Delhi District Court
Amiya Sharma And Anr vs . State on 17 April, 2010
Amiya Sharma and anr Vs. State
IN THE COURT OF SHRI AJAY KUMAR KUHAR
ADDL. SESSIONS JUDGE: SOUTH EAST-02
PATIALA HOUSE COURTS
NEW DELHI
IN RE: Criminal Revision No. 99/09
1. Amiya Sharma
2. Aneesh Sharma
(Both R/o B-375, GF, C.R. Park,
New Delhi)
... Revisionists
Versus
1. The State
through SI Satbir Singh
PS C.R. Park
2. Sh Bharat Bhushan Bhardwaj
R/o B-375, FF, C.R. Park,
New Delhi
... Respondents
______________________________________________________________________
Date of Institution : 24.07.2009
Date when the arguments
were heard : 17.04.2010
Date of Order : 17.04.2010
ORDER
CR No. 99/09 1/6
Amiya Sharma and anr Vs. State "!" # %$&$' ( *) ( +)# ,$* ") - .0/ . 12/3- ."."4 5 * (6879$' : , 5 ; < = : $ ; ><" ) ( ? = ; $ ( A@=. BDCE@"@"@9 F/HGI J/ 5 # K 8 ,< ) "!" %$L M$' N * ( O %$P Q ( R$' S! * <" )T$' $U$F , ( * 5 # V ,<8WHW ; ( 8$L! * (< )X$Y Z * ; " )[ "!" %$ $F , ( \ ]$' _^2 # O ) Y ?<" ) ( ( = ; $ ( `@a. BDCE@ b .c F/HGI J/
-(/ d,)0/e f (< = 0WY g$' T * ( O %$ h ,< 6" $H$* ")i$F $g$' 9^2 O )( Y X<" )"
= ; $ ( j@=. BDCE@ b,.N
F/HGI kW )[687mlon]le $'6 cl
! #pLGIlq J/H U/]GM 'rT O S s $ $* ")
6 ; < = h$' ; ( Z
8$o s 7Rte Y $ute "< , vte *) 5 xwj h * # ) !
y$'
z s { (< = {
/
{tM|~} B b p
/ u/G 'r p 5
(
$'
W' P %$W' " ( 5 * +$'
! * (<" ,)W ( * O ( %$P \U 7 _l ' _ )U , cl ' ` * * # ) !(/n $M
,<"6" $$* ")_$F $ote Y $ute "< , hte *) 5 wJ # * ; 8$ 7 Z <" ; # = ")y$' W
P %$W (
$' i 6, z )i < = h ) ` Y # 8
!_$' Q * %$U 7 l ' s 5
) O ) 7 "! ") 6 (<z$"7 # P )_
z$Y ) ]$* $' " * 5 2 (<z$M W z ) < = _ =
$F $ ; Z <" ; " = {$' { ( z$' * < = 0/ f m K! ; O T$' $?
