Central Administrative Tribunal - Delhi
Jyotsna Singh Kukreja vs Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti on 13 July, 2022
1
O.A. No.1810/2022
Item No.32
Central Administrative Tribunal
Principal Bench, New Delhi
O.A. No. 1810/2022
This the 13th day of July 2022
Hon'ble Mr. R N Singh, Member (J)
Hon'ble Mr. Tarun Shridhar, Member (A)
1. Jyotsna Singh Kukreja,
C/o- Tarun Kukreja,
Aged about 39 year,
R/o- Flat No-423, G/F, B-Block Pkt.C,
Lok Nayak Puram, Mundka,
West Delhi-110041.
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
Fazilka, Punjab.
2. Sujit Kumar,
S/o- Nandlal Prasad,
Aged about 30 year,
R/o- Mohalla mathuriya po Bihar Sharif, Dist.
Nalanda, Bihar-803101
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
JNV Sheikhpura (Bihar) Patna RO.
3. Skand Kumar Chaubey,
S/o- Tribhuvan Narayan Chaubey,
Aged about 30 year,
R/o-Babatapur Post-Niyardeeh,
Cholapur Varanasi
Uttar Pradesh-221101
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
JNV FAIZABAD.
4. Saroj kumari,
D/o Sh.Kanwar Singh,
Aged about 39 year,
R/o- Hno.335A, sec-3, Rewari, Haryana.
2
O.A. No.1810/2022
Item No.32
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
Jnv Kareera, Mahendragarh, Haryana-123401.
5. Manoj Kumar,
S/o Sh. Om Prakash Gupta,
R/o- West of Udit Roy House Chhota Telpa
Chapra. Bihar-841301.
Aged about 41 year,
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
Gopalgnaj (Bihar).
6. Chandra Singh,
S/o- Devi Singh,
Aged about 52 year,
R/o- Bhati ki dang, foy sagar road, GC-2,
Boraj Ajmer, Rajasthan-305005
Presently working as :
Counsellor, Group-C.
JNV-Mavli udipur, Rajasthan
7. Dharmendra Kumar,
S/o-Lala Prasad Chaurasiya,
Aged about 32 year,
R/o- AT- Chaurasiya Nagar, Po- Pachaukhar,
Ps- Deo, Dist- Aurangabad,
Bihar- 824202.
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
JNV-Nawada Bihar.
8. Renu Kumari,
W/o Prasun Saurabh
Aged about 42 year,
R/o-Plot No. 226A Venkateshwara Temple Road
Mythri Nagar Phase-2 Madinaguda
Miyapur Telangana- 500049.
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
JNV Rohtas Region Patna.
3
O.A. No.1810/2022
Item No.32
9. Rakesh Kumar Pathak,
S/o- Sarvjeet Pathak,
Aged about 31 year,
R/o- Hanumaan Mandir Narhan Kerakat
Jaunpur. 222142.
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C..
JNV Ambedkar Nagar Uttar Pradesh.
Region Lucknow.
10. Nishant Saini,
S/o Sh.Mahabir Parsad,
Aged about 33 year,
R/o- HNO-933/18, Moholla Sainiyan Hisar,
Haryana-125001.
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
JNV Roopvel Navsari Gujrat Region Pune.
11. Indu Pareek,
D/o- Mr.Buddhi Prakash Pareek,
Aged about 37 year,
R/o- 33, Narayan Vihar Sec-3, Pratapnagar,
Sanganer, Sec-3 Jaipur,
Rajasthan-302033.
Presently working as: Counsellor, Group-C.
JNV Kupada, Banswara 2.
Region Chandigarh..
12. Dimple Pareek,
D/o- Buddhi Prakash Pareek,
Aged about 33 year,
R/o- 27, Vinayak Nagar, Dholi Magari,
Hiran magari, Sec.4, Udaipur-313001
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
Jojawar, Pali, Rajasthan Region Jaipur.
13. Km. Falak Naaz,
D/o- Nizim Khan,
Aged about 31 year,
R/o-827/195/1996 Amba Vihar,
Gali-no.5. Muzaffarnagar-251002
4
O.A. No.1810/2022
Item No.32
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
JNV Murshidabad West Bengal-742101.
14. Reena,
D/o Rajmal,
Aged about 30 years,
R/o Village, Dhanouri,
Distt-Jind-126116
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
Jnv Palwal Rasulpur Haryana Region Jaipur.
