Delhi District Court
State vs Satbir Singh. on 16 January, 2007
1
!#"%$& ' ( )*" ,+-+.) / %0)/ $1 %32
4 5)
6 798;:=<,>@?BA CED'FGD@H
I >KJ >@? LNMPOEMPQRI S@TVU
JKW#M'WYX Z(XET\[]SE[ J M'W*^ U_T J`U_OKa b
ced/f hg ikj d'l m 2 mon5prqsgut dwv gR) xhy{z}|
c9~]f Pqhgu d p}gmonEt1m j vv j
m'mon5prqsgumonng st{gK) |K]2y]x 20o '
c t f qhg d ugum n pqhgut1m' l
d j d p%jn d E) d d' q d h
c f qhg d ugum n pqhg d t1ts v gwhg i v m / d hq'j v
d ig' p dw g d hi9g v j
/g ht1gK) J M W^ U_T J`U_OKa b
J F<=< U bKM OK
8 F< ¡}¢ C`£¤L¥>{L¥>5 < ¦3<PO § ¨
I M O Q bEM©8,< MKP¨
ª`WVWYMP« :=MKa MPT\¨`: ¬&>
c g f Pqhgum n_ng'ht1gut1m ld j®hgw¯mon )
/z v ° | ° z ° |w± !1 `2
c n f qhg l g d m n pqhg d t1ts v gw d hq'j v
go² d j® d p³j´m c jn d f ) ! lg d gwhmsp 'j l p9¶µ
t l
d j¶gwupij d l 2
c· f qhg¸nGj® d'l i9 g i³) m' ¹5j´t*prj
m'¯1z v ° |h± d h
d t1º 'jp9p}gw1z v ° | ° !1
c q f qhg d pgum n v htoqm i9 g'i\) //2y5/2|/ywy »52
Lª=¬¼-½¾ : ¿À?_¡
/2 ÁEikj
g n ig v /¶g©mon pqhgn d t*p v m nÂpqhg4t dhv g©m n im v g]to prj
m'Ãj v prq d p
m' |K/2®y]x 20o d p d ~ m p&o| 2 wy' d p ÄÄ% m l m ' l ©! d q d m d Åhg d i
Äkq/ j&hg d iR+ d hKj&
p9p d dw'd i}
,g l q'jÆ Ç¤jÈprq j®ÉprqhgÀÊ9 ij v j
t¥p³j´m Ëmon!{
Ä d d !o ikjÌprqhg d t1to v g] ¹]m l p d ij l t d v gw v j® l g j¥Ê/ij´g v m'Íprqhg
hg'i v m'm nÂ
v q d d sÎ d d' q d h Ç.jprq ~'l / p d h v q d ik gw gwRÇ g d hm'
i9g v hgwt*prjȹ]g l 2
| 2 " t1to v g] Ç dwv.d iGig v p}gw d hÏg' ld i g]Ïm ~hd j l 2R t1m' l gsprj
m'
m n
j® ¹]g v p³j d prj
m'Ðtoq d i g v qhgwgspÑÇ dhv nGj l gwE2% m 'j´g v Ç g'ig v l j
gw;p}m;pqhg
d t{to v gwE2Ò q d i gÑnm'iKprqsgumonng st{g v /'j v q d ~'l g h/g i hgwt*prj
m' v ° | ° z ° |w±
Contd....
