Central Administrative Tribunal - Delhi
Mini Madayi vs M/O Railways on 24 September, 2019
Central Administrative Tribunal Principal Bench New Delhi, This the 24th Day of September, 2019 O.A. No. 1375/2016 Mr. S.N. Terdal, Member (J) Mr. Pradeep Kumar, Member (A)
1. Mini Madayi Age 41 years W/o Shri M. Suresh Presently Nursing Sister Railway Hospital Palakkad R/o Adhwaitham Ullas Nagar Dhoni P.O, Palakkad Kerala - 678009
2. Suhramol T I Age 47 years W/o shri Sidheek M I Presently Chief Matron Railway Hospital, Palakkad R/o Thottathikulam house Hillview Nagar Dhoni P O, Palakkad Kerala-678009
3. Sindu G Age 46 years W/o Pradip Prabhakaran Presently Chief Matron Railway Hospital, Palakkad R/o Thulasidalam Shanthi Nagar 4th Lane Kallekulangara p o, Palakkad Kerala-678009 4 Lissy Mathew Age 52 years W/o T C Mathew Presently Chief Matron Railway Hospital, Palakkad R/o Thumpumpattu God‟s Will Ananda Nagar Kallekulangara p o, Palakkad Kerala-678009 2 5 Juliet Ramayyen Age 46 years W/o V K Surendran Presently Nursing Sister Railway Hospital Palakkad R/o Kailasam,Vadakkekara House Surya Nagar Lane 2 N S S Engg. College P O Palakkad, Kerala- 678008 6 Radha Vijayakumar Nair Age 50 years W/o Vijayakumar R Presently Nursing Sister Railway Hospital Palakkad R/o Sopanam E M S Nagar 1st Lane Dhoni P O, Palakkad, Kerala-678009 7 P Saritha Age 36 years W/o Suresh Babu C Presently Nursing Sister Railway Hospital Palakkad R/o Shalu Manzil Ananda Nagar Kallekulangara p o, Palakkad Kerala-678009 8 Rosily Joseph Kodiyan Age 54years W/o Baby Joseph K A Presently Chief Matron Railway Hospital, Palakkad R/o 178 A, „Thejus‟ Kodiyan House Dhoni P O Palakkad Kerala-678009 9 Shanthi Sasikumar Age 48years W/o M C Sasikumar Presently Chief Matron Railway Hospital, Palakkad R/o Ohm Prasadam Ananda Nagar Kallekulangara p o, Palakkad Kerala-678009 3 10 Shilly Paul Age 48years W/o Paul Varghese Presently Nursing Sister Railway Hospital Palakkad R/o "Boon", Thottumgal House Ananda Nagar Kallekulangara p o, Palakkad Kerala-678009 11 Elizabeth Chacko Age 53 years W/o George Jose M Presently Nursing Sister Railway Hospital Palakkad R/o Munduchira House Dhoni P O, Palakkad, Kerala-678009 12 Leelamani P P Age 52 years W/o M K Babu Presently Chief Matron Railway Hospital, Palakkad R/o Vishnu Vihar Shanthi Nagar, Rainbow Valley Industrial estate P O Palakkad, Kerala- 678731 13 Lissey Edison Age 50 years W/o K C Edison Presently Chief Matron Railway Hospital, Palakkad R/o Quarter No 256/A North Railway Colony Kallekulangara p o, Palakkad Kerala-678009 14 Girija Devi K Age 48years W/o Anil Kumar B Presently Chief Matron Railway Hospital, Palakkad R/o Thrippadham Paathiri Nagar Dhoni P O, Palakkad Kerala-678009 4 15 Sherly Robin Age 49 years W/o Robin Thomas Presently Nursing Sister Railway Hospital Palakkad R/o Assanparampil Roshin Villa Paathiri Nagar Dhoni P O, Palakkad Kerala-678009 16 Swapna Sasidharan Age 41 years W/o K Sasidharan Presently Chief Matron Railway Hospital, Palakkad R/o Aranipadath House Thomas Nagar Kallekulangara p o, Palakkad Kerala-678009 17 Asha D Age 45 years W/o Santhosh C Presently Nursing Sister Railway Hospital Palakkad R/o Hariprasadam Vishnu Nagar