N Ravishankar vs State Of Karnataka on 31 January, 2011

[Cites 0, Cited by 1]

Karnataka High Court

N Ravishankar vs State Of Karnataka on 31 January, 2011

Bench: Manjula Chellur

B E'f'V\? BEN:

1.

E'?

'EN 'FE"'H%Z E'-H'GI'3' COLE R71.' (3? K;"s..§'{Nz1'£"AKzX EX"? l:§AN(};'X§JZ3I{§*3 :)m'1:::1;) "I:---1:15; mi; 31.3? 1:2;-W <;>_£«"' L};-mtg-11_z3r". :25; PRES}? ?\ET:

"1."'Z---11?:.fTT{ON'IE3}.,E3Z RS. J:33':':<::::. E\,«r'I,z'\1f'\§J{,.?I.;':--$11?-1';E%f£.;§;i.J«E'~}i "

A;"£' Ii "mm-~~10N*£31,§§ W2. J'"§ES'I'ICE, 9;.axs.§<:'1:i§1=1;xx:;:.;as'§é'§Iz.§%;j3?A?§;A;"

WRIT P£I'<3'I'"'E"§'IGN No. 182:'é[§fe;.";<i;E'*_2e5és--5é§34z%A'é'ég NRAVESE-'izkNI{;\R. H AGED AE30_E,3";f"__:§«? ':5-":§,A:a:~:+, _ ;x8s£s's'A:.\v; 'f--::s:'1_s:c:t.3'm! :3 §2:N<:_ N{)¢282?*3 '~«2L'i .5.I'g:xI:\:,.':;'m..C%:_0::h:;, .

:)AyiAN2;g'E,7.:;:;_5';*?'ogzgj ?vf;.,_I').Muijﬁ}LE'--i:~;§?<::S~H. ..1a«:'aj§a':': iv, AGREE 4.zx£3c:~m'V .25:-;

ASSIS3-'IZIX*I\;"Z' Ir::f>«;§?%*,<:t L,?TI"'»JI%3 r'::N<.;zN.1:£::=a _:m3, fs5;w.'_;:>.., :'~;m;2 ::~;:'<'.2'1s3;:<>N§ é gik/Eg%'*;'L,11.\'3%d;'i',;i_V .. 'rAg§_.,zx;r:;Yzx .£i}ES'E'§'¥:§£f5E1 ' n ., §§'§'g'I'.~3;-»i--:>;z*a~-- .m'z;'§<':m' m2.._ " V _ ";xa:;'::_::: »A:'»:3§>";§';' 45 'r'E.iz'a}j%.S, ._ " ;'gsf':s":§g<z:A3».:'f:'4' §*£X£%3{.TU'E"EV§§ .E-%ZE?€{}§N§%Z§£E?;. ' N<:.4:. MW SE3£3~Ef}E"v'ES£GN, "?¥:'EA--Eg2X'i;'Ai#I.,E4 M;:3~:"::3m §')ES'i'R.§{fI'E'.

A " = 4:3.:;3m:?;-3:2:;&;;mf;;:$x?x;*g*a;%§zz'y:

» ;:{:{;«':£:> f:E}3{§E,§"'§" 45 y§s:;-1&5, ;f§SSES'§";¥1?*€'§' E~i><.F3{iTi}'EE¥Ei E-§?'£{f}§'§'$?E'£E%l§€a §"s.Eé:':¢é'3*§Zi :a::'TI'%--E {'.§{{f}E}%E_%, :2 gag :1' E-'::;:,<:;<:§-9 4% , {Q RAFEIAK R133?'-I'3\£;1.§'€;*~.,€}z\ I71.

':V.I.YSQR.EI--22.

5» SFZE_S.K.SI~'I1R:'A'Y'O{}I;

sgo S,1{Q'1"I2A.§::3E:E%x1I3'I?}5X.

M51313 AI:3{)LE"§" :29 %:;a§zS§ ASS§S'i'A.N'I' §:LXZ.§.%I(f :.;'1'1vz&: 122321;; ;;\z§:§e::»ez., §%$;,f5k'I' 31 g, vs' £22033 gm-> §%r'IA§:\E, 0M§3Im,sw<>1,:';', Ei3I'~'IUE?A3\?;%GlRi E3ANGAI.,C)RE§M5€-SO 04.3% (ray S3\:'£'I". N}-\.l.E.§.'€§ C2 II§.1):?\..E%;'Ii13s°xRAT%/E9 SIwZI.'E'.E2_,%X«JAI?f&ES/1., A1>v'0m;:'£:) 1'. 3"m'1'£; 01%' KA_;zmi'i';3KA, -

::»E1>AI~'mvI EN'? 0 F' W-1:3 LIC \:a<:3;22§e;3., _ REPRESENTEIZ) BY $33'3Ie:cR1;'m:::${,... " 1.

M,S«BUELIL)1£$EG. V. '-

E3ANGAL<;j>r'2;§--5eso :30 '3 .

2' C§~EIf9:_ff%'. ;:1'*~«;?cU' * C I-3 _(s<:2U*.

px2xr{;.._£)£:1>zx.i-xi. 7 K..sa'<3r:2;cr..¥s:, :'§$ﬁ;NG;%IJ®§2§§1 ' . . .RE-'§SP(}NI7) E33\E'§'S * «.{E§3'1r'v.Si§§'1i}.S}1J}i£i§,A.f§i¢{v.§$--E:ENAN, A(j}z;"%;} " » _ !\'§'§Tv'ivE:r§':? '§3-.'ﬁE':{§'7Ej' E1}§*Z'E'E'E"EQN ES §'EE.§%K3 {}DEi7{'; EXRTZCIQ-E33 226 535:3?) 22?"«:>§v €;£>?x§.S'{"E'I"%j'£':O?~: GE' mszgx §>R;u{:1NG *:'<:» Q{}AE3E*--i 'E'.%'i§;=.,'8RﬁE§3--§%;"j;; {BF "§"'§t'Eii.C :K5X}*{T%3z"YE?X.Fi,.¥§ 321)?'/EE?\? ES"§"E€f'{E"'EE*' E33 ""E'§&:EE?_%1£N§7;L. Eékf. £7-'aE'3§T'E.5i{7ZE%.'E."§{}E\§ N0::i~a:%i§%3{}k %§8f2;E3L E3825

-- ;'11\§E3 6E?'§2§ C)? 2092 f"}z"*J§'E?ZI') 18. i€}'2{}GE3 ¥'IE")E4: A?~€I'\§'§-§}:§,§§{};L .. A' ' ._"I'§---EES ¥§7E%EE"E" E1?§%Z"E'§"§_"'EC}§\J {§{ﬁ}?;»€ETa§{E §?<>:I% '§':£§§;3;§7{§'i'£{} {EN ~ ?:i':";f':£.f}E':Z '§_'§----§'§%Z E-"€}§;f.,€}'W' E??? E'€'i'E. E E42}-7% Tiiiffi E-133%-Y; Eiiéfgafifﬁgﬁ Qfiﬁigiaifﬁ, J,' _ . ;:f:f.1f}'€::S£~::::<:§3 &é=.§:NImg.fic:€:tL§:~é.S31i-::.' '1§>;:->5: :1; A' :'> ORE) E1243;

T%"1:Z.s Writ'. ;:2£:*1:iii()z1 is di1*«:':<*ic(1i z3g21i.:1sE. Lbs: (':z':.1»::%z's:4; {sf t.h:'-it K21r:'1at:z11i§.2;. Ad:*:1.i1'°:i&:i'.mt'ivc% 'E'ri%J):1:'1211 (for ::;'l'1<}r1 '§{;s-X3") in Ap}}3.i{?Eifi(,3i'E f'€<'>s, 8830? 8828. 6822, E382-EM'2€302 dateci 18$ 3 032006 '2-*i{':§<=: A.i'1I'iEi>{'L,£I'€?/£3"'I

2. The 1.EI'EdiS%§§}u'{f3d f2:"§C'EiE5 zzrer ihaii, <i':::._§'irv1§j;'~.1L'E35%'?'--.f 9 t.h::3r p<:tiit:i(.m<a1"s 2»1.1':»::§ {:)t'.§'1e3':'.~'s 'u-'<;*I"r: :1p;){)§1's1£,C;;i 'é;é3't'2'm{.7 EZr;gin:3<3r$ in Bheenmrayanagucié3 0:2. (é<'3'rz't.r:£<.i::"bazssis fez' §?+iT;--: :a€<;§11t.%2s; by iiim Ch..i.&::{" E:I'1§"§iI'}(?€'§'« iI,?__;:§}3_e:r _'{{:"i{»;'1';L'12.;;-1,}'5'1*(;j<:%cté, ~Cf2=-ma} Z(>1Et:-? N0» 3. T;'jS_1:i3_&s<3<;;'L:'é1:*£V§f;1, ~'~.,v<-:r:: a3>s;<}1"i3e{£ in p:.1:*s;:12m<.::: 0%' the K21fr1a1'ﬁ,a1k2;1'v..S!;}1i.«$?"«--._C'i¢i1 S<;%rvi<:e:~3 EAb3::3rpt,i<im <3?' ;:>ers{>.r':s ;-:p"p:3_iV1'n:;:%'.i 21$; '{Zf<";:'1'é',:'a-.:::E: E1:'1§;f%:n.:;:e:"i:; cm <:s>z'1E:z'21{':1 ?r)21:_5,{§é.i§1_ €.2'1ve 2.1pgje::..E{v_i_s;}1:r':a PIi'(}jtE(ffI, §3hf3€f1'Y1éiFE?t:y'€'iE'ZE3_g'3.i{EL _§.iT:_¢:=: '«.V§<Zgi1*:'";23iT2:E«:22 E3'1.:b§i<t 'ﬁ?'<:ri§ss a:'1:£ §1":"£.g§at:ie_>2':

L'"E}<E§§_;z:*%:§aéé::31%. E1?-v:::'giz":e-é%:r.i:':§§ EE5e:"a='§c::*s:: {S§'}€;'.'{I"ii:i§} §%u§cs EEEQEE {"E'::;%%:-232:':2_:§'{*i..::s2"<*"'i"€:i%?<rr«:;={E its Eiiféé 'E'.§':£:7=. ES;:';a>{:é.2':§ E~"{1.:E€s;§ _§_§§§}€}' E. Uppmf -KI;'iSh1'}Ei ,- [ _ " P:'c)j.<:€:tv€..

