H V Krishna Murthy vs M Nanjappa on 24 March, 2010

[Cites 0, Cited by 1]

Karnataka High Court

H V Krishna Murthy vs M Nanjappa on 24 March, 2010

Bench: N.Kumar, K.Govindarajulu

1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAIKA AT BANGALORE
DATED THIS THE 24" DAY OF MARCH 2010

BEFORE

THE HON'BLE MRJUSTICE  '   » A'

AND

THE I-ION'BLE MR.JUS'I'ICE K.C£AQVINi;)jiAuI{A.§IULU'».  A , [ T

REGULAR FIRST APP..:.~;5;, N03. /2005   2  "

BE'['\2VEC§r'Z%\J :
Shh' H.V.Kris1'1m1 1\/I;._::'1E'1},I.    '

A§-iﬁd ab()L.:'1: '0';'\*11's'L'7i::,. 

Son of later K.V,V'€';'j.1<_g1é.3;1p
':\?o.182._ CvH1;3':ss. 2;» ¥;:1§='§n;.si,.  
B'c11'1g21E01'e 4       .. API-'I*3Li.AN"}."

{By Sh1f.i-- ..R.S.G i1}_)T1;1'.- .i3E'11."i- I{':'{.:3i12;1(.iri. Zulfi. Adv0(',a1i@s)

 »

1 . Sh 1-".1  ..l\§ f311"jri{}' .21 'Q 
S /5;') late. 71'"%Téc;).i.i<21'z1.
1C')(%zi:r'l 1.5-_\,;* §<~g;:1t i'('Dl"{,'.S('Ti112-l1§\:'(i':~5

 H "{3} __ Sn]  1..2=11<s;h m 2111 1 1 ma.
 W/0 late M.Nanjappa

fb) Sm1,.AI<.1<a11'1m21.
if)/:1) lair M.N;.1r1_j;;:p§.>z1' _
V



. - V2.i1'--t1;11i»1":§Iobli.

L.)

[<:'} Sh 11 J :1y1';.: 111,
8/0 hue M.N211'1_1z1pp;.1.

[{1} S1'11%..C11211'1('l1':'111111m.
[)/0 Ian; :\/1.§\Jz111_j:1pp:1.

[C] Sri ML111iswa111y.
S/0 late M.Na11japp~£1.

[E] Smt.ChikE<zu11L.1niyL»1111111a.
D/0 late M.N;11'1j;1ppa

[g] S1111' ML111i1'21j11.
S/0 late M.N211'1j2113;3a=; 

{h} E\/1Lmivec*.r:1pp21._ 
S/0 late M.NL1l"1'jé'11')1.I)L1'_...  _ 

A_11;'11'c: 1'c'sid1'11§:E 213-':  .     _  
Mu}'111t'1{()1E11L1 \g"f1izi.g¢}=-v-*"* V V.  "
Va:'t:hu1' Hobli.  "

B2111g;1l01'e~ E33 $9.1" j 'F;:1}1.1 I{i.I;, s .

2. Shri Néagz-L'1'e1ja.:  
8/ 0 1:11.26 'Y (#1121 S'e1':1'y V.
Agccl «_mm:.'45'2~,_ye:>1
ResiAdi--ng at. N€.)_.1'§~77/2._ '.
R2'1.»:":..;;1g(:)'1~'1(12111 'C1 1'1";':.1 1i .

 

~ B21t_1gz1_1()17f;' 'E'1ZV2"'1".k':-.1 "1'2'11uk.

I  B'j§1;1gA:1.V}f;1j¢." V

3. S'n_1fi C.{,3:)15a;.ié;i.
801% u§""1;1I.(*(71111111z.:s:\v;.1my.
Agcii ";1_1:)r}; L 1% 4-? }~'("t1I'$s.
"R5:-:5.aj iC§€'lH1' 1. 0 1' R&1I'I1'c1g()1"1d 2.1I'1a-1hz=,11 ii .

 _ "\5Y_£1}'ﬁ1t1I' l---iobli,

'Av-Bba;*igaIo1'e Ea.s:1 Taluk.
E:3z11'1g21Ior<* V 560 066.



4" ShriS.K.1'is111':z11"1'1L1ri11y.

;'\gc(i z1b011£'. 45 3-'cz=11':-5.

S011 0fS}11'i S.E5er1112'1(*}"1;.111'1y.
R('.SS'l(.'lil'1\£_{ :11 No. 1(.)".2{:3.

111 Main. 1.) I::310(*.l<. AI:lCS3 1.e"1_v<)1.11..
KL,111€l211z:h;-1111.

E:3a-11'1g2:L1()1'(r -- 560037.

5. Shri }}3hopa:11 Redciy.
/\g(?cl z1b0L.11' 37 ye2':11's,
8011 of 12110 ij).Ra1m1(:tl1z-1Lzdm Recldy.   *
I'"\'es;ic'li1"1§,_;" 2:1. 1"1(').665. 
I1"1di1'&.1l'i£EL{___{'¢11' I Stage,
BE1I1g2l10I'€ ~» 560 038.

