Karnataka High Court
Shivakumar @ Shivanna S/O K.S. ... vs State Of Karnataka By Tiptur Rural ... on 21 March, 2012
Bench: K.Bhakthavatsala, H.S.Kempanna
ZS Tifie breisf facts sf ihs 68.86 are :' The appsfianizs/'3.cCuSed Cams :9 be "ma: Judge an the charge fgr {he>AA>V9ffer:€:_€es-»§§§g::§iéE1a.bie_ 4 under Sectisns 3&2 :*;'w§34 ef and 2&1 2*/X7934 of EPC Eofi 312005 at about gfgxaa géceasgd Ambarish was §<3::1i::Vg" --.E:'; a has with cash? they to0f.§:4_Efi'i::': 91:39; Kibbanahallé cross '£3 situated in E{011a::a;}:az*%§§:"fC;§'i::,St after rehiéving the sash 2x,;?}'i:ic}1 "$8.8 Carrying assauiied him with 'E€':§1:é;E-«. weégafgss,'«.. éGmmitt€d his murder ané "'«..ih€;*§§fi§::3 .__i:: t§§°€§~------E-"~'?;G C8.§lS€ é§$ap§€a§'a;:1Ce {:25 {:26 L;€'»;?;1é§$::C'<i.»_'{::§' "é;::é3I'd6r is Sfiffifin ih€§"§'1SE§¥€S {mm Egg}; §z,:'g;.§53h1::_§i§':;_ {breaks 3:6 bare beéfg ef '$26 éeceasefi mic Hihé 1*ai;: iazai§3* harvegiing diieh nsair éhfi S8};§ péace afid '%;§1e:§?::y 'fiiay "$33353 semmiiieé §§GE°€fi'i€§1§§G1"§€§ % .V _MQf§e::::§sg
23.; E? 28 "€136 €335 sf {Ezra p%"€}3€{i'Zii§G§} 'aha? £336 €:§.€€f€€'é':%3i%€:%€§, .«%mE::ar§sif: £3 '$326 5353:: sf §'x7'sfEa E6 was aafgrking ,.>'¢g 00:36:31: am amaunt <3? ?:~';,®C},GO§;'-- {mm $3.73? B€v:{:E1.§I:§ ef Banga}{>:'€, "EEK: said Rafish Kama?
E1dCiI'€SS€§ 21 1€i;ter ':3 P1333? 1:9 pay thé said V' PW?' and a copy of the Said latte':
him which is at EXPE5. 9 9 in ESSEEGESE ta deputed ihe é:3ceas€,§i'~'.__EQ $4' :ifofi'éEc: the am9L1n: 0f ?zi, OO§DG(3 P'.';_:Vé%v;?.:f': DS_¢viQhand, as indicataé in afidressing a letter fie the deceased Came and sefiected ':36 a::':s:1i*:: cf_ ?W3'? at abaifi !:3,€%Q aad 4:?§51fG:r::€f& sar'iV::sw0§: phGn€ ia PW'? Ehat he has :s31i§':::€§~,A:2:f€"'s2.:::<3un: §€'G§E}: ?'%f:73'7 aafi 3:26 is rfiturzzézzg E3 %::i. §"'¥3$§sns§ fig S16 same? 9%'? égoié 2:h€ §:é?S;:~i§£€f:':§;" ~.,
-- &e{:é;;»:s€'£3; ':§:ai 315.: 9? ihe gaid amaégné ie pay K - '£9 his ?a}:<>§E1€:* gé: '"§'§p'i{U;r 312$ fig brmg 'abs
-- ?§'§i 3.fi--C€ {sf %2.;%G,{3®Gfi"~.
2.53, 3'; i8 §:::*'{E:::::*r éézs 8886 $1? {$36 §§@$€{:::§}iG:':
§h§é:*€a:'°t§f £36 §§'i'Jii%a;'E§€'§ Es??? §E%§};§E5;§C%?f3 in has 30 :7;:2:::'§"; WM?
