Yamanappa S/O Rajappa Hebballi vs The Managing Director on 1 February, 2011

[Cites 0, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

Yamanappa S/O Rajappa Hebballi vs The Managing Director on 1 February, 2011

Bench: Aravind Kumar

4
M)
1

Them wrii peiitéens eemizag @221 'S0: GI'&€§'S this daasi; the

Cam": made {he f<:»Ek>w£z?:g;
QRDER

Féearci Sri S,E$e':"adra.mé., Eeameci Ci3Uf:S§';'~§ 'Far *"§'if3

petitienez am? Sn Ravi,°i/",Hesamar1:}, ie_3§:;j.z.:%:_i '1::::wz;t:~:.s;::~<:VE"'V:fc;;*

respandemsi
The Ner:h»~East §ia:9{1?'a;s;f:aE:Va I Tfaxasgert

2*
C0rp0:'ati:m Ehereénaftez' ré'§e:;%';ed«__ tagé§és~-.._"Cé:é;:2:;o:'a2iiar:' fer the
gaks 0% bresvit}-I} §E'1I'f{}?.,Eg§1 :'"'€i» B3:V§S}'i3:'};é§.VC.i}iii%§fO}.§€f imrifteé

q:.,:o*a:§.@1/:3/' €€nd$:":§:_ ft? Vlaisabixég sf i<:::;gn5'j;,é;'§"'E*xIe*vwr Cenwai BL:s--

atamd tgiisivspeEf:.;=s:h1::+_'--r:0:%Eé'€:»~-énviiéng temier dated

éamkga : G maasxurek 
3. Tha C§':;_s<>vra'z}'3n'~.és'~$é§5§ E0 §'}f8f4«'"€3 recéivsé bids Efrem

pa*'és.;:;A€c§..§fv%: ;:_:.g::';_étV_rachj%sv------a'<.f3;*:aZ£h camé :9 be wmpéisd 333,7 $323

Ee$§:*a_er:§6§.::tN,§;iZ""1:§%:j'e§ §s::w:a,rC§&£§ ii: ta {Ehief '?:°aff€{: Sezzireiisr
A.::r:é:;~:mf<: '$3' fats' éiafafmaziiem ané

" §;:§=° EEK: C__:}Vrpa:}1'§,={§*;£;§:'§V' 2:5; gm"
f:,:«r%;%:..:6z ::§i:"'i::3::%f€<}z';35 if 23;.:"':";;. '?§3.é:re2:.fi;€zfg 112%: Chief T':°3.f§§a':

'4;:22"f;V'?;*:".%I%§E§19"A::}fz7: {3¥{}°%3.2{§E{"% as:  c:{}::'::":2'L'2ré%s:2:':§:>:3 £%§':§'":€3}:'2J,.¥"i~t E

":'i§':*z:;=~;{:%::_€§ 232$: ;?%:--:s;p<>z:g§i§::2:: E'=»§:}z:2  ataéé ff? 5393?? ?.{az2.:::%;::'=:'£--; s;%.:':<:£:
'é%2«:ié«~:_'E&é2"€:":s.; 322% ::z€§s::"€:{E  Ezzgsgss 2'%f{§Ei}'i.3jT£, ;'%§§§§z'i<::7é:é{§   saézi

. .;'.3{} ii} ;:é;'%::::s;«;£§*;-::5§ E13}; i:'3_*:.€:  "§""§'2e:,§'§é<:% {X232 i.:"::;2§E:3::*'

~  {E {??%.if};

4%'



W

. §§i%'=::é1-2;:::'?;'ji':<;m;?:" 21.3352 Exa: {::<:>:,;E::§ :":.e::-$2'. 323% :«:2.2'§}§:E.1E.:is3<:§  ':'€5§:}<32"§; <3? %:.E"'::*

23.§§¢2GETQ by §"€SiI'i€27IiI'}. {he interim Qzdar $21229' i:g__ the

cieamingz Cantram: pertaigixino' ':9 Kappa} '}_"mw1 Bus~sta.::§;.-»

