Central Administrative Tribunal - Hyderabad
M Manmadha Rao vs Sri Vineet Pandey, Secretary, Dept Of ... on 20 June, 2024
CP/40/2024 in OA/195/2020
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
HYDERABAD BENCH
CP/021/0040/2024 in OA/195/2020
HYDERABAD, this the 20th day of June, 2024
Hon'ble Dr. Lata Baswaraj Patne, Judicial Member
Hon'ble Ms. Shalini Misra, Administrative Member
1. M. Manmadha Rao, S/o Late Balaji, Aged 61 Years
Occ: A.D Mails O/o CPMG T.S. R/o Hyderabad-500086
2. K. Venkatarami Reddy,
S/o Late Sri Narasimha Rao, Aged 62 Years Occ: Sr.Superintendent,
Hyderabad City Dn
R/o Hyderabad-500001
3. V.V.V. Sivaprasada Rao, S/o Late Sri Narasimha Rao, Age 64 Years,
Occ: Retd. Retd. Asst. Postmaster General, Telangana Circle, R/o Tenali-
522201
4. P. Radhakrishna, S/o P.S.Sastry, Aged 66 Years Occ:
Retd.Sr.Superintendent, Hyderabad Sorting Dn, R/o Hyderabad-500097
5. T.V.V. Satryanarayana,
S/o T.Brahmanandam, Aged 62 Years, Occ: Asst. Director, Telangana,
Circle, R/o Hyderabad-500001
6. J. Pandari, S/o Muthaiah, Aged 61 Years, Occ: Superintendent R/o
Peddapalle-505172
7. A. Padmanabha Setty,
S/o Late Sri Veeraiah Setty, Aged 67 Years,
Occ. Retd. Asst. Divisional Manger (PLI), Telangana Circle, R/o
Hyderabad-500019
8. P. Rambabu,
S/o Late Sri Dakshina Murthy Aged 71 Yeas
Occ: Retd.Sr.Superintendent, Hyderabad Sorting Dn R/o Hyderabad-
500089
9. S. V.S.Kamaraj,
S/o Late Sri S.Seshagiri Rao, Aged 73 Years,Occ: Retd.Asst. Postmaster
General, Telangana Circle, R/o Hyderabad-502032
10. P. Somasekhar, S/o Late Sri P.Krishnaiah, Aged 70 Years, Occ:
Retd.Superintendent, Z Division, R/o Hyderabad-500097
Page 1 of 5
CP/40/2024 in OA/195/2020
11. G.V. Satyanarayana, S/o G. Appalachari, Aged 66 Years, Occ: Retd.
Superintendent, Z Division, R/o Hyderabad-500070
12. M.N. Raju, S/o Sivarama Raju, Aged 65 Years, Occ: Retd. Asst.
Director, Hyderabad Region. R/o Hyderabad-500085
13. G.V. Rao, S/o Satyanarayana, Aged 62 Years, Occ: Asst. Director,
Hyderabad (HQ), R/o Hyderabad-500001
14. Syed Muzaffer Quadri, S/o Syed Mohammad Quadri, Aged 71 Years,
Occ: Retd Superintendent, CSD, R/o Hyderabad-500059
15. P. Siddaiah, S/o Late Sri Khasim Saheb, Aged 70 Years, Occ: Retd
Assistant Diector, the Postmaster General, Hyderabad Region, R/o Badvel-
516227
16. D.V. Mahidhar, S/o D. Suruswamy Naidu, Aged 67 Years,
Occ: Retd. Manager, SPCC, Hyderabad, R/o Hyderabad-500089
17. M.V. Muralidhar, S/o Late Sri Narasimhaswamy, Aged 64 Years, Occ:
Retd Sr.Superintendent, South East Dn, Hyderabad, R/o Hyderabad-500035
18. P. Sivasankaraiah, S/o Munesulu, Aged 62 Years
Occ: Superintendent, Z Division, R/o Hyderabad-500001
19. N. Harimuthyam, S/o Late Sri Koteswara Rao, Aged 71 Years, Occ:
Retd Sr.Superintendent, South East Dn, Hyderabad, R/o Hyderabad-500097
20. Y.V. Krishna Rao, S/o Late Sri Ramaiah, Aged 63 Years Occ:
Asst.Superintendent, R/o Parakala-506164
21. P. Rangayya Naidu, S/o Late Sri Suryanarayana Murthy, Aged 67
Years, Occ: Retd.Asst. Director, Marketing, Telangana Circle, R/o Eluru-
534005
22. C. Jayarami Reddy, S/o Late Sri C.Thimmi Reddy, Aged 64 Years Occ:
Retd. Superintendent, Nalgonda, R/o Gangaboyanapalle, Chinthaparthi-
517277
23. B. Udaya Sankar Rao, S/o Lat Sri Seethaiah, Aged 69 Years, Occ:
Retd.Superintendent, CSD, R/o Kolakalur-522307 Guntur Dist
24. T. Prabhakaram, S/o Late Sri Sarraju, Aged 75 Years, Occ:
Retd.Superintendent, R/o Rajahmundry-533103
25. B. Syed Imam, S/o B.C.Khaja Hussain, Aged 66 Years, Occ: Retd
Assistant Superintendent, R/o Hyderabad-500054
26. G. Dada Khalander, S/o Late Sri Khaja Mohiddin, Aged 66 Years, Occ:
Retd.Asst.Superintendent, R/o Hyderabad-5500089
Page 2 of 5
CP/40/2024 in OA/195/2020
27. K. Srinivasa Rao, S/ o Late Sri Suryaprakash Rao, Aged 60 Years, Occ:
Asst. Superintendent, R/o Suryapet-508213
28. Mohd. Yousuf, S/o Late Mohd Jamal, Aged 71 Years Occ: Retd
Sr.Superintendent, Hyderabad Stg Division, R/o Hyderabad-500064
29. A. Venkatesu, S/o Late.Lingappa,
Aged 70 Years, Occ: Retd. Chief Postmaster, GPO, R/o Hyderabad-500020
30. Dornala Sattaih, S/o Ganagaiah, Aged 59 Years, Occ:
Asst.Superintendent, R/o Siddipet-502103
31. M. Krishnamurthy, S/o Late Gopalam, Aged 70 Years, Occ: Retd. Asst.
Director, C.O. Hyderabad, R/o Hyderabad-500035
32. T.R.K.M.M. Niranjana Rao, S/o Late Thota Durga Rao, Aged 72 Years,
Occ: Retd. Asst. Director, C.O., Hyderabad R/o Hyderabad-500062
33. V.V. Ramana Murthy, S/o Nooka Raju, Aged 74 Years, Occ: Retd.
Superintendent, PSD, Hyderabad, R/o Hyderabad-500060
34. B.K.M. Satyanarayana, S/o Late SambaMurthy, Aged 71 Years, Occ:
Retd.Sr.Superintendent, Nizamabad, R/o Hyderabad-500038
35. V. Ragahava Raju, S/o Late Narayana Raju, Aged 74 Years, Occ:
Retd.Superintendent, CSD, Hyderabad, R/o Vijayawada-520003
36. P. Nageswara Rao, S/o P.Kotaiah, Aged 75 Years, Occ: Retd
Superintendent, Hyderabad Stg, R/o Vijayawada-520012
37. Mohd. Nayeemullah, S/o Late Mohd. Shafiullah, Aged 72 Years, Occ.
Retd. Superintendent, R/o Nizamabad-503001
38. R. Ramakrishna, S/o Late R. Venkatapathi, Aged 62 Years, Occ: Asst.
Superintendent, Hyderabad SouthSub Dn, R/o Hyderabad-500087
39. Ch. Someswara Rao, S/o Late. Bhavanarushi, Aged 72 Years, Occ:
Retd.Sr.Superintendent, Hyderabad Stg.Dn, R/o Hyderabad-500097
40. R.V. Ramana Rao S/o Late. Venkat Rao, Aged 77 Years, Occ: Retd.
Superintendent, R/o Hyderabad-500070
41. P.C. Rama Murthy, S/o Late Narayanaswamy, Aged 75 Years, Occ:
Retd.Asst. Director, CO Telangana,, R/o Hyderabad-500049