6. Shri N.1\/1:11'iye.xpp2,:.

1\g1%cl album 52 ye-;tz11's. A .

Son 0? S1"11'i M.N2'11:_§;.;11')}'.);z.:,_  V V
No.23. 1-:I1ksl'11'1111':a1"aya-:11zi13L:'ra.}'  }
K1.:1'1da12:1ha11i GEfi1.§?. ." vv
I\/Ia1'.21{ha11i I-30s1I._  __ I  _  -  '
E3z11'1gai01'e # 550 Q:-'a'7.      '--I'<.E§vSI?ON§i)££N'lS

[By Shri S-;a1'1'c;l' S .s'-'xv'ss,:f.)'c:i4£1:1.(§s§;--.AL}--vO<ia1'es. Ibr R~1.
Sh ri E--1."v': P'r2g1\re'-;=.1V'V1 §;.Q'wc1 §'c>r='R-5.
Shri TN.Ra1gI'n,_1pz;1Ely, J-\(:l.v(;t_j;L_.i;:e'. for R4}

.f'{T?}:'1is "i3c=.§gL.1izi1'" =.1?i1'51 [xppea.1  ﬁled L1l'1(lC'.l" SL'('li('J1"1 96 of

  (:'c)(T1&0">s)§"' C.'§'i~x.ril"~- P1'c)c'c-:di1'I"{i E908 21g;-1.i1'1$t' %1'1c;=. _juc1gme1'11. and
'ﬁd('3'C_'.1V"L'f'€'CL-?3..1,€('1 --'..3:'§3.20()3 passseci in ().S.1\?0.1883/2002 on the

ﬁ1.g--: bV[«',1.V¥1-1*AdtE«i§.i"(j;.1'1211 City Civil JL1dge, Ba1'1ga1(:)1'(~: CCEI no.8
dismig.g;i1'7.§§ 3',}.f§V'(?"SV'L}i1. 1'01' s1)e(%i§'"ic: p<--:1'f01'1T11z11'1cc>:.

'4lW3'1i.'-§'  ;".':'1'31')a'%:.-21 rc01'1"1i1'1;; on 1'01' l'1(:2;11'i1'1;_-§ this (1:13-'.

 -'44__l\'»*KUMAk'?,.t':",J (iL*li\.=<-?1'(:Cl i..l'1c-* i'()1l()\Jvi1'1é{ :»



J U D G M E N T

'§'his is; 2.1 pl;'1i11I.i!'l'.~s 2l})j.)(:'z-.11 £'1;.{2.1i115'%% Hlc' _j11:1;__;1':1c=~111...:1»m'(1T._V dcctree of" the Lrial ::<n.11'L._ \-\-'l'1i(',l'1 1'1z1e; c:lis111is:s::c'l 11is3§ §§t.z'i--«i..'_'£71.91" ;. spectific pe1'E'01'ma1'1.Ce 0! the :1g1*ee:11e1'1l. of $2110.

2. F 01" aha pu1'p0sLr of (30II'1\'C1'1i€'1.](?C? 'the '1':>g11"l~i,g;*..<ja§ 21.1:'c._. 1'eE'c1*1'c:c1 to as 1',1'1e_\; am 1'efc:I'1'r;>c1 to in {T118 <)1'ig,i1:_1a'1 .5u"i1,.

3. T116. s:::§3_j(:(.:1_ :11z:'i.1._c"1'=._ of .iVh<-:1 Sim. .a',:i.§'~--p1'u;')c%1'1:y 1:)e211'i1'1g.; su1'\.»'c=-ry 1'1o.«'iLO._ §V1L..}11(','Vk()1z--.-1121 \ j'i_i}';1.gci-.. _V¢}r1,l'i'a.1£;'~E;0_l1i--ii. I-32-1114'-L{z':ir\>1'c' South Taluli. m;:'as{f;;1'.it'1g 21é:.:1'{éS AgL1..i1%,2'a__s_;,: bouncled within the b(m11cl211'i(;§:3_V IT1~§'f'V1..'.i(f)I'1u€1?f'} 4i1"1'-'.':1"§i1(L""E312-1iI'H é;(rhec111l<;*. 1']€'1'€i1"1'c1f'1'.L",I' 1'ef€1'1'cc1 to as 'f1,1;it _:5<:1jE:{iA1ziv; >1'Z'J¥'_L')13_(',1'1.:x_~'". '1'1'1c: 'i':.;_1.éc%_ Qiﬂ ihé H1')--1.;_1.i1':{IiI'f is t;11a1. the c§t:i'€:;'1<:'1z1n¥;' 2-;x1)p1*c)ag-1rc<_1 1.11:.-3. v§f)'1£VEi1'1"§i1'[ l.()$5611 élw .<%('f%'1c-*::ix:lc.* p1'<">p<:1'1.y emcl 1 1v]"c"L.1 1.Tt". pi'ovi(.itrcl 113$' <>i.1'1e1' p1'(>1._)c>.1"§'.ic.s; to his (._'11i1C'11'('I1 2'21. 2-1 ps211'f:1.1_;i<>1'i.. W.T1'}"1iS'[~.v1§iro}>e1'1',}/ }<1a\r§1'1g {$111011 to his S11£1I'(;_'. the (:iL:["(=rn':'.1_z-11']1..~<">1'i:"gi--1'E:n.l to 5.sc"H 1.l"1::* ss(?l1t'(l1.1k' ;'>1'opc:*1'€y for ex '4".ﬂit)nsic.ie1;i';x!'V1A§)1"1 of Rs"s.5.75'OO{}/-. A :'js1.1:1': 91' R5. 2.50.000/-- ' .;)2;f1:§'(i on 12.6. 1989 13y the pla1i1'1l.i§"f'1.<) the c1efe)1'1c1z;11:11. On ,9.3_f I 992. 2.211 ;1_g1'('3%c':.:11c1:1 01' s:;2.zi<>. c";'11'nc 10 bv CX('.(?1.11..{"'.Ci. A .<'sL1r:1 M4 3 of Rs.3.0().()OO/-- wz'1s'a. §}z;1i{'1 2155 ti.11't1'101" z\.cT1\'z:1"1(:<>. 'i'1'1L1s. L111('1(:1' !;.1"1c 2=\.}'_-'{1"<_*(?1'T1'1(;'11t 01' sz1§c._ £§'1c (1cfc11(.i;-11']! a(:k1'1c'}\x'ic-rdg2;c(i Lila"

