Central Administrative Tribunal - Cuttack
Satya Narayan Mishra vs D/O Post on 11 September, 2023
oe oe PG Avett .
Sen eal head Srenet poe, van' fsasd mm id a) tony ae ™ pd ae) 8 Yr £0 ed » a bet ea we het a, Fant Sad ret pe Fy a in we tet x aye WM spe £9 wee, rey ef 'onemt leaped cai) ad a, eed 7 Seen ine rh Cp ", i Pog faved fo. ied, : Pins St oe o.. Po ree : t oye geen, foes & 4, aed " egg ce) 4 Caer jeden a ' "3 pee eee co ad ee: Sees et Save we yen % 'nena pate hog oo Ree 0 reo vt Fsaaas] an a ws 08. om os oe wot Pn - i * ae 3 arenas , a banal % b cr od a pos tS or ae! oe ee oa feat vee woes : sane, tw . Pag ia f ee pane abe ea poe i bot me ty Eh hoe OR Ay hes ¢ al re, ; we ee ny Saat cf ; pm, moped, ren, as Pee oe \ peed ar tee ont , mt Laas s . bow aan or wee pr, od ae &®. on on 4 ~ ae aeoen ae Oe Wag t3 Serre ore "wn tne LY ry, wee 07%, beter, aes vot bet pees whoa eh £8 atned er) Jeet pny ooh Lae hat det popes, 'mat we ive as eet fal " Bp ges wt + rae pee va oe pee grt pet ee. - : as Sow tad yen :
: be ome ey, yp, OS oom ne Sail nen, oa ote Cn at Cee a edn ort me oh, ee % oA sree acs pod . po" LS acl pene pes Jona a ee bee MY tte oe we © 3 o fet "xa! : we, we i FG ot Sort Noeew, "a ig arn mo pow caer "per hy, wee : a3 tS we tie th os st Ee rn (MOTE x a ot:
# . bated, d weet tl a eae, oe) Neal a ' saorne . Uy boca wi aes yr, wee fet Foagl z ie A . wm ianted pa spees fas ites Ute ot ewe to ° ~ y4 eee' » wt By aot Aer " hoe ' hat nae 'naa al ee am a Sr Od bes " ae Lh we tere a * od e aver segs! gon Seed ton war, oy er : wk jon ii masons pat : ae ae ores ey wf ¢ 5 hee ya a, lace Leael eed tf Me to KEEPK fee pes fe aa Oye no . " aaa z ¢ sce ran " ooay| rn y on Lon Fatal an joo. a wat, ed wll tw ow Pte ee ak pelos Sew & Gee hy on woe 4 oe te paid 'ebane e : ' ey oe wy. Sapa mo, oe Aen, ff wow 4 rite wy ae pee a oe ' ven oe gel . Oe oe ; oh a a ae eee 'nen! weit ne pm, ms gies a, : 4 - CL pawet, ed ee Sank yee nes is ' ae 'on? os ro prea were nt i fk SOE pe ra > 1 be or 3 weed "no et 7 ,
--- S aad $ sf t KO, we pe on. wee bere rot Leas aaah os ~ oy fore, peed twee ee, aad aye eens Me, pth ews ead ae ead wt fps hoe pam ee e re we, beh "% ded 5 a pte, han bad ; 23 ", ee ead tree paren Tend at baad ae ead 'ii ott : Pes, fen, on ree Wed lhe ne a, OO, nite hog 7 an en, we eoeueran' eek pons oe ete rs pares 4 fee be re : oy peed oon pene OE vee ay inet ye we, ant ras < ot jot seen ae few! stant ; Soe oe ig ans , we Sy co panes! re oS ee, ab to pee we, ee ~ newer. eg Wg OME None rs % of 4 wri ret deed an' ae Te OF wane pore, y gt io rinsed See Soot Paget 'eet * ore, aoe yt aed yen ¥ ~ aes! sone, feet, emi on wo BS foot pars m ares; es Cai Kore: toon Oe met Hs set oe o> fe oe heed wens hag 78: =~ tn, Te ceged aad one Tt aot oS oe as a, pain eZ st ic antl th vt Sedo we Ope oeed, et Belen Gy re, trx , Pree: eaS t vad Hn, ais ean pon sai ae w+ 4 Las aa, TATE segrt a a nid » Secares antes incon. wea 4 oe poe Bp we ke ayeet tas pa mo 4 we OR Wiles, ohn : pe, gg . pos a nog inne poy Kz. ws aa oer : pons © One Por, ae, wee we ere, ates ns eres nt Gerd, Fone = ren t, eet GE yp tis 'od ta roa) a oo x fas on eee seo eps thé eek wos te, eae! oa mm Conca a Uy pen "er gm, - moe ne tao So Le ow .
ns "cant a: mm A gt, ons Le pa pls pe, fener "sgt am, me coal meee goth aes an $ 4 yrs OE OE heh ce Med ., jew oe % z Doon eae det Oe bees pens OOS wees ay pa oe gh. ae P meee. lien ot shes! ae Bae OY ae limes Yeh pn, eo re4 % fe LM New, ia) yy Wires, 'eee a wit wape. Cope or bone . wom OE Face i ae ty ride! ad an OM Se ibcd ied go eats Neh Me ea en, tee rom ont pie, ps ae) oO en we ad wee, foob ~~ ae Co Nd Cred, te . ye, ne wnent ME road té erect"
Pa ceca' ¥ z on. ei Lf, 4 eee ky gree ad fon, woe Pp Ber RE vg, gs Le A eee a, 2s aes + coors Oe A ee eee oo Ef3 5 owe wen nh eet > a d 4 aioe . eee a, ' ep yet ge yo WEES bait AL " Feoad aR o ' tie ' ne: een aad ee ern vo. , 4 Sr £5 an 2 hee TFS Sanna Sag a Cat Snot % ; .
eae 3 .
ond ne Bars eee, eR OO RR Peamod Kumar Das, Memberf A) As if reveals fromm record, giving details as to how the ape failed fo maintain devotion fo duty and acted fn a manner which is unbecoming on the: part of a Government Servant as enjoined in Rule 3 Superintendent of Post Offices, Phulbani Division, a set of charge under Ride 4 of Rules, issued fo Ahn vide Memeorandum dated 08.09.2018 giving him an opportunity fo submit his reply, The Applicant submitted reply dated 1Q.12.2018 denying the The Disciplinary Authority Imposed the allegations level led ssainst him.