The carzteziiéon 07:' me iearnsd acivecate a§§eé::'jV§nvg;"§<3é." 's%":e.T_ '
petitiaraer S:*iaS.SK'f'ad::'ar::i, is Ehw: :.'f;€17i§:§'€i'f H:1{:tif"ié;::§:'::}ié"' is?

gczvvgrnsé by' Qﬁﬁﬁfal Standing Qrdar :1:§{+:'E_ h:"C>a}:3'.;g'i;,;.éi§e}iri%:E§'~..

issued by the Ir{a.m2ztaka Stats Ré:a\§i"'7¥;':<"a.§zs;';.>_<;j:*'%;ifagggéféiien,
Cenéral Officé whicéj is §3i:%%:§.i::g §9i;§§ujf::sp9n§Vé:1'iv$ herein
and as par ciause 71.8  fj-;~::'v"4g£§}j_~:;' _Sﬁiaémum béé
amaunt 0:' vs..-"ha:  '§%:A:1 é§e;xrn:=A._a$L ';3'§ce":*A2&:§>}'§§?iie..__£:§c»ens€ Fee {ELF}
before inviting  "ﬁat been dens ii: the
izzsiani; ::a%;ss_V.vv".i%.__a:=*;'_A that 38 13:3? '$32.6 €€E'§d6:"
ﬁatifisafiam A?:§}r:$X'u.':$«4§5;'A'-  '"2?-'5-<3 :"e$'p0:':.é.emjBivi31?c:>r:a§;
Cantmiier  :Zs  V_:8.1;':.§}'-:<>ﬁ*§_i§§?"'s {:3 {aka d§3C€$ian fer aiiher
 ::¢§<':e*;_*E;i.:1g"%?:vs...%t<3r1t§5r matificzztiom and he aughi: 219':

is :'7if5:'s'€f '$x':}?_,E§;E'.:Q§.' 'f§§"fu?§%T:€f i§§:"€<:i:ia2'3. fram thee Chiﬁf '3*"raff:Ec

C<>:=1{:r%::7§E€:é*__aé"=;é%:3ff_ ?€:j:v1*;{?ex:,:z*€wS and thég zﬁsazgiaﬁi be <:e:}"r:t§ar§.:-* EC:

*.__ﬁ':€ 36:15:'-3?; !%i'5<:.:":,::§~'i,ng 8:631' as aissaa 'é:Eh6;= canéééiaéfzs sfc:'p'::%a":':eé
zgsiéca é.ir:'2?§f;i.:::§_: 'izrazziiéizz Eiés EA-'{3{i§C§ a§:«;{': {:{}:2%:%3zz::% thai ;'?;W§

237$:§g_f;:::§_{§;€3'§§?:"_'{}:§§;f§'i§ is:  :.2eg<>t%a:<>:z:i amiﬁ £i§§::'éz:s;:~3€<:§ ~a.z.:§*;.%2 ihs

<«7??'§'
E



tﬁffééiﬁi' _"§31.'E}€2€SS "E0 Ehfi Chief Trziffia: C3<>:1i:'o1ie:" as 3:28:

An:":5:>:ure~§' As S'L3.Cf§'1 it is Cmrszenéed that 3. <:iiz*:«*:_vséi';'Z.st..§:f:--§"'v:7As,:

r:":qu.i:'e3d {:3 be issuad {Q the 2"" E'€S}i3ﬁ1'}d€'1'";'z'iL t{::. :*§:ca}:iVs£.{:Ee:f',* 

negotiate and 21¢: on {E16 $613018? s:,:'£::mi'fit':*;:i  t_§<2e,§";:*a:;=::;t'.i;v::7::é}::

pufsuaa: ":0 iender Izatéficaiiezz dated.A 'i._8}?}§92Q»1'€:;*}:£.e 

aise esslaberate his S?;,ibITE}3:SS§{}1'ES by 'c_:;i:";.:é;endiz:--g; t§<2.a_3:_; bf;-a V§_f'1:L2e of

inierérzz grater that has f;:»e_¢n  :tEii's' "€;:;Gur'{ in
':?v',P,?°£@.6:%689;'2Q1O whareéﬁ have been
rﬁstrameci frG.m a§:c='S;§ﬁ";,--ng further €31"é€§'S
fmm. fchis C0z;1*f   a8 an éaite, ihéé
mandamus bid' Submiiied by
pe*';%f:ie:m€r$ p &§LsLra;n%; datsci §8,':2¢2{f*.3,G 92* in
'she a.§:em.aii:;e;  submi: iiizat fresh iendez"
  <::}é1¥§$:i  Qréer is %":av€ vviéger par'::'c.ipa:i@r:,

