Karnataka High Court
The Commr Of Income Tax vs M/S Anand Technology Resource on 30 August, 2011
Bench: N.Kumar, Ravi Malimath
ms TEE EEGH swarm' GE rigflmzragm 3:1' gmggigagg §.L§:1:<t{i i§":§se; 'i.he {€22}? <3? :f'::,:§__;»;*a.::%'L 2{T$:'}."'E V' H z4>:2_:s:S§::2«srV:*M $33 EiQN"Bi,,$ MR, ;US*r:;C?E,:s: mmm * V ' 'mE ;»m§m:,E .:§i;-gf §{§$'5i'§CE} gifizysgwfi _ :I§:i':'*§g'_§_3-_:.:~2:. "
* E. C__{.m1.:T§'2§é5:'s;%.::=sri:{>z° GE' §:':s:'%::m'?:e:: '§'a.>«;.
r _ E'€-§2~m§§;;I:E:";2:*:::
.. ?~» EEEEE C. Es. E?i%:.:iEsf%§';':;.;
§;,s:..2.€3£:z":5.:~3 .%.'%:<>a-ziié 3 '§"h::% §1"i.«::mm:% TEZLX (§£"fi<:m' ._ i3:':{'§}{i§§ ?yE:2§§.:§>2;:i K.'z5':;::}'2e}fi2-12'2i.$'-
€33}-' Sri. EVE 5r3§:és;§':2§<?E':a1§;:2.. §;:§x><.>{éai{*:é-' ANS:
E"v'i,/ Ei:'12'i:'1£i'§ 'ft=.C§3§':{3§<3g;}* E€:25s<31.'::"<.7§':
P'2::rk. E3**<:'i;; E.,i.{§., E'\§{}'8§§,/'y L §{:,:':';':E3:-.:E;;<3<i Engii. Eazzvga _ E*E':z::::-.»;e--'§§g ?%/S;-'ss{3:"<% R{3z:{"§ ' _ . ._ E§2:::'z§,§21k§1"éé --- $6?) {}?c'E-- V' "(._f1'{{é:e:§3}{3;'iv;§é2m {E-fi§,:* $1'? 55%*'E?'g1:"iE':a1.:4:éfé:'2;::E1%. giwziéa This; E'§.'2'-1 Eiéeaf E,H"i§{'.:f"-SEt£fi?If§*{Z§fl sf" iii". fifiii. E361 2':fi:'~:aE:1g; em. 31' {}:'ds':'r __*;f§_V£?3'.i.%:_j<:§ V __2E1<'i«£*'3%g2'{§:;§i'i"é--*' pa§=:§;s:<E in E'E15: §j'%k3.§:}?5/ §'32£.':T:<? 1' '7E%I}{J'%.§i :E'o:" thcé ' €?E3S.ZE}.é'T'§iE§, jgsizzs" 19E};5?--§§*§.
§i:»r2?z.::i:"2§_§ is {E} i'{.*2:"::E;;.:.VEé1§€&:"':'§':::i :>;'z;"f:':3ss5'€'2;:.1.:;§..2'~3;'?.V.£gu€s2t§{3:':§; ('2? Saw: ;"§E1§€5'.€§ é.§'1t3:;'<;éi;;'§; {;£§}:.z{§§'{:3a: ~-"%;:7E'z';€;* '2*:§._:{;:3_§:éi1-1%.. z3.:fé{i~.f .2715-:§a:ie:% E233 ééyzkiéz' ;3a1:s:sa;<:%{,¥_ by {E36 E"§"':'-'¥E_' 5%: __ 2 £'E7L/.-'~;. §"»§<§;'E4~?5j'E§a:1;;§,f2!f}@3 {is-;é.€=.:'§ 28--}{}--2ji}{15_ ..;:f§<jr'1§11;>::"__ 'i.§?:%;:._V_H_(7»%{§e:' of '£..Ei1.@ z7%p§}€é§§;zi.é: {:(}§'i'1§E'?iv§5,,§{)§'§'€5§ «§i§"§{§ {f,§I}E';f_E:'T{".1'}éiTi: file? {T.é'§'€Z'§€?E"° <33' 2?:&3ss;z3,5::£s:3'1:;%:'":'E,° ~. ?&a§pa$2$s§2§@5_M. _____ gmwm [psi .
