Mr H S Rangaswamy vs Sri Ranchore S Gwalani on 18 March, 2011

[Cites 0, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

Mr H S Rangaswamy vs Sri Ranchore S Gwalani on 18 March, 2011

Bench: C.R.Kumaraswamy

{ff'E7.§'§{}.32'7F{}€§,5${}€}2 E.3§ESE§§SE.} BY "§'E'-EEZ ii'? EKEBEDL. C'§'V'§F's:§, Erﬁﬁ N {E-s*a§.;{} §¥?;,.E.{Z-'

-"mags iiiiéiii/€E?1'«f3%_§; E{E+:"€§;€%IC}N §?'E'E'E"':"'Ei}Ex3 {:<>:*»~i:3m <>:~»:T».§}*%::e;;a EEE§§R§§*\E{} "E"E~§'§E§ E19': '§i7'E*'§E:: CQEEE E3.,"§ I'v'§A§}§*: '§'§§ E': ?i} ~ V QREER Thég {3;:*}:::z1é:2aE §¥{s%vis;i:>:1 ?€:'t._§i:§<.}§.: f'i':{';d_ L:;':d<%2i"Eja:;::<:t:'{:x:1$"'. 39"? éiiiﬁ 48} Sf Cz'.P.C, pr2?:;yi§:gg :17: s¢3:i:V.,2:sé;i_€ie '{:h:£&'_; ié1*:;:§:g§§ri€:£§ V' GEE judg:1:2{=:ni {ia:;:;:*:<:i €35. iE2.2C2{§8 ;3e1:&;s5:*::('i""3ZL;::Tf§"{i::*§..A.E*£s:§_¢ §*§€«.;'??3»§ the Elie 9? City E'as;'a': '£'m<:E<:v E321n§2:§:€}?€ Ciijg' zinai 325% g§:.1«:i§.§m@:1£: <3? <::}::i%*i;é§;§%.}f1: 2":~:%;3:§'-[$€fa?;,er:<:::* daizéci

8.§}_,2{}€}8 in (3.63§:;;t3$?@§2_;2:g3a2 the XV £':d{§E..

CMEVL B2::";g;2;£<2:"e._ AV

2. ?~§ear{.§ :_;.?L:s5%%E«:%a1?:*%:'1<§%*<i <:<:é':;z§:s&§ §{>;:'° ilhii ma-«*§5§£<.>;": ;3£:i.i§;i@n€:r ;'3%:"§ 8 §?€£§;§3;€_.%i:':{i:2aa .__:%;~s:£§ é.;$ 'f'_:~IE".§ E5 §3":'<3m{;{§ 150:' ?:;§"2.{3 1"{ff'v"§$%{}§"£ §€:.%:s§>{}:1§E:%;:é; E :;1".E.>17£f'%»'?fi:-.. §}€'f};"3;.§E~'s'€:"?{§. Eh:-i:=. Siziési {i<>:.':_:"'§': r€:::::>§*:i:% 2.23 weﬁi as . V 3. 321%? 2: '>,5€§'§i:;_:j§.:<:7 %;"§%é::.z; E"? ~ ;%"éé§;:<)§:§is5:e. Kb :2 V ._ ._

-V 5%; " 5322535: :3? 'i:'§":€; ::{};:1p§.2i:§.:':2::':ié; %:;€:i"<i~;§"é=:~ 'ﬁzz:-f. §.:i"§2:E {3::}z::f§. .1 :;2;<:~;. :A*,;.:::§¥{7.:ff&:

"F'E':a::? ::<>m;>§z:.i.zf:z;mi'. s3*;:.22:E<3s; ma: 9:: 24" E2, EQQ8 ihézi é';1{ffj3'i,E:':§€{.§ b{}§'§"<f§\>a:ﬁ{§ Eagzzs ii}? E:€$f§§,{}{}{E;'? §1:;::" tT':':::;>: §.'§:1§°§3€.§i€~§{% <2?-___ Eéiffé §3:.::e;£§':€:§3§:: wE"2é<%E"; €T?2§§"'E'iéi'{.i in 'E'i'3;€i"f m23*:":<:: zzmi §>';'2:s£{§dE':: Pi'iI'E§'é?."§."E:S, R3221': km §.§'22*<m;.§E'1 <::E":.<3:<;"ra.':__é:;<fs, E:~s;%:i'2:'5i5:'T;;;§-;_f ' :"\E<35a«{}3§2<i.éFi,. {ES-§ET2é¥ﬁ£3 :s.mc§ C¥3E.2iE§2 {§;f::{%§?:i";>::