punishment af recovery of 6 lakhs In 30 instilments @ Rs. 20,000 /- p.m. He had submitted appeal dared 28.03.2019. During the pendency of the Appeal, he has approached this Tribunal In the present QA filed on 22.05.2019. However, during the pendency af the OA, the appeal . A * :
cs, heed oS et Sea a3 oO aad ot oA wy vo ae no es ae ww atm ¥ 233 ree te, Fook By , Tae lente, ae. nee, oad oan? ws os be Sak and ew es "
0% Spon me ' 2 Ane, ce eed coed oe:
be 4 pa Stina a f hag poe Sn, oy ren, : pens Tad: "ant ¢ a Ne? en, Seid dew oa he Ls a, me sored pas, re 3 ant ne, "a Swit ® " Pa wore ical " ft, nn, Soe baad Pang y i uf? 'mnt oe ra oo hee od i fan rae . me we ihe neo an = at veel. Het aeon 2 wet wheat eo od sed Sano aie weno aid ott ee Soomed 4 ae x Shas en fags es "nel cores, prod beraed on me
"3 need ae ga eae Nat ae Speer ", nd rites j eee pa '" need, . . tes eo wt ave per nes eee yee arsees & oe oe rad cacaaed Ms Bete, jew. J eee, Pecad % acl vores Spat Ms " wes, ol. eee, peeaes Res waged Saud! "set 5 Foun Pee, : ron we 0 bers as oo pd oe a oaged ee ; ae = woes a3 So ber: " 'rad as ' pages, wet poet ant napa. paves aieed ee pen ee ee "none a ys vee, on ° pew fon me th Le 'cad werd ben on pax on 'nee pee tant , raged, wr, eed ony ages ped ne airs ieodoe, proms wre 4 ; cee, Me fe", 2 7 toned le a rt A pen ee a fees :
5 y ce if Z wth ae "nna ts Spee Y fot ow ow eee yea oaeet poet hed, pats "ng ee : we alt bod : Mh : os y ne, we th, sheen ry peer baal bas . renee a a3 ts A os sone ie cs a "ee ve, 3 fe 3 aha bens ad enne, 2 ae nied jest foot a coe wie we oe pan ee ey een "ae feng, "tak tareen saaaed t fees a, "ne ra its o~. oa eee, veere od ge vee a3 Pes ee Srntor sganee Nt! fet Kee ~~ pod 43 ned ote. , aces werk, fon on aw haa agen "ead eke 'eat bee? we, ite fatal ree oe ood ore ee b rod and a wen tae, oa Nop poe ened ngs Mey Be ws eS on eb "geet od ine rn, ort eee ane es tee 4, hg re bon Catt 'mat Senet ot "tt oe watbn : : tow, 63 ~~ coer wor, eg) pees ne Soe baie on id wet on by oon te foe ey os pate See we, eet Peed Sone g . Oa 4 ty wees en ; 4 ft ans we nn ad oS ewe. ae ~ pte an ra Teta' >. ee ae sane, a sees bow, wee raps eed et fede, caaad wn Aerel Soe e ns om _ feet ry eee, pee 2. :
ae eet pea cies bee, vtwen. "et shack a fe, wn, . ees oe wee new ect fe ose an? ee fs * . : oe - nae eet the ° mee Seo a, ¢ ra 'eee peg seek ae A , t fea rsI oe ho ove, oe tt Ls uh ta, Bs fee oand . : am aed ay Oe i foc fy . pes ae te ee wy fac] seen pans sagen: ad een pa0ds spoon. ota peed Z ans, (as pris eo, a, ina ae eee, Pa e tg ie "na oad iat bana we 24, as on " te, G $ ' , pen ln ae Qe das oy ai ad Dra ad none ae oo om to "a ad aes ay 4 ead wy pee noe. wear 1, 4 Bae we wre oe ot we sree Ths asl 'are, et. a eed 7 pe zener oo 3 of gen * Rate can pag ~ baa age % poet : wey wink teh oy Pon, CL aa yf gen ye ees, ws tees weet costed we Gok ¢ 7 ,. es See Oy, sober, pawns wee ool "aah wes pot raft rae 7" Ao nanad ot ow Cora as pas fei seer She 'here, tae teet wae tet abe 'at Snel ee, rae pared cane wee te 1 pore Aine, my pet a seal pees é Snel pas Past roeee. oe re jee, ed Se na, peas war icoont eneeg ork fod ee sed an Ae we ve oe ae eal coed panty wert Nat > 6 ve rapes flee is hs a * 7 i ieee se ge met x - Ok *, Tea deed ee 205) ret ' 4 ae deed "A ae ine ayes or :
at aa' " dg fen? bre _* Saree! 4 a 'eh, oe ee? ire, 5 pos 5 hen, 4 Fo) ot * 2 ri Z r ' s . sre bane ass oats fs ne y ee fas hoe Ww eed sn, 4 ~ te a4 apr Ps a ceed pa me! aes t eo ee ' ~ y "ssa 7 s por -- a aA a Tae ot aS ed on; me on re no fo [o Ee awe 'se Pan venets ", bade gre Papted "eg 'pit a . a eben er, pre Te 'oot a. eoee a ub x a Q weiner wee ee, ni Pane See? Ano ge tr Bree, 2 we aaa dred od, Daal va fat; on on, : ies eas ~ nee, s oneee, me Oy wrest tee ool faaw, Sead yen Not tend an a ba Wes Z Zz Poa . gee seer Le , love pene 4 brmed, pend feoen, oy mt a, ts : ow, pen oo yo, on zg wen 2 ies z jot bie $i cas ae Gi a aes yee em, hore. Fed css aac' few a pad et pas oe woe aw A ny a a ~~ on a "% ny "Sy oF Be ro ss a, , pa , os, Png os eal cheat rd AS wore pron wieed, ve ane) 2 iF 3 ow ood fas rs Laeyel we ees aaah tees! tat ers fee ee pw ~ wee seen ee, sont Tt eee 'pod ere fen Seacat cane feed pad dott Pes foden, . ied a . ae beat a wn eG ae pane wae, s peers, teen pe 'abt we tot rs ot t ved atl o bert ap bee, pet ied ne , '4 fe yeees on, , oe : ae oo yom ae a on bette cece FE ost ees raat Cad on ' Ba a4 i Po e) ny, pos Ay . hind ih when a3 ae bas S sa om, eas Gs wveet ¢ ca seen read ons rons a4 Fated Ls ons pee Net shook a at inte, Sot Nad % fe at eaces pas oe Ese pe. Ant Sate nS Sa? bar' op od es n~ me é peas a 5 * 9% ae pas ws Te. gen few se a we 5s Pe os ay fa 7 yok ee % mm ane bok we a jen, 'nl on dane taal Aye Brces ion Sater sy "Ms feedes Sen oe es, wee hoe oe bus, aie 'wa hae om pes eer pws if pot og a fee. on One a me ee rr * ie me Lea me ne pn wit , Ss eS ty ba te tt Sad oo ty a; pleas ite Y gs pee Boe rs ene, gS her, an Soeh pan os pscand fi aes wot oh ey te oe vee, pase Ped ; nen, -- tone renee ace 4 Cae nee is of yee ee Be Sal Ws pad eet en a aes Le Rs ne 23 pons Aone an ag "re wa 4 epg on wee ay a, Sea, conte Lf on a Hs we we Set Kec ood eal we "S 50s) ed pad ae Fras a gn ree pon. nen, Foe so ree pate. 5 ok Wty : fe OD we oad sepres. ee eee ee weced, heat oan Ae pons wn wee Nn head eA tend pone dered, ann, Naot ery po, %, eines tn ee a foe bee ae on cat os ee bo we fe Aeat ets ee an be iis pase (or Pond aS aege a eS fey ne fone rae yan, pais oe ri, ore YF or biased od Bok nee a ad e363 yee ats pom 5 ped " " Seaaed sae ee a wh an 3 2 23 og o wet he 63 Rs awe men : ED Poe oe pas rae: a 'ned ae ~ ot 4 oA Ay Sethe Oe : ; an ined ed ee ve a ea one * os ee ea fe Sees. ret pass poe pees ser ssa mr a vit vere A, ed : feed iene en be Do bea She seven we on need heen ee eee, eed Z Laas iaaoad "ae fen tak 'eat al AG cae po pore. aoe bee Noo ae len aes or rae: os sere aon pee i? wo wee Fost ad wo, fenne, oy, pon on 22 £3 on we vied, on, A we ne for wn oer oe hood Lt basen Loot vs ee woo eben, oped, oe sod at ral ' es a pee ae, ee joe ad : ae. thes ey, re _ pee a paper. pon ound Bane, eh, Kelsie yee wit peed.
er wine, os $ ene, See "tat ow tf te ae a C5 het a oom os ee ONL rs se feo soe: ew a pane oe, ron, ' ; ee "a ae ean preg pots free %% ee buat geet "ne ee , dent hoe vinnad, Tho me heed ' weer. :
~ ens4 a im oes hee eit ae yee eee fis LY tet inet aes ae . ites Aebeite weaa , f hed ie ind ott ¢ Pan "ss wr en reat' dood Lo mid. Nie fone. oad oo we pas short on OF 5 Page yee Mie wooed foe t = pond ty ss te werk: awe "bed ~~ Be her Tye ca Dae CEs poor esate weer, wt wn 2 ey os od eee ees b Legs Son: rd dah ae eee See 3 rs a ny paps. ™ Fee a al biel & ay ' pees ~ w a ws ee: Pate rrr ot ad Shee on ' , ye sepees oe on LD a3 pn is ot ne 3 a 'ae feo Pp Fen ard we, ead as Ct ohn, , gee i fale *. ae uaa nt anes me, Se. pe 4 sen ns oy P a 'ed er, pe. vom a4 ie a W% ae ad pas i ve eos fener *: nag as Ws Ae apn "3 Ci ' oe oe Poa pes OS "pe 'neal be hoe, boc. acc ws arene is x a say fas bees pened heed oy Sree, io ihe yee 'ehees on So ie cad eonet.