Ummini, Dhoni P O, Palakkad Kerala-678009 18 Reji K J Age 44 years W/o Joseph T V Presently Nursing Sister Railway Hospital Palakkad R/o Gloria Sadan Hillview Nagar Dhoni P O, Palakkad Kerala-678009 19 Lizzy Varghese Age 46 years W/o Sunny Varghese Presently Chief Matron Railway Hospital, Palakkad R/o Kalarickal House Ummini,Behind Railway Hospital Kallekulangara p o, Palakkad Kerala-678009 5 20 Mini M J Age 49 years W/o Narendra babu N R Presently Nursing Sister Railway Hospital Palakkad R/o Rohini Prathiksha Nagar 3rd Lane Otturkad Industrial estate P O Palakkad, Kerala- 678731 21 Elsamma Antu Age 53 years W/o Antu C Paul Presently Nursing Sister Railway Hospital Palakkad R/o Cherivuparambil house Melemurali, Puthupariyaram Industrial estate P O, Palakkad, Kerala- 678731 22 Marykutty Kuriakose Age 50 years W/o M J Kuriakose Presently Chief Matron Railway Hospital, Palakkad R/o 247 B, Railway Quarters North Railway Colony Kallekulangara P O, Palakkad Kerala-678009 23 Renuka M Age 47 years W/o Sunil Kumar P V Presently Chief Matron Railway Hospital, Palakkad R/o Souparnika, Prathiksha Nagar 3rd Lane Otturkad Industrial estate P O Palakkad, Kerala- 678731 24 Meena A Age 48 years W/o M P Sureshan Presently Chief Matron Subdivisional Railway Hospital, Shoranur,Palakkad R/o" Neelambari"
Manjakkad, Shoranur, Palakkad,Kerala-679121 6
25 Saraswathy K S Age 52 years,W/o T C Mohanan Presently Chief Matron Subdivisional Railway Hospital, Shoranur,Palakkad R/o "Parvanendhu", Thumbayil house Nedungottur Shoranur Palakkad,Kerala-679121 26 Indira K Age 49 years W/o K P Nandakumar Presently Nursing Sister Subdivisional Railway Hospital, Shoranur,Palakkad R/o Karumankuzhi house Kavalappara, Shoranur Palakkad,Kerala-679523 27 Ambili Suraj Age 40 years W/o Suraj V Panicker Presently Nursing Sister Subdivisional Railway Hospital, Shoranur,Palakkad R/o No.305/A,RailwayQuarters, Shoranur Palakkad,Kerala-679121 28 Nisha Prakash L Age 37 years W/o Sasikumar D Presently Nursing Sister Subdivisional Railway Hospital, Shoranur,Palakkad R/o 301 F, Lower Railway Colony Shoranur Palakkad,Kerala-679121 29 J. Amali Arul Nayaki Age 48 yrs W/O K.Francis Xavier Presently Nursing Sister Sub divisional Railway Hospital ,Podanur, Coimbatore-641023 R/o "Abundant blessing"
73/1, vellalore road Podanur,Coimbatore-23 TAMIL NADU Pin: 641023 7
30 Saritha S Rajan Age 38 years W/o Binuroy B Presently Nursing Sister Railway Hospital Madurai R/o Plot No5, Singaiprakasam Garden Ananda Nagar, Anaiyur, Madurai Tamil Nadu 625017 31 Pratheeksha Vijayam Age 37 Years W/o C V Vasanthan Presently Nursing Sister Railway Hospital Madurai R/o 42/2, Immanuel Cottage Ansari Nagar, 7th Street Mahaboob Palayam, Madurai
32.. Mrs Annie Roshan Age 42 years Working as Nursing Sister Railway Hospital Pettah, Trivandrum R/o TC-76/2282, Green Park Anayara P.O. Venpalavattom Trivandurm-29
33. Cissy Shaji Age 46 years W/o Mr. Shaji P.K. Working as Nursing Sister Railway Hospital Pettah, Trivandrum R/o TC No.31/434(4) Varikattu House Madhumukku Anayara P.O. Trivandrum-695029
34. Laisamma Antony, D/O Antony Age 46 years Working as Nursing Sister Railway Hospital Pettah, Trivandrum T.C. 94/1538 EMS Nagar, Pattoor Vanchiyoor P.O., Trivandrum, Kerala-695035 8