£;::~'ngfm*d 'F:3w'n§ B2:::'}§§;z,'§:>re: ;ES1?::2§E§1z?'i_€__fg --_{>:t": "§~':;e' b::3;'mv».:ed 2iz1z>'{E'1er £92,331"; <2?" E2s;,2'é'3x{{f}{?{}/-- "§:_§f;:*'<:::1g;hﬂ' <:§';:;:q1:e'3 N{§:C?3E2e:§8 ¢;im2x;n 9:1 Caﬁzzzrgz §Eié9:":_.E%:;'- 1' .E,g{;r1.ggf<:rd Riéaai §{}"'Q€fZ"1 Bfiiféiih, §'3'c1IE§§Tc§_E{}I"€, z'§i{f{§{1SE?{§ §:X'€;:f,ui:é{? pmVri§r: ~"_:§}:y "§i:;>i.e3:s; zﬁimgg' xsziiib {T€}E1E:2."§@€f'I"(:};§L§{}'£1? 2:"' r;p'é.$"-.<§:';é:%""§?:>:3"Eig';-:3;'3,€':%§Gf~u an::>?{:I:1<:.:' far E€se,E3€};Q{}{Z%j gmzix/~ in :Ea1:r<}1.:':° ii}? {E36 {?::3mpEa§:'12?:'m'. A:>:§gfr:3:;-ii:1'g;;;;.V§%;;V%:{I§.1§,Vs.":";§i<::::'ii'z:}~a:§;':§; $9 r<3*pa3; '§'h{3 saefziai E.<>a1':§. 3:9 fizzje a:%<:::1;:;v§a§;::':é:é;':*:E %:::«nV{§§:2é':_z:af§'§ i:{>g§e€;:i§€:§* :2s:'ii:E":. §':3€€:mEs's. "£:§":€t'*&0§3 .... ..<7=:>:":1;3§3:i:'22::z€; $§'€..a§'.€;3E§ ihzgfg. £i§i,€',§ §"{I':V§%~';_f§2,-.1El§';?V*i§j' _;j:§"::f§ ;:'::~é3:"$::>2':2:_§. 2:§3§}:'{7s2?a<:E'::?:s; mzgzieé $3; §.'§.":€f {f<}{§'Eii}'§.£3:%.§.'%E§'§'E.§: {§§5'§§f§é§'§§§§{§.§§'E§;§ :*é::g}.;::;?§s3<:?§':§;. 5:? €;§;'22;% E52:-z.§*:. €.§2.¢=: ;":z:€:':.:é2;€::§ .E$s;:,.:{%a:i ;::"'{%§':§-::.;;;f:::§:.7%}s:r;':':"i§'2;§ ?'€<>,§i§é€f,%€{%3%§ zéézizaéai 2&3 E,3{}{}E E332' " "«§%?€;§5;;..?;.';'§1%A{}g:E{§<ié;¥" is; §'§'§.é3 {:%s;':m_§'}E;":_i.:_'":;mE {E3} 252% E,:1§i{}{}E i§:°2?§"s}2:"'Z§ ax: §~';:§.:*E2:§. {X}-'éT'§§§}., §E%;2.:;':.Ee:§ iZ%;:'§_§§3*§'i:é;:%i :'s;w;;:§':'§s §}2:;a::'z3<-3:::':'€ _ am §E:1<%A%::";%;€s:'§':.z.{

iii) :2 2.2831 37:)? $2.321: oi' $2.53. 2 ,{?%{i_GGii}j~ :i:"aw':": am Téags E§{}§{;'f§ §:':<:izra53;%r§aE {f<';<:z§é.-*%:"2§f:':%'».r€ E3gm.§<.. '§§*:a% {'i§§€f'?{"§i.E W235}; 'p:"<:é::%%3:2%<:c%.._éfzzfmi 331%'? .<;%;am€ W225; <.';§5~3§':0§':wm?{i zizmi ea §::>.§_.._§;=:': n.a:3~':,%{?té: ax-*;:;:%§'-- »;ié§-s5?§§::{€:'§..

E§:2:'§:':g i'he'~3. {T':{}i.i.§'§E§€';'t <2? <::°<::$:ss~ex2:.m1E:3.21'éiG:':., :'e;:.:1§ga3§.'ir;:':3.>§:%:a.$ V' M,' £12} him éghait 21{::::.3s§§2<:i 13:3:-*£3:* 'E3<}:*:*<3w:-55% ::::,j§ '"§(}£i":'1._§i"7's3}T£"§""§§7i€fi. {::on"2p§aéaa:1i.., ($136 $5: E'is3.ax:y ii}-535% Em: <é£<ﬁ':::€.{:':._ biz'; %}f'e_;::§'mé3s5s:~3'=--4 é7::?:;€§'-- E:E:§§'e::§'i%.<:%:' E18 wa$ :mi. 2}. g>1"<::;:s1*§€ét.<'§:*»..:«:.,.iéF HE' 3:213 ﬁiéﬁ. .i:1s§<>§'~:€n.z7%:¢' sasz:-*. / g§§g{é,§' ggrig gang;

and i§1€.<:rim r<=:::€:i%:e:' fggzzsa 'aha ggaicé firm.

