Gujarat High Court
SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION/11707/2009 on 20 January, 2010
Author: Ks Jhaveri
Bench: Ks Jhaveri
Gujarat High Court Case Information System Print PK �����;:5?\jE�h???,??L&$)???s??? g?< 4?^?fvx ] ? q?Y??| %???
qJ8rl"? P?%?} ?`zY? ?L???. -X??kU?l? ??M??? w2g H PC?q ?h?"V?_ ?S]&_?? 2 ?8 ?mv7 ?D??rP? ??i?Is?-? *?~?q?c?TH ?f??&??!K? ?=?}?.D,"??Z?-? 8??? P???0 ? ?
>?? ?="??? ?j?b??
T5}???#!i:S?^ % p??? KKeC? ??0?? R?U|??]p ????? ? ?y ??k b?o[?Y???f?:]T??ll?B?c?? ?C@?? ?\?r|????U?67!o???!? 1 ? ,???U?t??T???[?k? ???? Y} r)M@?2C? P?Z??V@? >? ??#? ]??b?7, ?'?? ?M ?O0???.?'??` ? ?;b$? ????&??/ T?V??
?s????x??o;0? ?&yX$?? V?6?[f94??v ? ? X { ???8?? ??gG?Zr?? ? ??Y, ?P?]??[uJ?swa:??o?? ?G?z$?!X_ 1 ???? ??,>"?6M?F$ ??7UV I> q?? I}+$?x q n# ?$??& )??%?;{??}RT ?^!??e?,ZkQ?W??uZ?j?H r u?Xu ????T^) 0??v??p?\Z/?? ?? ?==???^??Q?m??????\X=?\ ? ? G???y #$y K?V?mNU? {? U ?~@OmX?/????7Tc????6 ?$??s ?Aq?Q??-???p?c~?rs @ ?/">???y?EU ,???Y \d3??j?/[?Z?j? b?? ?Db?!?{ J>A?!?$????b?P?K? C?5E???o ? ??6] ?i? ? . T}b!?- ??'P+? MN? 4???? y? S ?$(f h0? ?g?�^~?8?S D?= G ?
Wk? EL?:z@?
? ?C-'??I]??D ? K4?d2????T?j?? ? ?7?%?S??[i?? ?? ? l?]?x?H''???I4"?F ?R }?:? R??x?O?-X4? ??�?? O ???? ? ??| ?s O~?T>#?R??h ?P?*h??e6??,??EF?/p?Q`?g I yI@?y??? 3?? ?^He ? ?2u ?'\*l #??
?g?s?f]A? }F!??P?>g? ?+ka P 4??W?YS T!??1K *? ???e?j? (?5?l?h?? *?i?k?WA T?? U{ ?k:? ?X- ??PY(? ???h?? y?#?$??4;&? bp *??6 ?????? ??| I?_???r~???? PK c??u? ��?:��PK � � �;:5<������������ ���styles.xml?Z?o?6 ~?_ah??dIv ?Y??Vl@? M Vh??D ???w$E?2%?i2?a}( ?????; ??$ ?P???C ??*??r!'i?? b&0?z?7-z ??S7} ?y ??C ?? Y? ?? ???$]?A???? ??I?5? ?p g?7*???@?MQ It?rN0 ?? ?? ????QB???? ?,????=3?? I??]?KAm??? L1'?n? D ?TZ?p? '?8???q ? ?}|?rL Tx?U?z ? =?T!?'?,{ {??1? ???3? &? ?5?S ??u ??- 3?S ?? ??'??]?E ??8???/ ??P?( ?F p@?P ???(?B? e?70 ? ???M? ?it??#?]?v?,?.? ?` 4?0S sQ?n??)}+? ??L@ ???3P.?? ??? ?FX ?0????6?V-?5?3l?y?]????jZ?b ?N? W???7X# ? ?bD79?? ?j� *8???Ci8 pD?_1?jQ??f??R y???IZ?(7?o? e"4dI ?1????Z 2??? ? 8K3? m*?C?T8'?R ??-A)?C?? (?n?? ????AD ".?R??P?Z? ?P ?)?7;E6? 7"?AT.? o?I??MF???HV _oex ?