35. Ratnama,Age 51 years W/o P.K. Sukumaran Working as Chief Matron Railway Hospital, Pettah Trivandrum, Kerala R/o C/95, I.S.R.O Staff Quarters Patithura PO., Trivandrum, Kerala
36. K.S. Jayasree Age 53 years W/o G. Madhusudhanan Nair Working as Chief Matron Railway Hospital, Pettah, Trivandrum T.C. 31/763(3), Moonamanackal, Pettah-24 Trivandrum, Kerala
37.. Jayamoli.R Age 47 years W/o T. Vinod Working as Chief Matron Railway Hospital Unit Kottayam R/o Railway Quarters No.3/D Near Railway Health Unit Kottayam, Kerala PIN - 686001
38.. S.Sreeja Age 45 years Presently Chief Matron Railway Hospital , Pettah, Trivandrum R/o Archana, Bhavana Nagar, Kadappakkada P O, Kollam, Kerala-691008 39 N. Baby Age 46 yrs W/O P. Jayachandran Presently chief matron Sub divisional Railway Hospital ,Podanur, Coimbatore-641023 R/o 106,107,Dhandumariamman koil street, Nerar Collectorate,Coimbatore Tamilnadu- 641018. KKKkkkkkkjjjjjj
40.. R. Kanagavalli Age:49 Yrs Daughter of T.Ramasamy Presently Chief matron Sub divisional Railway Hospital ,Podanur, Coimbatore-641023 R/o No 18, Mizpeh Cottage,Krishna Nagar Chettipalayam Road, 9 41 S. Berlin Sucila Age 46 yrs W/O. M. Prabaharan presently nursing sister Sub divisional Railway hospital Erode R/o 58, V.G.B Nagar, Sasthrinagar, Erode-638002
42. P. Kasthuri Bai Age 58 yrs W/O. S. Krishna kumar Presently chief matron Railway Hospital, Erode. R/o M. 630. Muthampalayam housing unit phase-3 Kasipalayam Erode-638002
43.. S. Sahaya Vijaya Rani Age 47 years W/o S. Neethi Rajan Presently Chief Matron Railway Hospital Perambur, Chennai R/o No.18, Bharathiyar street Solambedu Thirumaullaivoyal Chennai, Tamil Nadu-62
44.. S. Kiruba Santhi Age 50 years W/o Mr V Kingston Mony Presently Chief Matron Railway Hospital, Perambur, Chennai R/o No.4F, Preetham Flats, Palayakara Street Ayanavaram, Chennai, TN-600 023
45.. L. Sumathy Age 48 years D/o N Loganathan Presently Chief Matron Railway Hosptial, Perambur, Chennai R/o No.-18, III Main Road, Jayalakshmi Nagar Thirumullaivoyal, Chennai-62, TN 10
46.. S Chandramani Age 52 years W/o K.M. Tamil Selvan Chief Matron, Railway Hospital, Perambur, Chennai 13A, Palayakara Street R.C. Preetham Ayanavaram, Chennai-23, TN
47.. Susan Jubi Age 48 years W/o Jubi Abraham Chief Matron, Railway Hospital, Perambur, Chennai R/o 64, C-4, Galaxy Apts, Palayakara Street Ayanavaram, Chennai -23
48. J. Esther Age 51 years W/o P. Murugan Chief Matron, Railway Hosptial, Perambur, Chennai 179, 4th Street, Dr Ambethkar Nagar Kolathur, Chennai-99
49.. Punitha Manoharan Age 46 years W/o Manoharan Chief Matron, Railway Hospital, Perambur, Chennai R/o A, RS Puram, 10/11 Palayakara Street II Lane, Ayanavaram, Chennai-23
50. K. Amutha Age 43 years D/o Kallanai Nursing Sister Railway Hospital, Perambur, Chennai R/o 21/A, Patchaikal, Veerasamy Street Ayanavaram, Chennai-23
51.. Rani Ravindranath Age 49 years W/o K Ravindranath, Chief Matron Railway Hospital, Perambur, Chennai R/o 28, 6th Street, B. V. Nagar Palavanthangal, Chennai-114, TN 11
52.. Nandini Jagadeesan D/o jagadeesan Age 37 years Nursing Sister Railway Hospital, Perambur, Chennai R/o 3/3A, Venkateswara Street Rajaji Nagar, Villivakkam Chennai-49, TN