9$'
^2 O )( Y y<" ,)" ( M = ; $ ( @=. BDCE@ b . F/HGI Z ; W ; )" 7` ( )# $* W
; )" 8$ #
6 " ( ; $Y )0p $' ( * WY * 0p2$' Q ( *)" )# $* ")v- .0/ . 12/3- ."."4 5 * (687h , 5>; < = v $' ;
# 6 " 8 ,<, ")?$Y ?$' h * O ( %$P c $2 # Z ( ($' O 5 # L$' O ( *)" ( ) " c , $
Z ; W7$F , v #! $ ( y )y$F , V ,<"6 %$Y ; i ( $' X6 # O _ W 5 ; Rd,)0/Ilf )
* ; ( *) ") ] z ,$' O %WP ; $' ( ]$* ? 8 ,<, c , 5S; < = $ ; $Y $' ( %$P /
#} / d,)?g)")
/HG/Gi ( $' $' ( ) ) Y! < )$' $($' v^2 O )( Y y<" ,)" (
= ; $ ( K@=. B%C@,b,.T
F/HGI 5 # ;8; ( Z ) 5 $' 9 <" 6 J W %$Y $* ( s ( z$ X WU$'
* ) ( 8$P ` )y$' ; Z 7h W U ( 8$' y , 5
!_$' $$' ( * 5 # < ' * I6 $ 5 " (
6 $' h$' Z H$ " ( # = 0/n $ ?W'<" H$' , ( J ,<"6 $H$Y )Q$' ,$f X (< H7X<" ,)" ( @"@a
F/HGI \ " 6 ( $ $* ")R687 d,)(/lf¡ ,)$' $' '<8$' 8W'< 8 ( $' ( 5 = h WI$'
#!" $ ( L
]$' _^2 # O ,)( Y ; 6, )" ; )" "))(<
!s$' z )? (< H7#/
1/ nJ 9 " *)S$' ¢ ,<"6 8 R Wd,)(/J o (<" = W* ( $' Z H$ # X ,)
Z ( '< = )$' O z o (<" H$2 ; ( *)0/
CR No. 99/09 2/6
Amiya Sharma and anr Vs. State
"£ ¤ ¥¦T¦'§ ¨© ¨(ªH« ¬(z¦ ®=¨ ¦T¦'§ ¨ ¬(¯E° ¨"±a¦S¬ ²¢®=¨"±a¦ ³ ¬ ´ µ=¶ ·D¸Eµ £,¶ ¹ªF¤ºI¹ » ´ ¼
± ³
ª*± "½®%¦Y» ´,±8¨ ®³ ´?¾L§ ³ ± §`¿"ª*¬"±8¨ ¨"¼ ³ ´ Àh"´,¼"¨(ª ®=¨"±a¦ ³ ¬(´µ=¶ ·y®,§ » Á Á ¯,¨i³ ´ ³ ¦ ³O»,¦Y¨ ¼½» «¯ ¨ ±8¬(´ ® ³ ¼"¨(ª*¨"¼(¤QÂô ¦'§ ¨± »#®=¨y¬ ² Babu Ram and ors Vs. State of Himachal Pradesh ¦F§,¨Ä ¬(´ Å ¯ Á ¨\Äf³ À §K¹o¬("ªH¦c§ »"®T¬ ¯ ®=¨(ªH© ¨ ¼»"® and others 1989 Cri.L.J NOC 6 "´ ¼"¨ ªÇÆ È "The proceedings under Ss 107 and 150 Cr.PC are of a preventive nature. All the same they impinge upon the liberty of an individual which is of a paramount importance and value and a fundamental right guaranteed under the Constitution. It