Central Administrative Tribunal - Cuttack
Debendra Nath Mohanta vs D/O Post on 13 September, 2023
¢ :
SAL ?3
+ TRIB:
ne CENTRAL ADMENISTRATIVE x NCH AR BE TAC cor UO (2020 AO02 Q a. 26 ~ 3 HON:
x t ited nN al Appl x i 8 Ori % CORAM:
Hon'ble Mr. Pramod Kumar Das, Member {Adnin.} oN hampua et i ' Seep ar s re at ran of Ind {OFTE TE UUYERCS as ot uistry of st peewee, seein: Ce at Lael * at aeer ee ores poo e 4 few pened Ae et beam 'ene! prt Oo .
oe P eee oy -
we a, vue aoe ea os os Sc 'net ook ont ove, enh thon, San APE cots Sambatpur i oN Pane Cet Sook sweres, eats Ke brd wy Lanne Sted 'eet ae ee 4 wre a a3 BS eet whens 'ages ye ey ee, pred . tes Ke boo i ne eke ek ' ore, + % : Soden at aan typ Core ' Oh, J 52) $ ce a i ot ' 2 "om, oad soe set. we ee ; 7 eed 4 Pa ee baa rh oe pach ont ws % tod ee * poe eee, prt, rand fre. we oo fod. fond ay Lad bot eae a dk ood ie Sos By a cot pot i
-" ee ad plese a oS aa) hea nk oct 'ad os ae "net ok PA Sonne 4 eo ape: Ff Bek ae SS Sao ea ee cadens phe fan pon ew lgpot ne ca £ 4 t a4 SG ££ & Es S ee o & "i 2 haa ut eae ee ng oe ELS wt tend eeeet ribs OS rat. or , sa raed ae es om 'ny 4 boas Pol ot pas . aA re oe) aa ran) poe wt pres i Aap. ron 're pe ¢ < 2 sate ye ae heen alent G ts Peng ths Leer ; wn whey ed / ie, Snakes a Mu "oS e a" bael veers om tae ase geet pe na a8 on ike fet 'ae leet whens on, oes, B5.
pamerg oe wend: 3 jos Noni egy oat "4 wee ond we Y wet pe pees: . LPs Bes "er iit paced " ow a aie Sap, ang i bal fea oo! on a4 P "6 oe ot +e ant ret aod fees ered pales pee tet E es py " we ' "ws : het Goa ig wt oS : os a ie o a, ore, ae 2 yao. She eet hee. bie (nee. cae wn, oa pies z Pd wn reves wa oe 'fee La Sens: oes LP p eins yn eed ot os, . , re phew yer inn x ples s gy tats, ae . fenel S x be Sey, baeans poaaad eas nk par es " we ;
tee oa " "Se on s oot ah, oe Sod ee ; pron gts 4 Row fae "en, Tea " on leona 'nat 4 " Roaag! poet East 'ned . non se; re en Es oy oe ie oh a wae Oh
- Ca pen SA oe , oe ig et * 4 3 is a Sen ie PD "ae nap romat Ls io Kee Le "4 e ye Me : Co ny ion ened, a0 eS Fae Coe pa Pics 2 ms "3 za oe £4 we 2 of 2 as oes ey "er oe i % ee ox per tes ps pee ; zy baat aad ae BG : feed oes moeei Fas ead pana ee 5 fees ny + foe a = 1 Bo eS Be fee = ed -- Oe eb: pad eee eae wr pid "
eee oe ; ea "ha % poe vai ny 2 : Z me: ae 'ad. sit AY pa:
plot annen 36 lp a "te ie oo oe oad nde os o rn aac ry ° = ch. aa 2 : oot Ea pee cae ne oe ae oe 7 pied Lee Swine: m 3 oy tae seg a wh tat Least pe * Se peers on : Es ms wa oe a Loaded ven, cae al a" wee aowes we ry Seay et fa een tected x be de at Po eyrpyyn rhe.
tirade m continued up to 26 x x PSS Acco i y 2s } San at oe ur?
bee "g A the sup eh asm sk Ee xt exe Ry rot be pr RS & seeds pes nee at fraud cot i 3 cH SHAT "ee 2 AWUTLX, ( Fa 4S } as under:
PYSCOVEL au "ey 20 Sse Re © fe ;
{ oN 1é hoe Be ny nee wa Fad Rare:
pans aad oe.
PS > nder XY £8 Py %.