53..Reeja Varghese D/o K.V.Varghese Age 47 years Nursing Sister Railway Hospital, Perambur, Chennai R/o Angela Apartment Plot No. 55, Ambattor Oragadam Co-op Building Society, Thirumullaivayil Chennai-62, TN
54.. K.Devika W/O Thankavel Age 42 years Nursing Sister Railway Hospital, Perambur, Chennai 21/B, Bamford Road, PWQ Quarters, Ayanavaram Chennai-23, TN
55.. Grace Prabhakar John Age 55 years W/o C Prabhakar John Ponniah Working as Chief Matron Railway Hospital, Perambur, Chennai R/o Old No.5, New No.1, New Street Thatuankuppam, Villivakkam Chennai-49, Tamil Nadu
56.. Sheela Rachel Age 54 years W/o Mathivanan Working as Chief Matron Railway Hospital, Perambur, Chennai-23 R/o 39/2, narayana Maistry 1st Street, Villivakkam, Chennai-49 12
57.. R. Nesa Rani Mary Age 51 years D/o Y Raja Pandian Working as Nursing Sister Railway Hospital, Perambur, Chennai Falt No. S1, 52/31, Gayatri Flats 4 Guruvappa Maistry St Ayanavaram, Chennai -23
58.. Uma Nagarajan Age 46 years W/o C Nagarajan Working as Chief Matron Railway Hospital, Perambur, Chennai R/o 422, T.V.K. Nagar, Perambur Chennai-11, Tamil Nadu
59.. Nisha Jones Age 49 years W/oMr. Stanely Jones Working as Chief Matron Railway Hospital, Perambur, Chennai 76, A2 Diamond Castles Kumaran Nagar III St Jawahar Nagar Chennai-600082
60.. S. Poonkodi Age 40 years W/o K.S. Kalaimani Working as Nursing Sister Railway Hospital, Perambur, Chennai R/o 23, Gianesh Nagar, Thurvalluvar St Madhavaram, Chennai-151
61.. Indira Rajasekar Age 49 years W/o R.R. Rajasekar Working as Nursing Sister Railway Hospital, Perambur, Chennai R/o 45, Pasumarthy Enclave, North Mada St Villivakkam, Chennai-49
62.. Rajani Sudheer Age 40 years W/o Mr. Sudheer Paul Working as Nursing Sister Railway Hospital, Perambur, Chennai R/o No.5, Plot No.155-1, 25th St Poombuhar Nagar,Kolathur, Chennai-99 13
63.. K.Umamaheswari Karthikeyan Age 52 years D/o S. Kalyana Sundaram Working as Chief Metron Railway Hospital, Perambur, Chennai R/o G-9, Sayani Complex 354, K.H. Road Ayanavaram, Chennai-23
64.. S. Rekhaa Age 37 years W/o K. Asokan Working as Nursing Sister Railway Hospital Perambur, Chennai R/o Flat No.3F, Block-2, Yamunashiyam Thirth Apart North Jaganataan Nagar II Main Rd Villivakkam, Chennai-49
65..Durga Devi Vijayakumar Age 43 years W/o Mr R Vedagiri Working as Nursing Sister Railway Hospital, Perambur, Chennai R/o Pranava Kalpatharu Flats B-47, Manavalan St Vetri Nagar Extension Chennai-82
66..Premalata Prithiviraj Age 46 year W/o Prithiviraj.M Working as Chief Matron Railway Hospital, Perambur, Chennai R/o3/3 , Thirumalai Raja St Iswaryawarnam F, Ayanavaram Chennai-23
67.. K. Mangaiyarkarasi Age 37 years W/o Mr. B. Sugamar Working as Nursing Sister Railway Hospital, Perambur, Chennai R/o 139, Ayavi St Kambar Nagar, Avenue Gem Appt B Block, F3, Chennai-82 14
68..K. Ravathi Age 39 years W/o Mr. A Prakash Working as Nursing Sister Railway Hospital, Perambur, Chennai R/o Flat No. C1 R.C. Apartments No.4/13 Palayakara St, Ayanavaram Chennai-23
69..Sathyavani Suresh Age 39 years W/o R. Suresh Babu Working as Nursing Sister Railway Hosptial Perambur, Chennai R/o No.42, New Street, Ayanavaram, Chennai-23.