is thus imperative duty of the Court seized of such proceedings to see that all the relevant provisions of law touching those proceedings are strictly complied with and the liberty of the citizen is not allowed to be jeopardised on frivolous and baseless allegations towards achieving a particular end."
¥ ¿ » ªH¦#²*¬(ª'½N¦'§ ³ ®LÉ,¼0¤ ¹f¬ "´ ®=¨ Á=²*¬(ª ¦F§,¨ª*¨ © ³O® ³ ¬(´ ³ ®%¦P®§ »#®s» ÁO®=¬± ³ ¦*¨"¼±8¨(ªH¦Y» ³ ´ U °Ê ¼"À ½s¨(´8¦P®?³ ´h§ ³ ®²Y» © ¬("ªM¦*¬Q®,"¿ ¿ ¬(ªH¦ § ³ ®±8¬(´8¦*¨(´8¦ ³ ¬(´ ® ¤VË ¨ Á ³O» ´,±8¨h¾»"®?¿ ÁO» ±8¨"¼Q"¿ ¬(´ °Ê ¼"À ½s¨(´8¦M³ ´ Ram Chandra Jena and others Vs. Muralidhar Onjha and others ¾§ ¨ ª*¨h®,§,¬ ¾{± » ®=¨Q´ ¬ ¦ ³ ±8¨`¾ »#® ®=¨ ¦ »"® ³ ¼"¨h¯ ¨ ± » ®=¨h³ ¦¼ ³ ¼h´ ¬ ¦ 1988 Cri. L. J. 218 ¼ ³ ®=± Á ¬ ®=¨¦'§ ¨y®,"¯ ®%¦P» ´ ±8¨h¬ ²¦'§ ¨ ³ ´8²*¬(ª'½» ¦ ³ ¬ ´_ª*¨"±8¨ ³ © ¨"¼ ¯8« ¦'§ ¨RÌs»"À#³ ®%¦'ªY» ¦*¨Í¬(´¾§ ³ ± § § ¨Xª*¨#» ± § ¨ ¼v®z» ¦ ³ ®%²Y» ±a¦ ³ ¬(´ » ´,¼&³ ®8®, ¨X´ ¬ ¦ ³ ±8¨0¤ ̬(ª*¨ ¬ © ¨(ªFή,§ ¬,¾:± » ®=¨ ´ ¬ ¦'³ ±8¨Q¾ »#® » Á ®=¬q»q±a« ± Á ¬ ®%¦H« Á ¨"¼´ ¬ ¦'³ ±8¨0¤ Ë ¨ Á ³ » ´ ±8¨Ï¾»"®» Á ®=¬¿ ÁO» ±8¨ ¼¬ ´ Indravadan Killawalla and others Vs. State of Maharashtra and others 1989 Cri. L.J. à´¦'§ ³ ®± »#®=¨h¦F§,¨R¿ ª*¬"±8¨"¨ ¼ ³ ´ À"® ¾ ¨ ª*¨R®=¨ ¦o»"® ³ ¼"¨v¯8«¦'§ ¨VÄ ¬(´,Å ¯ Á ¨VÄf³ À §¹o¬("ªH¦ 1253.
¾§ ¨ ª*¨ ³ ´v¦'§ ¨m» Á Á ¨#À"»,¦'³ ¬(´ ®¾ ¨(ª*¨ ¦'§ » ¦J¦'§ ¨¿ ¨ ¦ ³ ¦ ³ ¬(´ ¨(ª ¦'§ ¨(ª*¨ ³ ´¢§ » ¼9® ³ ½¿ Á «T¨ Ð8¦*¨ ´ ¼"¨"¼ ¦F§ ª*¨#» ¦P®i» ´ ¼T» ¯ ®=¨ ® ¤Ë ¨ Á ³ » ´ ±8¨R¾»#® » Á ®=¬m¿ ÁO» ±8¨"¼+¬(´ Keshav Kumar Vs. State "ªÒ¦F§,¨(ªª*¨ Á ³O» ´ ±8¨ ¾»#®&¿ ÁO» ±8¨"¼S¬(´ 2008 Cri. L. J 2333. Ñ Kailash Singh and ÂÒ´y¦'§ ³ ®± »#®=¨i¦F§,¨+Ä ¬(´,Å ¯ Á ¨ others Vs. State of Bihar 1983 Cri. L.J. NOC 228.