' "1 ' g -.
,,:.A . «.
35; ii} $5 ""_«'E'.':"y3: §}é2:::=%...:£,}; {7i:.>:'m";:§s%:<;§m'2é::r <3? §:':.<.:<;2:"1';€:~ '§'2'-i:><: " {i§§:'<'?.§s:% 2% E:
CR&mmm %"
. _ {:(§I'E.}»1.§~'3s;:iS.':s=E§{}E'.2{??E" §:mé"§~' :.i<_>;_:_'} E if zxfic ' §;}E1{;*éEEi1§45 E'€<'}2-id §3;{lE'E§;'é.i§{3Z"€:?
.3 ';E'Z3a% E::<.>s.>.:'"z1<* "E"a.><.: {7)f."§'i<"*<?:' ' K v. _ . , i2:{1.§{.1}g 33%;:-;%;;;1§ ,,,A;':»;f:_:?.i-2;1z':; --
{E-3}? -Erézé M 'if' E§::?::;§'1;2s:T: f:;1E:i;.,..zf'fx(.§ !<:}<j;:éfé;?E " » .
:5'>;i'* E23? ,5 ;'"mz~.m.<§ '.Fc:{'t1"1:'1.c:E<>gj; E%{€<s3s:.>Lz'z*<'t's>.._ E-'3;au"§-z: }~}vE_, IKE', §'€<}.86;' L §{.:.z:'z'2E321§§g::>{i imfl. Amzi §1'E*32215se»E1;. :'\!§'j,I$G§:% E5%:i2az{"3 Z & E§'§2::3:13g:--t:kj};"€ ~~ 5%) {W4 V '_ V . " fE~Vi€:---:-f>«.SA.§'.j{.§§"}.{'.:§g;:EEA(§_éi-:
{iii}: &':%r:'. E} IT??;:2.2"f',€.§'1--21ss:*m::r:E'1.:i".';z?s.<ii?<; 2-;{E<¢:{E 'ms 'i"_E.7A 'iii -as:1s§.e»:*-.'ss.e;-éi':<m} gzgmx ms' :3: m::;;.; M»? .1 z3..:f:§s§;1E:";;§ .~i}{I§'E €:§fi.:z'%;~3§." "-.ri:i:'s'i::*:i "2;é1%¥§€3««2{}{}5 ;'}2z::~;:.=:;<;%(§ is': §'1'z'*: N52.1;.<3:7é§/Zi%z1u;1gfie%QQi§';«_ i':'rf} §' 7.f'E';t?> _' £Ksss;c*$:'~s::';{%:'1i §-'€:*,*.2-f£.§' £'é}§7}€%~S-3&1?' §.}:'2;1§£:'1g ':3 {E} §':';:';':'1V;:§;:f"a;% "ihic. _s=,::§j:$i..a::.:':'E§e%E £§t..1€s'ei'i<_>s'.3;$ 0? 32213; S*:.21%"€{E ih<i::fe*i.:'";; {i'i.E_ é:§aEi<:>v;' -.:..Ei1<:. '2:§3':: a.§ 2:;:'1<E s:.;<;?t': zwsiziér ihe <.>r<:§€:r §}£§i.§:'éS€'.€.§ E3}? 'iher-3': %'§':%'§T §E.2:n;_§;1E<;%2.fs:§ §.'§Z»'7'; NU, g4§7?€3;'E§§21:'1g;?;"2f}{§*f§ d2é.£§-:{'§ 28"" 20; 1?,-%f.3{}£§ u{'.rs::'1f£'< "':':3i:::_§_g :':§'"z::=. €::z'€.ie:1>:* {:25 5,33%: E%;;:>;:eé;*§.%a7;'é.9 LA ii": <:srd{5::° as? ;':s§se;a:-:<s:~.;:'n:==::'2.:n W ;§:;.j_';€:.,::%:§§f5; ..