4 3, fﬁeizugg z==x§,§g§.:*i€\:<3(1 by the :=;sai£'i x°'t,1§::-*:sa. thzz-? pet.it:i{3:'1<3r§:; :-;1';:s;::1"<>;"1<::::i'2e<'§ §<ZA"F' in 2:312 ycaxz" i;Z(){72, fI7iI.£?f' c':z3f£"z c.::3:1Ee1'1diz1g that. $118 p21Si. service 'I"€}"1d€:TI."€:{i by T'}f1€:';i*i»T:>as <-?ngi1'1.ee:*s an £7{}3'1§}"££C.?E' basiss <;%212*£ie.r {<3 'aha-: {iZ-i«i'fi~- .:;&:i3'.__{';§':'.?r;?:;,i_:* ab:-mrpi:i(::1. in pur:sL.1a.:':{te of €.hi% Eépecieﬂ _i¥.£_:2,,:v_i_%<::»sV {:0 above: was exctiuciéci by the] res§3{€s1ja€i€;:1itiS*--.2i:1.(i.,_ 1*1{;1i; f C'.E)£.1I1'i.€'3d far the ;)L2r;><;>s::e of,T':s<;:r'1§«:::>>:*i"£:y i'I*'z«::z1§;§1"1' ﬂfgééy 13;-"<>14<'~ 211% quaiiﬁtzd far the 21pp<>i11_t.n'1£=%::t. i' {} i:h{e-- gist. €43) wI";i<?}":

they wcgrzs app{)i1"1'i{1'fC.'i (Hit. §?'C}I1?;:1'£.1§ﬁ'§ E3-c~1.$i.é3;'~?'§12'1{: £100 £.§'1r(}1.:;_g;h the s%:11p1()y1"11e:"1ii,«%f'3~:<..éE'12:;t';.~;§€%, '='I'E"--:.<;':~.1=;j' <'r{§':'1i:{i%'?:i:i§.(H*: %;.I*m§ €.h<;=. past", s:<€'f4;?i<:g:':if:'en{i:E'1"e:i~, %,;y £:}éé%::1 in "£118 €:ap21<:i:y <32?" e17§$§i::geé~fi'S 'aim V:3<'>1%.:'if.:1*E'§C::. 'z5z"'v='»3xi's;."iTi;>ax;e £10 be :'e:«::k<331<::ci fe;:z:r me-? p1,:r;;:><>St=: czf dc:ti¢ém'i'i%:i3:1g'---- ._t:§*1eit" ssu:;'1E(}rit:y in the re::g:.:E21:'° e:'«3€,2ﬂ<31;i$E1mef:t...stj1.%:3é;c3q:Eemf. to ahmr ztgbsaa-(::rpii<:>n ass gx-3:' i"Ei:€> ~.§I36Ci'21§i,.,RL2§i3S '\?J§'£',i': i':he::;<-3 c{m'E:<':mi:m:9, é;.E[:<?:}' &:;»:j;§:11g;?1§1t--.,§E3r"£gi:::$h..i::;§ 'éihe i::1;.m;§z:~:2{§ E~2u§<>: 4 mi" Spzxtrgieii §{~a,1§'e<:ig E"':§S§_:f;s.,_ 215%' "ii. E:a::; C§£T:E'1ifﬁ€."§ i_§"2e£;' $€fI.}J§£3:'§EI}>' etmzé :>t§":e:;" §::ez'":£':.iEi:s;..9'~:rE:aA«§'::E"2 i" é,.:.E"€;','? E€i;g;;;2..E§}; <3.%m"iE.§<-:2<:§' (3

5. '1'he II'3r-::m':3r:?:'s2; of K5-'&_'1" 2:352? 1':=%ﬁ:%1":*i1'};;_;f ta 'i§'1{=:* z1rg'z.:1z":e:'1.t,$ e:}:f ¥.:><1>t.E.': Sac }7:z,1ri',ic:<s4; §"{'ff€f.I.'1'€{.i to E{:.1'ic* 4(2)? of $116 Spz-3r::§a.E R4119?-; zmai 211;'-.3<1 <;':<'}z':1pareti '£'j}";i? :'-:-sa:':.1:?-:T %;%e3:3':

Rule 5(2) Of Rtziess 1.986 ;.3&?1'i:21.i11ir1g rec%1'uii::n<:%1'11'; of §(3(':2_11 e:*;z;11'1ci.i€ia3'.€3r.s; zmd 1:§'£'i;1'1_2::.:ie=:1§=.§'i£:?--1:{i .EE1:1£"

'E.}'1(:f absorpt..i0t'1 of i0«:':;::] (.'.1:11"1C"1i{':»§1i..(i?jf3Z :?1,:1--:i::§ ._'w.::r'v;:="-._;'1Is::§'s .' qL1es;t:i<3:1e{i E:>ef<n'e E.Im? KA'.F.f'.I'-1_'_1,é-> «::E§;1,_1Ii;~.r1ge;\;x;%;a1::._;f€;}e;%§§,-i:3{i a_.I1d iihe same w2:1:'~:; I.,1§3§'1€;'f1{1 L' 1T1'1e "E§.i§_'T;'h'_ Cf;<1}1..1rt {)5 Ka.r1:ai.2;:ka 211116} }.z"1'i:ér £i fwfiI'I11{?{:§ 7:3" "€:Irie A _)E:'X Court: in m;:11<;%:' batch 05 wjsfﬁ: p::"r£:zf'£;is>:*;§+:;. V'§¥'1&'1':: §}i*¢s;&(5§3:.{,'}:a.11€;%:e; $1}:-3.19;; £1': p21re1n1;:i€§éfIa--'ssiifitfz ffféiﬁ €>ffF?i1.I1€*s§s_""V:§': ' 1986. E.i'1¢;:1'c ma} rm-rig'. in '£31123 (v:'ihE1H.fifI"i.'.$_;;;*;~F;'.V '1'1"::;;i::_i:£<«..by.-t.;i~:e p{>:t;.iiTi{>'r1ers§ E<-"n'1_dir3;;g fzzmit xviiifx }.}¢::t'ii'i<>f.:'-zézfé 22§3p1'::_a<%'E*§i':1§g RACE' with inm'di1'1ai'c?: e:,fi:-ri;_::§;», "=I.21£:heé Q-:71 i-Eigeiz" p2:'%*é;"'§1'1 E"§{'Jfl g.;1..:<::s=;E.i<:::T1ing;' E:§"1<=3 2:%3s3<)1'p€.:<}I: "%Im,m..= . .A }_Riz_§:::é.é 1 _ 'a3'_f;<§ "::2_:._'3tjj3i':<:-1:' a<':<:<3ptir:;_g Em: Sp:3:c::§a.E Ex1uIa%:+:. vs,»-*E';iE<;: i..ii:€éi.:f .:'<1%g;3.;Z';}:--:4i::-ea:'éigssg1 xms §i$§€,:'i'€'§. KKK" 1'::,=ja%:c.:i',v<.'% 'z:%':<:-éér 'A '"z%.§3§3ii<:2i*€é_i$:z.s. E"§c::'1<:<3., *€,E":;€::%}:° <":z.:3€ =:i«:}¢::s " 310:: <.%:":$§*.:*<.-'e;: «'atgm%i5i<:%':*'2::_'E:.i{2:f1 ':33?' éizia {T:<>u:"'é.e e..::":<:%. .s'.~_=,-,:=:€,*E<:;.:'=:~: +:i.i:=i;:::§:e;:§;T2E of E'%':<: u ..1%.r:::"iE.. §3€§"E:§*;.§Lé:?»:'";, \. la"

