S.S.Education Society vs State Of Karnataka on 10 July, 2009

[Cites 0, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

S.S.Education Society vs State Of Karnataka on 10 July, 2009

Author: B.S.Patil

Bench: B.S.Patil

at;

233

26

E~?A=.J§'~§ <§z%N§3i~§§ N§E{}§:i:€.
L»§§{}{}§;}45%1g §§ﬁN{}.Mi}§€E -- 
E3':-§5'.%%'I' {T3 SECRETARY,
iiﬁ' Y{2"%€3%E«3ﬁ;JU

i.«_§€".§€f.T«ECR§§ §§§:3{}iTiAT§.{}§'~E ${}{fEE--'§,'Y Q3;
E'v§}%Pi:%G§§'%'G EAJEEEZV C:2!%NIf}E~1I Mifkeﬁfﬁﬁliizii
EEEQHE-R PRIMARY KANNADA SCHCEUL
LAGGERE PSENYA {P{}.'3'§} B23§N{3»E,«}§C)E€_§i ~ 58,
§2E?.E§"'\f ETS SQCRETAEEY5

K VE?E'€KA'E'E$§§U 'E§fC,} {} KEERE.' 'E'HI§s%§§f§;%iﬁ,}§

SEEK Rzkxjﬁ P-Zﬁbé" E $§'"H¥§a§3?i51 V  b
§'§}5{?"f;}{A '%'§§§}YA SAf'v€S'E'§~iE  '
E*ei1%Né.(§§§*§{} f1Si~iV=i§?%§ ?L§?3LiC Sﬁéiifﬁiéé-_s
'§'?§~E C5§3€()SS, 33?} §v'[ﬁ§.§.\éZ LKG,RAI'~x'§é.NN§;' .
ElI>{TE:NiE§fC)§.'€, IJEGGEREB E3£iN£}§%f§}_HE ~ 38 '
§%E";F'.B':?° §T'S S3s§}{',R§1-"§ARY, '  '
§*;.'%f§L3'§E{:%TE$§~iU.

:§;:::::em'2; K%§'£AR& Ea>uCé;?§@:§.gL.V£g---- . 
{T:E.§E,.'"§'i§§{AL s¢;:€::§:*1":* {R}  5 _  ..
éssﬁzaa :--;«::r«:<;:L§s%§ ?R:i;:g%.§<Y";»:::%'s££><::}1.., 1
§\.=1ISS§(;:*§'~¥ Eiiﬁii :;e::.;£<><:sL §~2:.';=AE}.  '
)f:5;%N<}AL£%§E; 5135 <><:;:: {§Z}§.<;';=._ _ = '  q '-
 23? ms f§EC§%E<Z'E"j1§f¥iﬁ;S%%'é2§§¥f 'a;:..;Lg{::is *

:«:;::~; Eézzrsg «§:::;::.;;:ius;:**;:;:>::*a:; $¢;?.:_:_,"':?f:i'T£'?i'

9:9. :4. 2?<§E:== :»€.a::~--3 §:'2a:i:s:':.;s.  _

gA<;gJ E; gv.;::€'§z;g;é- .:~s;§:;§;§z... ~~

R-*:':~:d:r;;z:;{:s§2?g:V.? E8," '

.  H3 2'-:2::--:::sgj2'A:2%5, §'~£'.§'a§?':§3L§%{}} ;g;§;=w:§;:>.,

 

' v .33; §V§£%§3§f§ﬁ:*1E-3 §;13%3::§:':<>:~s 5;, <::;L?:;§e_::5, *§§:3'$-'1" {:23
* _%é:';;¢':.:§%;::';3;i§=~'E,r:;:' §;§'<:-- szmsgaa ~'~.;::::&*a %s:2A:x:::s3:f-2;:
.  Ci}CI&:'I§?%€i§E' <::A:~?~*;--:>§:;a§ 25:51:,
K (E%;':}£§%.:ﬂ§£§:§:'E»§%%§-1%::§JjJ§, BENQAEXQEQE W 533?;
-§;;?. 1% $2:£=:%g'z:&3:€?,

§',?§::~;:.;<3:>§a%,

AA ; L.:_:_,:§:t::'<':":? §::3z3'{:&'§:<:>r% :~30<::§;'§'~¥ gm

§'§'£E1}.4--é3ﬁg§ S §§§'§i%J2 RQTEEE,

V' *-§€;§%:.§£i}E~§ALE_£a§ mvscmg ~ 21-",

E31-V}? E? E'§"3 '$EC§E'i'éR'§'Z

§4§.ﬁ:§"%§%,S§% E=§}UCA'§'E{L3§§ SC39{f§E'?"2f"-,
MENAGEES E'vi%,§'~§ASA PUBLEC SCH€3£}'§.:_.,
%{:}:E.5'4:y ERD ST§;GE§; KLCEBE §.,ﬁ.YL"}U'T,
{TE-§EE§Eé$*;B£.§'*§;"3;'JREEi%., BA§§Gz'%.£»€I}§%§:§ ~ 93
Qiél-P,Z~3"§ 33$ S§1{3R.§"§éE%Y, S§§.':"E:'I35§{€E§.w§E,E'



513

43%

 ; éé" .