S04 20 = ad i PS arder date ask tes, pceasions % a OCCASIONS WPELE LS Fond tot 4 on ra ms " , ' Tee % pee, : oe Fax 4 " * A ~ "
ogee oot vpees a = od ae ae fees tere th poe ns a tS uae) era wives £4 aoe eres is oad ee gk ory ~ a oo snp aa pee amet ~. See laced hese coal nal cooeed ty, woes Saal ; tb 'ed Coad Tare "-- wok feet coed , Sot we, Etec "* saa -- set us bat aed Fox! ae ? Ai pr 5 os oak Boot ey ye tS ney yy 'ad Sabnate bee. b ben hy ad os hae (on: ow on mn spon = Sone: pee 'anne coe ened eat: Cael oy we wed go . : m oo tea ; wa pa oot ie as £5 Foes ae : re, ~ ae, bad pa oo we Co 2% nad as, won tee pas rs een te ie $ 7 See net a, ry Be ne Faas sees 4 pan on one en 'aad steed Send "pet tt eon on Se feved bP re ree ¢ 4 ened tre pon i las : ; ot el 3 res ores he, ot, re ne ere oo Ok Wy aed et tes See, yess ws S frei, a oe es pecos ros ae on atl ad . vase . cee ae on re ; Pas ue " Sob "> ee wenn a ne "xt Oe we aad ison oe pee zt sagen, Font rae raed Ly aan Need! feats baad Sten pod yee heed come aoe cea a aes tae peed, * peed a ~ wen ora weore yee a ae Fs a 'set wok ot os na wee sa ot wae) ae we te, vores te Cet vee As ae Pah we ed Pea on ~~ pees as pep pes wor nod x Sain Feng] 7 thea Rae ve pos ony ane S52: wey ee nee yore. foe a one . heser wee reer x cee Tate! wn 3 even . Ped gre, wor ra 3 te yr Pe oe os pale ded © ent ted coed ae a4 'ae saat OD hee ban , on, as 'ogres wr a ne rye : ee sme Sroaal Aet ba 4.4 7 gs Sate "ah bet 'ed nn, Sok Z : eed a; "Ar pea 7 we d £ . a none ce ee hosed poe * ab oy ree, pred tore ag gee poed ns ' pon mt Eg 2 Z a a ee te a oe mo Se SF "se ac! es Ries oe im Pi oY oe toes a oft i oy oo re ae £ age pend get ve shed eh Lpre, seat td £ ve Sd nl we. ead tek a2 aon ed eis os on, wee pres ns woe ge es ae os aon Seg - we telat omaal on, nad 'ae pam peed "at weees ae ae pen * Pa aa ~ ong fentin pe os, pees ty ne ve viene pees ak 7 cow poss aad a brs pees pans aa Saad OE see if es ¢ o% ord if ad a fon we Pat rene baba ps ed Cdn etek reves " 0 oa we fete Cah wt nea poe ~, vey wane er pe we irae * st re Peete, yer ww a Nat wet eae Sen od "ee ub cad ; om : * tere 'rat = past '3 meet an me Fae Se pee ot me oe Don wy on feasts:
a ees rade read ey ms Boe, fen, pa a a 'a aleek % Woe bie: fy bert ow: por re om. On ven x eg sarae, Lon vars r6, ned pees wand he. ree, oS ied Saat yes bes von wees poled, om poet waeee po toed re Ls oN, oe re ret we ra, teed wire bon sane oped es ened Soho % were wot oz. at Rbed Aer ee par ws an . bs 4b fg a pa AG g q epee of saat sae fa ver wt Pee ood ws Ge com rem Bi onto Ss pan wn pa Re ihe nes ' . wed ne} ae won po 'set Fae pee oe peed ey need Sit And oa 3 re bes : Lead ' rar, foe bad ant oe sant Bed ae) cond coed t ee ae, on, ps deed nd we ened Oe eee 2 vent pee Sans, 2 aoe as booed ° 2 * 4 ees *% Se, eed :
ae pe fee veer ~~ pa pe) ver, x weed een « he nad oer "a " fe eee Pee pond Meet oh been of F raed we on -- a ghey wanes oy pis ~ yee, 4 Ws Kad we Lane oe Loo fey, Shes 184. so scpeny Fal ve pre, is rn Daal pean Seat one wer, ao, aes ops oe: free aree pa Seat wine * Ne ~ aad we Cnet vee " ys ee per bows " ey tone wan an Poa es ' we z, . the ag Te a : "D " : ' eo " * a Ears tat wae Lo lex oo tea 45 ee, ted G Le ook Clee awa ie tat vane et baad Neen seve poe ~ " we ree laa a Os ss) a ee gen rn tres Fi cee few ae 4 OL fet % ve ad arte ms Y os "ee Part ey pare <3 pen ee ke Cad ver on woe at a a na es on wee ma thi a eet ; * a at ta Eee) bint coat eal bos oe bead " bee erees ae ae "i ' oA abe paid AG so Ce wo bg ea pees re pods ro tee Ecol om. poe Pian ee Sy. re eek . esi Peds Meena ey jon, cae Sain tae ee wn telly foe gtd 'eke God re wh oe on 4 we aod oy ia eee oe, 2 the oo ab seek a" we oink of scars whew at Nad " a Le nae! ieee Sed eek peas o boa toa we a oe be, nee, * coed ty 5 te ee, at neges sed oa oe, _ a ral ae gee Cb i ot Cn on ya rien iad a ft Le tole ton on ve ~ wo : wae vhon ped he poe pen al en S fees oe vs ro e * pan Ee oo me oe pas ' ees a ae oad ey atts thea a oa ee oa co ° ee fet eed 2 wens a "ated nen pa re co fend tr ", d os aos aa ees am " im : noe bre iy " per dev none pes i oe oe em thet : . é + pad Ets end ' hae, Fase b Vf deed bent vane : 7 a tne ne, a on bw Ceseed wekoe '. crend wt 3 gees Thp ww os, Ne ~ S me a , ay aa wee weet ye oo "det o toe "at re band Bete cond wn ae £% nee 'neo fe. bas on , sted Faw' Aig wa ateed we 'ait By Ton "sn ts ata Bead : it Pasi ropes raed ook 'aa nA ¥
- on ped lat TE dood ioe, ty te ae] eet wan , os ng oS te fe, Se 3 a a mm, "hed fet = ae eo a eee) a fs eae faa nee) wie ; oe fee be) bees Sebi me oe ay Sent aa "sod Sox oh 2% ons a n: he t as iy pod pene whe ra aS eri Coe hoe » a ee? Met sad et on bw. wrebe, re ped a i re 7 yee. rox, LP : x fee fede Bre as eed ve pe Co whe rem . weet the 7 aA arene wy a3 eee va aot a suk eal we 4 pes ny eh pas 4 wen cancti oe ge oetbe won et faheb pte, ea 'ad Wty deed ae: pars tome < aa 'as x bs ied ke x os fap a) : foes wen, geen when ew Te pot ira ona ym vgn fen seoe 5 ane ao Ea oy, a ye ee iy Aes lean baad Seve neoe. ae yee on Reve. mee An f pe, hetre coves tee , es bord, acon' vn oan . on how ah "rs vat ts yok yore x poo tows elk warns ca ae we Py peeed yon pire wie ran foe Paes "ped a ; on pam a8 its oe fad ee ot te iad F ws re om * bovis ar anes vy re how ae § +m Send 5a ina tent ; ae or pert Ws ne we et Ape? ee ng Fane, SS ed eer fied ea! 'bine at tae pate dod, yre hoe ae Kae, f ant awed Fined Sent +e re g end yay om) ve a a, Ines, An, nee wee a PG 'ad Sone ols peas pass oS eed ed "naeae See on bad ae ne Fen is an 3 os on raaaad 'ae eter he me whe Soto rood gS oy aes arene:
Fan eae en a "iS > A ce 9 pon ner mo ot, peciee het aad od See a, ¥.