6. A<*c::3;'c:1§1'1g 'i;:{_> the kw-;1z*z'1€£i S€r1':im" {fie':1.':j'i'1*~";°--;T;«»=,s<=§ Smti. Naiini ifffhidzzm?:i;.a:*2m1, 1:"hr3 E14119: 4(2) 4' R1.1ies 1998 d{;?$<jf'i"'€'(?S ti} be c.;:.12.:ssheci £1";__j¢&--::\x.?..A_1i;f"'{Em <":iE4a'->.t.i<>nse; :*€i'€'1*1*«:;~.<1 {<3 §:3j; her a11<;E ;;.1§s's<.>_A§:€:;::1j's;?:1'{f}¢;a<1_ :'.}1:-1§'%;.};1_c=={' se:f:ic>r'ity (if t11es:ae.~ §3e:i4:it:<)z1e'r'::a_ .'i1z2..<.:a'~'é;<:e '?i:u:~. r§=s:9R;_Q1jér;:{1 §"§::<:§r';.:

the inﬁiai <:iat,e of Eheix" e;1p;3'<u§i':iV):.ff;:1:cijmz i,.E':i;z:3.x1VVV from the datfe <>f1'.1'1eir 037 _19QiA- HVVIY1 39 fa?' as E1216: éieigxy and1;-1<:I1a§s.._V§i§:§:<;¥f%§i%:g'":15VI:f§i:§ ;iee1:*'r1cc1 E3<5nic):° Cmguugz-3;}, "§~'e;=;-~*:::§?1<-1% G€3'€€?l'I'1}"E1t;'I'}{ S{'3I'Vz1I1iS, :ix:g::";3'..a':33': V 1"€pZTf3S£'fI"i[LZ11.i(}ﬁS armi th{;*.§,f xr§r§%re_ ' .i_1b:£0.' 53;:-isﬁs S€:{?:uI'i{.};" givirigg Empc iifzai. <%<'3z'1.es§{i£~tr*eCi. i:her<:f%3re., €:h£3§,-»* 2:96-:Iff:':% g;°i1*:s':.i.fi€3:V§' ~€_'.:'} 21:p§3i':>z?L::hé':':;g £;ha=; Court xviﬁz {£632,132, »I€E£::n_<:7c §;§1.§:--.d:z~:§22y Efi.§l{fE Ea<tr%1<:':s <:zm:1<.>€; {*.{}mc in >::h<?§2" *~;v2:§,-' Ea; {ii§'}«§;}§i€£%§'ﬁ§E'; 7El}.Ei'fV:;.{1§§}i32"2%§.§z.i}§'1 {Ff Eiuiss 4; 2} <3? t.E":c= 8t§f}(f{,'f§:2§ Eizziéz:-2 §.§'§}{1% . '{:1§'2<-,=I :°€£e:'§'é::?<':E Ea} sa=::%'2:e:*.2:E ju«:ig§:n@:1%.:'e;- €19 fé3Z.1§"}f§:'f€Zé1§}§i.§21E'.€i »§'is€z*"::{}:.":i':.:3:;1iiiarrzSQ w3'1§c§"z 2,a»*'e:m§§§ Esau' :"aé§'};;é:":°:>;('§ Er; 1at:3:~ gm, f. 21.g.;§2;a.i:1:»;i iIr':c 2::'g:§1:z11ez_'1_t::§; of Smi. §\I2;2§i1'1i Chid21mba1*a_1n., 1e2zm'":r3:d G<>va%2"z'1.:11e:3'1t. A<§v<)<:2ai.€, Smi. $11<:.*e1.a K:*is11:1;2;'L I'::;*:>z.2g3;E_'::: iii") (')LiE' m>i.i(rc: Hit': r.:ie::e't%,_i17s: {sf {Q2113 4(2) 0f Specéai E?§?.t.:i:;%s;-s 1998 amd Rah: 5{2}"':3>If'...'1::§1- Rtmzs. AC<:c:;;"<ii1:3;.§ in her. the p€iif".i{)§1(;'.1"5?;»v----'£'v'"f:§F§ '§.r§.ii.,i;=zI§}Q' z1pp<)int:eci for 21 p€£'i(){i of :r11:;>i1'3.i:1--3s' . £-'1'11ii="=-i_I"1:3§:"

e1pp0im,1m:n€, I<:r1;'3;,<'r:f <':Iear£y»T' §.:__1c4§1T<t2>{'&:.<§s' t',}12:.'z'f"3;.:i'2f;?kr x_;;.-'»:=-::'7:=r app(:>inted on ci.o:1E.:'aC't basis. 1V~.5§.'£i§'1u a déiy'..;sj; 'E):*e2i§k§ exzasry six mimths, ihcéir <%<'>:'1.t::*.21%j',t:_ WT&3.'}§:}['i;'2'§'i'€i§'g?€vi3d'.~ _"I'i'1ere;fE3::*cx at rm paint. of time '{;}.'1.r3.1"e 1A?aE3"aiE]:§"v §:1:i«i1:3;1'£§§<;_I1«V Eliﬁ thtzé p<2t'ét4i:)1':e*rs:s E1121? i'i_if:?é3}"'2-i-:ré:.:if5izt1§;§é1':*1:«E'~.-é§i'::L:a1:,§%<f§" §%Z1_1g_§;Z11eers 2->..nd éhat. {hear 21}3p<3i::{E.n1i;%r:t4' xV2;.§};'»..12;::3},?i;i£:3_iVii;;; "arise: aztjfzm" i :'1£H'"§ e::<::'1t",m<'éi:' bassis. E'>1't'1*e £m"éh'er'%?§>12t,é:';1(ii:s ihai, ms: ;3€t_ii:§<:::'1€~=:'$ i:':ii;,i;":11y }<)§.§'1e;:.i "El?:€E'*;"'i{'?x';?"»QI':'iV'{;{3E'1Vi_§"a{f§. ':}a...=.:sis.s §z;.:'1<:m-'i.1:':§.'T_4{ Eifziiy x-veii £_E12,:'i "'~:'§_1e.i;g:i uWé:3";V".€ "mat; 9;;3:j'{i§:}i€3{i 2-1g;2;zins~;'{. £1223; s::;.21:T;<::EV:1?e:>z1<;:{:§ p<.}:&s'é4 a:._:.€i Aireaasg 2:30 £i€i"%f€?E'Ei;'-'%€fE'ﬁ€f§'1§, far the :'+;2;:zma. 1E':{%:1:V§<)%*é:f_'v::Ejfnzy""{'::5z:'::':<>i. m:':1 bn«t*k' :"'s<t{f<.::"{.%§:;1g E0 113:2 21% '§',§'1§Sé'"..EZ}{;?}.§§§:t'-ii".EE§Ei.éfi§§:{E ss:%::%§§.§.:':g§ z"a"eé::E<::?»:'.::':'2g;¢: <>i° iiizc s5e:':i<:s:"§i::; sgf

-~§§14::§:"; %';v%g3::'1. '::E'*:s;% izzéé £233 {§2':E1{T' 5:2? é,'%..E1=§}{ffs3l.:'E'E'.:'Tz':€3§":'£1' in Ei'~3é%sZ+'E_ ' ::£§;»», ',9 not {air mail ii-é§;a.L Sim zﬁsszu to (1992?) SCC {Labour 82, Service) 1 10 to <*m2t:'ez'1{.i. i41'1ai§ _§'L::=;;1f' _b:3=_:<32;14t:,s-_<.<:.* the §;«e't.i€.ic3r'; 21:22:11 :;>i:11<:r:s '.=V€3E'€? ?;2;:k:':_x.";.. ~ e1n'_p].c:yI11er:i: <::>;:{i';E':221:1gs:, their 21p}_3<}i11_t41 1§:%:':1;'.fv» éi3.14j::::<'>i_ V iyectozzm r<;:§_§u1zI:_1" :::§);,mi1":it11.<3n.'€:. 2'.:§;;f;21£1:é_§<;1:~'T t:.i'ié:. ";€e:2}::m;:z'§»;§;;';<}£;i«i post with '€..hesc= 21;*g11.n1<-';:.':'£..s. ':':a?1_e _ " §"c'>1* "

:::::3:1firme1t:i0n {Bf £;}";.:>e zjrcjer of ¥v§"'§..»"¥?Tf--. ' 8, By xx;e.2.y cﬂ" .E\x'Ii';§;"<:;1j:>:.tie1:):': filed 2:1":

app1i€:ai'.ic>:3 1;::)V1;.;;[1}'<.§;.:<_t,xv§§ mom .:it':»:}a-'1.:_ac1::z1;i:3 <31': r€:c0;:d_ £?£.I.}{i§ {:or1z:er1deé i_w'::»__d<1§:i':$n'*:s§:'2i::; were 1:zoi': p:"<>cim__=e<:§ b<-:f0:"€. --e?e.}iT3.ci '£.§fV§€'?;'-,.'_"é'3»»'AIVf':";'f {':i'i..;2(V?"i"23§§ {i0c:urI:&}:'1£:s t.}11'<)xx'i;"1§; iégiii. <::1'--.i:E";€ §1é:£i11 }'I":{(*;*._Eﬁf.__éL}§}ﬁ{)iI1'E.I'i"1€I1{. téf 'U16 pei;it;§<;':'";c:r':s and 5.-gifmiizaréy §V12i:(7'.£.f'{E giatréibzig, We-2: }2z1ar<?""§_ff{>1:}£: t,%1:'<'f}:.;§;i1 ihaz ;<_se'v£::*2?s.§ <%im'é.£<_21'1:~;:

1 L.-.€."eV::Vi"?;:";["':"'€v{:.§_'VV"*t:;{:s" ::r:">a.m:+;€éE §:;):* §:}{}"{'.h i,E'"ae;-': pé.iE'§'i£'_i'.::':' 2::'2<'.f sasimi-§;:2'r'E.°§;~ ' A,§:1;i.'}€:xz.z §'(?WE§§§i N<}fi.i'f§£'f2:i.i<}n §};'§':p<;2c::.E.z-':1. §'€:,1Ec%5.