?2?:1E3_,E3':' §'§"'$ J€I}'§N"E' $E€CP%Ef;'§f£E€E"{,
EERE  i§'§'E'%'a§.é{§}1;%T*€E}

§?§€;%Ti~%§§3}«E1§ E?-§§§'?}'?E§'E'§€i =Ij7iF' §;E:é§3{Tz'7'»f§'E{:>{*$ "§"E5€Uft§'? 
§*§ii'f§E,LL§?EZ"§' §E'<-§§iZ-f%F€ §'>2'L%RJ§?sEfa§3:'--'A SELEQ EEQEEES E}
§}£.}F}i};'%§E§£i_L§J;%?§§Ef, §~2U?'éE's§'EE'€€§} S{'.E%';€.'}f;}L §J§.'€§}E€;-P3, '§P§§:Z
E'§z'5:§°v'E§.§ ﬁfiiﬁ S'§"'3'LE-- C)?' §'§2;"5['§'E~§E§HPs E}§€E€E'}"a. P2331-E13'
f§€ZE§€;}{}§;, EERBY ETS S€C§?§;T§i§33Y

._}éé1}1'%.D§S§~§ REESE}? $35,} §§.1%§H3E3E!?aP?¢§: EEIEEBY,

SREQE §'v'Ez§NL§§,}'E%;%,TE§£ ESDYA KERDRE {R}

§"°%€j3.€7:§'?, 21.8?' SEQGSS, EAKSPEMEN Rﬁi} §'=f3%£3:'%i?3 J "  ' 

:<<:;;gzAm.ass<;;a;A ES'? gmcgﬁ, as2N<;:a:;:;j%;%§;  A
§2L,s.:»3~»:'§z~.;<;: ${:;§<><3; EENEEEEE -':"*:~s§<:. zszmsé  _
?':§\§D S'§";'LEi. <3? ﬁ;§L)§TE§'z'1% PUBLEC s<:H<1;>.;:::,;:_ T
:"~2§2;?3.B'1'§'§"f§§ $3: 3L:R§:a:£a:fa.  W

Mama -:':;2';::~;:39;af2:*g §::>é;$A?:o§»: :<<3§j.°E:§;?¥ T§<:§s§;j*s"  
G€;}§.,§$;R£HAE"'F3 magﬁg E~si§zEE'sE R{§ﬁ;§E)4, giarzeaytgzz

?<L§§'é§'€§%€G S{'ZE"%€.}é;}I§.; UE'~§§333§3 WEE ,?'§i7i'§ai§§'§aNE£3.
S?¥§£ €113? §:§'rEF%EE Bi-§Sﬁ.§"2§'f_§" '?;*"§..C?-§"§{}f.}§J_.,_ V  
<IE«C;L'*§J§.,;§,.§2ﬁ$}§;5%.'§"E'§ E%!§§Gﬁi3"i ":"Jf25%I?;':5 E~'3.{}§i:Dg.  .. 
§%§}'gNG;%,§,-GE'??? ~»-- '€31. REP. Q?!' YET-'::'> $EEi§%f%Z'EZ§_.~§§l'E" . f '

Z"3§v'§'?' C§E§»£N§}§%RK,%E_,&.  _ r

33: gm: RES 3:15, :a:E.-2:';c¢;?::i:';~zg':. 3:29; 

:§<::,é<;2._g ::":::5B$ ';;2%":'i§'i}f'?, ='2iE4}';'gYP;E'%_=§£};*%EE,
§;aA:u%;;;a«§  3 4%},,§€S$$7§§"5§§9~§{E'_S{?.?"i'C>(')L :;§~:';';&:§2
'§'§~iE<Z zmﬁ gm; E§'T"E<'L;%"; 133$ i"%¥'§:}K8?E--V' :2-Téi $*§i;;<::;;§::,
«'%'§'§§ §;:,:}<:¥;;.: ::«%aSa%f&:S\g¥m~--';m<3A22
z3;;;2~2<::;m:::2E. ~'=?f'9,"§€E?; :33» as E3§C'.§€iE:'}T}¢2 
§~2E:::',:T:~§ﬁ; SR§.NA"'§'§%: A  ..... <4 .

S75»: gag ?~§.§§'%,5EE*é7E§R!a V§?3;}§':'£ S§1§»sL%:~3'E'§%Ei

V "";'§§LC3§%E?€§;.§i§€1;§,E§i.a%N?iE§§?i§E?:1§ ?v§§I§'\% Riﬁzki},

" V §§;§€G§7:»§,Gi?§L=?8;.. Riizssmsgs SCEEQQL %;§E"€SE§

._ '-"Effigy, téssam: i1%;E?§"§1Z'€ s'm,:s: Q? Q&{';»HA'i«*'E:1?«5§EA vznm
A $;;§@i$':*§--i':::§'j%sEL::§w:§:~;A§~:1agL§,: mﬁsawga R,

%%$?.   SE{'iRE"F,%RY, SM'? ?,%E"vig%TE-§§ R,
8&ﬁ§J%*"'3EfS§*ZW£§g% E9E§{Zﬁ;"fi('}E'~3}%L ESSTITUTEL

.. §"J{}£3i'.:°£;2, ET}? CQOSS, E<;&$"I'°£}RB;% ﬁiﬁxiéﬁﬁa
'§{YSi}E€Eﬁ RGAEL EﬁNG~£'aL{}§E 26, E393 E? ETS

V V _$§f§A£R§;"§'§:RY, SEE? §€A§'~§GA§.ﬁ§{SH§a€§ $aREE'%EE%Z%S§:.