70..Bindu M.K. Age 38 years W/o M.Y. Sunil Kumar Working as Nursing Sister Railway Hospital Perambur, Chennai R/o 53/4 Eshwar Illam, Vasantha Garden 2nd Lane Ayanavaram, Chennai-23
71.. Parry Poonkodi Alfred Issacs Age 46 years W/o Parry Alfred Isaac Working as Nursing Sister Railway Hospital, Perambur, Chennai R/o 32, Veeramamuni St Tangai Nagar, Kolathur Chennai-99
72..Lorna Antoinette D Silva Age 48 years W/o Kieran Darius D Silva Working as Nursing Sister Railway Hospital, Perambur, Chennai R/o 91/93, Siruvallur High road, JS Shalini Classic A-1 Perambur, Chennai-11 15
73..Aleyamma Thomas Age 57 years W/o Babu Mathew Working as Nursing Sister Railway Hospital Perambur, Chennai R/o Penta Rose Apartment 34, Siruuallur Road Perambur, Chennai-11
74.. M. Ramya Age 37 years W/o R. Sarvanan Working as Nursing Sister Railway Hospital Perambur, Chennai R/o Sastha Enclave, Flat B C-65/83, Karthikeyan Salai Periyar Nagar, Chennai-82
75..Philomina A.D. Age 53 years W/o Mr. Richard Working as Chief Matron Railway Hospital, Perambur, Chennai R/o 53/2, Appa Durai II Lane Ayanavaram, Chennai -23
76.. N. Sankari Age 41 years W/o M Natarajan Working as Nursing Sister Railway Hosptial, Perambur, Chennai R/o No.2/13, Erikkarai St Perungudi, Chennai-06
77..Mariamma Charly Age 43 years W/o Mr. Charly N John Working as Nursing Sister Railway Hospital Perambur, Chennai R/o 73, Sabhi Nagar Extn II Street, Muthapudupet IAF Avadi, Chennai-53
78.. Reeta Angeline Age 48 years W/o Edwin Gnanaraj Working as Chief Matron Railway Hospital Perambur, Chennai R/o No.60, Subash Chandra Bosh Street 8th Avenue Extn, Banu NagarAnbattur, Chennai-53 16
79..Isabellamary Joseph Age 45 years W/o D Joseh Sheeban Working as Chief Matron Railway Hospital Perambur, Chennai R/o 3B/1, G,8 Anara Apartments Paui Arasan Street,Anna Nagar East, Chennai-102
80.. Pitchammal Soundara Rajan Age 48 years W/o Mr. N. Soondararajan Working as Chief Matron Railway Hospital Perambur, Chennai R/o No.48/59 Market Street, F4, A.P. Aarathika, Senbiun Perambur, Chennai -11
81..Marykutty Varghese Age 51 years W/o Varghese K.V. Working As Nursing Sister Railway Hospital Perambur, Chennai R/o No.339, SMU, Doshi Falts Divya 4C, K.H. Road, Ayanavaram Chennai-23, Tamil Nadu
82.. Beena Rani.S.S Age 49 years W/o T Santosh Kumar Presently Chief Matron Railway Hospital Pettah, TVM R/o TC 76/2564(2) Pratheeksha Anayara P.O., Thiruvananthapuram Kerala - PIN - 695029
83. Shylaja Haridas Age 50 Years W/o C.G.Haridas, Presently Chief Matron at Health Unit Trichur, Trivandrum Division R/o Chandralayam, 32/59, Sitaram Mill Lane, Punkunnam,Thrissur, Kerala 17
84. Susheela Chandrasekaran Age 49 years W/o Chandrasekaran Presently Chief Matron ICF Railway Hospital, Chennai 60038 R/o No.3, G. Dhanyalaxmi Flats, Muthu street, Rajaji Nagar,Villivakkam CHENNAI- 600049
85. Lissy Joyson Age 56 Years W/O Joyson Paul Presently Chief Matron ICF Railway Hospital, Chennai 60038 R/O C-14/8, 10th street, Anna nagar East, Chennai 600 102
86. Elsamma Shelby Age 48 Years W/O Shelby Issac Presently Nursing Sister ICF Railway Hospital, Chennai 60038 R/O 43/44, A4, Golden Enclave Apts., Narayana Mestri 1st Street, Villivakkam,Chennai- 600049.