u "§Q§}O§ .a':;&'E. aiscs {.E':::?: i,w<'} {i{}{'§':.£I}"§%;'?I'}§'.$§ §)':"{::£§:.'1<?:e<:i ':'::y' M2'. _ 'E?;2=:§*;'::..:*.r.-1:21 2;§.g3;}:'.:1':*'£:'; f:'<"::* i".E":s::% §><2§2i'§2?:'n'2:':2"se:. if.) 10* G11 p<3I":.:.<~';21I of ihe. 1':§<'m'cT.is z'.m{ji :~;yI2:');.T:::<sis%:« fi§:;=%<.i in éihiss Ca1se, we :'1<'.:i:«:"-r Iihaii: i'1"1<:% }}(?tli§§{)I}£*E"$ did ;:2:re:~;;-s im':.<> f~T~}€fI"\;"i.:ii%<3? t:}";<=3 ('.{)Z1'§'{','I'"E'i1'% 0? E"%"::;% e:'ia:fz,.2m¢::'1i.s dz1i'i?{§ 1&1 §:':§3§'<IE3% ]')I"(}(iiIC'.'(?d %'.(>da:;. E----iz'>xv<>v<;-2:3 %;'}'1c3,> in--1s::% maxi. p_1*{:}<im:<::::1_1';.1:::%ses»;:.* $.w<;) <.f£0c:ur:1:?,m,$ til} E_c>dz1y. As i'h.C? §(;'.8.I)T"I"é(£'.Ci (?;(.}'L1§'1S{;3"§:"f€)f'<.{_:f:.§; §)€'.fﬁfi()£'1€3f1TS €rr:31'1i:e1'1{'i.&; that: ¥;'..}'1.cé$s2.> {WC} Ci{.ﬁ)(j131ii'I1fjfZ'1iiS-- " 'as; It? 1 V' <:ru<:ia1 d<>c:~z1merats. E"13.K-='€?f v::.:C3'c'::::;::'g',<;=,{:*_' i::E.f1é3:'"'§::';':zi1c2[j.<,>:L':.. E"€"C{3I"d and W637 wit! 2.'é3f<:é'r Etc) 'E15;-';7rr§ -_izI1 t,h'<: ::c1>ziu'i~;.g§ Ci.iSC';i.1S&'s'i€}i"1.

M. So fax' as thxf: {zezsvsf"-fT.§:1"e,.pei.§i.i<;:?:er%; E3e3'7<':2r<:% §ix2X.';E'§;aIs_0. 3£:'i'tk:i:}I..V_<.*':z£'.s:t'gQ§é.::2':'1ij; ;;:::'§§1:%'i; :1? pam E rghai; Ems appoinixnem. is-3£j."s.:i<-=:.:.ff .§2§vi;fi'z~.by '£'é'1<3 Gm-*e:":1.:n{-am': p<)s'i'i::;,g t.hs:?m €10 va:ri.<::t_.:s pj§z.-§:<'€::<.s:é' in §€;=':m21tz11«;a;1. m£:é1'1i::i<_>§1Es E:.E"::.3 p<*::'.1L<1§g:i of &1.§Z)§}{:,)§E37E §'E"'§{3Z1§ :13 Six m<'::'1"€%"1:e§. A: E32731";-fa 2 Eéw}-* "fa;':t.:'§7E'w3r"":'f€:§%r";._.t:i}':&%3>* wszzw: 23;;'3§303Z.:":.':;:;:::E <:v<::1"y' s.::1%:>: m<:2m;E':s:; with {._.<§'§':¢;%. :€%g:"yfS ~ fU5"_2-:1 §,i{? zami s~;{m1:=::'..i::'1<::%; it wag <:<;§12:'k):'":<;:::E. fX{.%{ii§§3'{f§i£"i§:_f'.:{€'}r:: 1,.E'";:7::L iiujig' 2-ippasi§1'z.z":'1€:ni. in Ei'~}§E%7 w;::.~.«:

:h:"e:>é.: .E:E1':§f}§{i}j€§}'"§Ef'FEE' EZx.£%E':;:a:1;g: €:£'1{."§ €'.E'::%§; 1:-*a?:":',.:

'.:::;A.§};";_s:';;*:""2§'%z=i'.=:.'i'§ :'::'1E.};' 9:3 ':'.§3.{=.=--: %:::::.sa;§.&; :..s§'" :.'m>r:§E ;.2;:"§{:.'E z":3:~;:r::*v;.':?;'i<>:": 23;' E2 c':<:n':*<:ass;3£>:":«:i<:?nc<é 1:::>mx«=ce:'1 i'1i1c-? E}<:%_;:>z2:1:'E::1'1<1<1"st sf E"--'"a?'~.-T'E} 2:1 mi Wc:>rit:i Bank deE'initeE3; <:zmz'1<':«%, {:1211":.i:§.z «::er :7.::»z'1f§'1'n'1 ::E':c% S.-E'{',ai".i'1E§« azrid m-":E'.:.1.:":r-;' of appoim::'m3:'1iii; 0;? :§:.::: pei':it'i.<m.;:-9 ' ' 1.11:2: i1':i%';ia§ st.:1.;2;ca it z'1<:>:: in <4iis.;p1,::i'£:, t:E':<:%_§£&é2"r;ég5_;'::§3;g4 <:(:r1t€:m.i(>11s w:3_1."é: §"£;{iSr"sEi'€i beﬁsjre §{.,53X..'I'. t:Ef:;:§."'i;E';€%;z:: w'<%z*<§?' appomteci for six I1'3{)§1f;§.'1S £;1.1"IC§ :=.?g,11i$..abpai§1.{.'ﬁ1«:§1;ﬁ;',JfvaazésA' c:oai1{.ir:uec;1 f'r<>'r1: E':..i.;'11€ to t:in1é:§ f i1*:é._<(,:_ 9:9,:-e ;.a:§;§)A{>i4§':£<::c;%; <31":

1'eg':.:E21r basis agai:'::~fst the -S."c1i'1{'i'iii3'0,1?£'1L'-ii. p(>;s*'5L'.,«.3§%1e.r<-'iii W215 no z1<:*e(i for the dcztpazi :"xf1e:%*r1{if' ?;o'._$2::§; v£'.Z51";tIi.» fE.}:1{3§i:" 2.1;::p<;>i1'1¥:.mc:::"2E:

was; at the:-3 i11ié.i:::.E s:;€.;1.g(a;. igsri":1;"»_;:<);5ii::*;i::;.€i' basis. Eivgjéxz oih C'.}"\,'%.j'§S(;';;Elhéfiiif,{'@§;K}?! '2xpj3c>i31:',:9i'é.'<:1':{. wc>1.:iz:i ér";<ii<:21'a;e w}';a.1§' W21-55 ﬂ"3.{f1._{1EEi'.'i.3:.;{"*=";§_ V<',v§ "e:i:§i>;:;{}i1°:_i:Vi:{:¢:1E. 2-mci the x»-'e2*y C£,i$f;? (sf "ma.-> p€fLiﬁ{>f£€E'S _dC*€)-S §'§€.§€ §'§'}{i'§C£if€f t:.h2.1i: ﬁliifjy' wag"-2 r<5g_3;a:§a:'E};? a;p;3{3i.:1."€,«::{é. V ?{L}'zj_é" éE":a> oi.E':z:r:" hzmgi 'a:h£:3 3.'4i"':§}§fJ Elf {Eta-% .'"§'€:Eé3§;=€}i1{§.§1:§'3f"'77 E5{1Ei1E {u""§'i}{'§ii?E'ii§lti?S "£;'§'1.2:.1" at: t:Ez<.-5-1 E'l§.§'I.'1<:'? oi" i§':<:§:" é1;;?2j;§:>§:}i'.zf;§é:§:§1.nif.'Em3,z haves: givzin u:.'2<§erE,;3,1<;_i.i":g; Eééﬁiter ':10 Efze if)egiszyi:m<;:::*§i::.. ';:7;..<3£{::c%;.:i"i.:15.;; E: %":2.1..%: Elhéfii' 2i§}}',}{}iE'iE'.'£H€'E'}§' £53 an <"::;>:':.%i::<°.z::m<':*i:;'bazsﬁseg, '£.'E:::: <%e:';:'1%:::;':%.i:::z': <3? '§§"E€ E521:':':s:<:'E {'i{>:.::':s_~.;t>§ Hfgisi' £13925? ;3%?%E§i::*§i;>:':€:? * :°$ %.%":2;:E". s;1.2:_:E": 'a.::2<§:=::*E,z1.ie;§:'1;.§ azziii §_;?i2réz:;:;5 2.2 s§t,at'z..zs«s of <:c):'1t'.m.<:t basis; "W'é?.S 2:11.10 tic) the:-2 (T()1"!'E?$}}£l3I'E€16116%' 1:>c:i.wc€:31 iiilé? Chiéif 0.1"' mt: \=Vc:>r1ii ¥3ar1.k :':_§'it:§_ "'--«_f{2"1V:==¢ EZ")cp21ri:me:'H?. «:2? f3'»&~£"§_.} wfm w<:":u§<E de:e:%i{§<: 2Xg%T;':?;?i'}':.::f§"ks:

wt'-ire 21<:i;.t12i1.Iy z1;>§3<)i1'm=:::i 21gg2xi:'1.f;sé:*" '{7§:§g1.1 1E£1'H'§£ﬁ'1(lT£§{}i'fEf3:ti':;.. pasii. A p€'i"i_.ES£%1 :3?" aim zegziy g.;{_i*v«::2:°'rf€é1«::is% ass >?;.13 1.C:i*C:TE".: " ' "The Vc1c:a;'Tz4'g; of Ju'i'2}«2izV:V.i':*'~. Er1gf:':_e£3'z's:'.= I7z';z:; aireadg; bee:2.fz';EZ,e;d z.1p.,---'TE': <3. Cf?-ﬁg!" Ef'Zg'§IZ8éf?}". Upper Kr'i:;?'1i"m_ ' _ I?{'=:;j£%'{,=?'f 'M AA '{'Ca:'1c:2E:~_;) Bheemarc1y_::'uzagucii _F'z.cz..s<_ %,::;:»e'z-':3 356-§fVr*:é'izi.f:'c?e:i 5.5} Recruit' 5'iS1§§iS=:ia.?'i.E '"E%":::ii.=wzé3.€§°:~; f.f:r"ou§;!1 Erz1pi§3;§;:ig>;ii'- s§.g~:c'i'z-r:f;r::g'eV__ fr; "2;f{rd.r:2*' :0 E:<p€dz'£.<:.= :;:1.¢i<:a.¥;,f£f Sf' "'=:'§if*3{';';.€.'}.f'.§{;? 'v.§,.1i'2é1:*£: "i:}':m'<: 's5;<::i'e 25?} :<s;7s..:'3a<::i.im'1er<:i "=p0:é;'£;s"{3;'§';'§.ss;i;»;m:'3;E. V§Zé'éggiz':€c:'s. 'miss W215 £2 E"{{f'pE}' to E-3£3;?§'.i5§f::"

.%;;I.+~';I'e_?%:g:;::§f:e¢s} ;E f1:...{;-E '\3J<7;'r'£<:i Eﬁarzkh E3"; 22%} §3mE::»;:bi}§§:y gait Eézg? i.i§ﬁz:_ 1}?" 2.::«.v;'_£'é,?..*E:A'1 §é"é%;'. §{'.>:.:.§': fag" '{,,E§"§;::»£;*.:.' §<;Zr§s:»~sE'::":2?: E~':"z:=j¢i%{7£ E';>}_£ 'A "£1336 $iEﬁ;{f "G«:>v€z":'1:m:r1é: ix} {f€}Z'1'*'v"i§'1€.'{'3 $133; vzzetrzg mg:s§a?.%:'2;;1_§ 21%: "j«..;?"?»»»k 4- ' _ "£.«§':'é:%~..s:~<§£%§ri.:=s zmdf §:'§f222a.E: §E':s::r:=. wzsm ssz4:§'§i<?§.{::':sE: :'1:..::1:%.:ac:;_" :.::21?' u .,E%?:"iLg;:;§:'T:<é::%:':§ E".r:_': é§§"i{.§§f.'E'§E3:%;{? %_.h{'.=. 'a,j§§'::>g:§a_.%:" E£z".§;<;:sE:;_":e: 'E3':*{':}:%<:i. %_"E'::-=3}; 'ijl Eiixnp.§{>y'm::::'1_'i' §%§:~;<%}1;.:15;;{<-:2 in m"»:':§{':%.z"' £0 :?:*a;}"><-_=*{'§1'E'c* §'E":o _x:;(>:"§<;. T.hi.::~:: =.v}":2'11 the re .3136 .;ive1'1 1:33;' iizéé S€i(33't3§£;i1"',E «;:}.f: Vf-'J'E'\}:'I--''.>u'E'v.<<..> " W " ' 'I 7.

111:2' Chi~';":f Ofi"i<"€.=:"' 21:? \'wJ{3z"1ci E"32m_"§«:§ "1'h<:;};' 3:2» s::1e:1'r" 'ft,1"}.2~1i' 1.1295." 2132* r11z:1I/~:ir_1g:' 2;-m'*2u:gt}11':é*:.z'1i.:;; §(_7§. :_9{5.>'s;"}.:j zzii'-i--i;§€j; Asss3issf.:»mt: E21':g"i:'3:éL=I":22;. 'i'I':€: (T2110?xfiifikfétix "'x_3,?'<,§':?E«::i~ E132}-::1%1%,'~. wcmici not be §mc:"<:>.si':e::1 E-:;1'1.0v«;?a 'x1»:%:'1:{:'t'I1"éf1' WIh<>:_-.sc> z;=.;;3p<::s_iz1'é.m{%tltss; i»§rL.'1"'€§i <':<'>:'*;*iVi9:1i_{f:%;. j lV"3?z.1:_;--:i:':-:3 £532' E"£'ff.'§Li§é'U"

21p;)()iz1t1arm'~r1'1i:. it is; zfhz" 1:1-is S';;2';£N§ C§.:;3i;'vz--.-*:;%11*j::1cé1'1: E0 cict'-icic {i€}'3(}§1diE"1§;f :u'_}3£;?%1'§'-- i:_}'3c'-1;--.»7s»;ii:uéii'-i_{;:;1..._,f'w'I"1c:£:.i'1.e:" §:?t1{:_;w;':

2.*q3p<;i:1t;£I1cé}';i.s_. i£q{_ié1}E;¥ .}.T;>1'«*:aT'i'.'::;>;f':'---- <.'.i}I1 {.i:I'é1{_'i" ':::2.:s:';<3 ':'3e.<:z21u.;<9»;+ <1}? €x.igcén;;éj; <32' 'E, 250 As:s1.st:2-1--a?1§. E' 1;: g_;,__%j:;:fv1\:;*<;-:=';f';'~,;A_. ' " 2 ;1~v:'§: The V-;<;;:3{%<.?§.£7i<tV' <:a=1:'s:<;% e:?1f'%'.§'2c z'¢:%;=:~s'g3<m<:ic:':§: W S%.a.E<i E55 '%:i'3;.;;:."EI" it 'ii;;.;,5§:~.i;_%11'<.}z:;_f§';. 23:0 Em§.}i<">}='11'1<:':'ﬁ" E:X(T§'}é'1§'i§_{{f {Easy "::V=é:-29:1,; rgfraii-. fE:'§f1_é_-% %fiV.;>.§;'é:1§'.E:i£; <5? i;E'1é:s5@ E%Z21;;in<';i*;¢::*::s z?m{:E ggzzwé '['E:2::.";:

Ei."f{Z'§I'15E,'%i'£E£{?.'§_._'. be};-;:és~s aim;'.>Eoyme:'1E; 22.: i':.h:::*; ms-:.::-2.3. $1 a5_..§s:. J 123%. _§:;a%<[:z":2,1:;;{%*{he}; <'{2.§"m-* €E::":'::1.:gh Liza: ES-':.'11;3£:)}-':1'"::;>,:1E. <?:~<;<'E':;~m;:;<> ._<k;J'~,_:§ ' " '?;i3é:iri'E'::.:'*:" s<;:;.:é":_:.:§_; E.E'2;.s:': vyE"}e=2é Es; _' §'€,<.§é:;::i:§:e %s1<;E, z'z1=:%z.2§2 %.§'1;':§ E316 _§§::2E:i.%L§<':::';:>;'s; &,"i§"'t:'f {::r::%;iiE<>('i 2153:' a:":§;' §:';.:§§s::;:i<%<"§ HE §§'2a_%:éz'

-gm? V '§'3i3Ef{{i§ --

7<:;:r*e 7fw'2[:Es4"53gi.z":<:£::E{'};:'1 i'<:;° flit? ;1p§)(}Ei'1i":'}:1€§.'1E of E6 :1pp<3E1'1i.n1e1'1i' ('}f'd.{';1'. F03" this' xasc z'c":f"e:' to 1.997 SC:-._{§,, S] 110. in {hiss (".'€:"i.S{". {the q1.:c%s"-;t.i<>n wz=,-1s~:; xx?1'1<;a'tjf':s:f"'ﬂzi? £{kp§Z}{}§£'1'iI.FI1£EI'1f. ém. 2-2<'iE':c:..><: Emsaés W'i1I'EE.}L1'§i. €531}-"'_"{.é{}i'§'}:'}§i'(§§"§?.?ififﬁi * exam1'z121i.i<>n 'Wé,ZS r<:£":?:*;:&§E. "I"E'1c*r ;--:pAp:3i1'1i';T:':€é:'1"£"$: '_w£:'§'<s§Risa": iihrough En1p3:i>y'11:&é:[1?; Exc_:h.21:'1_ggt% in "i'£}}iS~:'CEIESE?'-.2ii"i€f§.. pri<>:r to R<3(:mii:1I1<==%:1I RI..iE{i'Tf5,5'.7}1"}sf,;f'}""I'2.1.iI.§iEj to Iiii"::::i§)1*aijL% <3?

