Karnataka High Court
Shankar Sangappa Kovalli vs State Of Karnataka on 3 February, 2011
Bench: K.Sreedhar Rao, C.R.Kumaraswamy
}--4
3% THE Eélfiiwf CGGRT 8? K/5'\R¥\EATAE<2% CIRCEET $E§\JCH fix"?
9HARW£:Q
$9353 THZS mg 33" am 09 FEBRUARY 2531:
PRESENT
"mg Hawggg MR. 3EE$T£€E K. $REED%~iAR *
AND
"mg HQERYBLE MR, EU§?E{iE C6RLKL;;s§¢:§A'S»;%A.§\€"~:%'*3
CRLMINAL APPEAL'am.25'41;'u2o1Q,'%.%._f "
BETWEEF\E:-
3:,
TQ: §§é2f:a??--.E«r; h3h§é, fiégtz fiagaikata
5 {_5:%f"E-§;"é'.L "c':%a :73 g
'.39 an
Séwamkaf $anga§§a %<:3x:a'EE~E.,.'
Age: 25 years, Sac: 1:\iea'~va;%r.,
. Qangadfiar "?€ee:%a §'§§a_'§%i»;=tVéE;:~;_s5*é;*'":3»€a:' @
Nee§anL2r,".%g1'a: 323 3,¥":E%.I.;g.:'s;..g'::;2:"f Bajsiness.
an '
;>is'ia$'§*a~§x§ ?§:§ra§:°gr3a E';/éaié,
':2-£.:__;'%g'.r.'%::.,:§EL:2"e.
{i
E
m2'3::5«
a ii} §
9 'Mfg: %%%%% j
;.23h;a':=aV:e$§fs'«?:2.s%é';:'3§a Dafiigmeéa,
':-'ag e_:_. 25; .v';%'é:_a ! §,v'*f:fl§.:€Z fig rim Em re;
ME R:£§ "§f*%--: aV:§a%_,
.\.é§:»;§€%§ar'2i'$
aéé M, Bhaif .5:m:§£ai§}
3
5
E /'"M""ym
5 'a
23
ANQ:
State 0% Kamataka
83/ State Pubféa: Pragewtcr ._.Resp::m a;ient
{By Sr§$"J.§'»-'E.Ba:'13§<a%}A.S.F'.?,}
Tééi créménaé appéaé $5 film E_;§gfS€C.3?4{2}~'_é:"f '
see§<.'mg to set asifie this émmggned JL,sfigemer:i_:..€3:f':;;<3r;-a_,{§'€:_i2;r2"'
and awe: of gentemce, dated 1G.O3.;2»Qi._0 am! ifsfi§}3;'Z.{}*1@'L-._V
feggsectiveiy, gagged gm §.C¢§'Ja.S6/21:36?by,t"ine'7Fa$:~.f?,r3C§~:_ '
Court; Eamakhandég by aééawinz Ems"-v.a '~..:ée:~;§%, T<:.r:m§e@;::;~:,?:**;---ii?
. . .5?
acquit the agjpeilaats 2 ta 4 J a<,:,e:_;.:§e§T"?>ai;§.'..: t03TlL& 6 l:>ff:h"e:»
Ch3§'§€S ievelieé against them,' _ " . 2
This appeai ::3mér':g.----.§>n :%z'i'$--. _:c5aVg}-«._wt" 'final ~%2 ear::'sg,
K. Sreegbar Rag, 3.; dseiéaéegfaé me ;'z'>,i%::,*::';~f»§,V%r:"g%:_~
auméasggf
2. =T?'s§ 'm_aé:~§s*%,3?T»__?&s.:;'?:"$, <3? the prasecutiaa Case
disciaae mat2:;-rfaé-S§§éa§aAE§.:§§«é-7£3 ms decaagafif we Rgmegh
V4-723$'»f'w'&,§L3"§"§"ta'Ff%:{:é jg i%§'é«.C'.:3_r:rsg§3énar:€ arzd znaterrzaé mile ané
E*i.3E<*;i}4?%"a;';.s"+ 5 the fiaihe: cf the zjieceaaeéz W23
V a§§é'!§a:*~."i ?\§€.s--3:"%Lj,--1 1=*§a fig are 3€€%JE:1€§ ?~éag¢§ %;a 3 am: 6
r:=:V2§€£i;4§%;gE1;,{?¥r 3523?: £3 is $3 mé §§§=§'}= "R18 aaaugefi
=.. :»'§.§,..4AA :T§L;---mi aizgrsng the j'}€E'%fi€F¥C"j;' cf iiém Ema; §§"s€§"E*;;{}§'€j'; me
£3.13-3:+:>":a§a%,%"§§i: aéciuaegi :5 abaiesi. éfme Zfétimaé ?'*'§5%"L§5i.i§
Pudafi} the accusefi $33.5 hefara: me "i""r3Ei €Z<:.>:.sri: iws mi:
greferred any Empeai against mg erdar 0? CQFWECESGFE aiiher
jaintiy with the 8§Q€ii3§'%§'S herein gr geisaraisigr.