15. Nilesh Kumar Mandal,
S/o- Rajkishor Mandal,
Aged about 34 year,
R/o-Village-Post-P.S.Panjwara
Block Barahat Distt.Banka.
Bihar-813110.
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
Jawahar Navodaya vidyalaya,
Nagarpara Bhagalpur Bihar.
16. Rukhsar shameem,
D/o- Md. Shameem,
Aged about 30 year,
R/o- S 10/78 M 7 Hukulganj,
Varanasi-221002
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
Jnv Ambedkar nagar (UP)-224122
Region Lucknow
17. Sweety Kumari,
D/o- Mr. Chandrika Kumar,
Aged about 34 year,
R/o- VILL+ Post Korai P.S.-Garhpura,
Distt. Begusari, Bihar-848204.
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
JNV Arambagh Hooghly West Bengal-712613.
Region Patna.
5
O.A. No.1810/2022
Item No.32
18. Mansha Upadhayay,
D/o-Late Shree Surendra Upadhayay,
Aged about 35 year,
R/o Gorakhpur Siktour Chouraha,
Jungle Ayodhya Prasad,
Uttar Pradesh-274603.
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
JNV Faizabad-224133
Region Lucknow.
19. Archana Dubey,
D/o- Manoranjan Dubey,
Aged about 31 year,
R/o- JNV Aipurduar- Bihar-841226.
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
JNV Alipurduar, West Bengal.
Region Patna.
20. Munish kumar jain,.
S/o- Inderjeet Jain,
Aged about 30 year,
R/o- 33A. New Master Colony Jhalawar.
Rajasthan-326001.
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
JNV Rajasamand Distt. Rajsamand Rajasthan.
Region Jaipur.
21. Baljeet Singh,
S/o- Kartar Singh,
Aged about 31 year,
R/o- Chunna, Teh. Bhaderwah, Distt. Doda,
P/O Udrana,
UT Of J&K-182221.
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
JNV Rakh Jaganoo Udhampur,
UT of J&K-182124 Region Chandigarh.
22. Dr.Ritu.Bhatia,
D/o- Mangi Lal Bhatia,
Aged about 30 year,
6
O.A. No.1810/2022
Item No.32
R/o- House No- 1-A-29,Hiran Magri Sec-7,
Udaipur, Rajasthan-313002
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
JNV Jhalawar (Jaipur region).
23. Ms. Kausar Ali,
D/o- Haidar Ali,
Aged about 31 year,
R/o- Village Alipur mandara,
Post Mandara Jakhania,
Dist- Ghazipur
U.P-275203
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
J.N.V. Radhauli, Basti U.P- 272151
Region Lucknow
24. Shantilal Joshi,
D/o- Kamla Shankar Joshi,
Aged about 40 year,
R/o- V/p Hemra tq Sunel dist. Jhalawar,
Rajasthan-326513.
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
Jnv Jhalawar Rajasthan region Jaipur.
25. Anuradha Sharma,
D/o- Sh. Som Nath sharma,
Aged about 38 year,
R/o- H. No191. Narwal bye pass road,
Jammu-182111.
Presently working as :
Counsellor, Group C.
JNV Arnora Ghat Doda,
Region Chandigarh.
26. Himanshi Singh,
D/o- Ghanshyam Singh,
Aged about 31 year,
R/o-215, Sainik Vihar,
Delhi-110034
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
J.N.V Barnala, Punjab-148108
Region Chandigarh.
7
O.A. No.1810/2022
Item No.32
27. Neetu Kumari,
D/o- Ashok Kumar,
Aged about 36 year,
R/o- H.No-40, Gali No-7/2,
Shakti Vihar, Mithapur,
South Delhi-110044.
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
JNV- Phalahi, Hoshiarpur, Punjab-146001.
Region Chandigarh.
28. Khushboo Rai,
D/o- Kamalesh Kumar Singh,
Aged about 30 year,
R/o- Kachhwa Bazar Mirzapur U.P-231501.
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
JNV Gyanpur Bhadohi 221304.
Region Lucknow.
29. Deepika Yadav,
D/o- Saroj Kumar Yadav,
Aged about 30 year,
R/o- Manik Nagar Colony Nai Basti Phulwariya
Varanasi Cantt-222127.
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
Gwaliar Region Bhopal.
30. Mrs. Rani Kumari,
D/o- Harihar Prasad,
Aged about 41 year,
R/o- Basbaria Chowk,
Sursand Road, Sitamarhi.