fvfavzaibiﬁ rand 'ihéz {i<><:::.m<5'z:':.s §}{fE'§'.EEi§"iE§1§.§ --aé:§r:3§:1§&s:.€.{:%r€d by i;Ef2.%: :n?;::::Eim I"€§{';€'ii-'€i'.§'. 9? E1325 cE":.s3q"a<-3 cE<:}::=:~=s ESE §3.§'§.$§;': u.21?:;?<:2.:3é%i§* £3523', ré:%:':é:§*s::::<F§ an}-Y §§€S*,3;T§:§3;'§§{§ i"i{'}?E:{3€?. §«'§;::§f;:§_:*§§&§'§52 _E%§€f:?i'€§l€?:€:3:'.':§3'€"'--.'§..}"1<'£ :Ti{ﬁ§§'§{3{'? zmi. =:':{§;*"§'€E{3§.. %§§§:';:;i€;é.:;'ﬁ §{}E1iE{§ :;:.s":{ § 'zmii %::{}::{.% é'?'.X'§i'3{f{§§',€{§ '$31; 'f,§7}€3 :;z<:<?:.2:§€:{§ amii %.4-*z:"§§aE;a§:'%:' :';§é:.:r%:%_; {'E§§;~;<?:E{:s€::; $222": ihéjgg-* §,::E§§;: 'E"'.'§:€3 £.§e§%:%:':.:t:e:'% :3? éﬁréé-3* ;jé:::£;"}"'2;:*;L;*s}€-.'%:§2';' ::?::a€; ﬁéz'-3: :":<f::";":g}§2a..§.:1:::":§: Ems; s.~3i'.:3E{%:: the {_'§.é€{§iE€f§ E.::z.a§. 2}£«§'i§"f3V.E§f§{T{.§ rzzsé §:%.E€:?:;i ;,2,:":§; it:§m§:}§2:i:':§:. '§'><::§<";'§°£»:% i%E";§:: §;2<':§§{*:s*:, '§'.§*:ai: 11.3953 {i§::.:;:*i £IE.}i%§{'} :.>%3s§&i%:"v<é:f§ §§':;«gé. "i:;_:4;?: 22§,.;:§::'§;*::%&§5g ::1<:::".:é'.'§{>";':_:;*{§ 5/" /"Kt e:mm,::'":§. {:1}? his E3§1s;i1":a:?s:':~;s;; ;:s:.2:"p<::»ss&% zmdg Eu-"r. E1215: §'"§{}§" z'é3pai{i é;:E':€ $z2;zm: '§"h::: wiai {.Z:;u:°i ;:i.f§:.:3::* 21;;:>'§3:*a%<>§;:_%:'§:':;;,§ {Egg-;% %:?'£J§{§€3?§'3{?i'f 23%".-.?'s§J.E gmai z:n2.4:£:<;=::°i;':E ;_;>Ea<t:*:d <31: i"€{':{}E'£§ hzrgég c<m'1<: to 2-: {E{"5E'1{E'§§ié5&§§'}'i§3 :"ii:";£§§KZ {ha :1<:<::,a§;€:ii is; ggumjg {:5 =:3ffs::%z'§c<% ;')a3.r":.i;<3'habEs-2 'i.,1§'}{§{?ii'?§€:{':i3§{}§'1 {if i:§";.€: N'eg;:3i:§a2bEe §E'"iSiI.E'Lf§ET':€'?§'§§.S é'%.<?;i:; Em: '§"§w,_ El€j.i-?2z;':::;_i;i:i':§_z.zE £3-:§u:"':

has ':15; <3«>:ami:":€: €1E":€r C<}rr&%aE'z:':§:%s;s.,, _§&>:ga'1i{jz E-;a.':;;_»:i §2*€3_jg3:*fis:::i§~; {,~f'é=h.é:s~_ <:r<i€:rs: <3?" the C€T}U§"'?j. b€:§a>w. E21 2:21§;é'L«L.*§,%§1a;>u?, i:}i':3._ E'i.':1rf§.::1g§;,ré{?<}rde::{§ V by time C{}'*;E'§'f. Eieiaw wéE~Ti¢_ 2;:s_* E.hé;-5 §,}.§f~}§T3§{'._§§E:1"§.{ff C:>:§:é'?:. ares: in ac{*:<}r€i22z§<%<3 '\>.,:..-viE;i'3. Eaves 21.:2{§ *é'Zr1€= ':é2:;$£%'{:§" '::%§::?1_9g":E2aE§2a1::i. cammi:

be i:€%:*':1'::;é<§ E.1.'i:"2'{?_4'§_"'9a.:::*i§F'?ggaiii £?:E>€i§'}g;§ EZIi3;t€f 5<%::§e;{iv.E_'§én<:% §:in{§§:1g r€::é::H"d@<'_i ':33; Effie gizézifgs "z3:3'§a:3£%:=" e.,1:--_¥'i_é;§["is': ';:_<_:1i%a.;::_°€je:z,:1<::;: wém 2.21%-*',. ii: is i;,?:;é;% s::s>V:3*;:._<3r;<3;%.V§<}'m7£3? ﬁgs: iéteirzaezii g:<>>:.ms~;;<:é§ it)? iihfft ;:*€%*;»*--%:e;is}::'v:i__§;£33i:_i.fg..%a:§f:€r €:E:2':i:.--.--?:h:-2 a1_<f:i::i<:<:é veg-:.:=s iigssmzééi ism. 'i_@§§2.2G€}E 9;:":;:§_ ézi'E'"s<_'?:"::a§V::<§§§E.é:§_':f§§:'*was; {E26/{E an 5228. §2,?;${}i 1s.:i§:E:":én 15 iiajxsg <;}z1t.:-_é {Ea}: .éz:§;§%%::é':r 31; E5 iiiaijgsa "§'§':_§%?:éE"<}£*sé '%;',':'::? ::{>:z:;:;§22§'§3é: ~ j -§§"_1::'éa;§ p'r::%::':';§,'§:é::f£:€E§:; ﬁe ::§§_<E §§€;%'i. Ezazé ﬁrzss. <:;§;}g3<>§§.a:z:%§:3r iii} I"'€E'§Z.%.§.i"i'"§ x 'i?:'T§§;%'§€}éE§E i;E.1iE'"§€'}é3;§'i§'". '§;'E';z,>z..a.z§E§. ?;f?1£:'--is; <?s:}:1é:.§a§s§ic>2": 322:3; §}%3€'?.E1 E£i§$€;?{§ E:zf§.-3' §§f§;i.:'.:";€;%{%i :i%:a'3:,::':s;e;{,%§ iii: '%':.'E":€: '§"€Eii'§.E'-E';fé§fE'§'E §:}%:%':',§'é.§{';':":€§1 éiiéé %;.{:}{§:23§,»: héii §'1;.-2J.:a% :':<i;é {.i<;>g>»:3s;i:.§r.d the £1§Zf'E€3E'i§'1§', in EI§':,i;§L3p{':*.'i'i'. £3? his {%.m':¥::e:':i"é=:>z3 Em 2*é:§E{z:~; are she f€)§§€}¥E"§§E§_.-_§, {'E&%<::§se;i<>:'1:e:

{E} E3ai€E Ej§i:"m&s;h'k':.:;":":22:' S§§iziv':*2?:__:11 S{3m{.é;::s.s .Vs;, P:2:'§T{:%E E{?:=::;;". i5' E'z«'E<>E1:e1:'z'i21§ zmai .-2a:":m.E1s:r :"'epc'§':"::=:é<§ in 2008 €§E§€L,EJ;;§__§ 3{§£Ea'?L % ' -- C:°§r:_§%_:'1a.§ ,:1:;3§;§:%2;E N'<3;?:'§ {>5 19%???) . V A ?~§eg§§'i.i21b'£e:> En&§u¥;4z':11";1€;%:'§t.;9 N,-émrt TE;}i:=»5h<m<3m' GE if£1SQE2€3--C{>I}"§§}§21iI%'§.?"_~Céléiiﬁfr cf" ;.i{?:.~£€}:}~V?§:ri{::;{:E §::%,-§_ E5 éﬁzijya <:%:1VE$;e1ga<d by S. ':38 {<:.}}'EL3s_::3ingia_ :'2%;.:1"v§}§§*-- {iééy :1.@§«;i' to {he ﬁzzy {EYE wh_§:::§1 $€?I"§-"i{T€f af :'1{;%:';:;€: iims ?::é'::r::_:1 'z:fi'a%<§:?:<2:i. {2} in ?*~§arsi'§1g;;.h gas; 'F21pzz:§:a;._'f£'sA 7_G{§--w§:'t.?;1E'222%1~%$21.3 £Paz:f:2mi gmd :».z.n0'::§'§er :'ﬁp@:"E.€{3 iii":

{3r'm1i:f;V2:_§...A§§'pVé::'§1--i??s§{}_.'?*»§2';V._§§f":£éiC3{}.;' €§€*{',§£§{'3£§ 032 Septsrmber $5.; 29%,, _ % 3%.. Neg£:i,§':«:'i3§=c? i€.'f;s%'£;;:z;:;w.f;éE:3_£xé5 _§%.{'.'i,5 EE_§8E_wS:2:~;, Eé§2{b3 zmci 138 ;3r<;>vi.5;<2 {C}¥i?§<3mp':a.i_:':3:;£F=ei5é_zé'§3i:é1:££1: i;§me~E'iz::1_£i: far iilizizgg if a:z},.:'w Héﬁﬂds %:E"3;9:*é;*> - F:?;;€i?-_ :E2.£:1é§fs;"é_i_.:m 'ii.:Z§:r1<-:--§§z*mf;*§. ~ EFs§'E";€::"€ 'size {7<}mpE2§::'::%:LA2=a;:$ :'.'§»f!j:-*,5{§' E?:€f§{T}I'€;? éléiée ziréssiizg Gf {EEELISS 95 2:{:.rf,'§<:»:': $.22 "€§i:'r;1§i;4 i_':a§ F; g::i*{3'2*v£;<:.<:«'{<:}Q E:e:3:§§§3 i:'"25:§-Esjazi af {:§.:sm:§§.=".-:.$§:'2g' 'éézef n1_V{ii<§§:?2§§é1.?'§T§i;:'E.é%:§::i3tf:§§ sf €:<>g:§:':§2::>m{:a% <::{:='uE§: E36 §}{}$§§;3{}§'§€.':f€§ iiii {E39 :2-::"é:3i:ig» ;::s:?7._g%::jL:":=.=;,é =3?' a<;:§:i::::": -- E21 £1316: %;:':s§'i.21z1%:'. iiéiﬁft' 221é:E:s;>:2§§b e:f£ﬁ='E"§,3:§V;E(§_§ci§.'§"§.'iL' 3:;-%;f:_$.Vv§7§:'§'{;%{§ i3<=:§'::::"s:: 'éhs;:: €X§f}§§'"}7 <3? i:§":€:z s2a%:&::z,:E:<>:"}=* _;}:§:":?<:~{§"§3:'a$§:%.:.*-E'fi:e:¥<i in p:":32:i5{> {0} ii} 3 §.z'§3;E ::::::.m: Egad. _%.aR€::""::<:;;.§z:;:a§'1:&€ &?:f€i§f'f ELEEQE wgpérjgz G? iihaéi p§:::*§:}<§ ~ Eﬁziziie. {:€'f§VH15'§iiE§ii§EV'iE3}! 'ih€';'i §:'§"ia.l§ gmzi zipgméiaiié-:.= :.::<}:,::"":;;% a;zpE2{~:E{§ « §"§§§§:i"§ _ {;'.{>:::ti;__<:':"2"::%':§ 22:: §'{'"i'v'éi§.E"E:?3§§"}§§ $127 sisaiai <:%s;%<:is'ai{;>2'3;$ 5&2": iiihé: §2*{3u:'2{E ' iii"-_:.;":%', _'i.E:?;§% <%é:}:3':p§;:mi. 235% 33'r€::':":§;ai;.:,::_'s? --~ §ﬁ£{:}r::§s:: 2:«:.:':{;E ?§'}f2é:'%£?i% ~ ._«'*:fE'::;_?«s:'§}:":;.:;T>;) {':<g;§§'2§zzm:i:<:**' -~ {7:§'E:":3ri'::;".:_.§ E3':°<.}a:<;?:{3i;t:.::'§;?% {"ﬁ{'::{§é;: EE7%?'3g S, E§§€}? ~ '§.':>z%~;§::":;;_>; {.?{}§;§'§'§I§.;a'fé§EiE.{f&% <3? <?:3::3;;3§2-'gﬁsé, §§E::%{§ §:€§'<>:"%;': »:.§:i' " -. éffégigm :32 E.'i.E'"','§,1.i§.K":?{'E:

9.' '-

x,,./ ii <::2'm :2::"is;9 0'i1E},:" SEE": E1216: e:>::.pi§'y <12? E5 iiagzss me§1i:::03;::e{i if; E3':'°{3'--Jé§1%£:: £3} <::§'§E"::%. gaiii ;"%{"E{'3?§,%{Z%:":.