1'cC?€ipt of Rs;/é.5O.0O[')/V. '1"}"1c, sai(1 saale was sL:i)}crC1 1.0 1.'1'1--<; conc.1iti<>n thai. the c1efe11c1z111l would <*.iear the dispuLe_;)¢1'1.c1ui'12g. in 1'('.1-7$[I)C{".I of the E-.~3(?}'1€CEii1t:' p1'01)c1'ty , i.1__:1 f*c:,z"t§i:s;* 11().KSC/S'1'/44/EH on the fiic of the if-1'1';«i "C~(')I"1'1;1'11.iVf§'f§.i_()1'iC?'ié;"

Ba11ga10re SL.1b--Div1'sim'1. I3211'1ga1o1fe. 'I'h'e_réi3Q1'c. t.11'c_-1fe"u:z=es V1--V16~._ V' st1'pu1a1i011 of 1.i1'1'1cé in 1.h(-1 ss211"c'1-«_ V;£':'£5§I't:'t?.I1'1'L'-1".11V. r,(;)f' ; ssV2.:x1CV T01' (:to1'11p§01:i<')1'1 of I'm' 1.1";-'11'1E€2.':(.'.1i'i.}',1. §')1;.':'1*'i'1ig:H16"51.;%)sis%i.£'-'neeVof the--' saicl agrce111011't.. the dc£'<:%1'1(ia1'11_. '1'ec1--:2:C.s1c{.i 'i-.1f1'c. f.)1:;1i111.if'f to pay the bale-1nCe 52113..(:-'>13si.de1i;1li.c;11_:.£')f'-.Rs;. }.._25,C%G0/--. On s1,.1cr1'1 1'eqL1es1, tihe 1:_)1§iAiAV1'15'(:.iv§V'I'_&1.>;i.ic1 ~ on 12.9.1994. Thus the c1cf(*.11(iz'mV1 1'L)'('(_"I~.~',L::?(V1' =é1<1\(V)'i'.:1__I" "(:<J'i'1sic1(:1'21tion of Rs.E3.75,000/ V a.1g1"c;'c.(§ .=:_.m(1(r1' V1i='.1,<:*2.1g1'cC11'1c}111 of saiv 21l'1('1 he 111ac.1c' am <: 1'Ic1'Q1'S€r11é'1'11 ui;.r:.f01'c the \\»'i11'1<'::ss<3:1a 1.0 the sai(.§ (:£'£'c<tt.. The (Ale-..fe1i1._Tci12_:1T"1L. 2z_1sti: "}~'1V21_',1:~1(1«;i-'(*1 <)\-'91" 1'1'1c \-'£1('T£.1I']l §')<'>sss~tL.é5;;<;i()11 of H10. :-'»(.'i1(?(.§~-:._1_{ti' [_11't"\;))n(:':".i1'1A 140 1110 pie.-1.i111'1'['I'. A On receipt': of the emire sake c013sideraLi0r1._ the '- fp§21f:1'1£ii'I' in pe2;1<:e1':.1i §)(')SS€SSiOI1 amd <:1:T1'j(.)_V:1'1<:111 of the "".VEf-§;{V'I'{"'1L;',C1L.1§.t', ;)rope1'ty eve,1' si1'1(:€ 12.9.1994, '1'i'1c-: c1c:f"m1(.iz:1r'1l K/. .

