Central Administrative Tribunal - Madras
M Vazhumuni vs Ut Of Puducherry on 29 January, 2024
(3
l OA No.310/00647/2023
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
CHENNAI BENCH
OA/310/00647/2.023
Dated Monday the 29" day of January Two Thousand Twenty Four
CORAM :
HON'BLE MR. MANISH GARG, Member (J)
&
HON'BLE MR. VARUN SINDHU KUL KAUMUDI, Member (A)
1, M.Mazhumuni
-GPS, Chinnakarayamputhur
'No.27, Subrayapillai St, Extn., Ariyankuppam,
'Puducherry -- 605007
2. M.Muralidasan
GHS, Kodathur
No.8, 4th Cross, Angalamman Nagar,
Muthialpet, Puducherry -- 605 003
3. M.Puttlai @ Vengadesan
GHS, Kodathur
No.11, Lakshmi Nagar, Karumariamman St.,
'Karuvadikuppam, Puducherry -- 605 008
4. J,Guberan
GHS, Kodathur
No.7, Shankardass Street, Puducherry -- 605 001
5, E.Idhayavendhan
GPS, Chinnakarayamputhur
No.2, Maraimalaiadigal Street,
Chinnaveerampattinam, Puducherry-
6. V.Mohanraj
GMS, Manapet
NO.9, 5th Cross Street,
Shankardass swamigal nagar, Lawspet,
Puducherry
A&
7. V.Yuvarani
GPS, Pilliarkuppam
No.344, Seenuvasa Township,
Thavalakuppam, Puducherry -- 605 007
8. A.Arunan
GPS, Narambai
No.42, Second Cross,
Moogambigai Nagar,
Thanapalayam, Puducherry - 605 007
9. PBally Vijay
GMS, Manapet
No.80, Kamaraj Street,
Ramaiah Thottam, Sornanagar,
Ariyankuppam, Puducherry -- 605 007
10.N.Sadhish
GMS, Manapet
No.406, Jawahar Nagar, Sudhana nagar Extn.,
Nainarmandapam, Puducherry--605 004 |
11. G.Thamizhvendan
GHS, Pannithittu
No.7, Marimuthu Street, Pondy Cuddalore Road,
Thavalakuppam , Puducherry -- 605 007
12. S.Joyce Linda
GPS, Ariyapalayam
No.7, 15 Cross, Lourdhu Nagar,
Villianur, Puducherry -- 605 110
13. S Jesintha
GPS, Embalam
NO.18, 2"4 Cross, Deva Nagar,
Reddiyarpalayam, Puducherry -- 605 010
14. G.Ranjini
GPS, Embalam
No.105, Kalathu Mettu ST, Tendral Nagar,
Saram, Puducherry --
15. N.Srilakshmi _
GPS, Embalam
OA No.310/00647/2023
>}
16.
17.
18.
19,
20.
21,
22.
23.
3
No.560, Bharathidasan St., Ashok Nagar,
Lawspet, Puducherry -- 605 008
R.Sonia
GPS, Embalam
Plot No.13, 15* Cross, Sri ram Nagar,
Ariyankuppam, Puducherry -- 605 007
R.Padmavathy
GPS, Vinayagampet
No.102, Vazhudhavur Road,
Koundampalayam, Puducherry -- 605 009
A.Nirmaladevi
GPS, Pilliarkuppam
No.24, Nehru St., Muthulingampet,
Lawspet, Puducherry --
N.Saroja
GPS, Thuthipet
No.42, Alen St.,
Vanarapet, Puducherry -- 605 001
R.Nalina
GHS, Keezhparikalpet
No.29, South St.,
Kuruvinatham, Bahour, Puducherry
A.John christina mary
GPS, Thuthipet
No.21, Ist Cross, Bharathidasan Nagar,
Manavely(V), Puducherry -- 605 110
M. Jeevitha
GPS, Thuthipet
No.22, Puliam Pattamman Koil Street,
Dharmapuri, Puducherry -- 605 009
S.Patchaityammal
GHS, Sandaipudukuppam
No.44,Mettu St., Veeman nagar,
Puducherry -- 605 009
OA No.310/00647/2023
4 OA No.3 10/00647/2023
24. N.Rajesh
GHS, Kodathur
No.21, Sri Nagamuthu Mariamman Koil St.,
Vanarapet, Puducherry -- 605
25. A.Gomadhii
GHS, Kothapurinatham
No.8, 4th Cross, Angalamman Nagar,