A€€;<5:=:§;1§:<é_gE}9 v§<:§~..;§1°?;}!g.v~'i'e:° Suéiabéae G§'d€E."S b€i:::1.g §aS$€3C§ in thég

V  %e ga:"'d;'

 .«_.?:3f"i:<::n:rg: Sré. Ravi '~£«H.{:s$am.ar:i, Eezaraeé a£%*mca_i€

'=._22;p'_:;%aiViz":g"{N}?  §'°€"3'S§3{}§E€§€'§"}§?i~% zaxazaiéai :;'::3T£}r:';§.': €L?:;-->.§ 'amgg sézarzszé

 §:":'<.e:;':.:l:9:¥;%é»:}':: is;  :@s3":;%: ?;i}2:_s«.; :~s'§,em.{%:  gags  iiézsi {;:,:%::~:«;%:é{:a:":. {:25

 §§:>:.§:.':§:i  :3E'ii",°.{'.': :32? §:f:{3iZ'9§".i{f5E"§2§{Z': Egérjizzééséé  '<2=;::>:.:§s:§ §'".E£>'{. 2;:?£:~se

%
1/=5?'



Chief Traffic: C.<3r1:mE1.er fer his»; azcceptazace and {Li-fiber

submits ihai as; directezzi bf; him '£32-'"}1.€7{§ rzew EIt3%'1€§:§?:S'-.;g%;i€:'.;i'f?5

eaiied fmj, the Cerpareitéan §'€fC€3iE?Ed Emlghez" §Qid''--4'.fiEi1E'1f§:§§-' 5? £9'

E.s595,Gf3*G;'~-- per meat?) as aga§:23:""éti::';.

patitionezzr herein far R$,8,E§@Gj'r ami  he  sj_':. 1bm:.:gf

there was a fénasrzciai £035 is $26"-vL.gCerp0rati,C§:VV.iii: 2:; siim. sf

Rs,86,S@G;'- per mamh. E5'\ssiQuic'a'"é§}$:§ §;€b.:::ii '{%i3;"t  way Of

aiterrsaie azjzbméssiazz that if Caz:¢:?§;:':iti:'1;;r._>'é;§j.fr€§_.§}1 ienﬁsm is

   

Qrderad in the ir:Ee":u= 0:7_ {§c:rg'3e'z*ai'§«f;':-1.,'___§E*:e petétierzer be

 

éérected EC: pay :'?§'<§   ihé fénanciai Ease, that
has eccz;rree§ %':éH  reimbursement cf
{ha e};p€::&iEv':§JEr¢: " "Life Cc::1"pa:{"a?.:i.@:f; {awards tile
Eﬁﬁdéfiflg §§E"GQa§S;'%! éﬁegé éfﬂzzmds he Seeks far désmtégsal {sf

Eﬁa ski: V§:e:::_:~:»:a»::;  

 V"}E£:5:1;*'i::£§;._'Z*:'é3:::i;<:§ {E16 .ie23v:'n5--d a<;*2:G€ai€g agpaaréng fa:

 r:éth::~ .pa§'§i<é.S §t"--i$.:-"a'z;2"§.:§ be 9:" heneféi {:3 extract the cantﬁum Eaéé

_ §3'%vvSé;\:§'E.,VV1€3:}f.' ﬁT1€3' E"§é§>f3'E3§€ ;'§u;_p;a"eme Cauzé in the sass if Tﬁﬁé,

 '€£§'££§.E;;£:E;as§%°'b'¥"3, ifniafz ﬁf gggggg :"a33;;~<}r€i3{§ gas: gm 3995 $é::: :2 

" . fa "aai§'é'::'t. :::e:s:z:a§z',;:é2:;§:3z%  'i»'éi§.3:{§ 3. 'i§5?§"§{"§€fE" é§%E"§.§§ :«;<:'a:§p:*: (:2? jazeiéaiééaé

' ya?  

 in %:€:%:":{§i;~%;" z:'2.:22:€'53.:rs§}  E: Efgzeaéé '::>{<=:%:=.": "%E'°::*3s:§ 223 ':::.2::;§€=3":



€326 qus:%si'€a:": <:>f5eg«cz§i':y' ifs; {;'<3z2::ra'*rr": 5;hau5a7  

'E"'?2,a2 duiy of 3%? <Z,T°::m*'£' 2'5; 352 {L'O?'§_ﬁ?"L€ z'Zs«:az:f7--:z:;

Mm

ix.»