2, Cine Kara, Sumiiiira is the sister
mi citefi as wiiriegs ii': the sriarga S.§fi.e':?>,.£-f.§§;_, A-;2"'i's§f;'.ié§'3d'_'.¢i'---_
2%,}, bfith 0% them aciviged am deaea?i:«sedi£:;e9'6iiscsiizfii;:§,}§i'*---:r;:'§1:i
icwe affair with iiism. fiumitizzal "i1:-zit 2:59" mi:
was me amiss. Tiserefciré, t?fz§%},>-..V_aai-e_»re E136-:'--3r§i'2gvi?grC%use
agaiiesi the éeceaseii. i_irier*i:_;:i_';:f"'i:.ii'e::§e<:ea5eé and he
had given hand §O8.i".§ {>25 3-E';";ii.,.Q.'{}G:,i-'!'*i'":0:'i:V§f'i§ i§€:Zfi<"i§€C3. The
decaased :efu$eé_ i:{?*%§f;ifi{§ ltiie éflfi-§i"QVEV'i"'iH{§'E,%§7'i{. Tiiareiare,
he wag beéying' gs,rééeé'-@_4ag3'i:3§'i~.the éezeased. "me damaged
wag iefigiizg 7t5;_:e"<3%ri£:_éf.§:§iié_;s£§'if3Qi, w7i:r:z am iii iave with
g;f;,a% 8n€rfl'_§:£fi$;V§;. i:heréfz:>..re, A4 and A6 had gr-suse agaérzaz we
é:%ecefas.i3@. _V{;V::*;a. ?earaEai :3 the wife 3'? A5. fire fieaeazged
waé~ié3_3iii;:i~ '§»<a;e'i;é'é§i, i§"'i€i'€ii7%f,,"'-E"!-3;, iué hm QFCSLESE agairigit
iiie dec.":.e:a3£§§,"_i>-iii"f,i ta $16 hag' éiifezemi: €'§3§€13E"'iS fer mgying
.1"':3%::szsse_a§aVi"nsi :i"wz:= afesegseéi iiierafare aii :3? fiiem fagmeé
€if'g_§i"%';.2é'i:2é§ i,mi§w§'ui a$:<;ei?:i:i%=:; vi-'i:?*2 5:: §i'?¥Z€F':?."éG%"i i:<3 C5§,§33
--«sf;:9:':.:';r*§'er {:25 §%="e:35ad~§ii%2;z3i%:i§i3:
M'
3
§
if
3. Ge 2@--§8~.2Q€}8 at abeut 8&5} pm} the deceased
ieft tee mesa, he me net return in the eight. P'W'.1 "and
ether fereéh; members meee atiemet fie trace the ee42:Veeee~:j
wen: éa vain, Or: 29«€%8-2fiG8 at ebeet 2-628
'meg; were eeerehéeg tine eeeeased nee; fine £eh"e"'---eé_"~,P"afif,'iA2--.e,
Beiepea Seiiyeeea Geedejé, they fe..er:c;?"e:ij?~;eé:;ee§é" efVf§he::Ve_Aé
deeeaeed scatteree. Wéth sage-..é:::_;e=§e;e{y...._.V;j;':e3ee%
irzienséve gears?» in the eur:euee§_eég.V:_eeV;j feééssdiieeefrj beey
ef ihe eeceesed wee s:enVe'e.eeiegi%e ;:»_j.v'.§"1"E??3{:§§73 :':C3~?;:.bp eieees. ?'\;xj,;%
Eedged 3 cemeramt.befeyre-~-fhie 'eee_;e«"'_e:tA"--ie3C% em" The