/_,\, Arasikazs Via Tipilhiifl Gr: the way§ ii i3 333 <:aS€ <;§§;_ f;:i1.§;;f §E'{}S€€:':i?iIi€3§i, ihai w"h€--n '£326 fieceasad Kibbanahaiii =:m$$ in ihs bflS§ .a§igh'ié'd'*--.§:'f:>f:1: ihefi same. At 1:h€ said piacs he saw P';x'J§/E§3_"%i9:0"h3'd:'<:v3'§ié--..:§:ii.T_i aneiiher bus fmrr: Banga1@:'é»V.:g%:f:s§r talked to him and 1:hev1i€.2}fterfVAVP'+§,%'§§"bga:§§1éd:iihgibus in which he haé CQEEE '£0 ' At Eihai jun:':ture it is '_c.V£':..::ic§:"--;:._.Se EEWEQ saw the éeceased; fi{§?oVV_€:<;€Vused in a mafia:
cycle xx?%:'§:"a;--A§i§é>;;:1d 'E:»;ag§ if; his hjgmdsz iowards Tzlptmz 2.6; 33;' is fi:z*:E:.1e;°,.'{h_é's§as€ ef 1:116 pI'GS€C%,3;fi0I1 £126 &C€3i}.§$€§ uzsjter '$36 deceased 0:: '$3551: znaim cjgcée §{é'€;§§Va.§§.»§,.%:&i1i SYGSS '£99324: him to ;3,No.EE,f?2? of {:'§q§w4.:%a§a§»z1raVéimaiafi in Koagfiakavalu F9233': A1333 Q ':E:€§é géiéséeliezréng figs: dsseaseé Q? éhfi sash azasfiéch was '..jL'm9ii%;._.Ahi:§: c@mmi'£'£§§ his maréer 'Q3; Skiing his thmai:
' %3{2§€fs3 3 kzziéeg fi'Ta€f€Ea§5E€E' §h?€"%A%" €136 ééaé %:n:"3d'§; iizés a :'aE:::
zaraier ézarvesiing éiich 3;: $16: sgaié péacfi aiizé mafis ggad {hair ESC3§€ f%'a:::":': €323 sgid EEEECS 32336 3: a%0:;:€ M.§@ 3:5': §§":::}:e:3§' i:y::é§:%3 5332:? 2356? §';:€§EIS§? :2? $3 gang? 390?: sf OCCHITQEECS zmd thsre he firsw zgp panchanama; as §€§ EXP-éi in the prrsgsrsce <15 .-?i1?i.?fI2;a'E§ . ?"~2x725. A': éihai time, he aisa get ihfi. »§hGt_og:*a"§E;§V"a%§v"tbs, deceassd taken and grepared Sizsicéi a§S..";:;;eE9.: E2<;.F4£'3~g 3': the 131116 of if::%_3.1s<é;A'::<€:fii2:€:1 :03 ES} whisk csmprisfid af agant, .. E<:(1if€., Yheréafter, E16 held 'body 91?" the d€C€8,S€d and €§f€'§f §:p;."iE;:fi*-- as per EXP3 in thfi arid afihers.
After cQ;:f;;I51e:ai%:2'§}_: requisiiian to the :::e<:§i<:af§ _ is iha spa: arzd conduct peg': in :'€s§0:1$€ is ihfii Same, §\E?3;§ Ca:s2:€: i:?::-- sfzstg Caaduestsd a:3i<§ps§,f ave? ihé {;f_ %;ié§..<;1?€.::§as€d, 331$ £53366: the @953'; martam raperé: E;V;>«fiv,I'_§?:__38;;'%;§{:(':{§<f:* which ha Gpinsé; Ehai the éagiih is
-V éue Er; &:hi35?:;E«: atgzci Efzgmgrrfzsags as a {€31,213 sf §f§j§;§§f{ ':9 "_=:%1V€"z:$€E«fi'. Afiaz" $26 gas': maftém examinaiieg SiI"i€f:€ 33$
-- b§:§§§;'éva$ 'E;§E"E}§I}§'%1J:'i, E15 gt): 'aha $&§§aa burziéé 1:68;?" we ééié pfiaca, '§h€1"*€3,§i<i§: he isak Stegas is gs: p22b1i€:iS&fi ii} phaio sf zmiéezriified had}: in newgpagaix The $am3..j2_§*as gubiéshcafl 9):: 8.2932996, 2.3 it 5.3 fur'Eh€r the 933% 9? {ha presé-fifiiivgrfii V' PWS E afid 4 GI} wading ihe s;aid"papé;r _:jg;{;1'b£_:céL't§::3:1VL"-V' came it: Eiptur rural psiice sta'i;i§>:*z:--.V_Aéa11& §h€;1f€.
seeing the photographs cf thé"";i:é€.€aS.<éd'--3:153' 8 which had been ssizesi: by "S%.me as 'that Gf Tihfi deceased. gtatements.