Cu

:43;

V  w?z,iCf":

'E2;/'?'£€i§':.e:*" :52 cfecisian ?'?'§££:3€'i??;, ;4bz &:sf?§,;:";}*§§'u:? 

ex<;'z5€da%d sis _paz:,_ée:t.:rs_P
CGf?E??2.§f{€€5 an e2:9§'<327e:Tz?*"£':z.z,s;f?'~ 
Commzﬁeﬁ breach, @355';  riﬂes" of

r2a€:;2fczZjusEgk:e?."v--_ '

Reac?2,eaZ;    r,;i€§?.5;'§*'£73¥?= " =_wi*w'Ch rm

' 'E"r3QSC?'?V.V§:Z'Z§E€?:: .?'?is;:E:.v:;:2a§«»: 'Lz2£2Li§d have

;'%*é:_:aa?a€«s2',; :8?"

'L-%.§::$--.€ :Z._§fS L:;@;s;;€%:3V

_j§"'§*;..a;"¢::zf%>';<§, if -is rm: far the Cﬁlbéff is

3

-- a,»:%%£~er:n,iT%';'.2 ..-wheéfaer pa.rz'z'§:a§a.r poiiag
:2: §:aCr'§:a-izzéexr decfsiorz taken. in the

 ~._ f%,$;;f'i§E§?zen: cf 5926 59935533,; is fczﬁr. It £21:

9231;; caz2.ceme.«:"E 395:3': {he masifer in
35935 §€cé$i:?ﬁ,3 Pzaaée 5388;':
:::zf~2:»::«?n. 'Z';i<z.e axzeizz {gf €525 Suzy ﬁe azcé
j55:;:'2*'§g_; 25253? zésgrg j%z}.r?':T  :9 Sage,
S}é.{}r.€E§,; ;3z,;:', 2792,53 §f;?"G?;i.??.:S§S 2,:;;3z:m w?z.ic?'z.
gm 52cfr?1i:2€5i:*ca§iv5? aa::'£z'z::': £3 :;:,sZ.3:;'e:::E :9
{fs5§??, Ea?

::s22.::"::§   .?"E;"iU§{3E{2



W31,

maz'2:':er in wh.z'c§2 fhe a'ecz's*i«:m was;

madss.

5;} ?'i7.e= (Tour: 52063 rm: haafe 

e.x:pe*rtz':«:e EC) cam-:26?   -3'

aa'frm'.rzis:r4::i:z;e de¢::€.;<;z?:>32.' if. ,q_"':<',eve:;zé2,z/?_

Qf the a.a'r:2inzL€e'imi:'z;a?¢_ ;:§e5*§si§o§2»:._ 

permitieci it wii _ 1 1' T

awn d€--':*z':~;--*:'.:j::rz,  w:,'i?zo:}gf  
rzecessary éfg::§ém:'s:e E,-zsifiz"c?z iz?.sa>Zf

znay.  f;:s:az:a:g=; 

{'4} The fe;frf3fil3.q;'"€_}:§: £?9i'wif{,£_§;:7z Ea Eenﬁer

*.._;:?c:;..212"z:é_>:' ;:*e. ..ei3;p'ezi"  gzzafzciai scrutiny

f:?2é'._'€?zé:é€:€5a§io:z is Eerzder" is

 of CO?'iZ?'°£E£'f, JVo:'m:zZEy
°3p"5€§zi=:z;:%ig;:,44%h.e cfiecigforz fa accepi ifze

 AA  T.::2;" :2:,:2<;az/'<3 zhe graniraci 1'3
 r9é$z'éf*§,ed by ;:2mC€:s:s; of negoficziimza
 iﬁzrough sevemf zéers. More afien
 €52,532 30?; :«::2{:%":, a%3{:'is:'0:?zs; £235? nzacie

<:;u.af€Zcz:2fz;eZg; 323?; exgﬁerfs.