Bihar-843302
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
JNV,Supaul. Bihar Region Patna
31. Dr. Arula Kumari,
D/o- Mr.Bhuwneshwar Prasad Sah,
Aged about 34 year,
R/o- H.No. 62, Adarsh Nagar, Baridih,
Jharkhand-831017.
8
O.A. No.1810/2022
Item No.32
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
JNV, West Singhbhum, Jharkhand.
Region Patna.
32. Annapurna Kumari,
D/o- Rama Shankar Ojha,
Aged about 46 year,
R/o- Jawahar Navodaya Vidyalaya,
Shahjahanpur, At- Hathoura bujurg,
Shahjahanpur.U.P-242306.
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
JNV ARWAL Bihar Region Patna.
33. Akanksha,
D/o- Arvind Kumar Pandey,
Aged about 30 year,
R/o- Prabhunath Nagar,
PO-East Telpa, Saran,
Chhapra, Bihar-841302.
Presently working as :
Counsellor, Group-C.
JNV SHEOHAR Bihar Region Patna.
34. Arbaaz,
S/o-Firoz Alam
Aged about
R/o- H. no 149,
Mohalla Khanazada, Machhlishahr,
Janupur, Uttar Pradesh-222143.
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
Jnv Pekhubela Una (174303)
Himachal Pradesh Chandigarh Region.
35. Rekha Laddha,
C/o-Sureshchand,
Aged about 41 Years,
R/o-59 p Sumer Nagar ext,
New Sanganer Road, Mansarovar,
Jaipur Rajasthan-302020.
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
Dholpur Rajasthan Region Jaipur.
9
O.A. No.1810/2022
Item No.32
36. Jyoti Shrivastav,
D/o- Mr Ratan Lal Srivastava
Aged about 29 Years,
R/o- S8/376H1 Khajuri Gola,
Pandeypur, Varanasi cantt U.P 221002.
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
JNV Jogana Lohardaga Jharkhand,
Region Patna.
37. Nisha Mishara,
D/O Om Prakash Mishra
Aged about 39 years,
R/o-Triveni Nagar 1 Nirala Nagar
Lucknow-226020
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
Hugli W.B. Region Patna.
38. Anita,
D/o- Sukhbveer Singh,
Aged about 37 Years,
R/o- Faridabad Haryana-101213.
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
Lumami Village Zunhebuto Nagaland
Region Shillong
39. Aasha,
D/O Mr. Mishrilal, 148 U
Mahuaisugharpur, Durga Chowk
West Gorkhpur, Siyar,
Uttar Pradesh-273016
Presently working as:
Counsellor JNV Anni Divang Valley
Region Shilong.
40. Kahkashan Parveen,
D/o- Mohd Ainul haq
Aged about 30 Years,
R/o E-392, St-12, Shastri Park, Delhi-110053
10
O.A. No.1810/2022
Item No.32
Presently working as: Counsellor, Group-C.
JNV SURANKOTE, POONCH, J&K
Region Chandigarh.
41. Annu,
D/o- Mr. Shiv Kumar
Aged about 30 Years,
R/o- Vill. Assaudha Todran, Asoda
Todran (28), Jhajjar Haryana-124505
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
Jnv Ambala Region Jaipur.
42. Rocky Sharma,
S/o Sh. Gopal Krishan,
Aged about 31 Years,
R/o-VPO Rehal Dhamalian,
Tehsil Jammu -181132,
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
JNV Nud Samba (J&K) Region Chandigarh
43. Shabnam Kumari Dobra,
D/o- Balbir Singh,
Aged about 33 Years,
R/o- 143 Bir Ghaggar Chandimandir
Panchkula,Haryana -134107.
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
Jawahar Navodaya vidyalaya,
Sec 25W Chandigarh.
44. Deepika Kumari
D/o- Sh.Prithi Singh
Aged about 30 Years,
R/o- H.no-62/2, vill - Har,
P.O- Talwar, teh-Jaisinghpur, District- Kangra,
Himachal Pradesh-176096.
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
JNV Lahaul and Spiti.
45.Harish Kumar,
S/o-Narayan Singh,
11
O.A. No.1810/2022
Item No.32
Aged about 34 Years,
R/o- Vill Susan P.O.-Chambi,
Tehsil Sundernagar
Distt. Mandi Himachal Pradesh-175018.