H) paid 11.11;,-' z11"11o11111 11:' i1ci1'1;{ in p('>+.+..~ac-*>a:sic'>1'1 111' ihc ss<':l'11:c'i21§L=* p1'<)1:)c=1'1.y CX('.{_'.[l}1 2'1 c1)111cc,11*1.cd ag1'cc1'11c?11t. §J;1s;c(.1 011 whi(r1'1 the above suit is ﬁieci. W"1r1c:n the p121in11'1"f' got. isstmd £1 11:gz1.l Imltice. it 11:15 §)1='*.1*1'1 s1111_:'1bEy 1"ep£icé(i. '1'he1'(: is 1:10 c'r'..11.1sL_*~~.__(')I"

av1'1'c1111 for the suit. 111 {.110 total ext.C1"11 0152 a1(:1:'es 8 g1111'.":1'1V..~fs';-E-'1":1V1j CX1'.c1'1'1 of 12 gu11'i.z1S was 1.2-2k.c11 over by the G0v@:i1'1i'1'11-int'$151' f01'111al.i011 of 11111:' 1'0a1(1. in the 1'c.'111:=1'1'1'1'i1--'.-;;>j' gﬂ1.11"ii..z-1:3' '1v¥.'}:i;:.' c1c1'c-;*11d;.11'11 11z.1:'s §_{1.)l 0:1§_\-1' 1'ig£'11 {(1 2111 2{.'XIC',I'1Iz (:)I"E--1)1vES -_;'111111,<71 '1'l1<--:ref()rL=-?. he Sought. for dis1'nisSai..__df'~.1he \.v"1'i1'_1cs1'1V $1.-VE'1I'VL'.1_'1V"1'"<'_'i'I1'I~'..

7. Aiier the 1')1"a1.3f&%1r we-1S_ Vzi'11'1u.11Ci~--:;t.d. he fi§1':(i an acf1diLi<)1'1z11 \-witteli s1'.a11.e111eV1'_11"dcxiying t'11c":i'§'a1,_i:.11 for money. x-vh§C.1'1 isV"-1112'-me.»i11"£,Vh~r:j h1;',hV1h'1--1:}1V."Q- 111' 11213 111530 1'11isec1 sex-'c1*a1 c1)r1te1'11.'101'1san-:ii'1c-.;'e.1i.i1;1g3111::";§111cga11ic_111s 1"1121ci1.* in Hit'. c>z11'£i€1'

--'v.[)a11'a1v»21~i1{t1 :.%'m.,1g1'1i £'(31'.§1is1}'1is;$a1E ()ft'h1: 51.111. O11 U16' 1-1f1'11'cs2-1i£1 "._;)}(:*;1C.§i11'gjss, 111116' ..1i1"i.;'1__§ (.'m11'i 1'12;-11-; I'1"1'1111c;*.cl i}"1r;:% [k"1l1<'>\vi11g 185111"-TSZ .'---71.. V"§J'.1'~1..L>1'i;:1Ev1' ihc pl;-,1§1'1i.i1'[' ;')1'<)\-'cw; 1111-11 the db1'e111«_§i2§11'-11;)"/151$ z1g1'eec1 to SEEM the $1.111. p1'01')e1'1:y for £1 \?a1__1:§z1b1e c.*1.msi(1er211,io1"1 of Rs.5.75.O{)O/--a1'1c1 V1"L:'"t1"€Ti\-'(?('§ 1111 1«.1dv1;11"s(1re. z1:'110=..:1'11' of Rs.'1.:':30,0{)O/~ on

15.

2. WlT1cll'1c1' 111:.' 1)l;.Li111.1'1"[' is c1'11i1.1c:(1 for 111:: 1'c*i1111(l of R&;.5.75.{}()0/~ al.01T1g \vi.111 i11i.e1"L>si all {he mL@ of 18% 1.3.3.. f1'0111 9.3.1992 in th(;é a*.111'.c1'1'1z'11Eve?"

8. In Fil..1]_)1')O1'1 01' 1T1is:+ ('@111-e111'i<)11. the ].')lzLi]'11'i[T'QXEX}"I.iVVi.li§{:1. himself as PW ~1 2-11"1d 1'10 11213 also ex:-1r11i1'1ed 3 witnc-28805 {.0 {the ag1'ce111t*1"1l' 0['s21lC 2.1.1:id §?'\Vs -- '.2 e'11"1('1 13 and p1"<')(1L.1ccL1 i"o.L_}1" clO'm1"1'i=1L-'111:3.. --'9;vl:ivi'a1l«'1 111a1'1<0c1 2.1.5.4 I£xsa.I'--1 to 1'--4. On Q1' llfc.vdﬂfEgi1(:l;.i';§1L.Hthe dcl"er1c1am was; <:xa11T11i1'1c('1' 11'11'('.L"

Wi{1'1CSSQ'.S I)W.c_;; ~ 10 4 g}_1']_€i docL.11'1'1c1'1t.S. \UhiC1'1 are 111a1'§<:«;§d 'Ex-E~f-_.I');1*"1".<> "I;)A- 13;a._fIf]§1e trial c:01.11'L on app1'e:%('tiz.-M011,0?" 1V.1V1(3-9,2tfo1'c_*§5':ivi('ln'na1'z,;1 -'a1'1('1 d0a':tL1 I1'1Cl'11'E.ll'_V cvide1'1cc-2 on 1'c<'o1"<:l. 1'l"c'.14(i"1'1'I£'1VVi'.' 11"5i¢ 1'1l;i'i'--1..)i.'il'I" 111.154 l';.1i1c:c1 1'0 1.>1'o\-'c- 11'1;-1l l'11t.* ci(:1"¢':1'1§1§.L1"i1 'z'«,i.f.___;1"t-3(.'Ei-._1"(.)V ssclll 1.116 Sui! sc'11cdL11(=: 1'J1'();)c1'1'y for 2:

'~.v;,1l1m_.li)i(* {:911:3idg:1';-11io1'1 oi' Rs.Fi.75.(T}{)(}/~~ mlcl 1'c<*ci\4'c-_~.c"l an

2.-1L'c:x¢§;1*i'1;;:..§ é--1.'1{-i'o,1V_111A1.'_'o'fR+s.1..Z3{).(){}O/-- 011 1:2.£«Ts.1s.3sss:3. I*1.1r111c1'11c _ 1"21i1<-3ci""1'() 1.".-a'1.'c')*\~*.'T%"V'€..i1z11 '§'.hc2 def(':1'1da11t. exccr.z.11.c(1 the a1g1'ee1'1'1c1'11 of &§é'111.i'?{--(.§£l1L?d" 9.3.1982 by ]'('(',C'i\-']'I'1§'.-§ l'1.11'1.1:1c=-,*.I" acf1vz'L1'1cc '<--L1'11OL1111 of

-_I:{S1,V3'E;a{1<1T'1s. E3i.111i1£11'ly. the 1.31air'11ifi' ['12-IS Failcécil 1'0 cs1;1b1is1'1 his "0:-'1--sc?. 1'112.1t he 11:-Ld p211'c'i h21§21.1'1cc 55'-1E'.t1t.'. co1'1sic1(*1'a1'.i011 of X 1111* 1"@1i(*1" 01' s.;])c-=1ri1'i1'.' p1'1'1'<)1'111211'11%(- as %.1'1c-* 1)1a1i1'11i1"1' 1'1.11:s ].)z1i(1 1'1. 31.1111 c')1"Rs.5.75.0()()/-- 1111c1Cr the 2-1g1"1:L%1}'1cr1'11.. he 1":111'.11.1cc1 1,0 21 C1t'(.'I"£'"?L"'. for the S€.1iC1 a"111'101.11111. with i111crc>s1 and 1.1'1c*.1'1-:I'()1'c,-"111:

1:}1'e1yC{1 101' 2.111 <.>1'c11*.1" 1.LC<t<21'(.1111g1y.

10. S1111 KG .Sac1ash1'\«'aia1'1.. 1€aI'I'1CC1, ' "v.C(')'1.1i'1S(?i a11}pea1*ing for the p1ai.1.1'[:i1"1' s1.1br11i1;1C(§ 111;.11 «-11.11;? '1p11z1i_11'ii1'1'..V_ 101'.z111y 1-1 s1.1";='111g1*1' 1.0 1111:'. (1c1b1'1c111:').1.. '1'1"1'<«?Ac'l'e11-*1':(1;'1,1-11..1i'2;1$§ 1201."

€111.e1*c(§ 111110 a.11'1_v 1..1"a1r1.sz11"iic)1'1 \-11.-'11,11V'V1"1»13\E'}'31z1i111'i~11 117-1j1s not 1'GC€1VC£1 21.1151 C(.)1'1s3ic1crI*211'io11"=:}s $161". 0111, 1f11"..1:1'113 1-9111111111.. '1'h<-3 def(~:11c1ar11. has not exeC1.11.c-:€1 a'1'1y :-1g'1~<-ic:11:~1e»1'i'1.--'.is.{'_ 1113 112155 not C1C11\'€i'C(1'v {'}15S.S€S.'5"1]."2.U-11d€1""'1v11.{J§3€ Ci1"1'*1,.11ns1.;.1macs, the 1'i11d1'1'1g 1'Q1'?.()1'C'1t'(1'1')yV'1l1"1£f 111711:1111'~,§.'V1'§"L11"11 111211 1.l"11"-. 11g1'1*c>111;<:1'11' 1101 ..)1'(.)vec1 is 1'3;-1s$1zd 1:11 10.01111.c¥vi{11.E'111':e 2.-11"1c§ does 1101. (35111 101' LUIV .V <5' . -1 *1111C111?1'5'.;1'}(.:1E'. 1Z\?C1*1.,V_ (}113t'1'W1SL'. 111* 1"?()I'11.C.'I'}.(11"'(1 1112.11 1.119 1'C1(";'t:1:1(1E.1Vl'11»V1V')!f1(11'1g5'$_ 11': 1111' ."51'l'1c~.c11.111~(1 (.7;1:s11?. T111-1 1;;11"1<'1 in c111cs31'i1>11 '2;-1--'V.g1'2'1'1i=11.61:1 1z.m{1 z'11'1d the $2110 01' ..s1,11'1'1 §;1*a11'11.cd lamd 'wi1'.110L11. .111'? pe1*r11issi01'1 of the co1.11"1'. 2.1f'1.e1" 1.111% ('.()I1'111'1g 1:110 11:1'c?1r' :91' 1.111? $21111 Am, 1-15; 1'1c1c:1 by this 1-01111. 153 zwofcl (.119 1Ii.i.I1() *--.1.i.1I3Cf1V(.1()1CS not. call for e'1ny i111.c:1"§e1'c%1'11t(?. 16 ll. '1"l1c }c.z1:'11cd C(..m11.~:c1 11):' the i11'1plca1(li1'1§..{ a}:)p1ic:z11'11.s. the ::3L1b$0.qL1c.1'11. pL11'(".l'1dSCI'S sL.1})}')o1'1cd {the a1'g_:L1rI1e11t. 0%' the. 1e211'11c?d Counsel for the p1a.intiI'1' zmd ('.()1"1[(;11CI1(:.'d 1h:.11 110 ('z'L::~:0 is :11a;1(7§c out to i1'1tc1'l'crc* \-\'i[.}'1,'[.':-~1L". _jl.iC}f._§I'11t'.I1§'l a1'1d C1CC1'(;'€.