ar Veagl ad Pann Ay eased Fama Po Sm aed. pons Sane SS faaead pees Feed cheat Facg oon ES fet TS othe 2% vy ictal ie od te ee Le ; Pa geod ae 'nad ee Abe. § fees ae bo $ yews a a os ieee pa he aand ae hoot mS a jee pond oaaee ton an : igen, x bye ras) a + te when aap, ae io aad Pasay % eens Cat go, nny, ad ome te z "es es fos Prey pee ne , % Pech oy eri Y pee, as sy 4 on 4 % aad Sy Ws vad ed jad ay Bi "se he pee + fal Lat peed og be ye pr, nines pon pen x ee aes ae Sook Sten sect seen P ty vee od Be 2 oer + ~ eee, pa ny * 4 5 we J pe yd ee tered a oy Ree Qe ies pee as pe Be pee: Fes cw ee Ae 'eons ood ager ped pon wt 'nef! for # 'nao ees oad bese ee lon " , ween ' Sent on ad wa we te Os ita panes, ad ours Seg a "ae: Pore <i oe Log bod 2 A Z >, ;
fats hone 5. aha ae pn 7 £ Les woe ~ soe ven jene iad ag a ives jon poe ewes "es tore &, '$ sites te bad aes 3 ane es :
Pad pons shed poe yt ners %, Bane tog ae a, a yee been 'ot ped om ro. sod ee ane hand a3 jak 'aot oe o, pa om sg ; Rae) = hut "eee poche, v WE . 4 een 4 cet oa ponte om Aieek a3 eo ce ey Soden, 'nat i ben pes, oes wp rio: ng ot bases pe ennre. oa a " besoce # pa Panna on ae he my if oe ba oa ¢ Asey Court in fhe case af Mahavir Prasad ws. State af UP, AIS a Lh, PY Oe PWS Sosy wehbe hex Peyegeeeaet fey Wy SC PTROk. According ta learned counsel! for the Applicant, wh ree Ae ye nayener cy etayy cede poe eetend bee tha Brmereasoter maf the aqusanyropriation was admittediy conumitted iy the Postmaster of the MM recovery ought ty have been made from Aim and not from the deceased and that as per the DUP&T Instruction dated LEQS.19es & review the Inspection Report submitted by the deceased and had {t been reviewed they should have painted out the discrepancies and having not He dione, the SPO/SSPOs are equally respansible bul without making them responsible for the lass throwing the blame on the head of the deceased by ardering recovery is Jlegal and arbltrary. it has heen submitted that due to pressure af work the husband of the applicant could not verily each and every balance sheet of 11 branches af Boudhra} MDG and other Branches within short span of time (19.10.2016 to 31.12.2016}.
Ne had randomly verified the P&S and other documents and not all the sy, rer peace x ee {3 peer oan o coal ey ep pod pen va Sanda ~~, ws ina 4 a pan yet 4 rt Ww reed wn! 'sae aoey, fete seein, xe "
n Poe 'nel sri vat ar ~ Fe soos rom eet yy balance sheet, The arguments of sum and substance, Is that the punishment imposed on the husband af z oe Z. the applicant Is too harsh and that he had been visited with the "3 egal zm ".
vi edd raed bead wy ped bigee ae oat wa ap pe ae net a, fees sas dent % 'ath iy oe dene rm 4 pond ae 'ey me gat, we ie es a fe aed nad a & eee y ; é is, al i oe a. vet i = Shen va ne Ws OS a See food ae a 5 BK vee yee pod hey * be re ww en aaa hate Puy 7 Rd ws ne wc Cy 6h Ped :
Sree: ged ened 4. pets * pees fe. Pats ws roa wa aad a hea som peg! wt ce os "a va bo a3 ae ea z Hes . 4 « * ae és soot <3 ay oe, ms Bios oe ga i Fad pr ; z P eh 2 oe we rad, afore % aS aatt ook wo he y Peg . seh! pa ned > eed epee sos ; ee Uh A ae aad Pil 2, i ot, * ogee, asaad ort ye ae on tool faa Sad ae oes Lae] nae Sa ib thei . wer, cael ae) we pron: geek tH. poy ne ae od pad wy ne ome) Nag Kanne Spied ¢ a ; a rm, eae nie? Foard no 4 Parr) Pade Exact a wn wwe ae % Fa yack Pk A, OG os ja ! ns BA ae Lik Hn pe a beds pa we if: 4 * Pak Sons ; eae) ' a, yon ad wee head an us ey AR: ine Sie 4 pe Croat ge
788. i 'ad. oA, oe oo Pace eee pore, a ay Fat rag a" fap ene, 7. ee gh Sa nt aoe put ya re bn oe oe wd as fo mh ee aes og my bry a Garand we Bcd Secol ad pn Kg ot "af canoe , nine, dod pened bcd pea eo race oe re, Pana if pone bakes, cae Sane we ied oe ' nae"
hone 2 = pa, nen, as aoe $ "s os cecad PA a Poaa' wee, } Saar" 'thes ie or girs, we oor or"
ey ern Tod wa Mags ¢ yy * we ies ona "cic 'nae hor x we PS ann a") pans a3 "nena? Me nn, ieee sy oe "ib ae wend pa ie . fe x Fes 'ne x . : ar, on 4 ° et erin ape book we ack ay tb ont igen 'apap es " wre, we boob deat S fg ee at i aod 4 We wae batt art - es fits ey wiht gen goons coded net wy Foat pon we on perch ater. ated. wr d * Be 'putes res Sok sg aad saad oh [sores ~ a tLe . ae aes ome poe eg "e on, fin, we wes Laan "es aed oe cy "ret one "he ioe or 'sage! Sab ft ea on ye wee : OL on os, pe, fr, ae Sean 'ee y wee 5 ? wn Pad oe et : yee were, Fn aed mm Son 'anit' pe co rane Peed Ese r4 fete ov Sint Pon ee: ae "hone. Sant ag ea £ft see? q "3 nat 5 ¢ poss io we aes ded yee ter Faas yo $04, "el aes ye ws ue ses ro ved aad a wo ag po iad hed ae : oe: box pe ner kaw, RI? jon, % Nw ey, Te aneees, to hee i ¥ 2 Page ys, Neen a ss; ae on wok: rm WS "eat Saeet fe ys pa Ay We fen, siete "haat gm, ut Paras Wwe ies seenoe. G3 es, ot oh: wm, hak tee pepe > 08 bese bese eed pa ied ee a bes os ay vont on "s vn bes re get ween, gee "pe 'att ; raise] a " toy peg deen po ss ae bea " me Re a ee s a = oo, evs ge ns loos he * a ye rs pei foal ag oo we 2B pte ein, A ee a3 fet od it: eaeede, ae, 2 § Neat e paced . vost a Foal Le 4 a) ron Son dens bons Sox,
-, ; wn, yi 1c wed, , cod ae wee, rae comis fans rn ts headie pa 3 payed. os, ' ee ws Lb ae wt Nahe ae Pa Pe ae, 'cad a. oe ee z paed' heat ne Ye coal es open bos, pe aa rs $04 za beet ree Aye on ope, ass ae er fe Be eet oon on feb ce a enh or aft car weve. sere iad on Pat : bovis "wri aa aed ee peas apaga P wg? neti fey arn Sut thy et om oheee seed, fs, oe ae "ney ade fe of: wr peead. ae es, yo er hed os, a) rgd pone at we coal el ged, ead pea facies 5% pm wees eee fats ne ree bra ron pete ae ae . 'sane sheet * be paid bases gy fone, ' ; * ia heb 'nein a yr, oo Mone re, Leen Oe YM me Pe ey peut pa a fo send ops Ps ats bon If ied "ehees Pewee on ane pac Ly vo ' oh ; Fag oo 25 wget . oe ie ~ om a fk . od ca Fs me Be we ret eens wee es A atc "4 a esd Ane , a pg fie fb ore has an pos Sank jon pence "the wen ae pool ee Sat eg NA poe neon Aeot ead Ly ao Sones f8 i" Sad eases A ae beck Feed 'Nest at ¢ ae :: wate ree wea ors ane Baws bce 7 oe os peeing aes ted x LS me Pao és bs pane teed A ood tot 4 ee Laces oe horned :
gs Bane pen ayes, pies poe th ead bia wer Presa' £5 re hora one diosa Sool peed 'eee. Sot Some ea pees owen m aie seek os pond Db Pad mek ol won fa pn oe s "3 pong etre a : rs pao. a b ~~ gt 5 ea beans Sone' ed ye baa 3 ped, asi 3 ' ose weet ae Pani Fi tf ve bat ff i' "1 eS eg a eg gon oo soo, ' oe po we an Fs 087 Seri wart Stee, aed Rona Coad Lotte pe pie we eee, a3 a ane oe Jonge pew yo, Seo, hed ae peed magn, os. pert 'oe ae, Sa ae 7 oe ep on FA oa ms ve bes "pe past ae "7 . Poe ais, . eet ve « a foal poe Naot ar aoe eo Nahin See adit acl cca baa ae: rd ed ues BoM ty pas _ tent re So ae '* ars Sin. ea Mons aot ia ed tan, r es es iter, ', hee, x 4 b 'aot : : oo peed oe fea) zs Boat ey A fa apis fad od po ee yom ae we oy nA Anes aed gachea: Oe pe * bod . * By "see bated ones -
aed ' oa prs, Pod 2 es Bs pe Me 4 wat Cy pn % ieee [een rs Red rth pen, whee vp ween a fe tat . sheet ¢ Lad im, heed : ' vipers yoo 'need 3 pod a 'se rate as Nod Be)
-- oot wn 5 See, x loeew! 7, 6 Gi fy oe lo ry mS tet ¢ gy peak eae ye, Pa f as , os, aeeeet Se ad on) aon, vit os 'ans . porn Nessa pe tea "ae a goon, weed, rm, iF] a ened. £ ore Fat hs enon, et oe abon$ oN, ot Sel pee head LANA anna nee eat pon leooad oe joe ity BA ort ren oes peo teak . a pds ofooe we pow tn :
ge Go ne ns aes wre ra, peed a a ee Soe a8 fae : bo Co 4a; rae "St 4 z pene "a Tae on aes %, 5 Q eaeed on Praad s eed oes, en pees raul oy 'red, " oS ws eal ar Cab ; "ea! Ne eee Spee Paarl on oes ' ye on, wee "net pa vn 2 a $ ef fee fet z ran, et olen 'eat wen ift ee pan ~, ce gen Ay oe ee ry ts 'aa Ke hak od wi4 , ". Raed Fass wy fea = hea Goad be pose od yw as Scand ee aad ¢ wes pee . 4 hae. ae net Pann deed Aen rd Ne aagee £5 ia we sheet ae oe pesee " r = ns go * ae nee iad yarns. dt vik oe wee Seah r ot n ved. een : Samad as Ss psd oe a Send eo * oa = lone Bow, raped oe nf cae 7A, ees aed to c 'ned Fasc ioaes a oo ; WS eed ed . heed peal i eee a ~~ '4 oa neee eert one' Mey ew aed Pees al fe wt, 'aed - yy ae Aen, © rn oe toot panes ifs we ty =. wee a a poe wed Pm fo ed ead pad ie "gen wet ord ba a o, os 'ned tat en saee tte, 2 po i: Lone gen ad P, % x "ye pete one eG pes corel Ez ad oe Pod on Ire, att oe oy fom ed ah Se ag woe eet pee pods ~ eo wn oa 4% we) one Grades ry ev) Sate i, ca been ' eter Frere, rangl ne "es Le, My 'eee a pede, pt ee we ay ina te it Pa I os ee. spord, TSt th a: gee aes oe ° yee Ay a, " ea we
- F hs os ao aa oon ame raped ae woe pape * vo = nae) pan ore at F i teene. baa aes wed oad es Eas 123 ee thet on pha? , * aod = .