oS ed os ys fe oe om) ae eee ay, 4 wn, pons ny sheet on : ' hand, Ge wn "
or Inot woe stnet ot bce , or ge o es ined ie ie aed a? a pened, Be a, ea wheat "aa wy "adh Faaas nen cane Annes ae
5 pre ie. peak art bud we eee a 4 a Lh ee! tte when oat oe ar fae Sat one ret beet ok . nt LY ee conees one, =o 8 eae Pa wee, * i ere a ake on wet heat eae pa oe Raat me ~ oo tne feet ft gore 3 anh bad kee a oe 4 ;
Be tas a3 oe wat bs
-- Ce ot wt wen: nek:
we ed wn, Q oe : = vi eanck = vi , g aoe oor tod vere 2 is ae . ee @ 2 gone of ise ban we oe Aina: pay % cis pe one.
word, rood ea, a, £3 seen?
onpet, ne a ware es z on ped heed pas bow, ws pees ee a oe get reed, sae! os we vee, el oo wee ed, beste or fey ~ ae ae ae 3 we ~ in support of the deposits x passhan SUPETVISO 2 uty 8S a eed era be, rae i.
on, ode wore tite . ewheongpe FD as erafer Rule .
$ oy PeEGLATEL FRE oxes QE SOF re the war eet of SpE ~ NG ance im re x st of ba) cand ou r agreement purp Ji. Due te ol Moanial, ¥ & aa! fee 3 os ee Focen es fe " + rene Kes ons, "ee & 'nie. Stel " eas es) se id oo oe ene to eee pee, ween ieee ne po. re el one. Ae. TAD ieee, oe Coe "ae soe 3 2 tp whe "mn, "pos "s os sai / wee ; ee eee eer 'anes en ip ae ne bok My an fra Lo ees vee ahd: . ee Re ¥ oe feta we ae tenth bon fad : oe ee a vane jen ween pat On oad oe taeos, BE : oe) Wap Bibs * ee Ge oe S8 " 'ride 7 en i " bs Bes ; ties fee. ; ee, ¢ ey, poad fae 5h gee soot a tages ° y m * a" cae Tet ce "
£2, nnn. aan ga Ra fone poe 4 ther beak jos a nee % pee et nb ra ies pty Kady nat oF, aed ps re pee AL Ss Lat gra Bs tet wanoe ; vanes ws nen en, ve fe x. oa a aoees : oe ae "het en, mn od oa ° fe os ry lat af th oes on Ws posed os) el oa BS ve wees: he GE 5 pee, pa eu ; as yu ng Don, wrest eae : Pes wen ee 2 phen box was yas we et eed a3 aad ee Sad wee novens jhe we ¥ Lawn os erin, on Prod back eee ron 0, need. oe ears xn ,somacd ps 3 Sess ood Fane Tess. Fat eed gon Rath ww & Ae boos yy vet yn, Manes « ; 9% eee fu wee ine Ti ee a ood " oe hoes:
Seto: cnene: ct ye. om oe and 4, a %. bes wee Le , Paves! 5 , Ley See, ceed oo. a ae ahy Meta, ye tl Peters tS tak Peannas es ey qeod. , Ss food na ~ a eb aod .
Ser so) a ay gener, ww ?; pod nares. 4 a a po pen be pa ts poe ek oot a : bit we Sa a4. it ae panes Pood ah poe im ah é es gh . isn S poked, Ae ¢ or aoe yo : itt os 3 ae a) hen Pos ee 3 Bere, rea poh GES ma ee ht " teh a, ess ne et. % oad oe cS ae ie : yee & Se io bead 'eg? tye a pan fed pe yor ord an 0, ee oa oe 2 pr wanes, oom ye wet ae Tos ot ey hed Co 3 bee hs Paget Ce sao Sas on, : Oe 3 hex as; Paccad ££ Fa] ens 'eit es a ors Lia Peal ad ' fs : fk Ks By ay Sd oA aed cane fen, paren wm eae, ee oD fas a 'at sheod pans feet ae is pond oe Thy os ond ie aaa et . ene Sened om, ri ee Bos at rie : anes Z Pa oe s ; Sent "3 one as "eit ws anes 5 rg hee oo i o 2 rae ceed oy ppages ses 44 ey 3 ne gee 4 fas pee) Sos 'emai? Lean howl moet Pagan &3 a ed ns Ry ros 1 ee peo Peles aed peiwte tines, hh hia! tae <a nang oo : onan as om rte ve ae meek ay a eee eae: £4 'ded als Sak iy oF os he noes, ra a, canes ered, Pa) een ¢ - oe Fae) re Pon tot ra OP Mele tah ea beter rm Sak peer atid ood aa) pad aya eae ti vos an he oe eins heat fo od pee. bees "oor ad pe oft boned 4 aed ised Econ) a road aoe ~_ heer oon oe Be t% oo ad yee aes! Pad Lom ooo pet ¥ en, oe gon * fy Yt fea fn, Pooes, mer bow oe wr 5 " pe sade a "heat! vx, oo 'nae Seca' e3 este ; bese Shot 7 OH poe " peohine f ' at fanz wine, yet es Fo ee 4 aad nen * isa es yon Wad Bs ts aes ae: 4 we es > pairs oe soa ae hee we Fs ' foe weed, w te me ees hx oon ae head oo Oey na ' Wee ees fom 4 , va Stans £5 ¢ "hp oh GPS aes te Ge : Raek Sn ae os fee % od , om pid ies, hat oy tag ' a do = wien Soke ee an w & " Seat pa Sot ed ugle ; sy ee hee ae Pag) pan "Se ; af ae poy, "G na "2 tot wee et meer pone ye sot at toh real woes were oh Res es on ; OS pion a3 on we a4 a "a % ra ene a i on vases pas 4 "nna * tad rae bas when sheet id a eG bead ae re in aot th ' a te awe eee ren Paes ey e Pana et are . ; ecb wens wees seest, " oe AS nnK ws Be on wore aenak read pa at oe, > a pes * sand "ae pon yer a aes on ' poe, pr SS yo is Pe aa ana ae % z "op "y fre shes * ran pre rm eee: wath z Prana ne Sad rs Laem me, Esa cig' huk ei re <= hee pe Be os nes ee Ve wat yer sates os ye pit cee SB wa
