Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

- Know your Kanoon - Doc Gen Hub - Counter Argument - Case Predict AI - Talk with IK Doc - ...
Upgrade to Premium
[Cites 1, Cited by 4]

Punjab-Haryana High Court

Pawan Kumar Aggarwal vs Union Of India And Others on 9 October, 2009

                 CWP No.5678 of 1999

                        -1-


      In the High Court of Punjab and Haryana at Chandigarh.


                                  Date of decision: 09.10.2009

1.CWP No.5678 of 1999

Pawan Kumar Aggarwal                         .. Petitioner

Vs.

Union of India and others                    ... Respondents.


2. CWP No.595 of 2005

Smt.Kamlesh Ghai                             ... Petitioner

Vs.

Union of India and others                    ... Respondents.

3. CWP No.20661 of 2006

Sadhu Singh                                  .... Petitioner

Vs.

Union of India and another                   ... Respondents.

4.CWP 20350 of 2006


Arjan Singh                                  ... Petitioner

Vs.

Union of India and others                    ... Respondents.


5.CWP No.20146 of 2006


Ex.Hav.Sarjeet Singh                         ... Petitioner
                  CWP No.5678 of 1999

                        -2-


Vs.

Union of India and others                   ... Respondents.


6. CWP No.13466 of 2006

Ex.No.7234976 Sowar (ADT) Makhan Singh ... Petitioner

Vs.

Union of India and others                   ... Respondents.


7. CWP No.10060 of 2006

No.659929 Ex.Corporal Gurdeep Singh Sodhi ... Petitioner

Vs.

Union of India and others                   ... Respondents.


8. CWP No.7634 of 2006

Ex-Sub. Gurbhajan Singh                     .... Petitioner

Vs.

Union of India and others                   ... Respondents.

9. CWP No.2407 of 2006

Ex.Hav. Dalip Singh (No.6367689)            ... Petitioner

Vs.

Union of India and others                   ... Respondents.


10. CWP No.20129 of 2003

Capt. Ramzan Mohammad                       ... Petitioner

Vs.
                  CWP No.5678 of 1999

                        -3-



Union of India and others                  ... Respondents.

11. CWP No.7849 of 2002

Mehar Chand Sharma                         ... Petitioner

Vs.

Union of India and others                  ... Respondents.


12. CWP No.4895 of 2003

Nasib Kaur                                 ... Petitioner

Vs.

Union of India and others                  ... Respondents.

13. CWP No.1871 of 2003

Smt. Vidya Devi widow of NK Bachan Singh ... Petitioner

Vs.

Union of India and others                  ... Respondents.

14. CWP No.2760 of 2003

Parkash Chand                              ... Petitioner

Vs.

Union of India and others                  ... Respondents.


15. CWP No.2725 of 2003

Gurmeet Singh                              ... Petitioner

Vs.

Union of India and others                  ... Respondents.
                  CWP No.5678 of 1999

                         -4-



16. CWP No.1562 of 2003

JC No.11998 Ex-Jamadar (now Naib
Subedar) Bachan Singh                         ... Petitioner

Vs.

The Secretary Ministry of Defence, Govt. of India, New Delhi,
and others
                                              ... Respondents.


17.CWP No.8856 of 2002

Surinder Kaur                                 ... Petitioner

Vs.

Union of India and others                     ... Respondents.

18. CWP No.7930 of 2002

Ex.Sub Lakhan Lal                             ... Petitioner

Vs.

Union of India and others                     ... Respondents.

20. CWP No.6722 of 2002

Ex.RFN Balbir Singh                           ... Petitioner

Vs.

Union of India and others                     ... Respondents.


21. CWP No.5265 of 2002

No.10355976 A Ex.hav. Satpal                  ... Petitioner

Vs.

Union of India and others                     ... Respondents.
                  CWP No.5678 of 1999

                        -5-




22. CWP No.3953 of 2002

JC No.189849 W Ex.Subdar Harpal Singh       ... Petitioner

Vs.

Union of India and others                   ... Respondents.


23. CWP No.3005 of 2002

Ranjit Singh                                ... Petitioner

Vs.

Union of India and others                   ... Respondents.

24. CWP No.1088 of 2002


IC No.15745-L Lt. Col. Shivdev Singh Randhawa... Petitioner

Vs.

Union of India and others                   ... Respondents.


25. CWP No.328 of 2002

Ex.Gnr. Vijay Singh No.14487569             ... Petitioner

Vs.

Union of India and others                   ... Respondents.


26. CWP No.586 of 2001

Mohinder Pal Singh                          ... Petitioner

Vs.

Union of India and others                   ... Respondents.
                  CWP No.5678 of 1999

                        -6-




27. CWP No.18122 of 1999

Sudershan Kumari Sood wife of
late Kulbushan Rai Sood                ... Petitioner

Vs.

Union of India and others              ... Respondents.


29. CWP No.14315 of 1999

Hoshiar Singh Colonel (Retd.)          ... Petitioner

Vs.

Union of India and others              ... Respondents.


30. CWP No.1308 of 2000

Hoshiar Singh Col. (Retd.)             ... Petitioner

Vs.