Muthialpet, Puducherry -- 605 003
26. R.Poornima
GPS, Sedarapet
No.18, Salai St., Muthialpet,
Puducherry -- 605 003
27. V.Sathiya
GPS, Sedarapet
No.88, Car St., Thilaspet,
Puducherry -- 605 009
28. A.Martial Andre
GPS, Sedarapet
No.34, Vandikara St.,
Muthialpet,
~ Puducherry -- 605 003
29. B.Angel Regi
GPS, Sedarapet
No.14, New St.,, Kamaraj Nagar,
Gorimedu,
Puducherry -- 605 006
30. S.Shalini
GPS, Pilliarkuppam
No.53A, Airport road,
Lawspet,
Puducherry -- 605 008
31. R.Gurunathan
GHS, Pannithittu
No.4, Kottabomman Nagar Exin.,
Manavely,
Puducherry -- 605 007
3 OA No.3 10/00647/2023
32. K. Bharathi
GPS, Pilliarkuppam
No.80, Kamaraj St., Ramaiah Thottam,
Sornanagar, Ariyankuppam,
Puducherry -- 605 007
33. P.Manju
GPS, Narambai
No.22, Mariamman Koil St.,
Kirumampakkam, Bahour,
Puducherry -- |
34, R. Karthikeyan
'GPS, Narambai
No47, Bharathidasan St., R.K.Nagar,
Atiyankuppam,
Puducherry -- 605 007
35. N.Senthilkumar
GHS, Kothapurinatham
No.49, Kamaraj Salai, Radhakrishnan Nagar,
Ariyankuppam,
Puducherry -- 605 102
36. R.Uma
GHS, Madhagadipetpalayam
'No.32, Bajanaimadam St., Muthialpet,
Puducherry --
37. PHemachandiran
GMS, Molapakkam
No.1, 24 Cross, 4" Lane, Krishnanagar,
Puducherry --
38. G.Rajkumar
GPS, Karasur
No.35, Vanidasan St., Ashok Nagar,
Lawspet,
Puducherry -- 605 008
39, A.Anbarasi
GPS, Arachikuppam
No.2, Mariamman koil St., Periyar Nagar,
40.
Al,
42.
43.
44.
4S.
46.
Kurivinatham,
Puducherry -- 607 402
K. Balaji
GMS, Keezhur
No.65, Ramana Nagar, Achirayapuram,
Urivaiyar, Villianur,
Puducherry -
S.Indra Priyadharshini
GPS, Kalitheerthalkuppam
No.56, Mariamman koil St.,
Ellaipillaichavady,
Puducherry
K.Senthil
GPS, Kirumampakkam
No.14, PWD Engineers Colony, JJ Nagar Extn.,
Moolakulam,
Puducherry
R.Kumari
GPS, Kirumampakkam
No.36A, Thuropathiamman Koil Street,
Artyankuppam,
Puducherry
P.Senthamizhselvi
GPS, Kirumampakkam
No.B6, Viduthalainagar,
Mudaliarpet,
Puducherry
D.Bharathi
GPS, Kirumampakkam
No.5, 6th Cross, Extn.,
Brindhavanam
Puducherry.
P.Logeshwari
GGPS, Bahour
No.74, East St.,
Bahour,
Puducherry
OA No.310/00647/2023
\
47,
48.
49.
50.
51.
52.
53.
54.
M.Muthukumaran
GPS, Aranganur
No.30, High School St.,
Seliamedu,
Puducherry -- 607 402.
B.Kavithadevi
GPS, Aranganur
No.60, {I Cross, Netha Nagar,
Velrampet, Puducherry -- 605 004
~6-
P.Sinnarasu
GPS, Ananthapuram
No.22, Usha St., Ariyur Post,
Puducherry -- 605 102
R.Giridharani
GPS, Moorthikuppam
No.24, 4th Cross, Second Main road,
Nehru Nagar, Thengaithittu,
Puducherry -
C. Vijayalakshmi
GPS, Sivaranthagampet
No.2, Vel Koil Street, Pethuchettipet,
Puducherry
C.Kalpana
GPS, Ananthapuram
No.38, Angalamman Koil Street,
Ananthapuram,
Puducherry -- 605 102
K.Sadeesh Kumar
GMS, Athingampet
No.7, Jayam Nagar, Manakulavinayagar St.,
100 feet road, Mudaliarpet,
Puducherry- 605 004
D.Kalatvanan
GPS, Seliyamedupet
No.37, Mariamman Koil St., T.N.Palayam post,
Artyankuppam,
OA No.3 10/00647/2023
?
55.
56.
37.
58.
59.
60.
61.
62.