-- en pant oo 33 oe i " 'ase bed nas fen Fae oe ia bet aes ae ¥ 3 7 geek poe 74, ~ "ease Pte hee 'he rae ieee, ta ices ws " " ate, Cait ¢ pon < oon ead aS it ene faa aes "nat Cs ke at. a, pie, bo wa a' ee ere: Sot. wee: pee me wees ae teat 4 we fod nak re : paee pn a, ; heed oa Lot a Buk fics : ne é oe 'yee " te Ege ares f an oe ad a 'pte me on, ee ot nee ta Le ty Sad pod Bee ite age a ood on woes aes 2S boot ad & wey. gee ° wy F prac Paad ot pier) i peas, Loot oocad iat ae ap aS is Cat Bare ft : a, 2 5G es £3 se] « Bes wee, A :
4 Soe: * ae weed top Ni Kook ao" we pe Saat oo 28.
tad a neee, Hen ced fens ee as ts ES Po a4 oe ~~ fone ween 'panies ey aoa! es 6. < Res = ~, os . a ieee ae, beat sad ye we a Nae ee pa feos ad nd het es we asa a ores ion ye eon ead eh aan see aes ae Ft be ries oe thee hs oon hed : 3 , oe on wire pa) on ee, Ls -- 5 aes had: + ay ifs aS rere Pe Sat : Seat fo oa apeae Sipe 'nee ras bai y as oe , ee rope , 3 oben head ae, Nee "igh Fave, Le es ea, as ' post, : ° :
as my wee ane, Be ie leer' ade oy, es eet eo spt oe nat ye sae en ee sehen Seek ook < "a, seks at pow, te yor. on ae: a 656 sl wre oes ry ra a me 5 "al x jana , po booed Moris 'ben oa oy pes be 4 oe E "sien "48 a ee i Be fa is eS ie ea oo we % "os oo oS | $ wr, paged Pros tots we % eines lee oN * Sy net oy 'apt Page' m :
pent od ee ae me we is: : gt ae oat pe id ee wane ie bn oe, 'ee Pe 5 a. ews *: tit ein ot Ps as iS oa, hee, bac wa Feed Roo iatak ne nee. = '3 ee 2 23 sarees pan wn ae Don _. pe Te Se toed * see Ean Fees hed Bot pees aot es ora SS pee : Ay ge ce. ye oe dt tae my oe os be = ae oot ty me Ps. oon we oo case hoe cae tert ty - Ped aed oe p4 5 ae acd a 1, of nt os eas ao bags pest fen Ne, vs fn "che ie nen, es paar pear poe ty ee wee heed ee na races Ann eed pea to £3 ' we ~ ow dove ane pe ded ad ae) ve pas es peo oie ae lene aed Reed cae a. Are, lees leg ha y- at: poe y es Comore ie pes if: eet a ey Coe sae Poms bare poss ae a ad a anne boas eis pel & oad Pott ree waned, 1h fone gene , ee pore 'dak $ ier? on be. yon on te paee os aang! ety OS on Koad aaa pry wen toe Pane sed 43 a "ne eg % ' nen cata oe tee Foal hace nant 3 - Pag cadd , ¥ bo ars. Coan zr % Fong! "ood bad a3 ee pe oe oo PAA A Sees nant peu ahoee. fon i pa ae % Pon te ¢ z 2 ad re, o eee Fees * en, Bee yee Peed oes ee, wel fad nee, ip acon: so aed "pink rs ¥: wees ne: Bem re fe fay Sas ain on Pads a aes sted, ate? a) toe SA ne food cers on and " peer. wanes pn Snot tet cae es reer ws, AY ", one, rire Ay post . eat pa ty Nee, we:
sa oad ca the ead a4 ot ao "ane ie gen. 5 ad pans om geeee, Pd gen Fs IS hen ents a Peas! pars wot oe, bead heed z Rew fecal baod pena eet ome es peed ioe Sones oe pont pons ott 24 Mee # yee, ee ae a4 tee eed ee ~ anni, 3 ns weeds cafe on "nant aint ted as See. ree ; a) on wad 05 es pees "ae ny ie os be apd a 'aed? spite Lh veer aot oo és i) & Sree 23 loi e LS bee :
en, on nooks, oe ne x ree, a" Fond oe fees, sod? ea or See ths ta os anew i 43 Prag ¢ wea 0% z peen ira ne 2 ye a oe, ' 5 Cale ead Det ans 'ab hee pe we oe ' <n Pa Pies aes wus wet iad ot 4 = = se ae a3 a gn ey aa od oF. nen ft Fae) ses poo "noe pone nm Gs ; wee fh . * fon phon, pee es nan 3 'ah igs ae oo Ean ; Hee set! wy BA Soe re on vs on et er ape yong weer pn " lax] my " Ls deel wee eobind: ea Ne" - a 4 Nederk, to oe " ye ved, ey oe, wm , * ' feed on deed "Se inne, $e aa eeged: ey bert yer ee Cod beet Fea' a: vp et . we aed a bork a wien ded "yen poe mere ar aes 'nee aod ee i ws an o set a \ eed a3 pens bet ", rats eee eee gen i fea Laas pe. cones ree ect Saad et oue apes " re pa a pees a wee oo; * tan ae at' te, ve, ° Nee "aa? a tone oy pee peeked soenee e bam > Coaad 4 se whaay 4 y Bette, "hpn, ree ear ee Soh dade, 3 oot = rd deed ded Lf bead on wer nanens , wn as pee pa "ty etd ie pen, w eet pet hl , ras Cnet ne poner My oo fs toned, "swat . we a sa pon os to wave aes on rie Poa ras ware, pape aeeod ees gen ths own a bee i" Ey ~. a me sob aa ad ny a.