12. En the liglll. of the E-'11'(_)i"L'E-'.£.Li§:1" £'z1(:{:~;_-a'L1'xd...:l:!:,1L?"=1'}i\:.£;1 ('('):'1':.t-r111'1'01'1.=-:.. the 1')(.>i:"1l.:; ihal z11':'$e !'(.)1"».:(.)L1!"~!_'§.§'1'1f';'iCiflfé--U'-i(')1'1 £3._1't?'~:.;,. as zmder:

1. \?v"i'1€{}1c:1' the p1a1i11[.i1'f 1'1El;~>}'31V:i(»)'v'.(":V{j c=>;é:§('tL1I.iu)11 01' the a1g:'ee1'z1em .. I «E ' WV

2. Whether Lhc p1ai.1:11Vi.t'f--,hé_% payment of *Rs.'~1 ' G. 1989. R.s.:3.()o.0o() /_ an ()1--1 12'9_1994_ in d§1'_ 1 :.~;x.;_1a1 Q51" :--é$;VV.V_§1f_7j:i5.000?

].:)1z1i1"1l'il"§' is tfiliillt-_'(I In 111:'. (§c<rx'(;rL' for V' '1V;e.1"I'()1'1'1'1z-.21T1(:=e'?

the p121i11Li}'1' is <:1'1ti{'1ed to refu1'1d 0? {he a.1'm.)um. pa-1i{1 undcl' {he '¢11§{:?g(':'C'1 E{§.§1'L?E?I1'1&?I"1l. of .~"'sa1e'? W1'1z1{. (">111 01""?

7')

14. The 1)l2:1i11[.itT an e:'111.')ic)yt:0 in Life I:'1s11:'2:1:'1cc Cc')r1..>01"a1i011 QfI11(li2-1. His \\«'i1'c also c1'np10_v0c.l. N0 1'n2,1te1'ial is 1)1ac'e(:1 011 1'c*<?o1'c.1 to .~;l':o\\-' I'hei.1" f:'1'12.1:'1ciz11 <:a1pe1('ti1.y 6.2.-'u'1iC;'_._I,o raise sL1.c'h llugc ;111'1<..m1'1t a1'1d if 1':-tally 110 ci()<h:1.111:c:1'1tssj p1'oduc:e.cl to show the s'a01.11'(:(? of H16' semi iI1C'()1"1'1C~. ':"1['_1"Ci".:1"]y pay:11o111'.s z-111"' 1"1"1z1<ic> as (1c1)0:sr:=(1. it _i;:+»v1;l'1:'r l].'()1'l"[v1£"-1}.V:»}»"E1lVi'11V§-ii'} ('.0I'1C§Ll(.'[ 1.0 Lalie-? I'ti'(.'€,'.i]JI cs;1.)ec:ia11y \{*1'j1m7..=_ATihst:'~});A'i3.5}i1::11i.'L%"--§Sw7?.A made when i.11c1'€ was no a1g:'eeh1e1"iI.~..;11' ;'11l'.'"11'11.1C :;.111Q_LV,1:*1~.1..h&1d been kept" in any bank. 2-1_.s;I'ate111e.1i11jof 3.(_:(IO1.11'1f,'S1'1(.)L1v15 hax-*6:

been proved that the ;')l21ih"1*if'1'T -2.11h0um.. If the z1moLm1. }>xa1d~ b_C':(:':l'1 E5i:;'r".:')\&*4}ci=.f1'(>1T1~~»:--3,133' ()1.l'1€31" .<;(.)11:"('*.c.ss. :+301'11e ex-*ic:l<-:1'1(::c' '&:1'1(.5a:lci' iiéix.-{{'.._l:5er-?1i=:sh'm\*t1 10 1_)r()vc.~ the 5-;1i<i Ehct. A su1'1'1 of I'{S.5.'7:5.UOO/< in._1.I'14;=.._§'c%211' 1992 1101. 22-': s11'1;.111 z111"1(>Lm¥;'.

