Karnataka High Court
Sri J Madegowda S/O Late Javaregowda vs The Additional Director on 17 August, 2011
Author: Anand Byrareddy
Bench: Anand Byrareddy
V ' E33. 6 :'£:=..§:3 <fi;frs:;i::*~--'§}; 2:
ix.) Si Thé: " ."';2:E1.3.53i§{§2'~:.2i', Sgzggazr "E"'::;¢ S21g_f:;z:'::, Shiz:1<}g21 E.'§i..<;~;':;
5;; 'Tbs .{}a3;§:.:§.3' C0:'z'3.n":§$$i@:'2e:::'.
§3éis;€é.riQ§, C8_S§,€f En{:<}m<::
'v'e:"§£."i€21%1i{m C{>n":n:ii;.i.e€;:
Sh Em zjggai E}isE',, Shiflmggzi, {B}; Szfi. E-'.S'E}§:':€3h Kumaix 5'-'-\.{£v.§ Saki' R2 3 {By C«&'a1g§a(§€:ess§*:§ zkaiam fog' RE R3 8: E'ii¥9j'--. A '§'h;%s W1*i%. E3@§i%i0§:~"§;sj f:'§<?~;;'§""i.,3;':f:;%:;iE;:%"LAg%.1?°'i:i{:§é3S;" 22% and
22.'? 0f {E16 C<}ns§i%;ui%0n :;§:f.T::1'{£§=a.;s.j_p3*2é};ir:g":Q 3«eE:--a$§ée: %1:§;1€:
{}TE"d€£° d:c1"i:€§E:2G'3E Ja:'3;:'1.a'rf§; €39 wig ;%;::§;:?g§.V§3;a:s5.;<3€§ by 816 R2 and a}s~fa{:~ the csréex" §1'aiI€€"§.:§'25".?'"fiLig§i;:S'i.,";2398;; pa§ss<~:c§ 'fly {ha 'E'.21h:e1SiZ.d~a.:'";'1 ésfse E'3;;n:>;~E<Z. ' This p§3€:iE:,_%;<§:":, .<:€i'§ni:§g'.':.%z>i'§~._{er "§j:€:'a;*:§§3g;; this <:i8,:,.r, {hf} Cam"; :ma.d:::, "fe::»7iE_:;f;_*e,>;.s;_*i£'1_;s,§§; ' Hfi-§2~"zz"& 4€I§'3.€i §f?f;1.;f§1§f,'.:§V€i.{3'1}fiS¢i*:§ far the p:3t:§;'£:i<;»m3:' and 2% $'i'.a€:e<§ "E33; 'fghc §§€E?Ii§i{}'L"§€E' is 315 i7<:E.E<3:x;f:; :
€;';»5~§ 4% a2§3§3:>§:":€:€:{§ 21:5 2: *é.:q'p§:~::.. zzzéééz ms: 21% :°a=%;*~;;p<;=:':s:§a.:':%:. :5: Segéia-".=::§%2€r E'£«§E.*§4ié. Ha {:<mE,§::z.2:%53 5:6 'fix-"{}§°§§ §:'h€:"é5: $3 $1.23 {Eater zzsf §3:':%t§£,§:}:: am}: F3}-F vE;"é%;:.:::% 0%' She? irzwrérzs ".{>§:='{§ifc:z;""~. §§r'am;<~3d by this Cmrzri: he <:z::m;im:es~3 iii} Lvsrk Wi'1ifi :~}€f.T:f:{3§3€E_ ré:s:;§}<}n::§€';";i; {E31 e:iai'<=,:
3. "E7 E19 pei€;:'i;i@:2e%r 0b '%.a1'i:1e<i the aéasfie {:€rE.i§§cam:~. E':°{'§::§t: xfti'Zr:_=:: '{'a.'Euk 21$ ésafiy as in the §7€f£:?;?." vi9'?;€%:~ Eprasixzcad 21$ Annsxaire ta $;fviV%a;:€}i'V"£,§1a: faei of fa}-as <::€rtifi::2u:§;:_~:+M___v wag 2: gc~:--::r:€::'21E dizfe:<:*{ioz: __§S8'L;é5' 'i«_:':'»:%fi t:?1'§:hé::a,t.aE§£ishmmtg iyzatiuding the presfizzé; §'é3s';§:s:::::.z:¥;€:ii._t:-:2. tsxéimims the §§%3§"§u§§"§€SS af Céififfi _..s;:€§'t..i;{£.:3:§J{.€$~ ;3§f{>dé,i::,:?:?rd <35; She bagiss 0? Whisk §3H1pE{}}.=*€:€§;
'§i;;§J;€' 's.<:§':z_..:_:*s.€;§'«s:r§':§3E£:jm1<3:2i; H. fL;:'§:E:e:" 's:ra:1Sp§:'*$s»; iihafiii thfi Q33?' AE'§§'E§§{}E"§'€:§.§Ef;-"Z.E=;.,1' bags isfiizza-éd 21 321%»: {?£§;iiS€ §'E{}'§i§C€ an 4 2?' E2\,2€?§«f% 3:9 "§',E";;:;:s ;3é3?:'.ii:i{:a:1:;*::° in §.€;'tE'.TI"§E§§2i '3' ;%:1§"::%>:1zr§;% -- "E? _ ééiifiiézégg;-.A'z,:p<}3;: '%};§;f;': ii} :%;%":{,:2}: £%;":a:,2s%3: £38 £15} %'s3§7E}:' $2235; E%€§"%'§€ff€';°S§ Z ,..