£41} in K 8h2;:é~:C§~:.2::"21::": E'§EiE'1P;£}i'E'i§'i '*x.?;:aic§hj;2'::'": E4§a2;E.a;r:';:.._ ;;ts,.;':{§ z:nt;i;.hs=::" E'€;"f§}{}E°'E,.€;?{§ in ERR 2:388 Kﬁﬁé 2'?

{£3 :-;ra:::r.::=';:'m3L:«: §*;*%~:Sf:";t2;:m:;rxv€§":::L;r'_';*;':: "%.z%;':'% 3 {CE;\§'§"RA.L AC? N{§..'.2;5 E}? E8 & ?RGVESO: CLEXUSES {E3} zmci {C}'.?E'€3f3U,;é1§}i,i(§£1 "<35 'E':~%3r3fEa~:s 2} . S'§"3Li(ZTE.'I_€;2-§'$£_ 2 zaszg 2' <31' Ngiigfe -» €\¥<>i._ic<~3 ssezfzt by K_;Péi;--$;éi 'm%i:';:r:1&*:*£ '--:;s;»%;.::::'%%kk e3:«:iE<>'r:?;e:*::€:»:1i: as "':.2r1{:E21i1r:'1?€€§__" «M "-'KW;/:32": <22.' ._;z::)V1%;i<::T:

;*~s:~mr:'2er:i by ihe SEZI\§{)EE =,m":{7E:>;i:.--i;";i::%Ve:f§_V,"_: Sticthﬂ date Wzmid be ihe si'.22_ri4i::g pzzxirzt sf {Li-::V1%E'.:c?d.i<)zi'e;3;iw<::uI%<:£ be: $11.19 €2€13E§"3;§E1§3'§T:{?.iZ1§_§ dzﬁi-3 in ri€a:::_ka>:f:i§ig 'the §3iE?.'§'§()(i =:}§""'§"if€[fae:n dazfgg c0n{€:mpiat.€:d E.i1."E€i€E1"' C'E:a:i2:'s§:'--_{ci}%.j§.<> 4'§p1f:';i-fis<: of E:-§{3C{i{)i?1 138$ 55} in Jzlvid .Ah:zm::i,,'Er'$< ,;'7~}3=.«:-->,_:::£» ;i§::zr221§:,E*;v:zEf§2:'." §-§2zs3s§2:§:':i 213:2 zazzmhez' §eg>{3r%;._;3€§ i}:§fé_7§§'£E:§' .CE%LuL;;.fa"-?;35VE§."

€ L'::'i:§i:1§rz:§1 u§*%i§'£i~::§; <}':-" 2.992 §:sg--2:3»s;» 3 9%' 'a"%E€:g:§{:«Léii;#.'E;,§<: E-;1$=::f:1,£§I..}':§%§"E§.$ Aztii £26 eiﬁ" 'EQQEL S;<.--;,E38 §}§"{"2'=J?Ir':%;Cs {:52} 2-zmii E'E:'8{E9j§~§f%is;-:»,:f%;"2{2:"::::»1.:z" sis?' €_Tf§1€;'.€§i§.€;'*~:3?{}E%{3{f'i2§I§{}i2 zzgzésfiizr S; E.3%§Z.§.:*:'i§%:.:3iE.:;;:»E:~;ss'u€: Sf §}{}$§i. {§é:'€€.£*.d <:§':g*:{;g2;:i:»§<£ai&;

