Gujarat High Court
SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION/16145/2007 on 3 May, 2010
Author: Ks Jhaveri
Bench: Ks Jhaveri
Gujarat High Court Case Information System Print PK �����?8?H?????% ?M?kA? ???o?G?x)|???Z?m??I??%^( ? ?/ j????ka ?~[??O?dH??\n(?"'?BJ??g? #2xH???h ??x?
? ???�?J? �??? ?k?JZ5c?zuu%?1 xi??\?o??}-??? F?? Q?! ?p?3Y?T9?$%:s@ ?"wF?r q?? ?}Z'?Y?0 8( L?X??i??"??E??.? L? ??:.?[S r????5O ?? }?"? ]?S??*?C l R?? #w"u B? R?K???jV@ ?? ??B???ScA\? ??E?c!?~?l (??kC? v k?o> l??? ?pc?i p ?? ?q?J?7??? f`v? :Y?JB*?? 41?$??: ??_???+v-ti ?<\ M vm?9?8C ? ???????.??p??/'?-P2? ?T ?P? m?'s?x?3?]@A? ?C Jo? ;n???? 4?L? ???"??@?Yo???0?\?? QA ?? ;?>{?t?B?,$?k ?{2= ?Q > mC?Y?% n ?sSsQ???"?Q?P?$ m?R??6y????[?M?3 ?)?1?P? ??X?
??? i{??H ?^?.|?? ??F+V???S???W???k? ?q?<[?a? S???i?u ?|l&? ??Y?x ^???N?]???7_!??Vh? ?.?o??
G=h??? ~???M\X?Y???oq?0?Mv}?Th5?>lo? P????fG?.?W ??K?izJ W ?I? ??? ??6+?A??>?p??t?+:?? ?? ? ??"xb ?;??D?V ?? ?gsu?;M?8??:{?? W?S??? W?\?2?? V?#???_ ? ???? D?i3???"??x?r 83?d:?w?8 I=??Q???u?q\??er?^frO {?OH6[ ??;?&? ?y???|@) ? ?1f ?? _?B?S?8? E ? k ?)t?T?
y??A#/??u?4?u?xr?$? f ?_sK? ?> ??=??=? |???q???g???N?h:??Q?V??n+?k?q* 6}?u ? u O?!? ???? ???J(?1? ?n? ?R?z`??X?? ?>?'K%??A|??k?} ???'m2 ???H?????"z ?K? ??V??D ?j)??? ??]?7? ? ?|P??$7????z ???|??v ? ?7Y??? :? ??? M??x? ?r+? ??` %? {?F?n?_?O???w???aO??G?t+x ???a M{????~ H?si? |p? e?????GZe?O?'????v.?Lo?o?????*l??wa?hI?[c ??? ]??@ ?D`?? ; ?g??cH R???d?+a?;?h??????K%???PC??=,`?
??h"?=N?A??~???kP5?R ? _o? K^??([? ?oq ? )MY? U??d??`??T?x ?mB?5Km??u%t??j=b"?\R???? ?{E? ?? ? ?h??0h g? ~??? N?? ?p?D?C ??? ;??t???!g ?N? s??? D}? ?"@P C?flK )o??A?d ?a? Jh A???i?]?91%4? ?? ???:C??U??8-17??? ???.M?? ^?3;?U?6?B"?o??cQ n?_?H? r??!;? PK H? ? ��O)��PK � � �?8?<������������ ���styles.xml?Z[o?6 ~?04lO?e?qbg???[? )64)?WZ?-.?(??/??;$E?L?v? ~X ?????s?9????.? ?8??? G?�?
I??s?<~pg???wo?jE | ? Op*\.?1? ???[-?s"!?[? N? ??7 ?F???)&?}x?0p?w? - % -??V ??%�?a?+Z????p;QH>?{??{ (KP?e ?? ??%???e9? * < cio??C?3? ??Y 8S%f?[D 5 ?7k k?Mi? B??1 Q?z 1?$,?D?a??? ??O?_X?\ ?? ?d??5?L???Z?
