Karnataka High Court
The State Of Karnataka vs Smt Nasseen Fathima on 6 February, 2012
Author: V.Jagannathan
Bench: V.Jagannathan
E1'? 'TEES EIGH C3153? GE' Ké%.R'é\E.ATAE<lz'"i 4%'? SE32? Eated the 5?" day sf F€bF'£Eé11°§7 2322......' ~ :BEF$RE: %' fi0NE§£mmR@Es?Kx§avgA§A§§Ai§g&*[ = "
REvHmvpEHTK»w§;565}2a::* ( 2:2. w.P.Nos. 2OQ3'?'«§G cm? 28Q88~1«{}fJ'j 2253V5;é:§i;':Lz<3i*§3§= BET"s¥EEN :
E. W The State ef Karnataka. _ rapt. by its PrinCi'§;3_.1 S€:::if€:t;a.éf;:. Yeuth Services Departrgxexiyg [ AA EvE.8.Bui}éing. Banga1Q:"5,""
The Bir<:€i'<:2.:f,"_'. 1. V _ _ SpGris4_.&'., YG{j:§::*£;_E1 Sérvices _D$-p52;'éi':%i€:}i. Sp<>rt5§ A1:'th'éfi4;:.§: e*)'§.'fI"£.3v§:':1 $;.té:i:;ez.' V Ka_n§€e'=ra.§k*3'.:§3Vta<fi -fjcrggpieég E§.é;sté:f'i>:gI B'a:figa1G:':éf' V The'; CQ:nmis«.é£Lc>:é'€:: 'G§ Ysuth S€1"ViC€ aaé Sparés. §ep3ai::n€::'i;-- 8:"§3i;é€:or Gsneral, Sporifi 91$: ih<:i:*i€y_ 0f"'Ka:°nata§:a;.
" ._§§{anis€§*95¢-a_VStadj::::':: Cempiex.
-- 'éiagiurba RG3;"£i;';'EB3.r1ga§0re. T " 'i"§'{3:§ré:V:*.zi'i§:Vg -- Ceuncié " zfigsi Eiregiier,
-- ' Vfipgrisj-.,?fi:iherity sf Kargaiaiia. E<:a;sj:.té':é:'3§Ja Siaéézim 'Cem§§€X. E§la§:%;u§'§a Reaé, B3.nga%0r€. . . .?5tiii0::€:'$ 83? SEE E§.}v€.§'{a§a:"aj. Add} édvgcats Genaraé. E _5%_ND:
Ex Ex) has.) Sm%;§:\?a$s€e:: Fsgthémag zixgfici 5% y€3;z's, D/0 Sysd; ESSQKEL Werking as Firsi; Division As$is'u:3.::i_ Sports Auiharity sf Karnatakafi _ Sr: Kanteerava Spgrts C0mpE:e:»g:,-, A Bangaicsres 1 " ' Smtfifédavathi, , _ Aged 49 years, V D 1 Q Lats B.G.Jayaram aCh::_:ya§ Wgyking as First £}ivisiQI1":'§S:4:.is'%:a:3:, Spams Authority :3_f"'}{ar--§1a*§a.}§§z:, % Sri Kantaerava Spéffs' Cs;'s.;':*:p§€:<];.. --
Bangalere ' "
Sr: Na:aj_;*a1i;;;TM} L * Aged. éféfé 3}sate;-;:--_VS;"Q--E§'11;§;icE9.pp5,?_ » Vx?er1:'1ng :'§:S;fS€Cb1:d"fiiiziésiifirx Assistant, Spams». ;5;':j;th'«:i¢:§i*:y 'Ka1*na€3.ka?
Sgji Kavnieé:a._Va.Sp.Qfi;s Cisjgnpiex, Beingale:'s_ "
Sr}: Lé;Eé:Sh::ii:r§a1*ag%;:::;R., Agessi; 4&3 :ge;a1:r'$g :3 Rajagspaig a5""$sf%_{:_<3::§ Déafigian §;.ss;':ss'{&n'{? _ Sp"':>:':*:S' ziguihariy of Karaaiaka, " ~ Sr':.,4§<:a;:1.i:ée--€av:: Sparta Cgmgiéxé ]'8a;:'é;g§:ig::f€.~"' A ,?;,0féA:i $3 zxgsra, 8 523+ '§a,r'iZ?:asaratE:y$ Ei; K".