a esd . a3 ae we te om, 2, gs ge) even pad gt os he ay tat whens, woe ewes, " "et se ron co oes y cod eed pas net seek re LE oe tt a ere oe wpe eet baad bey re deed Se, rm ye te eaeny oad see tf on oe eas "4 a oni Eee ys Si od gy woe D4 pe 3 z pinot owe 53 a web ea Spe Pan wood vad t rw yee pears we ty Boat Steet A ren Dara " or ae we sort we anes ne
- on yee ov ae deed gen nd "yp Feed ns where eee AY tf: aaa sgl we wy ae tot he yen se Ne neneg 7 4 LA we, pan el rn. "at att "net 3 uN shee' £ oe ween 3 ts deed vat ote, pe, cenne. aad mat that ¥e tot "
Coed eae tn 2 oe few ye L: g ta, 7 ~, van sane, : hand nt pos oe, ben pire re oe aa t toa be a es pou by ry * ee. en . read a oA teak, bene re wees, toe, a few. ryt, od van « seat ' ee) 7 "eed by ee ' Peas eae . Elead pores, 3 Ly, © ws ¢ my fw. , ee " aorre ? agra, ' $ faa Paes chy ne age; ae nie dead ones ae pan : se ws ae wet Ay pe roag n pan a * cit f ed pon is we creed fey roa a x eek meres ie a vie ions on ce Fat a "beet se oy ope oe cea Th. " oo Sat pe on ed Lt wer ~ pe ~~ peeed pata bee:
: feud Par) a Fy Fa baal 'seat a ra' : awa Anh, th bay Jew af < Liew Geese peed, am ott we nike rece * a3 oh . * ~~ St pac ogy on feote om £ a) a4 Ss ~~ . oo Z "pee ", ; "ad eet, wae, badd wt 'oud on wey oa ret Oo we > aw - re cs wow Rk "eat a a Se tad wae, 'nal cS pie <4 Mts vat Pant : 4 d =, "
ty Te Led na it bon cod pe un bad s sca Pe gy ' es s o a, Psd A oe; aaa eel hs ow bebed erty pan dent Preaed paves, $5 boat . ae ht Tang ote ro) ree shod 2% ed det ae =a . me i, Le ee me BS 'ad Sp we ne ae 2 en ost oo bea a oa Ps "endet Sot ras . bork pen ange' eeeal e wren, g one la eed oes on an, hod oy "rod wos fone pees aac pas wok fond t aaa ea f eee, oe) pur) mae nerd, ves pore bod ass Pat t ery ohne "oe dod yt baad Pat te oe , nnd, soar or, amie r ey ww ry Secreta! . rt ieee cael pee fee, ae a) nes > en ans ayy Lae) NK ween eed. ed pan ae Ae oa Brod eh wot A :
ee es 43 + ws , ween vn at ¥ oa; es ben ay ; " oe eae, ont oe +e "ne and fone ben es . wes sages ore Pend ot wood fad . 4 weed pad oa ex tab es ran oe bed toad Saat 5 e eed ans 7 BY net ra ", > coy ore pe ' ~ oe ft seers pes om a, bens vies an ww 3 wa r re ey es eer, fe, eee Sod Ay po 3 4 ci Bad tae pier) shred wee me a a Rod iad 'sed ae bend > -- we , fin peed weno it 2 oy cu "nail eee 5 aaaed 4 ener i", By r wee peo x oe pas ee, 3 eas pon seineah srk Sow. . ener aa ay A os ry tip pes boty very o vet ae wee. ge é WV ore pon ig anes yee pared aad pet wee nee tone he ro yo podbe, a ae ifs oA ee Oy dane ¥ 4 a yon, wares des ae heed Sa fe 4 bet "eae! etal 4 bed re Paes ae ae a4 pan I Sone ~~ 43 ; oe a" pes oan sa on ae wee bas prs " aeok nadine ore on a re, vt Peoed SAR APTA LE REREAD ae "tet th ben en ei bee o a = A is nad a pad ered we Posh te. a phe cae at "ere teehee ons we gee ne - poe 3 y aos whee o Py, tp p64 a loool bood A pgs Ay AG we ante peat ce roe inline, an os ea wT ' oo, nes Bee 7 pana Hees vee oo sed 't eboek aes Saad ad wet, oe od Mien? yor wee exes eae ann, tee As eee "s oe "be phew ed yanet pa % whe ee Soo os th os, ON. nga os ne ae . ot pees shed es a Bees ea eae = asd os a ie) wen pe ae we woe, asa Sood. pn cic, id afoot Ant gow wood 3 pe wget Ke ia : me oe bis os Bae : * oe a : whee a eee eb oe teed a3 Sad pot wa ae, 37 Fan Ge eee oe Sud pe is eS Pd BE oe aes, pe fey et on aa DFS. nome Koon a The wed Sates boo. 'thet ek cad ES ra oe baw oe fed fan ats yee ee os, See oe hoced hon er bonged gn es nent pen bee ne ee cee oad 3 ' vo fa coe toe Fcar ecg! £0, Tad poh wee whe oa ocan oe par od
- re ae wea es or, z oh abi can gy at ; et E iS oe nh es Ay: aA. 4 Gar en. eat 4 Re itt eo a Bes cas ge d Sa os f% por is anaes a. snd oe :