Thsrsafier, :3 31:16 8933 Eivisional ihs body, in respgnséé Magistrate, 'E'ipI:u:*
au:h::>r::§és:i_ Exscutivs Exriagisirate :0 get $326 b;;§3:§Xiiu-.r::5e'§ § in ::és§e:ise to €316 same; ths bséy ami baifig i§6::":'5£§fied by gar; &: mafia; as :%.Z8g'&';'_3é5aL::€§'=~;>,é is ?W§ and his rfilaiiéres whe 3:3 mm éisgii'--':I%2e:: Safiza 'Q @161? péaas agd cgmplazéii 'éhe £313} " V ,E'§:€Ts;_§ Eflt P3635 if: 1:335 megrziims 3333 égfik $'§:€§S is gait 'ihé gkéicéz 3? the 88633:? @f ecczzrrszzes §::'e§a:"€§ %;h2?<i>ugh ?'%§E;"i iv: raagazzse 'at; w§*:§s::%3 E35533 ;:%£si:§}ar€é iésfi séisish ye)' (J:
pI'GS€C:LE§iG,§E :8 <:'»s'!tabiish fitasi guilt af 3236: a_:f_%£V'l::.'é¥:~:§;..A Eiaboraiifig hég 3ub:::§ssion he sa:b:':2:i%,{$<:i ihaé 'T V' :16 €jy'€~Wi:::€8s€3 to the 9<:<:u§tefi€Eéf' "i'}<i;€"*?3Hii'f'A€'i;:4z5i"::f%:1f the §fQS€C{}'EiQfi reség an £i:<:umSI;a:i'{i_a% evi§_€1"z<:é: é;i£i ' Ehfi Circumstances refied nag, 'fQ:V_":'f:<: E3 Chain 0:5 fink to bying h§ r:.1_e ghe A8.'<§véu':¥':~éd., Tm €'v'i§€§1C€ cf the ivgféiifié upan is unirustwortfgfi cofifidencs ta piacs r€}ia;:§<3'i: Fu:'%:h€r, "éhe r€cQx*e:§ made at ihe instancs sf the afiéiazfiad accordanse with Eaax; ané fiaspjié {he time éeafxlsfi aria} JU;fig€ wiihout €g>:'o§€§E§,.? .f;;2§§_$£ia§:::@g maiériaé an racayd 1:: its fight §e§'b'-§si3é€i:?:§v.__h2§s' came :8 a 2xm3:';g Cenchzsism ihaé: éthe
--V ;p:'Qs%:'::1':§@:':E:as ;5:S§§h§}§S§1€di €313 €:ha,§§;:'€ Efiveiieé agaifigi '.j~'.é:§':€ ;=3,_§:e":u"S€é wlééch} gamma? E36 susiiaézzeéi 'E'he:€%f<:,::*€? 2: he _ $e3*':' 3,é§ée ':5; afiowézzgf {Es a§§:€ai.; 3 96:; Cazaiza $36 2633:5256 éafiéé. 8?? £0? 1&3 fiiais V 3u§§{;:"i§:r:g§ '§;/he i:f'E}§U.g"§}€fi*d guégmgiié anaé {srdar §a$$€::§ Ei';ns£% Sa"::§s~2;i§;::;~g gfzsiigéé :::{}:":é;:3:":::is3<:i 'aha: $%;:§€:::s::<3 E"?
M iii} 'wheiher Ehé impugned judgmeni aéid €£:m;§<':téo:: and S€i1"1§€§:<i:€ Cafis fgr iI1'§€E'§€:'.f;§:§:'€"?. ' -5 iv} Whawi order 'E Z Re.?0in: Na} :
Tbs pfOS€€:§i;iQB in {E16 §€C€8;S€fi Aznbarish véséih have relied upon 1ihe..€Vid€I::.c§.:.§f§ effissr what has 6 bgdy {H5 1313 d€cea$e§§.__ '1I'i*1f§:~ §;:1:é'd:<:a1 effiaer rev€als§ en the invastigating Qfficegu PW36 he %:LQ:::'mé%.e§..j;20§':.,m0r§:em éxammaéien Qver {E3 '§9d.§§.{;Gf {he déé:::3,aS€d E1681" $33 spgi sf GCCZi1"§'€f1C€f ix:
__ ef €§10:A,7§3ja§:::a siéuaéed Er:
§<;a::'a::aE<a:é%L;%i§3;VfG§€$§; aréa. BE}:-S €'iFZi("§€f'i€€ re2r@3;i$ éihai: h€ :§:§'%:§<:fi«;§7:3. ?::;:;'£ §:::j"sg:};* measuriizg afiaut 9 éfichfis X1 3 f_":r:i;'¥§f:€;s :3: 4 iflfihfifi :31": 8:6 EESCK s::2'i1i<:E:: hag :"€$:;:§*:€é 32:: ' éé;:':*i:§::g cf 93:: the bised :«*§s$eis§ %§::j§§"®ié Ca§:§Eag€ afié hjgaéd bans, Thsrs was 9:35 E13856 éf}j?.if:,?" §€§{%'%' £16. 33162 }é{}jé§:'f:; ¥'§E€&Si§.f§%f1§§; fé §;':si:E:$§3t 2:: E532 résaif: Si 3:22 éfzzshg :--'%g3a§% ' vw E8 érom ihs games, §§}€f€ wfire {fiber i1":jL§F§€$ cm; the esjzééaér §a§t:s 0%" 'me 39$}; He hag G§§I1€(i 'ihsfiz, £1135: d€a'{h~'_§t$*V is shack as 3 reguié; 05 irzjury {:3 the nack a.1 §éii V' iagusd pas: I'}'1QF'{€1T1 report a3 p€IT E§{:£3.'38.a' 'iizgg atateé tha': ihe dsaih migfhi hav:é.__éc§u3;':*é.{::»_ 24. hsurg prim is E1113 C0nducti:1g'§:»%S: m§ri€.:§:' in the C§'QSS e§<ami::ai駧*:«_0f 0ffié€fAV %2'€ find ngihing bag has}? as $0 the @3336 sf is She mask injury. medicai offiser is fertifieiig the investigating off}i{:€:' a§i€§L4'?ii?38_.«§;3.€* §a:1Cha. The Svziéifiglce GE P's?x?'3:'f;%:;aV€ai2 '§__::f'b' .?f2£3G'§ tbs §:G§.§{:€ fnéléd inquesé aver d€C€3;8€€i a,:1& diary 1;; £333 §:";.qu€3*£ §a:és_h3f§é.':§:a' §:é yer EX.?i3. Zfhig esrideace is farihfir
--V fsréi.§i€é"----V:§r{;>§%: the €V§&€?E'§C€ 9%' ?E7i?38 ihfi mxfesiégating . @§§i.:;__€§* €3£3'§§;S 3:33 éraum 22g éhg iE1§ii€%f gazzghanama. . "§§";€7§fA aafidénae zezféalg Q2631' Eizgéisicesid '§%:<:% Eizjmise :31: 32:6 %¥:;£5; 8? firse {§€C€8.§€§. ass: ffiééfid by $315 mfidisaé gffécsrx 7:325 was at 3321 :3;:a<"5;§:s:gr'i<i<§ ?'€:I%i".'§L af é*;;:§:€:. E:/3 <ii§®33»~ E?
oxaméoaiéoo of tfioso wiéoogsaos also ::othiog_ff§a,o'VV'bo:é::. brought aboo: io disogzré their iosiémoojg-q~A§)f§:*:.V:§:::or;i_'" this ':he evidence of PWS 34 ano AA diroctioos of PW36~inw*ostig3: fiog a f£:cé; the body from the ditoh. as hostiiee Tho fact of ofélnioxreé from, the ditch azzd ii: injsigfiés Pws 3% ago;
38 is not iiho prosecution has who has filed iho oompiagni in his evidence tho: he noticed :hVoi}o<iy ir; iiiao 'diéish and thereafter; he filed the «..oo::s§Eai;::i E;?:{e?2'f '§--§$~ovid<s:oco further rovoais 'iho oofioo _&E;$o_ "$o§2:<EoE..4*:%:§:~"2fv::'1:i::1es that were foono on ma body of €316 .__gioooas'o§:§7'a:}& ago a oaoé, yoiiow Shir: xvii}: Eoiaoii:
~w_ '-Si::'%;;>oS' .a;_.z:*11§ éioifo wéaich avers oi "£136 goo'; En our géow, o?;:%ooo,oo filffilfif foyiifies éhai SE5 oogiy wag foooé oi .. _j:}f{e spoi with §:'::§é};I"§€$ goo fioaéézsg in 338 \FJ8fiiZ€1Z Agar? V from ?§"iiS iio ooonoci ihe body as ihat of €316 €j€{,',€?:?;T>t'3C£,, the pE"@S<E€%f£i§€}E": hag rofooo' opor: {ho ovédoaoo of ?Wfi~ fiififlfif of '£115: afiooosssosi §"3"%?4 ~ 2: roiaéivo oi' $325: éooogsgeég «W 20 Their evidsnca revealg ihai :32: 6.'§'I2@{)5 an S€€i1"1g'_'£h€ ghaisgraphg EXE1 {g,b,:::) and {E16 articias tha:
seized by the peiice fauné can the bedjz 0f :3:.;{ ' at the time sf EXP4 drawn up ,a:~'th6-spef, V which are at M03 2 to 11? they that 01? the deceased. Apar:Vff'$§'k--,this§., 223$ ghé evidence gf PW36 "E§[<§{i§,:'*' 0f ihe Cieseased. was ggt " Gf PW26 Taluka of sxhminatien af the 13 is the pancha for 1 rsvaéfié ihe Tahzka Exficutive Magist:ai;?:_ ézziad "gé$: exhzgmed tha bsdy which hafi §>'e'c:1:; bu:és=:£§"::eaf {has Spat sf ccsurranse ané ihfi ;:::€$$":iné:V§3_3';ii_._Camé 02;: and ths samé was iaéaen £5: 3: %'g:;:;::;;: x§§?>? 3V.'§;%' tag: iizzie ?§?'€§, 302333 am Pwé, were V . p;*és"&z1é*--. air:§ tbs}; Edefiiified the aamfi 33 815;: sf '€213 K 'V " Véttagséfi; Ensafar as the §§$1'1iif'§C8;?;}}'f}EE $5 $16 &0§y Cf zhe ééeééésed E3}; PE-£53 E~$ :3 5: 4 is cangégéeni. '§'§;1s:»; Exaaass m駀:1'{:§§§efl Gm Elm: basis 5% E65 E {G 1.3 333d §h0i{>grap'%:s 3%' {E16 §€:::%a$€:3"f E/ha? w§:;'€ $:;@"?§:1 Ea" éhszzé £2": ins: §§§%€§ siatésmg Apex': {mm the E'>!E1i"1Q€, Ehey ham: aiss §Vder;§.ji'f'ia*:d 531% bed? 38 ihai Sf {E19 €1f3€;=€aS€5: 25:92" it sximmsd by ?'s?J2§--TaEuka Exeituiivé ?vIagis§:'3%:%;. <::re:;ss---€>:ami:1a'{i0n gf thsss wii:.f1€ss_¢S ézilséjfl nethimg having baen ¥3rQugh'L':32j }*f€C{)§'_'5L"§{} {E153 ésstimoyfies. Gr: éhs Qthsssr $$%i5{§n§}€ .:§3T1SVi}§f€S 2:: 215; to Ewéd ihai the féignfi éhs rain Water harvesting. :ii't<:%j, 1.' F;i'§§3'é!1§'I'€§1C€ was that Sf tbs iéiiige mattey, 1:3 View Of the Eghgfiicai ::ffic«:1g 36~ Envastigiaiizig panch and 6:16 €ViC§€§}C€ sf P212" L 3' __4a::sd; 5%? :1': céreumstazices, we havé ms E1$sv_§§;:i:;a',iC_§:; is §i9iév_____f:h.a1: ihs éficeasafi-Agrnbarésha has «:§*?:v.;eV'i:i";--.Va:('::vV'~§f3L§::>e1":*}i<:f§{%.3.§ £53112'; 332$; £136 pmsscuiierm has €é:¢a %31ishe§ j games .' A ?8§§}J: E\E{},2 :
'*§--'z:€ §:2§Ss:§::,:*z§{3;: iii Gfdfi? '%;<::: i;%s%:2}S§Ei§§:: $3332? $236 " ~"a:€:€:u$€§ 3,213 §€spa:':§§:>§€ §}::»:" She hamiiéfiai éggih 9:' me §€C€é3;S€§ fhfifv' EEa'2.s*€ :*<:5ii€v§§ §:?1€3 és=:$€a§;€§ 9% 5:13 s;5:2V§€h 952:5; am his; §3£?::"§§é3:"; hézvaé Vzsiéaii iiégiéfé {:3Zr£u::1s15:ar:§ia.E eviderice. "Piss céircumgiaixceg $§ha;v?::.§1~2;V2: 22 bsen i"€ii€d ugggzz are :--
3} £9 The ascuséd and ihé deceaseg h85Ji§":g"3E3.§'ff:'"i'*w.:S€?tf3IE__u meving together at Assagikere E§!im1:"" « The accused having beer: $6611 at Tépmz ~18'~té§. 'ax: " K.B.Cmss on 3f?.2Q€}8 a,t:'a'L:~i)x:,:t 839 ;m:!, % V:321.:<_iVf9..33§ Thecieeeased haV§:i__g"=~Ebe€_:f1 séeig ifiihe €?:$Hivpa:":y $5 the acczzsed far ihs 1a"st- .s';<:§2};--s§a.@fiI*:j:3_ 132:6 night sf {ha QCCu§}"'€1'1C€ aiE§.B, C?Q_Ss., V ' 7 The 8;CCuS€'éZ§?'f}._8::'§7§I1f;f'__b€:€:'*§i 396.3-i_'a:__§gEj0L1t 11.$Q pm. an 3.?.2__G-$£E'y C3i}.£E:f.if1'§§}4_'3_:}§' .;;,: rgiaiesr cyclé halding a bag and éflifififfillg the E':£>us€j:>f A73?