Pefiee ceméueterif-._see€V' _§rrée.;?*:eezI;2% ae..%§:~.%n"qé.s'e'S% mehazar. "§"§"1e
eeae my -'Pgefwféd examéeetéee, "flee
L
eetepey :e§2..e%*é_ <3E/Se;'::3Ase;§*-.._iiiinéi the death is eve :8
:::reeguE;3:%:.éee_, ee.ef:%2-?:'e §;e:%iée§eTei ewe' the eeee meg wee»
"?.§'v€R §*£3'g;é*{:V§"§ eéefleeee that the eeae: $2 see
iti-:_:_ tee?;:>rje':%_S%x:e«.?e:'..ee ie the meek arse E: eeesed 4 ie é eeage
peie-;** '%:e: e;§<'ex.re%'ee£:§er:, "fie eeeih ée Semi 'ze ee
V hemieéeeé, '
9+? deaegéfiisaj. if} 23%:
4. The mveatigaigmrz further reazeais that {me
Shévaji :.a:<mare S%*1é:7<:i%"%e~PVa;'.:€}, win: wag gemg c:r2_pE?»{?t;>.t€;-%f
Cg/<':%e 9? mg fréené 'm aiiem arzzmaé fair mjm
-w.
:2: 5' '
-'#1
an the way he féndg ihe deceasezi in .f_;;?2,;e__C0m_--g§'é'm"=g:}::5 ;¢3:.':» .:G_.
R6: Pvv11€: made fun ca? the zjecésagéiid a_jr2;<j..-i'ha':§._a'. cV"i*1a'%i %;w._';:2'1:::VT_*
the aecefieci thereafter F29 pr*ecéa--si£ e§ ?:;.r:V?3:ér. v:'.:._.§V
éjeceaaed gmgahaaeé s:7a§i<$ f:@Vrf{;;L "::.%}_gr;*--.._»;h(E P'\;fi}ji,? am'
gmychaseé beer frem the-fisfigajg 211:5? '§5V&j3;' §§>"_and guichagefl
mafia fmm {he 3&5}: V'? the ahm G?
P'J\i.§1: "§"%";e s!a4é..z:i§ ; witrzegaeg {G
Eagt seer: réirzviéwe cgmpazay of ma
abwe sgézj' 3§§{;AV$'é:-'$3,.-«..%"$*is"§..f:"*§r's?3fs:.&§§a§§z:>;r": furééwer sreveaég ma:
A3 hm 51":a:?:i":€3 €:~<t;r§<ifijfliC:_§<§%-.':ff{fi'§.t:%*§'ESS%an fer gauging; murder"
9'; 5:'r<;&S;: Tiififififi §"{€i§§sfi§E§»%3"v"»:'X5'
_ V.
.\ 5,}
ffii _ '%7.1§"gsf: '&i::%a'e:':<;e <2? ?'.;%i,1, the mgiemaé amcée 5:25
?%:'z;"'.Q".--§§:;%:Eé'e~?_"_v:3__}§'éjéié déetaasad éegtéfy 5:3 333% mauve if} the
;,~ffec't é'%":aé'---';%hé:;'"§a:eage§ E235 Eiiise affair aazéééz 551% Eumétféraf
A§%::f:er 5? AL Tm aieceagaé wga thragicenefi ima $3 amt?
._§%:!'":"'e:a:*5§' 'gm aé:zé3=:3§ me: is 2092:5253 'me §@a»~:~:~: 55%;: waif':
(S
Suméthrax The father am} L}flC§€ of ihe ejeceaseg saégc
§3K«'l§€d him ta give uép éease affair with Suméthra,
A3 are arféatesii 30~Q$~2C!G8 am as
31.99.2995.