Äf³OÀ §¹f¬( ªH¦ ¾»#®¬ ²e¦F§,¨Q© ³ ¨ ¾[¾§ ¨ ª*¨&®,§ ¬ ¾:± » ®=¨V´ ¬ ¦ ³ ±8¨&³ ®8®, ¨ ¼Q¦Y¬h¦'§ ¨ ¿ » ªH¦ ³ ¨ ®³ ´ ¿""ªP®, » ´ ±8¨¬ ²¦'§ ¨¬(ª*¼ ¨(ª¼(ªY» ¾L³ ´ ÀQ"¿¿"ª¬"±8¨"¨"¼ ³ ´ À "´ ¼ ¨(ªeÓg¤µ=¶ ·h¼"¬"¨ ®´ ¬ ¦f½s¨(´z¦'³ ¬(´ ¦F§,¨ ®, ¯ ®%¦Y» ´ ±8¨i¬ ²o» ±8± ®z» ¦ ³ ¬(´y¨(´ » ¯ Á ³ ´ Ày¦'§ ¨v¿ » ªH¦H«`¦Y¬h² ³ Á ¨ » ´¨ ²H²*¨"±a¦ ³ © ¨i®,§,¬ ¾>± » ®=¨ » ´ ¼±8¬(´z¦Y¨#®%¦2¦'§ ¨y¿"ª*¬"±8¨ ¨"¼ ³ ´ À(Î ¦'§ ¨¬(ª*¼ ¨(ª¼ ªY»,¾L³ ´ Ày"¿s¦F§,¨Q¿"ª*¬"±8¨ ¨"¼ ³ ´ À ¾ ¬( Á ¼y¯ ¨i¯ » ¼ ³ ´ ÁO» ¾s¤ CR No. 99/09 3/6 Amiya Sharma and anr Vs. State Ô0Õ Ö× Ø,Ù ÚÛ8Ü(Ý Þ ß à"Ú(á*Ú àâ'× Úsã~ä à#å æsÚ Ý8âÜ(Ýç× ß Û ×yá*Ú è ß Ø Ý Û8ÚQ× Ø#Þé Ú"Ú Ýhê è Ø Û8Ú"à Ø#Þç Ú è èØ"ÞâF×,ÚVá*Ú è Ú Ù Ø Ýzâ ê"á*Ü Ù ßOÞ ß Ü(Ý ÞÜ ëuè Ø,çsÕ ì× ÚRê"áÜ"Û8Ú"Ú"à ß Ý å&ä"Ý,à"Ú(áoÞ=Ú"Ûaâ ß Ü(Ý+í=î ï ð áFÕHñIð¡Ø á*Úê"á*Ú Ù Ú(Ýzâ ß Ù Úß Ý9Ý Ø,âFä á*ÚSØ Ý,à+â'× Ú ò¢Ø á*Ú{Ý Ü âsê"ä"Ý ß â ß Ù Úß Ý+Û × Ø áYØ Ûaâ*Ú(áFÕóì ×,Ú ê"ä"á'ê Ü#Þ=ÚÜ ëeß Ý ß â ß Ø â ß Ý åâ'× Úê"áÜ"Û8Ú"Ú"à ß Ý å"Þß Ý â'× ßOÞ ê"áÜ Ù ß Þ ß Ü(ÝcßOÞ â*Ühê"á*Ú Ù Ú(Ýzâ#â'× Úhé"á*Ú#Ø Û ×Ü ë ê Ú#Ø Û8Ú`ç× ß Û ×à ß Þ%â'ä"á'é?â'× Úiê"ä"é è ß Û?âFáYØ Ý ô(ä ß è ß âò#Õ õ Ü,ç Ú Ù Ú áFöMé,Ú ë*Ü(á*Ú ßOÞ8Þ,ä ß Ý åØ Ý,Ü â ß Û8ÚÜ ë Þ,× Ü ç:Û Ø ä Þ=ÚQâYÜRØ Ý8òQê Ú(áPÞ=Ü ÝiØ#Þâ*Üç×8òv× ÚvÞ,× Ü ä è à Ý Ü â ë'ä"á'Ý ßOÞ,×yâ'× ÚVé Ü Ý à â*ÜXé ÚvÜ ë å Ü"Ü"àQé Ú × Ø Ù ß Ü ä"áë*Ü(áf÷DÚ Ú(ê ß Ý åQê Ú"Ø Û8ÚÍâ'× ÚQøsØ"å ßOÞ%âFáYØ,âYÚißOÞ8Þ,ä ß Ý åQÝ Ü â ß Û8Úv× Ø#Þ â*ÜhÞzØ â ß Þ%ëHò × ß æÞ=Ú è ë â'× Ø â â'× Ú(á*ÚØ á*ÚcÞ,ä8ëHë ß Û ß Ú(Ý8â å á*Ü(ä"Ý,à ÞUâ*Ü`ê"á*Ü"Û8Ú"Ú à0ÕLì× ÚÝ Ø â'ä"á*Ú Ü ë2Ø è è Ú#å"Ø â ß Ü(Ý Þß Ý âF×,Úúù2Ø èOØ Ý à(áYØúöÛ × Ø áYØ Ûaâ*Ú(áiÜ ëiØ Û8Û ä ÞzØ â ß Ü(Ý"öÛ8Ü Ý8â*Ú û8âQß Ýç× ß Û ×¡Ø è è Ú#å Ú"àóØ Ûaâ_çØ"Þ Û8Ü(ææ ß âHâ*Ú"àhØ Ý àâ'× Úvê Ü â*Ú(Ý,ÛaòÜ ëIâF×,ÚhØ Ûaâ9æä Þ%âUé ÚØ#Þ=Û8Ú(áHâYØ ß Ý Ú"àhØ Ý,àiÛ8Ü Ý Þ ß à Ú(á*Ú"àié8ò âF×,Ú øsØ å ß Þ%â'áYØ â*Úúé Ú ë*Ü(á*Úúß Þ8Þ,ä ß Ý åÞ,×,Ü ç Û Ø ä Þ=ÚÝ Ü â ß Û8Ú(Õ ìIÜqØ á'á ß Ù ÚkØ âQÞ,ä Û ×óØ ÞzØ â ß Þ%ëYØ Ûaâ ß Ü(Ýâ'× ÚRøsØ"å#ß Þ%â'áYØ â*Ú_Û Ø Ý Ý Ü âß Ý`ØæsÚ"Û × Ø Ý ß Û Ø#è æØ Ý"Ý,Ú(á á*Ú è òä"ê Ü ÝâF×,ÚQê Ü è ß Û8Ú á*Ú(ê Ü(áÒâ#âYÜà(áYØ,ç9â'× Úê á*Ü"Û8Ú"Ú à ß Ý å"Þä"Ý,à"Ú(á2Þ=Ú"Ûaâ ß Ü(Ýí=î ïð áFÕHñIðJÕì× Ú_øsØ"å ßOÞ%â'áYØ â*Ú× Ø#ÞUâ*Ü Ú û Ú(á*Û ßOÞ=Ú&â'× ÚVà ß Þ=Û á*Ú â'ß Ü(Ý&Ø ëHâ*Ú(áUà ä ÚSØ ê"ê è ß Û Ø â ß Ü(ÝQÜ ësæ ß Ý à&Ø Ý à9× ÚS× Ø"Þâ*Ü ë*Ü(á'æâ'× ß Þ Ü(ê ß Ý ß Ü(Ýß Ý à"Ú ê Ú(Ý à Ú(Ý8â è òØ Ý,à× ÚßOÞ?Ý Ü â Þ,ä ê"ê Ü#Þ=Ú"àâYÜØ ÛaâeæsÚ"Û × Ø Ý ß Û Ø#è è òÜ Ýcâ'× ÚhæsÚ(á*Ú Ø#Þ,÷zß Ý å Ü ë"â'× Úê,Ü è ß Û8Ú0Õ ï Õ Ö × Ø,Ù ÚcÞ=Ú"Ú(Ý]â'× ÚÜ á*à"Ú(á à#Ø,âYÚ àü î0Õ î ý2Õ3ü î"î"þsçL× ß Û ×á*Ú"Ø à ÞØ#Þä"Ý,à"Ú(áÇÿ ORDER SHO/C.R.Park has sent up Kalandra u/s 107/150 Cr.PC against above respondents (s). I have carefully gone through the police report as well as the statement of the IO and come to the conclusion that there are sufficient ground of proceeds against them. Therefore, the Kalandra is admitted and issued notice u/s 107/111 Cr.PC against above respondent (s) directed to report in this court on 29.04.2009 positively.
SEM/SE Distt.
20.04.2009 Ö2× Ø Ù Úiå Ü(Ý,Úâ'×"á*Ü(ä å ×âF×,ÚÞ,× Ü ç:Û Ø ä Þ=ÚQÝ Ü â'ß Û8ÚvßOÞ8Þ,ä Ú"àXê"ä"áPÞ,ä Ø Ý8ââ*Üyâ'× ß Þ CR No. 99/09 4/6 Amiya Sharma and anr Vs. State "!# $ % & ' ( ) *+ ( , -. / 0!1!2 +34 5!6! !7! 8 "9 : ;!< = ):> ? = A@ " 2 B)= > CD / >E B F!2 ! = ">?GH JIK " B 4 !LIK " B EIK " M ON 9 P( "!Q!R*S'T !R! < U V B ;!2 2/ = ">V( , % !2 4 @ =)= !Q*W 3X!2 S Y/%*Z "
L "> 3 )T 5!