42. A. Venugopal Rao, S/o Srihari Rao, Aged 70 Years, Occ: Retd.
Superintendent, R/o Kavali-524201
43. R. Subhani, S/o Moulali,
Aged 60 Years, Occ: Asst. Superintendent, Central Sub Division,
Hyderabad South East, R/o Hyderabad-500066
Page 3 of 5
CP/40/2024 in OA/195/2020
44. K. Audi Murthy, S/o Late Lakshminarasimham,
Age 63 Years, Occ: Superintendent,
R/o Medak-502110
45. Nanda Banoth, S/o Late Chandru Naik, Aged 47 Years, Occ:
Superintendent, R/o Nalgonda-508001
46. D. Thulasi Rao S/o Late Sriramulu,
Aged 71 Years, Occ: Retd.Superintendent, R/o Srikakulam-532001
47. T. Venkata Rao, S/o Late Gangaiah,
Aged 70 Years, Occ: Retd. Chief Postmaster, GPO, Hyderabad-500050
48 . P. Venkateswara Rao,
S/o Venkatanarayana Rao, Aged 65 Years, Occ: Retd. Assistant Director
Postmaster General, Hyderabad region, R/o Hyderabad-500056
49. N.V. Prakasa Rao,
S/o N.V. Vhalapathi Rao, Aged 70 Years,
Occ: Retd. Chief Posmaster, GPO, R/o Hyderabad-500090
50. A. Sreerama Murthy, S/o Late Venkateswarlu, Aged 77 years, Occ:
Retd.Superintendent, R/o Tenali-522201
51. M. Seshagiri, S/o Late.M.Satyanarayana,
Aged 64 Years, Occ: Retd Assistant Director, O/o The Postmaster General
Hyderabad Region, R/o Hyderabad-500001.
... Petitioners.
(By Advocate: Mr. G Parvati)
Vs.
1. Sri Vineet Pandey
The Secretary to the Government, Union of India,
Ministry of Communications and Information TechnologyDepartment of
Posts, Dak Bhavan New Delhi-110 011
2. Sri Dr. T.V. Somanathan
The Secretary to Government Union of India, Ministry of Finance
Department of Expenditure (Revenue), New Delhi-11000
3. Sri Dr. P.V.S. Reddy
The Chief Postmaster General Telangana Circle, Abids,
Hyderabad - 500 001.
... Respondents
(By Advocate: Mr. B Siva Sankar, Sr. PC for CG)
----
Page 4 of 5
CP/40/2024 in OA/195/2020
ORAL ORDER
(As per Hon'ble Dr. Lata Baswaraj Patne, Judicial Member) Proxy counsel appeared for the petitioners and Mr. B Siva Sankar, learned counsel, appeared for the respondents.
2. The learned counsel for the respondents fairly submitted that the Department challenged the order passed in OA/195/2020 dated 09.02.2022 before the Hon'ble High Court of Telangana in Writ Petition No.9489/2020 and the same was dismissed by order dated 29.08.2023. Subsequently, the department filed an SLP challenging the order of the Hon'ble High Court with Diary No.27053/2024. Therefore, the learned counsel for the respondents prays to close the Contempt Petition since the matter is pending before the Hon'ble Supreme Court.
3. In view of the above submission, CP/40/2024 in OA/195/2020 is closed. Notices issued, if any, are discharged.
(SHALINI MISRA) (DR. LATA BASWARAJ PATNE)
ADMINISTRATIVE MEMBER JUDICIAL MEMBER
/SB/
Page 5 of 5