T2'. Tine accused $3 charg@£? f€,'r_A'§an9i':::'ét;%.§::.g" f%?z.§'* Gffence LE,/s.§43, 24?; 142, 3<3'2,,L:"':~»€:*;2% a%§d__ of EPC. A
8. in the Conte><t"éf 'i§éa 5a;§3§f§f'é:M.v'r_:.gf";§%ec% maieriaé faciza fmm the re_<i.:,:£;f'c}, H: §=j3c>e'S_"Jrr2<.;.:"ss.»:j_ggegb that 3% marge $3,143,, :47,,;:%'s..,,V:§éf EC further iaxfskifig saeafzim l4,{}'Ei§':£ i'§;iI::,;;3ro";f{er--,' ';?"h'€:V.V-3":§feCtiv€ Charge $§":GL§§C'§ %,3€ é§;'s.E2§€}'--e_8'.3hcE .'£ §,_ ""§hé~.. §'.;"§'é$,}v:';"%'.-CiA,i«?'Z %€V2r'?4*:' ram' E3$$f1 the fcxiiawmg :_.«"'<:§sr;;ur':";;..§_'§';3r:y::Lés.,:e:: p%é<se-------%«E*§E gaséét :33' me aciugedn ' fiat éihe EI§t?C8&S€§ was fiaxééng £0229 V . §<:;m'Sum%'shza, fins aégter sf éjf whéafi \.""'§"Jéi-Snsfiifiiééifi sf A; am aihera Thg father ans " ._§3~s2€£e af 3% ciegeagefi '%;"*J€;¥'$ aiaes aévésaé the éaceaseé IE3 Ewe §fE'a%r wétéi Suméiééra, :%2a:'ef@ra, 92,: arzfi i."L':'i§"E€§'S fiaagrmg grfiuge agamsé me fiéiifiaiééfi z" ""?~~.
E; ..
{iii} We iagi $e&n Cirmmgtamce af A3 and fiafi; and fieceageé being tagether gaurabaséng gnacks fmm the shag ssf PW}; gurahaging bear bettm frsm {ha gimp Q? PW8 and purcfiaséng etéwwa frarm shag of Pwfi §L;$é: a caugla sf éweurg bef@r_;s:_""t7r':'éj'~v-- . :
incident, The 23$: seen CEE'€ZE§f":'%SfBE'%C€ % and A6 and deczeaiaefl ;3a;rc:%§a;€;i'rzg.«B:aéjs'Aar":§:"
the smp 35 PW.1, just befw;~-- a ::¢up:e'"af grist' {Q the incident "$16 East seer: c§rcum§tan$é*.§{f 125.3, A26 and decegsed wé{ev-._§'c;us%fiWg§>é'ri.f;;V .§ %;é{;et%2er va '%@é3VVnd 8.38 pm, jug? 5 $C_'9'u§ief7'::? _?_z::<:§':;§:?::.L §e_f0re the incident 3;? ,?w.2::}"' "arm1Z';:%i_'a1:_'jPg\;{§;'.is ..;:a7:":§of made a far: cf éhe égiéceasésd éaé 3 :?'hat"v§:§t§:"'€he $583883; whe:éA E1féév.~a;g;%3:§3'g%aér:g; :;~r1_f='%.o':«3r Qraie Qf his frienfi» "§"§:e ::%rmzéé%s':a%§<,:§ t:*f"R3 making extra judicéaé €::3é"':fé'$$i{5r"s~:f:'f fiG§z*{m%'{t%r'2§ mugfigs' sf fieceasgfi ;>_i3ie§1::;*e ?K»='\f'.E,-- -----
V' -- 4%e::§§j.srt éégcisges that {$18 3633": is hemécédaé e§r":'V:é*:ja:€:;:é';:n%: 9? aggéécatéon <3? camgreggive forca $3 "€*E:':é';':!§:%< amti Qegm hag acaasrres 4 --- E: fiagsg gm:
-*;I:i:';" {fie ?.Fv"E. examématicsm, whim': apmsxémataéy qzgénaiéama the time :2? 31% ézzciéarzia ?' 1%, In the avi§es*z::§ W131 @733 givers the eviéance at) the effect that the deceaaed was having maze affair wééh me Sumétiwrag wéw ig gigier sf 5%.} am he was advisea by time 3C€iJ:'§€§ 3:36 by PW§1_4 family memberg of the deceagéd ff; give up the EGVJE§:éf§é%q?V:"éiyf'§E§§7____ _ Sumitéwraf but %';a Sid not heed and therefgre, the"»ac§L.::é::i: x;:2.{&:é: 'V bearing grease againgt the deceasgé, Be f::;;:"f';t.17E3s5<s i:;sAi:é'§- .' fleceaaed Ker': me 'réouge an 2é~«{}8-2C'G8s.._§r0uf'é:i,_85$§ p;:.;~;;; 1_g§~:_gV ma Rfit return is ixome' He aiamg maéé attemgi; to Search the 362<:easfe:<3;_..';:irz_'§ 353% b @dy in aha éam af ?W'12;, which wag a:o;r2;:e..:%ai,:駧_¢4§:"::.' if;%Vf':nf=;,L h3éaV:;t»$?jV»§§:Ejne$ 3% ZQG gm an zamawses afigii Q5-V6igéégrw§.§_éi5§':'§é;e'Ea~r;§ ma ?(}E§<:e. in {he mmgjiaéni Egg n_3;'*éé§-".;%%;;.i:vAiV"Ir:"§,g:;;~..,._;frx.;'E*;<j have zemmztieé the murder besauge 9? .iai§e '3ffai§'r"<§? with Suméthrak There is as mezztéen éggibéuég 535: §a».§sé':i:c:u'.mt:3nca :2? dezeasaed in the aesygpaugy 23?"