'éi:"fC3 33» S R§§'é§'«§§;S{~3;

   A%é:zg?€;:<3§3;«5gsg%ssa§a: §;£;z;c§§:<:>;~z $@€.§E';'E"*:'

§§§AHA§3E$Hi¥A§A N£G§;§%*%, BEQQERALLE
CROSS, V§$H?£ﬂ%I<3E§3§}z%§%€ F03?' B§§E'=3GAL{JR§L - 
§L§?*€Z'€E§\§{} SCEQEQEL EINEEEE ?§§EZ I\?}§§'«:1E ﬁiéifi S§"¥'L§iZ



46

48

{Z}? Ai§9§~3EE} F\EOBL§§- PE}8Lf§i3 8£?.ET£ff,3(iI?E.,
REE'. BY ETS S?-.f:R§Z'i'f: F??? EEA§'§'§E;%§as'§E'»%2'§
fiL§3'f.') §....»"J§'§3 VEZ§l§'<1:% SE-§EE{§={;%§'<§§'€;f§N

REX-.3 $§fﬁ§§{I'§J§'§i')?€ '?°'E€i§$'?' {E31}

§ﬁ.%N£{§§N£§ {,"iE§Ei$'? SC-§§C3f§ﬁL, %*~E{}1aé,

PEPE EJNEE R%C?=?:.§3_, Ei-§}E€E}$iaE-¥£aI~3ﬁ;i;:ZE E~.fE;%EE'€ Eiiwié'-'s';'},
E%f&&'_"}.i%.L{"}R§? 86:, REP. BY §"§"S

5§E»iT'E~?Ei'§'§:EE', SE2: %é.KE§ﬁ?$"aNN%'% {}£}";i§ ﬁé,

§§{}E?«{} ;'%E:'s(}E§'§' 55 Y§lAE=3S,,

S/5} EJ%'§§E- '?§%_'E§»'E§'é§; <I}€f}§¥§A'

SEE J"§'Q'§'E~§E '?'F:?.§S'T $3} 7  9
;i%*§j%E'%;é'§{§i§'€{"§ SR3 §:'{}Ti~§§ H§'S §l?~¥{I's§.»E$};"' ' A ..
§'§€.'§§4i's,§E'§' ENE} HEGF; S{3§%{§OL, JANGA=Mi'a§§£3'§'§i:v
S§§"},é&GHé§'I"T1§ '°?AL"i,§}€   A'
KGLRR IEESTEQEC'? $352 132, E€E?.§"3"f I'E":E'; '
$EC§E-TERYE SEE JR. SRENIR? 3} '  

356:} E€£aE'2£l.éCH£;E%, EEGEI} §%§3iZ3UT  %\\V§.--€'.,§,RS '

SQ} &¥0T§{§?RUS? {R},  , -. _ -- 
§;L%Ns%§%'sf<;é SE22" J'z'O'?Hi ;%::§§'';. 231% ?§%'f££*¥:Ai7<?E" .SC'%:§<Zi£i}L--
92 535333, 3:mAG;iA*§?A'?A,:J;§--:L_. 2§:3.:4a§T* j  % r _
E}ESTEE§C"E' 552 :92, 23;». B? wig ;:"é}£3Ci§€E;'ET§:.R"§.;'~. _
32; «.§i%=$R§NEVAfE.. ﬁghts:-zxagszgw »%'@.é*§§,.:.:.§2;«s, " "

gjsg: §~2szmAC'%:;g.§2, 'I _

:x§§%%x»§gN z::s::y::g3:>,% *:'::r::;:sf:f 232:1,

'xi'§3éY§;?$£§:G;§§{ 'mg: -.2?":s:;a SE-_, E~3..*;'£'éG;% :_<>§a:~:.
:vmsg<3:§sg; f§ER§=4j;N ;~*a::g:,.:;-~ sc::«;:;><,>;,, 31,352,
3*-;I;a;:~: EASE}, B§;Er§§?§§E} E~;g%,N<Z,%§;E;C3RE zsaxygggrrv
ggggqagaggag 1: 5%, 239, 33* ms $§C:?_E'§AR'{

v  ._%3§e:: Q_._§}§{"Ii:§{A%é §<:;}:1,a§;,.v:;;<; BA {}§:é.E«;5§R!3.P?f%.
* _ ;é;<':;g:*:= gegsazgfr 43 ygags,

" :{S§§£;§I¥§;'%_$E»§§E3§§U..¥§§}§§Yﬁ;§{§<:§*$E§§€A {R},
. "-Esm~z;£::3:~:s;;:z amam S:Z'\§E}E{EE vzaya :<;E:§~:§i,>§2g
1 E'F€GiE8%£-- _'~:~:r:-§a';<2<;:., r»:<:;x:2, 22%;; Mﬁéiﬂ $351223

