figs: €§.fZ{,':s;*'3é1%{'i{§ :1: ;%%?§';.:'i§:""§{"§{i%f ~ ;:s%::f§'7 é§_.':;--T R:~;.:".§§"§§§{§j ~ 3'%,;§.%a:{E fix-? -';«%";=&a~<:§'2sé:;%;:amz":?;Ti§~;-Iggziéé .;:é:.?;5:1i>_V $'::§:::"§i;:::°'§.é?:{i ':35; 3.41% §J}§.{}}?'§i1' sf' a€';¥3§:*'-.§€::E€:éé;:::{?a--, _§ ..<%'{:% ':";é§:.. %:_':;§:';§»: 'aim? €'§';5::*:'::= is: a§1§7v..L_ S{;@§>i-3' wf{3§';--..;:*%:;{¥;i:§f%}f1'§i;" 331$ "
i".'t{'}E§f3;§}%EflS$'fi.§Q§"E a¥;:r£z*::E::<i /'*;:';i';;<;i?;_}:=::'V %;}":a 1933 {:5 {§l§i§?€§fi£§{i'E'ié3§;' §§_§S§ §3{';C?"&"%;i$€;'. fihé !§::é__;}%;%,f§Tj;r§§£%;_ 5:?' 'BE' §;;";S"{<:z3;<;% 1 ~.:
:5? 'Q1' z3.%3:>;;'E§.rf§§§;- :E';;é.."f'3"é.';é':;»:::j:33: 'Ez":€W::{i §"'z':3§;:§ 33$-=' iégggéiz €%,?;:?::*%::' :"3;{;i*»i/'fi'.'-':';€':§¢§§:fi;;--:§'gig;V %::':.§'::';%1%r€: 'i,§"§'{E'§ 't.§2«E: gfz_:£%;§:"s':s:::%.?:.AV:::';<?: ;?}:;3§:,"§» ?:,f%'":<~': '€';:"é'§;:%z::;:23§. " ;'::§::§;:s'%:%?;:f'::;.§'§_;", £332 23-giégfgziz» ' E3 %:?':3Z$::ai&;:~§::<§§ ezzaszfé <';§:i::;Li€:* 22$ <:<;:$:§:.:~:.. 'E§'.§:::~': z§§:':s:;:::§:;:.% ii": 5%:-: :s{}$2Z.%; if 3211:: $3 V' ¥:f3§'{§f?',i.§';§',3'5?§'.._ E25: %::%::*;:»:::;2§.E.%:e:§ is ::§:s% "§':*§i;:.a§'3:e;§ 55:23"
' . §:::2;%;:"::a':%;*;'§, Sd/-
JUDQE