3.3,' M gmd' 9%,:-3 ' ir;u:::;aed $3; Pxzw, mg.-11?, mm and éxsw, 9:v:,a:§ ans WJL;"i.:¥";a'j_r:<,*é :'?:%-gig mentésa cf "free €IiE'€L§F§"%SE3;F'sC8§ 9? exiéa jzgéiaiaé V V' :.:3r:f€ss%'<::a;a ::f:_;3$eaE§'y A? m PWXE.
" *;l;§_§ ";%'"%':& mateiéai wéineggea 2:9 extra jsgdiztiaé €£'§F§f€S§i§5"'§ W¢i;E, .%z:.é1_:';é2fi§K?, ?Ef*«.;Z8, 9:.-r'»:.% am @232: hm mm-;e:§ %*:z3$ii%e am $3 /r' 'x....,,»é»"' ax {3} {W} :5 ii"?
Ting evéfience Q? PW} cjiacmsas témi: the deceawfi wag mésgmg gmce 2€5~®8~2OQ8:
am tizgy wem makmg geaschmg me deaeasefi.
camgiaéné hag been 3§::_d.g§§;i, _.'P'vz:'---.é~ é'E:i'V.' we evééeréce 3339 }3dnf.:.%,t?Sj.
sL;S§e£*:ed fix} tc>_A'3 g'r>a<>:;;.:V;d ;~:av;:;§eeu~.i " ' may an their part,--..§g?"e:.:;M he ha_s ':':;i_>'i:~-._§§'~s,{é's'~:~~ any qemmaént -.?<:>§%<:é«-._a1gaér§ig'=f. ihem.
The maéeria._%§%g;v€iV€'ze.s3§3s'°wh:é..'jVV%éstify L: the;"3«a_:§_"; ézgeg -- «t%r€::£'z*réj§-t,an§e$, mainigr ms"5,1~'V.mr'§';*.L_--.._we", 'f«';rwv.»9 am pvm: s~:'a;.;é 1'éi:§:;;_rVQ§'g«., _}pw,m,; wém hag gévars §fie _§EC€5SEfi has geen ev'V%:ieVr:'::. e: '.VEn...T'T':~:.,:§';:'=--pr:>rt 9% the wse £3? V p;r <:sec:i:,§:%%:;t.j:'s'".~.§I;;%; tine mééemce G!' ?'\,;':.h:G V'%;..?m'w§'a 91%.?" E, was;
':3 §;G.I"}{:€3C?é£": am' insrefiétsie. mum ég yet 32% deceaaed wag .!A'?%i.§":£VS'i §"'i§ fer the pagiz 3 Says <3? we W 'j:-::¥;':;:Vd'er2:_§ PW11 wag making émégenséve ' '»:$'éa:u::%'2,.. 32:3: P'af\f,1§ (meg §%s*<:Es::>3§ ihe E523": agar': firczsmaiangek T§"rE Si3.'{%8§'?"§€§'E?i if §'+--.:':;t: is :"e:<:=rd&é 3?: beéaieé séiage Q3~{%§-2&8, is Cfi:":'»§%'"'%'1?"3§ 3:5 '3§"*-f€?'E by %f'~«;.§€f% (M, )W_'_,..«--»''"
£l"£I.:T, attem ' "
Na :12-:'s5$ 2 ;é..g - "
{W} H. as is w%*'s\,r he wiiémeééd the materéai iasi seen aércumsiamce sf we éeceasem ii; "
the Campam; :32' A3; #4; arm A6 ' 8€Ef': bk; him arGur;d 8-3G
26.{}8.2SG8.