??? ?j? ?8(?H? ?? \???? ???e??,L ?(?p???/?(?W# ?w? H??4gD ]Q?X????R??cFV????? ?P?tp??G?Q?s ????-X??Am???k? g08??T ? @?m #?8??cDY ? ?}z??V Tl?UY???(??Q? '??[??????9??\?? #? ?P.]?t?W(???f? ?? e ?c? ??d?@?e?G(?[ s,?]3 ???'i 96? pD?P ??3 @?q!d?W ?b???? ?)??q ???�m??!???rA% MBL??\ g 20?o?0?B? ?P ?< ?"
az?\?l???!??0??F?]?B1? ?s?B??fV? S?w??
8N?? ?X ?0 ?t??5 ?T 4O ?|y(?c ???Y? ?
k?N q???: N?rgF??~?(X?HR?Z? 4?b?3?[JK?Em)S?M?B? N3.3? ??P# NO 1? ? :?? z?(}?jr??_$� e? ? %?Y????]???o?@vK??U???? ? ???Y? ?? ?u??'47{~Vm1YGP??4 !? & ??e (??"f???\Lt ?? ? ?D?g??p6??4??? ???*? of7W? ??ob5J?7???jk4 ? l ?? ?E??? ??v)O z??s:Z yM[??? o?k?'? _ ??E???(6?bs}Qln.?????/?????4Eu?+JEJ ?PZ? Y?L=@Xx?E ?? ?XU????? ]????g>?J? ???4&????{??j*;R??3?2????f?D???q?W???\???????Uo??? t??5?? ?O?9?K???_??>V? ,? ? v !?hp? ???T3?$??Ng????`DQ? ???z>??x?h'@? ?T?"?(?R ???Xu>? ?M*=*?MNo?Ri???|4?y?m}7?y V???? ?W? ??? ?evt??W2 ???` 5E?&? ?V? ?B???Q?? ?# ???? T=0?R? ?? ?T 6 ?Z {0gi?Z? q???? ?y???b?"
n?j?b?x??O ?iW??p?O? ?-?m?? (?|?x? ??a? \^g-( * `???&^[?=????1? ??B9R?j? ?5? ???G?n?? A???l? PK _~i �� '��PK �����?8?
OpenOffice.org/2.4$Linux OpenOffice.org_project/680m12$Build-9286 himansu 2010-05-12T12:35:28 1 PT0S PK � � �?8?<������������ ���Thumbnails/thumbnail.pngZeT?v??B?{q?B??V??B? E?{?? J?{qw-?? hq V ;!?y??3??s?n?$cde=?k????V?PU??8? ?O?}S ?? ??C+???P?1?(?C?}???>?? OFi yn@;?8 N?Ln?M_??? ?gx_-xg???,Af ??IV?-?x&r?E?? dra? \?z j F ??w_??#w??('?s r{?? ???*A?+?G?zy???dQ?*? ? ??Y_ ?R?/?Yo?[?%?+? #?? ???U??F??S?[? ?{?? ??*??S?x???.;??4?|p?? ?? N??[l�?, ?p u=A&u>???!?.?u? ?/?E? ??6?%?n?sa?. ??t?????0??F ????=??6t??&?pu'??h??b?!?r$?5Vg??b"G??^3a??g?? k?? ??5 ??(u??R- ?F?y?B?? ???' ???!?$?o??K?l??dln7??=?? y7?y??+?v?o ?(???Kt ??t]E?W??2??;n-?[W ?8? J? ??i? nY?CK???R??^~?~?a??Ae'????n???v???gG??????*u???o??/ ???U8? ?{] Q??^?o????_?r ?O2p?q&vq?-j9J5Wk??>?V?E%?P???K ????XS????N?>C????(xb??B?0[??R b??c-??m? ?gc0:??0?? M??#=pP r??}+A?dll?tyF td1??g?{k?h?;??~??Cl1??/h???:???;???q9_.?g/]???n??i????a??l9??gO ???~A? ? ???zPz4_m???? ?? D:?5?f?? ??B?M?? ? ?!??s? C? ?j?o??z???M?w ??S_?>? ??e '?x???Z? ? ?>W??ibN??=??5?i $?R ?? ???_ ??T?#?A? ?BM??eh??s?QC?a ??? ?x?'???.?>?Y?h??L? ?:??? ]L?h@?({t?^K:m N??8 ??u-,?K w ? ??NF?#9T ;????J?(???z ?1P?[?\ ?ZO@?+?^q?um???5mD???h?+?o??k7??cy?k]?f ??c ??_ [q?)J?t??? ?Q???