2
!1 Ç dhv-v g'ie¹]g] hm'pqhg d t1to v g] ~ R$YE2/!oi9gw g]t1g vv m'iGp}muǤq j
toq qhg
lg d gw smsp j l p d h¯t ld j®ug]prikj d'l 2
° 2 m i9ms¹]g jÈp v t dhv g dw d j v p prqhg d t{to v gw5 i9m v gwto p³j´m
go² d j®hgwÀj d'll Ç.jprhg vv g v j® d l®l d ug l ¯Är2P `2K dwv q'j v pq dhv !¥ÓÎhÔ p\2
d Ê d d dhv !¥Ó|'Ìt1m ld j® d p d d' q d h dwv !¥Ó °
!oi d /g]g'
Õ' d i dwv !¥Ó ± d sR %ir2o d ¥Ê d m'q p dh j dwv !¥Ó52
± 2 qsg i9g d n·pg i} v p d pg ug p mon(prqsg d t1to v g]Ð
/z v° ° i2Ö!h2 ×Ç dhv
i9g]t1m'i gwÇ qhg'ig j®ØqsgBq dwv lg d gwÅq'j v n d'l
v gØj® l j´t d p³j´m d hÅj® hmwt1g st{g
d hà ig ng'iki9gwÏp}m lg d © g ng st{gÏgo¹5j
g'ht1g 2©"@t{to v gwØgs² d jhgwÙq j v Ç.jÚng
v q ddwv PÓÎuj®¯q'j v g ng'ht1g 2
52 'q d ¹]gBqhg d i9prqsg v ~ j vv j
m' v mon@prqhgÏ$YE2¯" !s!.nm'i@prqsgR op d pg'
$YE2o m' v g l nÛm iKpqhg d t1ts v gw d hq d ¹]ghg'iG v gwprqhgt dhv gÑnGj l g 2
x'2 $YE25 ,g ng'ht1g t1m / v g l t1m pg s g]nÛm i d t1º 'jp9p d l m n@prqhg d t1to v g]
vd 5j
v q d dhv¯v p d pg] ~ 4j® ¹]g v prj 'd p³j Ãdh g'ht¥'Ep}mÃq d ¹]gÃigwt1g5j¹]g]Bpqhg
j®Ê ikj
g v Kq dwv hmop ~ gwg uthjp}gw dwv Ç.jprhg vYv /Ǥqhm ~ g j® ǤjngmonPpqhg d t1to v g]
q dhv ~ gwg' gs² d jhg] dhv /gong'ht1g Ç.jprhg vYv dhv Ó©/2× qhg q dwv hmop
v hm'iÛpg]ÜprqhgBt dhv gÎm nÂpqhgÅ i9m v gwto p³j´m ~ p j® v pg d 4 g'hm v gw4m n(q d ¹5j®
i9g]t1g jȹ]gwÀj®Ê ikj
g v n}i9m dhvvd lp ~ Ý d d q d hE2Å" l´v mØÇ dwvuv p d p}gw©pq d p
dhv hg'i g'hm v jÈprj
m'Üm n j®¥Ê9 igwÙ!¥Ó ° d d' q d hÃqhgÇ dwv /ig v g' p d p(pqhg
v hmsp d'l m' ǤjÈpq¶m'hg d' g v q d p prqhgÑp³j®ug¯monEmwt{to iGi9g ht1g52u d j´ d' g v q¯q dwv
hmop ~ gwg'Bgo² d j®sg] d h©go¹]g pqhg ~ im g' ~ mop9p l g©q dwv¶~ gwg v g5jßÞ¥gwRn}i9m
d d' q d s d h smspÎn}im' prqsg d t1ts v gwE2 ´p4Ç dhvÍv ~ jp9pg] pq d p
d t{to v gw q dwv¤~ g]g'Ìn d l´v g l j® l j´t d pg]E2
Contd....
3
»52 PqhgØt dwv gØm n%prqhgÅ/im v gwto p³j´m Øj v pq d p !¥Ó ° Ç dhv i9g v g' p d p¼prqhg
l
d t1g¯monPm]t1to iGig'ht1guǤqsg d º d iki9g l m n d t1ts v gwǤjÈpq q'j v Ç.jÚngp}mwm l
d t1g
j® v j´ gÉq j v qhm v g d hÀÇ qhg' ~ moprqÝm n&pqhg t d ug×m p v j
g d s d t1to v g]
v p d iÛpg] ~ g d p³j q'j v Ç.jÚng 2Ý!¥Ó °vd Çàprqhg' 2Ï" t1to v g]Üq i l gw d ~ v g vd h
dhv1 g]á!¥Ó ° Ǥq Ëqhg;Ç dhvØv jÈp9prj® pqhg i9g52 !¥Ó °×dhv1 g]Ôq'j p}m v p}m'Ùnim'
j¹5j® àd ~ v g v 2 " t1to v gw 'd ¹]gÀnGj v p ~'l mhÇ v m'Àpqhgân d t1gËm n¯!¥Ó ° 2 !¥Ó °
g'hº 'jigwãÇ q d t1to v g]äÇ dhvÉ~ g d p³j !¥Ó ° Ç.jprqhm' p ~ g5j åd ãg /jÈp
go²5j v p³j® 2â qhg'i9g d n·p}g'i(pqhg d t1to v gw4ǤjÈprq;q'j v Ǥjng©Ç g' pj® v j
/g;q'j v qhm' v g
d h d t1to v g] ~ i9m q p d ¶m'hgo4 l
d p ~ mspp l g d h ~ i9m gÅ hm' prqhg v¥d ¶g