Extra jL1Ad1.iéigi_':§Q:1§eS3iC;§1 made by tbs accused; :0 Re<:0v€VfVf3s*.._ Cx§. 5:; 4':::s:+;j_".:;3§ %:33§{}§G@GfQ and ihe knife E»/ELEE5. anfi '-?§§€" Efiiaéfk bag ~ $153818 83: 'due éfisiafice sf 83if§fi3§§_S€§§ _____ ' :':_ is; --§2::5€Eji geéfisé 1223}: ii} 9. cas& which rests an Cé§fCi2.:}3s'€a§€_':;é.3_-E'gééééencsfi {£15 §§®S€CL':'{§€%fi £2: 8§,'{§,€?f "£10 bsfizzg
-- horgé' éihé gig??? ia £1316 3CC?;§S€'€'}: Egaife: gs: ':3 €S'§8ib§§S§'i 3;}: '£33 " »§;;§§;§<:r3_ 2:: 'Eggs Chair: :35 é:::'C:.mSta::£:€s éihzai they 13%}? Ligezz. * E§ a§é;z $2333 95 ihis ?:i:e%§ in 333% shaiéa $5 C§§"€"ii§:flSiai1€€S £3 {mi eséafiégheé aha: gees againgt 5%? §:'@36a:u:§:':s::. Esaésizqgi this £24; §}":i§:{§ W6 §:'{3§s:;:'~:».a ii; £633 27251132 333%; £21? 2:236 '_,,p N w ciriizgmstazzses éhaé, Eigavs b€€:: gregssd ime s€:'as'§€_e_b§ fthfi §§®S='3C1;}E§§IL L The accuseé anfi iha d€cease§ havinf V' movin f to feiher at Arasikere tewng it is the Case sf the presécutigspzfi t3g»e::e%a,é駀;'i;V" was Waflging as a wfiter :3.r:d"'--vzg§§i'£€§%Ct«.:gsr'----§.r.V; éde Lmes which éieaig in ':i'"§;<}:p§"a 'isg The accused anti Eh: d€$ea§§€ with each fflihfif and 3' E13}; wars moviag "Eh; srder ta establish this ihgé tbs evidencs sf FY93 5, §§ away inentign that 333 tE:€s€:v';a*%L§fiesS:~3.3A G2": 'SVEEOEB §rG53eCui§@{: hag rsiigd have "%;u:f§§é:i : %9.:§S%:§E§. They haw gtaieé ihat E3163; E132? 12:3: 7$%%;*é,_ .i%"':a:€""2::::é§j;§e;.éd and 3&6 dscsassfi Engaging éggethsrg r§h€:*ef01'--.:§,' iziis 13:3? Eiizk E1: iihé Chaim af C3§I"C1Jé§'IE$§8;E}a":€3 is H 2 ' . §k:?;:§:'§:<;€¢éV?; s u The acsaiséd hazing '@661 86313 5.: Ti my 331$ his: 3%: Eifigfizégs 3:: 3.";?',:25G8§ 39: abaufz 83$ ,5}; zaurzé 33$ gm;
EN.) Q1» giéffifi a gG~b§: is 'She grsseeuiésn 89:86 gmé has stsziéd ihai: 116 (1968 :30: égnmv aazheéhey ihs accusfid; has? any {fail {mm EH8 bsoih er rm: azzd he H knew 316 {$33313 fay 1:136 death O§"€he'«fl$§:,5a$?5§;' has else tutnsfi hestfie E0 '£hejVpres:€c_u»§:;i;;Gz;3 " stated ihat he does :19: fiad fE§3%d€ any phone Cafis 0:; ?:}i'e"ii:ig§1t of
3.'?.2C3C%6 ai K.B5c;r0ss, 12$ avafi :0 the PTQSSCUEEQE14.' ;j;..:,:'~V has relied upm:
tins {if the pr036:€:i:i§§::
that gag anfi 9.30 §..:':3, iha ascusgeai isada ;_:;i.<>_::ie' ':s 'viiafihfia ha}: gimatsé at K.8.<:r<:ssg érinkg azgé {E18 sama hgfl baa: su§§§i€§ ";¥'€-}y'2;';'%:';"«..V_?'§§f2'3 E22: E53 €'%?§§€§"i{3€ hag géaiaé i/ha: {ha paiééa? E:§afé§.«-Ereughi thé acsusfié $631' 3116 $3: at . :§{A;B_{:mSs: Eiéféd had agaés efiqairéeg Whfitkar E3363? Rafi . éiazééia €336 bar azgfi 'izgad? éakaa éréfika ii'; 336%: 83:' am Eéifi Qigfié 0? 3f;?¢2@{}§, is afiiich Em ;*€:§§,€& 'Eiééaé sirzsé A- ,2-<«~>/'-£~v<- An 3 KW {'1.'S2'/'5 ' gm x;/kw '1 . ' * V 3 gmzggy gzcajgig :,:@mz; w $33.2: hm, hi: @393 E38? §;;25>a%,? 2% §"}%3':§'}$?3 é.a:,:gh*:e*; 'é?%fh§ was studying fiffiézr {failing hi3 éaaghiar at Bangaloyé he was féturnéng 3:9 33:3 §§ac€~J3§éa:_'*<.Vi%:A' Arasikers Taluk in 3; bus. H6 had gs: diaxxgzg' V' bus riéar Mayura 3:19:62 to have x:i:'.::fs;€,V -. the daceaséd, iravéiiirig in the hiss §:QHOW'fi';g 'E-".313 came and taikefi (sp0k<3:} ii) «T his bug after taiiizzg 33¢*i§Q§_:"fiféég §é::2;rdi%'§§":h'éV§bus ha saw the accused taking meta: Cycle:
iewarfis 'E'ip%:u;;:'"; in {E19 middle, Accused .":%:nV§';it;3+'cyCI€ and accused Nix} '...'§fiié'é;¢:ased;. The deceased was :xr€V%;r:fi'gVa' 312$ was hcaidiisg 'aha 'aagw EzE§1Eé; ~ in iuE:s. §:{}:§s éxafiainatéafi :2': $8 breughi {gut éihaft %i€ {f';£*;1:'::%3; :>'{;':¢_ with the 2«"&rs§@n sf seeizég 1:516 desaaseé g;§a:g izr:'éE":;.€ ::9;G::'i§a::j; GE tha §C{E§3a§f;'{i GEE $26 221533? Qysifi bafiéfe tiééréiaiégs GE} 2L'?.2QG§ zzaazijg 3J§3§;;i:, E8 égys ,:a§'f5::j thé GCCi::E"§"€§§$€, if: has alga sams in ihé: ::m$s~ _ é;'£§ E§§fi&{i§fi "§'af§i§"1i1§ 3 :5: 4 days hes: Egad. mfGrr:r:€<§ 5:23? gafhaé u "E35 had 866:1 is ?Ei?E aarhe is £318 faihér a? $19 éssfiaasgé 3: I <AV{'NV'?§/,"~ , ~»»3«/.3/4;» > "Ya; ' + »,~" , { ° V . * :%;a,:::,msc:§ mgggkaz. 31235 ;,hs::{>:°§ at}; :13 §'i&%7_§;3"i§.{ ms K;::f§'*3§,r»/" / / /'3} .45 asitused GTE thé flight Q5 3.'?I2{'}G8 has agrns is, _ 'me aCCu$s:=::§ have €'.0ffl€ is be f:'Lf§'€::--S"§€§ é:;:':~-'4 Whereafier his staéamsnt has {::::::€_?; Qj.'5a:3 ':4$'C--Qfsi:s.;j'V':;gjA' this Effsct. Even Gtherwise >§J:_is 1r§:':y ':ii,ffic1,:'1§,:A bev1E--?§€€v" his Sxridénai in View Sf 'éhfi f8!.C;iLV"-.tV:V§E'3.fi 'ihae 'bus he saw the deceasgii g§;i§:g..":':§1"1Eh_€ céfi3pa::.§} sf the accugsdi A&mi'21:€d*iy3 3:' EQOCE game V»f'Zr1eth¢Vr.f§: h.::'re ;:é%§/gs' enable ihis witfiess 1:0 from this, PW19 he had got dawn {mm {E}: * "di:1ne2' in Mayura hate} sétuataé auiL..]§§%.E"§$é;"Q;§s'?_ " has gal}; siafieé ihai: ins: haé 307; E3 §:é;é,?"::w Tt;:_i$_§}:2£;§ at Ekliajrura Hate}. Eifizeiher hes 333$' g0?:,,'Ca'£~::x:s:.;;""§Q §'i5}f€ E113 foaé :2": i'x£a5?:2ra 119:6} situated 85:' E€;';i§3»l,<:Eé;e-->,é7g:,>i, ::if:€:"€ :3 :39 svifiezzca Er; iriew 9% $26 faézi: j 'aha': "f:":.e"%;8;s cams 2313: wiira 5:26 '¥€I"S§G§ 9? Eégarézig S683} L£%_§§é§a/5&3 E8 @3553 afisf ';§::s %'}C€'i;f}{'€§3€€ than: :35 33:6? éfaje' .3;f§'€S?;1 Q? $16 acazsgség 5.96% 35:" :i§:Sp:§s= ESE}? ":%é:ér:§E{i€:n<::<: is géiacfi E€§§3£E€Z€:' 9:: his §€sé:§m<)::y. 3% Pwbfaihaé ef {he dessasafi wag searahiaég; fQ:é 'Ei3§s dsceagad gem he net 931118 0:31: 1; fiéh ihsé ha Ezaving seen them, an the nighi arr} ':T@ their hangs 3:1 3. meta? cycle arid Q_mT':a'§~s:iii g'--.:é--.. they were in periurbed moaii.-.__..I: :53A}§#f'QL1ghi"V'f:«f%§':'Vfifl 9:053 axaminatian that h€ which amused N32 was a' Qf he committing defaiflf: he had been éisr1:':embe:' €_§i 351$ in Yi€'W sf he at a Eater pain: sf ':'::me,, is 3133 cf :10 avafi :9 the §ri::s§::ui'§€;:rf::. » V' V . U H .
