Karnataka High Court
K C Murugendra Swamy vs K C Byrappa S/O Chikkaveerabhadregowda on 18 June, 2008
Author: V.Jagannathan
Bench: V.Jagannathan
~vsgn- ur mmnrmon me» count or KARNATAKA men COUR? or KARNATAKA HIGH COURT or KARNAIAKA c-E56573 mam amm' Q?' mmmmm AT amcgawxa mgmg 1% :33: my 5? may % _ Eayegg '§""r:E~ E-§a:."'::s%m:.$ rsm.J:33*1*zm:_é;%,J§gGA:§i~m1*H£g[i¢~.: }% . gawaag s3c@§%§§;§-ms; m.'5ss3;f_;a:r:6 ,,?v§;1z'L%an;:1m. ..
25 < 'Ea 1';
A%gv£§i.g;ga§:1§'*%;§.~§r¢:ar's, ' "
E*§%;_5$§;a;£%E':¢'s:::§.i,'*€Zi}1i£e.;a3%:a§;.$}mz1aEml1i 'ia1LJ.k. = -s:§i;§.€rjic>€:.+v5%'3'f§:2 3:4: ...2°sP%LLANTS ggrykgzem, ma;
' '€';,E%:,~:T.}§}~*:&&§3fi'$s-E. "
, , ._ :r€1;3%--3 "F2? 3 fir.
. .
';§§g%-zéafi afimi fifiywra ;, 5 égézi ~..~.:§;:a::2 mi. ?$ 'ymm § % T L , «§'-{'eZ§3:éa:=r3'."?.$ ';3§AE 5 Eiufiyar man,
-. -- ..-..,..,..... rnwrl yuan! or KARNATAKA men count or KARNATAKA H36!-I (SOUR? or KARNATAKA HIGH COURT or KARNATAKA I-HGH c L;%?€fl3.2%k wgrzirg ex: far afimimaian this day, Qfimfi €i§.fiEi'%!&'§?$'€i ma faiééwirg:
&{J$$r§¥iE§?
'%' Eififi Efiarzzeafi fimzxmi far pafiiéa. ': 4' 1% dfiffiiéfifli ssrzfi ha in Q5' ff;-",*¢4':?~*m» :32?' '£315: ;:%§§r¢$ that tha mg. ugzf the auit §;m§$::'%:é£,e§.s hash: wax:
Ema pmperty.
are ta 3% efizzt that 45% r§;ir:s§;§éig::?;*?:2:§:*:? 21% 31% 3; mi: in quaatian by »A fifgat %sE is the fibaaiute 93.29% of €13 suit in S§r,§¥$.3€}§,s" 'Z?' mmaur%m 3 acrm 34» 3 amw IS guntaa, .1. $3;-xI€:'3.3fi4f S ;
'aim mmi gym: at' 3 acgaaa. 2:3 gumasg 'gm his 51% '£3 Eiw 511%: gmprartieas an aucbfin " zmfig hm wxi aw? 3319: ms aucticrx §s*:;:;*.:*:,:%w,:a%;4:£ 'Sm plamzifi isaas 'mm in fisaasaémn cf the §:%;E"?'f%§fi3"'£;%'§ mfié the mwzma rwrais aka itrzdimtacs hiss }« 'J _... .._--.
--W-v~ rwn n-smxa or KARNATAKA HFGH coum or KARNATAKII men COURT or KARNATAKA I-HGH COURT as KARNATAKA HIGH c £33 3.21:3; aftazr agprwéafim firm esvfienm 0:1- zmazfiig Ewlé fix: Kim zmpmzflant 2%.}; %:3;:a {saga ihaé: 113 is fim mmer sf .fs:.1A_3;:€ Z mm mm mm that mrtgagziafi 'jag gmaafiségfi, Qf ram véfifiit n mrztsantéam $3? fiw €215}? hmsziz baa: in afivema "11%JLt:§:$§c[§m 4-.J2"*§:%§;;:.&z2§;.g'§§:; the auéi af as the: Icawer agwikm :";flLl2°'$ dfimfisad ;z:'i;::"*¢§ -'€§T::éH ma} ccaurt was (if "?c;1":i§g §é"'§3§*_%%§r2§e;§ %~* "figs E'? $§:3ndant. ' .. éiezxumal S§'i.fisflVgCangadharaq3rm, fimt bath the Ciuurfls bekw &.;3'§§s§§a£at¢ $35 écmameexats ymrziizwfi by that h z*$.:§~.$§ :3 3. auwtatzzial qfififififi eaf flaw and ma =&§§m§.?.a% agar': in the csume $21" in judgmnt aka fééaa §%:§§:.%:=m%{i €;.'%a: £13; 313 1.zm&u@s$a:'y' is rmrt tn diams <3%§*?;&:: mfiassgm mtg. Iflrfi mid {Elia a¥3$m's;amrn 3/ I! , ;*:»£~::np§&%§§ £3 gm: {£5 a;3peE§ant.a éaiefiasmfl "%"§E§3 €13.25 fikmtfls gaaawfiion §L1jt am': tkmmfzzsm tém quaafian sf izzmmme cf tlm _j ' r°-sf r«+=°-is'-A2.