d h dhvvd l pg]ä!¥Ó ° ǤjÈpqÀpqhg v¥d j
~ im g' ~ mspp l gÉm'Àpqhg d iG t d v j®
j®Ê ikj
g v m'àpqhg hg'i v m'ãmonB!¥Ó ° 2 "@t1ts v gw i d d Ç d àn}i9m pqhg v hmop\2
ÁEi9m g ~ mop9p l g Ç dhv q d h gw mo¹]g i ~ !¥Ó ° pm pqhg hm l j´t1g 2 !¥Ó ° Ç dhv
d jp9p}gwáj®ÙprqsgÉqhm v 'jÈp d l%d hÔq'j vBv p d pg ug p {² 2=!¥Ó ° z_"ÒÇ dwv i9gwt{m'i9 g]
d h ~ mspp l g Ç dhváv g j´Þg] ¹5j
/g v g j´Þ1 i9g ¶g'¶m {² 2!¥Ó ° zÁP2 æ p}g'i9g v p}gw
p}g v p³j®um ¶m n !¥Ó ° Ǥqsg ¯i9g d dwv&d Ǥqhm l g d sg d i v p}mq d ¹]g d ikj® m n5priG prq
j®×jÈp ~ g5j n}i9g]gÎnim' d p}g'ij d l t{m' pi d Kj
t¥prj
m' v v go¹]g i9gçj nGjik jÈp³j´g vRd h
j®/qhg i9g' p j® im ~wd ~ j l jÈprj
g vd h©g' ~ g ll j v q ¶g' p v m j® p}mBpqhgÅi9m]mop&m n%prqhg
d p9pg i pmÀtoqhgwt prqhg ~wdhv j
tB¹]g i v j
m' d h;t{m'i9gÀm n pqhgÐ i9m v gwts p³j
m'Ýt dhv g52
m B¶g' p³j´m j®Ü!¥Ó ° z_" ~ Î!¥Ó ° jØig v hg]t¥p m n qhg ~ g j® Bv¥d ¹]g] ~ dÜld w
d h d pq Ý d j®ÀjÈp v g l n=Ç m' l ×jÙhmÎÇ d ~ g v nnGj
tsj
g' pÑjÝjÈp v g ln p}m
Kj v t d iÅpqhg v Ç m iG v p d p}g'¶g' p m n-!¥Ó ° jØp}mop}m©m'iÌj®Ù d iep³j´ts ld ir2è jht1gÀjp
t d ~ g vd j
¯pq d p vd ug j vÌd pij¹5j d'l Kj v toi9g d ht¥ smsp,pm stsq j® prqhg t1m'ig¯m n
prqsgÏ i9m v gwts p³j
m' t dhv g d h©/h hgÏj® sm iep d ht1g t d Ïhmop ~ g d p9p d toqhgwp}mØjÈp³2
m Àgo² d j® d p³j´m Àm nÌthjp}gwá!¥Ó d g v q/ ig'hm'iÛpg] l Ësmsp¸pi d t1g d ~'l g d'l
v m
t d /hmsp ~ g
p}g'ikug]pm ~ gÑn d p d'l p}mÑprqhg/im v gwto p³j´m Ít dwv g 2
é 2 PqhgÎn d t*p-mon=ǤjngÙm n prqsg d t{to v gwÙt{m'j ms¹]g'i d h vd 5j j
Contd....
4
g ng'ht1gçm nÌpqhg d t1to v g] t d ~ g d i9g]tsj d pg] dwvÃ~ g j® Ëdâ g v pr/igÀnm'i
vd ¹5j qhg i q v~wd sBnim' d l j g l v g pg st{g52â´p- d ~ g v m Epq d p v qhg
d q d ¹]g i9g]t1m'htsj l gw qhg'i4 d pij¶m''j d'l Kj v p}g vÔd h ~ g5j ig v j
Kj
h/g i¼prqsg vd ¶gÃimwm n ǤjÈpqpqhg d t1to v g]Ý d Ùq d ¹]g v mØ g'hm v gw©pm v¥d ¹]g
prqsg d t1to v g] d t1t{m'i9Kj® l 2
K2 !¥ÓBâ i2 d ¥Ê d â /m q p dh j, g'hm v gw;mon.q d ¹5j® go² d j®sg]É!¥Ó °
¹5j
/gË+-$ ² 2&!¥ÓÎz_"åm j®'j j®¥Ê9 ij´g v q d ¹5j t d v g] ~ v q d iGÀg] g]
Ç g d hm' ~ g5j ©v j l g 2âæ¥Ê9 iÛÏprqsg i9g5j©q dwv~ g]g' gop d j l gw dwv f ,$êÓ m
l g n·p v qhm' l g i °'ëíì ¥z9± ë\ì z}| ë d h | f ,$êÓ m l g n·pB hg'im' hm v pg ikj
m'i
dhv hgwt¥p\2
oy 2 g v p³j¶m' Üm n !¥Ó ° q dhv~ gwg l g' p toi9g]/g ht1g ~ Ïp}g v prj®um Øm n
!¥ÓBà i2 d ¥Ê d Ý /m q p dw j d h©pqhgB¹]g i v j
m'Üm n= g ng'ht1gÝj2Pg 2`!¥Ó ° j v p}g d
q d ¹5j® Àdhvvd l p}gw Ó©Ù
v q dÐld t v toigw g'ht1g' v jht1gÎnm'i prq d pjÈp v p d s v
d jp9p}gw ~ ápqhgá g ng'ht1gápq d pBhmát1m ld j® pÇ dwvÉl mw gw ~ g nm'igÔprqhg