cas ay pad poe inne ce 4 ine tad en ar ant Sok > pend mS te? based % fs penne nme en asd teed ee ot $3 seed on 45 e id on, ae ae : Set 23 whe ~ esd he ors oo ad we ere feats, vas ee a as pone ihe Side ise oo pone % ae oe wy ot posit ns; ea Te we gs panes ke Le peas nant on ae See a iss, ray 8. Sod : 'he, "r ont ie we ook iy x whee "es 'nt ~s es a pe rows a3 "3 bk deo. weles St pees Ses ia As Te nae " yon of eat ifs psa wes sheet rag ; eed oy A Sy a "nee aad wy ot Py sheet ' ree Ba ba oe Fag aS Ga creed oe) ee "na vie Gen SS joe Re o: bo: jor 3 GK . woe pe on acs feat oe Ly ee wae me Faas; on bee bend. Poeaad . Soa con peers la sed ope. i Deas ey we wy Lt Peni, 'aa ies % heed aed wee ess Be een pane oy Fea we me E * % oe a bo) woe at Ai per pani) a} ee) Be Toe poo "nel 2 ye +. met ey ae ea eae aaa ts, os, Peed * ; ren ee, ie ee teat Keer het: 7 aod 4 eo: Esa ae fav Sa jeg lead ¥ rad ty wa 0h oe pen * ek wn Rend pea wut vr ant 'a ba? OUD. 'ont Caaei oy, tarnd fe oe; eed a fa wer canal ane, ¢ ms 4 ws raees By one Rasy es ies va ote fe ma oe a ee os weet tows id baa w aS ceed aad an ia "ee oy gt oA oy oS oo - on 3 hp Lop abe 0 oe Snel: po fey wet Lacaed Sone Paes ba re bord Pad - i? ee "a aes, fn, and : peed Fa, bed faa i we Ay Soe ; hk oe 453 z 4a oe poe, SB eet Pos oe Sat 'gre . pens wines paws "hd oe "s A P peed iy as : werd ta z ce, : viens be ws het Aes pen Zook "A wie , man on a ot wo areed. es: inane ce sat oy wey Ka aeons Shes 3 Seat ot a S eee os, a tab imag aod ee ~ hy a3 Lf ee a) 263 "aes hot beni ae Le " a2 ohne ae ' hha Foe ita dee 'nae. tt. AY coca ne _ Pe nas , nanae 3.4 few ea aed . Pee' yea, Cet witty Fasc en ors Fad Cee oe hee Ay 4 Vine fs heed, geen = we a," Pat we yore 6 aaa st Paar tot . neon yen Ps Pos po speech yan teint tos whee Aes a wee, yee yee ee, * coed nee z wee x x ad oe <a ra text gn oe 4 Leh, Sf pa . 4 ' ee wees an wees noe nin pan Bs, ban tee on ee cod ff nes " ped ee : sod ie = vies oe bid We OF ' when ye at one gh vo as . bed s weed we a : = 700) weed $x xe hoa oes bys Led ae Ayes 3 ify tad wt - "on ae ted ee "a 4 esd fn we fove Are fet be bed oe = oye. ps revit wed . nen, on sere cad on oe = ae 4 hed reat an, aed eek be we My ocd me ra yok iad 2, Ge ners ease gee rey pon oe wet z poor ce oes C8 aa * ag es oA ew yea td Ps me wlowe ae wy pes we eA nee on Pan ty is aed sae meee es tor we a ant, "ne Fol heat noe pang ibe w iG hy a we asad re a alec Fm gen ay poord é pe le raed be te en wna tAe ti aed wee baa' oad 4 Pe % eed ae gen Food boot sheet at rod os rate! on Pi oaed Seca 3 an a bet whos a oe cd 'a ae x % " a3 ao me ry, patel ee. ed tent races "not ret ost Sena, nf cd seen ete rt, poo oa ibd yo tty pe, ey . aed o4s ens ee ped roe aon a os be SoA ree peed Lt Oe ao :
os, Don, fe heed. L% pone Hoek ene peed Praad £45 popes gn Band hens ay . in ae aie : oon gs iy : fa pan ;
. pee at eee os x on ~~ ap Beet ¢ tad Se Riss ae et eon, 3 7 ry a iced panies oy en pee By ae Sa fea wn Sat sa son wees, pe cone Dee Lee Nad nS oe? ay "sSoet yon pon 4 mere ee 3 : cron. ' neers: 3 ae ri a Ran pct wre ptt racic Ye ee ec? ol oe) th ye ant kd npee eee ened at Oa Peace * es "E5 coach eas ye q . % ra Pod a. cas ts; 3 5 5 oe, we ' ifs x bee 78 whore ie Mi. des het to i aaa BY, 2 Gp pees hed * 25 basaed bea a wen ret Fox apa re Sern was UD oo, ee tend of ed Are? stew orn eveey oe oo ea on oe 3k 7 z ke oes re yee ete we, et wah coed wanes ty £2 2% on, ws pn poo aod or aot, yoy & pond, seen ne cor ne Seal i : oad oor Bear Py g : aes poae Bee, oa' G3 "an? we we gS, eden reed Bee, fan fs beat ae tig bie! _ rast By besa whee hes a3 5 re, net a ve yee ne + Read pane dood. loos, oes hoot Poa a eae she on rn et, 0 he oe a ps oe Sos ee ib coud ae as & be pend seeee, shined aes toad tte ws a ot ws Bet wm, ie pee, oS es 'ew Paar me Et uM pees " ; wegen ee 'cal ee Scar? ? ees, omeee, %, Rat ng 3 Fs tf 7 ae oad oe me eo me m a oo, a a hy, 3 pon a cane oo™, aes we af beet a ey a boa om iigeee a os 43 pen ion 5.