H : [ \ ] "!# $ % & B
=' ( "> ^ _ ! +` a6
a"b_
c` a a d&
% ' ( )$ !4 B) *8 =) %!e / 0!f!2 F , ! F 8 L $ " g 0*h " h %!i! - ( ): % A j
" k@ " B 2 )= = "> C !2 ! = ">l m / >\/%*n!2 o "9 : $ ;!< k " ( ( 6
p
q , ! n` a
a"b_
c` a a d6Cr!2 "3 6Cs ( ( < ]! E/ l(" , % ?'. " B)=) *F ' ( ) *
J! +/" , : M 3 !2 + ( Q! / 'H !Q!4 +/%*[tiuivo % % 2 6
w
x 6
,yq " )z3 ! & "9 : ;!# { > !2 " !,! & "9 : ;! |} 6
~
:
F $ i !# $% > / %!q * , B < ] "3f > g h : P L , #) $ f , $ = ">
,)$ { !u
B|D 6
, B C". &B) CBy
Q
Br 2-
^tD , ! + , B "> 0!4 < j B &/ "!2
3 !2 ' " 9 h> !'T 2 # B n k : & , $ = "> ,)$ m
! E
\uD n 4>B
!2 " !KGH rIK " 4 !sIK
IK " M ON : T P( ( Q!R* , ,)$ r , $ = ">
!,!2 B = < ;!K )
3ju
f|D
f , C
y
Q
fr 2- C|D D B) s \ " , ]! l
} "9 : ;!
'H *"
tD 2'T " m'T g % ' ( ): B = %!f > B = ;!GH IK 4 !eIK IK " M OND L !2 !
) B)r( B)= $ % m/ %! 5!2 , {!4 -z ,
tD ?/ = ">h B g ) ?): *F " "> 0!
% ;!4 % + "3 " = "): " B'. ) *[
B +tD " B 2'T C "9 : $ ;!D|} 6
,`^ L "
,) / =' ( )= ! = V!2 : W 3< ,) ) *,
$!g U3 Q! / 'H !R! !2 " !+!
,): 4 j M , ( ( ]/%*+tq tK !2/ _t} > / , X .9" > { B) )$ ,> !# $ "
t} ' ( ) *
0 * ">l!2 " !J!2 9 $ ;!< ? \ / >¡ , U "!H'. U %*%!2 = "> ) B % A!2
¢" 5! B/ , J B "¢ ( )$ B { J!2 ,): 4
d
f " 9 ? % " $ E!2 ? 0!# k34 5!< 8 o " '[ ;!4 % B g "3
!2 £ ,
B F!2 £ ' ( > n ¤ , ! £` a6
a"b_
c` a a dE , P ) ) ¥!2 E " £ !2 %
: % \( < " 0!!2 !4
|} !2 !2 o , ! o` a
ca b_
c` a a d !2 o
B { "!# $ % X % H!2 , 3Q! 1'. 0!2 [ 0*T ( 32 0! 3 B %*[ *j . L $ "
!2 E % ' ( )$ B " B %! , A / U B n!2 , !4 U/%*!2 \ "9 : ;!#
Gj 9 C
=' ( )$ W ,)=)$ > !# $ n "3[ / ">¡ "!H %3Q3# $ $ %!j34 ^ !# : !# = ">o!2 ( % ">
5!# $ U~5a z¦§~ a£ye
Rsy
Hence, the order dated 20.04.2009 and the CR No. 99/09 5/6 Amiya Sharma and anr Vs. State show cause notice are set aside. Revision petition stands allowed. Trial Court Record along with the copy of this order be sent back. Revision file be consigned to Record Room.
Announced in the open court (AJAY KUMAR KUHAR) on 17th April 2010 Addl. Sessions Judge: South East-02 Patiala House Court: New Delhi CR No. 99/09 6/6