Karnataka High Court
M/S Padma Phardmaceuticals vs The State Of Karnataka on 11 June, 2012
Author: K.Sreedhar Rao
Bench: K.Sreedhar Rao
25:2' 'Egg Efigg £@i;¥R'§ ms'
€§§.c§§§*§ EEEESE-E A'? aigigggggg
:}g3;§§:,§ m:$ 'mg um ms; 0:? g;z;':=~§E 2:} :;,2j
BEFGRE '
mg; 'e:@3»r§:3: :\;;R,J:;g3':§<:i§ % éé;ég:';%:%gé;Q_';%«.
€RIE';E?§,:'%L §?E'E'§"§'§§§ 1
§E"§'§?§?'EE§€:
- ¢ éE§§é€T,Ei§E'S fssr 2./'{:}E:%{:§g C33/:VE%;2'z:"§2:.
I :¢:'$:';v,.TE%?§;3§;é;:r:§§:§E1 Segati gévacaigé
A / p22_{1§:':2: P§";3,:'::":;> M
. S2": ?23,dm'_;,,:*g:'
e
2:éf:'.:"::a; gs; ' __
E'«l{§,8~<§c'%E 5' 2.}: ::;;§s;£,::--i._ V f%}:*iii ;:*:;:sa{§"~-{,%~:;§%3E2;:*§,§e:;
§;€§§€:$e§:%:§:<i Egy ;32¢2;:**a:2(:;:"<'.~;; ' 2
Eff:
* 8.," . v -_
rs:gz%§':%§4.,;v ;' V. ;1€f;%.:1i§;_{tamgzgti;scV:'fi%,'§3é&:":+;<>2":
{>fE'%i;';~:e.5 ?2?:g:E:<§::: gséégxfn I
, E" ;;." 'V EA 1' flips ;i2_;:§:":;; 'ism __ ya} 53: ifisméés Zi§"°§§;E[iE
Rf as E f*§:3 E E' » 3:5; 3; %;?:21
?;%;V;»;:2fE}§::s..g1é' £.':s§'§:7 'i;Z7§':.::'§j§ {}j;:'
S2"; :%:f€2§': E<:u:?%§ 'V1z:*{:;' .?:;.:§§
<'};, §V>:::f€VV:z<%'§" zizézii €ji'i>¥E'E§3€:§',{?iEET §}::'%i'S1%{}§E
~' Rf? }'::eé §'*23ai§':1-32;:Hgizzmxazzséeazéiazésa
M a?"5:'a::é.€:ia':::é.::%*::_'
.&"§'*%§§:
5;
__ "*7f§2::% <3? §§.2:z':':a§:;i1E<2:2
v»'§§%':]T:*:::a;L:,;;gE2 §}:*:2;;§;s'5 §2¥'§;E5;§%3{t§',{}§ if_§z;:_'§§::z;?::*;;::V
' €iié§i€.:'% :fi§§E£::;? {sf éiézs fizz-ésség {Z::;::§:*a,;£Es:i::'
% __ C€_>EEé:~.§§:': VE%.<i>:_3::§;§ §:«;§{i§fi2,1, §*§z2.V;;;:::,
= -»v.§:§%§i§7G§%.,§'§;§~:3%
E%E€'g;2:*a%$a:§':;as:E $3}; $3? 33%;}: @:}:::*§;: :i;2§
M
§i€%.1"2}E%.§T2':}§i€;':,, ii?/:§:'z:f::,V1§%;¢ 'i%§z~:§A':{:§;3* €%:;?:;>;':,:';;3;2;:..
§'€?§3ssp<>§;::%31:%
{E37 Sri. Suéizagia Eviaiiagmz E-i£G?:E
'E'hi:is: €:*;z":1é:':2;:§ §3*::%'i§':<>:/2 féézsiji 2.:::1:;§e;::° 3
€3:i?,€€ by $16 :%{§v<2{:23§;,e iE::::* §:%':€: __;3.r:2'::%;_t:Z<}r;--z:z*
i;;V%::2:f':i"~té1~é3i?. V'
i',h§.$ Ei{s::'i:2i€ Cauré; to :;1Ek3w 'fie };::3§i'i:_;é:>:2, __3§;'~§3'.j;%e7
$316 a:":;§€:' ;::2'zs;5;@{i cm da'::${§; 22.$"3.2F5_3EV"i2 éiéfg. _f;E:e E::%_i:.'.'§§é;{
£«€}EE':'3j, :3? é;h§:> E2?' Aaiiafii §};T.3i:,'_ 2113:? 8:"»:s§§§<'3:§§fs' ";:»::?i .'
G::%'§21:(;ga ii': {§1'i,g~':;:>pé§2:§,;"*€{t@,:i'>-E. ;2_:}€§.VVE§"z::i?:%EVé'"£f§i>a,m:"
'E/::} suspé-anti iiéséj s3<-3:§%::e:2<:£: g>21$5--:x::'~:<i§ u.:;1£:§:§r":§é;€ §:.:x:ig::2€:":%: <35
<:::>::vé<:':i{:::"; zzgaézzsé; ':if:€*:~._§é:*§,if§§§:%:<§:*:;; C§C{?%}"'{;,¥2"8s:E;'28G4
{H3 ézyéed 2;2'@2:.2s:2 aha: :~:Lg;:*%%;§L%:VV% of tbs: gixswa
2:: Aiéaipazy and Gffiééi' 3:3 §§8"§:§§§€_;;:}'i€:"S 6:: 333::
E3135 p:i~é;:%""
::{?;s§":%;:;:§~': 9:1 §?:;%_§-- .£:__;§Vf?::§:$§;é{t::'2 :7:E1é:s (E3132
ii/E253 <§<::2:/mg :i%§2?'i<i§é~ '
__ §'<3§ %3x>s;vi%.:': §§';_ '
...
'§E3%:::'-- '2,é£ff§'*f"ii,:i"§»;%§§V4 g3s:€1:V--i§:i'éV;--:§é:§"$ $2.221??? §§€i{§ an zipgssgzi ':E:€:%«..'Scsés;§z,:§:':$A_$i}j;:;ré§ GE,§§}"}2,1E'§':3:21ig 2::§>§3E*;€a"éé::::
mm :3_{E%9{E} {§§"f:if:_"f_._;?;{i9 §3:;»z* iraf :e:é:2?:§eV::{':a3 is; V §'§E'§§3 §.§j{:>'/":Ag'«E:.£'/E?-{}(:3d . = "$26 fins Ekffiiéiééié, £52; ;:'§ié::§;s:,}:/:«;%*;:s3€§;. :'%€ii§':§€EE€3€ s 5:s2;i§i;j::€:"::::E5~::E e/:«;:;%<?V:.:i:;i;:'2;§? f%><>§:::E §:;>;: 2: segzmz :35 ';
{§%é1a€3€}€C};"~ ssaiih i'%.?§"§h (ms: $:2§::~':'i:§; E:*»€;;§§s:*€ éhe Eriaé Saafi, ';/5:: ééézzai 'z'E¥;:::':; éfézzsézzgg ;:a§%:':<1€%:";<%;=* <25 %5;E/35:3 a_};>s:aE 'é3€a§'s:>:':*% §§"§{;? {?<;>:::'%1.
A{:<':<§:"{ié:/'zzziyi, {::"§mi:'1:;3§ pisééiémz is; 2?a§E::;:§*e%_::§:.. \»,/ SS':