}'"'}3.e {E5} zxerrzrrze 32$ mags?" izazze

733%

ﬁ'€e?e:§£3??E. 5,1?' {'::2r2,'€s"a:ci. 5'22, aiﬁzer :z;{}§"a'.3,
5:. ;"'£z:'27"3Es::.§; 5:2. 5&2: d,§<3's";"3.£'.;<;  5:,
z',3::%:é5:s;<zz"gg <;'<;a="z.::::;r:r2,zf§g:.;':2i f<::=:" 
§2,5§:2':,i:':.'§$€r5:i§ $16? E}s:;e{;7_§,,f fig :*:{;*-ff<2?2,£2':§;: in

 z;s:;§:':'2:';=z :::_;z;a?2,:;%:"e:2 <13?' {g'$é.{:'£€é%:'{3-
#2,'.
W?-"



,;;gm

azcifnirzisfrgziiare sphere, Hawezxéer E}'_i.<f«.?__
decisierz mags: mi: onfy be Z8S?€<f33~,§:zj;,f_ '=.
ifze app£i:*a€z'0n. of ':,s,2eJ:27r_::.gi>i;<;'Eﬁ'»2i.:';*;_:g{ 
prérzczpfe :}f }/€»}{:§,§;{;?V?T!?§i%'k?V:€fj€ri;a::$ %

[if1C?fLidi?1Q' ifs €23'-§";éé'2*'~--;i:z<:%i*'$ E:z.zf-vgyg-r,zSvir.i'.»

be ﬂee' fmm az*£j:'zi~r"§ca?"{?"2;€$;s_ ' §*ad:"*-. { ' 

affecied E21}-.__;Z%ia:3 :}r" (3(:i:.::'z":f'e2f3.V_Z')g,{V§

mafa fidggx

{6} Quas;-??_:£}=,g 7_:ie;::réi0.ras: ' " »?::1e:zg;* irrzpage
heavy a:im§:vfiS:'mz:i.;gév.§§:::i§.;Eer1 an the
-iA a-dm{§§9zist:ﬁiz0nA"~..L" .._<:z,z/tarV Eead to

'3._??«.Cr€;2$;§C€'....  %{:;2::£ . unbzzdgefed

;*'&:gxp55n.'{EiA:'::' :2???'  

 c<3::<;§':.v1V sT:%f§':*2.L:ézigo been had .213 under:

.  be I20 quegfiam 3f
§;1f?zZm:g;%é'r?2,e>:::z -3f A:"fi<:'5.:§«,?4 if Gawernmeni
V":.?7:'_e3  {ha ﬁaai g3e,?'::«:on 9:" 3525 £363:

 The rfg%'2.:' 23:; ﬁzagsss {:a:rm<>€ 59

V' '.V--V'%j:§:3:%§é;i:§6r\e>§,£ is be? an arlﬁfirczrgg power. {Eff

. "é}:>w":;'e, gfifze saézj pezyesr  az,2:5z*c:l3ec§j*Q3'° 331;;
&:>ZE5§§e*;r«::.! puﬁgyage €52.52 €3}:€?"C'§S€ oj't?:.5:fT _g:2:;:z:2er

232553 5%? simarfat £:"s:»:??%."

V.  Ya:  i;f:?:§:= §r§;{:§2'§>Es:': Sziprszizzaé éiezmfi; in she: cage

 ~ §~§§§§g§§§§§ $§,?§§§'?23§§ ,::::§.§ :53. 5%, 5% 5%



which was ba,:ee<:?. an c:bj{-':ci:iV<§ a:1a1.};s§s. 'E'h:iS act of {he

respandéanig Cafifiﬁi be tsrmeci :9 ha aéther e:x:<:€$$éw: €Z€f§~"*f_€§S€

9:" pozirsr (3? ceztirary ts) {he énterast {:5 this €i@rp0rat'i{;':::;"-§--%ﬁgé;;s