judécéaé s:=:>r:fes§E0r%;. %7as _tL}';'.r:ed hv;:~z§{é%:=3'~ am did no: si:§:>__§r3{t §?:e__ 'r;Vas-:3 g=rc::§e£uté<:;zv.._ The:¢_ ":2..:f:2=--..aé:>3éEuii§%§z réia materéais tc;;._4_%;'::m'vi.g§%: :?'§;7 '.€:<..§3v€:::%CU.$€3C§ fie crime" Thai: ap-iaiéféP%fif:.':,..}§'{:'fi{;. éQer*: A3, 251.1%Va.§é'd___A,€:'VVEéé%€:g égékémaay 9% t.h.€:§--._ ":s"séét memiém a"i:30:fa_fé;.~é:Z¥"aé"' ;::r_é':é.1és;:1§:e~.~af7{::%m§am; of :3." 3; "f3;,--.2j:f;3 5*: d 53;'; % E/{E'%:-3': ':€?2é'":":i*éce a Seék The "-"¥";§;3V§j_L'~{{§a.:_Ei-..%4n.--~we Eudgmmé has mat:
§.;Vs;3.€3rV§y_ a:}§3':¢$~£;:§aiedf the evéderzaa am =:".{3f?5S§~:§_;駀d aéé madmésaébée materéaég an égzgiag {ha gasmzéaiian, Tbég is exzééeni Gbservatian <3? we "%""r5:§ Cc:-urt A ';r1;§ge fié 'me Eezfigmem: 3%: $525 férgi 'Ema i;'%i"':E:'~£aF"z§§ ma? we Aziz is gaid ta $9 iggi gees me 9? 'me *v'z§%§;:é€$S m €329 {é.r::::r§:3i:5r%ce, 33:3 ézfi E5 nei ye: é:%::'--: flmafs: iinai i:%':% §:::s%§:€ 3€:s;€%:*:"2 reaasfisd 'B2; am:
If {he evééersce {if"é3*"$€i;_'Zi,%x'}%"~w. g_ rejecteéf F3W,.5 whefl *';e$_iif§_,;:. "':.g:> ':g:»ct_ra--.g., ' Ujsiél af C:*.PJZZ.§ £3 admésgibié gm can be reiéeci an if {he ex.-*;§er:Ce 35 PW.Si E3 rejected them Ea as maia§:_a§, '--4"' ' Th€?€%§}?€§ the 8&9? {ref m'rw.§ %c¥;':%@;2'7; "v: :"'~~ reaarciefi by the Tr%a% VCg:»§.2%"t %3"'E;>ad*_V.§:":* ' Zawa
15. S;*":. \/.M, Eanakar, ;rf>;i::L.s:§jj';~~..VSt:a"€:Aé S'{%'€{'%éJ£3E.§S°%§'y' sasbmétg that we C>:'xf3--%VIV":. <i1f"€:§flx;!.§'C"§§--f;%..§7 Viiiécerdeé by the "Mai {hurt is East: gees (:§f"CL,E§'T3S'§§i"§C€ 0? é§:"'é§t§'r;;r;: §ji The medécaé eviéerzce %_§_w_§%"..:.§e~afi~}g "i§ "?éVém§c%Ga§. Hence;
a;:>pea& is 3éa-b--ie_€22"§é*1;i_&5m._i:$3_é:,€I :6, {E5} ""{%:ar'w:>.;;,é'g-§'.éis'..%g:%"%':?«;f, we ma thai; {he evidence :3? ;$Wz§.C* -.::1%_§<:€$'§<.3:sA tie am éecéasea wgre aéé gamg V"?'ez:e§a§ "azzdf ?'x5£'§"i'€3 wa3 goizsg er: the Meta: :;'3g<:§e <3?"