Z7?
s;h{:x*a.:§:3. :25}? 'mg? '§{.i?E'E1E§I1é:*:§€?{§ in 2»=-'ia=-3'33; 3? that {:;.1*<§s%:" sf '£326:
Gaga: "v"<:%:r:i_fi{.:a%;i<}:_'*:_ {i<é:1§.:;_:*;_ié:i:¢=t<3 E3}; ié$ «:3:f:§»:%:* e:i;2z3§"_g;é{'; i_'§,:2»2;{}§"§ ii} the? e§§§%<3§. i;I*:e2*: §;h=r3 §3€:i.ii4i<>m::r {EM zmég, is 21 Satheiiuied 'I":"ibe arid i:%1aE': €:iE;":s--:< "::<3:¢3:if.?1<:¥_;1t,e g5;*t€3d1iz::£3d '§3§ Eiém E--i?'E3;-'ii 22 €21}-$9 a:{:'r§:if"i{f22;*(.s3. in :i::p§j;;:'_ is ':.h':;?.vVé5a2:n§;i pe3i;iti<}:'ze:' haii <:<>z1i<§::d<3{§ {§§§"cew:::.iz>:§ the 3mm £1}-0ve:'r:mé:é:'z§::" $213 ":94:<>E '£10 §§TIfi,§8_'€'.€E zmy acémm a§,§::ii:1';i¢;i'»'::2:::_::ii<:i:g§{é'é3. w§i'2">,»hamreé Seaiureé é31"§1§}§i€Z1}-".Z'§iE(i*.E'23L', iizzldezjrj gm}; 'Z"é':b'<§:'*:?:;fV;.-..:§;§if,21 and iihai they nzay '$6 %£:é3ai{e§-- Even if {hers was an <3:§e.£é3£" ._§;21§;sézi.:_ .,'__$3r_V V;€Eg1$é;€: Vmificatisiz C€)mmfi;t€~.§:__vi2f:»_§Ei*::§.;_:jgee;ij Séimfi wag wiihaxzi; §v;.z°i3<i:Z{:€,;;V{>::';, élisg {",:.§':}".é','»/'E.€T:'4f..{?w€3f.ET§;."i.fi:L?8$.€* Whiath W213 ;'§3{§L1§_l;hfi'. is be :':a:"::f:€=rE§€:.".*§§ 'wags; ..§v;T§5:%-{§<f€'13"3f}_§7"Pt7f1E? _j:.a:'is«~scE§i:Ei§<:na§ 'E';:2h$iE{iar* é3.,Z'£{§ §.}:€:* aaaici"':7iz:*'i:§fi<t.a€:é:s. aiayizéd; heave '$362': €:a:2{:@§§€r:§ iéniy ...§}y .3T§."2:za,i:1§;=:'«;%§:?§é§:'.,"'7E'ft:§_:s;_AE1as5 béféffi Eaié ::':<'m:1} E33; ibis: Cimzfi:
?é§5, F.a¥§.;§§fE$§{2fi@8 in £1325? fféfiééé? :2? ffiimmarafia Vgg §"*§:§éV.:§éi§*az§§,¥:§s§§é*'gépgfiiiani fi§£€§'§Q§'§§§_§s '§'EE;s3:§_°€f<>:*s35 3%,: .133 S :z";.{3é;v..-T'§i'.E":§sE:z?z:r:{§img; §.."§:1é': fz¢.e:%?;'. izhzfgi: "E: :1-': E':.2:2éa 5u§f€ ;¥"@r:'§ am {}:"<i:%:" '27:} "E35 {i9i',;"§:m%;':*:"
E2': amy €va':::1'§;, ih::*. pg/°ef:i3ss::*:";E;. p<:':t,§i'.i:_m §a<7E<;s+; " is; 9;::*;:?:<>:"di::g}y {§§S§'§1.iSE§€;'C§,= _Wfx §§;;«__ . V' V Q; .
'_ ""m;»§;a_§