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
JNV Kullu.H.P
46.Kumar Ashutosh,
S/o Bhag Singh
Aged About 38 Years,
R/o- VPO. Jalari Teh. Nadaun Distt. Hamirpur
Himachal Pradesh-177042
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
JNV Mandi Region Chandigarh
47. Ranjana,
D/o- OM Prakash
Aged about 38 Years,
R/o- Vill- Dareota, PO- Piplughat,
Teh- Arki, District- Solan H.P. 173235
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
JNV Mandi. Region Chandigarh
48.Sarika Sanju,
D/o- Raghbir Chand,
Aged about 30 Years,
R/o- Vill. Bholi P.O. Kasba Kotla Teh. Jaswan
Distt. Kangra H.P-177111
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
JNV Pekhubela Una H.P
49. Kiran Vijay,
C/o Sh. Harish Negi,
Aged about 35 Years,
R/o-Flat no.403,Basant Vihar,
Kasumpati, Shimla 171009
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
12
O.A. No.1810/2022
Item No.32
JNV, Kothipura,
Bilaspur Himachal Pradesh.
50. Aanchal Chauhan,
D/o- Jagdish Chauhan,
Aged about 30 Years,
R/o- Neri Ratoli (62) Pabiana,
Sirmaur, Himachal Pradesh 173101.
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
JNV Hamirpur H.P Region Chandigarh
51. Mohd. Imran,
S/o- Late Mr. Abdul Waheed
Aged about 38 Years,
R/o- Barielly, U.P-243503
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
JNV U.S Nagar, Rudarpur, Utrakhand
Region Lucknow
52. Shivani Sharma,
D/o Vijay Kumar Sharma,
Aged about 29 Years,
R/o VPO-Khairi, teh-Bishnah,
District Jammu-181132
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
Jnv nud samba. Region Chandigarh
53. Sabeeha Parveen,
D/o-Shafiullah,
Aged about- 33 Years,
R/o-Behind,gurudwara,
Saddupur, Chunar, Distt. Mirzapur,
Uttar Pradesh-231304.
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
JNV Patratu Ramgarh Jharkhand
54. Yogesh Kumar,
S/o- Mehar Singh,
Aged about-33 Years,
13
O.A. No.1810/2022
Item No.32
R/o- Gangana teh Gohana Sonipat,
Haryana 131302
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
Jnv jind Haryana..
55. Sonam Vishnoi,
W/o Naveen Kumar
Aged about 33 Years,
R/o-Vill. Badhpur post sherpurpati
dakhli mustphaba Muradabaad
U.P.-244601.
Presently Working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
JNV North Sikkim Phodong
Region Shillong
56. Monika,
D/O Vazeer Singh
Aged about 31 Years,
R/o-VPO. Farmana khas teh. Meham
Distt. Rohtak-136132
Presently Working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
JNV Niwarsi (Kurukshetra)
Region Jaipur
57. Anand Kumar Bhagat
S/o Sushil Bhagat,
Aged about 32 Years,
` Maniarwa Khajauli
Madhubani Bihar-847228
Presently Working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
JNV Saupaul
Region Patna
58. Sarita Prajapati
C/O Rajendra Ram,
Aged about 33Years,
R/o-Graam Mahuwari
Post-Jamuawan Thekma Jamuwavan
Azamgarh U.P-276303
14
O.A. No.1810/2022
Item No.32
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
JNV Saran Region Patna
59. Puja Kumari
D/O Radhey Shyam Prasad,
Aged about 32 Years,
R/o- Village Mouna Sadha Road,
Post-Chapra, Distt. Saran,
Bihar-841301.
Presently working as:
Counsellor, Group-C.
JNV Madhubani Region Patna
.......Applicants
(By Advocate : Shri C.M. Jha with Ms. Draksha
Khan)
VERSUS
1. UNION OF INDIA
Through the Secretary
Ministry of Education
Department of School Education and Literacy
Govt. of India,
Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi-110001
2. Navodya Vidyalaya Smiti
B-15, Institutional Area,
Sector-62, Noida,
Uttar Pradesh-201301
....Respondents
(By Advocate : Shri R. Gowrishankar for Shri S.
Rajappa and Shri R.S. Rana)
15
O.A. No.1810/2022
Item No.32
O R D E R (ORAL)
Hon'ble Mr. R N Singh, Member (J) :
At the outset, learned counsel for the applicants seeks permission of this Tribunal to withdraw the present OA, with liberty to the applicants to file a better OA. Permission is granted.
2. Accordingly, OA stands dismissed as withdrawn, with the liberty, as aforesaid.
There shall be no order as to costs.
( Tarun Shridhar ) ( R N Singh )
Member (A) Member (J)
/rk/