-'v.1}'1e-11.V_'1k§.§) Vihr :1 sz.1"1é;-r17i.¥._T3__«Q<311':1')1()yct". '§'l'1(_*:'<' is ;1}"):~;0l1h11(:l~v no V'.§?\'-"'iC,,1C?"i".l.(V'.(.' »V_ei'c1<'i':.,1€"u::l to .~';h0w 1'ha".11'. lhc .=521i(l 2m1(n11'1i. we-1:; 21v;1'i}e1h}L* \.\?i1:"h-. the pkaimiff 2111:} the said zmmunt. 11233 been 'paid 1;-;.%1f'1u_«¢: Vc.lc§ct1'1d211'"§1 amt} thus he has paid ent'.i1'c: sale .. V(:o1A51sTi-;*'l_ée1'ai i()1"1. " XV I Q 'J1

37. Agairl in the C'dSLI' 01' 'AJIT SAVANT MAJAGVAI US.

STATE OF KARNATAKA' 1'cp()1'1ec§ in 1997 [7] SCC 1 10, Age): Courl i'1;1s held than s;cc1.i01'1 73 of tho 1872. does not sspecrify by whom the ('rm1'11)211"i$;giﬁ'-.512:-:1A_§'1: T' n'1z1c1e. I--I(.)\vc*\»'c1'. lc)<)1<§1"15_;" i:T1%'0 {he ()1l'1(_r:{§ £1 is 010211" ($12.11 ssmtll ('.0:a11')2.11'i5c)i'V1V _'\:1;2)/ ('._iU"1:.T¥' be/' \lV1".1g'<A1:C'§'t' ' ha1T1<iw1'it.i11g c'?Xpc1'1 Lmclcr S(;'.('.I'i()l":'V"*««I#ﬁ.1§:V:")'.(')I' lav'=aﬁ'1y.r)ﬁt?xi'::MV2Vili£11' with the ha1I'1d\v1'i.t.i11g of {'tVV1V:'1'1.(;:§'{1 '§_j';'-0\:«A;' C:1@(1 by secL§()1'1 47 or by 111:: ('.()L1i"1' of ext.1'en1e caL1t.ior1 2-mci riot. nornuilly 1.211<.e upon 1.11:3 c1§spL.i%.cd sig1'12111.11'cV§§._« 'wL§1h . z1c'I111ii.1,Cd sig1'1a1'a.ire or hz.-11'1(;§\v1*i1.é1'1gT; 'zi-u:_1 cl.in' .E_.1T1L:_ of 1119 s§ig§':i.crs1. c1(mE:)1., L110 "v.1'}'2;;11.ELji"5'is viii 1.11:: lcfﬁ"-viu__1__§_);'? \-x=%s.a(.'1()2:1 01' c*x1..w1':s. {$111 lE1i..~'; ('§()L':'F;

-1:10?", i'1T:c:e1:'1_ "t11a.I,V '"'21__1e (.:o1.11"§'. has no p0\vcé:" to compzlrt: the dispL1.t.'<a~C1 si'g.g£i;;.t.{::fe with thzlt. of the 21d1m't;t.ed sigr1a1z.11'e as 1,hi9 I3(,)x\'«'7.E51"~" (*,1L::a1'1,'>" E-1\';'1i1E.i1'.)l(-Y. l111d('Z'1' :[email protected]'E'.i(')z'1 73 of the f~\('t'. £53. In the Sight 0E'1,1'u=. afar:-zszixid e11L111ciz1£,i0;2 of law by "--_the5ApeX (1<>L11'§:. it is 110 be seen in this (12180. no1_hir1;g " 2 11'1c:

31.1

1)1'c\-'c=111,c(1 1.111.' 1:)1;.1i1'1£11'1' 1'1'1..1111 1"1111'1_;;' SE-lid .':.':[)1.}11(f£.11.i()1'1 1;)c1'01'e 1111* 1111-11 ("0111'£.. 111z.1\»'i1'1g 111.11 1'i1cc'1 1116 811111 e"1pp111"a11.1o1"1. 1'11' 1'::'11'11'1111.

111111 12-11111 \\.»'i1'11 1.111-1 11"1;11 ('11111'1.. 11' 1111;' 1:01.11'? xx-21.5 ('o11\='i11(1'1~(1 110111 1.111.' o1'2==11 e.\»'i(11=-211m? a1«:1<'1111.:ctc:1 011 1'C("()1'(.1 111511 1111.' 1:xe('t11.1.1{->11 01' 1111: z1§£1'Cc1'1'1c1'11 is 1101 C512-1b1iS1'11;!f1. 11 112155 1'i.'_?111.1_\-' is 110 q1.1c&s11t.11"1 01' 1jt1.)11'1pa.11'1.~";1111 01' ("11s;p111'.1':('1 .<a1;§1'1;11111\x_V\.vi1'1'1». 17111"