vee. "" ae Sere! feted, saoet eo oy nat a nae ree ¢ pea "adn paneer re pe a Of: ned, Pann " Faen reat atone were see. wwe ci oh, "a Seat ev! Pan at sees 'vet? rans ray :
Sen we we sage, ert a, a0) ¥ poeen Bian we 4 4 ahd woe we eae el A ee Be : goa oe " n weft he ped aaa' setts wen pad eee m "athe me rn oe a ae a , " we ow "st fad oft "a we "
nye bed eaaed nah few ve wooo ws . wo Ded eed > aes ie syd nenet wae by ret: eae Li wove een leased % wy ned te na woe aa Ket fs foe ay pl ' : ts wo ee nee anne ay Seed g yon : in! oe neg eed oe oad cod re ~~ wee *, How rood "eat aie ie aad ~~ + heed -- "fs os nr mn ee) = boc pon (0) es ob: he wnee eee ane " ane 3% ° wey [<e) sAand : fe, ad net fy Sat a w ye ye me weet ae : Pes Panes es Ant ed tere ated wee es 4 ree, " rebel, ws yet: oo on we oa) a, my As pot ov oo aoot ad eons pens nt See te ar: oT viet = oe on Pal "et "Lh . ae ie crags! er * ve, ae on Fee, weed, Pad wren ina? Pood vo inv Lees * Saal Leet pod wee wes, ° "h ; nee > ", ond z Le oo bro me, ea ot en we ae a Oud ' aod woes wed an a oes porn, a - . 'a 4 Lee tab a want wo Gs heoed an pam : os, te om tert a ered oes os ant os Pas ; aes, tated iat ae tmnt fad 'ek oe Fonsi 4 eae . Paes cd wen pa "me oe S$ asi A os fe rive wy ; eet ~ ee 3 % fies a 'ni "3 face whe ed: Neat al es oo an" we pny rom hi iow whos V3 z casei om nek ao wn ae cso fee" al a8) yA wen my oA a Sal eed ni we pasd ee it Us "nat ed ae, one pees yon 4 pie roa Daal pa om : Bs ue pe oy pers Yu. ¢ ' pant joe ms bes fect o. --~ Ay a a a os aon tie pees > Peal eo ee be gee ae : aved 'ad ad A be eal at nad ae Neat on "aa oS wes aces es : er, ccanes . = seed Fs = uA "eee oy. : iN to ow my --s rn ot yr en pad we, poe 3 eed aw 'ete At Pras on on va ceed phe ~~ ; z Tae prea' 'i ws wn beech x5 weer! dew wieee aceon fees ae $ fon yen, nee Sate aeeet ta wares et Fok: wey re oes "ae eon sony 7 art ia St oo. 'oonn om Ca ~ gob rs bet we woe sf om ae we os Lt Vevey on, "eww "~ caeh 7 pods one ' . : ' re re caneeds oD a yes vibe " oS hee aie ve a soed os ba ae ~ S wee % 7 : sock awe wy , fon a " ad My vk , oe ma be ea > eae poe avs wy = Regent , pot a we. pon Life ree Bis pe tent ' ae) a aids fe, Wo Seed a vem ceed ee pod oe a pen pe 'att oad Saree ree aan re ee: "sg fen, i ; one 6S ye 3 oot rant Son ne Be ~, pee oot hw Laos vi} ' . : x f > * feo pa mS rH nen des ae Loa] cod Faget fone on ree eer ot ie caer ae mo, vee ve "ane ; £5 mnek canaed a eet cane. 44 bet ea is Ls shee ° ' Le ood, ae Sat $ wend -- ee wrod pen tft aes Sad seen a es ge he om at oS WY ee i, -- weet wes . 4 £ FA 7 wet ¢ ty f aes ' oa th on et a oo vow ; , bn 'et "hoot a ven, wet * eee. 63 Capt es ron nay 4 Line Ce oes, bn oted Kaod Pt Fe DA . 'aes we oe oer, at "chen es, wo LS pat ne Lane poe re rae to oy ro ae age amen 7 Esa 'nat oy, feed kee % wood, Fie 7 : eat oe * é yaa f epee en ieeee Meet ae EE ed ee. we a Bais i eat (ee 'adn, ned? ae oe ean) pant 'anne yy area c det os nm, meee aie pre, canned am tad we % '% Ga wIPY a "S 'y wider eng id ry and, therefore, thi Hs \ x t ee, ~, elt Scas pans aheiek er 3 * £ >: HHT the ore "
x et hy the husbared of spechion sy & gn Gh in rie fe FOYS anc Soe ey eee a fy an G20 s the Ins harala RAD ESR 3 yeanch office balance of f ection Report of the year GH he y & oft HEMP Oo} Da as 3Q.4 TES (DG & & Se aN} c@, AS Per Y balan 3C I i :
3s whereas the activa y veh S £ &, 90, 14, O04"
RS % eh as f tween the BOQ OO, GOO t ary ob aesci Re base
1. by x i x "ep dees we or soe wo rey os an Lad Py ae "4 oe YE) He had submitted the completian certlicate of Annual Inspection of the wt aph PAPER ERIER x ag .
RFR R S YASIR OU WEE MO ay tharal MOG wie letter authoriby could not get the irregularity, (Hegality and disrrepancy which enabled the Pastmaster of the MDG to cormmalt fraud in shape of utilizing Govt. maney for Ris Own PUrHOses. The stand that in the report he had a directed the IF, Boudh Sub Division to verily the transac ton transit said Branch Post is mot supported by any i shown against the :
document/fevidence.
7 As regards imposition of punishment without supplying him the documents is cancerned it may be stat tod that no myaterial has been oroduced to shaw as to which of the documents he had sought giving justification as to how the same were fF slevant and how rion supply of the said documents was prejudiced him to defend his case. The pleadings of this case are also silent in this regard. it is profitable to aete that Law on the subfect is well settled In a catena of decisions and Pand State Bank of India & Ors. Vs. Uhivut Kumar Mitra & yale
- SiG} wherein it was held that itis incumbent upon the petitioner ta slead and prove the prejudice by non-supply of the decuments. But, as stated above, the Applicant had neither in his defence statement submitted before the DA, in his Apneal nor even in the pleadings in this Case have made any such attempt fo fustify the relevancy of the documents and nan supply af these documents how he was preheiiced Thus, this Prfibunal is net impressed with the submission of the learned counsel for the applicant that imposition of punishment was in violation of principles of natural justice fo the extent Stated above.