8 OA No.310/00647/2023
Puducherry -- 605 007
P.Thamizhanban
GPS, Arachikuppam
No.18, Old Kamaraj Nagar,
Bahour Post,
Puducherry -- 607 402
P.Selvi
GPS, Krishnavaram
No.16/40, Moogambigai Nagar,.
First Main Road, Nainarmandabam,
Puducherry -- 605 004
5.Uma Shanthi
GPS, Krishnavaram
No.18, Poraiyathamman koil st., Uchimedu,
Manapet, Bahour,
Puducherry
R.Rajasekaran
GMS, Athingampet
No.9, Mariamman Koil Street, Aranganurpet,
Seliamedu post, Bahour,
Puducherry -- 607 402
N.Karunanithi
GPS, Perungalur
NO.5, 2"4 Mettu St., Uthiravahinipet,
Puducherry
P.Jayasudha
GPS, Perungalur
Gandhi Nagar, Kambar Street, Karikalampakkam,
Puducherry
R.Porselvi,
GPS, Perungalur
No.13, First Vanniar Street, Kanuvapet,
Villianur,
Puducherry
M.Nithilavalli
GPS, Korkadu
if
63.
9
No.17, T.V.K. Street, Fourth Cross,
Thillainagar, Villianur,
Puducherry -- 605 110.
G.Megaladevi
GPS, Korkadu
No.14, Thotikaran St., Kanuvapet,
Villianur,
Puducherry -- 605 010
64. R.Uma maheshwari
65.
66.
. 67.
68.
69.
GPS, Manakuppam
No.23, 4! Cross, Annaithersa Nagar,
Moolakulam,
Puducherry
K.Purushothaman
GPS, Nathamedu
No.3, Mullai St., Pudhu nagar,
Thengaithittu,
Puducherry -- 605 004.
5.Anandhababu
GPS, Ananthapuram
No.3, VIP Garden, Madhakoil Extn.,
Thillainagar, Villianur,
Puducherry
R.Sridhar
GPS, Melsathamangalam
No.18, Selvanagar, 7" cross street,
Urivatyar, Villianur,
Puducherry -- 605 110
P, Vijayalakshmi
GMS, Athingampet
No.3, Bharathiar Street, Kattukuppam,
Manapet post,
Puducherry -- 6-7 402
C.Sakthipriya
GPS, Kumarapalayam
No.8, 4 Cross, Aruthara nagar,
Puducherry -- 605 009
OA No.310/00647/2023
70.
71.
72
73.
10
N.Bhavani
GPS, Thirkanchi
No.46, 15 Cross, Thanathumednu,
Karikalampakkam,
Puducherry -- 605 007
K.Kavida
GHSS, Nonankuppam
No.56, Third Cross, Annai ndira nagar,
Ariyankuppam,
Puducherry -- 605 007
. R.Kowsalya
GMS, Sorityankuppam
No.20, Second Cross, Jayaram Chettiyar nagar,
Uruviyar,
Puducherry -- 605 110
K.Kida
GPS, Edayarpalayam
No.48, Cheran St., Venkateshvara Nagar,
Puducherry -- 605 113
74. K_Nisha
75.
GPS, Sembipalayam
No.15, 2"4 Cross, Parasuramapuram,
Villianur,
Puducherry -- 605 110
K.Kalainithya
GPS, Sembipalayam
No.8, V.S.Nagar, Kariyamanikam,
Puducherry -- 605 008
76. L.Rajathilagam
GPS, Sembipalayam
No.76, Main Road, Thattanchavady,
G.N.Palayam,
Puducherry -- 605 110
77. 8.Girija
GPS, Thirukanji
OA No.310/00647/2023
78.
79.
80.
81.
82.
83.
84,
11
No.3, East Street, Mannadipet,
Puducherry- 605 501.
U.Sankary
GPS, Thirukanji
No.A12 Police Quarters, Gorimedu,
Puducherry -- 605 006
V.M.Mangalam
GPS, Narimedu
No.3, 3rd Block Kavikuil Street, Ashok nagar,
Lawspet,
Puducherry -- 605 008
N.Vijaya
GMS, Pooranankuppam
No.10, South Street, Extn. Thengaithittu,
Puducherry ~ 605 004.
B.Sunitha
GMS, Pooranankuppam
No.F1 Vels appartment, Godavari Street,
Nainarmandabam,
Puducherry -- 605 004
C.Banumathi
GMS, Pooranankuppam
No.344, M.G.R Street, Sudhana nagar, Exin.,
Nainarmandabam, -
Puducherry - 605 004
D, Santhi
GMS, Pooranankuppam
No 47, 2nd Cross Street, Thilagar Street
Katterikuppam,
Puducherry -- 605 102
R Sudhandaradevi
GMS. Andiyarpalayam
No 53, Merket Street, Artyankuppam,
. Puducherry -- 605 007
85.