?]zA? +mMMfiEN?J"*?)GMm ?tY??'P _uN\?A -?$?J?? ?+??w ??�E??p ?p?F?????? ?J?lW"s?f??NJ?W?#?.
k??q?4? P?{?a?UCs ?? ??oXA?T????|?Wtv$??????UX ? C?? ? ?3??? ??p | ????O??5?b ??
?5?_m"??\?2?????j?C ??44 ?: s[?? ??.? Gj??y?3b? ?5NO?k???;?;? b? ??{ ?^b ??V??;
a?C?}D*?B+?_( ?yv? +?/?5?6?R?8?3??lzl4 { ?? ???Q??k?? ????Z~t?u?? ??Ek?Xd??.?Z?;?Cv?y?????V%?a 4?a;? ?dp???R?? :n - E???t??"$? cKb6ur=??*5L?sWB?d ?Mh?$?R ? ?o Oh?? us ?#WYu[ ???Y ?? Ih 8 p ?H8b?q7??ok13?~V?& ?? wxK n??L?f"} ?M? ??t,???j" ?? ?):a?q??M???_?o?R??????C? nu?9?y?y?? ?? ]?&nVt8o ?? f?+?E ?? ?n?2k? ???4?3?(???J+???r? ???8?6-??gbC??Q?T??k??1??T %dq?9?a"M? v??u Gh?
??e ???[??�w??H?? M?hS?R??1R?Jj+? |L???6} ??J ^?e=?????/q?? ??wF?H? l??? ?1h1hu?% ?NO??7 ??? :C? ??k ?!? ?` ??Ftmbur ?????!d??B? ?+ ???0 ?.1?9?? u??R? [ }:?"ipT???L?Z8? t?c+??] k??`?]"?7 ?? EQ v?a? ?n?
8??``a?tH?> ??y/?s?? ?M? ?q????m?[?F ?i??w? ??_?? E)8 GDyo?% ? fBi�%:???q??? ?} %v ?8PZp=?%?=?`?l}?J?Lp??ZO???/??a?g??]?O?(? ?? M?�??)N? D???Ok???XJ?F??.?O?}?: ?YNB?y?? ? -????_?& ?D.???*? ?|G?_?? Q?b?36o,'8?^?q? ???|g?i?g;?R??M'?h?RH*S?& ?,j??WV*'6G??1?-??r b \ q? 1??H.T? !:?????R, ?O?? P??? ??,? sTL????;=Ql??nLp?~(x?!n??4H? ?j?&?f???P^?U ??? ?$???M?'?o/?*??@?^)Fik{? ? ?? mj ? ?/??)? ?F?.Z]? ?b g? ?5??:`z)ViK( ?7?? ?????t? ??? Z ?? 9??�E?5u`??? ? ??Ws<^?Q??xi??THd3?/??]k?)?Q???$??Z?c?%?` ?RO ?9?? ?~? ? ?^ NZ? ?8c? ???n?L'?^" ??s?,"?? W???4UK?L.?�5?T_??(d@!+}?C?h??|$q2Q? ?@ ?????~r??d ?1A??t???|+ @?#I\\?NSB?OQH?bd?b ?e??OPV? h?V.? ?,Hp??? ?? W?????VC&?)z?H ^r?bjzL??