? G?k U-\?w?s?S?< ZD?8A????4l ???, ?F?YB? =r??RMe'?~GWn??6??l?(?T;??Z 2??GUyX?> (m?? ?p :I? AW1? ?? ?h'`( ??@ ? ?} ???YuN? ?M* *?lN??Q[???p?Oz^y[? t?????f??C?d?t???R?O??J? pW \??(?x>???Z>?v?P$? ????z??1RX0??T??? ? }????m?`?1??0�?,?QK?v ? jxC????nl?H????6*n????,?O????4 ?7 ?m?? (i>n]\??y7} ??u??B??? Q JM?oe???Y?\???Tj|@?Y>??`?O?O@? jn???Ut9?? p?C?l? o?e?r???;??Xz5?? ?Uks??-???????>W}??xW? BU?(??9?T ~?? ????? ???? ?? PK ?l? ��G'��PK �����;:5 OpenOffice.org/2.4$Linux OpenOffice.org_project/680m12$Build-9286 aakar 2010-01-21T12:47:54 1 PT1S PK � � �;:5<������������ ���Thumbnails/thumbnail.png?zuXTo?'Hw)%? t7C? % Mt?Cw ??t?(?twJ7C? ~??>??^?{]???0?k?w???s o? p0?1 p A?`?w " :*?? ??< W?????g?A Z????n?w ! ?X3/?X???> ?T?`? ???)????#?M?E?? ?1 ?] #]d ??`??3????&K?OG?> >Kg-??f ?9;? ?Y:?M??z}|?0Uo????h? &??M???"?c ? ???^r?? D ?# Z{ I `?O?uv??j9?n s|?~??Fwt? q?y? ??=j??%???,?1;?he?? ??dqd? ?Y?#??�7? ??? ?s?9 "fT? si/?. ?? W?? B?/??? I?l?8? ???i??W?*,??????O&0?9*%}m,y????}6 ??
???L? ? ?? n?
?
??? t4 m{??LW ?CY????8>8N}?e?????|g??? %??Na>??Q? ?,{b:??? ?;]?? ??C? ?????P?% Gs;??w???wu<\T?+?qn?*?Z???Y?Z?pE?g ;? ?? q??|g??PH?|??N2?u?c???J? .; a?!]x ???7M?T??� ?`~bC?D?j ???Zq?? ??* ? ?????|?}%???r , ?)? ?y ?@t7$? ?{? ?B??V. ? ???T^? ??]?~?l?X9??
? ? ?? ????K? ???m?T?} @.??=w??4Q?j4?=??@? ??;?$4]ht? ?Z%c1 j?#?z[? ? FW ??S ??8J?p?A??T?? ??C> { ?? ?K? d? ??
bP ?p?X???B?Et?]???= '?uo W|zg?l?? ? !l!?h2??$??? ??;rVW?? ? ???x ??a??"???;????' ??~>*???N?C!?FO?????? ??)e?j? ? ? ?=j??W$Az?Gut???$ +;? ? > p?? X?O???????????jfcV? &?7?u0???( D?2???f ? ?5? ?x?z ? ? k?m ??/ G??? ??v?? ??,??b? T)??-?jd???p W??? ?0?o?O~ ??>??t???id???F?x???+?g?,e?? w? ??B? 1?l0??b ??1?=? ??????#~ d?cg??$?9? ? ??q?V? f4?~)?>??sw?g&???4 ?! ]'*?? �?~?!?id;j]?? ??:?;? (S-????t???Oq??q?_?A ?�? bW????`? F??Bb? d ?i?EyV1amA7? ?? d?? %?]WRz2 ?A?m@??Z?LD?P?]??a??mkG???x?[ .�?? Lvg
-?
$?? ?HjN!?m q7s?i0.?:-+?b?E ??z??9?X?N? yE?,w? 6????{?#? ??N-??D QA??H?? o-??x ?????? ?7P?{??s[?/??-?E??Jk??Q?l?x??=ZgE? b?>a ??? )? *X??V?b??-p! ??:2??? ???C???????
7U??? ??.
MW?�?|=?)??p 5X )?????? ??u???Z=O??a?\ ?#??????'?~@???[A???e????
??>? ?|?$ ??O?
?.??) ?5AW?b?\?=O???
wV"?h?T>? ??j? ??|??? a? Y P??�????F ??\T?D?�??6U??? [ ["??9=\CEa?? ?c'?D[)D Wv??`??
`??v?~a?OK^?^??* X{?< -?+UG| =F ?g?h-?G>h?>????A???c?[%2??0???h_?btH? ???@=?Tl e?3? ?a???Gf??k??Z Hwox?;??e?"z>J??q??
l]?C? ?<%??[?O? o ?f-?P>-8G`? ?|??v?GdRr?f(?6?>?48??A ? ?? ?lOS? ?r?$?f94CZ ,???&? ??K>G?S?>?]V??u?;???? +? ? L??? ??3[P [h?i??s ??T3?_&?J?=??f?_ |?J???f?|O g??B? ??K?jR7?A`y;2D?(??? ???zT\ +y7??'4?J1Z !1??