we. =s:1l,.t..£x1'.I-'um {:3 Er: mg :::~ij:1m mafia: by %a:§.g.7': égézfifiag E haw ""';-"kw jucigments tzaf EM ~s;vr;:2.2§'%$ Ea a eosmmn by the plahrzfifi ia than sowner cf the 3:;-"ap@*£.%m 5.3» ' fir '£3 czaf the 1* d&:§"e3,.r::&>&;§'2*€. ifi a:?s'.}3"¥.j:,';¢f§.'§fl3:; {§é.s'L1z'ts haw hakfi mat irayya atamd m Irmve wi%:;§¢" fgséx -- -$§sV.1_it_j.. §rap¢r1Em and thzz safi and 3§3§*eé.%1 gumfiaaaé the suit ' A §:::~:,:»§§",2i~:;:f§i'§;t5::;__;"'»%:};2s2; afarfiafi fialamm Simh hitnaeif has
4. .. . _ if 4,-;-5;?£éi33iza25i'1 amt; * .. .2 righm. aver {Em suit Fafirme sf iim §m befsre: tbs L-afi walé fim mwémmn fiat was 5% %f€.2r& the a.2:.§:%m fit? 3;I'§.{3. the apmal prafafrmfi by Balaram fiingfi 'fifiéfifi fiéfimfifififi mfi afimrz "Rim wait Fleé; by {Ila 3* R / \ 3 um LUURI or KARNATAKA HIGH cquajt or KARNATAKA HIGH count or KARNATAIOI HIGH count 09 KARNATAKA mun-s uuum ur ~................. .. E} Etég §s~g#»{%.é§1c mat is ifiafi M :13 in §=r::.=5s&s§0n asf the-"suit fiat them wag may a@:~--§yaE§5«:::t% agafi; fgsammé: ma: was ciaimgd ' fiza 53- "$321.3 mum fif fiw m§::2m:;%:;»-:3 ts: fffiiffiéfi thé: a§:gac1ls::2.+Am;'«..fmza3».i:;1"§}erfer1%iiig érffga :§?2ai:1t:%"a gait Bfitli~7§;fiE ma pm$.as5s_s.5*im": £3"? amt am.' the said ' an mzrmt be smé m fig §i%€%1"¥'~.E'iT'§§& ar".f&f fmfimg ~~~~ _ :13 -- ' fig not menafidereé by t}1§{V'V1v§cz*»3:rg::" Wham the lawer safifibci that the figaaxmsnts S which ésmmfi am mat in ' .1' péaimifi 'magma tha pumhaser nf me an a gauhifim auafimn ané rm mine was aha _ kafiém 211:: $133 1§1a?mt.ifi Ming Fmauml dalisaszy rgmim mare wag rmuirfi far the murm fit. thg flaws Efiiaw 3:€§fi§'}'I%.a Eéw {Eases af €31: .::=.: . %wr*251Zz*3 imam rm: baen akha 'en %;%.m§§ "§'3"1fi sagya k .-
£1-i COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH C91.-JR?! OF KARNAIAIU'-\ Hzun uuum ur i'u-\!uVHu-uxn mun ............ V. ..n........ m'*:;aZi:a'§.:%:.ss"i"; 33%: tlaeir §::°§iime:$$or wntimr has tifik is the §%'21'}}__ Maia mzauae ma sfigin is &c:§4'm nmfw .' 'km: fiéé fiaizi Baimxn Séxgh himelf 323%. :;3;'§,?.%1.%'E«'§ er miile in the aziit §r::r $C£3E.§§§31'$1:1'§' figs ~ = V' K &_:"s.s:i ibfi ggpgi prssffirrm S mmwmxméciarazééfi a:::f_ €:§_3¢ _'ér§t.}f_i;::*:? 1. ééii"
E"fi'£.'QE"'{§. ;:9;1:"::z'wt m asafi m' %m aargéigizg _ :'-«'15 'ha a:§:&£:- £23 as: wwasigéi 'mzimatantial wé' Eggs, Em v§:*:w3a§" :%E:3512¥?;3g§:-:ei11g{'T'--#e3§g.§§c3z3s, E fin mat firfi ::::ae:~:§§T:;'?"§;.~:r*1éiajgg-_a§.>--@1ax1& ii is actzxardiatglgi fiififijififi-151:1. Sdl Judge