AA ; '--?%fJ<3r%x:i:':g as Szfzivar
6. V' ' - -Spergs £1;€:E:§§§€§; cf Karnaiaka Sri Eiaxzteezraisg. S-Epsrts Cempiexé Bangaéera SE3 Saffiiaagfz €§§E;§éE"&, Agéd E32 j§;€a;:$., :33:/3 Shsgéia ?S%1§':':§;, «M3
8. V2/'§rki§g as Driver, $po:*t:s Auéhszity Sf Kgrigaiaiiau Sri Kanéeérava Sgsarés Cgmfiex, Barzgaiers 8:": Krishna.A.$ ikged 42 years? S/0 Lais Appayegjdy, Worlflng as Briver, ; " ._ « Sports Authcsrity of Kafnataka, . A Sri Ka:1E€erava Sparts Compléx, Baagaloré "
Sr: Salsem Pa8ha__, Aged 42 yfiara S --
'-Afsrking as DFEVQE ' ' S;::eri:$ Authsriiy Qf Sr: Kante€3'a:{a S§3'é:**:sV.C§:11}§I§x,'~ «.
B3.1'1ga}0:"e .
Sri CE:a:12§:'aShsé:§':;'j'.--,_ "
Ag€:+:_i4Ei S: Xi'; a.ppa,5'NaiE:, V~f0§Z£if:g.§ajS Dxjijifi/:?r';*._ ' . Sporéis z--'s1:*:iife:;§it;§ :CxfT_Kar11ataka.§ Sri' Kamteerexgg' Spefts «iiiempiex, Bafigfaiérg V' ' "
.. "E:'~»h3.nVk:::aq ' A " Ages} 4;? jy*&a:S;WS/Q Javaraiaé/1, .3/'§.§f§§§';:§"'a_s Czmup B Emyéeyee,
- Sp;ff:'£$ A;:1E%20:°§'{y of Karnaiaka, '=»S:"°i §§§é.L;¢s:'A?§:aéra:7a Sparta Comgiex, __ Ba;»:;g.93}:;:'€ S3':§§,aE{$h:'::ina:ra}Ian'§.$.é » afigfafi 4} §?€33"S, S,/0 Siddagsjga, " -- . fiferififig as 3sX£3§i«:_€:; Sggyig Aaéhsrétgi af §{arna.§ai:a? 81% Kantasrazfa Spgrés Campisxk Sanggiam
-V :6;
Smé;K1'isE:na Kagmari, Ageé £4 yaars, D/0 Sr: "x7€nE«:@§§ Rae}, 'v'v'o:*}§ing as Marksn Spazrts A2L:§10riiy aaf Karnatakaa Sm'; Kantesrrava Spcrig Compiex; Bazrigalers Sri Shabir Pshmsd, Aggd 3:6 years, S/0 Mahamevdé 1s:;fr:T:«~;?;}, '= 1 ' V é Workizzg as Marker; V 8/0 the Assistant Direétezfg V V _ Dept. Q? Yeuih Ssrvicés é;::d=§par:7s,,_ Efieharu Stadium, Bids}: ' "
Sri §vEadar.M.R., _ Aged 4-8 years, S/0 §:f..1i.dYf':1§}"§a,._ 9' Werking as.VMarker-,'--v. . _ ' A ' V O/O the:$'::<s;i:~;ta::i_: D:r,éCi:arE:~f_~~. Youth S€rvi=f§és1 anfi _S-ggarijg '§>€pi.' R. N . s:~;e:~:;;-- VSf:é;a*:i:;fi:';.':