87. Sherly P. Thomas Age 46 Years W/O Shajimon P. Thomas Presently Nursing Sister ICF Railway Hospital, Chennai 60038 R/O RLY. QR. NO. 118/2, 2nd Street, ICF West Colony, ICF Colony P.O., Chennai
88. LATTISH B. Age 43 YEARS W/O RAJENDREN B.K. PRESENTLY NURSING SISTER ICF Railway Hospital, Chennai 60038 R/O RLY. QR. NO. 256/2, ICF NORTH COLONY, ICF COLONY P.O., ICF, CHENNAI-600038.
1889. K. VASANTHA Age 53 YEARS D/O M.KALIAPPAN PRESENTLY CHIEF MATRON ICF RAILWAY HOSPITAL, ICF COLONY P.O., ICF, CHENNAI-
600038.
R/o PREMIER C1, R-C ROYAL GRANDE, KAMBAR TREET, THIRUMULLAIVOIL,CHENNAI- 600062.
90. GLADYS DANLIWU HEPZIBAH D/o R. Jeevananthan Age 47 years Presently Chief Matron Railway Hospital ICF R/o . No.6C. Seeyalam II Street,Vllivakkam Chennai -49
91. AMBILI K. Age 38 YEARS W/O T.K.SAJU PRESENTLY NURSING SISTER ICF RAILWAY HOSPITAL, ICF COLONY P.O, ICF, CHENNAI- 600038. R/o NO. 9/12 , SOUTH THIRUMALAI NAGAR 2nd STREET, VILLIVAKKAM,CHENNAI- 600049.
92. VIJAYAMMA PRASAD W/o Prasad Age 56 years Nursing Sister Railway Hospital ICF R/oNo.257/2, ICF North Colony Chennai - 38
93. K. KALPANA D/o V. Kumar Age 37 years Presently Nursing Sister Railway Hospital ICF R/o No.22/2 Bajanai Koil 3rd Street, Villivakkam Chennai-49 19
94. K. SEENIPONSELVI Age 48 YEARS D/O S. SEENI NADAR PRESENTLY ICF RAILWAY HOSPITAL, ICF COLONY P.O., ICF, CHENNAI R/o : NEW NO. 22/1 , OLD NO. 12/1, BAJANAI KOIL 3rd STREET, VILLIVAKKAM, CHENNAI- 600049.
95. ANNAMMA THOMAS Age 50 years W/O K.M. THOMAS PRESENTLY NURSING SISTER ICF RAILWAY HOSPITAL,ICF COLONY P.O., ICF, CHENNAI R/o RLY. QR. NO. 104/4, ICF WEST COLONY, ICF COLONY P.O., ICF, CHENNAI-600038.
96. JOYCE FRANCIS Age 45 years W/O S.Francis PRESENTLY NURSING SISTER ICF RAILWAY HOSPITAL,ICF COLONY P.O., ICF, CHENNAI- 600038. R/o No:136/1,4th street,ICF West colony, Chennai-600038 (By Advocate: Mr. Padma Kumar S) VERSUS
1. Chairman Railway Board Rail Bhawan New Delhi -1.
2. General Manager Southern Railway Chennai- 600003.
3. Divisional Railway Manager Chennai Division Southern Railway Chennai- 600003 20
4. Divisional Railway Manager Palakkad Division Olavakkod Southern Railway Kerala.
5. Divisional Railway Manager Madurai Division, Madurai
6. Divisional Railway Manager Salem Division Salem.
7. Divisional Railway Manager Trivandrum Division Trivandrum (By Advocate: Mr.Kripa Shankar Prasad) Order (Oral) Hon'ble Mr. S.N. Terdal, M(J):
Learned counsel for the applicants submits that he be permitted to withdraw this OA with liberty to make representation permissible as per the law. Hence this OA is dismissed as withdrawn.
(Pradeep Kumar) (S.N. Terdal) Member(A) Member (J) /mk/