PubI.ic:: I~{€;=:aE1;:1.1. T 1*} :::"e%_f1>1"c:    <;*\:e:':
if:-.;L1::h app<)i_r::I'r1"1c3.m'.$'    Cc)1:I1I%1$:':<2<:?;:::1:;-#1if

of ReC1*u.it.m€I'1t' R141I<?s:~;V.,V_ 1'L','§«_§?_.I.1E1Y $31.2 ti rr2n122n'n E10 b@§~'21'{i[§j:}m:'? <::_:":.Ij,?j «:?s..Ef.:i.«}'1¢;% fact. ::h.2.1i' the <%211'1ci:i€i:é1€.cEse " ' Avx.*§r{:.1'c% 73.4 52%'-'i£:_$.€:r:§ .fr'<>m <:,h€;=;= £€1'1f1.;.3i<':y1:": val: Exctiiiangvs. ='1'h::31f(3:f'a'2.:fs:: Vi:~hé:i:* ='é:1'>pr:>.£:'":t..r::1c*:1t. was heici to bc ;1d}:m~«;?- éémd :'1€;€'._V2"¢%;;§sf:.l;':_;*;

" ' _ 16',' 'Si§':1i.E21r§}z, in E.hs:< ;;::_1.*t-:s%s€:::';i,. (321558 the z::g3p<'>i2":i:2'1'3<::?:"2: Ai~»sa {:':»<£j;'sA 2i:'ié;~%._ i,i2.L§:~vs;'e:"y' femi E?:a21é': E2': EEK: yezzzr EEEQG SL233 §:'7€:_.:§<?: iteraziaké. £:':..:,;t;§ -i"{?;i:f<'%:;1 far E._.%':@ 2a'i}s_s::tn.'§'}"i:m"; of §i1£::'~?;<;% ;;>€5:é':;"£i<§:1a::'=:§":~s H ¢.'§."i?.'}{§{:%'5{.§":V**¢T"E'f?» w:':u§{E §:"1{,%::':%ai:<: £121;--at: :Ti"1_é:% E?;:..:Ee.9§ <_>f .:'¥E3:~_=:<,>1"§:'§_.§:;:;

1. , " 'i'.§":

_'<:':ia_:V:'1%.:.:'*"'{.:> Ex? §'§"E&'i{ié,' ix": <;2*{;§{::" E0 §.§§"':'_>&'§{§€?r r«:-:§;;j':,.§_§:?:;"é:«.;e-Ia:§<>'z": :;=f ;':§:e§3{:}z'.:":'é§':2é::3;*§.$. "§"E'§z'.5:; w<}:_.:§_<£' waif; 5:39 "£0 :~;;§":s;..>z2; $3222 cf _p1"c3r11<>€:cée.$, whmx .:;2.E._1 o1"hc3;: §1'x<'*1<':t':<,--; 2.1m :=7-qL:aI %3cs_€-xvz_%£,%::, £113 diI"€{".?i', 1"€C.z'uii(§*cﬁs"~; and _prc'}1m>1:7<;*$¢ T1'1{_% f:z§.<:z'l:'~; 'o§f.:'§':s::% .s:"~;2ir£<:i iféiﬁttf héivffi no a;3pi.iCeu".i(>I': to €316 f2:r:i:t::§ {>?~1 hcr:;':2.;4{?:§:3::é_f V' a .

63:21:36 as; xx-*<::*. a2'€:~ um t,t<3:'1c:%:==?:"1:::%:.§" >i£~*::13=1 A_ E_.3j1<: .;«:.;:,i':«eet'i<:§23 ' 62%". se1'":1'<.:»rif.y bet.we<-3:1": the pr<'3r11{){.c%<:::+::; ;-=§1':d_ cii.r<:<'%p ;'-'::.»»%;e:~:.:_§::-:'g:..;~:%-:.'~ but we agree (?<>11<:t;3%:":'1E:d W1'f.h'~,iVI':~:: EI1'1gi.I_"ie}c:'_S \%;gI'2<: \,wz"L'.' 2:pp<)i:t';t:€3<:i an c?<:::1E .:*z';1<:{'" E;::j¢£.Si 2-n"::_I~. 33 ' E7C'f;;3;'LT1§:.iIT:}A.;'}«' ":"::<%r:1§h:%<E E31":g;i.n¢3ers 01' Prom 011:3:-3s.S 21%; Vi;i':L¢'{:é:is<?:.:1i.ay '18. $0 3_:f'2:1r:;1iT::L$1 1't_?1<,-3 3;'"§¢:$;{?(_)§f1?Zi'w. §1'=;%€é'iss'i':3:1 Aﬁvl'. 1:999 E-3('f. 3615, t.If1c-3y .fCi:i('{:V{V (5:41 b"€'};<1iés _"§u§flgn'1:§§2:1':, an ti'1{r pr<JpGs:;ii§<?;z"':. §'.§12::'E: LE-:.ngi'.f': .:§E"* '}éi'a::i%fv.:I,{":'5<:-':~-j.[A 'gin :::<:q'ui:'ez;ft :°i;g*%1_%: 11:'; an :'-%:1:pI()ye<:% wi<:ici'i" {:ﬁ{Ei»i,;iii%'3;; hm: M} bét C.<.>:'1s:'si<:i~:==rc{:E £Z">:"

:sa%;f:.icr;;;:£:3{ at fhr-".-;A *§,'i:19:::% s::>f <}i;hc31_° §}E'{)E}'E€}'€;.'§.{}Il".'}E-:3. En; é;:§'1:;*. $g.:£<:% "€I',£:{Si3-, w;;;s;; n_::s£;. Hi--i'"'§<éas3e;:% af §'::;:j':,.:_E_.:1r a=:mpE<:~y:1";c:'1i_. z;2_:":<'E 3::{§:'}E:.f"'a<':ﬁ'."«._'be:%éi§g " ::t1':":;3E{.3y'm.f:&-mi. 'm..:'£' E3, was: %.}c:w<;':a:>n. €319 pi":}:"15"';<;E»i'.:;=:<;=:g-73:35? £ii:"<%<*:%;. r«:;*r{::":.zE'm':<::";'s'9 T'E"i€':F€:§f(.}E'(?, zhig {.fE.£fé§i*. _ 21E:«::s<> 'Es; <:'§'A:3{}"9n;;.3é§ is ﬁn p<:.E£i.is:m==~:'., ' --:/'?<Z:?*«:s:%:::-.' = I9 19- 'I'h€:'1 c.:{:;:':1.i1':;;i 11.0 Iht' dtf('ii.Si(i)I"1 in {':9€%{}§ 4.._S{_T('f,' L226 _pa:ra 213, 1:1 'i:1'1<=. :>1E)m«'e ce's.<5«:% i'}"i€ii}' »_i'f;i3£_i.t.'i.;i.1 app<3i.ntn3<:%:':i;s W(f'1"{.'? c<3"s'1ssi{'%;e:"<;'*<i 211.3 s11'r3szi::a1_1'1I:.ive pe::)s;;t; '.I'E:c:%:':=2ik';m, 1E':v§:* L{j)3'£"§E§§§1i}_n?i§§."-:5&,1.1€3i"~{.E'Ei£?.2§.. ' p<5rs3<:>n said {<7} %1<)§(i a pc>si" in .2-1ws:z.,:}3$i;'£1z1i::.9:ﬁ;éVI, {%z1§2:=1_{?j.§>:jg;'<.. wE'1e1'; he E':(:2'£ds:e it I"-2.3:' an .in:ic3ﬁ:'1ii':3 ;3§:%'r§~::3(i[»::s;;~s;%':'.i2iE1§---,fEi31:*ii long" duration in C011$Fad?Si.iI'i(ii-§§{.}'l1 t:é;e.;3f;:sc%1's-._3:"i' '3;.:77.1.§3 }".1_e§3}(.if+s it far 27: dt3fi:r1:i_i".<3 or i"r;*::r1p()r21E}-i pr3ri()«:iwai'*h(>ItE:s it <:>:"1 pmba£,;1m:'i, s3ub;'<:.*<':% to :'~":s:;:1"ir'rné.i%::i.:i:; E9i"a:§:e {:0 bi?'Lfr<:3i':si£i<_:1'<:<E for the' S€I1i<3r'iE:3: ai: '£13.16 E.Er:A:{;%* §;r<5t;fi ::i:iM:5r_;, "ave an: ;i":.{::et_ fEi{T':€'{i §;i?Ei:15i "s;.::}r'j}'1 é1'< s;i_n12:;§'i;i<3:"i ,ii§'%' *£'h(.=: pr:';?sc:1€:. <'.:a:1$€. As; zxireelciyW:+;1;at:e«:i' _'E53,{_f.t_.'1»$:;._ '1_:§'2a%i.1' :21pp<i:E:1'i.mem:s w<;%1"e mm zigzsiizje-31?, a1"1},»?4?:;t.;:VI";:;i.2r3;_n'{..i.v£;% "§>{23i. am§I:;:b1<i: an Upgéer K:"is5h.r'12: V AEQ?"§'E§;iTifE,V{fi{Z>.§T§1.iE'1§.§ iiez} 296i} {'8} SCC: Ragga 25. E'.}":3'§-:. afEss<§=._ §3a:_E:k*ies2:§:'1 iiiznzrari. §'€i:'{";E"'E.§i'a.{'*i.%f*Ti zmé ;}r:}m{}'E:.:;~:.€:s~a. '.E'"E'::: hV.V""Eé3£:rn<i:c£"~€f3<:a:.m:ese1 Em" i_ha::% pei'.§i:i<:)::£2:*:'s :'£+}.E{-:<§ :..zp<'m i.E'§a',S§<ff «:A§§":é:i:%::sA§'{>.:':s; {Ti} <':<';:':i:m::<i €E':2;r£ w'}'2<é:': es; }i}<';.".'E"-fé3={}.'£.'E §:":~; 2':§:}pa:>:.:':é.s;:<:§ \§f\ .- '.