HESL---.f%:.$nVa[' ..§§;':'*:_;a:%"%*Vz§$3__;'§5_1as:a: mam gm he aige made 3 i'Ls;': $2' tha ' 'e'ja€&a§--.ef:%_e:.:a*' <;..3§§?;;'*;j':gA gs 321$ mar; ané ma 5 that wém Mm; Ea " '-1'i."V"<':_"n£:~» e\;ée:.ié'r2.{;-{$5 Q? Wxffiifi, the me§e:"':;e 0'? 53": am 2&2 $3 :76:
"«;"':i'e's;ff:i;:s:",is:*_:%;:fi if"? am: §"§":&%'3.?'3€?' érz %%"se iarngany 3? ihfi éaieageé. %""?i%"f;;3_%fFa_3a?%:; §§'§E <:ma:;'%z;::%; cf Pmfxifi E3 %':é§%:!'=; éaubifui is be 'Ait_::e';é:.:,a§;+sa.a;::'~;é;.; :1 asgiieazed. ?'€'»:',1 maisziag 393525 :3? the deceaaed far 'me 935': three {jays Q? the éréaiéenté 996.16 EH3 9am: are the regsderzts sf game kféimgsa am §<%"':{3¥¥.¥'i is eaih Gth§f:%,. ;§et PWVEJG 3333 Rat C§§SC§GS€S the Sag: gear: x:ircur_r;'s'L'a.é7jC..a:52:3 WL15 Mia gtaiement is regarded beiatediy PWEG gtates that after gaging we § e c}f3é:'§e':5;"'--:§;:{.:';»V._LL %?:ge1' comfiamz of A3 is 326 be $925; 31:53:: fligiiage éj%27é.E:a*§'i: §}<,>é'r: circumstanca with aria/may: T'§=:.é_é& «:::rc:§"c':i*:_s1§':<.«»r{<:e1'»{X63395 aerieus éaubt in the e:re:::f§"~£;'§éi::.é G'1f'vAé;%5:5e_é:\;gd§ncéA if §W,:€3 with regard ¥:G Eagt aeen <:érr:mi*;§f'3hzi»e._--=..if""--€V%2e'_'..saEé gvédefice is égnared, there ';s;1._ ;=;b5é;_£utgefy: ha:"'i:?ié'a:V.rfE_fif)'T§';flw&':£mg materiaig ilfrifiiéfé by7 t%'se_ g3%5:«:'e3+:t.;._;"E'§=<}fig.._:jé-..._¢cn.é':ec€ the aecazgesfi wiizés the came' Thes*e._f::a:.e3. 3-?"se"*V5:'<j'é'--:,LV cf camrictéen recfogfiefi by the 's"'r%a§ Cagm: 3; ba{§"»i:fz §a W. ' in aha': aséew af maize?! sage gags QR§E§ 3f%":z£;*V__;a;:g;é%:'ai E3 aiéssawesfi am' aréer 0:? caaaséciéaaz recsrdefi Véisyj 233% °?s'é3a.f "Saar? $3 36%: agéée, H .___%'§%§f§,;=-u 14 The agpeéiastszacmaad N931 EC; 3 and 6 are acquitteci far the sffense puzzéshabie U;'3.143,. 14?, 148, 392, 1&9}, 2%: E'/'W 1%? C}? {PC, The accazsed N93 afitmaggh has no? preferred an§g;'é§;>f'p.é3a.§'.g: fie weuéfi am he arétéiied for the Qeaefit GE a:e;2V§tta §"'f*§:>Vr'~./,§;§:s_:3 3 fiamé reagerzs appticabie ':3 A1 fig A3 ani: A.ij3.. f} '4 Tina a§p€%ia:1i$§aCCu$a§ N0s;::_"*--%:Q 3; '5 'arm '€:">:"A$«5??:%:";.!.,i__;V§t"+:3 {eiaaseé farthwstiw, %f not rgquired %;Q_ V§E::;§,_'d*e%jjaine d? ~%:é; ._a:2y :3t%18r Cfififi.
me {me 3{3j{}E,§§f1{'--- £}é":§:§fu:1§ea ':9 the a:Cu$eé{;3§$éiéa::%VSi "'}:,i C®rr:r'§:':;V;f:%'<:aM;t€;=' a§§&%.'a'?£%:}_§-..__;'91:;«%*§§en 9? me Eudgmami ts the °"§'":'§a¥ rmraas ;r:%?ei%,aS'%:é am 33%: fiaathsyétées fgrzawéshk fig':
5:» Q v3.
Qkmg ".:"?'€'"5'""%$g:§i 1 3 '. I O ':'».-u.3,§.s..J -:§