hm l j´t{gm i`jãpqhgut1m /iÛp³2
/2 Á/Ïprqhg d ~ mo¹]gØKj v to vYv j´m ÎEq d ¹]gÅi9g d toqhgwÎt1m' v j
g'igw©m j®'j´m
prq d p¸/im v gwto p³j´m Ùq dwvR~ g]g' v ht1t{g vYv n} l j®; i9ms¹5j prq d p d t{to v gwÝ d p ~ ji
q d ¹]m l / p d ij l t d v gw v j® l g q/ iÛp ~ v q d ik g] g] m ~ Êegwt¥pØp}m pqhg
hg'i v m' monÝ d d q d hE2 " t1to v g] j vãd t1t1m i9Kj Kl qsg l 'j l p9 d h
t1m ¹5j
t¥p}gwÜnm'i(monng st{gÎ1z v ° |w±À !1 `2Ô´p v p d h v hmop- i9ms¹]gw©pq d p d t{to v gw
q d dhvvd l pg]Ôq'j v ǤjnÛgá
v q d v jht1gá
v q d g j
gwËm n¯jÈp³2 hm;prqsgçt dhv g
dh'd j v p d t{to v gwÒnÛm i t1m j vYv j
m'Òm nm n_ng'ht1g z vç° | ° !1 v p d h v hmop
i9ms¹]gw d hnÛm i%m n_ng'ht1gB1z v¸° | ° !1 ©prq d p d t{to v gwØj v qhg l Ühmop 'j l p9 d s
d t{º5'jÈpp}gwE2¶$gop d t{to v gw ~ gqhg d i9¯m v g pg st{g¸nm i mon_nÛg ht1gz v ° |w±R !1 `2
î &S@T}ï UOE XET(I M ¦5J`U_OKa b@ð
= ¦Û> b U3X/ñ&½X]WT³<P5< ¦_UWYM OνMKa UÖ[1W*T³M WYX5¨
I Tr< OK< S OEò X5ÎU_OWbKX < 5XEOò < S TGW 8,<Pb@UO@UÖ¨`¬¼XE¦_b UÛ>
< OW*b@UÖ[£ £oó3ô M'§B< ñ LNMPO@SKM T}§P¨,õ5öKöE÷
Contd....
5
IN THE COURT OF SH GURVINDER PAL SINGH
ACMM : ROHINI : DELHI
State Vs Satbir Singh.
FIR No. 389/95
PS Janak Puri.
Under Sec. 324 IPC
ORDER ON SENTENCE
16.01.2007
Present : Ld. APP for the State.
Convict in JC with Sh. Satish Chandra, Advocate.
Heard on the point of sentence.
Convict is stated to be of age 37 years, married, having wife and four minor children to support, being sole bread earner for them doing job of Waiter. It has been submitted that convict is not a previous convict not facing any other criminal trial. Lenient view is prayed for the convict.
Convict has been held guilty for the offence punishable u/s 324 IPC. The convict has faced trial for about 11 years. In the present set of facts,I find it expedient in the interest of justice that convict deserves one opportunity to reform himself and re-establish in Society and sending the convict behind bars at present would serve no purpose.
Accordingly, I enlarge the convict on probation of good conduct by entering into personal bond and surety bond of Rs. 10,000/- each for one year with condition to keep peace and be of good behaviour and not to indulge in any unlawful activity during said period or else, he shall be called upon in this Court to appear and receive sentence accordingly for the offence he has been convicted.
Copy of judgment and order on sentence be given to convict free of cost today itself immediately.
File be consigned to Record Room.
Announced in the open (Gurvinder Pal Singh)
court on 16.1.07 ACMM/Rohini Courts/Delhi
Contd....