""E'*'i'1I'}.'.:§2'i§E'Ef%-:'a§. as :'«,;'L.':;§:>:;ei';;:_:';£.;?'<;a* g.';:.:::s=;£'. E:':'<*ssg.::<::e;*§'.iv<--% sits? ii}:-'= s~;E;-2:i.:a:.~e 22-1 L" i5i':a_:5 22 framsd suﬁh Rules"-3 '£19 abamrb t',h€,=m inm re§;§z;11a1* f:'§t:fI"%*i('?{"?.ES§ B}? V.iI"'ii1€ Sf UFEES reguiarisatiim in accardance Wiih 'i{.§'1:: Rzzies they? haare ':3:-f%{':€::";1€ ihe reggjxiiar €f{1p}G§7€€$VV.Q1'§_F{3£§i? State GOVEEI"1'}.I'{"§E3;".1§', {Hm} IQQ': <:'rm-*21rd$. RE'I}€,§'_~:§.{2}"> _ to pay. pension, ieave and S€;{1iGI'i'£}{M0f p€3r;:3'G:1s{:ab}:sé<:::"'£*;€:::i_4 uneti-er the Sub-Ruies af 1990.

K' fixatian of basic: gay an abgiﬂation, -- Su't;:%f§{:.:ive_VV '{2}; 01' Rake £1 refrirs {.0 counting of ':1"§;¢_x§.:i_'ri'¢;:s»<_i. fof thsff: p'L1 :*p?0se {sf seniority. Rule 4(2) rfszit-i$TaS'--L::§s:i.2r5:'--ff" .A 4, _ §}-'&jJ£:;.. .Peifisi;:}f2;,.: §~<:?az.5f'e2«..a:i::i¢:§énic>ré:1; of riergotzé5ﬁQs§rbe'd u.r:d€r' these rs;u'.es:' {E} The ir'z;i;?iaE'-- I3 *°"~';';(.:" -. am: ££$sz"s£'a:1: 3Engir1e»€2r' absoﬁi-ed urzgieéifv ifzsiée rules shaii be jixred azi Xéhé' §'E'1i'?'Z1;?':T'iL§'?fF@W 6.33;" the sccéfé Q?" the yogi cf A ' V. 3 A§$$£:;":_:Q,2.'::§: Engi:;:.eer in wffzich Em E3 abgorbed' 'V ' service rezzdered by a persarzs ¥a"'§ei:'cé;'siT:'*a{:§T Erlginée?' prim" :0 {fie daze Q?' éiéégrﬁiiasz sfmii c:Q:,:nif§r {hie purpage ojfézavé f,'a';,:':d pensimz arﬁg ﬁzz: ghaiﬁ $193; cmms: far {T316 p:zJ"§:%9i$e sf S€;<:.§§:'ii§ 2}" The. z:1I:::<'}*s::'-.1. E~'.:z1E€ w01.:1c1 iz1<i.i_c:2H,<3 t.h;;1i. '£.§m3 s:;€r1»-*ic:'_t<= rezuderﬁd by t.h:? p{31iii{}1.1er's5 2::.1:":;(:§ ot.h<:sr:+; ::;imi_Ia1'ij; I}1E'1{'€3{§ E§:'1_§_._;Ti1'2t?(%r$5 gyricar ﬁzz': my d;.1E..e «:":«f ;z':"i:>s;a<3t*p%i<):1.. Graig for the p1.1:*p<'>.<=;x:: of leave, §3;r:.§;: ;3€211$§.c:n_. §;%i.f ~ mat: be ::3i'a11'y a.si.4;i&;1'.21z1<?e $7"-.::x:* tjhé'-."f ;'}%,:»r»;3.0s¢ a.}::i';V 'V 21 n1ai.f,c=:1" of fact, 2.: sapeatific? <%x<%i;f: "{_)i' 15:' St';'.'I""~fiC€f 1"€E1d€."I'f;'.d 'by '€.hen1 ~..1}.j;:a_% to "1E.1_£%'.§:E:a.i',€"'~,{§i'miéeir "

H"-:gu1211"isati<)§2 fer)? i'.i'1.<3 pt:rpostf'"at;-1f" g--s§:}§T1iQriizy 'L.-ﬁzz:-2 .iv17:<:iEcf:2?:t&?:£ in Sub Rults {2} of Ru1s:'* Zi.; ' a<7%Ce.p1:c:ci ihv reg§1zIar'i$21t.i(3t:.. :=;i7.jVi..E'1{;%ir "

':-.m.:~;c p<:€é£:iz):1@:r:§ $€.ve':"aI §ei,'£€i'%--a 2:2 . B at V :;--'i;{f§v(f):i*t:§.i1'i'gf' and rt-3p11*§3S*c3:1t:tzi;if<£z=iS;. §,4?§"«.*i:11_i:..'f34";£'§_:{i'.,-'€,'E'£ by 1i:.h:.=:r.:1 <ie1:1az1<i§:':;:

<é<mn}i--ingg GE" §;E'1ei..:"f-- :-a€:'rvE{>e rigggm {rasnz Ehé:-? jg:-sag" 1.€¥?%"%'?' '-v.A€\>r1x;%2i;e73§:":ip_z-:».A ;;imd :€o"§::-------«'fzfészm ESESEE a1f?;:<~:*r §'iEg?J1§€iE"if§5£1§'.§{}E}. *f§L;,§§::;21*:3.;1i:iy';._i§':$:-;~s@ g:}<2:'.iE,§{>'1"mrs--s R2':<><:§<:_é;:::i {E19 {iO{§i"§E's <3? 3.3% {?.{}%L;--:i'E:.. ii': §*:'}}"{?é1:' 2{}{}2 $33; §'i'i'Emg_; ;uppE.é<::1i._i<':»:'1s irjcsfgkm §E'::% E{,§'{."'§i ii-,."" m:>':'c 'sham {'?§C"c"(EE"i };ez;n':+; 22§%':*.z* %:..§:T1<:? V"*:"i'%§5;2.1%;2r§.§%;::ri:.i<3:'; (3? €.E':<:a§:* :'«s:e:":r§£'=:;: in 21.23 gm: €§a2:T:§:»;i:ms~:. " .;°s'j3§;~i;-..*.2fAi?'{T';<f.'§ €125: 2z§}:}:r<:* E".h<::§: *¢;s::"<T% :'T:a.:.:5;;a::s%2 2>a§'§{::v::-5 %.§*':;"::}:* 2%-=:;'%:":_.: re3t1cierir1g of s;e3:'rx.-'ire f€')§' 21 §_.;i_ve:': k::1:1;:i:i'1 <3? time. E"§€§I'f;f %;'m:* guerimi GE' 3 'E10 4 };€'>:-1:3; <t2>..:1nx:3I 1736 a*::>::s:»;i<:i::1."c.?:;§ as 2.; 1i:.«_t4':};§;;_;=:"

{ia.1ra€§.a:}'rz of &3€EE'\?i{'fC ':'emi€r£:%c§ 2:33; zhxzz p:i3'£:§t:i{):'1<':j~§'é§'p:fi*::;§~#5:.) 1'€gtiI£iI'iSEif.i.C)I1. }}7jv<::'1 <'}i'.}1<3::*Wi::+;t;x arm: 3'1a5 {.0 i*t%§7k'{ 2_i"i. 't'.f:4_-%i.;..T s3<3z1iorit.y in 21.{::1<3r{.i;.::'1_c%{: with §~?.z,1i::€5};'AA%{)'§" '}.<}S';3--.() 2=;;;::=pE'£<:ab'i:=r7' $.51 tlmm. But far {.118 RL.1E€s3 of 1S§E%Q:'-.'ﬁ.}€&::i_';;'TT"ag;§p<3i:1i::fi could 110%: 'h21ve bsr::;*1': regzilz-:f§é~s:-=:c'i 2":t"':.s11I. V t;}_1': 1.{3;1..£.:Wh..;m<'i they are claiming b:?:'1<3.f.it (sf réggt};3ris21i:'i{;':';TL::1<.i§:é1" i',h<3:.~s<:

Ru}:-33$ 0:: the <>f,h<3.i* hé1----mf§i, tE';%_e},-j- :31{LG}.._£1{:i.C'Sf.i()E1i1'1g' 21: pa :1 0f the Ruit-355; W-'}1E'f§"€3 if ES _ £3i.:*:§é'ii§2'2'i«Ej1faZ>§»j{'f§ﬁ_1.ESE iii} '£h:;:::mu '£"h::»r€I":iire." "'s*'!35v53%1t:e%%§*§;<§;' §;f(1 L* €1a._i§¥.é:i'1<i er' rep.reSa%:':t.z1t.§<':::':5»; givei1 byfihfz p:':t;ii.'iv:§L:1e'r's:__ h~:=?1':.~:--' to be €i()I':S§d€;':1'€d wii'hi.n Elhif'. §;>ara;::*e_:1i.€:%ri2i§' div' 'i;3i1£i-sé-:"'£{2i'15<%s éliéii ii. <%z»1:'12:1£;i go '::}eyc>r;<i shes. *§C',§C}{i;1'1.:6.Eif:g 2:25 i.§1{;%:a€i"'?€'§u1<3s, T§'1€':£"(?fQF€L Sz1E3-§~Zu'Ic: LTLE2} 1:-'1;