o??!?V? ???; ???U'?#T??g?? "Tf7?[?q?????|>???e&1 5???xR??}m?? :??Q@R?EOB? ?? ?(y:? +b???>?d~j"???H(?&9?{/~??b?? 9???-? :? NZ???v?N?8?|?^??s?9 $q?[?�??s?V�:???VIv??-O? E9?yn ?7?O??(_?s ??7???z_> 6s > ????Xo??V????@ "???] ? 7;???? ????:OY? ?q?w????Z??} h???2??? ? ? ?6?~)??i]??=??? ?????r??-?g??.`???? ??'=?-???q?\? ?\??f?? l?QM $-? M(???$?c?? ??i@?u m?+ ?.+?o?}? '#?2? ??g&H3? ? M? ?# d*?}? ?ol] \O?T:h?;? ? ?a??l/?D??g[ Z?%" MX;|??t? ??N??>??\????S??)v?? ?????: t?? v?BE?=? ??9p{? O? 3?al?j?k?? xv??> cq???yu?YB?s?m??: ? c?O2????8o ? _Y??~?b????fZ G?BM_??X?????4[E?????6?2???X????? `?` ?w ?�?P?? \Gz?? ?8 C?h (??:?v H??? ?4 Cak??q? ?? w#?u? k ?dZ4\�9?T??? ???|_ ? ?!????5T-g???k???M?c %x?L?(\um??????0S?lX? >?ZiX'??[o(? ?c ???C?F (?C ?b& I??a ?j???? q ?? ??D ??|?= r0\?r?c ?* 3??i@;?jb?S??q??. ?ju?6?'*[O???????D??g?,+u?Q1+s???)?? ?7j ??? ??U?vc?M#??8\ ????u:?&p? )y?;W w ????I???)f xd<%??? K? ?@?n?-?P?b$?,lS?<7 ?)?
??6?p????H?*?Um$*?? ??K?' ??$da?????j?E??.?K????s?T?y? `=?????n??% ?
?~??V ???? ?ri ? Y;?~l??$? 2?D~6 X ?X???$F?z?i ?Yd?M???TX?w? ???d+?A?v? ? ?g?Fs z1??: ?z ?m?(\- \???? i???z?E ?y?j?3 ??c?s J/??LvVB?p f?C ?1>? ??j?cja?c?; }?o?g? h??c 5 ??? Y?R?9?|D??>?PN??@i ?u3Gj ?w!~???p#?s 3?xA ?2x?.??}�S ?5?{?1`K1? ? ??R?f}e ?[?t?m??l[.4??m45??e?s?qQ ?p??j?? ???.0TnT?a ?G???v??* ~0?d? ?T???v??2?? ??3P?
???j?$^?g P\sI? ????o ~??f?f11C??[ G#z???? p???a87?(??? ??!g???X? ??s ?$??%1?n?)6??1??]=?z1| 5??]??v?p??r ?1?1kA?B>??1}? ? ? b? ?V???~? I??l*???c? y?4=G ?bJ ?qsO?@?^??? ?4?iyL? I9????M???(' ?? ? ? ??? Z W?Fb? n? M J~??Z 3?b?7?*n?P?? e?6?/? ?> ?x??o?s?$e*f_ ? ?????C? w?Cb? w" ??:??][?? ??V??C0L??L???)?~zR0?Fa ?? ???? ???T??Q�??+??Y? p??*?`n?3@??D'z5?ke[?V#??>*???5?>?[?W6?E????????G?X?h?o %?Gd???^&?,e;?? ? ??oq6???? ?.?s{9"? ?? ???:n?v???%????v? M?}?n?8J?g+?7p????g??cn?0??!?&??i?:z?U?^ ?? ??? $c? �]e$(??Y?f?m????Y?????)???????? ]Y??n.U^??? [F| h?& ?*? ?O???-??/????h??Z??z?=?+Pr O?* 6?[?~}[ ?? e ???G ?)t?5?a?`+??Z??? ?U????l+, ?'a ??? ?Q Cl8$? O?`,?F? F??~ ??C !P? ??C?0?a?KW c:5???B?N?1?? ?x???%? o?*cwk?V??Z?gR ?V?+v??Md?I???>??U&Q O ????+????-??seiN?7B?^;?Es ?:C???- /?K ~??G?gmF?t}? Z??:?z T?#???D?e?i???S??U^ ?V?u?ya???pb? Z ? 6??6??\ f ????R\??
? s ? Y??\ \ ????????ym\]?/a?WS ??#???g??? X??Q?gs?"�???? f??S? ? ??jBbV???M??wS?Nk %?\?EN +H?|?9?S??
?? ??g?p+]?h?????? ??R?? ? 0 ??%J???#? ?tj5r ??,t d ?@ ?keQ? $K?^ b D???BW?j?W?T?!???_????E??&x?v?~??)?K?u? ?i????=??' J?j~}??1 ??????J??q? ??*D?r A?k? ??3? ?.?? L]?_ ?? t??cwV?a ?3?:???l?9k?-0xg???`Kj???D?83?,?/n?9?]??!?{??m?1PM???: e?|??M???;?.??v?? ??C?$??N?{??C?