{much as? as per the bmaii gL1id€E:7:r:e3 G1" the geneiﬁl sta;*i'd§r:g_f V'

ewe: dated Q2¢Q:E§«.;2Q01 at Azarzexzzrewﬁe;'%é:i3L'1:::t*t&_3j :,:::?r;.A a'1é._::1i'~?_'§'uSV".

stand are entrusted ta {E16 Eendez' §:Gr:':ri*:'£%;%:%s:j whic}; ;c":i;:'r1§Vr'=§ér;":$ '

Sf _§L:r1'Sc§i£ti0;::.ai Bivisienai CGf} Ev§f£§}§€1",  'fwrafféc
Gfficer, Accaunta Gfficer an:i~.SeCL1fi%y' v'C>f4§"1'"i:é"f:L<.:%r. 'T'1r12'.,vié;, Ehe Chief
'E':a.fﬁ<: Managsr being the  weuid be

within his p3v.,r6?*g.. 41;;  '=3:><:a§_1*::£2§1{--":_.' :§2«r: ' frfs:-:f:d};¢}:A's receivsd ami

evaluated  vie ensure that timre is
S'U:ff§{3é&f§'§: :':a,:z:§::*§é:*V  in the tender promss,
f%:1ar:cia§ Ef;*svsLA.is4"4"r@*.A;V':9 the Cofpwaiion and '§§'}.€*
  in the {ﬁnder pmcess and 21:}
Cﬁfiéé    . - '

IE. i':v%::Hg:z;3'::1€--ra.§ s"'z:a:§di::.g Gréer at A:f:.z':.3xU,:*€m{E éated

 séépuiaées the precadure :5: '$38 fsilawaé in fesgzwci:

 Z§c:3f:;.ci::'§; {if €:i}E:'§1'1':f3§"€:'iE3§ e3Ea{i§§is§2§i::€:r':':$5 %;>:_3£E§§§2<::.gs amé

 "..§a:":'ﬁé§"E3%3§£>:f:g§:2g; as  {:{T::§'°§}§3§"::2€Ii{}'f3. '§h§2; €§.{:es:.:>;  mfeg' *3;

 'agzizzaég E{*;<::gai'.§<:E 27:5; 3.536 §;>'u;:_% -E§'§§{:(:§v.:"4§.{l§'E;9<

.y="



_§ﬁ,#

12. Thus, {he s:@rzt€;<1.':§.0:1 sf the igarneé aﬁv-Qfsate

appearing far ihﬁ' peiifzianez" ihat 12%-'5 respzmdem: 

autharitjg 2'2': fa§i¥a.:'di:3gg tbs evzgiuation. 0%" i:'31"2&e:°&:"-éié 1215:. 

Traffic Cen¥:ro1.Ee§" Carma: '()9 heid §:ii:'E:4:* ::§A E;€:ATV'éxC§:?s--'é'§*s-*5;

exercising sf pawezr or cr;>m_tra.ry E(} ',_'t1i';1'€ i§3§é1fs?:ss':. o§».*{E~"1,é*

C0§'p{31"£.tiO:'1. In view 0f the sa§11€,'~i;}i'%3Vbf%rst'::Q'r1x:eif:{i%:;s::"{j§:f Sm,
SgS.'x:""adra.mé>, Esarned advacate 3. ;*"é'airi:z*:.<>*"'§%>r :héV""::v{§Et1?o:1er is
' ~. ,Lm')V '-

hereby rsjectﬁd.

RE-2: HXATIGBI 8;F'.--fEDL":0N€;D iif:I;fI7(3V::L1{:ECTf3If§C;§E 'mm:

E3. §i "§*:é;?s'-i::;¥:i;e::  $§fi;>':1€é':;;dY':3& '€b;'é;'i: 'te::::dez*' as f3;}."1ﬂ€X1Z£3"ES~:&.
ans? F' Gughi: {5} bi? Set aé§@é«:;_£i--..:fn.e gmzmd that {he aaenomic
1i<:@:r;e3€ fee £33.." ':he"--«re$e§v::&'~§3r£z:$ is rmi fixed when examineé
va1?:f.E*; rei'e:f-*§r1c"s:: Ea' " '*i:1r;¢'_'__.g3x2era§ sianéing GE'€§€§' ciateé.