'£3}§;%§e€E}3%E§§:ZS§{%'$A'E%;%LE L§¥."'z"€3§_}T,_
VE?}3?}i§¥AE*§§YAPUR;§, B§J§{}&i.(OR§:i- -- 'E?
RE§?'.B'£I.E'?S SECRETARY, SEE §},E%éi,E'~E;%R.ﬁ;':'A§'€}3&

 .. VTLga2:g§g?, SK} Lﬁa'?§; §x2i{}?~»E1ii§§S§%NaP?§;

* . §»§%;a3:~sﬁ§%?A m:§cm*:<:>§~sa:, *1'-ans'? 51%;,

E*3§;AE'~E;%ﬁ3N{Eé {}E'§z%E'§AV.R§iiN1 P'UE§${3' SCi~§{}{§E,,
E"€{}.i3a*i§6, i":3'§'§§ Eﬁﬁééi, STE CRGSS, 3&3 §:':LO{I'E£.
?=§;5'%J'*§§§E"~IE Lﬁ§':'{}'¥.}'E"_, EﬁF3GAL»OEE§ 3233?? BY E"?S
S§lC§%E§;'E'ﬁ§%Y, 8?} £3 E~E.iiZ'\§€.,§ %=5;%.§€&N{§f%§éIr§,

5,591"? L§3f?E C§%§§é%;A§€A?%¥G§%E§%§§



75%

  §3§1?A§<;?s.S'§é; E3;'{'} E3 G E€!%.£'€'£i§§3A
§§C%E-313 é.§E§<','}§§'E' $8 'z-:'Ef;,!%.§~3$

iziiigfséiﬁ s2:£;as:2:.Ns 5:; CHELD§<?EN5:"§
EBZ}{i'.A"§'i{"}§'J BEVELOPMEN'? {R}

§75é3§'%E"%E?~EC} sz:§~§<:2:3;, E}§'éEZ3 mg £'€§:£¥§E f:N%L} 3'm,E.;

<3? $z;Jt;mam <:{3:2é2s'E:«2T,

:33»: {::§::e:>s$, G K. 2,123:-'<:::;2: i:TEé%?~JN§3{ESE~§%fARA

mggak é}.~§<'j2$A ROEE 3 BANi'é3'aLQ§€E -~ es.

:'~:;amg~;A E§3E§CAT§£J§*€A%, 'TE€§.%'S'E {R} .

E-£§;§4'FANi-:KUE'€'?E, rmLLK:"-HAHALL1 gm; .
§3C3DDi§B&LL§§?U§[?15;ii§K::, E§AE*€G}%§;{3§~Z,E.'- 

RE§R;%.; §:$'§'§«2;<::':", RUNNENCE A SCHOGL 3,-=';=~.:;';--,%;2'«2 7

THE: §'=§AEa=§.§ ﬁﬁi} STYLE 0? m~':'i,E:'*:a2;.aa:3*":%§x:i<-a: ?:;L.:;.:€;..
gcmyzxa, mmgmxzgmgg 1%iAL§£&T§i2%E§ALIg§ =;§:_>§;:!;~- 
I"3€;f:E}§'},é.3A§;Lz%PL§R gmgux} Bg%..§'JC%ﬁ:L£;%VRE. RU§i§;L 23:3? _
RE? BY' ETS $r_a:£::n21s:'r~,9..'§~2é\:?,. §<;.€}.SEE§?%f-§711§&"%A "2:r§UR'E'Ei'z'1"--.. .~

39: EﬁN<:}&Nﬁ:3"}§£ 'rz<z;$'3:", '  ' _  ,    _
RUNNENG scéisggz UMBER 'i'~HE §'s£;éE\£E ﬁsgiéﬁj v§§§f§~"E'£,_";§.-
(:2? $31 i€$:§f'€GAN.~%.T§~i& HE£§§'ivE.R 'vPRi-?y§é';R':' s:s::::»:<;7«:f;2;?,?
H§:E\§11:BE, zaogni:-xg3a:,Lg;;>:5¥§, BA,z€(3A;1;G§€§: ';aE_s:<A:,
Q§S'§'R§<:'E"f', E?2§_3?T  £323 é3E<:2§:?ARY1  " 

32:: 2»: V S_E:;<&f:*s;t:V_,V_ :2/xcj:  5;: "v?EP§i§;%%'?§;CE~§!':L2%E£:B

}<*:E:f:ZE§"E'E--E.§ ::,:«:.;3;:4:;a ';3§si' E%$§i'~'$.i§ﬁ;v§}_§3_'E*éiai§;§§ V;:m2_ T'E%{j$"?' {R}
'?{§B£}ﬁ  :;<.é:}:::&§3£ ';"k¢:_ga;;:?;,¥£~2;.. gzzsa aux;

ggzqagzfgsxa §€§J';%%§;«.E}§$'E'E?§£'f'I'; §€b"Z%lE'~§iE'~EG gs, SC-E§{}Gi
EJNBEi§?: "ms; :'i,.¢:§*~:§TE». m'~:::>'mjYL§; 93

:~§.:.. 3,3; $<'::i2:<3{:;;,.§ .'i'E}¥'{;1§}E;l?;E, Ef}{}§}§sFaBéLLAPiJ?_ {'§'.%Li§E{}.
Bg~g§éG;a.:,x3R;*a: §<€§§£:%.L :3§3:TR1C?,

..§g=1=>*:j 33 §.fE'S $$E{3E%"£--"--E1*'§§€':', 3 aaruﬁasa

 , S51; ':g£'2: Qgxegmgmxgg.