M. Leela
GPS Thavalakuppam
OA No.310/00647/2023
86.
87.
88.
89.
90.
91.
92.
12 OA No.3 10/00647/2023
No 10, HI Cross Street, Sridhar Nagar,
Arztyankluppam,
Puducherry- 605 007
K. Prema
GHS Uruvaiyar
No 128, 2nd Cross, Pandiyan Nagar,
Villianur,
Puducherry -- 605 110
J.Sendhil
GHS Uruvatyar
No 15, Ist Floor, Mulla Street,
Puducherry -- 605 001.
B. Hemavadi
GHS Uruvaiyar
No 8, Murugan Koil Street, Kanuvapet,
Villianur,
Puducherry -- 605 110.
R .Anitha
GPS Manavely(A)
No 66C, Srinivasa Gardens, Kakayanthope,
Ariyankuppam,
Puducherry -- 605 007
T. Pushpa
GPS Manavely(A)
No 1, Kaliyan Street, Manavely,
Axtyankuppam,
Puducherry -- 605 007.
R. Malathi
GPS Manavely(A)
No 18, Royal Nagar, Manavely Road,
Artyankuppam,
Puducherry -- 605 007
V. Vasudha
GHSS, Nonankuppam
No 13, I cross, Mariamman Koil Street,
Thengaithittu,
13 OA No.3 10/00647/2023
Puducherry -- 605 004.
93. K Jeyasree
GHSS, Nonankuppam
No 8, Kamaraj Street, Indira Nagar,
Mudaliarpet,
Puducherry -- 605 004
94. J Jesper Felicia
GPS, Mangalam
No 41, Rathinam Street, Anandha nagar,
Kadirkamam,
Puducherry - 605 009
95. J. Tharani
GPS, Agaram
No 7, If Cross, Pandiyan Nagar,
Villianur,
Puducherry -- 605 110,
96. J. Victoria
GPS, Mangalam
Plot No 5, Vil Cross, Kamban Nagar,
Reddiyarpalayam,
Puducherry -- 605 010
97. K Rajeswari
GPS, Keezhsathamangalam
Nol6, Saravanan Nagar,
Reddiyarpalayam,
Puducherry -- 605 110
98. K suganya
GPS Manavely(A)
No 25, VI Cross, Sri Krishna Nagar,
Puducherry -- 605 008
99, A Thilagavathy
GPS Manavely(A)
No 4, Dr. Abdul Kalam Street, Sudana nagar Extn. I.,
Nainarmandapam,
Puducherry -- 605 004
100.M. Chitra
14
GPS Manavely(A)
No 21, Royal St, Ist Floor, Manavely,
Ariyankuppam ,
Puducherry -- 605 007
101.G Indhumathi
GPS Manavely(A)
No 2, Ist Cross, Annai Indira Nagar,
Ariyankuppam ,
Puducherry -- 605 007
102. S Kavitha
GPS Manavely(A)
No 21, Il Cross, Kalaignar Nagar,
Manavely, Artyankuppam,
Puducherry -- 605 007
103, M Revathy
GPS Manavely(A)
No 151, Cuddalore Road,
Murungapakkam, Puducherry-- 605 004
104. P Pooraniammal
GPS Manavely(A)
No 22, Pooranankuppam Street,
Ariyankuppam,
Puducherry -- 605 007
105. M Meera
.GPS Edayarpalayam
No C/55, Ambedkar Salai,
Nethaji Sala,
Ouppalam, Puducherry -- 605 013
106, K Amala
GPS Edayarpalayam
No 39,40 Marg garden,
Thavakuppam, Puducherry-- 605 007
107. D Rajeswari
GPS Pudukuppam
No 28, I Cross, Nanamedu Street,
Thavalakuppam,
Puducherry-- 605 007
OA No.3 10/00647/2023
15 OA No.310/00647/2023
108. K Nalini Devi
GHSS, Nonankuppam
No 37, Kamaraj Street, Indira Nagar,
Mudaliarpet, Puducherry-- 605 004
109. G Subashini
GHSS, Nonankuppam
No 49, Sudalai St, Manavely,
Artyankuppam, Puducherry -- 605 007
110. S Vinothani
GHSS, Nonankuppam
No 130, Moogambigai Nagar,
II Cross, Nainarmandapam,
Puducherry -- 605 004
111. I Sangidha
GPS Thantanchavady
No 15, Anandam Nagar, Main Road,
Arumbarthapuram , Puducherry-- 605 010
112, D Sugandhi
GHS Madagadipetpalayam
No 10, I Cross, Jansy Nagar, Puducherry-- 605 004
113. E Mohana
GMS Keezhur
No 6, II Cross, Annai Terasa Nagar,
Moolakulam, Puducherry-- 605 010
114, E Uma Priya Aiswarya
GPS, Pangur
No .LIG 245, 5th Cross Street,
Kurumabpet, Puducherry
115. V Gowsaly
GPS Narambai
No 13, north Street, valluvarmedu,
Pillayarkuppam, Puducherry-- 607 402
116. A Geevitha
GPS Thanampalayam
UU
&)