8 Next contention of the learned counsel far the applicant is that he was Imposed without causing any enquiry as is being followed in disciplinary preceecings under Rule 14 of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965, [f is noted that under Rule 16 ef CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965, cpportunioy is available to the delinquent employee to seek for regular inquiry. It fs not the case of the applicant that he had ever prayed the same befrre the DA but the sarne was not acceded te without any reason. In ne appeal 8 sone eae coornee tn:
4 p Foeaed bd worrn ew Qi Caan gh wren meet raed tes heat " Pee as feed awe Seat WEE oe Te "nat thd yr Siren $3 " ven re pose pan Eo' 'i vy ae * fond teh pane ot on ty pocoad asl red wt z yo te eer os cea Pad va Bod :
gi pe, wee yn os wee wee, ie 5 gt tod ae csc om oon heat aoe iene' de, rs wh wp " a P . Lane ok yy 'a tei oak ae at bah 4 ; ioe bead Pesci a ; od Aon eee ny fw bob a ' gos a oa aeok 'aoe et pe: ood tind % ean oe re : o weet vane " oy a Fed oe wt poe sone Kiel ere ee ~~, Sast nn, Peas oo 20% eo ors til pas ite peins een one fine Ei sd i aad Be we "se pois: 7 ie rere ee tt vad a3 " ' ms '3 es copen, Yes a yee Re - easel eer woe Paar Se Yash Ay ae pees , can rage bane pe a nat ps ~~ ara Dy Syed, fees a panel "ew tal Sa cores ses Fad new Louk ns ae we pa = Ae y: took Lesa bas aed se aod oil hes 4 fh bd wd o ny ied eo ee ° he ae a re aw Geta ors z De eee, ed a --_ werk "he were, yan oe t " ot nn : ant 4 pone pened, ek Ts wet ae, 'As, ma 'p. ve Fees ; ss : ood ~ % ; iif fo wares cia tee wry ", Se a re, aes ra ot, we ma wade pees s oe wt 3 yw '. ew feet weet mn a weet ee ol a de few os broaet a3 pore we 2 ns piped r eee ben z na ay oe eo iia on on ie oo a = wet eg ms x "es os on ee pears Pag' 05 ped tae, whet ane ne, fag aa yet by fv, fag bead yr dod 'ory rae n, ont tt ahaa 'eat 'af "ae eet, a, *s + andl "nase r 'gap en ete, fee. poet re 'eet hea: a aad fx os pe? pees Ww om, wrk, poor, hen ae oo pen pee ee he we \ & H ca bre . Pao lepead Pwr so! Naas 4 eet Gon bee stent au ~ ween Sf: i ny ald Lt ty wee ben : ty t x Heide tat rae ~~ os ea, 43 few pod, yereee, - ire err pee "3 ads . seit ~ wy nerd, ns ~~, a] > nen whe. ay 4 we ed, 'ned ty cat a" ys et % wt oat ~ Saat oes, ' oe wal 4 ; * oe hee a ott, coed ran ae Ait bat eat eee 4 gee 'nal! pea! BF an 7, oy oo iets Fema Let we ht fs o ee oad od heat had St pa ws ted ay a on nos eee, we aad as Chak eed pas means ye ae oan oot in co seen 'eer oe "4 se We bea whet gee pee Lee arene " ae; . 7 ned vot 'at por nee mn heed ot ben pact 3 oA, oan oS oa ween, wa gee whee, oA pied ae nad ae oe 2% woos 'cael Ay : we aed Ney aa Peal ry a nant pan Ge i we eee. wry de id z ane, wel " Mee be. whe oe. = on oe io wo . no, ee. oa tina ey he Ped wee ae 4h nerd: vr ee whe baal 4 Hani "aia "ant Lod whet . oe ae oy, Poet . . et io pees : oa ue. wn "ane! het aA bred ay 65) wee Ay . 5 Sere les 7, aerk pon fees ied weer ee Socead sen pot pan eed we ae ut % oe. gre het at oe oo. ae 'ee iva * Oh " " a rv os a 'et 2 ene fin ee , be 4 che. yee, Saat road wh . Set oes mel 4 . os "ee ye - nee, eon fod re los) on ret Bel asl bees vt aren saeee * sien uae peed bot ood ne Faael pad oe Sees ms ois oot . ren het ye a nea aS pies he 43 penn oe a, st ox worn ened a ined a poe a 'eee "re Ms pai wr baa on aan Pod > fetes ney oe, soe aes oe booed weds gen ey Soor: vere ; Nzees, Ca "ee we as ate' we Bea ae yee ene * ne ' ae tthe . vee, Pend Bans anal cos ca poerd s, wn ry mm St ie weer anes my we Ae pans me Li bond ee a oe os a ry oo A pee ase! ot : ae ease coe ra re ded. Kok, baad Nason' Ay we, book oe Pan fae eed get x, a "ae wis viet p 4 " "5 nae x y sport f. ns os, Ge cane "act tom. w ae pees, ae went rare, no we ee wegen: bead ae o res pee. a; a fo. poens 4 ag "aes 7 aw wore = velit nee *, oe "mnt Laan ~ 4 :. . ry At pay " 7 'ener! rete, . hed oy Ngheeeh, os "ene apea ne ae oe tot eek 3 yond orn re es yes 4 ral PF m7 2% Reg ima od aaa nes ion a went toa, "0g ed rey % 4 a +2 eo % 4 oa od 4 Ms ae tA . ao nea one 4 Vogl they peeve, At a ay aa enn oa aleve Re Pa dates "ae aa ae Lan oe Bb Le " ~ ay ad nanae rere ey wo oad were Peed pe Fang a ee 'at wy dere, ore « . 5 pon ieee %, © on dod ot ws, nw x i pees / " ote we waged, Pais wees longs on wee we 2%, ae ai a eo! : a7 faad . go "pee te at etn aed 5 ret if boot Ot isd Ae Re ~ ine tA Fase 4 * pee oe wt wy ¢ ngs ee, "nn 4 ae weet: FS ar. tan an wy pan ors ie tA ne sop ane rh we of he 'eh east gen ty sagt *" ° 'E he ween sat cn paben 4 cd oD "ened co feet &3 tow : a) ane ween : oe me 3 ; ' i nfl ween A wa wee font "doin ae ' ioe nk poe Ch were, vt on "bd a4 a. wn ead elec tft - , eos Cid sree 'th zo fen ord head pea Ts ay anne bead td "aa ° -- yn seed the a aod ; stem ne aos ed _ a rf ' , out aa hoot an we 4 7 dont Pa Sed cod Pa bet ee 7 ee ag eed pe bed od en ee ? &, eA . 3 ree. tans peut Pete at rho ae Spr Ye oe on coed ees rat ten
- ; % : ope a ra ad ae 43 + " we mS oe ee os iM Sa 4 % a, rot in ae. L3 oo a, e - peng Foagl wet ey ane, odawe ns, Sent 2; i a al "aed pore 'ahaa ab " 2 assed "et age Foon vor dent hac were: ae can we pon Fs rr ey het ott pa' ag roe oe hent- ae Boe nate age ed £ ee, * Ly oe sad. "ait Ae a oo wee phos pn rage yee : ott Poca ied ¢ the an Ae 2 pan SS Sees hon Ae need, ry peters om oy a ar mre 4 re yierl tot the arders are sat palatable fo thes e eanrot be branded * stab according * a Rad gg Baw MESES Say s held to be without any yunishiment was joe pie ete we ve eee Wa Pr, ons nee, f5 $s.
on fk we ope Bay bas fod 'oes ot oo ede yo.
'sat oa, we vara pet en B ~ yee re tot pee noe onan me oe, y 2 gee sea.
Pal oy.
tes * ~ larkel pare sarge goeae ipod.
oe
i) peg na disproportionate is cancerned if is nuteworthy that SPs ge APRERER Cry Mey Lae VE Sesto. avid stre TES er Ee DROME S Constitution and rule of law, keeping In mind the advancement of oublic good at all times. Public employment being a public trust, (he ieeproper use af the public pos e is considered as a serious breach of trust. With the changing times, the role of Executive and expectation of the citizens in governance alse underwent tremendous change. Citvens keep their hard-earned money in the past offices for their utilisation money is safe and secured with the Govt. For the fallure to discharge the anerous duty by tie ers concerned, who are suipgased to be responsible and to see that there is misappropriation and fraud a oY ree, a3 Raved ee fe, ¢ as peed Nand i ae ify t baeee when Sadel uh ye, Sood a 43 "ho ry eee hast a3 ad -- opens Ly Ione Pe. st, wD 'toot oa ™ pies sa! ~~ ' « ty ws ae eee Coad - ge pe MA ane, heel pea vt a mm we boob A ve a) Sa oon a4 o wre od eq a 'a7 ie, oe ra a Ieee Fea] 'beet oe ree Ld ne oy ee Peed itt wed ie 3 t ey fee rary bow ? fos 3 : De eee pate yore ae : ae % eens, ay vu dew y. a fee yA votes al wrod Fact eed Ae Senet, lee Pace Fame ie aot Sse oes 2, aes tres, Spot, wee ye acd Paes fant ap ein:
ws nm en meee Ps 'nase ra , pen" fretay! yom ees Sand xoday tre poe, +yrA wea Le ree shed fa Fad paces ore: wen lapel we waved, --_ s aad vw cal not Aa deed paw ron Pere, ge eaten to Cat pred eee hae o Som ime a be ay :
44 i oo ay " ye kes, 3 on sey id ha , Sone = anh ro ines? Ly be et a arn ea be Net 'ot pon ee et, tad ieee est! a 3 hes, Pp. ed a aac' Feecd a Pe pe ~ Awd Secaad 3 g < 4am, ve 3 Fan sate aa' pas page ape Nae an z eek oe 3 = pes ae wea. vee tod pa gene £ ae Bag Sade he < dene of Mo Nae Lr apow shad at peter, xe Lh we yak < . ot whens sents Paki pa Sent wd a rane) Pood fate, beeen wares, Oe ' oft Saat rete inte by ' pe ben peace ons aod anaes "f A . 4.