"*;;e=V E25: *zi';9i::s1':{€§§. as airazwm aim £'§a:é,<? is: <£é;'.E:'s->'a*,:°s"'.::§-I\E"<}=ii: e:::';:2 'zigiéie:.ii:'V'igééaﬁ+:§;--E;:ii§h:>:':{}z:1_;* <>§° atiisagizezé ':3c§s.::";§§ Six. ::a:a<mEE1s.~: 25;? ""TiE:§fifJ€;§"§?~:§.?}{':é"°§"REE": E33 5:0 pm§£:<:u%é<>:': 'L::':{§e:.:' S £38; £3, 2% 'i?'é_:é:3.y;",i.:g§2:§::. $5: ﬁg: ;':§'a.:?:;as;E"; {il:*.22:2':.::£:"&:"; iiiiéf} E} §.{§f§ _ .:'§::i}'?"E2,:§,¥L%}Ziﬁifgil 35?} {?a:'Ea<§§é_ §'.:V§€ §%"<,:a;":"§::§:é é%'E.g§.:i;*;3§g E-Eigggin {'i<}:;,2z"§: K_ €3§:s.§;§:*§é%V6::s:;§' 3&5 2;a'§'%<:§.e:%.§": ﬂ 12 ""'E'%1c ':§m;%i'.aE:i.{>':"; is; 2:1':{§s:>:.2!:2*i:.:é{i.E.y' prczvicisxi {mi}; fair" ﬁiiiagg; Elba? §',€.'.}£'i"}§}§é;3_§E'}i. zrmaé. :':.<'>'§ §{}3" %'a_E<:i§'1§;.§ iéa é;f".{}§_-§E.'.1;§?1&'iE"};{'fi? 0:" «zswssgg {GE i;~i;se;:.:§:1g iihé? §}r{><?a=%s:%a 'iT'E'f;::t*.;"£:: :':<)iE:in;;{ in itizeai, <:Ea'ussf:t §:i=;i§c :f:'£.§' €31?' ':3'ri:':g,>;i:'2g; i'e'i'::§5:r$ am Ehéf p:}'Wé%1':=; r:>:f §§"§€ ﬂ3E1§§iS§:'fT;:ﬁ,é?:'--il{§" ?V",;t«;::T§é«,';1§% ' €i%{}§§E1§§§E%{1{T€ am 21 <i:{3mpE2?:E:'1E. which ;'E*; éTL§:" b_€l«3:': .;é7:T1é'e€£ §;%:'¥};1E':i:12 §ifI}13€'.£1iii{}'I} §»<--?., w§'th.i:1 Ehirijg {£21163 GE f;,E'1e"'r§;1%.<:* r:':;1;;f: wE'2'~i{?r%':.' "thfiérg {':f:i'L§Sé3 sf 9.4/,":'i:i<>:': z1:°is::1'~s :.2nde::* <%E'a.«::;.:§€: {:2} éhésr p:"{}i«-'ii§5{) ﬁzz: §_%€3{f€'.iOH. E88, Sadr: §%:t;t;€.::s:t:1,;a3»* _«:7{:-:1:i<:.- ;§§f:§ '-€'hs3 gggegéeéiii iziw Gf §im_:1f;a€,ia::a {':(}1E'{;3.i3'1€3di in s:;:3:éi§<§'n_ <;§7'«..i§1€:":i'V_'véjéciéi sf Cfiiﬁilléﬂ §.~3§"{}<*i:Cmr{:§ bsgi: *£',E3.v'%1;*{:4 FlA5'%j.?z':<>T§. *éih€=i <t2&i§;{§"E°f:§§"r's:5i; V . '_E'§'1§s V '?«.-'-"§f'E"x.r-"'%-"V 'ix-i21.5% E23.§.{%::.V"' .§2>Eé{>we<% in é'§";;€ £32133: sf 5s%.§2gxa?;a::g§.§2§ "§7E1}i'E'§LE"ZA4S=._b' ':;:*:> 'ifs. EN'E"§;G§2A"E"'EZE} FENANCE z;;*:"s2::.g2.£:§<::,§,;;; A;:;[:%¢{m' 2:36 {:2/Ezggsg.

V' .,§§i§5'§f{}E;€i?*~.E';EE{? sézzé cf 22% aizijs-E; éha <::<}m§}E3.:§::f, aa:=;2$ "V§;:2'§:s%s%:'*:i.§2<{«§, af aiamggéézsiiiﬁi {ms 2-:.:%§§::s::*:{:'i. 'E'£:k.i:z.;;; " :T{§§::%;'§:f':§;5:z:.:::é::% -Efggr E;E:1£?: Eﬁféifiiﬁié 3'i«'§2:;§i$i.:"ai€ E3 I:iE"§{§ﬁ"§€§§" S-;i$§}{"'{E'C., Ea. i7§1§:és;§ z:%.;'£2$&%.A"%_:§*;{7: {fi{.31f;T§§}§€;§i§'3'§, §3:"€:ss<;=::':ii:<tt<% :.::%%é*2é:':a E5 ifiaaysg. 3%: i:E'":{? T '§«:?;?':§*:':€:<.§ }T"§'%2E§§§§§%§'§'£:ii.%? ws:§:,:§<f§ §Eé~§'%f=Zf €.;a.§«;<:%2.: {":ai:;_;'::?:.%;§:;/iz'§.':z%:»: ».'< X ~€.' xx"

13

2:i"i':<;%':' E5 {,§:1j,f'5%; Emit: §'1€;E E':a:i~3 gm': (1 5313:'. 5%). '§'h€3::"s:?: Wassg Giié?' @2133' 53-s§':<}::*§': if} {:?c';s:fs*:p1:;" wi.é:E': ﬁzz? {§%'3:E}T22:%i'E{i§ zzaswéa? £1": iihea :'2<'>'§:§;<.?;e_%.";-Eiizi. ::7s:-':*>,:'3 eiifiizez' :..E':é:=, {*--.<};":':pEei:i<};':: 53:? E5 532132:-2 {§s;.=.:1"2:i:':{i m;%2;.§?2§?:":. f::::;. »*:":E?:.<=:

:3:}t,i{:e '+.4':-'E?i;'Ei~3 gizsi; :;*.<.m':p§§§>.{i.