see "at een Eaoaed Shae 3 as 2 "New Pig ene! ay ne pans > Kad YD nner a bag a : eae whe 4 fon:
Seed "cet Sin, p04 ~ a ye real est nes peed ye f bees nd Le Fost a) hoe bax Ome oe As ° woke, sce ou, Ua ee pond Sted foo ot gs we 'ad, eet cad By $5 'ink MS £3 oy Fake: ig Soong ee ces peer. Sand al in en pene om, Goa eee z soraad seees Sonal cooed oa] we, wen fen 'ni on Pie nee, se ed eat sot 3 pee Sid gee aN, ie Seca ant wee wre eat 3 ware! yrs we : an Po x Lp S24 eee pn oe yh Panel Pee, fone pane, fore os yond wey rae Faas' ines Nd 'deed a ne, nS) : we oe vet en ost Sst ods oe wo ae pn 's ae! ae neal pod eee cee Meee, et ne abcd: me ey pr Eee 3 ¢ aires tee ae oon et eet wen Sete ass aed " Se a fre yo epee, fh5 yee z alae et , ben, abe Senet Be oe pos os Len ov 'uae &, ms get athens iat fered, Dips few ye We bs yee in As sn we Nad ett sete wy 3 re government servant we San rseo, Bod , oo Wd peed 506} on .
$ $ 4 de wer, firanh the app art¢ B admission on the ey x
-
neniian, as repeated ee.
NS ¥ t Ve yard e :
hatin sac z ided ft ders int ee, wee ve oa ¥in the man e x ' Hy He te be £ iN & pportunity is availa oS, ATE O uke ew, are, peed hs ie Pann] Wen pes we a es & mrt Seek AEP Pe Fy hus heer e when h wegen, CETTE TH ELE So = "
AWS x & &
-
for ef ta Oeil addy bekk € tin § poed, Him "
SEER shinent am Or & oN 2 pol gE CH TYCE "
cos % AB we.20z2 i .< rs ard act of MUN <3 eneral al Pradeep Kumar and Anr. Vs. Post Master &
-sustainable as with ti & by Phe awrany es Aes:
.
HTN) sh "RR 2616 disposed of an OF.
id b s yposing reading be:
cate eee 3 cs es rt OF respondents war N oa he stated that an < EER Sukom hee »} ie penn No. 4, im connivance or at the behest of Rukhsana. We begin by noting that M.K. Singh is not a third per: Son "put an officer and an employee af the Post Dffice. Post Office, as an abstract entity, functions through its employees, Employees, as individuals, are capable of being dishonest and commilting acts of fraud or wrongs themselves or in colhisien with others. Such acts of har epost office employees, when cone ch uring their course af ermmloyment, are dinding on the bank/post office at instance of the Js re ed by t the fraud and > Such acts ry rhe omple Oy mei at wi at :
process nur way GA aly vemety aps aint t the pest affice, Thus, the tke a bank, can and is entitied i proceed against the officers for the lass caused cue to the frauc ete, but this weald net absolve ther: from their Habil a i See Pup ne & Nati onal Banik vy, Smit Dur > ine Del oS employes invol mM In nthe course of his sniployment and duties.
;
ved was acting x Se. This Court in State Bank of India (Successar to the Imperial Bank of India} wo Smt. Shyama Devigi held that for the employer to be flable, it is not enough that the employment forded the servant or agent an opportunity of commiting the 'Ime, but what is relevant is whether the crime, in the form of fraud ete, WAS perpetrated ly the serva nt/ employ yee during the course of his employment. Once tis fs establishe al, thes employer would be Rable for the ermployee's wrongful act, even if they amount te a erime. WW nether the frauck is committed dur ing the course of employment would be a question of fact that nee nals to be determined in the facts and circumstances of che ¢ nase."
a ifis seen that the decision reached by this Tribunal in the case a Bag was without taking inte consideration the decisic CA No SEAMED peal referred to above. Hence, the said decision in the facts and circumstances ofthe case is not applicable to the present case, Ras ween OS OE ee Ca Ce ee fe ae ee esey : hoy x my ety Ebay eee In so far as not granting personal hearing by the Appellate Authority mre passing the order is concerned, no such procedure is provided in the Rules ard the authority concerned is under ob Higation to grant such personal hearing. This apart, it is noticed that has not sought al hearing in his appeal.
x hn by the learned counsel for the applicant in through the decisions relied o ths respect and find that thase deelsions have ne appli of the present case.
1 Reale TLGH) of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 provides for recovery from pay of the whole or part of any pecuniary loss caused by him to the his worthwhile to note Government by negligence or bre that hard-earned money of pour citizens and taxpayers cannot be allowed ty be defrauded due to failure to discharge the onerous duty iy the employee concerned, who is supposed to bse responsible and to see that BY there is no Misappropriation and fraud is committed by any Individuals.
in the Instant case, the applicant was not charge sheeted for comm keting i i ¢ y i z enettat dt dase ra ed nine Pron) a, Soe byt ot tes asa oy eal how Ret es oe ye Sod Mlacad ond ay ey, dant sme Slama road rst . et Kina pan baa went eo te, th) Faas sre ft Peoad eee 'eee ek v4 or, es See Chae ae naoes, +o iS Bot 'he oa ren a Li des 2 eee wee we ban, "ew to aS aed. ant foe ot rans oe sass oe ho : ne reree, 3 rer. the "net entity pent on os pan "nat by the sa as BS ae bet mm bee 5 ok oe ed ws we eM A te Poeast fea, eee, oe oes oe re vo we ; pent Lk wa bt 'es aft. eeat' ' et as 4 - warn ry ne Se, ee meoee hove me od nbd teat vee pad pete Cat weeds hoe Ped tend CS 7 tae ae 'ans oa oper fe gS ews nee, pane Tee : we a os oe * re, yet ae om rs f fest reeee cai OS er end ik ees z _ wt Pas yen ry peret * Coe rman ast the tad hans: Sood Ee ers ny on por Pa oa rae Focal Ay 4 : ad Po woe canes Sat pee ~ Soo s At a as pas : e oy we oad dad ? wad ae) aa a a cr tek fsa need roped om op 5 aes es Ew me ad oes oe Seah cece net roe' ede 4 $23 Pas pee wet £3 te need a ns joo wed bows Z sheen 4 es ay ape, os a ed i ae Ee ty i) ae aso coon ; jas 3? w Ae i " <.