woes weeds fore, es "oe aeel wee, 3 whe! pen ahs a Veaad yee vee. ered. we ot eet wee pos. eben, eee paar' is Pact aie . pea ca ides] 0% e, oS yr. pend vaaad Bs fen See. yee ae ee, Soe enews, peed pane : wn my 'ne ae wee A aay rene ' 4, 4 3 Anan on aod how nes GB we ES ae yee vom seach as buat? pps is pers ve a ong ' Sede weeny dese ee panes ee > poet ones, oe pane " im a ia oe we we Sete seo om ' be cnt oa oy E oS in mm Dey cares Selene Seedey oy ft, . put gee Ae pa fot wets peoees fy Sonn pees "hee it we peeen te a he tapes pen Lon eerie ancl mG ie "ns on ' baal ro in foe he? a wos pore wae, wn wep pa mind tt a ty on vs wars tof ey faa beet fas ge hes % * Me an ob aia Sat onal eee we feo, rar ns mate' fans rere feet 4 open ae iat poe peed M4 vaead Need 'i 7 a, tad het oA oad ot geet nat ee a we oe oo rg yes oS "3 o moe me 7% To S had "3 nes 0S ae raped, ind ends nepes, Lod eons, bea, 'el Neel "nee oon ah pes rans eee joe re We ~~ wy pes Seades wee ah wd font pay et s yee ee, CS yee one pee "not we "aS En = ie ad ia i °s Sone Rees Tones: a) Sh St eo% peas i we wo3 oe on f Hod piel 'ad pees ea Ls 3 Le ree:
4 a3 : dew 5 Meael oad pes ta m a oe, aon wa ~ Pasced pean oe us ~ ews wee wm, ae St ~ rok cod poe 4 nga, oe) Natt doce hee as er teens eos gt pon - "se ee free, te as tif pads os ; ' Wwe bo oe as ee oe vA ates wees Oe 05 Ahead . ek be, on lon ae, (% As wee, ee sent tat oat eevee pe vaeet Dod we set ny eee rte, we Monts a ee vt o Soma "no oa cro oD ra pen eaped. Faas wee Nan mnt ar Lam os, ¢ rs weer fend roo, ' cae won oS ea steed, bee eae vane oe.
aes om om hea Sanat ome a3 "hed ¥ < wk - in era Ses "Sil Ee Sy ae me BA we te et men , 4 Ok A hth th OE Eset ion BH cad & lam COC IE SC wee oo see oe ppecanr AMS ae Od mo bee4 aan oe ' ; Wi & w con a 5 hes wen es, ee BS oniey ba. 4 £y 8 be al Cos Sach : eg Sepia Loe Ca acce he & we ee - oe Ci, Tee » Sn ~ 8 e & 4 a mo wa : es SS SS aa pes a3 ie ea " 5 ee acs ue oe pes ne) a 'seine Pa pom a nd ea porn 00 oom "it ai: Sg ae eas rats u, . apes. on a pee: ya. ae ce @ es fi, ep A gee a a he oe tn od if, 0% ae pe hit ae * cea SE ve < taaet we, "ea 5 Po ag AEE OR sacar' P ae, eed me Oh me ee z : k ae ood ; 3 ore om * ae he EES age, ten ; hee ja re, on a ce @ em : Te a be a es re ce Ce me oa Fe ews a f G Sem me S ay ,% eo a a Ls os te get "oe tng "We ate % ; wee Speen: a Fo ee 4 pe a Peed pad ' * 4, oe ¥ pasa 5 wn a Tue ioe = oe EES! 2 "
x wi 2 Se we bd ; acl aS ee 2 od bases at gee col w, warns wet ¥ Ne. AK, As he ca ty.
mem: a ee pod we repees wr fe OMSL oo nom dae vee "Saad: ws we A pes Be bee oe ap oe ap a ' ee pores ad & wee * fod Py pom ee ' me cm Boo mY oa ae te are a4 a, a a es "
ta Peon ae oo " ge me Om 1 # me ee ' a we, sent RON ..
oe Pm a a es] Me om ven ng Ph keg oe ; BE ya 2 ee #3 a ees om ns 25 iain fs, ee EN om FE g Bea tae EOS, fees va a og fees. cas es. Beg Sab OE Be. he a 2 wg Fa ee vn we me ne FEO aed $ pe. -- a ee Le peed 3 om we Se ee ' 4 hes : gn Tg BEY:
a a hy Se pee psc FO a ae oe i ae i ee eee oe) 4 Roe, Sa oo ' ' a te *s " ee.
g ¢ Bee eee we Bhs game Oe Ee Pan ae ae eee ae ¢ os ' i Bm Pe (oT ae Oe Se HRI Prades Apoeal i ey wre, re, ;
i i 2 o og hi & Sy a a won oe ene nae, ed ; vi "ad seine head 7 ceed altel bakes get eit oe. ay eed fantne emcne' we pee weet Z fae 3 x es od eet yon oe pan Deed aes yore om 7 ow sok om oa SS ab om we os mo oes peed oon 'nae ional ioe 2 be ° Sane wiped: "we i eet a ho a me oot he ty et 'ae weeee. poe " pee a3 we neat on ny 2 ' ee "oat *s ie cx pos 'na ead wer het Be wt Epes of ot por. ae snes. 4 Gy patil, 'wheinh, . % fey were, fas ; : :
oc ons es J eh ge Sek g fe Bo Be He ge Bey sabi' Bene ae geno £ Fae' 3 Faces : ited veo footy fess ue heal nal er & oo cme Peat pees a ideas weg P ie ei ed a fect, ve rs, "bie sot ay wy ont DG Aeod Fae:
w On : fe Nat oe : Puen Set te. on erent vos cae z om oe air Y $ 'net See! eed my on ft eet pow baal bod wt ead Ms 2 ae - a $ vied ~ ree 4 bomed pa aad raed at bs bcd co deed boond zz gl fad esae i Se ies eal wee rel veo air rhe, At Sak veces a $ pane aes Patel "het ge Sat on " pas Nat send "a ; Yon fone bead Ceoaae' a £85 ow rhinek . om x 'ae aioand tro "
Sok oan oe ome pa es Pa oe Nee agi wheat Iberia steer Sat ed os he ~ waeet gee 0o e ot Pg pe ih dee, 4 "
ea 2 oes a oS ~ we baci ae ae Bal rm . va pack "ee a oe mat Be, o . een eon is Aye a oe here ; re a ie as ~ ohes i © ua z - ves me fa it ~ +4 ' : we oy Lew " neh oY ot a é fas wee oe bees ai ~ "3 ZS a a = , ? we at weet pon . on " aes , fee fe Cue, be hed pened, a me ard oy * srtent Q fad 3 Soa ~ 3 ; Newt twee, aye, Mae! - "and on, nooo ant ge a3 mm kee Hart ned en ney wee pot ; eee mei vee oo et toe howe # t ewe ye pen pene yey shen raen nen, 748 Sah -- ae tee an a? uM oo aks 7 nee "yee a LD yee few read pe a, oa fo, o , pet a on ad toe ae ot anne. Fad Bet : g Lr, wt tnt oa bere, wees we nal: ifs Head! ~ ae wy tA ape re 3 Bod er food ia Se nee a shee?