Union of India and others              ... Respondents.


31. CWP No.12515 of 1999

Jai Pal Singh Siwach                   ... Petitioner

Vs.

Union of India and others              ... Respondents.


32. CWP No.17580 of 1998

Jasbir Singh Ex.GdSM/CK 13689259A      ... Petitioner

Vs.
                  CWP No.5678 of 1999

                         -7-


Union of India and others              ... Respondents.


33. CWP No.16382 of 1998

Ex Sepoy Harbans Singh                 ... Petitioner

Vs.

Union of India and others              ... Respondents.


34. CWP No.4307 of 1998

Brig.RS Sharma (Retd.) and others      ... Petitioner

Vs.

Union of India and another             ... Respondents.


35. CWP No.16845 of 1997

Dilbagh Singh                          ... Petitioner

Vs.

Union of India and others              ... Respondents.


36. CWP No.16821 of 1997

Ex.MT Driver Kishan Singh              .... Petitioner

Vs.

Union of India and others              ... Respondents.


37. CWP No.3336 of 1997

Krishan Kumar (GNR) No.14378785        ... Petitioner

Vs.
                  CWP No.5678 of 1999

                        -8-


Union of India through Govt. of India
Mnistry of Defence Pension (A)
New Delhi                                   ... Respondent


38. CWP No.12671 of 1995

Mrs.Baljinder Kaur widow of late
Major Balwinder Singh Mavi                  ... Petittioner

Vs.

Union of India through Secretary
Ministry of Defence,
New Delhi                                   ... Respondent


39. CWP No.15622 of 1993

Kamaljit Kaur and others LRs of JC 139115-Y
Hony. Sub Major Clerk(S) Tarsem
Singh and others                          ... Petitioners

Vs.

Union of India and others                   ... Respondents.


40. CWP No.15194 of 1993

Dashrath Ray No.14390275 F Gnr
(OPR) of HQRS 7 Artillry Bde.
Camp though his brother                     ... Petitioners

Vs.

Union of India and others                   ... Respondents.

41. CWP No.13319 of 1993

Ex Naik Chiman Singh No.3378174-N           ... Petitioners
Vs.

Union of India and others                   ... Respondents.
                  CWP No.5678 of 1999

                        -9-



42. CWP No.234 of 1990

Ex N. Subedar Balwant Singh                  ... Petitioners

Vs.

Union of India through Secretary
Ministry of Defence, New Delhi               ... Respondent


43 Amended CWP No.5981 of 1989

Narinder Singh (Formerly No.1061586-N LD
of 5 (1) Armed Sqn. 63, CAV
                                             ... Petitioners
Vs.

Union of India and others                    ... Respondents.

44. CWP 8346 of 2001

Smt.Bimla Devi and others LRs of deceased Balbir Singh
Ex-Sepoy No.4146004 and others             ... Petitioners

Vs.

Union of India and others                    ... Respondents.


      CORAM: HION'BLE MR. JUSTICE PERMOD KOHLI


Present:   Mr.Vikas Goyal, Mr.Hemant Bassi, Mr.KS Boparai, Mr.RS
           Panghal, Mr.RA Sheoran, Mr.Rajeev Anand, Mr.Bahadur
           Singh, Mr.PL Verma, Mr.Sanjeev Gupta, Mr.SK Sharma,
           Mr.RS Sangwan, Mr.SK Rattan, Mr. Bhim Sen Sehgal,
           Mr.Mr.VK Gupta, Mr.Sanjiv Pandit, Mr.RK Girdhar,
           Mr.VS Sehjpal, Mr.Rajnish Bansal, Mr.Salil Bali,
           Mr.Rajeshwar Singh, Mr.SP Singh, Mr.Naresh Ghai,
           Mr.SS Johal, Mr. KS Dadwal, Mr. Ashok Gupta, Mr.Angad
           Singh, Ms.Lisa Gill, Mr.KS Gill, Mr.KS Grewal,
           Ms.Tanisha Peshawaria, Mr.SN Yadav, Advocates,for the
           petitioners.
                    CWP No.5678 of 1999

                           - 10 -



             Mrs.Renu Bala Sharma, Mr. Gurpreet Singh, Mr.Chander
             Mohan Sharma, Ms.Pooja Satija Advocate for Mr.Anil
             Rathee, Mr.Kamal Sehgal, Mr.Amit Rao Advocate,for
             Mr.SK Sharma, Ms.Sangeeta Dhanda, Advocates, for the
             respondents.


PERMOD KOHLI, J. (Oral):

The issue involved in the present writ petitions is cognizable by the Armed Forces Tribunal constituted under Section 4 of the Armed Forces Tribunal Act, 2007 ( 55 of 2007) by the the Central Government vide notification dated 07.08.2009. These cases are accordingly transferred to the Armed Forces Tribunal, Chandigarh Bench, Chandigarh.

The parties through their counsel are directed to appear before the Tribunal aforesaid on 01.02.2010.

A copy of this order be placed on the record of each concerned file.



09.10.2009                                        (PERMOD KOHLI)
BLS                                                   JUDGE