ii. in §'{2.?1.};1.§.i§'E1E£..i1iZ:fE Das 'V' Er'i1::i:1y_ E{w;r2"'3a:3i*' :"«:f;*._':§)'e.:::';*V?':§ifi'VVVV§_r*f$§' AER 2982 SS :§3§2$ 32:3: %§{>n'b}€: S1:_p:*e:1éi:'i_Cs'm_:"'i.:. Vhé:s:j:é:;::{"V "21.:45s:;22min§g? t:hz:2"§: €t.%":e:'c"t u»-"eye ::<§::°*3€3z%,:V§1%"2: i:'r<3§;e:Eéi§i§'i€s':: 3:": iT}'}.€ pr»:}{::3{§2;::°€, zm, jg:-::':gm&m: {if 7':'?Ei;:_,gj.??: "{3.{;1:,:*"é;.M«:::::3::E.<i :i1<3$;' bﬁ-3 $611 asiaisa. :_,z:::ie$2s it W'Ei:"£ ;$'h{}1RfE'}_V,_E}f§"Zi"}.€f_ 2,é,;3§;§€=;;§v1;1':*?§f:;---- *:ih2:.E. éhgre E3213 E'}@€':'s fe1ij§u.r§: ~ '<:éE""_;?z;; :a;§_§:i{:€:, 'Q 4 fl: " * E3: Sh;:é:n:":«s;21E::%§3"V}§':;='E._ i'i£{§'.§.é,é'.;a;s1§ 1:' 5 §E23;'E€f sf K€iE'§?'i2E€i&Zi§§££ §Téi%_§}€§§°§i€{§ iii; §2{}€'}§§ ;:%}éZié:f iET?'? ; E;.h£: §L:>'::":3E:;': $'%.§}:§'§'€;"f.E'E1€': Czmrii has 7%'-??4'*Ei§'i%3"12%;E--«';§§§£.£5:€E* .§'é€€3?1ié3Vé:i'@'Eiz'3:§E? {Z::P,<:'. :5: {:{}§3'§?§{T:§Zi{}§E wzmki; Eye.

2-*2:§§Z'{E_ é:%2:':s;%'z'*:* am}; {:;m§:§§:;i§:sm *;rs#::§_;u§a§:"§é'.§r £2': izhﬁ ""':?'§':;:::§'g§a: §;'§:"{}'§E°§§éi'{.§:'.~§§A', {E353 £'Z'ii§'§'. €f§{f{E&"§E;ii3E"§ 2?. :§"::=;§Ez:§'::% " j::%~s:§;é{:€;( "§"'§/:6 "'-«€:';*;"g>:'* e:}§" §;ha:%v.V}:z"2;::E:€:€.§" ifs; ﬁzéség 2=%:{.::,:§{i E:,§*:s;-*:.:"%;:% Egg? <i}<i?::>2:iss§<;z': 53:' as "%'2:2 3;§;:,:'s2%'s:§:§'_;§'é.:s5§._§{.:é:% 2.'§{,§{Zé§}'{.§.§T§§{ ;é:s:.§{*:§': {?i'§E.Z§":%i'? '§,i'.'> s;:<::';v'§s;:%. gm V'<~,';*:€:§"'f§'"i~~§,i§.*fi"I:'s?7;§?"~VZ,§ <31? §'.'E"_'::&.% {}§§{i%.§.'E€'?éf m2<§s;%:" :",§éff'{'f'.'§f.ié')§'§ Sf%'fEé~§:% §:':s:§"§_2;§:é_ §5%3::":;::..E ..f \ 2""

14?

Czxie' Whém 3.3 i.E'3;::%: imggretiiiezézliis; Z'E€':<?é3§§§.-"s&7i.E'}=*' f£'>§f '§f':'°:e éazziéi <>ff:--3.i'1<:<;>:

EEEEVQ? a:f<:;zm'% <>2;€' in i'3E:'i{§£%§'1{'.€,y z2E§;§:@uggE'; ha": w;zs:'~; :'1<;i: éif§1E,%;E';§€§{§.__E£?§?i:'i Ehss §_%E§§{§ :;§§f§%;é:2_<ti-t'?

"F315: €X§)I'€';'SSE§{}E2 "'§a.iE:.:r€% <>f_§usﬁ<::==:" §><:=::"Tt*;;:2,.;";*«s§ '§{3:,f:»..§§E"§:§i":E€r £3?" _E7.21<:i.i€:: 252:1 :s.xpr&ss$i<>:1 \x;%1£<:§"1 e::a:.:=;.1§d E}'é*:"§'i*§.é.'e:§ 1.3;': ;;:'r:3;*'%;:i:.;:2;:€:i£>:": {if :1 (T"c'iS€3'.. 'E'ha=: €jr§1:1in3.'§. €<:~ur'":; §32;ri:i::z:z1£a__r§y_$1/352 i'~:§;§}ér.j,{_:§' Cit)?-a,rii~.u S§1{}"i,i3d make 3,. {.'.i<§$$ {:*.Xé?E.H1if§é1§.i{}.Ei'V"~«E:i§f§"~E§S{Ti€EI"7CE"i§£'E'v'ﬁjhifﬁflﬁg §h{--:~::'s3: was réstaiigg' a f21.§Eu§'::% gf. §':;V_€§'E.§(:£é m§'i'* L..'f»v1fie§.?:<%r ES 9111:: 2% €,'.E£i"'i'1{}L3ﬁ&g(3,"

1:2. ds>*.:.;§: 1?: ilhﬁ exbave .m€::::.t§@me{§ ii: :i;::_f:5;' 'z:haé'. 'iihe :f<}m§§a§niZ.

p2"a%$€:z:i::%{§. _V{;1r:§: "='~:E;%:3_,V ..::;;.£:«:_%;=,g;..% mag: véahiész 'E'§"3<»:§§:%E1:>r€? "E.'£":<:% t;§;*:_§j Ea:;:~A2":'>; :9:r};{%:'£<"i1{V{::3u.:.'25a€E Em' mt: p:3:,iE.iQ:":€:" thzii. :';?;s:

{3{}§iTi;:§.}§é?,:';§EvfV'1i"§§€é;§§~_"iL'{"%u3:}_€ :Z§§E§EE§§3E=3{i¥{§ Eizm mg} §<}:'<:<-is ;i.E'§.€§ 322.52% {'fE"i.§."1§'}{'3>€', Em": 2za:<:€é}j}§;.§;é{i. .~ ~ AT

" 3 "§'E';¢ Eiﬁzxtf igz:€:$§é1i€i;§"§ ihzié: f7e:>§* my {f{"3§§i'%s§{§€:fE'§;}'i1§.€}§'E ES =&:E':.aéé.§.:§%:< :'"%::"z§:% E.§.§31{}§j§§":i" as? §*::':Eé. E .E'é§,{i%€}{§f'~ §:':§§E:;%§,a%:<f§ (:4: $9:

€E.{?{T' §§§:%§"{i;}:'°§;3'§'.§% :3? 3::i:'%i:'?