Sage baad , ows go Th ma nde vee, ree Le en wes, as banaed o. awe . nos aK ae, -- Renk 4 Saal mens Fees eo oa pas Do pac . tes sae a hoe aie cnet 5 5 ' eapee: oon eee 'shee gee LE ~ Saal we ud ) aon, res a oo. fi en we. 4 neat ees on Lut oe oe Poe vee: "i ha eo " Got wt ~, ees Poa oD t f pe n fs sal eon eed ee rn ae or bed, Ss Pact pan ons -- eee, " od a? ow o% Nan? gS Ae tho vee: he sat 43 fos st es Paes es oe na 'enee cs nea ee Page = Ae 'na wen. Sheet! aca a fret reek foe he vo rered. pong ra ; fet oe "eit " ; ox ries Een po. mp, tet 5 ee ae teed pee . eee ee 'ine phe aeons bees ae ow sk Pead wee, ne Ge drow! aa See Py ere. apeasl a ben 4 ao ne on pas fein, St 2 wee see vs, fon ae ~ i red, tae pee yea oa ae oo tt on oa wees wet ry i ea pee me 'a oS au he 0% a4 ad ion snoot cite as < nie coed ¥ fe ¢ gree i tat é pe rae foe. : nee pore bark yeeros die ¢ 6 x 'et hot yes noni a3 eal aoe oe tt oe " a3 i at aa er a Ke oe ete oe 4 a ft, Pa catia oe wr rn nee 2 Ata a vere Sas i howd Fag inn At ne z me can eroe na tad ee pee af shook om) tad wt peewe, 5 "ee. cad ; wr fore aad at Lp as oa aos d oe ie , ow) ay Aeet A soe tn & a pase been AS reed hand he L3 ¢ ; es ier owen "se Pe et Mees pees hese na ae ao oo sree: the ae rey as bow re oe td a3 ood ae on ue ¥ wee, an pet i rere, aA base fea renter Ph a roe as acd . og eee naiod Pood oy ad a bev. tags we es Soon pew ay or wee Spasvn get g z shy : Veco] os x As 2%, we woo, x Baar "ae wn ces ed a Cais 'ead Sane! oe ect oe eee necaee pa 43 Paes a4 een a £4 node pai teal fees oe ord he hot pacers "are ane a 3 23 o w Pe Po bn eee Sow. eae vee san Beet tet : ceed bed een ses poss boon ata, 4 po we. et ' cae eat igen ae oe at eet eat ge eran peeee:
pea we wener pees aa Ad, ae qened won, ye oad wrleet: Heed: yy t or teoe ee Bs see, RE ME aa ar et ae we ee og 0% neg Gs et Op ey Oe fe coer oa ce ee Saad Kinde abe poe ee Son it . ey ve Eo pot a penne etree eee noe & 'es a Oe rs oe, we Boe too omy ae at Sew, Pe aye, roan Set nes ne aS pon weed wm we Be baz No os ae re ous bam 5 'a oan] ote: ceed we poy heen, pore, FS, foe ee ad ' ane' Un Renneke + att aed an as wwe ton Ly a % 8. yee As De 'ta cd 43 " an Pe bok ars rere. ed ys + Lee pr wo eh, we, ey Sesh, oot re 7 we tat seat MS ert ase ae isi poo ae! aq ae Ps ona ie af pone: a igen oo," cd wen. foow eg i tons dd pes. weret on RS rte, wenk Jens. MD oe HE gs ad "ye wh "net ny es i ae OA ener wane, Rancl one eg t. sree. ue rs. pes gt, yo Peers aA perce, poe SHH.
Sy ios cl Keen, ah Te ay baad Besa hfe. St Sabin mt Ea as 'cs pea ge hs fue oy % ised 'det : a pod aes: oe Sed ised Sad ons poss t3 "3 oe Ua : -
rs " we Pas Pony ws pes Prac' a her . J teed Fags coed + pan °y aoe we hs wd te pees : ee 2 :
oF eo ve FS ¢ ca bree ae wee pe pon oe oe Ft , oa & oot mn , wa one posts Se, er A id tot fa aed Se i pend, oft wen oa th EG ee OED pees ee a otier ee pos 'ee Sonu, ee ee yer, OF ye is ' a they At eet Pike ree ry Soe gna GR EE ee un Sad cane oe or Os spon, Suse ae i a So wet Oe y Zz 'hnind, pia io tne oe pea wee oe ' ~ woes, OB , ca od Le oe ye ven eed asad png 'a? oy shred i 7 et re if aed ez, boat oe ee begeng 2Y pit rn wm, ae nee, "ae ;. ; " - a * ne gy ss Sica ee Sod aa Fe we " Sot wo io ee ce a poet - oe aa pee ee pas xe, baal pen ook "het owt, Bs ees oes eae z 53 Rees fats = toi ark gah Fa secs 4 , hee ee nee oS oe a ont ~ a nn arr ee ene Papel 'det. " ms ey PoP. coe " dood 'eet lion pen ty carne TL DS an "il on "wer ba Ee ned. cod ens eink costs Coe & Gok tok ae ae cea ae. aes Facies a na prare oe we La, cilia ae , yore "a : id bods, CS 'eat fs tee toot pan) wre . Tow put ed eet "ine : ae pan ad ge at Laee z ' poo +e "4. tn «6s OF whee, ye wee aeet eet oe pee ae raeeg bai x ie, ay OW Re EO LE Baste sen ee, eee Paes eee fen Meee ar Panel ee, tone ht nani He, Fann' © St det senaet a ca nen . Po x "ee naa g nat Poy bees pom, rat tt Creeed "a tae toe 5 ein were we on eS Nonnt Bi Se tee Writs, Pees ae peer ~ Bie wee Poaned 5 hh ' hee ang AY ie wid, . Bae Ae; Pa Pl wee ie Loy Soe 4 2 bese a3 pate waite Nene Bae " : or, aad i. a a ot 3 Un ee oe ogel ae 4 he a Su bo wens cae Sot ty bad ae Soe BA eee oe a3 oe ae a pe a; eo% ae om Bea wees pees fame) fe ony tight Pete yoo yee o's Ve yor Mewic? ees mbt oe ion yt en vom OE OR ha Net whens dete 'ot ae Beas ane eg. Fa Beard fealty re Page ree, *, 5 % '*etare bald 3 Feast ee oe es veh he ose vig? CPt ccd bai os cal ; eae' he me ' % pe hy ye ns i. oe yen tee ape ees eit as caer Tat ~ bea £3, 'pei eet "att age ims Ao a oe nes pees AY ee Poe) ses eant ge re, ve v Us PA ee cage oe 'at a 2 4 Mint hen a wor: we She on, ett LF OK omen mena. Pos fe her 'ope ee pe aad mes eet ~ - we mo Be hea pe iaee " Bw invbey, wm, ¢ Noy, pon ee, = baie Poy es Snes : pee wer oe "net fave ey ra pion ; an lon vee e an ate ver aa " deol yer St wre nen. Nene a4 my yee sd Se er io : om a steed Bid von "att lodaigs ee. 3 te aed o5 at Sates ra aan, Pa or a 9 ca, - aa oe, ed ' ret Ws aoe nea pees pa Deed Me iy eh flee, * thy 43 hd baeeens aed bones oe paaa Fs Qe wa wo wt, Sp ee aad! Sy on * how ad ss i a Mone ee aed z 3 ores, wae, wn gene re weed eS. a, hi hove te, x tas vas Sa pon when sober Ricags oa ne Fadl eet ms Poa raed ra wheat we wer "fk Reo anead Feoad jo Bex hase 'deat pans beeee. 5 See, fs ae $ ree oe 'att oy ; eae 3 pn yen E wh on oa fee 7 z wn, "ae oad pny Sea he SEM Sorte: "st Ph, ann wn pee hee ent Prod a, tah ot fee yet he et weap: we hod et a ie ie ; shoo Sue wert aa Shee op sae x tf : cae s May ' LE oan " my % $ woken ae aes pase > ied Be swtee t re tank 4 " pa 6% pee As ea cal pees Se ee As ae ny $3 z= "naga rye "Ae ran -. wy acon yin tat eee ond ¥ the Aen, oe wares, wenees Saat Re eae fis Pie] Worst a in hee, wer ae Spi Pann] aed 5 tee TE 'a, on renee, stent AK ceaacd £5) wen pera LL, weenie ~ ° os ites pian SaaS SSS rE See coca! shud Snel Teel ee Ne wh, Pe, po dant $4 gh ere Fe nee "sy ° we yo tied aa fons Reong , bes gcass a gE coer ae ; , a3 Ce nevi hoe anne nd ino Mes Tom ad ee feet 'ii Fg nee eo seed on june oe % Dad % *. wen, j ta pe Zumt wen OD 5 S @ B 2 ¢ = £ of 8 See 86 . cont ihe wn pe ~~ 4 Bead m spss . Ls om pars nese tn z 'pe, Psa We Meds to fe Kaiic yen, ese] eons 3 Pong poe oe oat oo, Se oe bes a thee es: x i mu ot a3 foo wh TE oe tee aad ea "if peor, ae Cone Be ge. Be cee A ek SR ge ES hen Sat Be eet Son, hy Se ie ge x py Oe te owen "as wee % py, nae -. ae wn = 2 eae Te ans a ws sas as ne oe ve "y te ones apes oo "stat bos oe york a Ey pretes boos as po : bet os ron hast Sod Ieee Sat pe caae $6, thee ane a ee 4 yee, ny box one ea ' we baal oy om bee es: ainene pee ane >", pa ee es doped laa pe wore on Ral thet, oles "Ss the 'it 'anes. +s ed tee a3 wheat < a f % "at .