5. " _§E;>*<;i:.ra. 'z;<'i§A<:_i:é:V§ <:<>:§2f€ss§@:1 made 3:: K 31% aceuged Ea * """
E:h€ §i"§§S€€*ti1:§O§E '£16 accussd aim; <:@:;%:,;*::%f:ti..:::,g"" §":€ Gfience mafia ax axéra guéirsial '*.__ '*€:§}::f6s'?s%§_?%: is éhai sffecé, befmrfi PW2 0:: §.7§2€}$§. ?W2 ééfidégss E233 €§8;§fiE€Ci; ihaé: knews {E26 acmzssé assd éizegg baii fmm Sfmiafagaagay 33': }a:'a$§};<3::€:, $3} §IE'.2{}£}§ is: the z:::@1"2:2i::g Em baiwssn '?¢§§ azzzi ?.:3fi E316 zzcéifzgsgfsé iféifiéfi {gear hiss; iréaage $2 Enaisr £:3z{:§€3, 32 Sifi{Z'.€ %.?,29Q8 h€ ignew abeui {E13 ésceased migsimg he has EESEZ I'€'\5§a1€d ':0 any 0:15 afbezié {he 3991:3852 Extra jzxéicial comféssien 023 3.7.2006. This .:zi}*=id€f:1c;;é * PW2; W110 is 3130 Closely acquaizg-i6'd»--xafi;tE§"¢ .§1_1§', View, dQ€S :10': mspire any C0nfidé';i:(§€ id __p=1a_{;$ "
rfitfiance an his Eesiimonye Th'E§f€§{}E"€, é'i1is--§:i:*g:1i::§§{é{a%:C€ pressed into servica :13 ~"::'=.;:r v%eéi:'Aa_E::e3"'g'§:i§ déiiztzhéd fmm the chair: 0f circumstances.' 5; Receveg of %:nifs~MG15 and b1aCkVE:xa_ ?{M§i?3'at-:he.i1:s1ia:1<:e of the accused, E': is,..:h,e 'V'c$:s$1.:;;§3f ihat PW'? under Whsm. '£16 had said Capra af the valus sf ;A§r€2:f:3i.'L'his firmw'v's;savi Trade 133353 35:
-"'~._;%§a::i'§:6:_$' 12¢ «:3r§é'«',R_._aj€:3h Kumar 6;? Varanasi» 36 had said aapra wéih 'SE: 93: 21.62666. 1::
:'€$;3 97:";s§ éé:i__ éhs same. $13 said §;aj€$%: Kama? 339$ .,ad<§3"$ssv€<:i a iaéisr is him it; cefieci an amaugi sf ~» {mm LQWB? 38: B8,I}g§§$§'€4 sap}? £2? 331$ HS§:'i§i£§ §%{§€§ E3 3%: EXEJEE, Er: :€:$§é>§:s§ ':43 432% gama has ha/§ V' de§ué:e§ 'aha ééateagfid fig <:@E€<:§ aha gaéid amsugi frag; §%Ef;':'?" 8?} i":§,,?'I2£§®8 aéarzgg '\5.?§§L§'; E533 Eséjzy E}:'?1E3, \,.2>/ gag»-' U4) Km} §':£:<:5rdi:3g§y, file deeaageé wem; $0 "thee Shggj ;:1 :?::ij cofieatted 455:6 385$ amsuni gf Bafigalaré: at about § p.33. '1'h:--:§ "said '$5 Q'-«:%,GG,0GQ/~ according ':0 m%:>€€n relieved by the aCcuse:5;4'E1fic§:n_«'At"1H1:é of '!:'}V'i'é éeceassd after Cemmittirxg 'AA*i[I_1%:'_'--~sai:1 &mQu:3i ihey have r€Q§;x?é§j§f:§: a in {he {aim 0f ?1§80,G0O/ V'f££}€"iVnst8"I1Ce sf accused N933; EXSP23 ané P24 apart f1;{:>§n" " H The tpz-*..::$ss3c1;:1;i~:>:::_vi::.:_'€>:rde:" is establish {he reasvszy ZL§':é§fe.-..§f:fi_;Cr15 and {E16 biack 'bag-EVES18, in which, Cash,'<.%;fas Sarriad, havfi rssfirsd apes": the €'»f§§;€lf1E'.€ $:§--§'%;E-ES $3 36 4:113 izaveséigfaiing offisez in thég 'V <:as€. gipaféé' ifam 31$ 355236, 33:65; have aisg rséisd Qpam wsfiidéiizcfi «:3? EWS 7 arm"? 337 in éihis CGZ}i1€C§iGiQ. E: is if:
':'§t2_§"a>5*;?§ds::§:€ <35 PWEQ éhai he arrsgiad 1:313 aiizzzgaeé fin .E,§E§f?€2GS§§ §§E'{%3E"§'G§3§€§ éh€m azd ffififiiffifiéi {flair xfgizzniafy E%§73X§€§:"i€E}E) 3.3 pg; P45 3:20': ?§6; ../'J 4&6} <:h2:rg€§ §£:v:3E€§, zzgainsi: them, '§h<e§: :'5:rs__ in C1lS§.{>§:y1 'I'%:€}; am Qrdéred is 33%: 36:: 21:' fefihwiih if moi rsqaireaj in any eilfgarir caigé'; 'v Sifwf" ;
.. _A rs