??? ?p!? ???"?g:?? ?,T &b=?Qe%?]?{F?? ??/??
??rF u(\?? D??, \??: # ??odP???Y~???8%~Lm=?? EL ?,D(?k ?
3?????P>m?_ ? ?5 :??*7?? ?5]??h?e 7?E=?2??? hu? -?C??? ){?$[ gf??{ K | ?Y9? i8{???? 8Z ???pKQ l?c ?|.??v n??*?H?O2o ?h??R?9Q???8? ? ??? ? Y ?uZ(??0?*??Y? ????RW): =?R+ ?"???4???????z_???????b?i????}????E ??PhO ?? ? K?.?|?8???y?OF ^??
??r? ~? ? Q1kLBH8!??O`A*9?@?0???.???-^???b ?? ????_[? ?"?&r????2}{x??} ????i?& ?"
T??{? ?i"?[? ?C\ ?s? ?R???w? Q\(?? U?+]??
?j??&?L?Q????GP gd??_???XE? e ME.]?/% ??a??? ?C ?L 8ib;? ??SY? }XO? ?e: :k?q?(J?R ? �? X ???? = i?}??kT}??A?IF??WI??~q?fE?~?? o? ?0???Q?????uS?q? ??| 0m [O 'Ar ???l????FC ?=U|X? k?? ??c"o?\??.??U?D??j??F6F ???gtu? ?????????{??� ?y=o???A?\|? ??Et?? ,F??8?6?N1?J?|??W?Q? ?? q>9? 5g?]>8???F @? ???x?H?+F? ?Sk ??4 ?*p ????1p??}_i? ?g }???%?PC?}?? ?)6s �??+? ?4???????4?x? ?g??2??P? ?p5?F?k5??)?*-KF? ?&??T++p ?'??]?5L??X???Z~? Y ?b?? Z "?w;?' wy ??kj4: ?????gE? ?a4???IC |Zn ?R??k??f7? J?&)??~%b\ ?3r7qz+>? ? F???>?^??�? ?L?? ?? ?N??:? t h ?,? ?? ?(?B??f??, *????c-? "+?`3 ?x ????X??5 ???? ? k?W x?"}? ? ??????Z??6?*???C ?g3i?`kd?jj??85?(?B]?_?8?2: ? hj_? 'os[V?:;Mq ???tm??1/ ?,?=? ? n?{ ?; ?^i???,/??y ( ?4A?+MA?????L\?-?p? 9?S/v ??D? e:?} ??V?h l D� fQ????_? .?pt P??`JQI???^'-?V ????? LU <`|?# ?y@ ?m ? odc????H?LO?4?d Tt>z? 6??????K? a0?k?.???x[? l? 7 ?l;?�;Ob?/??,??J(.?$?@?5? Y?
-?>"??q+??Z? ??"?? ?P??u?V ?"? ? ?T!@?W?)??% ???S>? W??????8g?~ ????R?"?/Y0 ?? c?Z? s?o? ??f ?? 0Qbt b[ ??P^?bk?? ?$.???S???0 )+ ?C????3??{;? &??4? p??G??\ ?m6? ???4 V?k~?~?YM=?a x?6?b ??? ?fVR0P ? ? ??:?uW?S e???2T d? gUM3??O ??!X?u?zCzW????9??o????gdRJU g= ?m?|??? ~=Q"???,??[# Cr3?'?Z??Q??w??h?(? ??1}- k? ?Na? ??~S?G$?'??? ?t??8 ??[z0kZ ?l#c/? U?Ca??$?g?\??l??J?R/?????*? %x.??; ?? ? f*?hT?$?A9~M5?V?0`??u.K2?