Sr:' B'aiu,"E3,, '*3: " _ Q _ v .__ Agéd abcjut é%*5*§zé31f1s*~,.._ Efiferlégzg as'Gyi3::3a3S*:.£<: Ceachg Sp0rts"'Ea.Li':h Qiffiityref 'fiarnatakag ,_§§€p%f. cf ?:3:._1;:h Sefrviceg 5i Spsftsg
- £';%:.'a:::uA::di 'v'i1*é'3;r' S1:a<jiu::2, E/Ey;~ss3:e~E@§ . _Gvf¥£:;i2:--3_1 L ?%1*% Crass, g€':3_}:;5a,_fvt:§}33:€;;1;:°a R3351, K.R.Moh3;11a§ '~E§§'§}?g3:€-f€"E%Z?G 995; :'f'j::i' §é'}£§13a§h.§§.L» Sg'7<:3 :Lakshm&§ap§aj2!§aS.. .. AA figfid 48 yeais, Khaufiho $5 Kaéaédi Coaiih, " _.f'7:5§3<:2ris f§_il€:¥:G}"if}" {if E§a:':n.ataka§ fiapi. gf 'Esézéh Sszrvices anfi Spszwisg, Shamurséé Efihaz" Stafiiumg E'a:Eyse3r€- 3%, 81% Din3.man..A.C., D/0 Che::::annaj:.M., Aged 44% years, Hsckey Coach? S§0r:s Aé.z1:I:10ri€;:y* of Karnataka Dept. of Yauth S€Zf"ViC€S ané Sports, Naiionai Stad§um., Mangaiors, BK; Sri Mahad€v.G.Ghat:':atti, 1 8/9 Gurupadappa Ghai:r1ai{:»,_ _ Aged 45 years? Gymnastic CG€;Ch;._ Sparta Authofiiy of Ka:'t::a:§aka, Sri Kanteerava Stadium}. V' x . BangafiC:r€:-56Ci OQ1. V St: Shr:Edhara§N.,9 _ ._ 1 VA A' S/0 Narayanappae Agsd y<3:::3;S§ Kho~Kho &A'E-iabagitii"C%:)acE:','*,_ %_ «V " "
Sports Af;:thjQ}*:ity 53f Iia.§'i3ata;k:é;--,.. Sri K?:L.I1i€Ev:$I'r'§{!__'izfi¢':':_ Stadium if) Bangaleréiééé "€}€3i"5jj ' Sri Bié1§:3A:.1§;f'urL%?§'é_j _ S 5,0 C3} ;'£?,Vé:*;":1:a'i:2;s5'e:}§aj ah;
Aged 4'? yeafS;'~FC:@:TA:3a..:E (leach, Sports Esigtfigriiy cf 'iiarnaéaka $3? MFG"; S'ti2:ii§*u::i, E'§?f[8,ndya§ .. fiziafgéya § 13:3§T:'v§_C'E. a , _§3:f:Z Eiezggmesh Rae, V' VE:§,z'A {;».aE_gz:i1evj._§{;fi3Ir::39.§i Raeg
-- -.;%g€::§.':'§i§3.réars, Cficiéai £{'.}§,{::%:; A G;'€3~ §;§.3€s:aI:§ Directaz, G3' Youth Sefizicas 832$ Spsrisa n j Bazzgaiore R1223} Gffieea Bazzgaiaie.
I-ix/~; "
" E§'ija§Ia§~:r§sha:r:."?.3 S /G Ra;'ag@pEa::.}§:1., faggé 49 years, Eife::E«:§ng as Eieskay Cgach, Sparis ;'3;é:{h0Fii§? sf Eiayfiaiaka, Sept, 95 Yszgih SSWECQS and Sperigg 253 Efiiazarabadg Myssre, Mysera Bistrici. 83:}: Chizzriappag S,/0 Kantharaj, Agéd 40 years, Warking as Tennis Coach?