?K }'A?u Mw?G?}#?;}8j?@VW ?J ?BP????�e?\)?5?S6?
?'?Q? ?5? ?E ??? ?@;V?`? ?wJ/??q?r ?? ?vc[ ?\+?mOf??1??6YL JB?{f? ???? ??E??C??gD[M ? !??????_Vm ZN??? ?9 ?? 3.?m?U?7g?f5? *???A? h{ Z?A???n? f? ???H~ ?P?(?p??t?'#??? #r0??????:C?r??`?}?
8 ?)? ? ? ?@ ?i&a?A7??bK/?? +.?5 2w=?S?x?l?? ??@= ?5???4X? ? 6 %???C??
? ? ?&@Cu.I ? J9d2 f*V? ? s? ???X??uDw~??}�?`s????J5=??j$?U??\??4???/? ?:h??S???? ?+s^???~?
?? !??L?MsT?q[?K??????z???enK???? *1?? ?sc??cV?.7 ?"?81 ` ??w M? ???? ?V0|B?( =7?b]`??? ??r? ?_$J_^o Z?? 63?$`}$ ?-z ??s?T?Au????<9?(? i?~a??@?/?8 f??|q ?? ? ?9'?q?%a?#?,u T? : Bp i L? @ ?'?K?????`|?/J? ?* 7??^?Ha? ???? ?>?18?M?>?f ??j{ ??SHJ??4??%??b�?^?H?3??&?[Td?'N??;v ???y5G? ?r???^????]bv"? ?U ?-??Ef6?+(7 5a]6QE?????]??~ ?D}??{?? #??g^?9?k??h?Z?? ??6J???A??Ix ?? i?_??n??? ???6B0i??k ^W?_?? ?? 2?|6??n???; E?? ???Nx?R?q T?'???E2??[.? C? ? 8N? ?c?o? g???i&??3U&?? /?? ????>H??%\? ?8?w] ?4?? f 3?X?#??(?$?@s???-???@??0?|? Z?;}c?? ?v -?
??o??J ????u?2??G. ??T$!? ??1;? ?*?X: 7?BX??'??
?^t?J X??]??M ?z?D?Q{?LV?w? d !m?E ?1???? ? ?????9R?-= G? b???Ia?60?=]ids?\7?)?g`?)y?? ?[G? ???C?L??????????K ?H?m?USU<2 ???l??q? PK $ >UN.��?/��PK � � �;:5<������������ ���settings.xml?Y]s?: }??"?w?G>?d :??^ ?> { ??Z?$ ??]FI$?FO X>?v??]n?-C~?
R (n??i?9 ? ?m?4?T?:????t xp? ? tE?D???B]??o????u?? ??S??j?V?U??N? ?e?~?X?. ??j?t??C1 f `??? ??????I2?? _w?kK? 6oR?? ?@Ch??~ ,$?_ Xl|???~?/Z?J`c??? ???I ???C?2? ???,? !%?? ?? JN?:??]?JK?_?i??Q?&??E?V uO????kWEQU0?`!S \ ??� ?%I????k)? j?a??/ ?p#?cB}?9J ? ?0O? ?_ ? p?4? I_ ??/???Y??/ m9L?? ?d?4?3?????I6f ??y? ? " = #???>H?=~? ?{? ?/�??8??? ??Jy?|??x ?% ?=??j??(?L??N ?&3?K?'tW?t ???? ??0??L?ut^H 7" 8???^?0#??$R?0??< ? ??g :? cXB)?p\:%???? #???8?? 5Q6??=??wa .?[?`r?T ?1,?dQ_?[) m ?
???,�:?g??K? ?? ?c ? ? O?? ?b?/?ny%}?N?z??@;??6&? -?cSB C?^X?j-MQE-c ?\U? IT ?6???? dK??s\${P'?f? nA??K ??! ~N[?L?
V?????? ?+?6?9?? &b?[ ?PC0u?+?1 OX? "f??u?`'}2v6?D? ?c+???ZO??D?
yl?TF lNu?Q? Z?{?I?????????2'????c???^ 1Z?{?????7H?&?/??'g?l???;hu?o???PK D??V? ��E ��PK � � �;:5<������������ ���META-INF/manifest.xml???k?0 ??? ]??S??X ??A ? ?k H??\??? ?? ?~]K??? ??&?ZF;?Nh??~?c ?L?B?)? ? 6 ??????m??j?D???m ?6??Y?b??A?, ?a?m 0_???\? ?,b?$?? ? ?R??? t??? ?z}h (:I?? ?"?u???15 S??"? ???? ?U B?w+ -;]*????T? \?qY?iU????l7�G???r?
_H??D??F ojT?#???n9??;?Ik? .j^????? ?i"?O_? Iv ? ? ? ???r??? gUN.��?/�� �������������? ��Thumbnails/thumbnail.pngPK � � � �;:5 Top