?U ?-%;??? ;??B? v?Ay?L?01???j?? ? ?z f?< ?w??? ??E??s??X??@????m?/?9}F?+ ??Te?O?? Z?`>??+ {???? X? H^v?V?%4?? ??\e1?? ????? s?? ?O?TE?
? ?gE?? )}?f$??M ~?,Fc???d?O5?% E??a?V????G�}? *? ?Or H??A&???G ? ? ??U?Q/{lD.?�7?* ;n 1 J/?T? ?'"+}?5??wW???YJU??H?? ??? ? f?? ?
?^m1?>??a#6?v???? *q?+? ?e ?????e???, Q??j?m???M?%?b\9??@?Ez,,?[??/?�x? 6 55=G w) dqf? K_???R??y:_????D? ;M?&?:? ?q?,??b8??n/?|??|???? ????Ct U??kAuG ???8`(E??:??+??J0?xU5???$? 6? ?? '*J5{ 6??d?#l ?5B??+? ?%?yM.????I?B??'?rD?P66 ?1 #)C ?? ??? c?U ??? FQ? ? [\??O?
???2~G D??p?YO v?} ?`?a4?7?? ?JD^Y&?fww? ? -6?? ??? 4?o??x???%? ??? z ???t??AK?? R?Arq!4,? ???js???5?F?Q?OWK ?h? v??-Y??? ?>_?$???u???te`?: ?Q?4????k?b??5???'^?;????? 6??[=???DB{??e?????r &? ?V ?9 ??
?E? ?? Mg??n4?? ? ?p>??? ?3&??6?? ??Z?p? w?%q?? C >a\?
_?YR?D ?]U _? ?L????w??Q?? ?^???? ?+?.j? ?;??????h* s8z?XT im? ?2$_?3?Pk? ?|Y?zy ?o?xDH??6Cy?? h? e1l?v ? ?@C ?? ?\??????8??? $+?P?!?L??}F??0?3?F??`??????Y?O? `? 6??0?|??K?a?.???????1?? ?0??n]*P????"?_?a G}? ??37z5 (? I?? ??? ?N?t i??? ??8??L?ut^?? ? ~?x??J???xG ?A?p??Q??Y ??3 ?nj?1,??? ?L?(\???a??Q ?U]_?&?x????.L???V$?\z?=?lY??y?vPn?? L??,D ?e I?;? C, ?O?bFot?? a?3????R )???*?}!P? v????E ??(?V? ? L ??? m ????m???[0?%??? ~??? y?4;>|? . n?^?W6??6Gu??r{? ??? S8??;uO???~* ??JC?GSA?; ?QE ms??y??j]??"? ?Y?R??K+?.??N??k2Am??? b*?-????=?? Q?Y?S ???{??TO ?vp|?* ?? ?(kr y???????E) RJ ? G???%=An?ptQ?*??0?? ?z?? \?%??&"7?2? ?b? ?ny%}?N?z??@;???&? -qc?%? P?`L"??????N?*?$??jfW???_? ??D??9?? ?? ?; ?R@?u?DX?V??h9??* M?&m?s?g L???$? 7 ? `??W a6?p?9D? c?R?M???llI? ?eKL7?Z??gD? yj?TF \Nu?Q? Z,x?JL????????2??F???t /? ?=XP? ? $R ???j;k?n? Z???o?PK K U?? ��@ ��PK � � �?8?<������������ ���META-INF/manifest.xml???k?0 ????.?g!v?? ?mz?? c?Z i ?W????X?0 s????|?/ B'?C??=:/?N X?:3??e?6?S?&?w???j????Q%?,??)??f???r ?fhJ??2a;"; 0?7?? ??l P?J?T ?&w?? s)b:ZL??V?LP?5?u?}?y ? N :? *j?b+h?0`pS?uent!??}e? x T?p??2"( ? [?
u? ?L???7?S??d??
??(??LR%??5?F?UK?] ? ? !?: ?) >?????w?VH? ?u,???V ?Top