Sportg Authority of Kamzxataka, Sri Kanteerava Sports C0:1:1;te3ié§:,"" « '_ Bangalore. * 8:': Ma1}a:1agouda.B,Pai:iL..__ S/0 Bapugouc:ia.S.Pati1, 'Aged 45 Warking as Basketball Cgachg _v Cham1mciiViha:rf Snfgadium, " :4 Nazarbad, Mysore». iv = Sr)'. Anantha_.A., ' S /0 Late. H arézappagg Aged 49 yééars, Workingas ;}i§2;:s1«:<a§tba1_VI Ccggnfsh;
Assistant.'£)ii*éé1iQr;---{jj-. x V. _ Dept. 025 Yoaiih Seiwribés aiid Spafis, Kahfeerava s:;adm:%, B 'a,:1g,ai0r€*" 1'.§':'b a:_i 'D;fS*éri<':i:. Sr: V.a4:se:ar1i;f1-- 4 ' V. S/G S15':~.N'ar.a3}~ian3 E?;a;e.S.3 _;Afge«.d. 4% yeaisg Aihieiics (leash, _ - . Sp§:z.:'":::3 Authmiityvef Kamatakag . W , Egpi. .§f--Youth Services and Spats, " V _ '' '£%f{_a;:1VgVa:i;2;Si:adiu::1§ Mangaioreé " --.__11'3a7i«:éi?:_i_::;: 'Kannada, 2'? , ._ Sr: 'S%:i%;?ara::3:2.C.B,, E3,!§;:a.._L3.§:e Sr: Eajisiddagevséag gfiggfaé 52 Effififfig "s?£?$ig};":%:1§f*£§z:g Saach, " VT '-1359 ihé fissgisiazzi: Béreciszg V" "§€§3§ QfY§{1?§1 Services Ejféd S§{}I'{$g V 28.
8:3" §sfi.§7§s:2;?s$:xraxa§aE: Staéizgmg Eéaxzdya Exziazzégga §i$::*isi:-5?} 4% E3 31?: Ramaeharzéra, Agéd aéazyi 4? jgsaya 325 M.) 8/0 8:; Eshwaraggag Warlkirzg as H<3€Ei€y Cgasfi, Governmani; S§0ri:s High Sciiheei Eiuéiga Eviadikari District Sri AnanI:ha,ra.ma§K., S/3 Dfiarsna G0wda,K., Athie»tiC3 'ii '. V Bistrici Youth Services ané i;Spo;fi;s " ' Udupig Udupi District firi [email protected]., ~ V ._ figeé about 49 years, Crmigéi Ceac3r;.._ - District Youth Sexjvices a_n.ciA';§3p@r;Es Qfficg, Man(:1ya.,, E\/Iandya;__§§§stri_r€:t,_V .. . ' Sri NarayanasC.G§,W H _ Agsd ab0u?_; :§8 y€:f3;rS,'*~; _ ~ S/3 Working V 'COECE; H Bangaigré Elurai ,' A;<:é;<3.is{£é11Vi': Direciar, Sn. B3,sa'va1'aj:Y;E{ " _ ' g%gé«:i_'a4bQui-é'§~6».fi;ea::§; 9 V' ' ' Sfo YJs:;:anappaéY.'§:'L', Gjynrzrzastiz: Csacim Spgrts Aaskiihéfity 'of Karnaiakag 4Eéazgtcgrava"'Si3.{%,:'Li:3":, Bangaieré' A " » rS::1iV; §{§z*:*1::':_isa, ' 33g:-aé» 48 years, . 50 Lé:<35"§§pp:1su3i&§ Sahsa ..{§?0§_§'€};?3';§;§ C(:saC§L {}.,f{};_ ihe Asesisiayzé Eémaésiz = .. '%'0i::'§%: Ssrvicss & S§::s:':3% " E_{.§€.Sh€t:§I Stadium? Biéarwaé, 8::::,R€m:}ia.N.F'a:d;a:€§ §,};'{; Na*:ajé.T;¥'a§ia:*€% Ageé 33022: 4"? years? Cyztémg Ceaafi Yaaéh ?3€E'°%}'§{f€S £2: Spgrta 36, 38' RN,SE1€{ij; Siadiuzzg Dhazwad. SEE V§si"z:fs?as,E{, Pawai', S/G Ramachar:d:"aIY.Pawar. Aged about £38 yeargfi Swimming C<:>a€h;V.__ District Stadium, Dépt. af Yeégfih S€r2f.i::€$.;' "