"N3
_. -{IS .

" V ;$:::: :}§€v«<qi1a»v:i$iE:S:.é2sJ;ma.:A§§ E§UC£'E'§G£*€E.i.- ':*:2:§$? {Q}
._ ';:§,,::2:}{;:;::::g2§»§;::é,f'2;;", Dgzamaazmyiéa '§"§~'aLL§K,
. BgN<;A;£2§;>:;:.T;2URAL m;3*m:<::*:; R¥.§E%E1"€EE§G SC§£iI}{3L LENEEEEQ

'§".'§i§~ z§a:,4E:._'=A:§§ S'E'Yi,-§3; 0? 312 E9? zrzsaﬁzggwaéeaaasg
E'%E§)F2S"E§2Y sa ?§z3.%mR? SCBQGL, i§€3§GE{§E:}iﬁsL
i3G£3xE}é§~E§ALL&P¥.JE€ ?;=aLU:~; amagwwg; EEJRM, BE 3'?

A. , °;s_.§~3f::?'§"g°=:r' rm S§1€ZRE'E'&?i":' K 3 E%%Tl§§¥A$
$;<:;>; L.§£""§: §{,E§BE§A?'*»E€&E.AH
"S=':'5. E«J£E§EE?_&S 332223233' 35305;?
% we 3, ;<Aca:::§,a:,L:, ¢a:;g;<:;: <;£'2;,Lgu2a:»§,w§§,

EE;%§'€{3A§QRE~9§, %3§l-,'f?§ BY §."?$ SE1{Ii§E'§';%S"Y9
S QEEPEK,  F'E'i"'§'i'¥$YiE§5;S

{By Sré. E3'.E},Su;1*a_na, ﬁév.)



E §§?;%'§"'E'. i}? KR R§'é1%.'?A§<£2%
EEEPE' BY W8 $E{Z'§€t'§.-'£"3%§'{ §3{}R E§}L3€;'.ATiii_'}E'%§
3%. £l'£E§EE }§{A§ '%?E3E;{}%é§,
f%'i{§L'I"§S'E'C!R§E;E} §§_¥EL-DENEE, E%:*i§F%{}.§%.LQ§~EE:';:

12 DEPUTY EEEEEEECITGR OF PKESLIC: §%\§?3'?i§3£,§C"Ei{i}f'§-§:v
§}§2§'AWME{*-ET {T}? B-§I}i}Cﬁ;T§{}N, J'  A'
E§A§'§{§1%£zC3R?~ N€C}§%ZT"§{ '"i°'£§§jU§\ig.

K. C: R'=;}1%.D§, E=AN£§AL=I;}E€E°

€22;

:s§§?L§*w §}1§§§{ffi'?'GR <3? 993255: 3N3'?-IE,'£§CJT§1{>?'%
E;}E%7§R'§'Fa:E§,N'§' <3»? E;D€3{ER?§E{>?€  * 
E:%5§'=$GAL{3E2E: §2::.r§eA:;. ;3:::i§:E"<§a:t=::-_

Bazaegimaa ' '  2

4 33923:"? EZ§iE13E{T§'_":'i}§~Zj Q??UE1L}%$;£E'{S""§7§iE}'§:'?E'£3§'}§. "
§3EE'ﬁ;§€'?§vE§:ZN?§"{) .E1DE§Cé§JF}€3§<%" ' 
E'5§§s.§\§a'}1%i,»OR,?Z'-?:§G .,__ a%;_'i"'.£LL'é:,"fK  _
mmS:?a;'L¥5_"--~.   
BA:~§<3.a:,x:;2"e,§  

    

5 m;P:.;*W ;:3§§%gi.:--*r<;;R':f;:r ';'~7'i§}'51.i=§C_iE'=i5€sTEi§_3£T"i"EQ?%,
BEP;§;R'{'§e;§§:i§%'§7 :3:'a*."E::;>Lf::A " «e '
CH§E;E:L%BRLLA,§'f}E?  " ._
£?E;%§KKﬁ,.E?£L%.é?§j'?E §.',%':$'§§-;--":;€*.:.'