s"::;::&£;«e;
'E2? {T<5;é:":s.::'2.3§s:sssiz.::":<%:* {sf Ez"2<.:z'::z'm,= F §<i§:':;;§ . E{<::;«t:{'i ':._(":«n',':
[MN ;,,:_1\{m\;A# \ J "' ' W r .A »---$ ' = ,.....o' " :_ J'»», m "ES es»? tbs: :=;:.2:;ié .'§z:§2m fig eliggibiis fa}; b§}:$iZ1%3"$S 3ff'iXE}€3E1€§1§§'.?;1:§:i'-".:é{'§.?§§;3<§'§}.' fiézcéimz Efiiiiéiéfié 3:" the §'§.{E§L. Q, in éhiza {'€}§':E'E€&i',iI§{}§"E it is us€§%;:?3;{s' «:féfs:.r is}. ';_i*:é__;t,:a%'gfr3€3:;V§ {;f the ziagex Cam'? in {he {:as& 9f {SF TAX 2.25 mmymm PLaNiTA3'I§J2?._"S z:z$g:*E:§{g1 ?9:$'4;5;{3 ;2'R" ' 248}, aarhare: the pézmse ij-"far t3z;e:~~-g.%.i§rpE:#s;e af %§mbu$iness" :3:
Bastien £G{2}€Xv} sf £22 'ar€;L3§¥; §:%3rfl{i:§§;:5sf:fi»:%rati@:z1. The Apfix Cieurt hem as :,:2":§_§}é':*.__: » H L' {?}eJ§}VIié3SEF,{{}?"?: '_'";'?:}r 3153 purpese Q?' 5339 E32V§:;~'~;:':':z"V:T«v<3?$[:~;':*% ;;;:,* SCO;".%éV E)§?.§i?7£ {he £?X§*§"'€SS§§:'"£ 'fffirj iTE*2§_3* "C§;!';fi '€§é§'§§i{fg _g3;'"Q;"'zit',s its range is w:'deE* _zf,§'" :;§';oig;_ E205' eniy 332$ day :3 éagg ;;'*a;::;"aing.V{g§". Q;Vb:'i,3:i:%,é5;s:; E:s:.a§: aisa E318 s*aEié'.0naEiza2fz'0?: of , a5i§r:§:1é;%Vi%5z'§:£:§?'z and §"E'2{}d.€3}"?2.€ZCi§.'if}E"£ e::j" as ._:?';a_¢§2£§2é%g:___ ézi. :3':a;; inciudae nzszagzamg far 51%: sf §f§'E€ Emsirzess a::"2dj'7ar {fie yraigésiian A {;;'"'.~£§'.§'4j':2§$"sar_*§:,sr magi §§¥°€}§3é3Tfi§.;' f§"€%§?3; e,3§a:r0§:":e2i:é8:::, e:;e;§*;%i§;e pgwcgagg gr asgerzém, Q3' 3:935:39 i'§'§:§18; if; may ' _Qi§$ Camymhersai §;3£igz'§?§éf§'§{ of $§:az'::§';az"§; filzgeg arzzi
--=§'5§x£3§; s':?2§;a3€3e£ cm 5: ;3r53~{:<:sna§f§:§a§: £18 {:<';n":.me=*2*2{rs'3 3?