W:

15

E4. E3': 'she Eaéggai E'1€}{.§€.'?€*, if iiiég :m:é:':'i:§e:>:'"::%c§ tE':2=2J;. "5i',§1¥.§ £%;.{Tf£;fii.E?«§;'%€§ E2213 b<2:z*r€}1w3{§ §<:s::2;:': <>§ E%iss;,§%:'§§}®{};'--e_ '¥.i!§1{?'3'°§i'éi-5% é:"m% ;1_<:<:':2s;:%€§_ hzis .'§S:%§§%E{%{,§ 2:: <:he<;;.;:;'-% :§'<':»:" §.%$ﬁ ': §{}{'.i(;%€}{};'M 'ii' 52%: ':,2:":{:§§s;--3;m%;<;':;;j§ "§7:§;{l:"{. :'ifégesi. $19: {§{}§':<}§3§£-iiiiéiifli 21 §:;1:;:.z'1{:<;% {'.{}E'E'.i $2-3.11;-*, 1%. A3 $';:z:i'.e(?; :52>z.zfii_&%:1 :.he- Iizxszza jé f;1:*r3_:}i,é:1%;'A_ '%:3;s;1[_§§;-*' R;s;.§55,{}@$;'«--. "§'E":€ a.{?<7:u$e{.§ ha5~3V;s;;;a_4_§§E;72'é%{§.Rigs; in»'§f:t%;é§':>:1:s£;:'1:€::ss; zmaé %.h<;% E"€:{,'f{3E'd €§.§.ss<:k>s§e&; t.h.a€': 111%: fi1':'§1 §;%°_f:,E".a<E :':::*;_:i:é£-:~s:§ Vhzzs baen 2:.:imini$i.{3:*€:d by Eheé i'r:i::e:V°*;~:f2'i"reé:€3§:§--<:29 €e2:rE';. En. ihgﬁ. 'ifi%'3"*-E2' af 82$: maiéﬁix %..:3,.E«:i:";§g _1:..f"-iii}.ifffjféﬁif§€;?f'i§:'$§{;é':£'"i.V,"ii aii £:iS§}§f{E'i',S <3?" ﬁat: €521:-39? i::V':iV?;;§f"sr%AV¢§§'s&', ii"?-15:»: ::3é'><;§§:':»riie*;'1';'*;"':','«:'3'V :."e::«:i'::<:€ ihéa finéé ammzzzi. :§":*<:::'r: 2 ix? E:h<9 £2316: e:.m{>:1mi is;

:;:=é.2*zEi.:e:@:£:.%, §?;$£§§§,G*;'}€%_,f.~_s§1;:_§§ €36 pa-mi 151;; '£:§;1<:= €€)§£1g3§&'i"§l.§".i2?sEi€1 améi 1-?'~§$;'§;s,i::§G$ ?§;@:w;*::i&; %:§é{%"':%:és.€.e, Egzs. <:21s*.e&, E? {he 33:93.23:-'::§ 'f22..%_§<§<§ ta: §}£1j;J~__EZE"§§%. £2235»-:%§§:":é};.:§§:., Ew shgizié 2::'::i£;>,z*g;;<'; -EBEEEEEEEE: §m§}:"iS{}:"::":::~'::':§: '§'":'2§° ": §Z%€;'f'Zf_§{}€§ :(_~is§ _{i§::.::" §'§1.{."}§.'1§,§'%$¢ 'A '§§éV'i?§€::>a%* {E73 €215? ;2a'§§<}2?:é s:i§:2a;<::::$si:m§ E g}as:§:+3 ihszé §e§§{}%sJ§§";;;§: Qﬁﬁﬁﬁ

-xé u i'%;?=ifiE%:%i'é'§.'§ ;:>€;%§;é§?: Eééiii 2:; é%;§§{,}$£€?{'§ '§'jE»;?i§ L. ,«"z .

<-"" ,2' ».f YKL 16 fa/E21§:";'t.21.i:2.i:':;;g: ihcza <%{}nvi{:'ti<:»:'L ¥.'E?:.€: §im.> 2m1:>2.:ni. _:*<3{§§,1€:&.{i ézfam §~€5.,1,,:§5§{}€}€$,f»~ Ea} §§§{};.{§{§{};"-' "E5 thé? i.};:.":e 2%.m«:§m;'zi': is-5 '£"£'.£%..§i:§§éE{§ §{s§.§%;5,(}i}i"§f~ S§E;i.§§"%3.{?"'--?;§€§'§d ta 'ilhé? :?:<>§np§2:i§12::'zi. mad E{sf}§€ZI{}€},/T -- ii} 'iézéi Sé,é5:.<%, E31 ca:~;{:s, if the zzztcuseti iéiiéaqi to :*:}'€;'fp:}E~§§%. %;.he_i"i3:E5' 2?{.:;1.{}&m'1.§;« he :~;:h21Ei :::':r:Es:::"gg;<:s $i:np§€% i.:n}3ri$€;:':f:ze§1t, f€§:'_ 2x._§3€=fi§::? 75;?' .f{:su§* msiﬁizs'-,:.

}3- «% §5?"%* = _§g§a£

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court