5 532913'? m;§~::<:_=::*2':;::;2-'-- aypmiéazaé §r~:s?R%;;c?::>:=.:
:2i£a%,%tmag§:i:~;?'  §ii:s§;§C;%'§'§Ok'

..§%g§'-f:s<;;_gga. {f_:=£$'§"RIC"§",~ ..... --. *
._ _ 2g2'§?$<;::*<2*;: «_
  é}EP€¥'_§"?'~;€ffiivE€E';C*E'€}R <:%E<"'.?E1§'i%L§f;", §§€S'§"§U{I':"§'Z{}N
 ._T§3:;§;:;1::A..:}i,r::?:§:2%;*i:v2§*;ra:*i* £2? £Ef}U{3§{§'i€J§$
2 "E1§I»§K§§§~§'_'£%S€3Z?§'E«£} Tijzwiiiiéz? 5353??-2:3?

V V' 3 ':;:=._§:;?*L2i'?¥ 2':;;?:s2§*;<:':':3R (>2? 923313': ms?§:::;3<:*§§<>;s§

"  -€§i.B:3 ésiaziahai', £%.§£}

E»*§53z,§':>:§£ ;:§§;?gm'§s;:E:.~%'§' O?' £:.§a,%«=:':g,-':*§a:;:*«:
 i::§A§w€},é~L{}RE; ms-'";"*:%: ::*?
'A =:~s;_g;x:sg;,<',>RE  RE$F'GF§BEFi"'FS



¢ peiiizézmers anti 9:0 gfarzt :'ts:€:0§{1§tim'1 Ea ﬁzzaﬁie ihe p€§%:ia2:»m":;'

'"%['§rzr::s:*;:3 Writ §3<":'z" :'£é:}n$ am iFE£s:<:§ u:':d{:§ gfariiéties 22% $5 22? 2:»? {he
{Ii<:::'":$i§1;L::§<3§3. :31" Enziéa ;:s;'a§_;§:'3,g is q%_3a;=3E': EEK: §r11;_:L;gm:ri
<2z"é::.:'$/&::da:?$E:z':16r:£t8 arid; ziiiect thgzi §'€S{.3{"}§1£§'F:X"':€$ :5: $31.23 c5:§'i:i:fi$s:;i€: 0%'
:*é':gésf,rati::n I'€i§{§;'Si€§'§§Eg ;2ré:::&:s:"§;* $:tEr";<"3{3§ in §&Vi}LiZ' of siege}: Qf {ha
1.

§az*23.;:

Ezlngiésh Mée:§§1,3{:: PI'éma;*§; Schixsi $1" ﬁr: ihﬁ :5.Eie:*':':a't,:v€ ':9 {§€;i'E,*.§c".'ii-"r'§_"'?:':.§l';:.':"'?_"'£ {E35 petitioners am eyéiiiiad in $113: E;-§':g%i.$h ?'§%§(§ii.ii'Z.'§ §*:fé--:2*1a.:*jz,*' 3:12'? 6:0"

'§'hc3s~:"--; §'{--;%4';'i%,c>;/':3; :'.sm§:':g '«:'i§"§ 32:2? <m'§,:3':j5; t§1.'§$T §.§':"if_-,?;.}?§1'6:': i:Tf3L:":§§"=.€j;:s§:?i: '€336: .;z2§::'=;%¢%z"zg: -»~ §RDE& -

1. 19:12 {ha ;3€ti%iQ11€rS aré'ci%§36':_ r1:?E§g»é$§9€z:§:;§ :§r;;ciﬁ'{i€S 9:' 'I'r':1$'i3 rzmgzizzg <§vV§3?Ti"£c5n:3::}i'i;:sc}iEi${>i',§ ﬁzz} §§d123;<:aii0:1 Exam 153 £0 5'41 Siaiidaiﬁ. "§"1:avcAV:§_';aéi'E__%iie$€ iwit pgtiiiams <?ha}1m'1gé11g Q16 f€jéEC€§;fi(}I1'€f~f?:€:§'§;7i}.€§'_ IA'€3{.}:3;ii;f§§§ mask: fin" pamﬁgsiarz $.19: impart

-=€:§3~1:c23_ii€;s:;Vi.i: Ei:1gii$Ea.z;;$di:1m 'Eb? the aca{i$mi{: fa,-'E:af ;.?{}{}9~§{'} Q}: ":?<;:>:: g:E:'::3::ge?,_Q¥'§'A£E:.§iiéum.

2' ' ._'_§';'§e jéiiiséﬁiiritinziai Beputy Eﬁirecmr cf Puiziic Ensiiticétiomé .. %::;1s rejecigéi 1316: apgﬁicatians fﬁeé %j; fhﬁ psmigzimca 9:: '£316: i:'§1€ ziesisimz féiidﬁrﬁzi by $33.6: Fzzii B€I§.{f§E£ 9%" this ..._ '{f:m: .2:rt in :32: C355 Q? ammmmn aamgamkmxrs me' rmggagv gxﬁ "$$€9§§ﬁéRY 3€§*§Q@LS Eﬁ ﬁ'?$§§& Vs. '"£'E§E $§'A"§"E $33' K§;%&T&% R? §'i'$ $E€§$"§?.z%RY, ﬁE?&R"i"§rﬁ§'F G13' $"§?3Cﬁ'fii$?§ £33. #6 aﬁmgs {ELR QQGS EAR 2$§5§ is; €.'h&3l§€§.1gf":{ii E>z3§:'?{;3:%: ihé ﬁggxtx {iami £32 Sb? Rm; 3.3 13% 18 16:3 ;'2G§8,