213}'§}<3L 2{§.Q:§; _é i .:;:. E1.{3:j.::€& that unis? the Qenerai Sianéirzg

iﬁrciﬁf" '<:iah:%§*"'{}2mé}f§,2€}@E 53:: z%:2::exu:":5--B §{"3€S 225:3

 , §;:i:pu§a:e» 252$ E9.-§i><_::';§.'{€a§z <35 ecangmic Eiaésrzse fw: :3? E°f3S€§"€J€ _pri<:€

'«-z§§E;2:£:z.g £0 '::a__?1§_:°:1g fat" §I§3'2".':.{§€§' ff}? znzaéniaiaéngg" Esiiéig amﬁ

 in  :~;ta.z3£§E--: emzé :.::1:":.:>:.2":m.g;§ :2?' "bus sigma? ;3z*:::2;';%${-ése 5%

. :§;:2?':fz7j,ﬁez.:"f§:i<;<';3"s ax?" iiézémizai  iérﬁair :5»:-M: _%3;rm€X'%,::;'e-~-{E i"§.E%§Zi"':£T§

VvTf";E;i3;.4?;:"5%»2{}{}§;   fi%%;~§.:2{.%..§§:g {}f€§€fE'" .?*£::,>/~%§?3 :,§.:%.%:§2<§



$ 37 ,
02.83.2303

21%'; f3x§"1§"1{3X'L1E"€-§ would g:} is :3§i:ew' tha': ¥:h<:%§q__ are f:3€@!;?.1"EiE€, distmet and m.€:i€:3p€I':€3€nE.

E4. Yet ancétber yeasen Maia}: requires 1:@?'b; € «3§g:~;;3§7g:91€d,--T V' fax' ;*€§e::ti.ng {$1.9 Ciiziiﬁﬁtiﬁfi -13%" {E16 }ear%:€{§"é:d:v{'2Ca-:£e. f5§:;:2p§é:':'in§j fer the petéiioner is that in cases Qf mai::eie:1a.n£e {:25AtG'§Eé:*i:s'=~¢af;&'--.. urinaés, the respandents 2":L:th0ritf;?'L«L..};:i:«z:«*<e {gﬁzzitted to stipuéate ELF' 'ands? O2',v§5:iQSE far simpéé aria? <::bv£s::s'a2s 16:33-or: frczm time is timﬁ} saasan ta s«:§as$:§;si1:}.'a:1<:C¥_. ''?his absence af ELF is axpéicit erders rzamaéjg 493 éazesﬁ is-' mmpareé wslth Gazlerai Standmg Grd£::_ 4':\§:>.%%'9;&2'--:..é:§%i%:ai: '?§£'3DG4,2iZ'IQE ,%3x§::1<-3X':.3re»~€ and azfe Ezaié in _£_C;rﬁ§§4;ézV:"iV_.é:;z:V.';.Etis éiisa EC: 33%: zzrgiicsd. that gaeiiiéener hgigeéﬁ r:;;j:§'3'%:h_§_:'b>'g3is :::§'E'«::2.:f>_?'La:*@ iim-7§'§fit";g ienésrg gt ﬁnr1€X:;z:"&-ﬁ; §'1{:"%V$' V _%;e:':és::* 'E35; paréécigaxtimg E21 ihsz ienciér p:';}<:&4;=_%:§; =5;%_:"z%f§'~'%E?1;--«*_;Vs§kzzaéuiecé Em éiigzappeé {mm c@ni:€;'1d§.z2.g ':1/':3:

Eﬁﬁﬁﬁ? émpsseé ﬁg =?3{}:'1§i"3.Yf§£ tit: 53% C%6r:_€r'a§ {}§'{§§i;;*. %§22:--«"§:1g;; ;::::::§a:_.%:3:%¢§:<:'§ E5; §3a>;r%:i:*:i}38JEé:':§»; in '$16 ;;;*:;?v:i%a:§35;:I; p:::=i:§é;.§{::::3%;r.* am: aiafi 3m?" 'BE: s:~3.:a§.:;f.§.s3::§ ':1: >:a§$:'2 :';.'%.,s.z:éE"§, 21 "*1 " :*:';:§.:,::':":<;§=2*:%*;;{3;. {f'*J€:;§."': :>z§'1%::='s2 f:'§'iLE§_'§§ §:*z:::,:n£§' $3 i%;x2»"s;a*2§.:7:<:t{§ ii: f%::s':s:3:<§ "n a xxag, ,.