16 OA No.310/00647/2023
No 50, Muthumudaltyar Nagar,
Thavalakuppam, Puducherry-- 605 007
117. K Makesh
GMS Molapakkam
No 5, VS Nagar, Kariyamanickam,
Puducherry -- 605 106
118. AAlenmarie
GPS Keezhsathamangalam
No 66A, Thirumal Nagar,
Kosapalayam, Puducherry-- 605 013
119. A.Ananthakumar
GPS PS palayam
No 16 Water tank street,
Thirubuvanai , Puducherry
120. R Malini Pon Devi
GPS, Keezhsathamangalam
No 9 Thirumalai st,sivaganapathy nagar,
Villianur, Puducherry-- 605 110
121. S Subalakshmi
GPS Vadamangalam
No 17 Main Gate street,
Ariyur, Puducherry-- 605 102
122. V Tamizharasi
GPS, Keezhsathamangalam
No 183 Ist cross Thiruveni Nagar,
Manaveli, Puducherry -- 605 110.
123. S Joyce Linda
GPS Vadamangalam
No 7 Ist cross, Lourde Nagar ,
Villianur, Puducherry-- 605 110
124. T Bavani
GPS Agaram
NO 176 2nd Main road ,Thiruppur Kumaran nagar ,
Velrampet, Puducherry-- 605 004
17
125. M Manimaran
GPS Manakuppam
No 15,Anandham Nagar,
Arumbathapuram, Puducherry-- 605 010
126. R Gomathy
GPS Andiyarpalayam
No 2,kamban street , Sugumar Nagar,
Kalitheerthalkuppam, Puducherry-- 605 107
By Advocate M/s B. Balavijayan
-VS-
1, The Union Territory of Puducherry,
Rep by its Secretary,
Education Department,
Government of Puducherry,
Chief Secretariat,
Puducherry -- 605 005.
2. The Director of School Education,
Perunthalaivar Kamaraj Centenary
Education Complex,
100 Feet Toad, Anna Nagar,
Nellithope,
Puducherry -- 605 005.
3. The Deputy Director (Administration),
Directorate of School Education,
Government of Puducherry.
Puducherry.
By Advocate Mr. R. Syed Mustafa
OA No.310/00647/2023
.. Applicants
... Respondents
18 OA No.310/00647/2023
ORAL ORDER
(Pronounced by Hon'ble Mr. Manish Garg, Member(J)) In the instant OA, the applicants seeks the following relief:
"To direct the respondents to strictly followed the methodology adopted in clause 7 and clause 8 of the circular dated 26.06.2023, for preparing the entitlement list, for implementing the transfer for the Primary School Teachers, working in School Education Department and pass such further or other orders as this Tribunal deems fit and proper and thus render justice."
2. When the matter is taken up for hearing, learned counsel for the applicants submits that the transfer order, dated 29.09.2023, has been made by the respondents and the said transfer order reflects only 8 applicants in the present OA out of 126. The names and the serial nos. in the OA are as follows:
15. Sri Lakshmi. N 29, Angel Regi
30. Shalini. §
41. Indra Priyadharshini
62. M. Nithilavalli
64. R. Uma Maheswari
65. K. Purushothaman
66. 8. Anandhababu He prayed for liberty to the said applicants to prefer appropriate legal remedy in accordance with law, challenging the transfer order, dated 29.09.2023.
3. Learned counsel for the applicants submits that, in respect of the "
19 OA No.3 10/00647/2023applicants other than those mentioned above, the relief sought has become infructuous.
4, In view of the categorical statement made by the learned counsel for the applicants, on instructions from his clients, the present OA has become infructuous. |
5. With the aforesaid directions, OA is dismissed as infructuous. However, liberty is granted to the applicant at nos. 15,29,30,41,62,64,65 and 66 to act in accordance with law, if so advised, No order as to costs.