jar {?&§'§""§;i3°'§§ we. zgf :5; §;z:4gs::z?:e::§$: :5": ariacgg {f§3'n§z§"'€§i£€§'§.di "3 2 E2 33;; {£26 {2f.3~?;€S€;'j~§5~§{;?{-;? 2:23 (2 $z{::u§<;:.r";; czgmzi 52:: tf§s;{'f§2&2;fign:* ' ii? $:(2{z.s£<4>?";; 5:51.: 5;; z£.z'z<f<}I2:':séz:;~§z=?{1i z4z,>'if'f':. z"'E'z.{:? §2_3.:is;§.z'zé}f$§ :!'z.z:;zz§;iz i"?2«:.> <;<7<:'<zs2':'m jE:;»:* zzf-'25? z'.:72pc:>,s,f:'zi:5--;2«2.';: f_}:,%<':{.;2.§:5-;e? a;}_,!" 54%;' :.er'rif.{):'i(.a.E. f"2{'l'.v'§;';i.'iA;'::¥s: f;§;?E}Itf_e%:i' 2:25,'-z;7z'{.§a9¥'z{ <33" 2'i'.s'; 03:>f,r'2;:,: E2zzs£1.9i':3;s;;<§..A_A T 532. _ {ha-%re;;'?:.;ra.: ??.{')f£5 i"?'ze:2E é!'2.a* e':<~f.{:izf£? "5E.z.:{:';; 95525/z:V€v:;?' §;§g;.,,§i::§:..3 ?'{;.'S{}{,'2§'ld£:':'?Z{" was ':"E.€}{ 52:2': {zE'V1féi,3:§§:t;.;?'2Zse-? €€{3:i.?.5{%:.€:.§'%'2. :.§:§z€im* 5§éi'€?5'?€3!'? .3 {3{53}{L'<':.."<} €3_,?7 ?T'§f:.é-? z"%.<:A£;"'i'i2':;{}:i::';é§z:;er s'f'2%?:'§z.ge;%'$ai'z':é:£ in {.336 s'zae§gcz£"iz:é?. jlfiiis; £>?';€'§§i?I5; {3j"'@3553?! {?0m'§ £5; z;sm:z.§; :i:i:"2::£ :5 sgaz. :fz$.€.<fg';%fi V . V V. 1%}. '_:'::;g:;"~T; {:f::m*:._ :::z;_*é.}~«'g_'<:: €33: 353$ vs sagimzzagiayg-R fig '§§§7Cf}2ifE '§:'z9:?g; 323 gm 249; E':e§.::§ ems :.:§:1::§é ;'v2 ': ' ' V ' h §_f:'i.s1_.§r'«§é%{7:€:>;*z 3{3?{';',:'{i:'§J Q?" gm-,> .{'-'flag-TIE; 2'; 58 ,._§:§Z?f}§.*.?'E.::?{fé?$S'eZF_%T;§;v E.?'2.fi§? 53%;'? i',i£='§§.§£?£§?S=:-?{:' :'3:.::§;;:.' §'2.e:i;.:.:{? z,as;ae:Z §'%€é" E%:V§.zA:S';';'zaa;s:s; fez}? {§{)§?'2§§ §';z4:si:3a=%:;$ :2: 3.326 3 " 'zféE~:}%<:,2.z'::'.§. ._§a:1=ff<:3:gzz.§.ir'£§; ggew"; fI§'E.€? ;s;}<,?i'z{Eizz§,5 53;" {4*C;;;§§.a§ 'H ;.>z.i.:"g3<}:;{'?.<a: <3?" 5z€:»::g:.:é:af§.§::§?'3. £53" E3:.:::§:'[:g¢;¢;$ '-'%:'e:§£;v ' {T'If§£.}"'i§'"£§} §"'§'2.a:% §'~€f§{'f2..?{T;£§"2§ :fT£.{f{'7€_}Z§§E?,f?'Z§§ ggyzgzz' $§':gfl{'fi.z4%§e?:'::, __,?'<:ez' 552:6 §?2"£§.§§§.£'?'?'i{:'2ii. 5.53 Em-? €}.?éE?{'§£.i.{f7§§{}E§ «:3?
V "§:"2{'s3:'c:'75;§ ;:;:t::f§€ s.z.5'::i§€:" :'§ce:.'§i{}:':. §§a':§{'§§Eéi§§ <);_§"E§'z§;> g%.:::§.;