3. '?':}€ imgmgzied e§1:§01"$$m€1:'£$ Siam mat. {E123 €'§§.i{§.SE'i{)§1 mgartiizzg ;3€:'mé.$:s:i0n is he gragtﬁsii fer '?:mp3;£'%:x;11g €t:3;u€:%at::§;:§ §:3 Eiizgiish ijﬁﬁfiiiiﬁi is»; 'izaken up 33€'§€?3I'& {E153 éspax €;":m.:a*:9{" 3:33;? ''}.ié:§1,¢£; "

3.1% §'€:;;aest. maéﬁ 'E33; ma }_L>€ii{Z§<f}§E€i"S {=;~1n;:;:f*:: 'Q57: g1';é:;:fé;% §::;31;f .:%§';~; p§*€s&n:. it .m;.--2§,r" ha mantierisﬁ Eha: thaiigh ;§.§¢é.i. $12:

emiorssemeniis am iS$11€€i icy mf€:*;tE_:'i'g..ft::: thé j1:c%gz3:<::M:1tV._§é'E'f£.:e: i3'1:i§~ V Bench smii 6:"; ma gzﬁuﬁd ighat the,.r3{g'xt':e':*..§s tai;:£*:';3.V:;p_?;3€£%31"& {ht Eapex (Emmi, same: mi" 'S16 "§J*:i§j}a.:§g.rz1€if;iV }e:i'<.:'f€l>3::~?s3£;:m:313.is: are Téssueci priwr ta {E13-g_§.1;€i g::;i§§:'f.:;i;;_ fjf F"é'1i§-...E3€:ich.: HQ'W€'i$€1', simtﬁ {£16 <tmﬁ1'€:V€z"§;§»* YEiZiS€'ﬂ i1v"§i'if'ii:._§T€::;i1{f'1{1(1€§d 133;" the jzlégzzzﬁzzt of {ha §3":1ﬁ §€n<:.E1, ii: is'3;z:;::12atsé:"iaiA.1:;%;1¢§§':€:' the ':'3.T£1€}LOI'S€i1"ﬁf:§Zi'§jS 2:63 ismzesi _ tariéar, ':5:;:§3s:2{;3i*&2'a::_iV:{{; $5 jutignaﬁriﬁ 0f the i{~f'"i3.}.E Bmzcéz. ir~im1<:e, ~.i§., 'i:e., :"1e:>j£ .:{;.::%,<:%i:-:=;$aztj; $9 rfafésr ta} 33¢}: ﬁsf 'aha iinyugzssii e:1§?é3u:_}fzfT':é¢;me?':';:e":':«;.,_p:*%§:§'£iceﬁ £13. @1655 writ peﬁtiims. §'€?:i§§{;:§.€:"s 213% V 323:} §'m:g;Eii fair 3; éiremiiazz is the rssgmndezzis is iﬁﬁtlfi H "ii§.é;'?if§ca€€"V§§' R€g:istra'iii@:1 :'egzZs%:ari::g '§Z}"iE Frimary Scihaois mm giéﬁitiaaﬁra am} gran: rétcagnitien tie them enaijiing them % és:s..r:;:n English §.§f':{§§11m Pxdmaijz Schmis.

gﬁ ,.§ 77..

5%. ixameé cmsmsai app€m'3';r;:.g $503" ﬁat: p€~:tii:ic>m:§'5; bzimgsz :0 {ha Erzmiare 0%" iizis £36111? the jmigmitmi :r::3x:§§:§€d by this; iT7<m.1*E in §J.?..2€e$.639é-6395£2GO§ whssixsain szimiiar <:E1a}}€mg{t was :z;1"1a::Ti:=:.. '§'i:i3 {Tsum 137; jucigmanf. dateai 06.34.2909 has {gt}:/}§$i'iV(:?.{_"'§' ".1§lii.€3 siﬁsélar fi§fI€,§(}i"$§€1Q€E1'€S issuaei in £'t?.Sp£tC'i ﬁf ether sc::.;;i€x)1$'~i;iV1'§:}1é~. Eight zaf %:I::<: jurigmﬁzxi rﬁnﬁered by the §%'11}i Bench. ., Ffifﬁfffid E0 htzmin above. A di:2s%<:ti3:n 1;; 'aka iSSu_€':{i,V'TQH§:'1(:' §'ftSpGI1{3€E}?.S ':%1e;re§n cgnsizisr _"§}.';€ a;}p'1Er.:ati0;r1--'V--A.iIi1ém7«'by §L%3€ = pci5£.i9n€1"s ﬁt}? rcgigtazilxg the scﬁogig £9 iI:}1}}EiVf'{ ':€€§iiCa§i011 in Eng}is}3, medium iii aecortiazxce vf;%i*{h 3:15': on tE1:ei:i'AV:ref5:.pectiv:-3 marits. PeEiEio:1.srs 'warts: diracmé iii) iiié f:7¢:¥§1:£.:';3f913Iicafi0:: prayiilg for mgist:':atic;J;: sf 'v--i2_=:i':'i1in a paiiiemti of 0316 week fmm 'aha iiatzé sf ﬁzeé Saiii Thﬁrsupezi the rr3$;3:::3(it:::t~ ' §}€f}{i.i};""§: '§*?'.i'€€f§01" §1}$?.1'l1C?;§GI1S has beam dirsgtisd ie 7,ce1::$;i$§=::;' apgzsiicatieng wiihm 3 peiieé 0:" f:::;ur weeiis f:?€<:rm 135315 daft "-#5315 riﬁzfrkiiyig .:;é>'§s"'€he sp§ii;::aEiQ:};$; This Q1"€§€I' havézxg 'imei:

_c23aﬁe"'1?agec?._ i:: §3§ﬁ%. Agma; ?%s&i682~iE'?83;'2£}€§§, tbs Sivﬁigimzz '~.§?<:3f;<:?§: :<::s§;;ﬁrm€€i the mtim" passsti by 1315 23311336 Sizzgie A ;J 12.d§§:€}8a€}?'i3{}§§}« " " £33. Efiief Eight, of ihé Qfiiﬁi" §:saS$@d by $316. iﬁazneii Sings u Qiudge raiériﬁé 15:} suggra ami me gfudgmezﬁ pasgsd. E3}: the E1}§v%.$i0:: 8€:Z{"iC§'§ 9%' this {ﬁeuri cazﬁinnéng €315 $83118 ami if: View {sf %.

Em: fact? ifégai Q16 p€'{§.'{i€3§;"iﬁ1"'S %1::":1"€£§2. 5-Fifﬁi Similariy gyézicmi, __%;_h<:$a batch sf '§%?'E'i'£ §'§!iEi'EfEOZ'£1"3 éesarvs {:3 b5 {§§.Sp{:$§{':§ ef zarms.

é. Aac:cQ:*&i:1g1§;,, the émpugmtzi en :i=3:3:=~.mé:1?..$ .r: :»{:::*e?i1 &::::$x11:"(:~ﬁ;34 airs h=E:r%::33j»; qu.a.$h§::':§_. E3; i$'---mafia {:1 agar Aihait e';.#<i%;::$ r prsaiiuceﬁ at z'%:';:1sX':1;"*<:s--Ai :0 33, E3 aiaﬁ 8 Ejﬁiiiiﬁﬁﬁfﬁ £16363: &I€ }i§3€_i*%§'V_ i:;<;:§3i%}'~a;1pEi{f$§}0:i §§'i"{}§iE1 :31 axggek ﬁsmm taiiay *a{3fe:>ra :§§_ f;§i:*ea:*.t«<>r «sf Pziééiic §ns§§ru<:ti<>;;1s"?;€§é:£<i:1:§ ﬁzizxcation in Engiish. 151;':"1*:§q:'é::€i';f€§:3.gV éZéf--:,A{:§¢;a1:g€ 0%' medium, '$316 'a§'2;p:§iC3'é;:Q11s am: pass apprapzfzaie {>ﬁiﬁ:"$ ¥;§.':.§--::1:z fearxx.7t:§i1;'s'?'%.§;é1*r§:'b:§f= 37'. V. :*€:ga§;'sis: ..§3{£'i:§.§%@%;e1* in S§'E'=§€,a.3f% {hang}; ?B§_; mistake 21 wmzzg :;§s§<i;€:3z1€":1?: is grmiuaéd at Aﬁ:1€X::r§~%;%4 {shat §:"~:Ci mmaizxs; §%'Ef;:a;'%{"' £:;5 ':1*?s§€;:§§:1%§>z::ii3.<iﬁ bf; §:e¥:i'§m1er ?§Qw34 is 3336 §e::j€=:i§e:{§. am; _ £§1€ré3i'<§re.._%;:;*i§'§1--:§%1*£ stanéiing an ax}? '%tecl:mi:7:aEii§;, {ﬁg §'ﬁS§)§3§1{§€EE1'§ exiiz-:.::%§~ simfiéar b€:1§,ﬁi".$ '£9 gaeiiiisiisy '?§§'34 :.2;E":Q sahaéi maiié ' . za;%;V:3;._§s§:%£ica'ié::3:": $212: gﬁgigégwaiimg 23:' ibz Cfsgazigﬁ G? mad £133} w:§f{.E"aﬁ1 " = -€::=.'?;E5$ 2z::*;s:€k; iiem éézﬁ (3213:: sf §'€C{'i§:_'§}§ :3? €f£_".3§}§;' {:§ Tihiii ilﬁilfiﬁf am? am: §{i$p<3:;§%€%:':i ashaéi €Z.".<}f§Si{§€£' ﬁgs': sami-3 it; a<":(:.§rﬁa:<1::s: wiih iaw wééézén 3 fg;:€2"%{3:i 9%" fm.:;;" w<:$i<;3: i§E§3I'€i3f§EZ£1 fk/My

8.

W 1%: Pzéiiéicszis 215$ a<:x:r:;z~{§;'1r:g};}? ﬁ.§$p<§3<:{§ afl

Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court

S.S.Education Society vs State Of Karnataka on 10 July, 2009

Author: B.S.Patil

Bench: B.S.Patil