£3 me as aot eed Pod shook tnt on a ~ aa ms fat Cd hs , coed aid : Fru a ns , yn, * as poe ? f ded. Ley Sith nine, pre Ze 4 Seance" we rs Fat ene, song A Ee EE Seat as paeee KaaeeeCSEn ST MEE EER EE coe, A oo x % pens ey, ae So ange iy a dS" cal wee goes pn ace a a ae a we pas 'st : ee pee i chron ot ae "i ase ch 4 i nas iy feat *e ye ee om, Ske rte, Ob Eos 'cmstt Aah 4 ee ORS fey "
'nl a se re a he Fale wort, COM mene we bo TRE tee ¥ oy nee Aeee: eed ¢ en wg OD Ot vol aca A vane aed pont ae were Papad whens, Peco On, errr, n = week eee Tamme Ay ig ee ae eee cecal een we OS % aint ae oS ees Pweg ee EE a a a> tee! ~ ae ae Ss , % i evi, naeed Aen Ma os we a ass weaad, Phy Sao ae [on ww ¢ CL Ain oh Taos x a a4 om Poel fa ay Rem abe "GS dee phe BL :
booed oe an own sand. ~ ae ae . es Mit aoe a rrr ca ns wood ad oN G3 Law we eat x wet 8 OR, oe pe. on ng tan 4 ifs * ya Te naman . WF ons, pa raed, a a apes Gr TE ee RE ee gee to boeead 3 a, 4 Ped ge OT Oo a ar Ot peers. o 4 yen re Poy Beene, Pet Cnn Re Sa ee ahs Sonne! fee. ee aed re gree as . a awk eo% vee ee eo we. oe pr ae os a Snot ae jee ge ape, Loe Bare Meee ng 7 a) Mere . rod eae wt 'et (sas cconed pon pies nape: sy we WE ah Sad wat nG ca eS oe ye ocd ye steed. noel Sent or wa hat eter, ek a a te ee: ween, e yee ws hts ee ar see OO Os ag ey ond aaa a5 Feo! ra} Bi 2th beet % here Pgh we aes Sat a ue mcg a en Om nr Or on" "roenit? were, oe on , a es ee aa uw os ne Sot A Ao Yer Paar vm, Petit ioe eee . sons ' ala ; east tip Med ye s o ee % cond a heey we hale, 5 oy 'hd ote Pete bat aD 4 oo ~~ tan pet vadnns, we we Pad oe, fe pet wee > hee ees, res a ; whee a ny Meine Xe Snes ae Faia aes " "hed m ow TS om OO ee nat oe me ew pet on ne ee a ay GP OR oem te OT, ed veyed ie 'ab raped gk as te el as bey ws, rs rd feet 0 a od ny owe oe nen Yet pe ven el pt ba 'od on. Sit 'mar ay there oi cash ' ¢ id x Set ' B 69 Faw oa 5 wane, whe feed, +e ams wet rads beanie ee pore : : Sd Anges 4's ; a ;
wen ea Bow 8 a ce Se jew os Ke a owen aiand oe hee ree She ass beet be «. 2 Oi kee go es eS yeree ye "
'cease i, iron ae oe een at ine, pine 7, ern, Peagl pe ~ wae oe re, feeb, By a & warns Kane o , pana coed fo et %. oye vase rn oe LE gem Be wh oes ed:
pasa we yore, Oe Pa a: pen. Yo Pai ra Sosa 'o ee, hag Sa Pars rd Rad he oad 'ens , "oe oe oy al Fear "ah a, pee, ceaaael * 4, are fF wed ca Mes Sead fe, par oA a pee on peal LORE Berry pes eneee rn nx ist oon aw; wen " noel t 2 fone holt ; oa os ~ sehen a ee jens wee 4 ' Mae fit od as endl wt fee, pon a? oem, oe mee OT Ot po el oe oes wa , 3 * at eet hee, Faeel Fr, te Qe ao r,t a maa a so ao) we ed . Ss ae a 6 a ee 0 my ney faa Bs wey de te pee FR, pene, seed, me : fied bere at os, mae Spee Lee ote Peg eit we " Aa Me YS aS et fea. Shere 2 ot oe me, ab pene, pe re rom: Pc a ee ocr Ccwny eo Me ees a ond : rete Nal gti dy are 5 wyere Ea in wee OTe"
Bb ian an ao oe oe w fore rosa . | oe " ef pn wo 63 wre fern a, LL Pa pet . ee, pe Prag. : ra) 'St 2 hoot? wn . g , vat eer -
oe pws oe Si a arn mane os aa pr De ere eee, oS Sided pa we, Baas 4 ae ho ¢ haf Sena fey, ers ae! mn Pie ye i eet Oey oo ees tony y Mart tos CS Koad eee) oe Si A a CO pal baad eo sat teed wn a PO ane gh Ory 8, ae Sal we OE, we ' and Te eh pa read 3 :
raat on we fea? os Pees a Ca 2 howd . veeen 'eae "Dd. feet wong yo 0 gee oe ae nt Ps wane On ss ' Das Tg ee eee Ms 'nde pid ree Ng Boa we Rr oe OED Eg re ge oy he vid bed a ee Gy CE ha ae on ee ONS on Pn ars SY fee . ae we a OS Se Tah a we ae ye ey tees wn 'a "et wee OO baedl ve Oh OP ae "oo ; ae ke % gor a fe Men 4, gre ad ye seal aod mens S ben free ode. Y wae, lated eee ess wer poy ree pane an, nee coaad eee ek oa capes ey tty gaan gee, eed OS oe Sot as oA Ay Gort re ea ty VR a Ra tates, Nery tated, tad aac acd ; ~ fs ps pened, £98, "at peoree foot faces wo OES a yen fae geet % 'nt asd " tee 'eet on ogee ran . 3 nn, od 4 coped ee Sond ois ie, a ; ten, wore, igrrirk ' ve a4 Joes Pane ort aac ws egos, ame 'os 2 vee toot ' pe 3 weeea" peers east et po bod pomen a ed ee x oo Neh sen ee yor ee ;
os wee FS ee a pies Sy 'ead! a Lt cnaad 7. Ss eS poh se pee: soe "
pene Sen, eae z 'shen oe ON oe oH ~ ome d aa oe Pe me -
e on eS een" a Rnd, eee, eee ce ee Peal om Ey a < aes we oe ee "
te ene wo it a ee ss on ee gore is bey Bs ., te ES oe fod d ae one Soo pa fen es oa peek Tht etme ie brand i ify det i Sb ® oe a 4s fn g ee ot Pa ;
oar Be get x oe ab he ie oe Pee fan Le oe i me cae ae ;
Aro ee d Cand ee of ened, aon oe war FS we, besa Med aif Boced a4 Wh pen pee bai oe Fen, ee Laces' ee Med, Sand aad oo a 'nee .
ss phos Sones, Cee ant Spey a TS no Pe we wes 4 aos Fares epee HOt s inary pA / om, Land , ae 3 oe ye a ' pont iw. fat phone uae + bad fen bad pan oe. oe rn if, pe et eee seen Sige baal toe fen 2 a adres:
Kaa Pa Paes sa 3 ka Le a oa ye aan cal age pa ws "ee " ay a fm Pon, oo : er] % oa a: ow o, ae mm ss " <r traged sped & tab ce
- he 2 "OSS t "a is ne ¢ yer ad Sod ea pea raeee iaraes poetin os es tik 'een os beers Me Ls pa when Soot ee ¢ ne on, % "at toe 'aot Saal ek het Took Sinn ed a. El x xe off entrusted with the nawer fo hold inquiry has jurisdiction, power and authority te reach a finding of fact ar conclusion, But that finding must be based an some evidence. Neither the technical rules of Rvidence Act nor of proof af fact ar evivience as apply fo disciplinary proceeding. When the authority accepts that evidence and conclusion receives support therefram, the disciplinary or on 'kag! senor is endtied te hold that the delinquent officer is guilty of the charge. The Court/Tribunal in its power of ludicial review does not act as appellate authority to re- appreciate the evidence and to arrive af ifs own independent findings on the evidence. The Court/Tribunal may ioterfere where the autharity held the praceedings against the delinquent officer In a manner in a manner eat with the rujes of natural justice or in violation s prescribing the mode of Inquiry or where the conclusion or finding reached by the disciplinary authority is based on no evidence. ff the emnehusion ar x finding be such as no regsanable person weld have ever Pankin , £ S:
Joe Wa:
Thus, this OA oy fa 1 Sas ary merit and S to bear their cavn casts, o fos part * * x Sceoy