" xx Riﬂéé as if; xssm; <':h;?aB€t;3g;:{><:§E aiiej reifm" ¥;.<,:» v2;s1%{:§i*i_§; <33' "\r;. " * "{faz1:i§{§2I:%:::%s;.»;} "%1%:§§e;':%:~';§ 'E'h§.se I.?i:.:§e:': 5%} ' ~..:,%:::.:'§r fL'T.,§,.¢:'5'~5§1ii:f.V§*~ . V V _}~

23. '§"§'é€: T:'iE:m§;';a'-1% :>=Jh§E<:-3 a::}:1$i{E{é:'i:'1;g 'EEK: '<a.»'2::§i{"Eéi.j.; {if A §{i»?:) of {;".%;:3a=:{:i;2E Ré::<:m.?Z.£_m<7:m; of E.,{_;<:t;¢-ai <3? Efés L:":{'::-"'i.E pe:::.i.7€'§w';%;:§s ,i=é.:--:':;"<é :10?' E:"1iE:.i;1§Ej; 22;.:s;;>::::s%1ir;:<:e:E z1g;;;:.i;:::ae§: %";'1<'= '~ _ _V ' 9%} E. bg%_§;:*}:"e {32'1.1'1cii<:Eai:e353 (#211116;-;*. to 't::s<? (';i1{';':'é{"'i{'}.I1€'{i in :'X;:)p£i::i--2-:1ism

4.» E\:'<)s,29'E}f5 {.0 i3{)E{1};'§E}EB8 z-mt? iiza-> 5:ez.m1'2r2. wzzsz 1'q'§"'V 596'}. .%:;$:

Eh T:"ib1.:1'1:.-11. 'I"E"1§:~; <'}z"<ic'r 'i"'JéE1f%~:~ 21{i'i2'":";T1€;:r:E ':;?f.\;*"" i.§"1r::?: V» {3m.::"{. 0f;E{2::m.211:'zz:.}<.,:>z 2-1:":_<:i Eh if 5;~_:;;:.112_:.f "z:?;»?:m{:%~ (":2 E33 _€%'Ev'":§.:.;:%Ieré§:§::§':'; ':3€f<:sr'e Eht' Sup:'a?mc;-2 C<31.1r'i" i:':;__ F3, "-~f:%:"§'~ 8494/1996. '.I"1'1<:? <_:~rd:':I"s ()1;'Ti"iE?_'TI'ij.5L3w1f1é.3;}.VV'::3ii?1(Ii'V'-LivEff'f'i§i§:{}"£ 'V CGm'i: 'xaI01'<;% <.:<">;'1E3.1'm¢=:<;;¥. E3}! f}*:--:2, }5~_},§€:>; (§m :g:"£;~._ if-£"%'1&::"1 ea $imiiar R1116 pc>1*€.21irT:i:1§g;-- i«::>.,§{>r:7:213§ §:::2;ii*:éiVi(;1é1i..e;%ss has }"€f2?£tiT?'"1C{,'§ i'ir1aI;;'i";Vl we z2m=:. :>f :;%'1:3?:-e:i:»§3iIr1i{'::1"-?EJ;2;ii:_ '§"..'1"1'v::§ ' "i'r1'bL: ma: maxi; ﬁasstiiiézci in p1éi<_:i:}*'f ':"c:i.iv§211'1€:{_:;%" Em f:.E;=:2,:3?":f:;é1.i::1'fz1<.::, per%,21i.1".1iz'1;g In 1°}."1€i*. Rtgiles §)[f7flE:_98£§1e< 'N§4i;}'i.._.f€'ff€:?FC1'1{f<3 €10 ioctai <:21:'1<Ei:1a"£:<;*:~;. Apart: fi'.Qﬁ1_ ii 1 at ' « .:*c;:-§iT2;:I1€%*::%' ' :55':

__ i2;;1:*:i':s:;, £219 'T1'ib1.zx'2a.I {iii} d.iss<:=.1ss fE§:i{f}"§ . ;a:ﬁd.

:%£:iﬁ:i}:}:";@"rs3 e1.ré€i'» . 3"12:s_§:~:. :'i_<¥E1i:h:' €?i,)E1{3§{Z{§{'3E{'§ €_:}":;_1é. i}'1€;r5:ﬁ-3:"

. 3' V V V . ..... 2-: « 2 L:~='::g'g1;E2;':* ~-saémg::_.§%2.;%é'e=:<:'§ ;3<.>s.~2:€': aemd £:E'1.::=.3,r §ﬁ£'i;"f}"{? £Zi§f§§.'){1"2§§'":'E€ii 9:12;.' on <':-a;m':2j::2é.:.i:_ £.§'1<;*:"'e§"<'>;'€: %.§'1{,' _;:}{%:'§o<;i Ei3¢::::'x>%:e:+€:: }E}E.%? M:

x 5 -gm: :2:%g__§;:,:Ez3z*§s:s2s§izm <3? i.%'2.:=:i:' f.%€3E"V§.£':éi?&§ 2:55 . 'aféy-:".% Z16 A$:sE:=3i.a1:'1i': E:I'}g§§.'1'3€'€?I'S {ﬁ'.21i"iI"1{f}*{'. be 1"v(_%}~:<>:':e(fE €02" '(E132 p:..1:'__pw:~;<'* Caf S€;',E1i()E'iiy".

24. 'i"1'1<:é 'E'r'ibm':23i while c['<;}:15i{iL%1'i§'1g:g; ?E1";=.'*§ :;:.i€1.2:1:§,?"' {3."§"17§..z 1 "

121<:h<;%s, has rig;'hi.I},«* 3a.id t.hat5'. 3f'i:{:é:""1.'e?;}<;.§:_'1g £;£_,€i"ié*2:a'j1f'2igg:::i'«~<33. sau<:11 Rulers emci gaﬁttizgf 1*<*g1:1121ris:-ii.«i0'1*1--yirif {.E"1é.' seimirx-'i:;7<:€,,%'§'3;%"

pet..i_tiG:m~33:s siepi; 0\::3:* £1611" :'ig}r.z:.Es«§i.i1} 2002 if'E:"1.e§1f€éii}1"<ii*. {he dtgiay 21116} i.:>1c:hc.~s::2 <:~w;":~..t_:.heii'=:;ié1:"?:f€:?21'i:;::j:£>i: I*:s<%'i'§;§I'i:'«E;>rr:rai»

25. Then c«:)1'1'11':1g_-g ta '~2113:%1:h:?:" £>,.Q'1"2tf;~m?é_:':*ssy misc-:c:i by the r<3s;3c>r1ci::%;':f,g._ ? ;':;'.a._ta*._f,<:-V: r€%g3Ai1:r:{i§.:;;§V.f' n<>r1-j€;i£1der of? 2'1e.é:eSs;éi r3;-'TVp'2-m"j:;{i;-1253' f'{,?'Vs-?' 1:"; r§t.:;=r E',E':.;eV1V'iV:. iV he }::r;%E"[ii:i<H1t%rs;a have 1:01 nlzide £1113? ' of _Vi}};~i§;*~}.. t;:»:1i1£ii€i:§,ic%ss I;-1S ;3a1"'t.i<-as W'E'1('} *WC.'{'€-E zapg;n:>i:*:t.s.:2(i'*ziyggzziraﬂ._*iE':§a »1:~eg;:::_£a: ss:::2_:':::E,i<m.<:e:§ jg3<>s;t;s §:3téi:x.>s.-'C92':

i:<3"~é99"?;"E:v::%i" re Viiafczir :"<:;,_;:.:L;-:.ris2?:i,i0z";Q LJ1":i<;-35$ asmi i.::1ifE E21/iii': E§"£g.;§rZ::1e<?:*:€e; Wh{) Wmxid be 21ffe(:t'.e{i in <:ass3 'ah:-=% L-§;>€:i;§.§.:§£3;":€35':-5:;" §Ei'§?i§§i{'2;1E_§C§I'} \a;€=:'<;% Es: 'ax: 2iB{}'W{i€3; $33,»-' E§,A._'E.". 1arér<:%"V::121{i<'3~§:»afir':iess5 21:9 ha*:%;*<-3 {es E":::':»E<.E iélai. 'die. ;3c;=ri.§.i:3i{>'r: is j aEs;«:: %;:;:{§.§'<::" n::;:"f:--_§{}i:2{§e::* :31? :'}.:*:<."e::sg;s:_~ssz':::"";£ §3a:°€,.Ecs>;.,

28. In vi<;wv' 05 {E13 a1:2s:)*va:-7': £§i??3{?';.1-:~i3§%;i{)I'1._ xziewe-.{i..f:"<3m amy zitigicé. W"€f 231%? :5? tzhtz (3pi:'1§i:_)I3 '£'1"12:.t: I'1.<::"1<%{1":g'* :i:<:1=:";i:<;%n.§,i0r":.e; rmlsaécji bf; 'i'.1'1€ §3€:'fii.i{T§I'§&i1'S (it?-~§»:{i';*v:;.*.j_é1<.§ V' aIE{.)w:'3{i. * A»::<:<>r'ci§1'1;g1y. {E716 p<::t.1'tio1'3 {E§VE§i;1'1'i§:;3ES{3(i;' '~

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court