a ,18_ E3}; thig C-mzrt that tmé game is; bereft czf i1"LI{§'}. as digcuwad }'§€i*:'€iI'1€J:§O1»'"tC?. £*'aC<::;3z*€§17:<*:gE§=*, i:h»:-3 Said {'{}§'];{€E."§1iiG.'§'} 23 .3130 §':%_éi»"&b;; / sejaczeﬁg 15° This Cgaurt by 0§"C§E3Z' datsd msiraimed the reapazldem 2mthe§it.i€.:_$ fl-"A£'%Af,:'*§}"--F1(§C.i*i:;}'ﬁE'1Vg..__E;3:33j§i* tandem pursuant Ea ArmeXur5wF'.::.1.1.;é1 fufzhér 0rdér§.v3§1d.saié erdsr has baezz in Gpezraiéan {ELIE cia§é""s23f:;§.V_§1'i: 1?s ::«ﬂ;.0_f€ 11591.1: nézrzﬁ mﬁnths that ?'{sC}1'§€"'éZ¢,i'?1,1E"'§I1€?;.}.S"'-_é,"iZ'E'1:'&C§p3E:§;?.1' ._s"€a:r:d is being Gparated by entrusting; ta s,;;a;';*;j§~f"<:§:* .;;5s:iEéo cf §:V:. 3;'::»§iS and it wmgld net be in the bag: ~5:{f« 11:9,;-.:-i, C;;;:'}L:;::>§9a,«:x: }L'é £3 itself ta put {he slack back é;,:1a§,<;§i§7§»£:':'tEg:'e:i;f§."*i:§"'pr'a3§:eed with accepiéng 9? '£3123 €€3'i€§{3§'S a%re&5§,s:._$:,:E:>:i§%;.'i'%:ié'2{%iA' p4i:j1?;<§::V;?;1r:t to Ann&Xure--F, Tha gaéd t€::dere.r$ Mafia §1;§'§a°*%j:v:§3€:«i7%'i"§{3.1u'§')E'i'T:iEC§ in flhé Eéfﬁéﬁf hava :;z£$@ :10':

e3;«i'%::~$;¢c§ ;_:é:A::':L3:;'e32':"V'é.:".:--s:?;-~«i*:ax;& ﬁat maﬁa any attempts E3 €:":8€:§+f3.§:"§2?_§°."E;:"=.EiE§'x__i{"3 "a:%:e1 :° t&:::d.e::°S hawé: rm: E3932": §1,E%."i§f]€E° prGceés:a;é?e:f§.__;:.:':":%;Eggs t_}":5z°:* séfezacés alga sxhibéts {heir E.a::§<: <3? *,_E'%:'*:;:*.~raa'i: is '€315: Eenégezg szjbrzzéiieé by iham is 13:3 ens? ??§fff€ E"3;§"€3 2:3 2§ppE§c:::E;é:>':::~; rzzasﬁﬁ ;'*3';-' 3.21:; 3? '§l*::3 ¥i1é:V2..:§é:--%;:::§?§;, §":a:v;.»-"<5,-: a:::'%3:z2é%':_-753 €::E2§:,§;' i<'f§'I§{5:€f.E"S §3[a:r$:,z.as":?'; ii} .§%":_:f;_:'":'e3'XL2;:<i?«~§i '%3&f1:};*§'--: Camrz €?§E§"i:.€3?§" a.:*;:a{%23::::'::":§ 'iézszé

--2E_.-

Cerggaratian whiie inviting t€'1"iCi€I"S. 53$': persarns *L3':I:::--:rest€_d in pazéécéipatian in the tender are 3,239 aft; iibertjg Us pa.rtis%r2;:é§{<s:_T'§z; the Sam: tenéer. Qréezsﬁ acsgrdéngijgz RE{K;"v"r1p*

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court