Beigaum, Bfigaum Districts Sri M0har:.M.Pattar, V Aged abcut 49 yéarg, Cyffiing C':-:s_aCh$ District Youth Sérvices &,Sg:»;>r¥::s @ffVié:~3,_ _: A Belgaurm Belgaum D1:S"£§'.i§f;-. _ $riMustaqAi1me:;ES1._,A 1 'A S,/8 Late S.AbdUi Kh-Tada3f'39;b,_.-_ Ages'; abGu§49 yesggg .E§<::{:}§€:§:_ iZ'ié_a;E:,j ' Q/Q Assjs::3ri_"é: Bi§;fe3c§;o::", * A' i_ .. _ Dis{ric%:.é3ta:5§iu_m~, Be:-L_:;ry._,-- [2 Beliazfg m"s:;~i;c:;--. > ' % Sr:"§ik:;;;:::i:;,r.:i/ii-;§v'£. Q * . . 0 P_:mdi'*:;§,--pp'a . H«;M'a_1_°1m::
Aged abbut yéa.:S---%.,.C,iyding Csaclz Q/Q'ADYSS--O.7'N<::--h}E':: Siadium, Bjslgazifii,"Be:}ga:;:n"i§is1:riC'L .. i 33:; {:3/'a1*a§é::':-r:§3;. M . K. 9 , 3 E} is ?%§fE..._Ka1iappa§ T "z%g§d'VaE;<§u'§.. 48 years? Heckay Csaeh ._ "'___{Sp3{:>:*':>&?;_'_\:~E3:";j§*:£:;::>L "':f§§yanaga:: Bagégjaisrfiz 43;' V"-.S§',%.__'Rfiaéimaihfiigg 5:§;" Q' flats E\§a¥ayanasé2s.r3.my§ , Agsé ab$U;'i §§ years, Bsxizig Ceach, ";'§ ADYSSQ Bazzgaiere Ciijg, "§aE1g3}£'}§'€.
Sri ?:aé«:as%: Rsxzaiaiiary 5/3 8:31 Shavazi Shankar §5€E?"8;3'fi<:8£", figsfi aheéfi £8 }7€€:§S? fi;r,E':§<:~f{;;a:% Cozacig O,/G ?:fiY$S@, Eéamzagzz Kama? Sisirééé.
425 Sr: Bheemaraj2;.B.R., ;
Sfs Laié BgN.Ra:3":aiah, 4' = H Agsd abeui 54 years, BaSebéJ;1 <§_{;>5;é:h;T'~_ A G,/O 1:h€:'3xSS§S*if:iI1'E Director, ' A ' V ' SE66 Kantéerava Ii'1C1{}GI'.S £E§§iiuI'f1, V V Bangalare. "
Smt.S3::aswathi W'/0 H.N.Sh€ni§ Aged' A:~{L2;:v>i::2:}éL " --yf:3Eu:¢fs,:.,V Weight Lifting cea,;::g', = ._ Disirict S€;iw?i;:€'~;3.;1§"$pQ:'is;G'ff§Ce§ Mangalaj E\»L2i:1g2;iQ:I'€'. "
Mfiespondenis _ .... _ 1 R e*vfvi€:'w P<3:fi;i}§'13 fiZ.éd<zizlder Grder 45?' Ruie i of the C,P.C_._ praying' fa':-_ :*A€:V»§é**;i%: 0f the order éateci 3}_.,11.2<31G '_ paffisgdv :3: \3"%;'ri*'§'A£"i=ti:Vi_ft_i_£>;:1 N05. 2903750/231$ C/W 23088~ :%:~aa%%;'2Q:¢{:_ggz§ .'23263f:3~851/2810 {SE63}? 9:: the file of Céflifi 0? Karnataka, Barggaiers. Th§S"§;~::%§:§0n caméng 0:3: 591* Gfd€FS {big fiay, {ha 3%}:/:1': .1:ia,§%: "fiha feiisvgigg :
GREEER Eiearé 'isafiééd Ai§€i§Z§€?f:a} AdV@Ca%':€ €}fi§:€:*2£ Sim':
§§;§;'1*§aiar3;j far §h€i'r p€§§%:§e::z2§:'s«St2}%i€ 333$ ieggmad " cagngeé SEE}? B,fi,Ba§€:a.'?;§§ fa}? '£326 1§"'€S§OE§(it3I1§iS.
V. V K %