z1c':11'1111,1'('('1 .=;i_<___1;_11a'11111'1":s"»'. '1'"'11c.* 111.1¢3s1i1.111:"()1" ;1'1'1<1w'1.115.__§~;':11.1(1«i1.i1111*z.1'1 ex-'1dc11cc;'. 111 e-11'>pc11z11'c> ('Q1111 wg)1.11{.1 a1v1j1sc_ <11'11_v »w1'1»c1'.~. 1;1_'1(:--, 1 21ppe112.11'c L.'01.11'1. 1:; 1111211311' 110 111'01111.1*1.11'11+£* 1.116' ;¥11{1g.;j11_"'1_.1r11"1V 011" 1.1111 1'11211.€1'1;;11 ax-u111;113E1=: 011 1'e.C<;1'*c1..,_ 19x"1"111'-:5.1.1§j. i1'1*ii31'1.e1-1.1S1.z;11'11'1':;1s.e';: as 1'ig1'11.1y 1'1e1(.1 13}-' 1.11:'. 111211 001111. "1.1'1c' C1-'1.{f1"c:.1'11%&'j "1~1.1_""11'W's.iZ LIEIC1 3 (.111 1101' 1'cp(1se (to1'111<1e11L:e 2'111--r:1 1,1i1<*1'1'.cx*i§1i--t1'1z1:§3 do 1101' j.)1'0\-'C (31111? e.\'ccL.1£'1111"1 1'11"

':j1'1.'1j"_1':"11r:'11 01;""i~;i:1..11"f".33}-' 1111': (.11"1'<'11(1;-11'1l. S11'1111;11'1_\:'. 1111* V'..1';"ViV(f1'(,'T11(V'f(?'y_131'1'%._1"CT'1T,O1'C1 ("10 1101. c;%5:+1e11:.)1i$1'1 1'1);-13,-11111-=11?' of any

1.:01'1s31f.11§1';'11.1o1.'1: -.111: 1 he 551111: .

1 .21). \-V6 1'1a:1v1.: (>o1'111.:1z;11'c'c:1 1111'? (11:s1..)L111'%c1 ss1g}§1'1a.1.11..11"c 1-V1111'; 1.110 '.1-'a1(.1';':11111<:11 s'sig,_{1'1a;111.11"1'ss 10 111'1e11<1*. 31.11%: w1'1c'.1'1'11.*.1" 2.1 ('.&1f'~5(i 101' >'c;r1*;'11i11.11"1n>' 2'11.'111i1'1o11;.11 1'\-*1('11*1"11"1'? 1.2; 11111111' 0111 1.):-31'<)1'1* 1111:"; 1:01.111. .V ha 3 1 p:1yn'1e1'T1E should llzwc been cS12113}isl"1ed by :=1(:(*epI.z-1b1e? t§\rid<:1'1<..'c bei'01'c the £:'(':mr1.

27. For the ree'1.<3<)ns af0res211'c1. we are s21i.is1'1'ed the p121i1'11i.E'1' has failed to €'S1..i:ib}iSh ;);.1.3_,.~111t;71'11' 01' a-1113: 1_)()1'Li,_() 1'}c)I"

Rss.E3._75.()O(}/--. C.)11c'tc z:g;1'c-*c1'11e'11I is l'wl(l [0 be not :"["l:"L'14'C;Ji§_i:iC¥ the abst-:11ce of any 1'<;r(':£9ipt being taken in p1'(_J0.1f.13a3Qfi'1T1g {he said z1m01.1r1i, and in the a-1'0sCn(':e offzlny_;1i21t.éria%} <')z1_ 41"cVL".(V_)1"VC'1_t:.()' Sh()W t".11a.1. 1,11:-3 p1a1'1'1Lifi' xw-15; i;1_1)0s5Sc..s3sIm1 OI_ vl":~'E'A;? &.-if(}1'E?Sé(iC1 {and 01' z-my p01'i.i(m 0f1'.1'1<: SE-lid i£1';1jt):11'1t at? £1113-*T 1'-E:1<:ia;':1'1'i. point 0E3'1.1'me. 11, is not p('>ssi1i>l__ci'=L_(> l'1_:3ld _tAh':1.1. ;'.1i"1},.{ p01'1'i([)Ai'1"oi' the $21.16 CO11SidC1'EE-H'iOI'1 is paici by 1.1919 p. Ié1Vi.:'"'1I'[i1-'i7._1:(;. :1~l'1_t:'_. de£'e11(1z1111' and

1.he1'L=t1"0r(: he is 1101 G1-11':"i 1.061 'H5' ~l.'(?i'1J1i'd, kf)"£ I'M? sz-;1i(T1 211'}'1()Ll111. also. In ?..1'1('? liggjh 1, 01'[.]T1'C \;_-'im.=.-'.\'vc 1*:e1\"Cr 1.2-1.1<L:1'1._ 1Ih(i'I'(T no merit; in t}1*f s :;.1"p.p<:a1V'}L--; AL:'(éc)1*c¥§1?1gly. 1lﬁc%"é.113}3€211 c11smisse.c.1. Sé/~ W393 Sd/~ IUDGE

Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court

H V Krishna Murthy vs M Nanjappa on 24 March, 2010

Bench: N.Kumar, K.Govindarajulu