oe oe te ed ty 2 z tet Aone sees te ion we oo "a i we z a Sood. ts eee honk et ted As ad wey G3 Fax ana wat wet, ret ms, She : pod eng p a Ne raat Sew 'ent aad ad a, py , Manes pan 3 . ene Pann Pegs bn 'sa fs oo. sew a ot <= wea S ts om "oa bacon bes det oe pie see, howd oo > bien 'i 'aint! ya $ex vv : rere ae x ent wee ", oyen x me lew ape ey ever, we ; wr 6 y ees peed one, Les we vad Sig shed ae alt an ay ry pen at oot > a Bees my sak werd os a om Fons "aes mm ser; ed ext oe Sed rer on fant gon x en i iy ° a hed es ant we ded on pee ant "oe ~~ mm veved meted 3 ooh oeters eee Fas ae , Patan on ape, yre "e £3 7 mo oe log oy, on wed, oes ened neces aad z yen oe at bed a wees wre Saat fon ws wd re Faag acd wk re nee ee oo o my x wat AG wees io ? aa eee oes 'et As % at a fy ong, wey a - ae Se ae a ye he Pat 4 ' et ed " wee wd pod om * a at pan ix aed, eo enped we Tet : ot " S 'sat he " poe we y . . Sent res head ate deed 4 Z tind ord on, aon ad wee 4 Z ied 2% LS ner ew, 53 g oo A te bat eo pas ti hock g prt, be ras ad ? pa oi pice YZ oe 4 lat Eee som pa pas wanes wet, Kent pan sored, Tho peers ws te mm fet on dred sreed : cad net 'A ee ny, card bod Peed 'mt * yer oe oy, peeen aaa pond ees Tene iw ay Sue an iz io meee o ino "ht % ae we ee vm ot lew yen al opal nen Fae pee Saal eet real when eenns teed eee tne, ». a pane teed wee fr, j ag?! Pt "oy, Io mt os oe a a cen feet man aw one head on ma 4 work God ne we . wonk oe Od ; yon oA ry at L pa pad open, rare, ven, i ie 3 a oe 43 roa oo Z 'f % < yor peor a pared a ey st oo a8 wee ine ab oe ams on . en a wieet ped ren ea 'au! at a ioe re aad 'a oad * ote, " vo 7 aso, a io eae x Cane Ieee of deed ae on " pe - a wey acs nk 'nee? am) vee eee a] shoot fee coe, - on Fasc ¥ mr oe ee peed pa Pa Z ed 2 as thet hw. @ 2 ere ind re hee, bed penn ed Lae od "a fee if Neer % en "aes ret on See pet band tg See ot oe ae pa OG os te: a eee, aia rn, bed a ane ool ree, ora vet Z bet nea as tiie tin a ee os rs oo 2 a oa ~ a . ne 5 % i , eo at pete one tna "spud, at id eel ? ~ pon oe noon v4 were pas rere al am 4 £ et Men oe ae wire "a a7 # "
Ande n paca' vi set « n a he? = fea me el spd ont A ae
- : = i x o ce x ~ "re wee, ten, a wey neds gore, " i. ayes v7 aed ons aw ren ceeed ant dt gee justice oF in violstion of the stabutery rules prescribing the mode | anquiry or where the comchision ar Gnding reached by the disciplinary authority is based on no evidence. If che conclusic wed:
es es yon vad.
et.
~ "oe cee fon Set pn paved wee et n eek we yt oy ee.
fe nang ce tee:
z oP, a * rin z 7 eae pees og ¢ ce ie pains a ¥.
aN wa So s peeves ned op, pees Lt iy tae Ky reasonable Persea 8 conclusians upon consideration af the evidence reached by the disciplinary authority is perverse or suffers from patent erraron the face of recarrd or based on no evidence at all judicial interference is warranted. To sum up, the scape of judicial reyiew canmet be extended fo the examination of correctness or reasonableness ofa decision af authority as a matter af fact. Pr itther, rat is well settled that the Court and Tribunalin exercising its jurisdiction of gohy ete < arsee akc we % SS Sho. Shey oltidexsre 2 SORES: artes ek ae dias fudicial review would not interfere with the findings of fact arrived atin BS the departmental enquiry perversity, he where there lan evidence fo support a Anding ar wheres @ wk finding Is such that no man acting have arrived at that findings ara] so isng as there is same avidence to support the conclusion arrived at by the departmental authoriby, the same has fo be sustained (Deputy General Manager .. vs Alal Komar Srivastava, (2021) 2 SCC G12. No such case has been made o ee ee ip.
'agit aa at oe.
feage we t% CEH HEHE g ;\vl°5 '"™hblh®hkhlil.
ory "ees me Feng) Sn, = re.
a on ae ey, y . PGunase a Vs i af ind a EQ vu een pl Se ave | x tis rere r OuUPt Cart Oy eh oe?
alee x £ "ty see whether LaVe § § N i x Sreree elias ei he av ' ays ced rey wk FLEE iE fo be in ¥es t 3 3 $ u EEN, OF % at at ee ue COECU % 3 t > a eae iva "
ever he e 3 q x i x "SOMA OOD BE 7s re se Ny ME ff that no regsoral Os on, ted. a twee 'ue nd <oget oe wert;
me, St Behn. "tad as Ce pet ted LD 3 % Cad enced Sad Pond ee, Sooned Coad me sont BON s va, Un adi 2 % akury .t. C8 9 pines.
eet.
asses, pos "0 oe & we, whe %.
¥ << wy a 3 cae oe